Method for determining the expansion capacity of roadbed material

The method uses Rietveld analysis and multiple regression to predict roadbed material expansion capacity accurately, addressing the inefficiencies of existing methods by identifying crystalline phases and predicting hydration expansion in mixed steel slag compositions.

JP2026182241APending Publication Date: 2026-11-19JFE MINERAL CO LTD
View PDF 2 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
JP2025078301
Authority / Receiving Office
JP · JP
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2025-05-08
Publication Date
2026-11-19

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing methods for determining the residual expansion capacity of roadbed materials containing steel slag are cumbersome and inaccurate, particularly when multiple types of steel slag are mixed, due to complexities in diffraction peak analysis and absorption effects, leading to delayed and incomplete assessment of MgO hydration expansion.

Method used

A method involving Rietveld analysis of powder X-ray diffraction patterns to identify multiple crystalline phases, followed by multiple regression analysis to predict water immersion expansion ratios, allowing for early and accurate determination of expansion capacity without lengthy immersion tests.

Benefits of technology

Enables quick and precise prediction of roadbed material expansion capacity, reducing the need for prolonged testing and improving accuracy in assessing potential roadbed damage from MgO hydration.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure 2026182241000001_ABST
    Figure 2026182241000001_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

This invention provides a method for determining the expansion capacity of roadbed material that can predict the expansion capacity of roadbed material containing multiple types of steel slag early and accurately. [Solution] Each of several roadbed material samples is subjected to powder X-ray diffraction measurement, and Rietveld analysis is performed to obtain the calculated values ​​of the content of multiple crystalline phases in each sample. In addition, each of the multiple roadbed material samples is subjected to a water immersion expansion test to obtain the calculated value of the water immersion expansion ratio for each sample. Using these calculated values, multiple regression analysis is performed to obtain a first multiple regression equation in which the water immersion expansion ratio is the dependent variable and the content of each of the multiple crystalline phases is the independent variable. Subsequently, the roadbed material to be predicted is subjected to powder X-ray diffraction measurement to obtain the calculated values ​​of the content of multiple crystalline phases. The obtained calculated values ​​are substituted into the first multiple regression equation to calculate the predicted value of the water immersion expansion ratio in the roadbed material to be predicted, and the expansion capacity of the roadbed material to be predicted is determined based on this predicted value.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The present invention relates to a method for determining the residual expansion capacity of roadbed materials.

Background Art

[0002] Roadbed materials used for roads, parking lots and the like include, in addition to natural crushed stone, steel slag, non-ferrous metal slag and the like. When these slags are used as roadbed materials, problems such as uplift and destruction of the roadbed may occur. This is because if expansive minerals such as free CaO and free MgO are contained in the slag, CaO hydrate and MgO hydrate are formed by a hydration reaction, causing the volume of the roadbed material to expand.

[0003] When steel slag is used as a roadbed material, treatments such as natural aging in the atmosphere or accelerated aging using hot water or steam are performed to advance the hydration reaction in the steel slag in advance. However, while the hydration reaction rate of CaO is fast, the hydration reaction rate of MgO is slow, so the manifestation of expansion due to the hydration reaction of MgO is delayed, and the expansion of the roadbed material may not be sufficiently suppressed in some cases.

[0004] Conventionally, in roadbed materials, the evaluation of residual expansion capacity due to hydration of free MgO has been carried out by a water immersion expansion test. According to Annex B of JIS A 5015:2018, the water immersion expansion test method for the steel slag described above is as follows. First, a molded body obtained by compacting slag of a predetermined particle size into a cylindrical shape with a diameter of 150 mm and a height of 125 mm is immersed in hot water at 80°C in a curing device, held for 6 hours, and then allowed to cool. This operation is repeated once a day for 10 days, and the water immersion expansion ratio is measured each time. However, in the case of steel slag containing a large amount of free MgO, expansion does not stop within 10 days, so a much longer period is required to confirm the end point of expansion. For determining the expansion end point of free MgO, it is preferable to perform immersion curing in hot water at 80°C or higher for 21 to 35 days in a water immersion expansion test, then measure the water immersion expansion ratio, and judge the residual expansion capacity based on the obtained measured value. However, since it takes many days to obtain the measured value of the water immersion expansion ratio, it is required to establish a simpler method for determining the residual expansion capacity.

