Quantitative structural assay of nerve graft

JP2024075634A5Active Publication Date: 2024-11-19AXOGEN CORP
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
JP2024038926
Authority / Receiving Office
JP · JP
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2015-05-28
Filing Date
2024-03-13
Publication Date
2024-11-19
Estimated Expiration
2036-05-20

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

There is no efficient and reproducible mechanism to assess the structural properties of nerve grafts, which are crucial for their effectiveness in promoting axonal growth during nerve repair.

Method used

A method involving image processing techniques to analyze laminin-stained nerve grafts, identifying endoneurial canals, and measuring structural properties such as the number, percentage, and circumference of endoneurial lumens to determine graft quality.

Benefits of technology

Provides a quantitative assessment of nerve grafts, correlating structural properties with qualitative scores and bioassay results to ensure the grafts have sufficient bioactive scaffolds for effective axonal regeneration.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure 00000014_0000
    Figure 00000014_0000
  • Figure 00000014_0001
    Figure 00000014_0001
  • Figure 00000015_0000
    Figure 00000015_0000
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

To provide techniques for determining the quality of a nerve graft by assessing structural characteristics of the nerve graft.SOLUTION: Aspects of the techniques include: obtaining an image identifying laminin-containing tissue in the nerve graft; creating a transformed image using a transformation function of an image processing application on the image; using an analysis function of the image processing application, analyzing the transformed image to identify one or more structures in accordance with one or more recognition criteria; and determining one or more structural characteristics of the nerve graft derived from a measurement of the one or more structures.SELECTED DRAWING: None
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[Background technology]

[0001] During human trauma, peripheral nerves are often damaged or severed. Small gaps can be repaired by direct nerve repair, whereas larger gaps can be repaired using nerve grafts. Axonal segments close to the injury site are capable of regenerating new axonal sprouts, but non-functional distal axonal segments and myelin sheaths are thought to have an anti-proliferative effect that reduces nerve regeneration. It has been demonstrated that elimination of non-functional nerve elements improves axonal growth in distal nerve segments.

[0002] One technique to improve the efficacy of nerve grafts is to eliminate the nerve graft of non-functional neural elements before surgically placing the graft at the repair site. Nerve grafts, such as acellular grafts with a structure and composition similar to a nerve bundle, can support axonal regeneration by providing a scaffold onto which new axonal segments can grow. Acellular nerve grafts, sometimes called processed nerve grafts, support and direct the growing axonal segments with a supporting structure while providing a pathway free of axonal and myelin debris. Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]

[0003] The present invention provides materials and methods for determining the quality of nerve grafts by assessing their quantitative structural properties. [Means for solving the problem]

[0004] In certain embodiments, the method includes acquiring an image identifying laminin-containing tissue in the nerve graft, applying a transformation function of the image processing application to the image to form a transformed image, analyzing the transformed image using an analysis function of the image processing application to identify one or more structures according to one or more recognition criteria, and determining one or more structural characteristics of the nerve graft derived from measurements of the one or more structures.

[0005] In certain embodiments, the structural properties are derived from measurements of endoneurial tubes present in the nerve graft bundle, hi certain embodiments, the structural properties include the number of endoneurial tubes per area, the percentage of endoneurial tube lumen per area, the total circumference of endoneurial tube lumen per area, or a combination thereof.

[0006] In certain embodiments, the techniques also include comparing the structural characteristics to a qualitative assessment score, one or more reference ranges indicative of acceptable structural characteristics of the nerve graft, bioassay results of the nerve graft, or a combination thereof.

[0007] This Summary is intended to present selected concepts in a simplified form that are described below in the Detailed Description. It is not intended to identify key or essential features of the inventive subject matter or to limit the scope of the inventive subject matter.

[0008] This application contains at least one color drawing. Copies of the color image will be provided by the Office upon request and upon the necessary fee. [Brief description of the drawings]

[0009] [Figure 1] FIG. 1 shows an image of a slide with cross-sections of peripheral nerve fibers stained against laminin to highlight endoneurial tubes and other adjacent structures. [Diagram 2] 1 illustrates an exemplary procedural flow used in certain embodiments of the present technology. [Figure 3A] FIG. 13 shows the effect of binarization on images of cross-sections of laminin-stained endoneurial tubes. [Figure 3B] FIG. 13 shows an example of the effect of particle analysis on a binarized image of a cross-section of a laminin-stained endoneurial tube. [Figure 4] 1 shows an exemplary embodiment comparing images of nerve grafts subjected to the various techniques described. [Figure 5A] Scatter plots comparing various architectural features with historical qualitative histological scores are shown. [Figure 5B] Scatter plots comparing various architectural features with historical qualitative histological scores are shown. [Figure 5C] Scatter plots comparing various architectural features with historical qualitative histological scores are shown. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS

[0010] The degree to which a nerve graft is effective in promoting axonal growth is believed to be related to the structural properties of the nerve graft. However, there is no efficient and reproducible mechanism for evaluating the structural properties of nerve grafts. The present invention provides a technique for determining the quality of nerve grafts by evaluating the quantitative structural properties of the nerve grafts.

