Apparatus and method for enhanced beam reporting for sidelink communication
The method optimizes sidelink communication by determining the best transmission and reception beams based on received signal characteristics, addressing ambiguity and improving resource efficiency by only transmitting feedback when the signal quality is superior, thereby enhancing beam reporting and communication reliability.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- GB2023007120
- Authority / Receiving Office
- GB · GB
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2023-05-12
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-13
AI Technical Summary
In device-to-device sidelink communication, existing technologies face challenges in efficiently determining the optimal transmission and reception beams for feedback transmissions, leading to ambiguity and reduced resource utilization due to partial beam overlap and strong reflectors in the environment.
An apparatus and method that listens to sidelink transmissions using multiple reception beams, determines received signal characteristics, and decides whether to transmit feedback using specific transmission beams based on these characteristics, ensuring that feedback is only sent when the signal quality is the best among previous measurements, thereby optimizing beam pairing during initial communication establishment.
This approach enhances beam reporting by resolving ambiguity in beam selection, ensuring that the latest feedback corresponds to the best beam pair, improving communication reliability and resource efficiency by only transmitting feedback when the signal quality is superior, thus optimizing sidelink communication.
Smart Images

Figure 00000000_0000_ABST
Abstract
Description
TECHNOLOGICAL FIELD Various example embodiments relate to an apparatus and method for enhanced beam reporting for sidelink communication. BACKGROUND In device-to-device communication, for example sidelink communication, a user equipment may communicate directly with another user equipment. This may enable better usage of resources and enhanced user experience to a user of such user equipment. BRIEF SUMMARY The scope of protection sought for various example embodiments of the invention is set out by the independent claims. The example embodiments and features, if any, described in this specification that do not fall under the scope of the independent claims are to be interpreted as examples useful for understanding various embodiments of the invention. According to various, but not necessarily all, example embodiments of the invention there is provided an apparatus, comprising: at least one processor; and at least one memory storing instructions that, when executed by the at least one processor, cause the apparatus at least to perform: listening, using a first reception beam for a first sidelink transmission and using a second reception beam for a second sidelink transmission of a plurality of sidelink transmissions from a user equipment; determining a first received signal characteristic of the first sidelink transmission; determining a second received signal characteristic of the second sidelink transmission; and determining, based on the first and second received signal characteristics, whether to: transmit a first feedback transmission to the user equipment in a first feedback transmission resource associated with the first sidelink transmission using a first transmission beam corresponding to the first reception beam; transmit a second feedback transmission to the user equipment in a second feedback transmission resource associated with the second sidelink transmission using a second transmission beam corresponding to the second reception beam; or transmit neither the first feedback transmission nor the second feedback transmission. The instructions, when executed by the at least one processor, may further cause the apparatus at least to perform: determining whether the first received signal characteristic exceeds the second received signal characteristic, or whether the second received signal characteristic exceeds the first received signal characteristic. The instructions, when executed by the at least one processor, may further cause the apparatus at least to perform: determining whether the first received signal characteristic exceeds both the second received signal characteristic and a received signal characteristic of a sidelink transmission associated with an earlier feedback transmission occasion for which feedback was transmitted, or whether the second received signal characteristic exceeds both the first received signal characteristic and a received signal characteristic of a sidelink transmission associated with an earlier feedback transmission occasion for which feedback was transmitted. The instructions, when executed by the at least one processor, may further cause the apparatus at least to perform: determining whether to: transmit a first feedback transmission to the user equipment in a first feedback transmission resource associated with the first sidelink transmission using a first transmission beam corresponding to the first reception beam; transmit a second feedback transmission to the user equipment in a second feedback transmission resource associated with the second sidelink transmission using a second transmission beam corresponding to the second reception beam; or transmit neither the first feedback transmission nor the second feedback transmission based on the determining of the received signal characteristics. The determining of whether to transmit based on the determining of the received signal characteristics is set out in the following paragraphs. The first and second feedback transmission resources may occur in a same feedback transmission occasion and the instructions, when executed by the at least one processor, may further cause the apparatus at least to perform:, determining to transmit the first feedback transmission to the user equipment in the first feedback transmission resource associated with the first sidelink transmission based on the first received signal characteristic exceeding the second received signal characteristic, or to transmit the second feedback transmission to the user equipment in the second feedback transmission resource associated with the second sidelink transmission based on the second received signal characteristic exceeding the first received signal characteristic. The first and second feedback transmission resources may occur in a same feedback transmission occasion and the instructions, when executed by the at least one processor, may further cause the apparatus at least to perform: determining to transmit the first feedback transmission to the user equipment in the first feedback transmission resource associated with the first sidelink transmission based on the first received signal characteristic exceeding both the second received signal characteristic and a received signal characteristic of a sidelink transmission associated with an earlier feedback transmission occasion for which feedback was transmitted, or to transmit the second feedback transmission to the user equipment in the second feedback transmission resource associated with the second sidelink transmission based on the second received signal characteristic exceeding both the first received signal characteristic and a received signal characteristic of a sidelink transmission associated with an earlier feedback transmission occasion for which feedback was transmitted. The listening, determining and transmitting may be repeated successively and earlier, previous or preceding listening for transmissions may have resulted in feedback being transmitted based on the received signal characteristics of those earlier, previous or preceding transmissions, and the received signal characteristics of those earlier, previous or preceding transmissions may be used later, following or subsequently to determine whether or not to transmit