Method for controlling the power of a turbine plant and device for implementing the method
Patent Information
- Application Number
- MYPI1998004233
- Authority / Receiving Office
- MY · MY
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 1997-09-22
- Filing Date
- 1998-09-16
- Publication Date
- 1999-03-22
- Estimated Expiration
- Not applicable · inactive patent
AI Technical Summary
Conventional power regulation methods for turbo sets, which measure electric output power to control thermal power, fail to accurately account for kinetic power changes, leading to unstable network behavior and potential hazards during load shedding and network instability.
Regulating thermal power by determining and incorporating both electric power and kinetic power of the shaft, using the rotary frequency and its change to calculate kinetic power, and comparing the sum with a predetermined power value to adjust thermal power accordingly.
This approach prevents undesirable power regulation behaviors, ensuring network stability and preventing overloading of the turbo set by accurately accounting for kinetic power changes.
Abstract
Description
DESCRIPTIONMethod for controlling the power of a turbine plant and device for implementing the methodTECHNICAL FIELDThe present invention relates to the field of power station technology. It refers to a method for regulating the power of a turbo set converting thermal power into electric power, said turbo set comprising, on a common shaft, a turbine driven by the thermal power and a generator driven by the turbine and delivering electric power to a network, in which method the electric power delivered by the generator is determined and the thermal power for the turbine is regulated as a function of the measured electric power.The' invention refers, furthermore, to a device for carrying out the method, comprising a power regulator for regulating the thermal power for the turbine, and first means which compare an output power of the turbo set with a predetermined power value and which transmit a differential value as a control signal to the power regulator.PRIOR ARTThe conventional way of regulating the output power of a gas turbine is to measure the electric output power Pg delivered at the output terminals of the associated generator, to compare the measured value with a predetermined power value (desired value) Pg and to transmit the resulting differential signal AP=Pg-Pg as a control signal to a power regulator which3q regulates the thermal power of the gas turbine.An illustrative circuit diagram for such known power regulation is reproduced in Figure 1. The power of a turbo set 10 consisting of a gas turbine system 15 and of a generator 16 is regulated. The gas turbine system 15 comprises the actual turbine 11, a combustion chamber 12, a compressor 13 and aPI98004233controllable inlet 14 for the combustion air, said inlet usually consisting of adjustable inlet guide vanes (Variable Inlet Guiding Vanes VIGVs). The turbine 11 and generator 16 are seated on a common shaft 17, the rotary frequency f of which is measured by means of a rotary frequency encoder 25. The generator 16 delivers the generated electric power Pq to a network 18, as a rule a three phase network. The electric power Pq of the generator 16 is compared, in a subtractor 19, with a predetermined power value Pq and the difference ΔΡ is fed to a power regulator 20 which in turn, via the controllable inlet 14, controls the quantity of combustion air fed to the compressor 13 and the mass flow dmfc / dt of the fuel fed to the combustion chamber12.The predetermined power value (desired value) Pc is obtained from the sum PQt=pc*+^pCt °fareference power value Pq* and a correction value ΔΡς^. The correction value ΔΡς^-, for its part, derives from a characteristic encoder 23 which, in the event of a deviation of the measured rotary frequency f from a rotary frequency desired value fc, outputs an appropriate correction value in accordance with the difference Δί formed in a subtractor 24 and with a predetermined characteristic ΔΡς=Κ(Δί). A rise limiter 21 is additionally provided, which limits the rate of change of the regulating signal.It has now emerged, that the regulating circuit illustrated in Figure 1 may lead to a possibly hazardous behaviour of the gas turbine when high (positive or negative) accelerations of the shaft occur. In this case, the measured (electric) output power Pq of the turbo set is no longer a measure of the generated thermal power Ρψ of the gas turbine 15, said thermal power being determined by the mass flows of the combustion air and fuel, but additionally contains an appreciable fraction of kinetic power. The resulting inequality between the measured output power and the generated thermal power may cause power regulation toPI98004233- 3 initiate changes (unjustified per se) in the mass flows of combustion air and fuel which may be hazardous to the gas turbine itself and / or to the stability of the connected network.Furthermore, if the generator switch opens, the