What Is A Butterfly Valve?
A butterfly valve is a flow control device used to regulate the flow of fluids, typically liquids or gases, through a pipe or conduit. It consists of a circular disc, or “butterfly,” mounted on a rotatable shaft that extends across the diameter of the pipe. Essentially, the butterfly can be rotated between an open position, where it is parallel to the flow direction, allowing maximum flow, and a closed position, perpendicular to the flow, thus blocking the flow entirely.
How Does A Butterfly Valve Work?
Operating Principle
The butterfly valve regulates flow by rotating the disc between open and closed positions. When the disc is parallel to the flow (open position), fluid can flow freely through the valve. As the disc rotates towards the closed position, the flow area is gradually reduced until the disc seals against the seat ring, blocking flow completely.
Flow Characteristics
The flow characteristics of a butterfly valve depend on the disc’s angle relative to the flow. At all opening angles, the flow is highly turbulent, with significant pressure drop. However, as the opening increases, the flow becomes more streamlined, reducing turbulence and pressure loss. The discharge coefficient, which relates flow rate to pressure drop, varies non-linearly with the opening angle.
Torque Requirements
The torque required to operate a butterfly valve is influenced by factors such as fluid pressure, velocity, and the disc’s shape and size. Notably, at intermediate openings, the torque is highest due to the asymmetric flow pattern and dynamic torque caused by vortex shedding. Therefore, proper sizing of the actuator is crucial to ensuring smooth operation.
Components of A Butterfly Valve
Main Components
A butterfly valve typically consists of the following main components:
- Valve body: The valve body has a flow path and houses the other components.
- Disc/valve element: A disc-shaped component that rotates to open or close the flow path.
- Valve stem/shaft: The disc is mounted on the valve stem/shaft, which rotates to actuate the disc.
- Seat ring: An annular ring that provides a sealing surface for the disc.
- Flanges: Flanges at the ends of the valve body allow connection to pipes.
Sealing and Bearing Components
To ensure proper sealing and smooth operation, butterfly valves incorporate additional components:
- Bushings/bearings: Bushings or bearings support the valve stem and allow rotation.
- Seals: Seals are used between the disc and seat ring, as well as around the valve stem, to prevent leakage.
- Packing: packing material may be used around the valve stem to prevent leakage.
Actuation and Accessories
- Actuator: An actuator (manual, pneumatic, electric, or hydraulic) is connected to the valve stem to rotate the disc.
- Manual locking device: Some butterfly valves include a manual locking device to secure the disc position.
- Position indicator: A position indicator may be included to show the disc’s open or closed position.
Design Considerations
- Offset design: Triple offset or eccentric designs improve sealing and reduce wear.
- Materials: Valve bodies and components can be made from various materials (e.g., metals, and plastics) based on the application.
- Lightweight design: valve bodies can be designed with hollow spaces or divided into sections for easier transportation and installation.
Types of Butterfly Valves
Classification Based on Sealing Mechanism
- Rubber-Seated Butterfly Valves: These valves use a resilient rubber seat to seal against the valve disk. They are suitable for on/off applications at lower pressures and temperatures.
- High-Performance Butterfly Valves (HPBVs): These valves use metal-to-metal sealing surfaces, offering superior performance at higher pressures and temperatures. Moreover, they are chemically inert and suitable for severe service conditions.
Structural Variations
- Concentric Butterfly Valves: The valve disk rotates around a central axis, providing a symmetric flow path.
- Eccentric Butterfly Valves: The valve disk rotates around an offset axis, allowing for improved sealing and flow characteristics. Additionally, they can be single, double, or triple eccentric.
- Wafer-Type Butterfly Valves: These valves have a compact design with a resilient seat sandwiched between two body halves, suitable for installation between pipe flanges.
- Lug-Type Butterfly Valves: These valves have lugs or tapped holes in the body for bolting to adjacent piping, providing a more secure installation.
Advanced Designs
- Triple-Offset Butterfly Valves: These valves have three offsets (stem, disk, and seat), offering improved sealing and reduced wear. Consequently, they are suitable for severe service conditions.
- Dual Stem Guide (DSG) Butterfly Valves: These valves have two stem guides, improving stability and reducing vibration, especially in larger sizes.
- Perforated Disk Butterfly Valves: These valves have perforated disks, allowing for better flow control and reduced pressure drop.
Special Designs
- Butterfly Valves with Multiple Seals: These valves have additional seals on the inlet and outlet sides, providing improved sealing and reduced leakage.
- Butterfly Valves with Protection Against Leakage: These valves have a leakage chamber between two butterfly disks, allowing for flushing or cleaning when the valve is closed.
- Butterfly-Type Gate Valves: These valves combine the features of butterfly and gate valves, using two semicircular disks that fold or unfold to control the flow path.
