Method and model for predicting weld joint shape
By using surface temperature distribution and arc pressure peak value as boundary conditions, the method efficiently predicts weld shape in arc welding, addressing the inefficiencies of existing methods by reducing calculation time and trial numbers.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2025078247
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2025-05-08
- Publication Date
- 2026-11-19
AI Technical Summary
Existing methods for predicting weld shape in arc welding are inefficient due to the difficulty in accurately calculating arc heat input distribution and arc pressure distribution, leading to prolonged time in selecting welding conditions.
A method and model that utilize the measured surface temperature distribution and arc pressure peak value as boundary conditions, eliminating the need to calculate arc heat input distribution, and adjust the arc pressure peak value to efficiently predict weld shape.
Enables efficient selection of arc welding conditions by reducing the time required for weld shape prediction and minimizing the number of welding trials.
Smart Images

Figure 2026182213000001_ABST
Abstract
Description
[Technical Field]
[0001] This disclosure relates to a method and model for predicting the shape of a weld joint in arc welding. [Background technology]
[0002] The quality of arc welding is evaluated by the shape of the weld obtained as a result of welding. The weld shape is specified by the bead width, reinforcement height, or penetration depth, etc. Weld stability has improved due to advancements in welding power source control technology. However, the reality is that the welding conditions for obtaining the optimal weld shape are still selected based on the experience of skilled workers. Furthermore, even when skilled workers select welding conditions, they may repeat test welding when welding with unfamiliar materials or new materials. This requires extra workspace for test welding, as well as additional workpieces, materials, and time for the test welding. This increases the cost of welding. Moreover, when a novice with less experience than a skilled worker selects the welding conditions, the number of repeated welding tests required to obtain the optimal welding conditions increases compared to when a skilled worker selects the conditions. This further increases the cost of welding.
[0003] Against the background described above, methods for predicting weld shape to reduce the number of test welds have been developed, as described in Patent Document 1 or Patent Document 2. The following describes conventional techniques for predicting weld shape.
[0004] The method described in Patent Document 1 precisely calculates the arc heat input using a heat source model equipped with a function to simulate the current and voltage output by the welding power supply, and estimates the weld bead shape by calculating the molten pool shape based on this arc heat input using heat conduction calculations.
[0005] The method described in Patent Document 2 estimates the penetration depth by preparing a database in advance that associates the total heat input and penetration depth for each welding condition, and then estimating the penetration depth using a correlation formula between the welding condition and the penetration depth calculated from the database, in order to estimate the penetration depth by laser and arc hybrid welding.
[0006] Alternatively, one could consider a method in which the arc heat input, arc heat input distribution, peak value of arc pressure as a physical action of the arc, and arc pressure distribution are set by a combination of virtual parameters, and the molten pool shape is calculated by heat conduction calculations based on this arc heat input and arc pressure to estimate the weld shape. [Prior art documents] [Patent Documents]
[0007] [Patent Document 1] Japanese Patent Publication No. 2008-200691 [Patent Document 2] Japanese Patent Publication No. 2021-79430 [Overview of the Initiative] [Problems that the invention aims to solve]
[0008] In the methods described in Patent Documents 1 and 2, the weld shape is predicted based on the heat input. To improve the accuracy of weld shape prediction, it is necessary to calculate not only the arc heat input but also the distribution of this arc heat input relative to the molten pool, i.e., the arc heat input distribution, more precisely and set it as a boundary condition for the simulation. Furthermore, it is also necessary to calculate not only the arc heat input distribution but also the range of influence of the physical action of the arc on the molten pool, such as the arc pressure distribution, more precisely and set it as a boundary condition for the simulation. However, calculating the arc heat input distribution and arc pressure distribution is not easy, and a great deal of time is spent on these calculations. As a result, a great deal of time is also spent on selecting the arc welding conditions.
[0009] In view of the above facts, this disclosure aims to provide a method and model for predicting weld shape that can efficiently select arc welding conditions. [Means for solving the problem]
[0010] The method and model for predicting weld joint shape related to this disclosure, for achieving the above objective, are as follows.
[0011] (1) A method for predicting the shape of the weld on an object to be welded when arc welding is performed under the welding conditions to be predicted, A method for predicting the shape of a weld, wherein, when arc welding is performed under the predicted welding conditions, the measured value of the surface temperature distribution of the weld when arc welding is performed under arbitrary welding conditions different from the predicted welding conditions, and the peak value of the arc pressure on the surface of the weld when arc welding is performed under the predicted welding conditions, are applied as the heat input distribution to the weld when arc welding is performed under the predicted welding conditions.
[0012] (2) A method for predicting the shape of a welded joint as described in (1) above, wherein the arc pressure peak value is calculated based on a calibration curve that shows the correlation between the arc pressure peak value and the welding conditions.
[0013] (3) A method for predicting the shape of a welded joint according to (1) or (2) above, wherein the arc pressure distribution calculated from the brightness of reflected arc light is applied as the arc pressure distribution on the surface of the object to be welded when arc welding is performed under the welding conditions to be predicted.
