Evaluation method for the protective and repairing effects of sunscreen compositions

A method for evaluating sunscreen compositions assesses both UV protection and repair effects by measuring initial and post-UV exposure conditions, addressing the limitations of existing methods by providing a comprehensive evaluation.

JP2026181603APending Publication Date: 2026-11-19LOREAL SA
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
JP2025065099
Authority / Receiving Office
JP · JP
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2025-04-10
Publication Date
2026-11-19

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing evaluation methods fail to simultaneously assess both the UV protection and repair effects of sunscreen compositions using a single test method.

Method used

A method involving steps to measure initial and post-UV exposure conditions of keratinous substances, applying sunscreen, irradiating with UV light, and repeating these steps to evaluate UV protection and repair efficacy using metrics like color, TEWL, and texture.

Benefits of technology

Efficiently evaluates both UV protection and repair effects of sunscreen compositions using a single test method, providing comprehensive indicators for developing new products.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure 2026181603000001_ABST
    Figure 2026181603000001_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

This invention provides a method for efficiently evaluating both the UV protection and repairing effects of a sunscreen composition using a single test method. [Solution] The method includes (i) measuring at least one initial state of a keratin substance, (ii) applying at least one sunscreen composition to a predetermined location on the keratin substance, (iii) irradiating the keratin substance with UV light together with the at least one sunscreen composition applied to the keratin substance in step (ii), (iv) measuring the same state as measured in step (i) for the keratin substance with and without the at least one sunscreen composition after a certain period of time, and (v) repeating steps (ii) and (iv) at least one more time, wherein the at least one state measured in steps (i) and (iv) includes at least one of color, transcutaneous water loss (TEWL), water content, and texture of the keratin substance.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The present invention relates to a method for evaluating the protective efficacy and repair efficacy of a sunscreen composition, and more specifically, to an in-vivo evaluation method for the protective efficacy and repair efficacy of a sunscreen composition against damage to keratin materials, such as the skin, caused by exposure to UV light.

Background Art

[0002] Sun care products are widely used to protect keratin materials, particularly the skin, from damage caused by UV radiation. Several evaluation methods are used to assess sunscreen properties and to develop new sunscreen products.

[0003] It has been reported in several documents that evaluations have been conducted on several sunscreen formulations to utilize the sunscreen properties of the formulations.

[0004] For example, Romain De Dormael et al. (February 1, 2019) disclose (in the abstract) that 31 randomized controlled clinical trials were evaluated to determine the potential of vitamin C to limit pigmentation induced by ultraviolet (UV) daylight, taking into account dose response and different populations of skin types (Caucasian and Chinese).

[0005] In addition, the International Organization for Standardization (ISO) method 24444 is a globally recognized and validated standard for determining the sun protection factor (SPF) of sunscreen products. For example, Helene Meaudre et al. (September 13, 2023) reported the SPF value of their novel sun care technology using the ISO 24444 test method.

[0006] Maintaining healthy skin requires not only repairing keratin from damage caused by UV radiation, but also protecting the skin from UV exposure. Given the recent release of sunscreen products with skin care properties, there is a growing need to simultaneously evaluate both the protective and repairing effects of sunscreen products using a single testing method. [Overview of the Initiative] [Problems that the invention aims to solve]

[0007] The object of the present invention is to provide a novel evaluation method for sunscreen compositions that can efficiently evaluate both the UV protection effect and the repair effect of a sunscreen composition using a single test method.

[0008] Another object of the present invention is to provide a novel evaluation method for sunscreen compositions that can provide a more adequate indicator for evaluating skin damage, which is useful for developing new sunscreen products. [Means for solving the problem]

[0009] The object of the present invention is a method for evaluating keratinous substances, preferably skin, using at least one sunscreen composition. (i) A step of measuring at least one initial state of the keratin material, (ii) A step of applying at least one sunscreen composition to a predetermined position on the keratin substance, (iii) A step of irradiating the keratin material with UV light along with at least one sunscreen composition applied to the keratin material in step (ii), (iv) A step of measuring the same condition as measured in step (i) for keratin substances with and without at least one sunscreen composition after a certain period of time, and (v) A process in which steps (ii) and (iv) are repeated at least one more time. Includes, At least one of the conditions measured in steps (i) and (iv) includes at least one of color, transcutaneous water loss (TEWL), water content, and texture of the keratin material. It can be achieved by certain methods.