measured electric power Pq at the generator falls to zero, since there is no flow of power into the network. In this case, too, the result is inequality between the measured output power and the generated thermal power, and power regulation receives false information on the thermal state of the gas turbine, thus leading to an undesirable behaviour of the power regulator.The fundamental cause of the problems mentioned becomes clear when the following power equation for the rotor of the gas turbine is set up:d)PG= pT_pkin'Ρψ signifying the effective thermal output power of the gas turbine, and (2) Pkin= 4π2θί(df / dt) being the kinetic power of the shaft, with the moment of inertia Θ of the shaft, the rotary frequency f of the shaft and the rotary frequency change (acceleration) df / dt of the shaft. It becomes clear from the equations (1) and (2) that the measurement of the electric output power Pq is, in general, not directly a measure of the thermal power at the gas turbine, but a measure of the total power at the shaft, and includes the kinetic power which is delivered and consumed respectively in the event of braking and acceleration of the shaft.This results in the following undesirable power regulation behaviour patterns:PI 980042331. Thermal relief during a delivery of kinetic powerIn this case, the rotor (shaft) is sharply braked. This takes place, typically, when the gas turbine is synchronized with a network which undergoes a sharp fall in frequency. As a result of this fall, the rotor delivers a large amount of kinetic power, thus leading to a sudden rise in the measured output power Pq. If the desired value Pq does not change appreciably, power regulation reduces the thermal power Pp, in order to keep the measured output power Pq as near as possible to the desired value Pq. However, this is precisely the wrong response of the regulating system, because a frequency fall in the network is a sign of an increased power requirement. Instead, gas turbines having sufficient power reserve should increase the thermal power, instead of reducing it, in order to assist in stabilizing the network. In addition, due to the delivery of kinetic power, the thermal relief of the gas turbine may lead to flame extinguishing which aggravates even further the already existing power deficit of the network. This behaviour therefore, altogether, puts network stability at serious risk.2. Thermal charging during load sheddingWhat is considered here, is the situation of a gas turbine which runs synchronously with a stable network at a constant speed and with a specific power (for example, 160 MW thermal power). Since the speed of the shaft is constant (df / dt=0;pkin=°)> the total measured electric power Pq is, according to equation (1), identical to the thermal power P-p. When the generator switch opens, then, the measured electric output power Pq falls to zero. The power regulator consequently receives a signal representing an output power of 0 MW, even though the thermal power is actually unchanged (in the example, 160 MW) . The power regulator is thereby falsely induced to increase the thermal power by an amount which is demanded by thePI 98004233- 5 power desired value. Theoretically, as a result, the thermal power may increase to double the power desired value Pq. As soon as the generator switch opens, the rotor is accelerated by the thermal power PT. The fall of the signal Pq and the resulting increased thermal power of the gas turbine will further increase the acceleration of the shaft, so that the shaft possibly reaches a speed limit range.EP 0742356 A2 describes a method for setting a main regulating variable during the operation of a gas turbo set. According to this solution, for example, the generator power output or the rotary frequency of the rotor may serve as the main regulating variable. A desired value of the selected main regulating variable is compared with a measured value of the main regulating variable, and a required main regulating difference is distributed hierarchically to at least one cascade via a management system. In a gas turbo set with sequential combustion, the procedure carried out by means of the management system can preferably be in this case such that, first, the potential of a first power / temperature cascade which sets the fuel mass flow into the first combustion chamber is exhausted until a maximum turbine inlet temperature is reached, and then the potential of a second power / temperature cascade is exhausted for the second combustion chamber, and, thereafter, that of the power / pressure cascade. By the main regulating difference being distributed to cascades independent of one another, an interaction of the cascades is ruled out. By the series connection of main regulating variable controller and variable controller within the cascades, the variable controller is always ready to respond. This makes regulation rapid and reliable in terms of ruling out interactive influences. Nevertheless, if there is a restriction to the main regulating