feedback based on the received signal characteristics of that later, following or subsequent transmissions. The first and second feedback transmission resources may occur in a same feedback transmission occasion and the instructions, when executed by the at least one processor, may further cause the apparatus at least to perform: when determining to transmit neither the first feedback transmission nor the second feedback transmission to the user equipment based on neither the first received signal characteristic nor the second received signal characteristic exceeding a received signal characteristic of a sidelink transmission associated with an earlier feedback transmission occasion for which feedback was transmitted. The first feedback transmission resource may occur in an earlier feedback transmission occasion than the second feedback transmission resource and the first and second reception beams may be the same, and the instructions, when executed by the at least 3 one processor, may further cause the apparatus at least to perform: determining to transmit the second feedback transmission to the user equipment in the second feedback transmission resource associated with the second sidelink transmission based on the second received signal characteristic exceeding the first received signal characteristic. The first feedback transmission resource may occur in an earlier feedback transmission occasion than the second feedback transmission resource and the first and second reception beams may be the same, and the instructions, when executed by the at least one processor, may further cause the apparatus at least to perform: determining not to transmit the second feedback transmission to the user equipment in the second feedback transmission resource associated with the second sidelink transmission based on the second received signal characteristic not exceeding the first received signal characteristic. The first feedback transmission resource may occur in an earlier feedback transmission occasion than the second feedback transmission resource and the first and second reception beams may be the same, and the instructions, when executed by the at least one processor, may further cause the apparatus at least to perform: determining to transmit the second feedback transmission to the user equipment in the second feedback transmission resource associated with the second sidelink transmission based on the second received signal characteristic exceeding both the first received signal characteristic and a received signal characteristic of a sidelink transmission associated with an earlier feedback transmission occasion for which feedback was transmitted. The first feedback transmission resource may occur in an earlier feedback transmission occasion than the second feedback transmission resource and the first and second reception beams may be the same, and the instructions, when executed by the at least one processor, may further cause the apparatus at least to perform: determining not to transmit the second feedback transmission to the user equipment in the second feedback transmission resource associated with the second sidelink transmission based on the second received signal characteristic not exceeding both the first received signal characteristic and a received signal characteristic of a sidelink transmission associated with an earlier feedback transmission occasion for which feedback was transmitted. The received signal characteristics may comprise a received signal quality and / or a received signal strength. The instructions, when executed by the at least one processor, may further cause the apparatus at least to perform: listening, using a sequentially different one of a plurality of reception beams at the apparatus , for a corresponding one of the plurality of sidelink transmissions from the user equipment. The instructions, when executed by the at least one processor, may further cause the apparatus at least to perform: determining a configured number of sidelink transmissions to be transmitted by said user equipment with a same transmission configuration; and listening, using a sequentially different one of the plurality of reception beams at the apparatus, for a corresponding one of the configured number of sidelink transmissions from said user equipment. The first feedback transmission may indicate to the user equipment that a transmission configuration associated with the first sidelink transmission is to be used for sidelink transmission with the apparatus and the second feedback transmission may indicate to the user equipment that a transmission configuration associated with the second sidelink transmission is to be used for sidelink transmission with the apparatus. The first and second feedback transmission resources may be Physical Sidelink Feedback Channel resources. The first feedback transmission and / or the second feedback transmission may comprise Hybrid Automatic Repeat reQuest feedback information. The plurality of sidelink transmissions may include a reference signal. The instructions, when executed by the at least one processor, may further cause the apparatus at least to perform: determining said first and second received signal characteristics by performing a measurement on the reference signal of the first and second sidelink transmissions. The plurality of sidelink transmissions may comprise a Direct Communication Request message. The first reception beam and the second reception beam may be the same. The apparatus may comprise a responding user equipment and the user equipment may comprise an initiating user equipment. According to various, but not necessarily all, example embodiments of the invention there is provided an apparatus, comprising: means for listening, using a first reception beam for a first sidelink transmission and using a second reception beam for a second sidelink transmission of a plurality of sidelink transmissions from a user equipment; means for determining a first received signal characteristic of the first sidelink transmission; means for determining a second received signal characteristic of the second sidelink transmission; and means for determining, based on the first and second received signal characteristics, whether to: transmit a first feedback transmission to the user equipment in a first feedback transmission resource associated with the first sidelink transmission using a first transmission beam corresponding to the first reception beam; transmit a second feedback transmission to the user equipment in a second feedback transmission resource associated with the second sidelink transmission using a second transmission beam corresponding to the second reception beam; or transmit neither the first feedback transmission nor the second feedback transmission. The means may perform the optional features set out in relation to the apparatus mentioned above. According to various, but not necessarily all, example embodiments of the invention there is provided an apparatus comprising circuitry configured to perform listening, using a first reception beam for a first sidelink transmission and using a second reception beam for a second sidelink transmission of a plurality of sidelink transmissions from a user equipment; determining a first received signal characteristic of the first sidelink transmission; determining a second received signal characteristic of the second sidelink transmission; and determining, based on the first and second received signal characteristics, whether to: transmit a first feedback transmission to the user equipment in a first feedback transmission resource associated with the first sidelink transmission using a first transmission beam corresponding to the first reception beam; transmit a second feedback transmission to the user equipment in a second feedback transmission resource associated with the second sidelink transmission using a second transmission beam corresponding to the second reception 6 beam; or