[0014] (4) A model for predicting the shape of the weld on an object to be welded when arc welding is performed under any welding conditions to be predicted, A weld shape prediction model configured to input, as the heat input distribution to the weld object, the measured value of the surface temperature distribution of the weld object when arc welding is performed under welding conditions different from the arbitrary welding conditions of the prediction target, and the peak value of the arc pressure at the surface of the weld object when arc welding is performed under the arbitrary welding conditions of the prediction target. [Effects of the Invention]
[0015] According to the present disclosure, a weld shape prediction method and a prediction model that enable efficient selection of arc welding conditions are provided. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0016] [Figure 1] This is a schematic diagram illustrating an overview of arc welding. [Figure 2] This is a block diagram showing a configuration example of a prediction system according to the present disclosure. [Figure 3] This is a thermographic image showing an example of the surface temperature distribution of a weld zone. [Figure 4] This is a graph showing the surface temperature distribution along the alternate long and short dash line (A) in Figure 3. [Figure 5] This is an example of an image obtained by photographing the surface of a welding target. [Figure 6] This is an image obtained by binarizing the image in Figure 5. [Figure 7] This is a flowchart showing a procedure example of the weld shape prediction method. [Figure 8] This is a diagram showing a shape example of a weld zone obtained by setting a current value larger than the welding conditions under which the weld zone in Figure 1 was obtained. [Figure 9] This is a diagram comparing the shape of the weld zone in Figure 1 with calculation results. [Figure 10] This is a diagram comparing the shape of the weld zone in Figure 8 with calculation results. [Figure 11] This is a graph showing an example of the correlation between the welding current value and the arc pressure peak value. [Figure 12] This is a diagram showing a shape example of a weld zone obtained by setting a current value smaller than the welding conditions under which the weld zone in Figure 1 was obtained. [Figure 13] This is a diagram comparing the shape of the weld zone in Figure 12 with calculation results. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF EMBODIMENTS
[0017] The embodiments of the weld shape prediction method and prediction model relating to this disclosure will be described below with reference to the drawings. Each drawing is schematic and may differ from reality. Furthermore, the following embodiments are illustrative of an apparatus or method for realizing the technical idea of this disclosure and do not limit the configuration to those described below. In other words, the technical idea of this disclosure can be modified in various ways within the technical scope described in the claims.
[0018] (Overview of the method for predicting weld joint shape) By performing the weld shape prediction method according to this disclosure, the weld shape obtained by arc welding can be predicted. Arc welding is a method of joining objects 4 by generating an arc between the object to be welded 4 and the welding torch 3, as shown in Figure 1, and melting the object to be welded 4 with the heat generated by the arc. The part where the objects to be welded 4 are melted and joined together is also called the weld 5. The weld 5 includes the part that has solidified after the object to be welded 4 has melted. The weld 5 also includes the heat-affected zone as defined in JIS Z 3001. The heat-affected zone is a part that has not melted due to the heat of welding, but whose structure, metallurgical properties, or mechanical properties have changed. The prediction method according to this disclosure may predict the shape of the weld 5 including at least a part of the heat-affected zone, or it may predict the shape of the weld 5 excluding the heat-affected zone.
[0019] The shape of the weld 5, i.e., the weld shape, is specified by the bead width, reinforcement height, or penetration depth, etc. The weld shape can be controlled by the arc welding conditions. Conversely, in order to obtain the desired weld shape, the arc welding conditions must be selected. The weld shape may include the cross-sectional shape of the weld 5. The weld shape may also include other shapes of the weld 5, such as the surface shape or toe shape of the weld 5. The arc welding conditions may include the arc current or arc voltage. The arc welding conditions may include the speed at which the object to be welded 4 moves relative to the welding torch 3 of the welding apparatus 20 during arc welding. The arc welding conditions will also be simply referred to as welding conditions below.
[0020] To select arc welding conditions, the weld geometry may be estimated through arc welding simulation. Arc welding simulations include calculations of heat conduction during arc welding. Specifically, the arc welding conditions used in the simulation are adjusted so that the difference between the desired weld geometry and the weld geometry estimated by the simulation is minimized. The parameters of the arc welding conditions that result in a sufficiently small difference between the desired and estimated weld geometry are selected as appropriate arc welding conditions.
[0021] Arc welding simulations estimate the weld shape by setting hypothetical values for virtual parameters representing arc heat input or arc pressure corresponding to the arc welding conditions and then running the simulation. Each parameter is adjusted by repeatedly setting hypothetical values and estimating until the estimated weld shape approaches the actual weld shape. To efficiently select arc welding conditions, it is necessary to reduce the number of trials required to adjust the parameters of the arc welding conditions set in the simulation.
[0022] A weld shape prediction model may be used as a simulation for arc welding. The weld shape prediction model is configured to output a predicted result of the weld shape obtained by arc welding with the arc welding conditions applied, when the arc welding conditions are input. By changing the arc welding conditions and repeating the simulation using the prediction model so that the predicted result of the weld shape approaches the desired weld shape, the arc welding conditions for obtaining the desired weld shape are determined.
[0023] The prediction model may be, for example, a model that applies the finite element method (FEM). If the prediction model applies the finite element method, parameters determined according to the arc welding conditions are set in the boundary conditions of the finite element method. The prediction model may also be a model that applies various other methods such as the finite difference method (FDM).
[0024] The boundary conditions, which are determined by the arc welding conditions, include the arc heat input distribution. The arc heat input distribution is the distribution of arc heat input to each part of the surface of the object to be welded 4. The arc heat input is the amount of heat that enters the object to be welded 4 from the arc. Calculating the arc heat input distribution from the arc welding conditions is not easy, although it can be done, for example, using another model.
[0025] During arc welding, a molten pool is formed on the surface of the object being welded 4. Heat entering the molten pool from the arc is transported into the molten pool by conduction or convection, melting even the solid parts that have not yet melted inside the object being welded 4, thereby expanding the melted area. Therefore, the temperature distribution on the surface of the molten pool during arc welding reflects the distribution of heat input from the arc, i.e., the arc heat input distribution. When the temperature distribution on the surface of the molten pool is set as a boundary condition in the prediction model of the weld shape, the heat transport phenomenon within the molten pool can be reproduced and the weld shape estimated by calculating an energy conservation equation that takes into account heat transport by conduction or convection within the molten pool.
[0026] Therefore, in the weld shape prediction method according to this disclosure, the surface temperature distribution of the object to be welded 4 is set as the boundary condition of the weld shape prediction model instead of the arc heat input distribution. The surface temperature distribution of the object to be welded 4 may be measured during the execution of arc welding and stored in association with the arc welding conditions.