[0005] Therefore, attempts have been made to quantify the amount of free MgO present in an unreacted state in the slag and evaluate its expansion properties. For example, Patent Document 1 describes a method for quantifying the free MgO content using the following steps. First, the sample is brought into contact with iodine-containing alcohol to dissolve the MgO and Mg(OH)2 contained in the sample in a dissolving solution, and the amount of dissolved Mg is determined. Next, thermogravimetric analysis is performed on the sample to calculate the amount of Mg(OH)2 from the mass loss due to the dehydration of Mg(OH)2. Then, the amount of unreacted MgO is calculated based on the amount of Mg obtained by subtracting the amount of Mg calculated by thermogravimetric analysis from the amount of dissolved Mg.

[0006] Furthermore, Patent Document 2 describes how, using a diffraction pattern obtained by powder X-ray diffraction measurement, the free MgO content is quantified from the intensity level of the diffraction lines appearing at 2θ=109°~111° or 2θ=126°~128°, and it is determined that if the value is 2 mass% or less, the expansion of MgO will not cause damage to the roadbed. [Prior art documents] [Patent Documents]

[0007] [Patent Document 1] Japanese Patent Publication No. 2014-209101 [Patent Document 2] Japanese Patent Publication No. 2024-74115 [Overview of the Initiative] [Problems that the invention aims to solve]

[0008] However, the technology described in Patent Document 1 is not suitable as a simple evaluation method because it involves steps such as dissolving by contact with iodine-containing alcohol and performing thermogravimetric analysis. Furthermore, the technology described in Patent Document 2 is not suitable as a method for determining the expansion capacity of actual roadbed material because, in roadbed material mixed from multiple types of steel slag, the number of crystalline phases increases, making the peaks more complex and prone to errors in background removal, and it becomes difficult to ascertain the presence of the MgO phase in the slag. In fact, Patent Document 2 states that it is preferable to measure the MgO phase content of each slag type before mixing. Moreover, quantitative methods using powder X-ray diffraction, such as the standard addition method, are often difficult due to problems such as the influence of absorption effects by coexisting components, overlap of diffraction peaks, and bias of crystal planes.

[0009] Therefore, in view of the above problems, the present invention aims to provide a method for determining the expansion capacity of a roadbed material that can predict the expansion capacity of a roadbed material containing multiple types of steel slag early and accurately. [Means for solving the problem]

[0010] To solve the above problems, the inventors diligently conducted research and obtained the following findings. By performing Rietveld analysis using diffraction patterns obtained by powder X-ray measurement on multiple roadbed material samples, it became possible to separate and quantify multiple crystalline phases. Furthermore, multiple regression analysis was performed using the calculated values ​​of the content of multiple crystalline phases obtained from the Rietveld analysis and the calculated value of the water immersion expansion ratio, and a multiple regression equation was obtained in which the water immersion expansion ratio was the dependent variable and the content of multiple crystalline phases was the independent variable. Moreover, by substituting the calculated value of the content of crystalline phases in the roadbed material to be predicted into the multiple regression equation obtained above, it was possible to accurately calculate the predicted value of the water immersion expansion ratio of the roadbed material to be predicted without having to perform long-term water immersion expansion tests on the roadbed material to be predicted each time.

[0011] Based on the above findings, the gist of the present invention is as follows. [1] A step of preparing multiple roadbed material samples containing multiple types of steel slag in different mixing ratios, Each of the above-mentioned multiple roadbed material samples was subjected to powder X-ray diffraction measurement, (I) Obtain the diffraction patterns of each of the plurality of roadbed material samples, (II) Based on the diffraction pattern, identify the multiple crystalline phases contained in each of the multiple roadbed material samples, (III) Rietveld analysis is performed on the diffraction pattern to obtain the calculated content of the plurality of crystalline phases in each of the plurality of roadbed material samples. Powder X-ray diffraction measurement process, A water immersion expansion test step in which each of the plurality of roadbed material samples is subjected to a water immersion expansion test to obtain a calculated value for the water immersion expansion ratio of each of the plurality of roadbed material samples, A first multiple regression analysis step is performed using the calculated values ​​of the content of the plurality of crystalline phases and the calculated values ​​of the water immersion expansion ratio obtained for each of the plurality of roadbed material samples by the powder X-ray diffraction measurement step and the water immersion expansion test step, to obtain a first multiple regression equation in which the water immersion expansion ratio is the dependent variable and the content of each of the plurality of crystalline phases is the independent variable. A step of subjecting the roadbed material to be predicted, which contains steel slag, to powder X-ray diffraction measurement to obtain calculated values ​​for the content of the multiple crystalline phases in the roadbed material to be predicted, A prediction step of substituting the calculated values ​​of the content of the multiple crystalline phases in the roadbed material to be predicted into the first multiple regression equation to calculate the predicted value of the water immersion expansion ratio in the roadbed material to be predicted, A determination step to determine the expansion capacity of the roadbed material to be predicted based on the calculated predicted value, A method for determining the expansion capacity of roadbed material, comprising the characteristics of a roadbed material.

