A low-cost method to compute the shielding effectiveness due to reflection (SER) of vacuum coated thin films

IN595849BActive Publication Date: 2026-07-17B M S COLLEGE OF ENG
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
IN202541131922
Authority / Receiving Office
IN · IN
Patent Type
Patents
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2025-12-26
Publication Date
2026-07-17
Estimated Expiration
2045-12-26

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Conventional methods for characterizing the Shielding Effectiveness due to Reflection (SER) of vacuum-coated thin films require large samples and complex two-port antenna setups, leading to high costs, material waste, and experimental errors, which are not compatible with standard vacuum-coating chambers and industrial PCB processes.

Method used

A one-port waveguide-based characterization technique using a customized PCB with optimized vacuum coating and single-port excitation to measure the input reflection coefficient S11, reducing sample size and eliminating mutual coupling errors, compatible with standard waveguide geometries and scalable across microwave and millimeter-wave frequencies.

Benefits of technology

Provides high-fidelity, low-cost, and accurate SER characterization of thin films on PCB substrates, minimizing material use and experimental errors, while maintaining compatibility with industrial processes and standard laboratory infrastructure.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

ABSTRACT A low-cost method to compute the shielding effectiveness due to reflection (SER) of vacuum coated thin films The present invention discloses a low-cost, one-port experimental method and system for characterizing the Shielding Effectiveness due to Reflection (SER) of vacuum-coated thin films. The method utilizes a customized Printed Circuit Board (PCB) designed to match the specific aperture dimensions and fastening geometry of a standard waveguide adapter, such as in the Ka-band. A conductive thin film, approximately 1000 nm thick, is deposited onto the PCB using an optimized physical vapor deposition (PVD) process with a 0.2g metal source and an 11 cm source-to-substrate distance. The coated PCB is fastened to the waveguide adapter, and the input reflection coefficient (|S11|) is measured via a single port. This eliminates the need for electrically large samples and complex two-port setups required by conventional free-space methods. The invention provides a scalable, high-precision solution for EMI suppression characterization with significant technical advancement and economic significance. Fig. 1
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

FIELD OF INVENTION

[0001] The present invention relates to the field of electromagneticcompatibility (EMC) and electromagnetic interference (EMI) mitigationtechnologies. More specifically, the invention relates to a system and amethod for the experimental characterization of Shielding Effectivenessdue to Reflection (SER) of vacuum-coated conductive thin films ondielectric substrates.

[0002] The invention pertains to a one-port waveguide-basedcharacterization technique that utilizes a single-port excitation todetermine the reflection coefficient S11 of a specimen. The system isspecifically designed to accommodate substrates realized throughindustrially viable Printed Circuit Board (PCB) manufacturingprocesses and Physical Vapor Deposition (PVD) techniques.

[0003] The disclosed method provides a scalable solution forcharacterization across microwave and millimeter-wave frequencybands, particularly the Ka-band, by utilizing customized PCBgeometries compliant with standard waveguide aperture dimensions.This invention addresses the technical limitations of conventional freespace measurement methods, such as the requirement for electricallylarge samples and complex multi-antenna setups, by offering aprecision-guided, small-form-factor alternative for characterizing thinfilm reflectors.BACKGROUND

[0004] Electromagnetic interference (EMI) suppression is a criticalrequirement in the design of wireless products, typically achievedthrough the use of absorbers or reflectors. While reflectors are relativelyeasier to fabricate, their experimental characterization presentssignificant technical and economic challenges. The conventional goldstandard, known as the Free-Space Method, requires an electricallylarge sample—typically at least 10 λ X 10 λ in size to be mounted in thefar-field of multiple horn antennas. At microwave and millimeter-wavefrequencies, such as the Ka-band, this requirement necessitates thefabrication of large-scale samples that often exceed the physicaldeposition limits of standard vacuum-coating chambers, which aretypically restricted to smaller apertures.

[0005] Furthermore, traditional two-port measurement setups involvecomplex calibration processes to mitigate mutual coupling betweenantennas, which introduces high margins of experimental error. Thefabrication of large structures also results in a high consumption ofdielectric substrates and expensive source metals, leading toprohibitive costs. There is, therefore, a long-standing need for asimplified, low-cost characterization method that is compatible withindustrially viable PCB manufacturing processes, utilizes minimalmaterial, and allows for accurate SER determination using a singleport excitation that can be scaled across various microwave andmillimeter-wave frequency bands.OBJECT OF INVENTION

[0006] The primary object of the present invention is to provide a lowcost, simplified method for the experimental characterization ofshielding effectiveness due to reflection (SER) that overcomes thelogistical and financial constraints of far-field free-space measurementsystems. Another object of the invention is to provide a characterizationtechnique that is fully compliant with commercially availablewaveguide adapter geometries, specifically optimized for the Ka-bandand scalable to other microwave and millimeter-wave frequencies. It isa further object of the invention to enable SER characterization ofvacuum-coated thin films on customized, industrially viable PCBsubstrates, such as FR4, thereby reducing the volume of dielectricmaterial and conductive source metal required.