[0027] By replacing the boundary condition parameter from arc heat input distribution to surface temperature distribution, the need to calculate the arc heat input distribution is eliminated. Eliminating the need to calculate the arc heat input distribution reduces the time required to obtain a prediction of the weld shape using a weld shape prediction model. Reducing the time required to obtain a prediction of the weld shape reduces the time required to select the arc welding conditions. In other words, the weld shape prediction method according to this disclosure allows for efficient selection of arc welding conditions.
[0028] However, when welding conditions change, the temperature distribution on the surface of the molten pool is also expected to change. In order to accurately reflect the change in the temperature distribution on the surface of the molten pool due to changes in welding conditions in the prediction model, it is necessary to obtain the surface temperature distribution for each welding condition. Obtaining the surface temperature distribution for each welding condition requires a great deal of effort. Therefore, even if the surface temperature distribution of the object to be welded 4 is set as the boundary condition of the prediction model, when the welding conditions are changed, the effect of streamlining the estimation of the weld shape and the selection of arc welding conditions decreases.
[0029] Here, arc pressure acts on the surface of the weld pool during arc welding. The arc pressure distribution follows, for example, a Gaussian distribution. The maximum value of the arc pressure in the arc pressure distribution is the arc pressure peak value. Generally, the larger the arc pressure peak value, the greater the convection in the molten pool. If the boundary condition is set to the surface temperature distribution of the molten pool, the amount of convective heat transported from the molten pool surface to the inside of the molten pool increases due to the increased convective heat transport from the molten pool surface to the inside of the molten pool. The amount of convective heat transported from the molten pool surface to the inside of the molten pool increases the amount of heat input due to welding in the simulation. In other words, the larger the arc pressure peak value, the greater the amount of heat input due to welding. Therefore, the arc pressure peak value is considered a parameter that represents not only the increase in the arc pressure peak value itself due to the increase in the arc welding current value, but also the increase in arc heat input and the expansion of the weld shape due to the increase in the arc welding current value.
[0030] Therefore, the weld shape prediction method according to this disclosure applies the surface temperature distribution and arc pressure distribution radius of the molten pool, obtained under certain limited welding conditions, as fixed parameters to the boundary conditions even when the welding conditions are changed, and applies only the peak value of the arc pressure distribution as a parameter to be adjusted when the welding conditions are changed to the boundary conditions. As described above, by calculating the governing equation with the boundary conditions to which the parameters are applied, the weld shape under the changed welding conditions can be easily predicted. As a result, arc welding conditions can be efficiently selected.
[0031] (Example configuration of the weld shape prediction system 1) As shown in Figure 2, a prediction system 1 according to one embodiment of the present disclosure comprises a prediction device 10, a welding device 20, and a measuring device 30.
[0032] The welding apparatus 20 includes a welding torch 3 as shown in Figure 1, and performs arc welding by generating an arc between the welding torch 3 and the workpiece 4. The welding apparatus 20 is configured to control at least one of the arc current or arc voltage during welding. The welding apparatus 20 may be configured to allow at least one of the workpiece 4 or the welding torch 3 to move. The welding apparatus 20 may be configured so that the stage on which the workpiece 4 is mounted can move relative to the welding torch 3, or so that the welding torch 3 can move relative to the stage on which the workpiece 4 is mounted.
[0033] The measuring device 30 measures the surface temperature distribution of the workpiece 4, including the portion molten by the arc, during arc welding by the welding device 20. The measuring device 30 may include a thermograph. The measuring device 30 may also include a two-color temperature measuring device.
[0034] The prediction device 10 inputs the welding conditions and the surface temperature distribution of the object to be welded 4 into the prediction model 12. The prediction device 10 acquires the predicted result of the weld shape output from the prediction model 12 and outputs it externally.
[0035] The prediction device 10 and the welding device 20 or measuring device 30 are connected to each other in a way that allows them to communicate with one another. The prediction device 10, the welding device 20 or the measuring device 30 may be equipped with a communication interface based on a wired or wireless communication standard. For example, the wireless communication standard may include cellular phone communication standards such as 3G, 4G or 5G. Alternatively, the wireless communication standard may include, for example, IEEE 802.11 or Bluetooth®. The communication interface may support one or more of these communication standards. The communication interface is not limited to these examples and may communicate with other devices and input / output data based on various standards. The prediction device 10, the welding device 20 or the measuring device 30 may be connected via a network, or they may be directly connected, for example, via peer-to-peer (P2P).
[0036] The prediction device 10 may be connected to an external device in a communicative manner to transmit the prediction results of the weld shape to the external device. The prediction device 10 may include an output device that outputs the prediction results of the weld shape. The prediction device 10 may also include a display device for the prediction results of the weld shape as an output device. The display device may include, for example, an LCD (Liquid Crystal Display), an organic EL (Electro-Luminescence) display or an inorganic EL display, or a PDP (Plasma Display Panel). The display device is not limited to these displays and may include various other types of displays.
[0037] The prediction device 10 may be configured to include at least one processor, such as a CPU (Central Processing Unit) or a GPU (Graphics Processing Unit). The prediction device 10 may consist of one processor or multiple processors. The processors constituting the prediction device 10 may realize the functions of the prediction device 10 by reading and executing a program stored in the memory unit described later.
[0038] The prediction device 10 may include a storage unit. The storage unit stores various information or data. For example, the storage unit may store a program executed in the prediction device 10, or data or processing results used in a process executed in the prediction device 10. The storage unit may also function as the work memory of the prediction device 10. The storage unit may include, but is not limited to, semiconductor memory. For example, the storage unit may be configured as the internal memory of a processor used as the prediction device 10, or as a hard disk drive (HDD) accessible from the prediction device 10. The storage unit may be configured as a non-temporary readable medium. The storage unit may be configured integrally with the prediction device 10, or as a separate unit from the prediction device 10.
[0039] The prediction device 10 may generate a prediction model 12, or it may obtain the prediction model 12 from an external device. The prediction system 1 does not have to include a welding device 20. If the prediction system 1 does not have a welding device 20, the prediction device 10 may obtain the welding conditions from an external device that performs welding. The prediction system 1 does not have to include a measuring device 30. If the prediction system 1 does not have a measuring device 30, the prediction device 10 may obtain the surface temperature distribution of the object to be welded 4 from an external device that performs temperature measurement.
[0040] (Regarding the weld shape prediction model 12) The governing equations that form the basis of the prediction model 12 used in the weld shape prediction method relating to this disclosure are explained below.
[0041] First, as a comparative example, the energy conservation equation in a model where the arc heat input distribution is input is expressed as equation (1) below, where ρ is density [kg / m³]. 3 ] represents, H represents enthalpy [J / kg], t represents time [s], u→ represents velocity [m / s], λ represents thermal conductivity [W / (m·K)], T represents temperature [K], q Arc The arc input heat flux [W / m 2 ] represents the normal vector [m -1This represents ]. Note that symbols with an arrow (→) above them to represent vectors in mathematical formulas will be replaced in the specification by notations such as u→ or n→.
[0042]
number
[0043] In equation (1) above, the second term on the left side is the convection term, and the first term on the right side is the heat conduction term. Furthermore, in equation (1), the second term on the right side is the arc heat input term, which reflects the arc heat input distribution. In the model relating to the comparative example using equation (1) which includes the arc heat input term, q represents the arc heat input distribution. Arc To determine q Arc It is necessary to match the arc heat input, which is the integral value of the arc heat input distribution, with the radius of the arc heat input distribution. The radius of the arc heat input distribution can be matched as a parameter of the Gaussian distribution when the arc heat input distribution is approximated by a Gaussian distribution. In this way, a considerable amount of time is required to determine the parameters that represent the arc heat input distribution.
[0044] On the other hand, in the prediction model 12 used in the weld shape prediction method according to this disclosure, the surface temperature distribution of the workpiece 4 is input instead of the arc heat input distribution. By inputting the surface temperature distribution instead of the arc heat input distribution, it is not necessary to determine the parameters representing the arc heat input distribution, and the time required for prediction is shortened.
[0045] In the prediction model 12 relating to this disclosure, in which the surface temperature distribution of the object to be welded 4 is input, the energy conservation equation is expressed as equation (2) below. Q EX This represents external heat generation other than arc heat input.
[0046]
number
[0047] The velocity u→ used in Equation (2) is calculated by solving the following mass conservation equation (3) and momentum conservation equation (4). Among the symbols used in Equation (3) and Equation (4), P represents pressure, μ represents the viscosity coefficient, and F→ AP represents the arc pressure term, and F→ EX represents an external force including gravity, surface tension, arc pressure and the like.
[0048] [Mathematical formula]
[0049] [Mathematical formula]
[0050] The mathematical formulas used in the above description are merely examples, and may be modified as appropriate.
[0051] (Regarding boundary conditions set in prediction model 12) When predicting the shape of a welded portion formed by arc welding using the prediction model 12, the arc heat input distribution to the surface of the welding object 4 is set as a boundary condition of the prediction model 12.
[0052] <Surface temperature distribution of welding object 4> In the present disclosure, the surface temperature distribution of the welding object 4 is used as the boundary condition representing the arc heat input distribution. That is, in the present disclosure, instead of setting the arc heat input distribution as a boundary condition, the temperature distribution at the surface of the molten pool, that is, the surface of the welding object 4, is set as a boundary condition. The range in which the surface temperature distribution of the welding object 4 is set as the boundary condition of the prediction model 12 is preferably wider than the actual influence range of the arc heat input in order to sufficiently incorporate the influence of the arc heat input, and as a numerical example, the range preferably has a radius of 2 mm or more.
[0053] The surface temperature distribution of the object to be welded 4 may be represented as a temperature image generated by thermography, as illustrated in Figure 3. The temperature image in Figure 3 includes the molten area of the object to be welded 4. The molten area is the part of the object to be welded 4 that is melted by the heat of arc welding. The molten area includes the arc heat input area. The arc heat input area is the part where the arc directly inputs heat when the temperature image is taken. The temperature of the arc heat input area is the highest in the temperature image. The arc heat input area corresponds to the area of white pixels in the temperature image in Figure 3, indicating the highest temperature. The temperature of the part of the molten area other than the arc heat input area is lower than the temperature of the arc heat input area, but higher than the ambient temperature outside the area being arc-welded. The molten area corresponds to the area of gray pixels in the temperature image in Figure 3, indicating a higher temperature than the surrounding area, and extends in the Y-axis direction.
[0054] Regarding the positional relationship between the temperature image in Figure 3 and the welding apparatus 20, the welding torch 3 of the welding apparatus 20 is located near the white pixels representing the arc heat input area in the temperature image. In the temperature image, the white pixels representing the arc heat input area are located in the positive Y-axis direction within the gray pixels representing the molten area, which means that arc welding is being performed while the object to be welded 4 is moving in the negative Y-axis direction relative to the welding torch 3. Note that the temperature image in Figure 3 was taken when the thermographic camera of the measuring device 30 was positioned in the negative Y-axis direction relative to the welding torch 3.
[0055] When the measuring device 30 is a thermograph, the infrared intensity measurement obtained by the thermograph camera photographing the molten area and the arc heat input area is affected by the emission of the arc. In order to remove the effect of arc emission from the infrared intensity measurement, the arc may be momentarily extinguished when the thermograph camera photographs the molten area and the arc heat input area. By photographing the molten area and the arc heat input area with the thermograph camera while the arc is extinguished and no light is emitted, the effect of arc emission is removed from the infrared intensity measurement obtained by the thermograph.
[0056] Furthermore, it is preferable that the measuring device 30 photographs the molten area and the arc heat input area after the arc welding has reached a quasi-steady state, that is, after the arc welding has been performed for a sufficient length of time.