[0012] [2] In the first multiple regression analysis step, the t-value is determined for each of the plurality of crystal phases, and a plurality of specific crystal phases are extracted from the plurality of crystal phases whose absolute value of the t-value is 2 or more. After the multiple regression analysis step, a second multiple regression analysis step is performed, in which multiple regression analysis is carried out using the calculated values of the contents of the plurality of specific crystal phases and the calculated values of the water immersion expansion ratio obtained for each of the plurality of roadbed material samples, to obtain a second multiple regression equation with the water immersion expansion ratio as the objective variable and the content of each of the plurality of specific crystal phases as the explanatory variable, The method for determining the remaining expansion capacity of a roadbed material according to the above [1], wherein in the prediction step, the calculated value of the content of the plurality of specific crystal phases in the roadbed material to be predicted is substituted into the second multiple regression equation instead of the first multiple regression equation, to calculate the predicted value of the water immersion expansion ratio in the roadbed material to be predicted.

[0013] [3] The method for determining the remaining expansion capacity of a roadbed material according to the above [1] or [2], wherein the plurality of roadbed material samples and the roadbed material to be predicted contain ore smelting reduction slag as the steel slag.

[0014] [4] The method for determining the remaining expansion capacity of a roadbed material according to any one of the above [1] to [3], wherein the plurality of roadbed material samples are collected from roadbeds constructed at a plurality of locations.

[0015] [5] The method for determining the remaining expansion capacity of a roadbed material according to any one of the above [1] to [4], wherein in the powder X-ray diffraction measurement for the plurality of roadbed material samples and the roadbed material to be predicted, the diffraction angle 2θ includes a range of 5° or more and 80° or less.

[0016] [6] The method for determining the remaining expansion capacity of a roadbed material according to any one of the above [1] to [5], wherein the water immersion expansion test is a test for calculating the water immersion expansion ratio after each of the plurality of roadbed material samples is continuously immersed in warm water at a water temperature of 70°C or higher and 100°C or lower for 21 days or more. [Effects of the Invention]

[0017] According to the method for determining the remaining expansion capacity of a roadbed material of the present invention, it is possible to quickly and accurately predict the remaining expansion capacity of a roadbed material containing a plurality of types of steel slag. [Brief Description of the Drawings]

[0018] [Figure 1] This is a flow diagram of a method for determining the residual expansion capacity of a roadbed material according to an embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 2] This is a flow diagram showing an example of the powder X-ray diffraction measurement step (step S2) in an embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 3] This is a flow diagram showing an example of the water immersion expansion test step (step S3) in an embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 4] This is a graph showing the relationship between the predicted value and the measured value of the water immersion expansion ratio obtained in the invention examples. [Figure 5] This is a graph showing the relationship between the predicted value and the measured value of the water immersion expansion ratio obtained in Comparative Example 1. [Mode for Carrying Out the Invention]

[0019] [Method for Determining Residual Expansion Capacity of Roadbed Material] With reference to Figure 1, each step of the method for determining the residual expansion capacity of a roadbed material according to an embodiment of the present invention will be described.

[0020] (Step S1: Preparation of Roadbed Material Samples) First, in step S1, a plurality of roadbed material samples containing a plurality of types of steel slags at different blending ratios are prepared. The roadbed material is a roadbed material including "steel slag for roads" specified in JIS A 5015:2018, which is produced by crushing and adjusting the particle size of steel slag. Since roadbed materials are used for roads, parking lots and the like, roadbed material samples can be collected from constructed roadbeds. It is preferable that the plurality of roadbed material samples are collected from roadbeds constructed at a plurality of locations.

[0021] Steel slag is broadly classified into blast furnace slag and steelmaking slag. Blast furnace slag includes two types: granulated blast furnace slag and slowly cooled blast furnace slag. Steelmaking slag is further broadly classified into converter slag and electric furnace slag. Converter slag includes converter slag, as well as desiliconized slag, dephosphorized slag, desulfurized slag, decarburized slag, etc., as pre-treatment slag for molten iron, and ore melting reduction slag generated when chromium oxides (chromium ore) are melted and reduced in a melting reduction furnace (SR). Electric furnace slag includes oxidation slag generated in electric furnaces and reduction slag generated in ladle smelting furnaces. Generally, slowly cooled blast furnace slag and various types of steelmaking slag are used as roadbed material.