variables mentioned, namely power and rotary frequency, the abovementioned disadvantages cannot reliably be ruled out.PI 98004233- β A method for protecting a turbo machine against a dangerous rise in the rotor frequency during load shedding is described in SU 1149037 A with reference to the operation of a steam turbine plant. This method is based on three initial variables, namely the measured electrical generator power N3, the rotary frequency n of the rotor and the effective mechanical turbine power NTwhich is determined arithmetically indirectly by means of the measured pressure parameters pi; p2; p3of the process steam and coefficients Ki; K2; K3, not explained in any more detail, in an adder (1). The kinetic power I-n-dn / dt of the rotating rotor is calculated from the mechanical turbine power NTand the generator power N3in the subtractor (3) according to the equation NT-N3=I-n-dn / dt, in which I symbolizes the moment of inertia of the rotary mass of the rotor and dn / dt the acceleration of the latter. An adder (6) links the signals corresponding to the rotary frequency and to the kinetic power. As soon as the sum of these signal exceeds a predetermined limit value (comparator (7)), a warning signal is transmitted to the logic module (12) by the pulse former (8).In a second cascade independent of this, the generator power N3is routed via comparators (9) and (10). As soon as N3undershoots a desired value over a predetermined period of time, in particular falls to zero, the pulse former (11) transmits a warning signal to the logic module (12).If warning signals arrive at the logic module (12) simultaneously from both cascades, a protection signal is triggered which causes the supply of steam to the turbine to be shut off.This method is not conceived as a regulation of the power of the turbo set, but as a method for the protection of turbo sets against mechanical overstress during load shedding. By the parameters of rotor frequency and electrical generator power being determined and by the kinetic rotor power being calculated, hazardous situations caused by mechanicalPI 9«004233- 7 overstress are to be detected reliably and forestalled in good time by the supply of power to the turbine being shut off.SUMMARY OF THE INVENTIONThe object of the invention is to provide a novel method for regulating the power of a turbo set, which method avoids the disadvantages described and regulates the thermal power in such a way that both a network instability caused by the turbo set and overloading of the turbo set are reliably avoided.In a method of the initially mentioned type, the object is achieved in that the thermo power of the turbine consisting of the electric power PGemitted by the generator and of the kinetic power of the shaft is regulated in such a way that, in addition to the electric power PG, the rotary frequency f of the shaft is determined, and the kinetic power Pkinof the shaft is determined from the rotary frequency f and the time change df / dt of the rotary frequency f according to the equation Pkin= 4π2· Θ· f · df / dt (in which θ symbolizes the moment of inertia of the rotary mass), the kinetic power Pkinis added to the electric power PG, and the sum of the electric power PGand the kinetic power Pkinis compared with a predetermined power value Pc, and the differential value ΔΡ determined in this case is transferred to a power controller (20) for regulating the thermal power PTof the turbine (11).Undesirable misbehaviour of power regulation, particularly in the cases of load shedding and network instability, can be reliably avoided by incorporating the electric power of the generator and the kinetic power of the shaft in the regulation.It is in this case possible in a simple way, by means of a single rotary frequency encoder on the shaft, to determine the kinetic power of the shaft reliably and accurately at any moment.PI 98004233In principle, the electric power can be measured at the terminals of the generator. According to a second preferred exemplary embodiment of the invention, another type of measurement, independent of the generator, is characterized in that, in order to determine the electric power delivered by the generator, the rotary frequency of the shaft and the torque exerted on the shaft are measured and the electric power is calculated from these variables.The moment of inertia Θ of the shaft is included in the determination of the kinetic power of the shaft. In principle, the moment of inertia may be calculated or else determined experimentally. A particularly simple method of determination is obtained if, according to a further preferred embodiment of the invention, in order to fix the moment of inertia θ of the shaft, which is critical for regulation, the electric power is set to zero at one moment by isolating the generator from the network in a steadystate mode of the turbo set, and the rotary frequency and angular acceleration of the shaft, which occur at this moment, are measured, and if the value for the moment of inertia θ of the shaft is selected in such a way that the kinetic power Pkin, calculated according to the formula Ρ^η=4π2θί (df / dt) , is equal to the measured electric power Pg at the moment of isolation.A device according to the invention for carrying out the method for regulating the power of a turbo set converting thermal power into electric power, which turbo set comprises, at least on a common shaft, a turbine driven by the thermal power and a generator driven by the turbine and transmitting electric power PGto a network and a power regulator for regulating the thermal power for the turbine, is distinguished by first means which compare an output power of the turbo set with a predetermined power value Pcand which transmit a differential value ΔΡ as a control signal to the power regulator for regulating the thermal power PTfor the turbine, second means for measuring the rotary PI 98004233- 9 frequency f of the shaft, third means, which determine the kinetic power of the shaft (17) from the measured rotary frequency f and the change in time df / dt of the rotary frequency f in accordance with the equation Pkin= 4π2· θ · f · df / dt (in which Θ symbolizes the moment of inertia of the rotary mass (17)), and fourth means (30), which add the electric power (PG) delivered by the generator (16) and the kinetic power Pkindetermined by the third means (26, .., 29) and which transmit the same as the output power of the turbo set (10) to the first means (19).A preferred embodiment of the device according to the invention is defined in that the third means comprise a differentiating element, a multiplier and an amplifier with an adjustable gain.According to the invention, the method is used for a turbo set which comprises a steam turbine or a gas turbine, or for a combined cycle power station which comprises a gas turbine and a steam turbine connected downstream of the gas turbine.Further embodiments of the invention emerge from the dependent claims.BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGSThe invention will be explained in more detail in the text which follows with reference to exemplary embodiments in conjunction with the drawing. In the drawingFigure 1 shows a schematic circuit diagram of power regulation for a gas turbine according to the prior art; andFigure 2 shows the circuit diagram similar to that of Figure 1, additionally taking into account the kinetic power of the shaft, according to a preferred exemplary embodiment of the invention.PI 98004233WAYS OF IMPLEMENTING THE INVENTIONFigure 2 illustrates, in a circuit diagram similar to that of Figure 1, power regulation for a gas turbine 15, on which a preferred exemplary embodiment of the method according to the invention is based. The gas turbine system 15, together with its parts 11, ..,14, the shaft 17, the generator 16 switched to a network 18, and the control loop formed from the elements 19, .., 25 are essentially the same as inFigure 1 and are therefore also given the same reference symbols. There is a change, as compared with Figure 1, to the effect that the measured electric power Pg from the generator 16 is not compared directly at the subtractor 19 with the predetermined power desired value Pg, but the kinetic power Ρ^ίηis first added to the electric power Pg in an adder 30.The kinetic power P]<in i-scalculated, in a correction circuit 26, from the rotary frequency f of the shaft 17, measured at the shaft 17, in accordance with equation (2). For this purpose, the measured rotary frequency f is transmitted to one input of a multiplier 28 provided with two inputs. The change in time df / dt of the rotary frequency f is transmitted to the other input of the multiplier 28, said change being derived from the measured rotary frequency f by differentiation in a differentiating element 27. The product of the variables f and df / dt, which is calculated in the multiplier 28, is then amplified in an amplifier 29 which has the gain 4π^θ. The variablepkin then appears at the output of the amplifier 29, which at the same time forms the output of the correction circuit 26, and is transmitted to the adder30. The correction circuit 26 of the exemplary embodiment constitutes an analog computing circuit which calculates the desired kinetic power P]<in from the measured rotary frequency f. However, this calculation may, of course, also be carried out digitally by means of a microprocessor or the like if98004233 the input accordingly. the rotary variables are previously digitized In Figure 2, for the sake of simplicity, frequency f is measured by means of a separate rotary frequency encoder 25'. Of course, this separate rotary frequency encoder 25' may be dispensed with and the output signal from the rotary frequency encoder 25 may be used for calculating the kinetic power.As already mentioned, the sum of the electric power Pq and kinetic power Ρ]ςίη, said sum being formed in the adder 30, is compared, in the subtractor 19, with a predetermined power value Pq, and the thermal power Ρψ is reduced, when the differential