[0057] If the measuring device 30 is a thermograph, the measuring device 30 generates a temperature image by calculating the surface temperature based on the emissivity from the measured infrared intensity. The emissivity of the object to be welded 4 differs depending on whether the object to be welded 4 is molten or in a solid state. That is, the emissivity of the molten part of the object to be welded 4 differs from the emissivity of the parts other than the molten part. Therefore, the measuring device 30 according to this disclosure may generate a temperature image by setting the emissivity of the molten part and the emissivity of the parts other than the molten part to different values. The emissivity of the molten part may be set to a value greater than the emissivity of the parts other than the molten part. Specifically, if the object to be welded 4 is a steel plate, the emissivity of the molten part may be set to 0.1 to 0.5. The emissivity of the parts other than the molten part may be set to 0.4 to 1.0. The emissivity may be set to other values depending on the physical properties of the object to be welded 4.
[0058] The measuring device 30 may estimate the surface temperature at a specific location on the object to be welded 4 with high accuracy in order to improve the accuracy of the surface temperature distribution in the temperature image. The measuring device 30 may correct the overall surface temperature distribution to match the surface temperature at a specific location in the temperature image to the surface temperature estimated with high accuracy and generate a temperature image. Specifically, the measuring device 30 may estimate the location on the object to be welded 4 where the surface temperature is at the melting point of the object to be welded 4, and the location where the surface temperature is at the boiling point of the object to be welded 4. The measuring device 30 may identify the location where the surface temperature is at the melting point of the object to be welded 4 based on the distribution of infrared intensity. The closed curve connecting the locations where the surface temperature is at the melting point of the object to be welded 4 corresponds to the boundary line enclosing the molten area.
[0059] The location where the surface temperature of the workpiece 4 reaches its melting point can be estimated based on the distribution of infrared intensity. As data corresponding to the distribution of infrared intensity, the graph in Figure 4 shows the infrared intensity at each location along the dashed line (A) parallel to the X-axis in the temperature image in Figure 3, i.e., the result of calculating the temperature from the one-dimensional distribution of infrared intensity. The horizontal axis of the graph in Figure 4 represents the X-coordinate of each location along the dashed line (A). The vertical axis represents the surface temperature calculated from the infrared intensity at each location. The graph referred to as "before conversion," which includes points plotted as solid circles (●), represents the result of calculating the surface temperature from the infrared intensity at each location using a uniform emissivity. The surface temperature at each location in the graph referred to as "before conversion" is proportional to the infrared intensity at each location because it is calculated using a uniform emissivity.
[0060] A discontinuity exists in the surface temperature distribution, i.e., the infrared intensity distribution, represented by a graph referred to as the pre-conversion graph. In this disclosure, the discontinuity is defined as a maximum point that appears while the infrared intensity is rising towards its peak. The discontinuity is not limited to the above definition, but may also be defined as a point where the rate of increase in infrared intensity with respect to the change in the X coordinate decreases sharply while the infrared intensity is rising towards its peak. The discontinuity in infrared intensity is caused by a sudden change in emissivity due to a change in the state of the object to be welded 4. Therefore, the discontinuity in infrared intensity may be presumed to be the boundary between the part of the object to be welded 4 that is in a solid state and the part of the object to be welded 4 that is in a molten state, i.e., the molten part.
[0061] Furthermore, the peak in the surface temperature distribution, i.e., the infrared intensity distribution, represented by the graph referred to as the "before conversion" graph, can be presumed to be the point where the welded object 4 is evaporating from the molten area. Therefore, the point where the infrared intensity peaks can be presumed to be the point where the surface temperature of the welded object 4 is at its boiling point.
[0062] As described above, in the graph referred to as "before conversion" in Figure 4, the positions where the surface temperature of the object to be welded 4 is at its melting point and boiling point can be estimated. The graph referred to as "after conversion," which includes the points plotted as solid rectangles (■) in Figure 4, is a graph that has been converted so that the surface temperature at the discontinuity point of the graph referred to as "before conversion" becomes the melting point of the object to be welded 4, and the surface temperature at the peak point of the graph referred to as "before conversion" becomes the boiling point of the object to be welded 4. Temperatures higher than the melting point and lower than the boiling point are converted as appropriate to create continuity. The measuring device 30 may generate a temperature image using the converted graph as the surface temperature distribution of the molten area and the arc heat input area.
[0063] In the temperature image of Figure 3, the dashed line (A) set to calculate the one-dimensional distribution of surface temperature, i.e., infrared intensity, in the X-axis direction, is set to pass through the point where the infrared intensity peaks. The measuring device 30 may calculate the two-dimensional distribution of infrared intensity by calculating the one-dimensional distribution of infrared intensity in the X-axis direction for multiple different Y coordinates. The measuring device 30 may associate the maximum value in the two-dimensional distribution of infrared intensity with the boiling point of the workpiece 4 to be welded. The measuring device 30 may identify a boundary line where the infrared intensity becomes discontinuous in the two-dimensional distribution of infrared intensity, and associate the infrared intensity on the boundary line with the melting point of the workpiece 4 to be welded. If there is variation in the infrared intensity at each point on the boundary line, the measuring device 30 may associate the minimum, maximum, or average value of the infrared intensity at each point on the boundary line with the melting point of the workpiece 4 to be welded.
[0064] In the example in Figure 4, the one-dimensional distribution of infrared intensity is calculated along the X-axis direction. However, the direction in which the one-dimensional distribution of infrared intensity is calculated is not limited to the X-axis direction; it may also be the Y-axis direction or any other direction.
[0065] As described above, the measuring device 30 can generate the surface temperature distribution of the molten area. Alternatively, the prediction device 10 may obtain the infrared intensity distribution from the measuring device 30 and generate the surface temperature distribution.
[0066] <Arc pressure distribution on the surface of the object to be welded 4> In arc welding, the arc pressure distribution on the surface of the workpiece 4 can affect the heat input distribution on the surface of the workpiece 4. Therefore, in this disclosure, the arc pressure distribution on the surface of the workpiece 4 is used as a boundary condition representing the arc heat input distribution. The arc pressure distribution is reflected in the arc pressure term included in the momentum conservation equation (4) used in the prediction model 12.