[0022] Multiple roadbed material samples need to contain multiple types of steel slag in different proportions from each other in order to predict the expansion capacity of a wider variety of roadbed materials. In this specification, "type" of steel slag means the specific slag listed above for each of the blast furnace slag, converter slag, and electric furnace slag. That is, for blast furnace slag, it refers to each type such as granulated blast furnace slag and slow-cooled blast furnace slag. For steelmaking slag, it refers to each type such as desilicate slag, dephosphorize slag, desulfurize slag, decarburize slag, and ore melting reduction slag. Each roadbed material sample can be predictable even if it contains all types of steel slag, but it is sufficient if it contains multiple types of steel slag, and may contain all the types of steel slag listed above. It is particularly preferable that multiple roadbed material samples include ore melting reduction slag as steel slag. Since ore melting reduction slag has a high free MgO content, this embodiment can be suitably applied to it.

[0023] The number of subgrade material samples is preferably 30 or more, from the viewpoint of ensuring the accuracy of the multiple regression analysis described later. However, if the number of subgrade material samples is excessive, the accuracy of the multiple regression analysis will saturate while the process time will increase, so it is preferable that the number of subgrade material samples be 60 or less.

[0024] (Step S2: Powder X-ray diffraction measurement process) In step S2, each of the multiple roadbed material samples is subjected to powder X-ray diffraction measurement. Specifically, referring to Figure 2, (I) the diffraction pattern of each of the multiple roadbed material samples is obtained, (II) based on the diffraction pattern, multiple crystalline phases contained in each of the multiple roadbed material samples are identified, and (III) Rietveld analysis is performed on the diffraction pattern to obtain the calculated value of the content of the multiple crystalline phases in each of the multiple roadbed material samples.

[0025] In step (I), multiple roadbed material samples are crushed and subjected to powder X-ray diffraction measurement to obtain the diffraction pattern of each roadbed material sample. It is preferable to use Cu-Kα X-rays. The diffraction angle 2θ range is preferably in the range of 5° to 80°. This is because a range is needed in which the peak of MgO, which contributes most to the water immersion expansion ratio, and the peaks of various crystalline phases can be measured.

[0026] In step (II), the diffraction patterns obtained by powder X-ray diffraction measurement are compared with a crystal structure database to identify multiple crystalline phases contained in each roadbed material sample. For example, the ICDD (International Centre for Diffraction Data) can be used as the crystal structure database. As mentioned above, the roadbed material samples contain multiple types of steel slag in different proportions, making it possible to identify multiple crystalline phases. In addition to crystalline phases caused by steel slag, there may also be crystalline phases caused by other components in the roadbed material, such as natural crushed stone and soil. The crystalline phases resulting from steel slag are not particularly limited, but include Gehlenite (Ca2Al2SiO7), Akermanite (Ca2MgSi2O7), Bredigite (Ca7Mg(SiO4)4), Spinel (MgAl2O4), Periclase (MgO), Lime (CaO), Wustite (FeO), Hematite (Fe2O3), Magnetite (Fe3O4), Siderite (FeCO3), and Ettringite (Ca6Al2(SO4)3(OH) 12Examples of crystalline phases derived from components other than steel slag include 26H2O, Magnesite (MgCO3), Brucite (Mg(OH)2), Calcite (CaCO3), Portlandite (Ca(OH)2), etc. In addition, crystalline phases derived from components other than steel slag include Muscovite (KAl2(Si,Al)4O 10 Examples include (OH)2, Quartz (SiO2), Enstatite (Mg2Si2O6), Albite (NaAlSi3O8), Anorthite (CaAl2Si2O8), etc.

[0027] In step (III), Rietveld analysis is performed on the diffraction pattern obtained by powder X-ray diffraction measurement to obtain calculated values ​​for the content of multiple crystalline phases. Rietveld analysis is a method that compares the measured powder X-ray diffraction pattern with a simulation pattern from a crystal structure model and optimizes the crystal structure parameters in the crystal structure model so that the difference between the two is minimized. Because Rietveld analysis allows for the analysis of the peaks of each crystalline phase separately, it is possible to obtain calculated values ​​for the content of each crystalline phase more accurately compared to quantitative methods that use peak intensity at specific peak positions (Patent Document 2, standard addition method, etc.). In addition, since multiple crystalline phases can be analyzed simultaneously in a short time, it is possible to obtain calculated values ​​for the content of not only the MgO crystalline phase but also other crystalline phases at the same time.