valve ΔΡ is positive, or is increased, when the differential valve ΔΡ is negative. When a gas turbine system 15, which comprises a controllable inlet 14 for the combustion air, a compressor 13 for compressing the combustion air, a combustion chamber 12 for the combustion of a fuel, with the combustion air being supplied, and a turbine 11, is regulated, the mass flow of admitted combustion air via the controllable inlet 14 and the mass flow of fuel dmfc / dt are regulated in order to regulate the thermal power Ρψ.In the arrangement according to Figure 2, the electric power Pq for power regulation is picked up directly at the output terminals of the generator 16. If such measurement on the generator 16 is to be dispensed with, in order to determine the electric power Pq delivered by the generator 16, the rotary frequency f of the shaft 17 and the torque exerted on the shaft 17 can be measured and the electric power Pq is calculated from these variables. As a result, for example, insulation problems on the generator side may be avoided.For calculating the kinetic power, it is necessary per se to know the moment of inertia Θ of the shaft 17, so that, for example, the gain of the amplifier 29 can be set correspondingly. An experimental determination of Θ is expedient in thisPI 98004233 respect. For this purpose, in a steady-state mode of the turbo set 10, the electric power Pq is set to zero at one moment by isolating the generator 16 from the network 18. The rotary frequency f and angular acceleration df / dt of the shaft 17, which occur at this moment, are measured and are entered, for example, in the correction circuit 26. The value for the moment of inertia θ of the shaft 17 and the gain of the amplifier 29 are selected, then, in such a way that the kinetic power Pkin< calculated according to the formula Pkin=47t2©f (df / dt) , or the output signal from the amplifier 29, is equal to the measured electric power Pq at the moment of isolation, moreover said electric power being equal to the thermal power Ρψ at this moment (due to the stationary state prevailing at this moment).The background to this type of determination is that, if the electric power Pq lapses in a stationary state (kinetic power P]<in=0) , the total thermal power is converted into kinetic power, thus leading to an acceleration of the shaft (df / dt > 0) .The kinetic power of the shaft 17, capable of being determined from the commencing acceleration, may therefore be equated directly with the thermal power at the moment of isolation or with the electric power, that is to say PT=PQ=Pj<in=47i20f (df / dt) . since Ρψ and Pq as well as f and df / dt are known, the moment of inertia Θ can be ascertained from this.The regulating method described can be used in the case of individual turbo sets or else in the case of a combination of a plurality of turbo sets. At the same time, as in the example explained, the turbine may be a gas turbine. However, it may also be a steam turbine. In particular, the method according to the invention can be used in combined cycle power stations which comprise at lease one gas turbine and at least one steam turbine connected downstream of the gas turbine. PI 98004233DESIGNATIONSTurbo set TurbineCombustion chamber CompressorControllable inlet (Variable Inlet Guiding Vane (VIGV))Gas turbine systemGeneratorShaftNetwork (three phase network)Subtractor Power regulator Rise limiter AdderCharacteristic encoder Rotary frequency encoder Correction circuit Differentiating element MultiplierAmplifier
Claims
PATENT CLAIMS 1. Method for regulating the power of a turbo set (10) converting thermal power into electric power, said turbo set (10) comprising, on a common shaft (17), a turbine (11) driven by the thermal power and a generator (16) driven by the turbine (11) and delivering electric power Pq to a network (18), in which method the electric power Pq delivered by the generator (16) and the kinetic power Pkin received or transmitted by the shaft (17) are determined and the thermal power PT for the turbine (11) is regulated as a function of the electric power PG and of the kinetic power Pkin, characterized in that the electric power PG and the rotary frequency f of the shaft (17) are determined, the kinetic power Pkin of the shaft (17) is determined from the rotary frequency f and the time change df / dt of the rotary frequency f according to the equation Pkin = 4π2 ·θ·f·df / dt (in which θ symbolizes the moment of inertia of the rotary mass), the kinetic power Pkin of the shaft (17) and the electric power PG are added, and the sum of the electric power PG and of the kinetic power Pkin is compared with a predetermined power value Pc, and the differential value ΔΡ determined is transferred to a power controller (20) for regulating the thermal power PT of the turbine (11) ·2. Method according to Claim 1, characterized in that the thermal power Ρψ is reduced, when the differential value ΔΡ determined is positive, and it is increased, when the differential value ΔΡ determined is negative.