[0010] The method according to the present invention allows for the evaluation of both the UV protection efficacy of a sunscreen composition and its ability to repair damage caused by UV irradiation using a single test method.

[0011] At least two of the following may be measured in steps (i) and (iv): color, transcutaneous water loss (TEWL), water content, and texture of the keratin material.

[0012] At least three of the following may be measured in steps (i) and (iv): color, transcutaneous water loss (TEWL), water content, and texture of the keratin material.

[0013] Color, transcutaneous water loss (TEWL), water content, and texture of the keratin material may all be measured in steps (i) and (iv).

[0014] The total duration of the method according to the present invention may range from 3 days to 3 months, preferably 1 week to 2 months, and more preferably 2 weeks to 6 weeks.

[0015] Steps (ii) and (iv) may be repeated independently of each other.

[0016] Steps (ii) and (iv) may be repeated independently three or more times, four or more times, five or more times, six or more times, seven or more times, eight or more times, nine or more times, ten or more times, or more.

[0017] The second and subsequent steps (ii) may be performed 2 to 72 hours after the previous step (ii), preferably 4 to 60 hours after, more preferably 8 to 48 hours after, and even more preferably 12 to 36 hours after.

[0018] The second and subsequent step (iv) may be performed 2 hours to 72 hours, preferably 4 hours to 60 hours, more preferably 8 hours to 48 hours, even more preferably 12 hours to 36 hours after the previous step (iv).

[0019] The keratinous material may be skin, in particular arm skin.

[0020] The irradiation level of UV light may be 0.25 to 5 MED, more preferably 0.5 to 2 MED. [BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS]

[0021] [Figure 1] This is a diagram showing a comparison of the flowcharts of the present invention and prior art documents. [Figure 2] This is a diagram showing another flowchart of the present invention. [Figure 3] This is a diagram showing an example of the test schedule of the present invention. [DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF EMBODIMENTS FOR CARRYING OUT THE INVENTION]

[0022] As a result of intensive studies, the present inventors have surprisingly found that by the method according to the present invention including steps (i) to (v) as defined in the present invention, both the UV protection efficacy of a sunscreen composition and the repair efficacy of damage caused by UV irradiation can be efficiently evaluated by a single test method, thereby completing the present invention.

[0023] Accordingly, the present invention is a method for evaluating a keratinous material, preferably skin, using at least one sunscreen composition, comprising: (i) a step of measuring at least one initial state of the keratinous material, (ii) a step of applying at least one sunscreen composition to a predetermined position of the keratinous material, (iii) a step of irradiating the keratinous material with UV light together with the at least one sunscreen composition applied to the keratinous material in step (ii), (iv) A step of measuring the same condition as measured in step (i) for keratin substances with and without at least one sunscreen composition after a certain period of time, and (v) A process in which steps (ii) and (iv) are repeated at least one more time. Includes, At least one of the conditions measured in steps (i) and (iv) includes at least one of color, transcutaneous water loss (TEWL), water content, and texture of the keratin material. Regarding the method.

[0024] As explained above, there is a growing need to simultaneously evaluate both the UV protection effect of sunscreen compositions and their ability to repair damage caused by UV irradiation using a single test method. Currently, there is no evaluation method that can simultaneously assess both the protective and repair effects of sunscreen compositions using a single test method.

[0025] For example, Romain De Dormael et al. (February 1, 2019, Prior Art Reference (1)) have disclosed that they evaluated 31 randomized controlled clinical trials to determine the potential of vitamin C to limit ultraviolet (UV) daylight-induced pigmentation, taking into account dose-response and different populations (Caucasians and Chinese) (abstract).