[0011] In certain embodiments, the structural properties are derived from measurements of endoneurial tubes present in the bundles of the nerve graft.

[0012] The outermost layer of the nerve cable is the epineurium, which is the layer most commonly interacted with during peripheral nerve repair. In larger nerve cables, the cable is further divided into numerous muscle bundles, which are defined by another connective tissue layer, the perineurium. The "endoneurial canal" is the smallest, thinnest and innermost connective tissue layer in peripheral nerve cables, also called the endoneurial membrane, endoneurial channel, endoneurial sheath or Henle's sheath. They are covered and concealed by Schwann cells of the sheathed axons. The orientation of the endoneurial canal is generally longitudinal along the direction of the nerve cable, except where the fibers leave the nerve cable (or enter, in the case of a breakdown in communication between different nerve cables). The endoneurial canal is a thin basement membrane consisting mainly of a layer of collagen IV with a layer of laminin on the inner surface.

[0013] FIG. 1 shows an image of a slide with cross-sections of peripheral nerve fibers with anti-laminin immunostaining highlighting the endoneurial tubes.

[0014] An important aspect of the efficacy or bioactivity of nerve grafts is the structural integrity and structural properties of the graft. The greater the amount and tangibility of bioactive scaffolding (laminin-coated endoneurial tube arrays) present in the graft, the greater the bioactivity of the graft. This is because more bioactive scaffolding provides more growth structure for axons and Schwann cells to extend from.

[0015] Immunohistochemical staining (e.g., anti-laminin staining) can confirm the presence of laminin in the endoneurium. In an embodiment of the technology according to the present invention, tissue from a processed nerve graft is stained with an anti-laminin antibody, e.g., a polyclonal antibody. Analyzed images of the tissue are subjected to image processing to determine the structural properties of laminin stained structures, such as endoneurotic tubes, present in the two-dimensional tissue sections.

[0016] In some embodiments, image processing also includes the selection of substructures or regions of interest (e.g., fiber bundles) to further refine the image regions in which relevant structures reside. Selection can be done manually by a human operator, for example, using a selection tool to outline the outer edge of a structure or region. Selection can also be automated by the image processing application, and in some cases, verified by a human. In some embodiments, a "sampling window" can be used to define a subset of the image. Also, in some embodiments, the entire image may be utilized.

[0017] In some embodiments, image processing involves manipulating the image to make structures of interest more visible for analysis. The type of image processing used in some embodiments includes binarizing the image according to various parameters.

[0018] In one embodiment, the identification of a structure (eg, endoneurial tube) used to determine the structural properties is according to one or more recognition criteria, such as size or circularity of the structure.

[0019] In various embodiments, the structural properties include measuring (1) the number of endoneurial tubes in a region, (2) the percentage of endoneurial lumen in a region, and / or (3) the total circumference of the endoneurial lumen in a region. Better structural properties will result in higher decision values. These methods provide quantitative evidence of the presence of laminin and structure in the endoneuria of the nerve graft. Structural properties are calculated for regions comprised of selected regions of interest and / or substructures, for a sampling window, or for a fixed region.

[0020] In some embodiments, the quantitative assessment of structural quality is correlated to a qualitative assessment. The quantitative metrics can be correlated to other metrics, such as qualitative scores previously obtained from the same graft. One method to qualitatively assess the structural integrity of treated nerve allografts involves anti-laminin staining of the tissue and scoring on a qualitative ranking scale of appearance (e.g., a scale of 1 to 5 in 0.5 increments) compared to a positive control containing untreated peripheral nerve tissue. However, this method is operator-dependent and does not allow for a reproducible method to accurately assess the amount or usefulness of the bioactive scaffold.

[0021] In one embodiment, the structural property determined for a sample can be compared to a reference range for the structural property that is indicative of acceptable nerve graft quality. Nerve grafts having structural property values ​​outside the range are considered to be of unacceptable quality.

[0022] In certain embodiments, the determined structural characteristics may be compared or correlated with results from a bioassay of the neural graft, for example, to determine the bioactivity of the graft by measuring the extent of neurite outgrowth in cultured grafts. In some cases, the results of the bioassay are correlated with the results from the structural characteristics to derive a reference range for a graft of acceptable quality.

[0023] FIG. 2 illustrates an exemplary procedural flow used in one embodiment of the present technology.

[0024] Some steps are performed using functions or features of an image processing application, which is a computer program for manipulating the properties of digital images. An example of an image processing application used in the examples is Fiji (also known as ImageJ). Additionally, some steps described in FIG. 2 are optional in some embodiments.