transmit neither the first feedback transmission nor the second feedback transmission. The circuitry may be configured to perform the optional features set out in relation to the apparatus mentioned above. According to various, but not necessarily all, example embodiments of the invention there is provided a method, comprising: listening, using a first reception beam for a first sidelink transmission and using a second reception beam for a second sidelink transmission of a plurality of sidelink transmissions from a user equipment; determining a first received signal characteristic of the first sidelink transmission; determining a second received signal characteristic of the second sidelink transmission; and determining, based on the first and second received signal characteristics, whether to: transmit a first feedback transmission to the user equipment in a first feedback transmission resource associated with the first sidelink transmission using a first transmission beam corresponding to the first reception beam; transmit a second feedback transmission to the user equipment in a second feedback transmission resource associated with the second sidelink transmission using a second transmission beam corresponding to the second reception beam; or transmit neither the first feedback transmission nor the second feedback transmission. The method may further comprise: determining whether the first received signal characteristic exceeds the second received signal characteristic, or whether the second received signal characteristic exceeds the first received signal characteristic. The method may further comprise: determining whether the first received signal characteristic exceeds both the second received signal characteristic and a received signal characteristic of a sidelink transmission associated with an earlier feedback transmission occasion for which feedback was transmitted, or whether the second received signal characteristic exceeds both the first received signal characteristic and a received signal characteristic of a sidelink transmission associated with an earlier feedback transmission occasion for which feedback was transmitted. The method may further comprise: determining whether to: transmit a first feedback transmission to the user equipment in a first feedback transmission resource associated with the first sidelink transmission using a first transmission beam corresponding to the first reception beam; transmit a second feedback transmission to 7 the user equipment in a second feedback transmission resource associated with the second sidelink transmission using a second transmission beam corresponding to the second reception beam; or transmit neither the first feedback transmission nor the second feedback transmission based on the determining of the received signal characteristics. The determining of whether to transmit based on the determining of the received signal characteristics is set out in the following paragraphs. The first and second feedback transmission resources may occur in a same feedback transmission occasion and the method may further comprise: determining to transmit the first feedback transmission to the user equipment in the first feedback transmission resource associated with the first sidelink transmission based on the first received signal characteristic exceeding the second received signal characteristic, or to transmit the second feedback transmission to the user equipment in the second feedback transmission resource associated with the second sidelink transmission based on the second received signal characteristic exceeding the first received signal characteristic. The first and second feedback transmission resources may occur in a same feedback transmission occasion, and the method may further comprise: determining to transmit the first feedback transmission to the user equipment in the first feedback transmission resource associated with the first sidelink transmission based on the first received signal characteristic exceeding both the second received signal characteristic and a received signal characteristic of a sidelink transmission associated with an earlier feedback transmission occasion for which feedback was transmitted, or to transmit the second feedback transmission to the user equipment in the second feedback transmission resource associated with the second sidelink transmission based on the second received signal characteristic exceeding both the first received signal characteristic and a received signal characteristic of a sidelink transmission associated with an earlier feedback transmission occasion for which feedback was transmitted. The listening, determining and transmitting may be repeated in successive transmission occasions and an earlier, previous or preceding transmission occasion may have resulted in feedback being transmitted based on the received signal characteristics of that earlier, previous or preceding transmission occasion and the received signal characteristics of that earlier, previous or preceding transmission occasion may be used in a later, following or subsequent transmission occasion to determine whether or not to transmit feedback based on the received signal characteristics of that later, following or subsequent transmission occasion. The first and second feedback transmission resources may occur in a same feedback transmission occasion, and the method may further comprise: determining to transmit neither the first feedback transmission nor the second feedback transmission to the user equipment based on neither the first received signal characteristic nor the second received signal characteristic exceeding a received signal characteristic of a sidelink transmission associated with an earlier feedback transmission occasion for which feedback was transmitted. The first feedback transmission resource may occur in an earlier feedback transmission occasion than the second feedback transmission resource and the first and second reception beams may be the same, and the method may further comprise: when determining to transmit the second feedback transmission to the user equipment in the second feedback transmission resource associated with the second sidelink transmission based on the second received signal characteristic exceeding the first received signal characteristic. The first feedback transmission resource may occur in an earlier feedback transmission occasion than the second feedback transmission resource and the first and second reception beams may be the same, and the method may further comprise: determining not to transmit the second feedback transmission to the user equipment in the second feedback transmission resource associated with the second sidelink transmission based on the second received signal characteristic not exceeding the first received signal characteristic. The first feedback transmission resource may occur in an earlier feedback transmission occasion than the second feedback transmission resource and the first and second reception beams may be the same, and the method may further comprise: determining to transmit the second feedback transmission to the user equipment in the second feedback transmission resource associated with the second sidelink transmission based on the second received signal characteristic exceeding both the first received signal characteristic and a received signal characteristic of a sidelink transmission associated with an earlier feedback transmission occasion for which feedback was transmitted. The first feedback transmission resource may occur in an earlier feedback transmission occasion than the second feedback transmission resource and the first and second reception beams may be the same, and the method may further comprise: determining not to transmit the second feedback transmission to the user equipment in the second feedback transmission resource associated with the second sidelink transmission based on the second received signal characteristic not