[0026] In summary, Romain De Dormael et al. (February 1, 2019) (i) As a 5-day pretreatment, a step of applying a vitamin C-containing formulation to the skin to ensure that the formulation is adequately administered to the skin, (ii) A step of irradiating the skin with ultraviolet (UV) light in order to induce skin pigmentation, (iii) The process of applying a formulation containing vitamin C to the skin, (iv) A process for measuring skin color and performing a visual evaluation of pigmentation, (v) A process in which steps (iii) and (iv) are repeated for 5 weeks in order to evaluate the effect of vitamin C on preventing pigmentation. This document discloses a method for evaluating the anti-pigmentation effect of vitamin C, including [specific example].

[0027] Therefore, Romain De Dormael et al. (February 1, 2019) disclosed an evaluation of how well a formulation repairs skin damage over a long period (e.g., 5 weeks) after UV irradiation, but did not disclose an evaluation of whether the formulation protects against damage caused by UV irradiation. Since UV exposure is performed before product application and the skin remains unprotected by the formulation during irradiation, the method disclosed in this prior art document does not evaluate the protective effect.

[0028] Furthermore, prior art document (2), International Organization for Standardization (ISO) Method 24444, is a globally recognized and legitimate standard for determining the sun protection index (SPF) of sunscreen products. For example, Helene Meaudre et al. (September 13, 2023) used the ISO 24444 test method to report the SPF value of their novel sun care technology.

[0029] In summary, ISO is, (i) Applying a predetermined amount of sunscreen formulation to a first test area of ​​human skin, and leaving a second adjacent test area of ​​the same subject untreated to serve as a control, (ii) A step of irradiating both the first test area and the second test area with UV radiation of a predetermined spectrum and dose, (iii) A step of evaluating the minimum erythema dose (MED) for both the first and second test areas 20 ± 4 hours after UV irradiation, wherein MED is defined as the minimum UV dose that produces a perceptible and distinct erythema, and (iv) The process of calculating the sun protection index (SPF) of the sunscreen formulation, i.e., the ratio of the MED of the first test area to the MED of the second test area. This document discloses a method for evaluating the sun protection index (SPF) of sunscreen formulations, including [specific ingredient / component].

[0030] Therefore, while ISO discloses evaluating how well sunscreen formulations protect against damage caused by UV irradiation, it does not disclose evaluating long-term repair effects. The method disclosed in this prior art document does not evaluate repair effects because the sunscreen formulation is not applied after UV exposure, thus hindering the evaluation of its potential to mitigate UV-induced damage.

[0031] The method according to the present invention addresses the limitations of conventional evaluation methods by providing a comprehensive evaluation of both the protective and repairing effects of a sunscreen composition on keratinous substances. In other words, the method according to the present invention can simultaneously evaluate a significant reduction in keratinous substance damage when a sunscreen product is applied, both in the short term and over the long term after UV exposure, where the protective effect can be evaluated in the short term and the repairing effect can be evaluated over the long term.

[0032] In addition, the method according to the present invention can provide evaluation of the state from multiple perspectives, including not only color, but also barrier function (TEWL measurement), moisture content (moisture measurement), and / or surface structure (texture) of the keratinous material.

[0033] Therefore, the method according to the present invention is for evaluating a keratin substance, preferably skin, using at least one sunscreen composition, with respect to both the UV protective effect of the sunscreen composition on the keratin substance and the repair effect of damage caused by UV irradiation.

[0034] Specifically, the method according to the present invention is: (i) A step of measuring at least one initial state of the keratin material, (ii) A step of applying at least one sunscreen composition to a predetermined position on the keratin substance, (iii) A step of irradiating the keratin material with UV light along with at least one sunscreen composition applied to the keratin material in step (ii), (iv) A step of measuring the same condition as measured in step (i) for keratin substances with and without at least one sunscreen composition after a certain period of time, and (v) A process in which steps (ii) and (iv) are repeated at least one more time. It includes at least [this].

[0035] Figure 1 shows a comparison of method flowcharts between the present invention and those of prior art documents (1) and (2).

[0036] Table 1 also summarizes the comparison of evaluation effects and properties between the present invention and prior art documents (1) and (2).

[0037] [Table 1]

[0038] The steps of the method according to the present invention will be described in more detail below.