[0025] Images are obtained that identify laminin-containing tissue in the nerve graft (200). Typically, these nerve graft cross sections (or "strips") are obtained by histological preparation of the nerve graft sample, e.g., sectioning, staining, and mounting the sample on a slide, which is then imaged using slide analysis hardware and software. Such images may be by-products or artifacts from, for example, manufacturing, processing, or quality control steps that prepare the graft for surgical implantation of the graft. In some cases, images may be derived at one stage of generation / processing, storage, and may be evaluated at different times using the techniques described.

[0026] In one embodiment, the nerve graft is a processed nerve allograft (human) that is responsible for the surgical repair of peripheral nerve transection to support regeneration across the defect. One example of a processed nerve allograft is AxoGen's Avance® nerve graft. Nerve allografts provide surgeons with an easily accessible nerve graft to repair peripheral nerves that have been damaged, for example, by trauma or removed during surgery. Decellularization of processed human nerve allografts results in surgical implants with naturally organized pathways that guide axonal regeneration. Such nerve grafts are available in a variety of lengths and diameters, and function similarly to autograft nerve grafts without the complications associated with secondary surgical sites. Decellularization of nerve allografts removes most axonal and myelin debris, allowing the nerve to have an unobstructed pathway to regrow. Processing also removes materials and molecules that may cause adverse immune responses in the recipient.

[0027] In some embodiments, the nerve graft strips are immunohistochemically stained to identify relevant structures in the images. For example, anti-laminin staining of nerve graft strips results in high contrast images showing endoneurial tubes and other laminin-containing structures. In some cases, for example, staining can be performed with immunoperoxidase dyes using a polymer-based secondary system (Dako Envision and Rabbit HRP) and polyclonal rabbit anti-laminin (Dako Z0097) with DAB (3,3'-diaminobenzidine) as a revealer. However, other types of dyes (e.g., monoclonal antibody stains) or other structure segmentation techniques that adequately identify endoneurial tubes or other major structural components in the images can be used.

[0028] Referring again to Figure 1, anti-laminin staining of a cross section of a nerve graft is illustrated. In Figure 1, laminin-containing structures are shown in brown. Laminin-containing structures important for determining structural properties include the endoneurial tubes and perineurium (which define the bundles).

[0029] In some cases, the quality of the staining is inspected for suitability as a basis for analysis of the structural properties of the graft. Such inspection is performed by a human operator or quality control personnel. Anti-laminin staining quality characteristics include: The strips are largely free of technical problems such as artifacts and / or lifting. The dye color is brown (not blue, black or other colors). The staining is localized to extracellular matrix structures expected to contain laminin (mainly the endoneurial tubes and the epineural layer, but also the basal lamina surrounding the lipid droplets). No staining or minimal staining inside (lumen) the endoneurial tubes and epineurium.

[0030] In some embodiments, the technique includes the selection of specific substructures, regions of interest, or sampling windows within the image (205) prior to further transformation and evaluation of the structure. For example, in some cases, specific structures (e.g., nerve bundles) are selected to normalize the data to areas predicted to have structural properties. In this manner, the selection of substructures or regions of interest may also allow the structural properties to be expressed in terms such as "per bundle" or as a percentage of the fiber bundle area. In some cases, the selection of structures may exclude regions that are outside the structural properties or measurements (e.g., lipid droplets are typically outside fiber bundles).

[0031] Selection of regions or substructures of interest (e.g., fiber bundles) can be done manually or automatically. For example, in manual selection of fiber bundles, a human operator traces the outline of the bundle using a region of interest selection tool in the image processing application (e.g., to select a region of interest in Fiji / ImageJ, use the "freehand selection tool" to draw the region of interest and add it to the region of interest list using the manager tool). For automatic selection of fiber bundles, automatic feature identification can be used to identify structures with specific anti-laminin staining characteristics, e.g., brown color and thickness indicative of perineurium. Automatic selection tasks can also be inspected by a human operator in a quality control step and are also called "computer-aided selection".

[0032] In some cases, a sampling window can be used to select a subset of the image, for example a predetermined square region of the image (e.g., a central 100,000 pixel region of the image). Using a fixed size sampling window eliminates the need for a manual or automated structure selection step, so that structural properties can be determined for the fixed region.

[0033] Using any selection of regions of interest in an image, a sampling window, or the entire image, creating a transformed image 210 using a transform function in the image processing application can aid in identifying relevant structures. In one embodiment, the transformation includes "thresholding," where the image is converted to binary, and pixels of the image that approximate the binary condition are selected.

[0034] Figure 3A shows the effect of binarization on an image of a cross-section of a laminin stained endoneurial tube. In Figure 3A, a laminin stained region 300 of the image is shown. Binarization of image 300 produces a binary (e.g., black and white) image.