[0028] (Step S3: Water immersion expansion test process) In step S3, each of the multiple subgrade material samples is subjected to a water immersion expansion test to obtain the calculated water immersion expansion ratio for each of the multiple subgrade material samples. Specifically, referring to Figure 3, the subgrade material samples are prepared, placed in a mold, compacted with a rammer, and then continuously immersed in 80°C hot water for 21 days or more to calculate the water immersion expansion ratio of the subgrade material samples.

[0029] The roadbed material sample used for the water immersion expansion test is the same as the roadbed material sample mentioned above, but the water immersion expansion test is started using the same amount of roadbed material sample as specified in JIS A 5015:2018 Annex B. The process of placing the material in a mold and compacting it with a rammer is in accordance with JIS A 5015:2018 Annex B. In addition, the water immersion expansion test specified in JIS A 5015:2018 Annex B involves repeating a cycle of holding the material at 80°C for 6 hours a day for 10 days, but in this embodiment, since it is necessary to determine the hydration reaction in which the expansion of MgO and other materials occurs slowly, the water immersion expansion test process involves continuous immersion in water at 70°C to 100°C for a period of 21 days or more. The immersion period can be 21 days or more, for example, 35 days, and it is preferable to keep it to 50 days or less from the viewpoint of not making the process time excessively long. After immersion, the water immersion expansion ratio is calculated for each roadbed material sample in accordance with the method specified in JIS A 5015:2018 Annex B.

[0030] (Step S4: First Multiple Regression Analysis Process) Next, in step S4, multiple regression analysis is performed using the calculated values ​​of the content of multiple crystalline phases and the calculated values ​​of the water immersion expansion ratio obtained for each of the multiple roadbed material samples through the powder X-ray diffraction measurement process (step S2) and the water immersion expansion test process (step S3). A first multiple regression equation is obtained in which the water immersion expansion ratio is the dependent variable and the content of each of the multiple crystalline phases is the independent variable. Here, if simple regression analysis is performed during the regression analysis, since there is only one crystalline phase as the independent variable, even the most accurate simple regression equation with MgO as the independent variable will have a large error with the measured value of the water immersion expansion ratio due to the influence of other crystalline phases that can also be independent variables. Therefore, in order to obtain a regression equation with high predictive accuracy, multiple regression analysis is performed using the content of each of the multiple crystalline phases detected in step S2 as the independent variables. The first multiple regression equation is as follows.

[0031]

number

[0032] Furthermore, in the first multiple regression analysis step, the t-value is determined for each of the multiple crystalline phases, and several specific crystalline phases with an absolute value of 2 or more are extracted from among the multiple crystalline phases. The t-value is a statistical indicator in multiple regression analysis that shows the magnitude of the influence of an explanatory variable on the dependent variable. The larger the absolute value of the t-value, the stronger the influence of that explanatory variable on the dependent variable. In particular, if the absolute value of the t-value is greater than 2, the statistical significance level of 5% is met, and it can be concluded that the explanatory variable has an influence on the dependent variable. That is, the several specific crystalline phases with an absolute value of 2 or more can be concluded to be crystalline phases that influence the volume expansion ratio obtained by the water immersion expansion test, which is the dependent variable.

[0033] (Step S5: Secondary Regression Analysis Process) Next, in step S5, multiple regression analysis is performed using the calculated values ​​(only) of the content of multiple specific crystalline phases and the calculated values ​​of the water immersion expansion ratio obtained for each of the multiple roadbed material samples to obtain a second multiple regression equation with the water immersion expansion ratio as the dependent variable and the content (only) of each of the multiple specific crystalline phases as the independent variables. For example, if there were 7 specific crystalline phases among the 18 types of crystalline phases detected in step S2 whose absolute value of t-value was 2 or more, then another multiple regression analysis is performed using the calculated values ​​of the content of these 7 types of crystalline phases. The second multiple regression equation obtained as a result has only the content of the 7 types of specific crystalline phases as independent variables, and although it is a simple multiple regression equation, it extracts only the independent variables that have a large influence on the water immersion expansion ratio, so the accuracy of the predicted value of the dependent variable is high.

[0034] (Step S6: Powder X-ray diffraction measurement of the roadbed material to be predicted) Next, in step S6, the roadbed material to be predicted, which contains steel slag, is subjected to powder X-ray diffraction measurement to obtain calculated values ​​for the content of multiple crystalline phases in the roadbed material to be predicted. The roadbed material to be predicted is a roadbed material containing "steel slag for roads" as specified in JIS A 5015:2018, which is manufactured by crushing and adjusting the particle size of steel slag, similar to the roadbed material sample prepared in step S1. The calculated values ​​for the content of multiple crystalline phases in the roadbed material to be predicted can be obtained in the same manner as in steps (I) to (III) of step S2.