[0039] [Step (i)] Step (i) is a step of measuring at least one initial state of the keratin substance to be evaluated in the present invention.

[0040] In this context, keratin material refers to a material that contains keratin as its main component, and examples include skin, scalp, and lips. In a preferred embodiment, the keratin material of the present invention is skin, for example, body skin and / or facial skin.

[0041] The initial state measured in step (i) includes at least one of color, transepidermal water loss (TEWL), water content, and texture of the keratin material. These aspects of the keratin material can be measured by any common method known in the art. In a preferred embodiment, the initial state measured in step (i) includes at least the color, transepidermal water loss (TEWL), water content, and texture of the keratin material.

[0042] In one embodiment, the color of a keratinous substance can be measured by determining colorimetric values ​​(L* (lightness), a* (green-red), b* (blue-yellow), and h (hue angle)) using a spectrophotometer, such as the Konica Minolta Spectrophotometer CM series.

[0043] In one embodiment, the transcutaneous water loss (TEWL) of a keratin material can be measured by measuring the evaporation of water from the keratin material using a closed chamber system transcutaneous water loss meter, such as the Vapometer® manufactured by Delfin Technologies. Water evaporation is measured by measuring the relative humidity on the surface of the keratin material, thereby determining the amount of water loss on the surface of the keratin material. This measurement allows for the evaluation of the barrier function of the keratin material, such as the skin barrier function.

[0044] In one embodiment, the water content of a keratin substance can be measured by measuring the capacitance of the keratin substance using a moisture meter, such as the Corneometer® CM825 manufactured by Courage + Khazaka Electronic, which is a skin moisture meter. In this embodiment, since there is a proportional relationship between water content and capacitance, the water content can be determined by measuring the capacitance through a probe of the moisture meter that is in contact with the keratin substance.

[0045] In one embodiment, the texture of keratin material can be evaluated by microscopic observation. For example, a high-resolution UV microscope, such as the Visioscan® VC20 Plus manufactured by Courage + Khazaka Electronic, can evaluate and quantify the texture of keratin material from images of the skin surface.

[0046] In a preferred embodiment of the present invention, at least two of the following are measured in step (i): color, transcutaneous water loss (TEWL), water content, and texture of the keratinous material.

[0047] In another preferred embodiment of the present invention, at least three of the following are measured in step (i): color, transcutaneous water loss (TEWL), water content, and texture of the keratinous material.

[0048] In yet another preferred embodiment of the present invention, color, transcutaneous water loss (TEWL), water content, and texture of the keratinous material are all measured in step (i).

[0049] By using two or more conditions in step (i), a more comprehensive indicator can be obtained for evaluating skin damage, which can lead to more detailed evaluation results and may be useful for developing new sunscreen products.

[0050] [Step (ii)] Step (ii) is the step of applying at least one sunscreen composition to a keratinous substance, preferably to a predetermined location on the skin.

[0051] The sunscreen composition used is not particularly limited, as long as it is intended for use as a sunscreen to prevent damage caused by exposure to UV rays. The sunscreen composition can take any form, such as a cream, gel, lotion, milk, suspension, dispersion, and emulsion. The sunscreen composition may contain at least one UV shielding agent selected from inorganic UV shielding agents and organic UV shielding agents.

[0052] The application of the sunscreen composition to the keratin substance can be carried out by any means, for example, by hand or by using an applicator.

[0053] The predetermined location of the keratin substance can be determined based on which part of the keratin substance is intended to be evaluated. For example, the predetermined location may be the skin of the face, the skin of the arms, and the skin of the hands, preferably the skin of the arms. The area and shape of the predetermined location to which the sunscreen composition is applied are not particularly limited, as long as the condition can be measured. The area is 1 cm². 2 ~25cm 2 It can be within the range.

[0054] [Step (iii)] Step (iii) is the step of irradiating the keratin material with UV light along with at least one sunscreen composition applied to the keratin material in step (ii). In this step, the keratin material is intentionally damaged by UV light irradiation for evaluation purposes.