[0035] The binarization of image 300 in Fig. 3A is performed in an image processing application such as Fiji / ImageJ. Various settings such as binarization method, binarization color, color space and background are used for binarization. The resulting binarization operation of image 310 modifies the background color from white to black using the "default" binarization method, "black and white" binarization color and "HSB" color space.

[0036] The thresholding often does not need to be adjusted from the default settings. However, a high quality thresholding may require additional adjustments (e.g., manual adjustment of the "brightness" control by a human operator). Some characteristics of a high quality thresholding are that predominantly brown stained areas (e.g., endoneurial tubes) are binarized, and only a few pixels of lightly stained or hematoxylin counterstained areas are binarized.

[0037] In some embodiments, the image may be converted to a different representation, such as an 8-bit image. In some cases, converting the image includes converting the image to a different file format, such as a TIFF format. Of course, such conversions will depend on the image processing application selected in the embodiment, and are by way of example and not limitation.

[0038] An image processing application is used to analyze the transformed image and identify one or more structures according to one or more recognition criteria 220. Structures of interest (and measurements of structures) for determining structural characteristics include the endoneurial tube, the lumen of the endoneurial tube (i.e., the spatial area within the enclosed space formed by the outer endoneurial tubular structure), the area of ​​the endoneurial tube or lumen, and the endoneurial tube lumen.

[0039] In one embodiment, the transformed image is analyzed, for example, using the "particle analysis" functionality of the image processing application (particle analysis is the term used in Fiji / ImageJ, but one skilled in the art will recognize that different image processing applications have similar functionality under different names.) The particle analysis functionality is used to identify structures that have specific characteristics and derive measurements of the same structures.

[0040] Recognition criteria are requirements that a condition or characteristic of a structure must satisfy in order to recognize the structure as of interest for identification. For example, when using a "particle analysis" function to identify structures, the recognition criteria require that the structure have certain characteristics to be recognized as a particle. Recognition criteria are introduced by setting limits on the identification function or by using characteristics of the image processing application to eliminate structures that do not fit the analysis.

[0041] Endoneurial tubes are generally circular in nature (i.e., in line with the ensheathing Schwann cells), but because of the biological nature of the source material and because the observations are made after tissue preparation and sectioning, endoneurial tubes are not perfectly circular when viewed on a slide. Fiber tracts appear as flattened, elongated cross sections.

[0042] In one embodiment, the criteria include a requirement for the "roundness" of the structure. Roundness is a measure of the similarity of the shape of a structure to the shape of a circle (mathematically, roundness is calculated as 4 * π * (area / perimeter^2). In principle, the circularity of a structure is 0 to 1. In a preferred embodiment, the recognition condition for the circularity range is 0.5 to 1.0.

[0043] A "size" recognition criterion is used to eliminate structures that are not of interest because they are larger or smaller than the identified structure. In embodiments where endoneurial tubes are the identified structures, a size criterion can be set to eliminate non-endoneurial tissues that also have laminin. For example, the basal lamina of lipid droplets and the perineurium of fibrous bundles themselves are sometimes excluded from the analysis due to their size. In a preferred embodiment, the size criterion for structures is about 4.8 microns to about 16 microns in diameter. Example 1 below outlines a procedure for testing different recognition criteria useful for identifying structures.

[0044] Figure 3B shows an example of the effect of particle analysis on a binarized image of a laminin-stained endoneurial tube cross-section in Fiji. In Figure 3B, a binarized image 350 is shown. Particle analysis of image 350 produces image 360 ​​in which relevant structures are identified (in the image, relevant structures are cyan and the background is black).

[0045] Returning to Figure 2, one or more structural properties of the nerve graft are determined 230, which are derived from the measurements of the one or more structures. Once the structures of interest have been identified, measurements of the identified structures can be taken (e.g., area, perimeter, number, etc., as described above) and calculations can be made from the measurements to determine the structural properties of the nerve graft.

[0046] Generally, relevant structural properties are indicative of the amount and palpability of the bioactive scaffold of the implant. Structural properties are derived from measurements and calculations of structures identified from the transformed images. For example, structural measurements include: (1) number of endoneurial tubes per area, (2) percentage of endoneurial lumen per area, and / or (3) total perimeter of endoneurial tube lumen per area.

[0047] Certain structural characteristics are determined with reference to area. Area may include a certain number of absolute or relative units. Such area may be, for example, pixel area, i.e., pixel length, for clarity, when relative units (e.g., pixel length) are also used. 2Actual size may vary depending on the characteristics of your image scanner, image format or display technology (measured in microns or 2 For example, a sampling window of a certain unit (e.g., 10,000 pixels) 2 ) is extracted from the image and the structural property determined with reference to the sampling window. In other embodiments, the area of ​​one or more regions of interest within a larger region can be shown, such as a preselected collection of fiber bundles having a certain size or visual characteristic. If fiber bundles are preselected in step 205 (manually or computer assisted), the area used to calculate the structural property can be, for example, per each fiber bundle in the sample, or per total area of ​​fiber bundles.

