Mig vs. Tig Welding: What’s The Difference?
MIG vs. TIG welding, 2 of the most widely used arc welding processes in industry. Both utilize an inert gas shield to protect the weld pool, but they differ in the type of electrode used and the method of metal transfer.
Electrode Type
- MIG welding uses a continuously fed consumable wire electrode that also acts as the filler metal . This allows for higher deposition rates compared to TIG.
- TIG welding uses a non-consumable tungsten electrode . Filler metal must be added separately if required.
Metal Transfer
- In MIG welding, the consumable wire electrode is continuously fed into the weld pool, melting off droplets of the electrode metal to form the weld bead.
- TIG welding relies solely on melting the base metals to form the weld pool, with or without the addition of filler wire.
Arc Characteristics
- The MIG arc can be unstable in pure argon shielding gas due to irregular cathode spot behaviour on the workpiece surface . This can be improved by hybridizing with a TIG arc.
- The TIG arc is generally more stable and can produce higher quality welds, but at lower deposition rates compared to MIG.
Applications
- MIG welding is suitable for higher deposition rate applications like structural steel fabrication due to its higher productivity.
- TIG welding is often used for high quality root passes, thin materials, aluminium and other non-ferrous alloys where weld quality is paramount.
In summary, while MIG offers higher productivity, TIG welding generally produces higher quality welds. Combining the two processes via TIG-MIG hybridization can potentially offer the best of both worlds – high quality and efficiency .
Mig vs Tig Welding: Which is More Efficient and Practical?
MIG welding uses a continuously fed consumable wire electrode, while TIG uses a non-consumable tungsten electrode. Both processes use an inert shielding gas to protect the weld pool. Key differences are:
Efficiency
MIG welding is generally faster and more efficient than TIG, with higher deposition rates. However, TIG allows for more controlled heat input and finer welds on thinner materials.
Weld Quality
TIG welds tend to have better weld quality, with less spatter and porosity . Pure argon shielding gas improves weld metal toughness in TIG. MIG welds can be improved by using pulsed transfer modes.
Arc Stability
MIG arcs can be unstable in pure argon due to irregular cathode spot behaviour . Hybrid TIG-MIG processes stabilize the MIG arc by combining it with a TIG arc, allowing use of pure argon for improved toughness.
Applications
TIG is preferred for high quality welds on thinner materials like aluminium and stainless steel . MIG is suitable for thicker materials and higher deposition rates.
Automation
Both processes can be automated, but MIG is generally easier due to the continuously fed wire. Automated TIG requires precise torch positioning.
In summary, MIG offers higher efficiency and suitability for thicker materials, while TIG provides finer control and better weld quality, particularly for thin materials. Hybrid TIG-MIG processes combine advantages of both for high quality, high efficiency welding .
Mig vs Tig Welding: When to Use Mig Welding or Tig Welding?
When deciding whether to use MIG or TIG welding, several factors should be considered:
Welding Speed and Efficiency
MIG welding is generally faster and more efficient than TIG welding, making it suitable for high-volume production . However, TIG welding offers higher quality welds with better mechanical properties .
Material Thickness
MIG welding can be used for a wider range of material thicknesses, from thin sheets to thick plates . TIG welding is typically preferred for thinner materials under 4mm [supplementary].
Weld Quality and Appearance
TIG welding produces welds with superior quality, finer bead appearance, and narrower heat-affected zones . MIG welds may have more spatter and require post-weld cleaning .
Shielding Gas Requirements
Both MIG and TIG welding require shielding gas, but TIG welding is more sensitive to gas shielding disruptions [supplementary]. MIG welding can be more suitable for outdoor or windy environments [supplementary].
Automation and Ease of Use
MIG welding is generally easier to automate and requires fewer parameters to control [supplementary]. TIG welding demands higher operator skill and is more challenging to automate .
Cost and Equipment
MIG welding equipment is typically more affordable than TIG welding setups [supplementary]. However, TIG welding may be more cost-effective for low-volume, high-quality applications [supplementary].
In summary, MIG welding is often preferred for its speed, efficiency, and versatility in material thickness, while TIG welding offers superior weld quality and appearance, particularly for thinner materials and applications requiring high precision. The choice depends on the specific project requirements, balancing factors like production volume, material thickness, weld quality needs, and cost considerations.
Application Cases
| Product/Project | Technical Outcomes | Application Scenarios |
|---|---|---|
| Fronius TPS/i Robot Welding System | Utilises advanced waveform control and pulsed arc welding to achieve higher welding speeds, improved gap bridging, and reduced heat input for thin materials. | Automated robotic welding in automotive, aerospace, and other high-volume manufacturing industries. |
| Miller PipeWorx Welding System | Integrates advanced waveform control, pulsed MIG, and TIG welding capabilities in a single power source, enabling optimised welding for various pipe materials and positions. | Pipe welding in oil and gas, power generation, and other heavy industries requiring high-quality pipe welds. |
| Kemppi X8 MIG Welder | Utilises advanced adaptive joint tracking and automatic parameter adjustment to optimise welding parameters for varying joint geometries and positions, improving weld quality and consistency. | Shipbuilding, heavy fabrication, and other applications requiring high-quality welds on complex geometries. |
| Lincoln Electric Augmented Arc Augmented Reality Welding System | Combines augmented reality displays with advanced waveform control and real-time monitoring to provide visual guidance and feedback, improving training efficiency and weld quality. | Welding training and education, as well as complex welding applications requiring precise guidance and monitoring. |
| EWM Alpha Q 552 Pulsed TIG Welder | Employs advanced pulsed TIG welding technology with precise pulse control, enabling higher welding speeds, improved gap bridging, and reduced heat input for thin materials. | Precision welding of thin-gauge materials in aerospace, medical, and other industries requiring high-quality welds on delicate components. |
To get detailed scientific explanations of MIG vs. TIG welding, try Patsnap Eureka.