Pros and Cons of Butterfly Valve
Advantages of Butterfly Valves
- Bidirectional sealing capability under full pressure rating from either direction
- Tight shutoff due to elastomeric seats, suitable for solids handling
- Lower cost due to less corrosion-resistant materials used
- Minimal dead spots for material retention when fully open
- Higher flow capacity compared to off-center disc designs
Disadvantages of Butterfly Valves
- Reduced and more likely to plug flow channel due to disc presence
- Upward disc motion can compress and pack bulk material, increasing blockage risk
- Lower pressure ratings and shorter cycle life compared to off-center disc designs
- Higher operating torque in one direction for off-center designs, requiring larger actuators
Applications of Butterfly Valve
Butterfly valves find extensive use across various industries due to their versatility and cost-effectiveness.
- Water and wastewater treatment plants
- Heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC) systems
- Chemical and petrochemical processing
- Oil and gas production
- Power generation (hydropower projects)
- Pulp and paper mills
- Food and beverage processing
- Mining operations
Their applications range from basic on/off isolation to precise flow control, making butterfly valves an indispensable component in modern industrial fluid handling systems.
Application Cases
| Product/Project | Technical Outcomes | Application Scenarios |
|---|---|---|
| Rotork IQ3 Intelligent Electric Actuator | Combines data logging, asset management, and network control capabilities, enabling predictive maintenance and remote operation. Thus, it reduces downtime and maintenance costs. Oil and gas, water treatment, and power generation plants requiring precise valve control and monitoring. | Oil and gas, water treatment, and power generation plants requiring precise valve control and monitoring. |
| Emerson Valve Condition Monitoring | Uses acoustic sensors and machine learning algorithms to detect valve issues early, reducing unplanned shutdowns by up to 20%. It extends valve life and improves process reliability. | Refineries, chemical plants, and other critical process industries with high-value assets. |
| Neles RotaLock Valve Security Solution | Provides tamper-proof locking and remote monitoring of valve positions, preventing unauthorised access and ensuring process safety. | Critical infrastructure, power plants, and facilities handling hazardous materials. |
| Flowserve Valvtechnator | Combines CFD modelling, 3D printing, and rapid prototyping to optimise valve design for specific applications, reducing pressure drop and improving flow control. | Complex piping systems in oil and gas, chemical, and power industries require custom valve solutions. |
| Metso Valve Diagnostics | Utilises wireless sensors and cloud-based analytics to monitor valve performance, predict maintenance needs, and optimise valve assets across the plant lifecycle. | Large industrial facilities with extensive valve networks enable predictive maintenance and asset optimisation. |
Latest Technical Innovations of Butterfly Valve
Valve Design and Materials
- In terms of design and materials, improved sealing elements are easier to replace, with radial branches and semicircular cutouts in the valve body to accommodate the sealing element. This not only facilitates maintenance but also extends the valve’s life.
Valve Performance and Flow Characteristics
- Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) analysis predicts performance factors like pressure drop, hydrodynamic torque, flow coefficient, and cavitation. Therefore, CFD enables optimization for specific operating conditions. Additionally, eccentric disc designs (tri-eccentric, bi-eccentric, and mono-eccentric) and dual stem guide technology improve flow characteristics.
Actuation and Control
- Mechanisms exploiting net fluid torque on the valve plate for dynamic torque balancing and control, using translational movement to facilitate rotation.
- Locking systems and operating levers to prevent accidental opening/closing enhance safety.
- Butterfly valves are integrated into advanced control systems like intermittent gas-lift installations and exhaust braking arrangements.
Emerging Applications
- Use in vacuum equipment like semiconductors, LCDs, OLEDs, and solar manufacturing to maintain constant chamber pressure.
- Adoption of high-performance butterfly valves (HPBVs) in applications traditionally using gate/globe valves, offering improved performance and economies.
The innovations cover design aspects like materials, sealing, and flow optimization, as well as control strategies, actuation mechanisms, and new application areas, reflecting the continuous improvement of butterfly valves to meet evolving industrial needs.
Technical Challenges
| Butterfly Valve Disc Design | Developing disc designs with through apertures and movable inner butterfly elements to allow limited flow in the closed position, enabling modulation and control of back pressure. |
| Computational Fluid Dynamics Analysis | Utilizing Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) analysis to predict performance factors like pressure drop, hydrodynamic torque, flow coefficient, and cavitation, enabling optimisation for specific operating conditions. |
| Valve Materials | Exploring the use of new materials like sintered ore to minimise abrasion and increase durability in harsh environments with dust or particles. |
| Eccentric Disc Designs | Investigating eccentric disc designs (tri-eccentric, bi-eccentric, mono-eccentric) and dual stem guide technology for improved flow characteristics. |
| Hydrodynamic Torque Modeling | Developing models to study hydrodynamic torque using free-streamline theory and iterative schemes for accurate prediction and optimisation. |
To get detailed scientific explanations of butterfly valves, try Patsnap Eureka.