[0067] The arc pressure term in equation (4) may be assumed to be a Gaussian distribution, as shown in equation (5) below. In equation (5), P peak represents the peak value of the arc pressure, and r represents the distance from the center of the arc pressure distribution. AP This represents the radius of the arc pressure distribution.
[0068]
number
[0069] Here, calculating the arc pressure distribution from arc welding conditions is not easy, although it can be achieved, for example, using a different model. In this disclosure, the arc pressure distribution is calculated as described below.
[0070] During arc welding, a molten pool is formed on the surface of the object being welded 4. The arc pressure acting on the surface of the molten pool deforms it. This deformation of the molten pool surface affects the shape of the weld. The direction of reflection of arc light differs between the deformed and undeformed parts of the molten pool surface. Arc light is light generated by the arc. As a result, when the object being welded 4 is viewed from one direction, a brightness distribution is observed on its surface. Since the deformation of the molten pool surface is caused by the action of arc pressure, the brightness of the surface of the object being welded 4 reflects the arc pressure distribution. Therefore, the arc pressure distribution can be easily calculated from the surface brightness of the object being welded 4.
[0071] The surface brightness of the object to be welded 4 may be calculated as the brightness in an image obtained by photographing the reflected arc light on the surface of the weld 5 with a measuring device 30, as illustrated in Figure 5. The image in Figure 5 includes the welding torch 3, the weld 5, and the deformed portion 7 within the weld 5. The weld 5 is the part where arc welding has been performed, or the part where arc welding is in progress. The welding torch 3 of the welding device 20 is located near the deformed portion 7. The deformed portion 7 is the part that is deformed by the physical action of the arc pressure from the welding torch 3 on the surface of the weld 5. Within the weld 5, the brightness of the deformed portion 7 is higher than the brightness of the parts that are not deformed by the arc pressure, i.e., the brightness of the parts other than the deformed portion 7.
[0072] As illustrated in Figure 6, the image in Figure 5 may be binarized based on luminance. The luminance threshold when binarizing the image in Figure 5 may be set as appropriate. For example, if the luminance of the image is 256 levels of grayscale, the luminance threshold may be set to 128. In the image in Figure 5, pixels with luminance above the luminance threshold are replaced with white in the image in Figure 6. In the image in Figure 5, pixels with luminance below the luminance threshold are replaced with black in the image in Figure 6. In the image in Figure 6, the area represented by white pixels corresponds to the area subjected to arc pressure. The arc pressure distribution is identified as the area on the surface of the workpiece 4 that is subjected to arc pressure.
[0073] The relationship between the brightness of the deformed portion 7 and the brightness of the non-deformed portion can change depending on the arrangement of the measuring device 30. When the measuring device 30 is arranged such that the brightness of the deformed portion 7 is lower than the brightness of the non-deformed portion, the area affected by the arc pressure corresponds to the area represented by black pixels in the binarized image.
[0074] The radius of the arc pressure distribution may be calculated as half the width (W) of the area affected by the arc pressure. Therefore, the radius of the arc pressure distribution is calculated as the width (W), which is the length of the deformation section 7 in the X-axis direction in Figure 6. When the measuring device 30 is positioned in the X-axis direction relative to the welding torch 3, the radius of the arc pressure distribution is calculated as the length of the deformation section 7 in the Y-axis direction. Note that the image in Figure 5 was taken when the measuring device 30 was positioned in the negative Y-axis direction relative to the welding torch 3.
[0075] As described above, the measuring device 30 calculates the arc pressure distribution based on an image taken of the surface of the object to be welded 4. The measuring device 30 may calculate the arc pressure distribution by binarizing the image taken of the surface of the object to be welded 4. The prediction device 10 may acquire the arc pressure distribution calculated by the measuring device 30. The prediction device 10 may also acquire an image from the measuring device 30 and calculate the arc pressure distribution by analyzing the image.
[0076] <<Arc pressure distribution radius>> When the arc pressure distribution radius is set as a boundary condition for the weld shape prediction model 12, the weld shape can be predicted by calculating an energy conservation equation that takes into account the physical effects on the molten pool.
[0077] Therefore, in the weld shape prediction method according to this disclosure, the measured value of the arc pressure distribution radius physically acting on the surface of the object to be welded 4 is set as the boundary condition of the weld shape prediction model 12. The measured value of the arc pressure distribution radius is calculated based on the brightness in an image taken of the arc light reflected from the surface of the object to be welded 4 during the execution of arc welding, and may be saved in association with the arc welding conditions. As described above, the arc pressure distribution radius is calculated from the surface brightness. Therefore, the arc pressure distribution can be easily calculated.
[0078] <<Arc pressure peak value>> The arc pressure peak value is determined according to its correlation with the welding conditions entered as calculation conditions. When the molten pool, i.e., the surface temperature distribution of the object being welded 4, is applied instead of the arc heat input distribution, the weld shape is estimated by adjusting only the arc pressure peak value, reflecting the changes in heat input and weld shape in response to changes in welding conditions.
[0079] The correlation between welding conditions and arc pressure peak values is determined by calculating the arc pressure peak value in welding under certain welding conditions. For example, the arc pressure peak value in the calculation is adjusted so that the error in the calculated weld shape is sufficiently small compared to the weld shape obtained from a welding experiment using a certain welding condition. The weld shape may be expressed using the width, depth, or cross-sectional area of the weld 5. The error in the weld shape may be calculated as the difference between the respective values of the width, depth, or cross-sectional area of the weld 5.
[0080] This process is performed for multiple welding conditions, and for each welding condition, an adjusted arc pressure peak value is obtained so that the error between the actual weld shape and the calculated weld shape is sufficiently small. By representing the relationship between each welding condition and the arc pressure peak value with a calibration curve, the correlation between the welding condition and the arc pressure peak value is determined.