[0007] Yet another object of the invention is to eliminate the need forcomplex two-port antenna setups by utilizing a single-port excitationmethod that relies on the input reflection coefficient S11 forcomputation, which significantly reduces experimental errorsassociated with mutual coupling and multi-step characterization.Additionally, the invention aims to provide an optimized vacuumcoating process involving specific source-to-substrate distances andmetal mass parameters to ensure a uniform 1000nm thin-filmdeposition across the waveguide aperture. Ultimately, the inventionseeks to offer a streamlined, one-step characterization process thatprovides high-fidelity EMI shielding data while remaining compatiblewith standard laboratory infrastructure and small-scale vacuumdeposition apertures.SUMMARY OF INVENTION

[0008] The present invention provides a simplified, one-portexperimental method for characterizing the Shielding Effectiveness dueto Reflection (SER) of vacuum-coated thin films on dielectricsubstrates. The method utilizes a customized Printed Circuit Board(PCB) designed to match the specific dimensions of a standardwaveguide adapter for a target frequency band, such as the Ka-band.By integrating industrially viable photolithography with an optimizedphysical vapor deposition (PVD) process, a uniform conductive layertypically 1000 nm thick—is deposited on the substrate using a precisesource-to-substrate distance and metal mass configuration. Thiseliminates the need for the electrically large samples (10λ X 10λ)required by conventional free-space methods, thereby enablingcharacterization within the size limitations of standard vacuum coatingchambers.

[0009] Technically, the invention replaces the complex two-port hornantenna setup with a single-port waveguide assembly. The customized,coated PCB is fastened directly to the waveguide aperture, and theinput reflection coefficient S11 is measured. This value is then used tocompute the SER through a simplified mathematical process,effectively reducing computational steps and experimental errorscaused by mutual coupling. The invention offers a scalable solutionacross microwave and millimeter-wave bands, providing a highprecision, low-cost alternative for EMI suppression testing in wirelessproduct design. By minimizing dielectric material usage and utilizingstandard waveguide geometries, the method achieves significanteconomic significance while maintaining the rigorous accuracyrequired for thin-film material characterization.BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF DRAWINGS

[0010] Figure 1 - Flowchart to illustrate the disclosed method toexperimentally characterize shielding Effectiveness due to reflection(SER).

[0011] Figure 2 - Schematics of a standard waveguide adapteroperating in the Ka-band (isometric view)

[0012] Figure 3 - Schematics of a standard waveguide adapteroperating in the Ka-band (side view)

[0013] Figure 4 - Input reflection coefficient of the standard openended waveguide adapter operating in the Ka-band

[0014] Figure 5 - Schematics of the overall assembly of the waveguideadapter with un-coated substrate (isometric view)

[0015] Figure 6 – (A) Schematics of the overall assembly of thewaveguide adapter with un-coated substrate (side view) and (B)Schematics of the design of the customized PCB prior to the metalcoating.

[0016] Figure 7 - Input reflection coefficient of the waveguide adapterfastened to the un-coated PCB.

[0017] Figure 8 - Schematic of the overall assembly of the disclosedlow-cost method (Isometric view)

[0018] Figure 9 - Schematics of the overall assembly of the disclosedlow-cost method (side view)

[0019] Figure 10 - Input reflection coefficient and shieldingEffectiveness due to reflection of an example of the disclosed low costmethod.DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF INVENTION

[0020] The present invention provides a comprehensive technicalsolution to the existing challenges in electromagnetic interference (EMI)characterization, specifically addressing the measurement of ShieldingEffectiveness due to Reflection (SER) in vacuum-coated thin films. Theinvention centers on a one-port experimental characterizationtechnique that utilizes a customized Printed Circuit Board (PCB)substrate integrated with a standard waveguide adapter.