exceeding both the first received signal characteristic and a received signal characteristic of a sidelink transmission associated with an earlier feedback transmission occasion for which feedback was transmitted. The received signal characteristics may comprise a received signal quality and / or a received signal strength. The method may further comprise: listening, using a sequentially different one of a plurality of reception beams at the user equipment, for a corresponding one the plurality of sidelink transmissions from the user equipment. The method may further comprise: determining a configured number of sidelink transmissions to be transmitted by said user equipment with a same transmission configuration; and listening, using a sequentially different one of the plurality of reception beams at the apparatus, for a corresponding one of the configured number of sidelink transmissions from said user equipment. The first feedback transmission may indicate to the user equipment that a transmission configuration associated with the first sidelink transmission is to be used for sidelink transmission and the second feedback transmission may indicate to the user equipment that a transmission configuration associated with the second sidelink transmission is to be used for sidelink transmission. The first and second feedback transmission resources may be Physical Sidelink Feedback Channel resources. The first feedback transmission and / or the second feedback transmission may comprise Hybrid Automatic Repeat reQuest feedback information. The plurality of sidelink transmissions may include a reference signal. The method may further comprise: determining said first and second received signal characteristics by performing a measurement on the reference signal of the first and second sidelink transmissions. The plurality of sidelink transmissions may comprise a Direct Communication Request message. The first reception beam and the second reception beam may be the same. The method may be performed by a responding user equipment and the user equipment may comprise an initiating user equipment. According to various, but not necessarily all, example embodiments of the invention there is provided a non-transitory computer readable medium comprising program instructions stored thereon for performing at least the following: listening, using a first reception beam for a first sidelink transmission and using a second reception beam for a second sidelink transmission of a plurality of sidelink transmissions from a user equipment; determining a first received signal characteristic of the first sidelink transmission; determining a second received signal characteristic of the second sidelink transmission; and determining, based on the first and second received signal characteristics, whether to: transmit a first feedback transmission to the user equipment in a first feedback transmission resource associated with the first sidelink transmission using a first transmission beam corresponding to the first reception beam; transmit a second feedback transmission to the user equipment in a second feedback transmission resource associated with the second sidelink transmission using a second transmission beam corresponding to the second reception beam; or transmit neither the first feedback transmission nor the second feedback transmission. The instructions may be for performing the optional features set out in relation to the method mentioned above. In some example embodiments there is provided an apparatus comprising at least one processor and at least one memory storing instructions that, when executed by the at least one processor, cause the apparatus at least to: use a first beam (bi) of a receiver UE (B) to receive at least one first data transmission (PSCCH / PSSCHi) in a first data transmission resource (n) from a transmitter UE (A) comprising a first reference signal (RSi) and determine a first beam measurement (RSRPi) based on the first reference signal (RSi); use a second beam (b2) of the receiver UE (B) to receive at least one second data transmission (PSCCH / PSSCH2) in a second data transmission resource (r2) from the transmitter UE (A) comprising a second reference signal (RS2) and determine a second beam measurement (RSRP2) based on the second reference signal (RS2); and determine, based at least on the first beam measurement (RSRP1) and the second beam measurement (RSRP2), whether to: use the first beam (bi) to transmit a first feedback transmission (PSFCH1) to the transmitter UE (A) in a first feedback transmission resource (fi) associated with the first data transmission resource (n), use the second beam (b2) to transmit a second feedback transmission (PSFCH2) to the transmitter UE (A) in a second feedback transmission resource (f2) associated with the second data transmission resource (r2), or transmit neither the first feedback transmission (PSFCH1) nor the second feedback transmission (PSFCH2). As used herein, data transmission may sometimes be referred to as sidelink transmission. For example, data transmission on PSSCH may comprise a DCR. For example, the first and second data transmissions (or first and second sidelink transmissions) may comprise the same or similar DCR. The instructions may further cause the apparatus to: determine to use the first beam (bi) to transmit the first feedback transmission (PSFCH1) if the first beam measurement (RSRP1) is higher than at least the second beam measurement (RSRP2); determine to use the second beam (b2) to transmit the second feedback transmission (PSFCH2) if the second beam measurement (RSRP2) is higher than at least the first beam measurement (RSRP1). The instructions may further cause the apparatus to: determine to transmit neither the first feedback transmission (PSFCH1) nor the second feedback transmission (PSFCH2) if both the first beam measurement (RSRP1) and the second beam measurement (RSRP2) are lower than an earlier beam measurement associated with a prior feedback transmission. The first beam (bi) and the second beam (b2) may be the same. In such case, the receiver UE B may be configured to use only one beam. That is, the UE B may not be a multibeam capable UE in some examples. In another example, the UE B may potentially be a multibeam capable device but determines or is configured to use only one beam. If the first beam bi and the second beam b2 are the same, the first beam and second beam may simply be referred to as a beam. However, as discussed herein, in some examples, UE B may be configured to and capable to use multiple beams and may be understood as multibeam UE. Hence, in some examples, bi may be different to b2. The first feedback transmission (PSFCHi) may comprise HARQ feedback information associated with the at least one first data transmission (PSCCH / PSSCHi) and the second feedback transmission (PSFCH2) may comprise HARQ feedback information associated with the at least one second data transmission (PSCCH / PSSCH2). The first data transmission resource (ri) and the second data transmission resource (r2) may be associated with a same PSFCH transmission occasion (Pi, P2). The instructions may further cause the apparatus to: use different beams (bi, ... , bo) of the receiver UE (B) to receive at least some of a configured number (Q) of first data transmissions (PSCCH / PSSCHi,1, ... , PSCCH / PSSCHi,Q) in a first set of slots (Si, ... , Sq), and use different beams (bi, ... , bo) of the receiver UE (B) to receive at least some of the configured number (Q) of second data transmissions (PSCCH / PSSCH2.1, ..., PSCCH / PSSCH2,q) in a second set of slots (s’1, ..., s’q). The first set of slots (si, ... , Sq) may be consecutive logical slots and the second set of slots (s’1, ..., s’q) may be consecutive logical slots. The configured number (Q) may be configured to be equal to or larger than a configured PSFCH transmission occasion periodicity. The optional features set out above may be provided in combination with the features