Apparatus and methods for testing variable resistors

MYPI1998004930A0Inactive Publication Date: 1999-04-29PANASONIC HOLDINGS CORP
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
MYPI1998004930
Authority / Receiving Office
MY · MY
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
1997-10-29
Filing Date
1998-10-29
Publication Date
1999-04-29
Estimated Expiration
Not applicable · inactive patent

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Traditional methods for testing electrical characteristics of variable resistors in manufacturing processes are labor-intensive, require complex procedures, and suffer from accuracy issues due to reliance on visual and auditory judgments, especially in assessing slide electrical noise.

Method used

A testing apparatus utilizing a personal computer with a mother board section and a connecting jig, which allows for automated testing of variable resistors under arbitrary conditions, quantifies noise data, and measures contact and insulation resistance, reducing manual intervention and improving accuracy.

Benefits of technology

This approach simplifies testing procedures, significantly reduces man-hours, shortens testing time, and enhances accuracy by converting noise assessments into numerical data and precise resistance measurements.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

AN APPARATUS FOR TESTING A VARIABLE RESISTOR (45) IS DISCLOSED WITH WHICH A SERIES OF TESTS ARE SUCCESSIVELY PERFORMED IN DIFFERENT STATES OF A MOVABLE CONTACT BRUSH (47) OF THE VARIABLE RESISTOR (45) INCLUDING A VARIABLE RESISTOR (45) HAVING AN ON-OFF SWITCH (49), NAMELY, A STATE IN WHICH THE MOVABLE CONTACT BRUSH (47) IS AT AN ARBITRARY POSITION WITHIN THE OPERATING RANGE, A STATE IN WHICH IT IS MOVED TO THE STARTING POSITION, MIDDLE POSITION, AND ENDING POSITION OF THE OPERATING RANGE, AND A STATE IN WHICH IT IS BEING MOVED FROM THE STARTING POSITION TO THE ENDING POSITION. THE TESTING APPARATUS COMPRISES AN INPUT UNIT (31) FOR INPUTTING INFORMATION FOR SETTING TESTING CONDITIONS OF A VARIABLE RESISTOR (45) AND FOR CONTROL OF OPERATION OF THE TESTING APPARATUS, A PERSONAL COMPUTER (32) PROGRAMMED TO PERFORM SETTING OF TESTING CONDITIONS, CONTROL OF OPERATION OF THE TESTING APPARATUS, PROCESSING OF MEASURED DATA, AND JUDGMENT OF PASS OR FAIL, A DISPLAY SECTION (36) TO DISPLAY SECTION TO DISPLAY VARIOUS INFORMATION, A CONNECTING JIG (41) TO CONNECT AND HOLD A VARIABLE RESISTOR (45) TO BE TESTED, AND A MOTHER BOARD SECTION (35) TO SUPPLY TO THE VARIABLE RESISTOR SIGNALS NECESSARY FOR MEASUREMENT, AND TO TAKE OUT MEASURED DATA AND SEND OBTAINED INFORMATION ON MEASURED DATA TO THE PERSONAL COMPUTER (32) VIA THE CONNECTING JIG (41). (FIG. 1).
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