[0021] Traditional methods, such as the free-space method, areinherently limited by the requirement of electrically large samples,typically 10 λ X 10 λ in dimension. In the microwave and millimeterwave bands, such as the Ka-band, this requirement translates tosample sizes that exceed the uniform coating apertures of standardvacuum deposition chambers, which are generally restricted to 60mmx 60mm. The present invention overcomes this physical impossibilityby adapting the measurement environment to a waveguide geometry,where the effective sensing area is reduced to the waveguide aperturesize, such as 7.11 mm x 3.56 mm for Ka-band applications, therebyallowing for the characterization of high-precision, vacuum-coatedsamples that were previously impossible to test accurately usingstandardized free-space protocols.

[0022] The methodology begins with the selection of the microwave ormillimeter-wave band of interest. Each frequency band corresponds toa specific commercial waveguide adapter with standardized internaldimensions. For instance, in the exemplary embodiment of the Kaband, the waveguide dimensions are meticulously noted as 7.11 mm x3.56 mm. The invention involves the design of a customized PCBgeometry that is strictly compliant with these waveguide dimensions.This design process is not a mere selection of materials but a preciseengineering of a substrate that accommodates the nuances of thewaveguide adapter interface and the subsequent vacuum coatingprocess.

[0023] The fabrication of this board employs industrially viablephotolithography techniques, ensuring that the process remains lowcost and scalable. The choice of substrate, such as FR4 with athickness of 1.6 mm, a dielectric constant of 4.4, and a loss tangent of0.04, provides a universally available and cost-effective medium. Thecustomized PCB is designed with specific protrusions and drill holesthat align perfectly with the fastening holes of the waveguide adapter,ensuring a secure, gap-free mechanical and electrical contact that isessential for preventing electromagnetic leakage during themeasurement of the input reflection coefficient.

[0024] The vacuum coating process is a critical inventive step withinthe disclosed method, optimized to ensure a uniform and homogeneousconductive layer on the predefined geometry of the dielectric substrate.This process utilizes Physical Vapor Deposition (PVD) where the metalsource, typically 0.2g of 99.99% pure Aluminum or other conductivemetals, is placed in a tungsten boat filament. The filament acts as asurface source, and the deposition uniformity is achieved bymaintaining a specific source-to-substrate distance of 11 cm. Thisdistance is strategically chosen to ensure that the primary effective sizeof the substrate (7.11 mm x 3.56 mm for Ka-band) stays within thelimits of the uniform coating aperture of the vacuum depositionmechanism.

[0024] The coating process is conducted for a duration ofapproximately 3 minutes, resulting in a thin-film thickness of around1000 nm. This specific thickness is sufficient to achieve high reflectivitywhile remaining within the thin-film regime, ensuring that the electricalcharacteristics are dominated by the surface conductivity of thedeposited metal. This optimized process ensures consistent electricalcontact and uniform film morphology, which are prerequisites for areliable and repeatable |S11| reading.

[0025] Upon completion of the coating process, the metal-coatedcustomized PCB is fastened to the commercial waveguide adapter. Theassembly is then connected to a single-port excitation source, such asa Vector Network Analyzer (VNA) calibrated for the specific frequencyband. The use of a single-port setup is a significant technicaladvancement over conventional two-port horn antenna systems. Intwo-port systems, the mutual coupling between antennas and therequirement for complex de-embedding of the environment often leadto experimental errors. The present invention eliminates these errorsby confining the electromagnetic waves within the waveguide structure,where the input reflection coefficient (|S11|) can be measured with highprecision. The shielding effectiveness due to reflection (SER) is thencomputed directly from the measured magnitude of |S11| using asimplified computational approach.

[0026] Because the waveguide aperture is completely terminated by thereflective coated substrate, the reflected power represents the shieldingcapacity of the film. The mathematical relationship enables thedetermination of SER without the need for complex transmissionmeasurements (|S21|), thereby reducing the hardware requirementand the time taken for characterization.

[0027] The non-obviousness of this invention is further demonstratedby the integration of the PCB manufacturing process with microwavecharacterization. A person skilled in the art would traditionally seek toincrease sample size for accuracy; however, this invention moves in theopposite direction by shrinking the sample size to fit the waveguidewhile simultaneously optimizing the coating parameters to maintainaccuracy. The technical effect produced is a high-fidelity measurementof reflection shielding that is immune to the multipath interference anddiffraction effects typically encountered in free-space setups.Furthermore, the scalability of the method is a vital feature; by simplyaltering the waveguide adapter and the corresponding PCB flangedimensions, the method can be applied from microwave X-bands up toW-band millimeter-wave frequencies. This universality, combined withthe significant reduction in material costs using only 0.2g of metal andminimal dielectric area confers an economic significance that meets therequirements of the Indian Patent Office for an inventive step.