of any apparatus set out above. In some example embodiments there is provided a method and a non-transitory computer readable medium comprising the features and optional features set out in relation to the apparatus mentioned above. Further particular and preferred aspects are set out in the accompanying independent and dependent claims. Features of the dependent claims may be combined with features of the independent claims as appropriate, and in combinations other than those explicitly set out in the claims. Where an apparatus feature is described as being operable to provide a function, it will be appreciated that this includes an apparatus feature which provides that function or which is adapted or configured to provide that function. BRIEF DESCRIPTION Some example embodiments will now be described with reference to the accompanying drawings in which: FIG. 1 illustrates multiple feedback being provided during initial beam pairing during sidelink unicast link establishment; FIG. 2 illustrates enhanced feedback being provided during initial beam pairing during sidelink unicast link establishment; FIG. 3 is a flowchart illustrating the steps performed for providing enhanced feedback during initial beam pairing during sidelink unicast link establishment; and FIG. 4 illustrates schematically an apparatus according to an example embodiment. DETAILED DESCRIPTION Before discussing the example embodiments in any more detail, first an overview will be provided. Some example embodiments provide a technique for providing efficient feedback when initiating sidelink or other communication. Typically a first user equipment seeking to initiate sidelink communication has one or more transmission beams that it may use to support sidelink communication and a second user equipment seeking to respond to a request for sidelink communication has one or more reception beams. Selecting the correct combination of transmission and reception beams is important for providing reliable sidelink communication. Typically, the first user equipment will be configured to transmit sets of repeating messages to the second user equipment, each set being transmitted using a different transmission beam. For example, the first user equipment may transmit a first set of repeating messages using a first transmission beam to the second user equipment. The second user equipment then typically attempts to decode each of those repeating messages using a different reception beam for each message. The first user equipment may then transmit a second set of repeating messages using a second transmission beam to the second user equipment. The second user equipment then typically attempts to decode each of those repeating messages using a different reception beam for each message, and so on. If the second user equipment were to indicate to the first user equipment each time a message was successfully decoded, then this feedback would assist the first user equipment in understanding which transmission beam(s) may provide for sidelink communication, but does not enable the first user equipment to understand which transmission beam is best to use for sidelink communication. Accordingly, each time the second user equipment successfully receives a message from the first user equipment, the second user equipment is configured to determine or establish whether the received signal characteristics associated with that message indicate that particular transmission / reception beam pair is better than any previous feedback indication provided to the first user equipment. If the received signal characteristics are better, then feedback is provided and this indicates to the first user equipment that the transmission beam configuration it used to transmit that message should be used for sidelink communication. Likewise, this indicates to the second user equipment that the reception beam configuration it used to receive that message should be used for sidelink communication. Typically, that feedback is provided using a transmission beam from the second user equipment corresponding to the reception beam that received the message since that transmission beam is likely to provide the best feedback transmission to the first user equipment. However, if the received signal characteristics associated with that message indicate that particular transmission / reception beam pair is no better than any previous feedback indication provided to the first user equipment, then no feedback is provided even though the message was successfully received. This reduces the amount of feedback provided and, once all the messages have been conveyed using different combinations of transmission / reception beams, then both the first user equipment and the second user equipment know that the last feedback provided indicates the best beam pair for sidelink communication. Although the following description relates to initiating sidelink communication, it will be appreciated that this technique could be applied in other situations. Sidelink Communication FIG. 1, illustrates an arrangement of user equipment (UE) configured to support Sidelink (SL) communication where the first user equipment (initiating / transmitter UE) and the second user equipment (responding / receiving UE) are denoted by UE A and UE B, respectively. In this example, UE A and UE B both use 4 wide, partially overlapping, initial beams (ai, ... , 34) and (bi, ... , b4), respectively, for initial beam pairing (for example, corresponding to the widest attainable beams for each of 4 physical antenna panels on each device). In order to determine the best initial beam pair during SL unicast link establishment, UE A transmits a standard Direct Communication Request (DCR) message (as defined in the 3GPP specifications) repeatedly in 4x4=16 consecutive slots while both UE A and UE B perform initial beam sweeping across all 16 possible beam pairs. More specifically, UE A transmits the DCR message 4 times in a first set of 4 consecutive slots associated with a first feedback transmission occasion (Pi), using transmission beam ai, while UE B listens for transmissions in the first slot using reception beam bi, then in the second slot using reception beam b2, and so on. Next, UE A transmits the DCR message 4 times in a second set of 4 consecutive slots associated with a second feedback transmission occasion (P2), using transmission beam a2, while UE B listens for transmissions in the first slot using reception beam bi, then in the second slot using reception beam b2, and so on. Whenever UE B successfully decodes a DCR message, it transmits feedback information to UE A using a Physical Sidelink Feedback Channel (PSFCH). Such feedback information may be used as an implicit indication that a particular beam pair is good enough for SL communication. However, due to partial overlap among the initial beams and / or strong reflectors in the surrounding environment, it is possible that multiple DCR messages are successfully received by UE B, and consequently UE A may receive multiple feedback transmissions over PSFCHs from UE B. If this happens, UE A may not have sufficient information to determine the best beam pair for further communication with UE B. Thus, it may not be desirable for UE B to transmit multiple PSFCHs for initial beam pairing during SL unicast link establishment. For example, a first DCR message transmitted using beam pair (a2, bi) may be received with sufficient signal strength at UE B for successful decoding, as a result of UE A radiating enough power towards UE B when using transmission beam a2 for DCR transmission. Thus, a first feedback transmission PSFCH2.1 may be transmitted by UE B in the associated PSFCH transmission occasion P2, using beam pair (a2, bi). Later on, a second DCR message transmitted using beam pair (as, bi) may also be successfully decoded by UE B, with significantly higher received signal strength, as a result of the beams pointing directly towards each other. Thus, a second