[0048] As an example of a structural property, the number of endoneurial tubes per area is calculated by counting the number of tubes and dividing by the area. As noted above, this property can be calculated, for example, by the area of ​​a certain number of absolute or relative size units per fiber bundle and / or total fiber bundle area.

[0049] As another example of a structural property, the percentage of endoneurial lumen per area can be calculated by taking the area of ​​each identified structure (i.e., endoneurial tube lumen), summing the lumen areas, and dividing by the area. As noted above, this property can be calculated, for example, by the area of ​​a certain number of absolute or relative size units per fiber bundle and / or total fiber bundle area of ​​the sample.

[0050] As another example of a structural property, the total perimeter of the endoneurial lumen per area can be calculated by taking the perimeter of each identifying structure (i.e., endoneurial tube lumen), summing the perimeters, and dividing by the area. Because the identifying structures (e.g., particles) are the lumens of the endoneurial tubes, the measurement of the perimeter corresponds to the measurement of the perimeter of the laminin-containing inner surface of the endoneurial tube. As noted above, this property can be calculated, for example, by the area of ​​a fixed number of absolute or relative size units per bundle and / or total bundle area of ​​the sample.

[0051] In some embodiments, the structural characteristics are weighted by the size of the bundle. For weighting, determining the test statistic from multiple bundles of different sizes refers to increasing the importance of larger bundles for determining the test statistic for all the larger size pieces (i.e., the test statistic for a piece is the average of the test statistic multiplied by the weighed relative bundle area vs. the average of the test statistic only for the unweighed pieces). In this manner, weighing the result average per bundle is equivalent to converting the result average per bundle to the total area average per bundle.

[0052] FIG. 4 shows an exemplary embodiment comparing images of nerve grafts subjected to the various techniques described. The nerve graft in this example is an Avance® nerve graft from AxoGen, Inc. In FIG. 4, the first row of images shows "acceptable structure" and the second row shows "unacceptable structure." The row labeled "acceptable structure" shows the original stained, thresholded and analyzed image of a nerve graft that originally passed the qualitative evaluation by a human operator. The row labeled "unacceptable structure" shows the original stained, thresholded and analyzed image of a nerve graft that did not pass the qualitative evaluation. The original stained images resulting from the conversion and particle analysis steps are shown respectively. After analysis, the determination of the structural characteristics showed that the acceptable graft had an endoneurial canal lumen that contained 30.4% of the fiber bundles, while the unacceptable graft had an endoneurial canal lumen that contained only 6.7% of the fiber bundle area. EXAMPLES

[0053] Experiments and Examples Below are examples illustrating the technology disclosed herein. The advantages of the technology will be shown from the results of these examples. The examples also provide experimental conditions to detail the characteristics of specific method parameters. The examples and experiments are not to be construed as limiting.

[0054] Example 1 One embodiment of the present invention is believed to be experimentally derived from specific ranges and parameters. Images of samples containing cross-sections of nerve grafts were obtained as described in the method flow. Experimental conditions included alternative choices for some parameters and were compared to approximate qualitative histological scores obtained from the same sample images.

[0055] Laminin histology images of 11 nerve grafts were evaluated, including Avance® nerve grafts from AxoGen, Inc. The lot contained 33 large diameter (3-5 mm) and 33 small diameter (1-3 mm) specimens. Images were obtained from slides analyzed on Aperio's ImageScope. In this case, images were inspected by the operator for the quality of anti-laminin staining.

[0056] In this embodiment, fiber bundles were selected using an image processing application, Fiji (also known as ImageJ). Fiber bundles were selected using two parametrically evaluated methods: manual selection using the freehand selection tool in Fiji, and computer-assisted selection using a Fiji macro followed by quality inspection and correction by a human operator. The results of the two techniques are summarized below.

[0057] In this embodiment, converting the image using an image processing application (here, Fiji) involves thresholding the image. Thresholding increases or decreases certain characteristics of the image to allow the image processing application to better analyze tissues shown in the image (e.g., endoneurotic vessels). The initial thresholding settings use the "default" method of the image processing application, with the threshold color set to "black and white." This includes setting the color space to "HSB" and setting the background to dark. The brightness of the converted image can also be adjusted. Here, converting the image also includes converting the image to an 8-bit representation.

[0058] Tissues (e.g., endoneurial tubes of fiber bundles) were identified in this example using the "particle analysis" function of an image processing application (here, Fiji). The particle analysis function identifies tissues by its ability to recognize individual objects in the image, as objects are highlighted by immunohistochemical stains and, in some cases, image transformation settings make the stains easier to identify in the image processing application. Additionally, subtissues, regions of interest, or sampling windows may be selected and analysis limited to those regions.