[0028] The detailed assembly shown in the accompanying drawingsfurther clarifies the invention's practical application. Fig. 1 illustratesthe sequential flowchart from band selection to SER computation, whileFig. 8 and Fig. 9 show the isometric and side views of the finalassembly. The protrusions on the customized PCB, as shown in Fig.6B, are specifically engineered for handling during the vacuum coatingprocess and do not interfere with the electromagnetic measurementsonce the board is fastened to the waveguide cavity. This dual-purposedesign of the substrate serving both as a deposition carrier and ameasurement flange is a novel structural feature.

[0029] The input reflection coefficient of the waveguide alone (Fig. 4)compared with the assembly of the coated board (Fig. 10) clearly showsa dramatic shift in |S11| toward 0 dB, signifying near-total reflectionand high SER. This quantifiable change provides the evidentiarysupport for the invention's utility in characterizing EMI suppressantsfor wireless products. By providing a method that is compliant withstandard laboratory equipment and industrial PCB processes, theinvention bridges the gap between material research and practicalproduct design, offering a tool for testing labs and wireless hardwaredevelopers to validate shielding materials efficiently.

[0030] To conclude the technical disclosure, the invention successfullyaddresses the problem of expensive and complex EMI characterizationby replacing electrically large, hard-to-fabricate samples withcustomized, vacuum-coated PCB flanges. The technical advancementis rooted in the optimized coating geometry, the one-port waveguidemeasurement technique, and the simplified computation of SER. Thiscombination ensures that the invention is not a mere workshopimprovement but a distinct technological leap that provides accurate,repeatable, and low-cost characterization data.

Claims

1. A method for experimentally characterizing the Shielding Effectiveness due to Reflection (SER) of vacuum-coated thin films on a substrate, the method comprising: - Designing a customized Printed Circuit Board (PCB) substrate having mechanical dimensions and fastening apertures congruent with a flange of a standard waveguide adapter for a selected frequency band; - Depositing a conductive thin film onto a predefined effective area of the said customized PCB substrate via a Physical Vapor Deposition (PVD) process optimized for a uniform coating aperture; - Fastening the metal-coated customized PCB substrate to the aperture of the standard waveguide adapter to form a terminated waveguide assembly; - Exciting the said assembly through a single port to measure an input reflection coefficient (|S11|); and - Computing the SER value of the conductive thin film based on the magnitude of the measured |S11|.

2. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein the Physical Vapor Deposition (PVD) process is optimized by: - Placing a conductive metal source of approximately 0.2g mass in a tungsten boat; - Maintaining a fixed source-to-substrate distance of 11 cm to ensure deposition within the uniform coating aperture; and - Executing the coating for a duration of 3 minutes under high vacuum to achieve a uniform film thickness of approximately 1000 nm.

3. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein the customized PCB substrate is fabricated using a photolithography process on an FR4 material having a thickness of 1.6 mm, a dielectric constant (εr) of approximately 4.4, and a loss tangent of 0.04.

4. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein the selected frequency band comprises microwave and millimeter-wave frequencies, including but not limited to the Ka-band, where the effective area of the substrate is approximately 7.11 mm x 3.56 mm.

5. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein the single port excitation is performed using a Vector Network Analyzer (VNA) calibrated for the selected frequency band, eliminating the need for two-port transmission measurements.

6. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein the computation of SER is performed using the formula SER (dB) = 10log10 (1 / (1 - |S11|2)), where |S11| represents the magnitude of the measured reflection coefficient.

7. A system for characterizing Shielding Effectiveness due to Reflection (SER), the system comprising: - A standard waveguide adapter acting as an electromagnetic interface; - A customized PCB substrate acting as a test coupon, characterized in that the substrate is dimensioned to terminate the aperture of the waveguide adapter and comprises a vacuumdeposited conductive thin film of 1000 nm thickness; and - A single-port measurement means connected to the waveguide adapter to record the input reflection coefficient across a target frequency spectrum.

8. The system as claimed in claim 7, wherein the customized PCB substrate further comprises structural protrusions designed for mounting within a vacuum coating chamber, which do not interfere with the electromagnetic aperture of the waveguide adapter.

9. The system as claimed in claim 7, wherein the conductive thin film is a 99.99% pure metal selected from a group comprising Aluminum, Copper, Silver, or Gold, deposited specifically to cover the effective area corresponding to the waveguide cavity dimensions.

10. The system as claimed in claim 7, wherein the alignment between the waveguide cavity and the coated area of the PCB is maintained by concentric fastening holes on the PCB that match the mechanical housing of the waveguide adapter.