[0035] The type of steel slag included in the roadbed material to be predicted is not particularly limited, but it must include at least some of the types of steel slag included in the roadbed material sample prepared in step S1, and preferably all of them. Furthermore, it is preferable that any types of steel slag not included in the roadbed material sample prepared in step S1 are not included in the roadbed material to be predicted. It is also preferable that the roadbed material to be predicted includes ore melting reduction slag, similar to the roadbed material sample prepared in step S1.

[0036] (Step S7: Forecasting Process) Next, in step S7, the calculated values ​​of the content of multiple crystalline phases in the target subgrade material are substituted into the second multiple regression equation to calculate the predicted value of the water immersion expansion ratio in the target subgrade material. By substituting the calculated values ​​of the content of multiple crystalline phases in the target subgrade material into the second multiple regression equation, it is possible to calculate an accurate predicted value of the water immersion expansion ratio with little error from the measured value, without conducting long-term water immersion expansion tests on the target subgrade material.

[0037] (Step S8: Decision-making process) Next, in step S8, the expansion capacity of the roadbed material being predicted is determined based on the calculated predicted values. The smaller the predicted value, the less expansion capacity is considered to be. One method for determining the expansion capacity is to set an upper limit as a threshold for the predicted value of the water immersion expansion ratio in advance, and if the predicted value exceeds the threshold, it is determined that the entire amount of roadbed material needs to be replaced.

[0038] (Other embodiments) Furthermore, in another embodiment of the present invention, the second multiple regression analysis step may be omitted, and the calculated values ​​of the content of multiple crystalline phases in the roadbed material to be predicted may be substituted into the first multiple regression equation. Specifically, steps S1 to S4 described above are performed to obtain the first multiple regression equation, step S5 is omitted, and then the calculated values ​​of the content of multiple crystalline phases calculated in step S6 are substituted into the first multiple regression equation to calculate the predicted value of the water immersion expansion ratio in the roadbed material to be predicted. In this case, since multiple specific crystalline phases are not extracted, the number of explanatory variables increases, but similar to the case where the values ​​are substituted into the second multiple regression equation, an accurate predicted value of the water immersion expansion ratio with little error from the measured value can be calculated. [Examples]

[0039] The following are examples of the present invention, but the present invention is not limited to these examples.

[0040] As roadbed material samples, 60 roadbed material samples were prepared, collected from 60 different roadbed locations. The roadbed material samples in this example mainly consisted of four types of steel slag: "derinsing slag," "desiliconizing derinsing slag," "blast furnace slow-cooling slag," and "ore molten reduction slag," and it is also possible that soil from the construction site (natural silica, etc.) was mixed in. The collected roadbed material samples were crushed and reduced to approximately 25g, and the powder obtained by sieving through a 250μm sieve was used as a sample for powder X-ray diffraction measurement.

[0041] Powder X-ray diffraction measurements were performed using the following apparatus and scanning method. (1) X-ray diffractometer: D8 ADVANCE (manufactured by Bruker) (2)X-ray: Cu-Kα, 40kV-40mA (3) Sampling interval: 0.02 (°) (4) Scan speed: 2° / min (5) Measurement range: 2θ = 5 to 80° (6) Analysis software: TOPAS ver.6 (manufactured by Bruker)

[0042] Next, the diffraction patterns obtained from powder X-ray diffraction measurements were compared with the ICDD (International Centre for Diffraction Data) crystal structure database to identify the crystalline phases. Although the diffraction patterns and intensities differed depending on the sample, the crystalline phases shown in Table 1 could be identified. Eighteen types of crystalline phases were detected, including ghelenite and okermanitite, which are the main components of blast furnace slow-cooled slag. Of these, Nos. 1 to 13 in Table 1 are crystalline phases caused by steel slag, and Nos. 14 to 18 are crystalline phases caused by components other than steel slag. Subsequently, Rietveld analysis was performed using the diffraction patterns obtained from powder X-ray diffraction measurements to quantify the content of each of the 18 types of crystalline phases in each roadbed material sample.

[0043] In parallel with the powder X-ray diffraction measurements, water immersion expansion tests were conducted using 60 roadbed material samples. 5 kg of roadbed material samples were placed in molds according to JIS A 5015:2018 Annex B "Steel slag for roads". After compacting the roadbed material in the molds with a rammer, the compacted roadbed material was continuously immersed in 80°C hot water for 35 days. After 35 days, the water immersion expansion ratio of the roadbed material samples was calculated according to the calculation method described in JIS A 5015:2018 Annex B.