[0059] In this embodiment, particle analysis function settings included size and circularity recognition criteria and "include holes" and "exclude border" settings. Measurement settings included "area", "perimeter" and "integrated density".

[0060] Example 1 uses two recognition criteria to judge structures: size and circularity. A total of 32 different combinations of size and circularity are shown in Table 1 below. Size indicates the area of ​​the structure in pixels. In this case, an image pixel is equal to 0.495 microns according to the Aperio slide scanner settings.

[0061] [Table 1]

[0062] In Example 1, three structural properties were determined from the identified endoneurial tubes: the number of endoneurial tubes in an area of ​​100,000 pixels, the percentage of endoneurial tube lumens in a region, and the total circumference of endoneurial tube lumens in an area of ​​100,000 pixels.

[0063] In this example, weighting was used as an experimental parameter, which, as described above, converts the test statistic per fascicle into a test statistic per total fascicle area.

[0064] Since the purpose of Example 1 was to evaluate different parameters of the present technique, the effect of different parameters will be described. The value of "approximation" is calculated based on the previous qualitative histological score (e.g., R 2 The results of different parameter selections were evaluated by comparing the histological score to the laminin appearance in test samples of nerve graft tissue (values). In this embodiment, the qualitative histological score is a human assessor's rating on a scale of 1 to 5 in increments of 0.5 that compares the appearance of laminin in test samples of nerve graft tissue with a positive control containing untreated nerve graft tissue. Higher scores indicate a closer, i.e., more bioactive, scaffold appearance.

[0065] "R 2 " (or R^2) is the coefficient of determination, i.e., the closeness of fit between the experimental data set and the theoretical / modeled data set. Mathematically, R 2 = 1 - [sum((yi - fi)^2) / sum((yi - avgy)^2)], where "y" is the experimental data, "f" is the modeled data, "i" is the counter of the dataset (i.e., "i" goes from 1 to the number of data points), and "avgy" is the average of "y" over the full dataset.

[0066] There was little effect of weighting for fascicles / area, however, as noted, weighting the results by total fascicles / area yielded slightly better correlation to the historical histological score.

[0067] Auxiliary range selection is R 2 It was equivalent to the fully manual method, as evidenced by the similar values. This assisted range selection method was reviewed by the analyst after each selection and revised if necessary. The assisted method tended to not include some of the smallest fiber bundles, but was largely equivalent to the fully manual method. This is expected since the ranges selected by both methods were very similar (R 2 =0.995).

[0068] Data collected on the number of endoneurial tubes indicates that using a lower limit of 20 pixels would result in the selection of features that are not related to the previous histological score (i.e., reducing correlation). Thus, a preferred lower limit for the "size" recognition criterion is 75 pixels (diameter ∼5 microns).

[0069] Data collected on percentages of area (and perimeter) indicate that using an upper limit of 1,300 particles or more results in the selection of features that are not related to previous histological scores (i.e., reduces correlation). Thus, a preferred upper limit for the "size" recognition criterion is 1,300 pixels (e.g., 820 or 1050 pixels, diameter ∼16 or ∼18 microns).

[0070] The circularity was approximately the same for the number of tubes and the percentage of area (%), but was unstable in the circularity ranges of 0.3 to 1.0 and 0.4 to 1.0. Thus, the preferred circularity range is 0.5 to 1.0.

[0071] All three structural characteristics in this embodiment (number of tubes, percent area, and tube circumference) gave broadly similar results, with some differences depending on the particle analysis method.

[0072] Example 2 An embodiment of the present invention was developed to experimentally evaluate the closeness of certain described techniques to qualitative historical histological scores determined from the same sample images. In summary, in Example 2, specific ranges of size and circularity recognition criteria were used to aid in the selection and comparison of three structural features to the qualitative historical scores for closeness.

[0073] Sample images were obtained containing cross-sections of the nerve grafts as described above in the method flow. In Example 2, 32 lots of AxoGen, Inc. Avance® nerve grafts were evaluated. Four lots were included that did not pass the historical qualitative histology acceptance criteria. Results analysis examined correlations between historical score data and the three quantifiable structural characteristics. Data was evaluated by comparing the historical scores of a sample (e.g., from a single graft (or "section")) to each of the three structural characteristics. Additionally, data was evaluated by comparing the historical score average of a lot (averaging the scores for each of the six samples from separate grafts) to the three structural characteristics of the same lot. In summary, the circumference of the endoneurial canal was compared for each individual sample to best approximate (R 2 = 0.622), and for the lot average, the percentage of endoneurial lumen area was most closely approximated (R 2 =0.581).

[0074] In this embodiment of the technology, the following parameters and conditions were used: The area of ​​all fiber bundles in the section was outlined in Fiji with an initial computer selection, followed by manual inspection and correction if necessary (i.e. computer-assisted).