feedback transmission PSFCH3,i may be transmitted by UE B in the associated PSFCH transmission occasion P3, using beam pair (a3, bi). Further DCR messages may be successfully received using beam pairs (a3, b3); (a3, b4); and (a4, bi), leading to further feedback transmissions PSFCH3,2, PSFCH3,4, PSFCH4,i. In addition, due to hardware constraints, it may not be possible for UE B to transmit PSFCH3,i, PSFCH3,2, PSFCH3,4 in the same PSFCH transmission occasion using different PSFCH transmission beams bi, b3, b4, respectively. Hence, as mentioned above, some example embodiments provide an arrangement which enhances beam reporting when performing initial beam pairing during SL unicast 16 link establishment. In order to avoid ambiguity at the transmitter UE A regarding which of its transmission beams is best for communicating with the receiver UE B, the receiver UE B may determine whether or not to transmit feedback over PSFCH associated with successfully received Physical Sidelink Control Channel (PSCCH) / Physical Sidelink Shared Channel (PSSCH) transmissions based on corresponding beam measurements on, for example, reference signals (RS). Enhanced Beam Pairing Feedback For example, as illustrated in FIG. 2, in overview, the receiver UE B may successfully decode multiple PSCCH / PSSCH transmissions (shown as dark rectangles) transmitted over different beam pairs. For each successfully decoded PSCCH / PSSCH transmission, the receiver UE B may determine whether to transmit feedback (PSFCH2.1, PSFCHaj) or not (PSFCH3.2, PSFCH3.4, PSFCH4,i) for initial beam pairing based on how the respective beam measurement (for example, a Reference Signal Received Power (RSRP)) compares with beam measurements associated with other successfully decoded PSCCH / PSSCH transmissions. In particular, the receiver UE B may determine to transmit PSFCH for a successfully decoded PSCCH / PSSCH transmission only if the associated beam measurement is highest among all beam measurements performed so far between the pair of UEs A & B. This approach addresses the issue of ambiguity in beam reporting in case of multiple successful receptions of SL unicast link establishment messages (e.g., DCR), as a result of partial beam overlap and / or strong reflectors in the surrounding environment, when initial beam pairing is performed during SL unicast link establishment. By transmitting feedback only if the beam measurement associated with the corresponding message is highest among all currently available beam measurements, the ambiguity is resolved: the transmitter UE can assume that the latest feedback corresponds to the best beam. In overview, some example embodiments perform the method steps set out in FIG. 3. At step S10, the user equipment UE B listens for transmissions using one or more reception beams. At step S20, the user equipment UE B determines received signal characteristics of the received transmissions. At step S30, the user equipment UE B determines based on the received signal characteristics of the received transmissions whether or not to transmit a feedback transmission to the user equipment UE A. FIG. 4 illustrates schematically features of an apparatus for performing the method of FIG. 3. The apparatus 10 includes control circuitry 12, memory 14 storing software and a database, a radio interface 16 and a user interface 18. The control circuitry 12 includes listing circuitry 20 for listening for transmissions using one or more reception beams. The control circuitry 12 includes determining received signal characteristics circuitry 22 for determining received signal characteristics of the received transmissions. The control circuitry 12 includes determine transmission circuitry 24 for determining based on the received signal characteristics of the received transmissions whether or not to transmit a feedback transmission to the user equipment UE A. Alternatively, the control circuitry 12 comprises at least one processor. As shown in FIG. 2, the receiver UE B may use different beams bi, ... , b4 to listen for potential Direct Communication Request (DCR) messages from nearby UEs, such as the transmitter UE A. For example, the receiver UE B may use a first beam bi to receive a first DCR message DCRi from the transmitter UE A in a first PSCCH / PSSCH resource n and use a second beam b2 to receive a second DCR message DCR2 from the transmitter UE A in a second PSCCH / PSSCH resource r2, and so on. Although in this example, UE B cycles clockwise sequentially between different reception beams, it will be appreciated that this need not be the case and UE B may be configured to select between the reception beams in any order. Reference signals (RS), such as SL Channel State Information Reference Signals (CSI-RS), may be transmitted along with the DCR messages by the transmitter UE A. The receiver UE B may perform beam measurements on such reference signals. For example, the receiver UE B may determine a first beam measurement RSRP1 by using the first beam bi to measure on a first reference signal RS1 transmitted along with the first DCR message DCR1. Similarly, the receiver UE B may determine a second beam measurement RSRP2 by using the second beam b2 to measure on a second reference signal RS2 transmitted along with the second DCR message DCR2, and so on. Based on the beam measurements RSRP1, RSRP2, etc., the receiver UE B may determine whether or not to transmit beam feedback information to the transmitter UE A. Such beam feedback information (i.e., beam report) may be conveyed by PSFCH in feedback resources fi, f2 implicitly mapped to the PSCCH / PSSCH resources h, r2 used for transmission of the DCR messages. Exploiting transmission (TX) / rece ption (RX) beam correspondence, the receiver UE B may use the first beam bi to transmit feedback in a first PSFCH transmission PSFCH1 associated with the first DCR message (DCR1) or use the second beam b2 to transmit feedback in a second PSFCH transmission PSFCH2 associated with the second DCR 18 message DCR2. For example, the receiver UE B may determine to transmit only the first PSFCH transmission PSFCH1 if the first beam measurement RSRP1 for the first beam bi is the strongest (i.e., RSRP1 > RSRP2) but transmit only the second PSFCH transmission PSFCH2 if the first beam measurement RSRP1 is weaker than the second beam measurement (i.e., RSRP1 < RSRP2). Alternatively, the receiver UE B may transmit neither the first nor the second PSFCH transmissions PSFCH1, PSFCH2. For example, the receiver UE B may already have transmitted a prior PSFCH transmission based on an earlier beam measurement that was stronger than both the first and second beam measurements (RSRP1, RSRP2). In an alternative embodiment, the receiver UE B may use a different transmission beam (i.e. different to the beam used for receiving) to transmit determined feedback (e.g. transmit feedback in a first PSFCH transmission PSFCH1 or transmit feedback in a second PSFCH transmission PSFCH2). However, using the beam corresponding to the received transmission may be beneficial since feedback transmission using that beam may potentially be more likely detected by UE A. In some cases, the first beam bi used to receive the first DCR message DCR1 and the second beam b2 used to receive the second DCR message DCR2 may be the same beam. However, the corresponding beam measurements RSRP1, RSRP2 may be different, as the transmitter UE A may have used different transmit beams ai, ... , a4 for each DCR message. For example, referring to FIG. 2, the DCR message transmitted using beam pair (as, bi) may lead to a significantly stronger beam measurement than the previous DCR message transmitted using beam pair (a2, bi), even though the receive beam bi is the same. In some embodiments, the PSFCH transmissions used for beam reporting may be legacy HARQ feedback transmissions. For example, the first PSFCH transmission PSFCH1 may convey HARQ feedback information indicating a first positive or negative acknowledgment ACK1, NACK1 for