3. Method according to Claim 1, characterized in that the turbine (11) is part of a gas turbine system (15), said gas turbine system (15) comprising a controllable inlet (14) for the combustion air, a compressor (13) for compressing the combustion air, a combustion chamber (12) for the combustion of a fuel, PI 98004233 - 15 with the combustion air being supplied, and the turbine (11), and in that the mass flow of admitted combustion air via the controllable inlet (14) and the mass flow of fuel dmfc / dt are regulated in order to regulate the thermal power Pp.
4. Method according to Claim 1, characterized in that, in order to determine the electric power Pg delivered by the generator (16), the rotary frequency f of the shaft (17) and the torque exerted on the shaft (17) are measured and the electric power Pg is calculated from these variables.
5. Method according to Claim 4, characterized in that, in order to fix the moment of inertia θ of the shaft (17), which is critical for regulation, the electric power Pg is set to zero at one moment by isolating the generator (16) from the network (18) in a steady-state mode of the turbo set (10), and the rotary frequency f and angular acceleration df / dt of the shaft (17), which occur at this moment, are measured, and in that the value for the moment of inertia Θ of the shaft (17) is selected in such a way that the kinetic power (Pkin)' calculated according to the formula Pkin = 4π2 · Θ · f · (df / dt) , is equal to the measured electric power Pg at the moment of isolation.
6. Device for carrying out the method for regulating the power of a turbo set (10) converting thermal power into electric power, which turbo set (10) comprises, on a common shaft (17), a turbine (11) driven by the thermal power and a generator (16) driven by the turbine (11) and transmitting electrical power PG to a network (18), characterized by first means (19) which compare an output power of the turbo set (10) with a predetermined power value Pg and which transmit a differential value ΔΡ as a control signal to the power regulator (20) for regulating the thermal power PT for the turbine (11), second means (25, 25') for measuring the rotary frequency f of the shaft (17), third means (26, .., 29), which determine the kinetic power of the shaft (17) from the measured rotary PI 98004233 frequency f and the change in time df / dt of the rotary frequency f in accordance with the equation pkin = 4π2·θ·ί· (df / dt) (in which θ symbolizes the moment of inertia of the rotary mass (17)), and fourth means 5 (30), which add the electric power (Pg) delivered by the generator (16) and the kinetic power Pkin determined by the third means (26, .., 29) and which transmit the same as the output power of the turbo set (10) to the first means (19).
107. Device according to Claim 6, characterized in that the third means comprise a differentiating element (27), a multiplier (28) and an amplifier (29) with an adjustable gain.
8. Device according to Claim 6 or 7, 15 characterized in that the first means comprise a subtractor (19), the second means a rotary frequency encoder (25, 25') and the fourth means an adder (30).