[0075] Converting an image using Fiji involved applying threshold settings to the image. The initial threshold settings include using the "default" method of the image processing application, setting the threshold color to "black and white", the color space to "HSB (hue)", and setting the background to a dark color. The brightness of the converted image can also be adjusted. Converting an image also involves converting the image to an 8-bit representation.

[0076] Endoneurial tubes of fiber bundles were identified using the "Particle Analysis" feature in Fiji. Qualification criteria for performing particle analysis included size range and circularity range. Size criteria were set to identify structures with 75-820 pixels in an area. Circularity criteria were set to identify structures with a circularity range of 0.5-1.0. In this embodiment, the particle analysis feature settings included the settings "include holes" and "exclude boundaries". Measurement settings included "area", "perimeter" and "sum of brightness".

[0077] Three structural properties were determined from the recognized endoneurial tubes: number of endoneurial tubes in a 100,000 pixel area, percentage of endoneurial tube lumen in an area, and total circumference of endoneurial tube lumen in a 100,000 pixel area.

[0078] Note that a coverage of 100,000 pixels is equivalent to 24,502.5 square microns (~0.025 square millimeters). The units of the inspection statistics are linear pixels (i.e. pixel length), and on the Aperio ImageScope, one pixel is 0.495 microns.

[0079] A weighting based on the size of the fiber bundles was applied to calculate the structural properties.

[0080] As described above, experimental data was evaluated by comparing the historical scores of a sample or set of samples with each of the three structural features of the sample / set. The mathematical "goodness of fit" (R 2 ) was calculated as part of the evaluation, and the results are shown in Figures 5A-5C and discussed below.

[0081] FIG. 5A shows a scatter plot comparing the structural characteristics of endoneurial tube counts with the historical histological scores for each of the entire strips (individual samples) and all lots tested. 2 The R value is 0.551 for the lot data set. 2 The value is 0.5118.

[0082] FIG. 5B shows a scatter plot comparing percent endoneurial tube lumen structural properties with the historical histological scores for all strips (individual samples) and all lots tested. 2 The R value is 0.6121 for the lot data set. 2 The value is 0.5814.

[0083] FIG. 5C shows a scatter plot comparing the structural characteristics of the endoneurial tube circumference with the historical histological scores for each of the entire strips (individual samples) and all lots tested. 2 The R value is 0.622 for the lot data set. 2 The value is 0.5522.

[0084] Table 2 shows the Pearson correlation coefficients of historical histological scores compared to the structural characteristics of the samples. Note: The correlation coefficients ("R") are the coefficients of judgment ("R") shown on the plot. 2 ")isn't it.

[0085] [Table 2]

[0086] To summarize the experimental results derived from this embodiment, the structural properties of the endoneurial tube perimeter approximated rather well previous qualitative analyses of graft structural quality. There are two possible reasons for this result. First, the structural properties of the perimeter remain unchanged even though the circular structure is disrupted during histological processing. Second, the luminal perimeter is a direct measurement of the laminin-coated inner surface of the endoneurial tube, and the quality of the palpable laminin is presumed to be the primary bioactive substance supporting neurite regeneration in the graft.

[0087] It should be noted that the examples and embodiments described herein are for illustrative purposes only, and various modifications or changes may be suggested to those skilled in the art and are intended to fall within the spirit and scope of the present application.