[0055] The term "UV (ultraviolet)" here includes the UV-B region (wavelengths 260-320 nm), the UV-A region (wavelengths 320-400 nm), and the high-energy visible light region (wavelengths 400-450 nm). Preferably, the UV applied in this invention has wavelengths in the UV-B region, and the UV-B region spans the range of 290 nm to 400 nm.

[0056] Examples of devices that generate UV light include high-pressure mercury lamps, medium-pressure mercury lamps, and ultraviolet LEDs. The UV light irradiation level is not particularly limited, but is preferably 0.25 to 5 MED, more preferably 0.5 to 2 MED. MED here represents the minimum erythematous dose and is defined as the minimum UV dose that produces a perceptible and distinct erythema. Those skilled in the art can measure MED appropriately, for example, in accordance with ISO 24444.

[0057] [Step (iv)] Step (iv) is a step in which, after a certain period of time, the same conditions as those measured in step (i) are measured for keratinous material treated with and untreated with at least one sunscreen composition. In this step, in one test design or one test method, the treated and untreated conditions are collected after a certain period of time in order to evaluate both the protective and repairing effects of the sunscreen composition on the keratinous material.

[0058] Therefore, in this step, the same condition measured in step (i) is measured at a predetermined location on the keratin material to which the sunscreen composition has been applied in step (ii).

[0059] In addition, in this step, the same conditions as those measured in step (i) are measured at a different location on the keratin material where the sunscreen composition has not been applied, in order to obtain control data (untreated). The efficacy of the present invention can be evaluated by comparison using the control data.

[0060] For example, the state of keratinous material can be evaluated by color assessment, transepidermal water loss (TEWL), water content, and / or texture of the keratinous material.

[0061] A certain period prior to step (iv) is performed after step (iii) and may be at least one hour. Thus, step (iv) may be performed 2 to 72 hours after step (iii), preferably 4 to 60 hours, more preferably 8 to 48 hours, and even more preferably 12 to 36 hours after step (iii). In a preferred embodiment, step (iv) is performed the day after step (iii) is performed.

[0062] [Process (v)] Step (v) is a step of repeating steps (ii) and (iv) at least one more time. By repeating steps (ii) and (iv), the present invention can evaluate the efficacy of the sunscreen composition against keratin substances both in the short and long term after UV exposure.

[0063] In one embodiment of the present invention, the UV protection effect of the sunscreen composition can be evaluated by the first step (iv), and the repair effect of the sunscreen composition can be evaluated by the second and subsequent steps (iv).

[0064] Steps (ii) and (iv) can be repeated independently and separately. Therefore, step (ii) may be repeated one or more times independently of step (iv). Similarly, step (iv) may also be repeated one or more times independently of step (ii).

[0065] In one embodiment of the present invention, steps (ii) and (iv) are each independently repeated three or more times, four or more times, five or more times, six or more times, seven or more times, eight or more times, nine or more times, ten or more times, or more.

[0066] The second and subsequent steps (ii) may be performed after a certain interval from the previous step (ii). For example, the second and subsequent steps (ii) may be performed 2 to 72 hours, preferably 4 to 60 hours, more preferably 8 to 48 hours, and even more preferably 12 to 36 hours after the previous step (ii). In a preferred embodiment, the second and subsequent steps (ii) are performed the day after the previous step (ii) is performed.

[0067] The second and subsequent steps (iv) may be performed after a certain interval from the previous step (iv). For example, the second and subsequent steps (iv) may be performed 2 to 72 hours, preferably 4 to 60 hours, more preferably 8 to 48 hours, and even more preferably 12 to 36 hours after the previous step (iv). In a preferred embodiment, the second and subsequent steps (iv) are performed the day after the previous step (iv) is performed.

[0068] In one embodiment, the second and subsequent steps (ii) are performed at least once a day, for example, twice a day, three times a day, or more times. In another embodiment, the second and subsequent steps (ii) are performed once every two days or once every three days.

[0069] In one embodiment, the second and subsequent steps (iv) are performed at least once a day, for example, twice a day, three times a day, or more times. In another embodiment, the second and subsequent steps (iv) are performed once every two days, once every three days, once every four days, once every five days, once every six days, or once a week.