[0081] (Setting boundary conditions and predicting weld shape) As described above, in the weld shape prediction method according to this disclosure, the surface temperature distribution of the object to be welded 4, the arc pressure distribution radius on the surface of the object to be welded 4, and the arc pressure peak value are set as boundary conditions for the weld shape prediction model 12. In this way, the arc heat input distribution to the surface of the object to be welded 4 is reflected in the prediction model 12.
[0082] In the method for predicting weld shape according to this disclosure, when predicting the weld shape under multiple different welding conditions, it can be assumed that the surface temperature distribution of the object to be welded 4 does not change when welding is performed under each welding condition. It can also be assumed that the radius of the arc pressure distribution among the arc pressure distribution on the surface of the object to be welded 4 does not change when welding is performed under each welding condition. Furthermore, it can be assumed that only the arc pressure peak value corresponding to each welding condition changes.
[0083] By assuming boundary conditions in this way, if the surface temperature distribution and the arc pressure distribution radius of the surface of the object to be welded 4 are measured using only one of several different welding conditions, there is no need to measure them using the other welding conditions. In other words, in order to predict the shape of the weld when arc welding is performed using the welding conditions to be predicted, the prediction device 10 only needs to obtain the results of measuring the surface temperature distribution and the arc pressure distribution radius of the surface of the object to be welded 4 when arc welding is performed using at least one welding condition different from the welding conditions to be predicted.
[0084] The prediction device 10 can calculate the arc pressure peak value when performing arc welding under the predicted welding conditions, based on the correlation between the welding conditions and the arc pressure peak value. In other words, there is no need to actually measure the arc pressure peak value. Therefore, there is no need to actually perform welding experiments under the predicted welding conditions. As a result, the number of welding conditions to be experimented with can be reduced.
[0085] The prediction device 10 inputs the welding conditions to be predicted into the prediction model 12, which has boundary conditions set as described above, and obtains and outputs the predicted result of the weld shape obtained from the prediction model 12. The prediction device 10 may display the predicted result of the weld shape as an image. By determining whether the weld shape is the desired shape from the image of the predicted result of the weld shape, it becomes possible to appropriately select the welding conditions.
[0086] (Example procedure for predicting weld joint shape) Hereinafter, an example of a procedure for predicting the weld shape of a workpiece 4 when arc welding is performed under the welding conditions to be predicted will be described with reference to the flowchart shown in Figure 7. The weld shape prediction method may be performed by a prediction device 10. The weld shape prediction method may be implemented as a weld shape prediction program to be executed by a processor included in the prediction device 10. The weld shape prediction program may be stored in a non-temporary computer-readable medium.
[0087] The prediction device 10 obtains measured values of the surface temperature distribution of the object to be welded 4 from the measuring device 30 when arc welding is performed under arbitrary welding conditions different from the welding conditions to be predicted (step S1). The prediction device 10 sets the welding conditions to be predicted (step S2). The prediction device 10 calculates the arc pressure peak value corresponding to the welding conditions to be predicted, and sets the surface temperature distribution of the object to be welded 4 under arbitrary welding conditions and the arc pressure peak value under the welding conditions to be predicted as boundary conditions for the heat input distribution to the surface of the object to be welded 4 in the prediction model 12 (step S3). The prediction device 10 inputs the welding conditions into the prediction model 12, for which boundary conditions were set in step S3, and outputs the predicted result of the weld shape obtained from the prediction model 12 (step S4). After executing the procedure in step S4, the prediction device 10 finishes executing the flowchart in Figure 7.
[0088] In setting the boundary conditions for the heat input distribution in step S3, the prediction device 10 may use previously acquired surface temperature distribution measurements instead of using the surface temperature distribution measurements obtained in step S1. Furthermore, the prediction model 12 may be generated as a model with previously acquired surface temperature distribution measurements set as boundary conditions. When using previously acquired surface temperature distribution measurements, the prediction device 10 does not need to perform the procedure for acquiring surface temperature distribution measurements in step S1.
[0089] The predicted weld shape is compared with the expected weld shape when arc welding is performed on the object to be welded 4. If the predicted weld shape is sufficiently close to the expected weld shape, the welding conditions at the time the prediction was obtained may be adopted. If the difference between the expected weld shape and the predicted weld shape is large, the welding conditions are changed and the weld shape prediction is redone. The process of changing the welding conditions and predicting the weld shape is repeated until the predicted weld shape is sufficiently close to the expected weld shape.
[0090] (Small summary) As described above, the weld shape prediction method according to this disclosure reduces the man-hours required to determine the boundary conditions to be set in the prediction model 12. As a result, the time required to select arc welding conditions is shortened, and arc welding conditions are selected efficiently.
[0091] (Examples) The following describes a specific example. The base material used as the object to be welded 4 was mild steel. The size of the base material was 16 mm thick x 150 mm wide x 200 mm long. KC-600 (φ1.2 mm) wire was used. The wire protrusion length was 20 mm. The polarity was positive, i.e., rod negative, the voltage was 32 V, and the welding speed was 30 cm / min.
[0092] Here, the welded joint 5 illustrated in Figure 1 was obtained by performing arc welding with an arc current of 300A on the base material described above. When arc welding was performed with an arc current of 300A, the surface temperature distribution and arc pressure distribution radius of the object to be welded 4 were measured. On the other hand, the shape of the welded joint 5 illustrated in Figure 8 was obtained by performing arc welding with an arc current of 350A.
[0093] To predict the shape of the welded joint 5, the surface temperature distribution and arc pressure distribution radius of the workpiece 4 were measured when arc welding was performed with an arc current of 300A, and these measurements were set as boundary conditions for the prediction model 12. The welding condition with an arc current of 300A corresponds to any welding condition in the embodiment described above.
[0094] Furthermore, the peak arc pressure values were measured when arc welding was performed with arc current values of 300A and 350A, respectively. The measured peak arc pressure values when arc welding was performed with arc current values of 300A and 350A were 4000Pa and 5000Pa, respectively. When the conditions with arc current values of 300A and 350A were used as the welding conditions to be predicted, 4000Pa and 5000Pa were set as boundary conditions for the prediction model 12 as peak arc pressure values.