[0044] Using the calculated content of 18 types of crystalline phases in the roadbed material samples quantified by Rietveld analysis and the calculated water immersion expansion ratio of the roadbed material samples calculated by water immersion expansion tests, a first multiple regression analysis was performed. The first multiple regression equation was obtained with the content of the 18 types of crystalline phases as the explanatory variable and the water immersion expansion ratio as the dependent variable. Table 1 shows the coefficients and t-values ​​for each crystalline phase.

[0045] [Table 1]

[0046] Next, the seven crystalline phases whose absolute t-values ​​were 2 or greater in the first multiple regression analysis were designated as specific crystalline phases and listed in Table 2. Then, a second multiple regression analysis was performed using the calculated content of the seven specific crystalline phases in the roadbed material samples and the calculated water immersion expansion ratio of the roadbed material samples obtained from the water immersion expansion test. The second multiple regression equation shown below was obtained, with the content of the seven specific crystalline phases as the explanatory variable and the water immersion expansion ratio as the dependent variable. The specific crystalline phases corresponding to the explanatory variables x1 to x7 in the second multiple regression equation and the coefficients in the second multiple regression equation are summarized in Table 2.

[0047]

number

[0048] [Table 2]

[0049] The results of the first multiple regression analysis showed that the amount of MgO with the highest t-value was highly correlated with the expansion of the roadbed. Furthermore, since the t-values ​​for both MgO and Ca(OH)2 were positive, these two substances had a positive correlation with the expansion of the roadbed. Therefore, it is thought that the expansion of the roadbed is due to the expansion of MgO by more than double in volume during the hydration process (reaction equation 1 below) and the expansion of Ca(OH)2 by approximately 1.1 times in volume during the reaction with CO2 in the air (reaction equation 2 below), and that the resulting water promotes the hydration reactions such as those in reaction equation 1.

[0050] MgO + H2O → Mg(OH)2···(Reaction Equation 1) Ca(OH)2 + CO2 → CaCO3 + H2O ... (Reaction Equation 2)

[0051] Next, we compared the predicted and measured water immersion expansion ratios for 10 roadbed material samples A-J collected from roads and parking lots in Chiba Prefecture. Powder X-ray diffraction measurements were performed on roadbed materials A-J, and multiple crystalline phases were identified from the diffraction patterns. Furthermore, Rietveld analysis was performed using the obtained diffraction patterns to quantify the content of each crystalline phase in roadbed materials A-J. The quantified content of each crystalline phase in roadbed materials A-J was substituted into the explanatory variables of the above-mentioned second multiple regression equation to calculate the predicted water immersion expansion ratio, which was presented as an example of the invention.

[0052] Furthermore, as Comparative Example 1, a simple linear regression analysis was performed using the calculated MgO content in the above-mentioned roadbed material samples and the calculated water immersion expansion ratio of the roadbed material samples obtained from the water immersion expansion test. The following simple linear regression equation was obtained, with MgO content as the explanatory variable x1 and water immersion expansion ratio as the dependent variable y. The calculated MgO content in roadbed materials A to J was substituted into the explanatory variable x1 of this simple linear regression equation to calculate the predicted value of the water immersion expansion ratio.

[0053]

number

[0054] Water immersion expansion tests were performed on subgrade materials A to J under the same conditions as those performed on the above-mentioned subgrade material samples, and measured values ​​of the water immersion expansion ratio were obtained. Then, the predicted values ​​of the water immersion expansion ratio from the invention example and comparative example 1 were subtracted from the measured values ​​of the water immersion expansion ratio of subgrade materials A to J to confirm the prediction accuracy. These results are shown in Table 3.

[0055] Furthermore, as Comparative Example 2, we implemented the method described in Patent Document 2, which determines the MgO content from the peak at 2θ = 109° to 111° and judges it as acceptable if the value is 2 mass%, and the judgment results are shown in Table 3. In Comparative Example 2, all subgrade materials, including subgrade materials E, G, I, and J, in which the MgO content in the Rietveld analysis exceeded 2 mass%, had MgO content calculated from the peak intensity at 2θ = 109° to 111° that was below 2 mass%, and were judged as acceptable. Therefore, it can be seen that the judgment method in Patent Document 2 is not suitable for actual subgrade materials that are a mixture of multiple slags.