[0070] In a preferred embodiment, the second and subsequent steps (ii) are performed regularly, for example, once a day, but the frequency of the second and subsequent steps (iv) may be gradually reduced. This means that the interval between each of the second and subsequent steps (iv) may be gradually increased. For example, the second step (iv) may be performed the day after the first step (iv) is performed, then the third step (iv) may be performed two days after the second step (iv) is performed, then the fourth step (iv) may be performed three days after the third step (iv) is performed, and so on.

[0071] In one embodiment of the present invention, the second and subsequent steps (ii) and (iv) are performed on the same day. In another embodiment of the present invention, the second and subsequent steps (ii) and (iv) are performed on different days.

[0072] The total duration of the method according to the present invention may be at least 3 days, preferably at least 1 week, and more preferably at least 2 weeks.

[0073] The total duration of the method according to the present invention may be 3 months or less, preferably 2 months or less, and more preferably 6 weeks or less.

[0074] The total duration of the method according to the present invention may range from 3 days to 3 months, preferably 1 week to 2 months, and more preferably 2 weeks to 6 weeks.

[0075] Figure 2 also shows a flowchart of the present invention.

[0076] Figure 3 shows an example of a test schedule for the present invention.

[0077] Therefore, it can be concluded that the composition according to the present invention is highly suitable for cosmetic compositions for scalp care because, despite containing a large amount of lipophilic and hydrophilic active ingredients, it exhibits good stability and is less oily.

[0078] Therefore, the present invention is extremely useful for evaluating sunscreen compositions and for developing new sunscreen compositions, as it allows for the efficient evaluation of both the UV protection and damage repair effects of a sunscreen composition using a single test method.

[0079] (References) TIFF2026181603000003.tif42160

Claims

1. A method for evaluating keratinous substances, preferably skin, using at least one sunscreen composition, (i) A step of measuring at least one initial state of the keratin material, (ii) A step of applying at least one sunscreen composition to a predetermined position on the keratin substance, (iii) A step of irradiating the keratin material with UV light along with at least one sunscreen composition applied to the keratin material in step (ii), (iv) A step of measuring the same condition as measured in step (i) for keratin substances with and without at least one sunscreen composition after a certain period of time, and (v) A process in which steps (ii) and (iv) are repeated at least one more time. Includes, A method wherein at least one of the conditions measured in steps (i) and (iv) includes at least one of color, transcutaneous water loss (TEWL), water content, and texture of keratinous material.

2. The method according to claim 1, wherein both the UV protection efficacy of a sunscreen composition and its ability to repair damage caused by UV irradiation are evaluated by a single test method.

3. The method according to claim 1 or 2, wherein at least two of the following are measured in steps (i) and (iv): color, transcutaneous water loss (TEWL), water content, and texture of the keratin material.

4. The method according to claim 1 or 2, wherein at least three of the following are measured in steps (i) and (iv): color, transcutaneous water loss (TEWL), water content, and texture of the keratin material.

5. The method according to claim 1 or 2, wherein all of the following are measured in steps (i) and (iv): color, transcutaneous water loss (TEWL), water content, and texture of the keratin material.

6. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 5, wherein the total duration of the method is 3 days to 3 months, preferably 1 week to 2 months, more preferably 2 weeks to 6 weeks.

7. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 6, wherein steps (ii) and (iv) are repeated independently and separately from each other.

8. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 7, wherein steps (ii) and (iv) are each independently repeated three or more, four or more, five or more, six or more, seven or more, eight or more, nine or more, ten or more, or more times.

9. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 8, wherein the second and subsequent steps (ii) are performed 2 to 72 hours, preferably 4 to 60 hours, more preferably 8 to 48 hours, and even more preferably 12 to 36 hours after the previous step (ii).

10. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 9, wherein the second and subsequent steps (iv) are performed 2 to 72 hours, preferably 4 to 60 hours, more preferably 8 to 48 hours, and even more preferably 12 to 36 hours after the previous step (iv).

11. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 10, wherein the keratinous substance is skin, particularly the skin of the arm.

12. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 11, wherein the UV light irradiation level is 0.25 to 5 MED, more preferably 0.5 to 2 MED.