[0095] When arc welding is performed under welding conditions with an arc current of 300A, the shape of the weld joint was predicted as predicted shape 6, as exemplified in Figure 9, using the prediction model 12 with the boundary conditions described above. In Figure 9, the shape of the weld joint 5 in Figure 1, which was actually obtained by performing arc welding under welding conditions with an arc current of 300A, is shown by a dashed line. The predicted shape 6 when the arc pressure peak value was set to 4000Pa was closer to the shape of the weld joint 5 actually obtained by performing arc welding than the shapes predicted when the arc pressure peak value was set to a value other than 4000Pa. Therefore, it was determined that the arc pressure peak value corresponding to the welding conditions with an arc current of 300A is 4000Pa.
[0096] Furthermore, when arc welding is performed under welding conditions with an arc current of 350A, the shape of the weld joint was predicted as predicted shape 6, as exemplified in Figure 10, using the prediction model 12 with the boundary conditions described above. In Figure 10, the shape of the weld joint 5 in Figure 8, which was actually obtained by performing arc welding under welding conditions with an arc current of 350A, is shown by a dashed line. The predicted shape 6 when the arc pressure peak value was set to 5000Pa was closer to the shape of the weld joint 5 actually obtained by performing arc welding than the shapes predicted when the arc pressure peak value was set to a value other than 5000Pa. Therefore, it was determined that the arc pressure peak value corresponding to the welding conditions with an arc current of 350A is 5000Pa.
[0097] Using the correspondence between the arc current value and the arc pressure peak value described above, a calibration curve representing the correlation between the arc current value and the arc pressure peak value was created, as shown in Figure 11. In the graph of Figure 11, the horizontal axis represents the arc current value [A], and the vertical axis represents the arc pressure peak value [Pa]. Assuming that the arc pressure peak value is 0 Pa when the arc current value is 0 A, and that the arc pressure peak value is 4000 Pa when the arc current value is 300 A, and 5000 Pa when the arc current value is 350 A, an approximation curve was created as a calibration curve assuming that the arc pressure peak value can be expressed as a quadratic function of the arc current value.
[0098] Next, the weld shape was predicted using a welding condition with an arc current of 250A as the target welding condition. The peak arc pressure value when the arc current is 250A was calculated to be 3100Pa from the calibration curve in Figure 11. Then, in prediction model 12, the measured values of the surface temperature distribution and arc pressure distribution radius of the workpiece 4 when arc welding was performed with an arc current of 300A, and the peak arc pressure value when the arc current is 250A, i.e., 3100Pa, were set as boundary conditions.
[0099] To compare the predicted shape of the weld joint when arc welding is performed under the condition of an arc current of 250A, the shape of the weld joint 5 actually obtained by performing arc welding under the condition of an arc current of 250A is shown in Figure 12. Then, in Figure 13, the predicted shape 6 obtained using the prediction model 12 with the boundary conditions described above set as the welding condition to be predicted, and the shape of the weld joint 5 obtained by actual welding are shown in a comparable manner. In Figure 13, the predicted shape 6 is represented by a solid line, and the shape of the weld joint 5 obtained by actual welding is represented by a dashed line.
[0100] As shown in Figure 13, it was confirmed that by changing only the arc pressure peak value in response to a change in the arc current value among the welding conditions, the predicted shape 6 became close to the shape of the weld 5 obtained in the actual welding. As a result, it was confirmed that in the weld shape prediction method according to this disclosure, even if the boundary conditions of the surface temperature distribution and arc pressure distribution radius of the object to be welded 4 are fixed to the measured values under arbitrary welding conditions, the weld shape can be predicted with high accuracy by reflecting the change in welding conditions in the arc pressure peak value.
[0101] While embodiments of this disclosure have been described based on the drawings and examples, it should be noted that those skilled in the art can make various modifications or alterations based on this disclosure. Therefore, it should be noted that these modifications or alterations are included within the scope of this disclosure. For example, the functions included in each component or step can be rearranged in a logically consistent manner, and multiple components or steps can be combined into one or divided. Embodiments relating to this disclosure can also be realized as programs executed by a processor in the device or as storage media recording such programs. These should also be understood to be included within the scope of this disclosure. [Explanation of Symbols]
[0102] 1. Prediction System 3. Welding torch 4. Object to be welded 5. Welded section 6. Predicted Shape 7. Deformed part 10 Prediction device (12: Prediction model) 20 Welding equipment 30 Measuring device
Claims
1. In a method for predicting the shape of the weld on a workpiece when arc welding is performed under the welding conditions to be predicted, A method for predicting the shape of a weld, wherein the heat input distribution to the weld object when arc welding is performed under the predicted welding conditions is applied to the weld object by a measured value of the surface temperature distribution of the weld object when arc welding is performed under arbitrary welding conditions different from the predicted welding conditions, and the peak value of the arc pressure on the surface of the weld object when arc welding is performed under the predicted welding conditions.
2. A method for predicting the shape of a welded joint according to claim 1, wherein the arc pressure peak value is calculated based on a calibration curve that shows the correlation between the arc pressure peak value and the welding conditions.
3. A method for predicting the shape of a welded part according to claim 1 or 2, wherein the arc pressure distribution calculated from the brightness of reflected arc light is applied as the arc pressure distribution on the surface of the object to be welded when arc welding is performed under the welding conditions to be predicted.
4. A model for predicting the shape of the weld joint in a workpiece when arc welding is performed under any of the welding conditions to be predicted, A weld shape prediction model configured to input, as the heat input distribution to the weld object, the measured value of the surface temperature distribution of the weld object when arc welding is performed under welding conditions different from the arbitrary welding conditions of the prediction target, and the peak value of the arc pressure at the surface of the weld object when arc welding is performed under the arbitrary welding conditions of the prediction target.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Bead shape simulation device of arc welding
JP2008200691A
Arc penetration depth estimation method
JP2021079430A