[0056] Furthermore, as shown in Table 3, Figure 4, and Figure 5, the predicted water immersion expansion ratio of the inventive example differs from the measured water immersion expansion ratio by less error compared to the predicted water immersion expansion ratio of Comparative Example 1. Therefore, it is preferable to use the inventive example rather than Comparative Example 1 to predict the water immersion expansion ratio of the roadbed material. Accordingly, the method for determining the expansion capacity of roadbed material according to the present invention can predict the expansion capacity of roadbed material containing multiple types of slag early and accurately.

[0057] [Table 3] [Industrial applicability]

[0058] According to the method for determining the expansion capacity of roadbed material of the present invention, it is possible to predict the expansion capacity of roadbed material containing multiple types of steel slag early and accurately.

Claims

1. A process of preparing multiple roadbed material samples containing multiple types of steel slag in different mixing ratios, Each of the above-mentioned roadbed material samples was subjected to powder X-ray diffraction measurement, (I) Obtain the diffraction patterns of each of the plurality of roadbed material samples, (II) Based on the diffraction pattern, identify the multiple crystalline phases contained in each of the multiple roadbed material samples, (III) Rietveld analysis is performed on the diffraction pattern to obtain the calculated content of the plurality of crystalline phases in each of the plurality of roadbed material samples. Powder X-ray diffraction measurement process, A water immersion expansion test step in which each of the plurality of roadbed material samples is subjected to a water immersion expansion test to obtain a calculated value for the water immersion expansion ratio of each of the plurality of roadbed material samples, A first multiple regression analysis step is performed using the calculated values ​​of the content of the plurality of crystalline phases and the calculated values ​​of the water immersion expansion ratio obtained for each of the plurality of roadbed material samples by the powder X-ray diffraction measurement step and the water immersion expansion test step, to obtain a first multiple regression equation in which the water immersion expansion ratio is the dependent variable and the content of each of the plurality of crystalline phases is the independent variable. A step of subjecting the roadbed material to be predicted, which contains steel slag, to powder X-ray diffraction measurement to obtain calculated values ​​for the content of the multiple crystalline phases in the roadbed material to be predicted, A prediction step of substituting the calculated values ​​of the content of the plurality of crystalline phases in the roadbed material to be predicted into the first multiple regression equation to calculate the predicted value of the water immersion expansion ratio in the roadbed material to be predicted, A determination step to determine the expansion capacity of the roadbed material to be predicted based on the calculated predicted value, A method for determining the expansion capacity of roadbed material, comprising the characteristics of a roadbed material.

2. In the first multiple regression analysis step, the t-value is determined for each of the plurality of crystal phases, and a plurality of specific crystal phases are extracted from the plurality of crystal phases whose absolute value of t-value is 2 or more. After the first multiple regression analysis step, a second multiple regression analysis step is performed to obtain a second multiple regression equation in which the water immersion expansion ratio is used as the dependent variable and the content of each of the multiple specific crystalline phases as the independent variables, using the calculated values ​​of the content of each of the multiple specific crystalline phases obtained for each of the multiple roadbed material samples. The method for determining the expansion capacity of a roadbed material according to claim 1, wherein in the prediction step, the calculated values ​​of the content of the plurality of specific crystalline phases in the roadbed material to be predicted are substituted into the second multiple regression equation instead of the first multiple regression equation to calculate the predicted value of the water immersion expansion ratio in the roadbed material to be predicted.

3. The method for determining the expansion capacity of a roadbed material according to claim 1 or 2, wherein the plurality of roadbed material samples and the roadbed material to be predicted include ore melting reduction slag as the steel slag.

4. The method for determining the expansion capacity of a roadbed material according to claim 1 or 2, wherein the plurality of roadbed material samples are taken from roadbeds constructed at multiple locations.

5. The method for determining the expansion margin of a roadbed material according to claim 1 or 2, wherein the powder X-ray diffraction measurement of the plurality of roadbed material samples and the roadbed material to be predicted includes a diffraction angle 2θ in the range of 5° to 80°.

6. The method for determining the expansion capacity of a roadbed material according to claim 1 or 2, wherein the water immersion expansion test is a test in which each of the plurality of roadbed material samples is continuously immersed in hot water with a water temperature of 70°C or more and 100°C or less for 21 days or more, and then the water immersion expansion ratio is calculated.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Quantifying method for magnesium oxide and magnesium hydroxide in inorganic compound sample

    JP2014209101A

  • Expansibility determination method of inorganic material containing magnesium oxide component and inorganic material containing magnesium oxide component

    JP2024074115A