the first DCR message DCR1, and the second PSFCH transmission PSFCH2 may convey HARQ feedback information indicating a second positive or negative acknowledgment ACK2, NACK2 for the second DCR message DCR2. This has the advantage that no dedicated PSFCH resources need to be configured for beam reporting in initial beam pairing. In some cases, the first data transmission resource n and the second data transmission resource r2 may be associated with a same PSFCH transmission occasion Pi, P2. For example, the receiver UE B may use the first and second beams bi, b2 to receive a first and second DCR message DCRi, DCR2 in a first slot and second slot, respectively, where both slots are associated with a same PSFCH occasion Pi. This allows the receiver UE B to obtain respective beam measurements in a shorter time. In some embodiments, the receiver UE B may determine or be provided with a configured number of repetitions Q (in this example Q=4) which will be applied for each DCR message on each transmit beam of the transmitter UE A. For example, the transmitter UE A may use the first beam ai to transmit Q first data transmissions PSCCH / PSSCHij, ... , PSCCH / PSSCHi.q of the first DCR message DCRi in a first set of consecutive slots Si, ... , Sq, and use the second beam a2 to transmit Q second data transmissions PSCCH / PSSCH2,i, ... , PSCCH / PSSCH2,q of the second DCR message DCR2 in a second set of consecutive slots s’i, ... , s’q. Correspondingly, the receiver UE B may use different beams bi, ... , bo of the receiver UE B to receive each (or at least some) of the Q first data transmissions PSCCH / PSSCHij, ..., PSCCH / PSSCHi.q in the first set of consecutive slots Si, ... , Sq and use different beams bi, ... , bo of the receiver UE B to receive each (or at least some) of the Q second data transmissions PSCCH / PSSCH2,i, ..., PSCCH / PSSCH2,q in the second set of consecutive slots s’i, ... , s’q. The number of repetitions (Q) may be configured to be at least equal to (i.e., not smaller than) the PSFCH transmission occasion periodicity (sl-PSFCH-Period) configured in the SL resource pool (sl-PSFCH-Period = 4 slots in the shown example), such that all slots associated with a same PSFCH transmission occasion (to be used for receiving a potential PSFCH transmission using a corresponding beam) are fully utilized, thus providing more opportunities for the receiver UE B to sweep its receive beams. A person of skill in the art would readily recognize that steps of various abovedescribed methods can be performed by programmed computers. Herein, some embodiments are also intended to cover program storage devices, e.g., digital data storage media, which are machine or computer readable and encode machineexecutable or computer-executable programs of instructions, wherein said instructions perform some or all of the steps of said above-described methods. The program storage devices may be, e.g., digital memories, magnetic storage media such as a magnetic disks and magnetic tapes, hard drives, or optically readable digital data storage media. The embodiments are also intended to cover computers programmed to perform said steps of the above-described methods. The tern non-transitory as used herein, is a limitation of the medium itself (i.e., tangible, not a signal) as opposed to a limitation on data storage persistency (e.g. RAM vs ROM). As used in this application, the term “circuitry” may refer to one or more or all of the following: (a) hardware-only circuit implementations (such as implementations in only analog and / or digital circuitry) and (b) combinations of hardware circuits and software, such as (as applicable): (i) a combination of analog and / or digital hardware circuit(s) with software / firmware and (ii) any portions of hardware processor(s) with software (including digital signal processor(s)), software, and memory(ies) that work together to cause an apparatus, such as a mobile phone or server, to perform various functions) and (c) hardware circuit(s) and or processor(s), such as a microprocessor(s) or a portion of a microprocessor(s), that requires software (e.g., firmware) for operation, but the software may not be present when it is not needed for operation. This definition of circuitry applies to all uses of this term in this application, including in any claims. As a further example, as used in this application, the term circuitry also covers an implementation of merely a hardware circuit or processor (or multiple processors) or portion of a hardware circuit or processor and its (or their) accompanying software and / or firmware. The term circuitry also covers, for example and if applicable to the particular claim element, a baseband integrated circuit or processor integrated circuit for a mobile device or a similar integrated circuit in server, a cellular network device, or other computing or network device. Although example embodiments of the present invention have been described in the preceding paragraphs with reference to various examples, it should be appreciated that modifications to the examples given can be made without departing from the scope of the invention as claimed. Features described in the preceding description may be used in combinations other than the combinations explicitly described. Although functions have been described with reference to certain features, those functions may be performable by other features whether described or not. Although features have been described with reference to certain embodiments, those 5 features may also be present in other embodiments whether described or not. Whilst endeavouring in the foregoing specification to draw attention to those features of the invention believed to be of particular importance it should be understood that the Applicant claims protection in respect of any patentable feature or combination of 10 features hereinbefore referred to and / or shown in the drawings whether or not particular emphasis has been placed thereon.
Claims
1. An apparatus, comprising:at least one processor; andat least one memory storing instructions that, when executed by the at least one processor, cause the apparatus at least to perform:listening, using a first reception beam for a first sidelink transmission and using a second reception beam for a second sidelink transmission of a plurality of sidelink transmissions from a user equipment;determining a first received signal characteristic of said first sidelink transmission;determining a second received signal characteristic of said second sidelink transmission; anddetermining, based on said first and second received signal characteristics, whether to:transmit a first feedback transmission to the user equipment in a first feedback transmission resource associated with the first sidelink transmission using a first transmission beam corresponding to said first reception beam;transmit a second feedback transmission to the user equipment in a second feedback transmission resource associated with the second sidelink transmission using a second transmission beam corresponding to said second reception beam; ortransmit neither the first feedback transmission nor the second feedback transmission.
2. The apparatus of claim 1, wherein said first and second feedback transmission resources occur in a same feedback transmission occasion and said instructions, when executed by the at least one processor, further cause the apparatus at least to perform: determining to transmit said first feedback transmission to the user equipment in said first feedback transmission resource associated with the first sidelink transmission based on said first received signal characteristic exceeding said second received signal characteristic, or to transmit said second feedback transmission to the user equipment in said second feedback transmission resource associated with the second sidelink transmission based on said second received signal characteristic exceeding said first received signal characteristic.