[0088] Although the subject matter has been described in language specific to structural features and / or acts, the subject matter defined in the claims is not necessarily limited to the specific features or acts described above. Rather, the specific features and acts described above are disclosed as example ways of implementing the claims and are intended to be included within the scope of the claims. (Additional Note) The technical ideas that can be understood from the above-described embodiment and modified examples will be described. [Item 1] acquiring images identifying laminin-containing tissue in the nerve graft; applying a conversion function of an image processing application to the image to create a converted image; analyzing the transformed image using an analysis function of the image processing application to identify one or more structures according to one or more recognition criteria; determining one or more structural properties of the nerve graft derived from the measurement of the one or more structures; Including A method for assessing the quality of a nerve graft. [Item 2] prior to creating the transformed image, selecting one or more of a region of interest and a sampling window to delineate a selected image region, and performing analysis of the transformed image only on the selected image region. The method according to item 1. [Item 3] The region of interest includes a nerve bundle. The method according to item 2. [Item 4] the one or more structures include an endoneurial tube; The method according to item 1. [Item 5] the step of creating the transformed image includes binarizing the image; The method according to item 1. [Item 6] the step of binarizing includes applying one or more of a binarization method, a binarized color, a color space, and a dark background; The method according to item 5. [Item 7] the one or more recognition criteria include a size range of the one or more structures; The method according to item 1. [Item 8] The size range is from about 4.84 microns in diameter to about 16 microns in diameter. The method according to item 7. [Item 9] the one or more recognition criteria include a circularity range of the one or more structures; The method according to item 1. [Item 10] The circularity range is from about 0.5 to about 1.0. Item 9. The method according to item 9. [Item 11] the one or more structural characteristics include a number of endoneurial tubes per area; The method according to item 1. [Item 12] the one or more structural characteristics include a percentage of endoneurial tube lumen per area; The method according to item 1. [Item 13] the one or more structural characteristics include the total circumference of the endoneurial tube lumen per area; The method according to item 1. [Item 14] further comprising comparing said one or more structural characteristics to a qualitative assessment score. The method according to item 1. [Item 15] and comparing the one or more structural characteristics to one or more reference ranges indicative of acceptable structural characteristics of the nerve graft. The method according to item 1. [Item 16] and comparing said one or more structural characteristics to a bioassay of said nerve graft. The method according to item 1. [Item 17] acquiring a tissue image showing a cross-section of the nerve graft treated with a dye indicative of the presence of laminin; selecting one or more nerve bundles from said image using an image processing application; using the image processing application to generate a binarized image that distinguishes one or more visual aspects of the image; identifying, on the binarized image, one or more endoneurial tubes that are included within the boundaries of the one or more fiber bundles using a particle analysis function of the image processing application that identifies one or more endoneurial tubes according to one or more recognition criteria; determining one or more structural properties of the nerve graft derived from measurements of the one or more endoneurial tubes; Including, A method for assessing the structural quality of said nerve graft. [Item 18] the one or more recognition criteria include a size range of the one or more endoneurial tubes, the size range being from about 4.84 microns in diameter to about 16 microns in diameter; Item 17. The method according to item 17. [Item 19] the one or more recognition criteria include a circularity range of the one or more endoneurial tubes, the circularity range being from about 0.5 to about 1.0; Item 17. The method according to item 17. [Item 20] the one or more structural characteristics include one or more of: number of endoneurial tubes per area, percentage of endoneurial tube lumens per area, and total circumference of endoneurial tube lumens per area; Item 17. The method according to item 17. [Item 21] and comparing said one or more recognition criteria to one or more of the qualitative assessment score, one or more reference ranges indicative of acceptable structural characteristics of said nerve graft, and bioassay results of said nerve graft. Item 17. The method according to item 17. [Item 22] The dye is an immunoperoxidase dye. Item 17. The method according to item 17.

Claims

1. 1. A method for assessing structural quality of a nerve graft, the method comprising: acquiring an image of the tissue, said image showing a cross-section of the nerve graft and identifying the presence of laminin; selecting one or more nerve bundles from said image using an image processing application; using said image processing application to create a binarized image, said binarized image distinguishing one or more visual aspects of said image; using a particle analysis function of the image processing application on the binarized image to identify one or more endoneurial tubes contained within a boundary of the one or more nerve bundles, the particle analysis function identifying the one or more endoneurial tubes based on one or more recognition criteria; determining one or more structural properties of the nerve graft based on the measurements of the one or more endoneurial tubes; and assessing the quality of the nerve graft based at least in part on the determined one or more structural properties of the nerve graft. A method comprising:

2. The method described in claim 1, wherein the identified one or more endoneurial tubes meet the one or more recognition criteria.

3. The method described in claim 1, wherein the identified one or more endoneurial tubes do not meet the one or more recognition criteria.

4. The one or more recognition criteria include a size range of the one or more endoneurial tubes, the size range being from 4.84 microns in diameter to 16 microns in diameter. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 3.

5. The one or more recognition criteria include a circularity range of the one or more endoneurial tubes, the circularity range being from 0.5 to 1.

0. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 4.

6. The one or more structural characteristics are one or more of: a number of endoneurial tubes per area; a percentage of endoneurial tube lumen per area; and a total circumference of endoneurial tube lumen per area. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 5. [0021] Claim 7: The method further comprises comparing the one or more structural characteristics to one or more of a qualitative assessment score, one or more reference ranges indicative of acceptable structural characteristics of the nerve graft, and a bioassay result of the nerve graft. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 6.

8. The determined one or more structural characteristics include two or more structural characteristics, and at least one of the two or more structural characteristics is weighted; the assessment of the quality of the nerve graft is based on the two or more structural properties including the weighted at least one structural property. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 7.

9. The method further comprises the step of selecting one or more substructures in the acquired image prior to generating a transformed image. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 8.

10. The method of claim 9, further comprising expressing one or more of the one or more structural properties per substructure, as a proportion of substructure area, or both.

11. The presence of laminin is identified by one or more structural resolution techniques. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 10.

12. The method of claim 1, wherein the at least one structural segmentation technique comprises at least immunohistochemical staining. The method of claim 11.

13. The method of claim 12, wherein the dye used in the immunohistochemical staining is an immunoperoxidase dye. The method of claim 12.