3. The apparatus of claim 1 or 2, wherein said first and second feedback transmission resources occur in a same feedback transmission occasion and saidinstructions, when executed by the at least one processor, further cause the apparatus at least to perform:determining to transmit said first feedback transmission to the user equipment in said first feedback transmission resource associated with the first sidelink transmission based on said first received signal characteristic exceeding both said second received signal characteristic and a received signal characteristic of a sidelink transmission associated with an earlier feedback transmission occasion for which feedback was transmitted, or to transmit said second feedback transmission to the user equipment in said second feedback transmission resource associated with the second sidelink transmission based on said second received signal characteristic exceeding both said first received signal characteristic and a received signal characteristic of a sidelink transmission associated with an earlier feedback transmission occasion for which feedback was transmitted.
4. The apparatus of any preceding claim, wherein said first and second feedback transmission resources occur in a same feedback transmission occasion and said instructions, when executed by the at least one processor, further cause the apparatus at least to perform:determining to transmit neither said first feedback transmission nor said second feedback transmission to the user equipment based on neither said first received signal characteristic nor said second received signal characteristic exceeding a received signal characteristic of a sidelink transmission associated with an earlier feedback transmission occasion for which feedback was transmitted.
5. The apparatus of any preceding claim, wherein said first feedback transmission resource occurs in an earlier feedback transmission occasion than said second feedback transmission resource and said first and second reception beams are the same and said instructions, when executed by the at least one processor, further cause the apparatus at least to perform:determining to transmit said second feedback transmission to the user equipment in said second feedback transmission resource associated with the second sidelink transmission based on said second received signal characteristic exceeding said first received signal characteristic.
6. The apparatus of any preceding claim, wherein said first feedback transmission resource occurs in an earlier feedback transmission occasion than said second feedback transmission resource and said first and second reception beams are thesame and said instructions, when executed by the at least one processor, further cause the apparatus at least to perform:determining not to transmit said second feedback transmission to the user equipment in said second feedback transmission resource associated with the second sidelink transmission based on said second received signal characteristic not exceeding said first received signal characteristic.
7. The apparatus of any preceding claim, wherein said first feedback transmission resource occurs in an earlier feedback transmission occasion than said second feedback transmission resource and said first and second reception beams are the same and said instructions, when executed by the at least one processor, further cause the apparatus at least to perform:determining to transmit said second feedback transmission to the user equipment in said second feedback transmission resource associated with the second sidelink transmission based on said second received signal characteristic exceeding both said first received signal characteristic and a received signal characteristic of a sidelink transmission associated with an earlier feedback transmission occasion for which feedback was transmitted.
8. The apparatus of any preceding claim, wherein said first feedback transmission resource occurs in an earlier feedback transmission occasion than said second feedback transmission resource and said first and second reception beams are the same and said instructions, when executed by the at least one processor, further cause the apparatus at least to perform:determining not to transmit said second feedback transmission to the user equipment in said second feedback transmission resource associated with the second sidelink transmission based on said second received signal characteristic not exceeding both said first received signal characteristic and a received signal characteristic of a sidelink transmission associated with an earlier feedback transmission occasion for which feedback was transmitted.
9. The apparatus of any preceding claim, wherein said received signal characteristics comprise a received signal quality and / or a received signal strength.
10. The apparatus of any preceding claim, wherein said instructions, when executed by the at least one processor, further cause the apparatus at least to perform:listening, using a sequentially different one of a plurality of reception beams at the apparatus, for a corresponding one of said plurality of sidelink transmissions from said user equipment.
11. The apparatus of claim 10, wherein said instructions, when executed by the at least one processor, further cause the apparatus at least to perform:determining a configured number of sidelink transmissions to be transmitted by said user equipment with a same transmission configuration; andlistening, using a sequentially different one of the plurality of reception beams at the apparatus, for a corresponding one of the configured number of sidelink transmissions from said user equipment.
12. The apparatus of any preceding claim, wherein said first feedback transmission indicates to said user equipment that a transmission configuration associated with said first sidelink transmission is to be used for sidelink transmission with said apparatus and said second feedback transmission indicates to said user equipment that a transmission configuration associated with said second sidelink transmission is to be used for sidelink transmission with said apparatus.
13. The apparatus of any preceding claim, wherein said first and second feedback transmission resources are Physical Sidelink Feedback Channel resources.
14. The apparatus of any preceding claim, wherein said first feedback transmission and / or said second feedback transmission comprises Hybrid Automatic Repeat reQuest feedback information.
15. The apparatus of any preceding claim, wherein said plurality of sidelink transmissions include a reference signal.
16. The apparatus of claim 15, wherein said instructions, when executed by the at least one processor, further cause the apparatus at least to perform:determining said first and second received signal characteristics by performing a measurement on the reference signal of the first and second sidelink transmissions.
17. The apparatus of any preceding claim, wherein said plurality of sidelink transmissions comprise a Direct Communication Request message.
18. The apparatus of any preceding claim, wherein said first reception beam and said second reception beam are the same.
19. A method, comprising:listening, using a first reception beam for a first sidelink transmission and using a second reception beam for a second sidelink transmission of a plurality of sidelink transmissions from a user equipment;determining a first received signal characteristic of said first sidelink transmission;determining a second received signal characteristic of said second sidelink transmission; anddetermining, based on said first and second received signal characteristics, whether to:transmit a first feedback transmission to the user equipment in a first feedback transmission resource associated with the first sidelink transmission using a first transmission beam corresponding to said first reception beam;transmit a second feedback transmission to the user equipment in a second feedback transmission resource associated with the second sidelink transmission using a second transmission beam corresponding to said second reception beam; ortransmit neither the first feedback transmission nor the second feedback transmission.