TITLE OF THE INVENTIONApparatus and Methods for Testing Variable ResistorsBACKGROUND OF THE INVENTIONThe present invention relates to an apparatus and methods for testing electrical characteristics of variable resistors in a manufacturing process of variable resistors.Before describing a prior art, a product outline of a variable resistor to be tested by a testing apparatus is described in reference to Fig. 8 in order to facilitate understanding.Fig. 8 is a perspective view of a rotary single-shaft dual-resistor type variable resistor having a push switch, which is a typical configuration to be used in audio equipment such as car stereo. As illustrated in the figure, the variable resistor comprises a rotatable and pushable operating shaft 1 made of metal, a bearing 2 made of metal, variable resistor units 3 and 4 each having the same resistance value and the same resistance-change characteristic, an elastic-return type push switch 5, and a terminal 6.The above-described variable resistor is installed by soldering the terminal 6 provided on the bottom surface onto a circuit substrate of an equipment such as a car stereo and fastening threaded portion of the bearing 2 on a chassis or a frame with a nut.Operation of the rotary single-shaft dual-resistor type variable resistor is described below for the case of use in a car stereo as an example. First, upon pushing the operating shaft 1, the push switch unit 5 connected to the power switch of the car stereo is brought to an on state thus turning on the car stereo power, and the operating shaft 1 returns to its initial position by an elastic returning force.Subsequently, by rotating the operating shaft 1 to either left or right, an internal movable contact brush of each of the variable resistor units 3 and 4 connected to each respective volume control circuit of the left and right channels of the car stereo is rotatingly slidden on the surface of a resistor element thereby changing the amount of attenuation of a signal and allowing one to adjust to a desired volume of sound.Traditional way of testing electrical characteristics in a manufacturing process of a variable resistor having several functions as mentioned above used to be either to successively test a variety of test items using individual testing apparatus corresponding to the contents of each test in a testing work by testing work process, or to dispose each apparatus at one location and to successively change over connection between each testing apparatus and terminal of an object to be tested by means of a selector switch or a relay in accordance with the sequence of testing and to make necessary tests and judgment of pass or fail.Fig. 9 is a conceptual structure of a typical arrangement of traditional testing apparatuses for variable resistors. In Fig. 9, a total resistance value testing apparatus 7 tests the total resistance values of the resistor units 3 and 4 of the variable resistor shown in Fig. 8, while a residual resistance value testing apparatus 8 tests the residual resistance values at the beginning and ending positions of the effective angle of rotation of the operating shaft 1 (Fig. 8) of the variable resistor. A resistance-change characteristic testing apparatus 9 tests the changing characteristic of the resistance value obtained by rotating the operating shaft 1 from the starting position to the ending position, and a slide electrical noise testing apparatus 10 tests electrical noise while the operating shaft 1 is rotated from the starting position to the ending position. A mutual deviation testing apparatus 11 tests a mutual deviation defined as the difference of attenuation, during the period the operating shaft 1 is rotated from the starting position to the ending position, between the variable resistor units 3 and 4 which have identical resistance values and resistance-change characteristics, and a switch testing apparatus 12 tests the on-off operation of the push switch unit 5 provided on the variable resistor. In this structure, each of the above testing apparatuses is connected to a testing station13.In the testing station 13, a switching circuit (not shown) to change over connection between a variable resistor to be tested and each testing apparatus in accordance with the testing procedure is built-in, and a selector switch 14 to activate the switching circuit, an indicator lamp 15 which is lighted upon receiving a pass or fail signal supplied by a testing apparatus, and an alarm buzzer 16, are provided.An example of testing work using the above-configured traditional testing apparatuses of a variable resistor is now described. By operating the selector switch 14, total resistance value is first tested by connecting the terminal of the variable resistor to be tested to the total resistance value testing apparatus 7. If the variable resistor passes this test, the selector switch 14 is operated again to connect the terminal of the object to be tested to the residual resistance value testing apparatus 8 by changing over the circuit inside the testing station 13, and the residual resistance value at the starting position of the object to be tested is tested. The operating shaft 1 is then rotated to test the residual resistance value at the ending position; if the variable resistor passes both tests, then the test proceeds to the next step of testing resistance-change characteristic.Now, by operating the selector switch 14, the circuit inside the testing station 13 is changed over so that the terminal of the object to be tested is connected to the resistance-change characteristic testing apparatus 9.As set forth above, testing of all characteristics can be performed by repeating the operation of the selector switch 14 on the testing station 13 and necessary operation of the operating shaft 1 of the object to be tested in accordance with the contents of testing.Next, a method of testing slide electrical noise is described as an example of a testing method by means of the above-mentioned traditional testing apparatuses. Fig. 10 is a simplified testing circuit diagram of a traditional method of testing slide electrical noise. In Fig. 10, a d.c. voltage is applied to the terminal leading to a movable contact brush 20 of a variable resistor 19 being an object to be tested through a resistor 21, and a variation of voltage appearing in a variable resistor element 22 is picked up through a capacitor 23. A signal corresponding to the variation is amplified by an amplifying circuit 24, the output of which is supplied to a VU meter 25 and to a speaker 26 for visual and auditory judgments of pass or fail.Next, a method of testing on-off operation of a switch of a variable resistor having a switch is described. In a simplified circuit diagram of Fig. 11 for a traditional testing of switching operation, a resistor 28 and an LED 19 are connected in series to a switch 27 of an object to be tested. By turning on and off the switch 27 thus applying a d.c. voltage, lighting or non-lighting of the LED 29 is visually judged.In the traditional testing of electrical characteristics of a variable resistor in a manufacturing process as set forth above, as individual testing apparatuses corresponding to each respective characteristic to be tested are used, it is necessary to change over testing apparatuses, move or temporarily store the object to be tested when testing processes are separate, and repeat insertion into and taking out from the connecting jig, thus requiring much manpower and skill for understanding complicated testing procedures. Furthermore, traditional method of testing suffered a problem of instability in the accuracy of testing when making visual judgment of slide electrical noise based on the deflection of an analog type VU meter 25 corresponding to the amount of noise, making auditory judgment on the noise through the speaker 26, and making visual judgment on lighting and non-lighting of the LED 29 by turning on and off the switch 27 when testing switching operation.SUMMARY OF THE INVENTIONThe present invention address the above problems and aims at reducing the number of manhours of testing by simplifying the procedures and to improve the accuracy of testing. In a preferred embodiment of a testing apparatus of a variable resistor to address the above problems in accordance with the present invention, the apparatus comprises a personal computer in which testing conditions and a program necessary for the control of operation of the testing apparatus and for making pass or fail judgment on measured values have been installed, a mother board section to take in characteristic values of an object to be tested as obtained by outputting signals for testing and to send out processed signals to the personal computer, a testing station connected to the mother board section, and a connecting jig for insertion and taking out of an object to be tested.With this testing apparatus, it is possible to make tests in such a way that the characteristic which can be tested in an arbitrary condition of a variable resistor is tested while it is connected and held to the connecting jig, the characteristic which must be tested at the starting position, middle position, and ending position of the operating range is tested with the operating section of the variable resistor moved to respective positions, and the characteristic which must be tested while the operating section is being moved from the starting position to the ending position is tested while the operation of the variable resistor is continuing, thereby realizing simplification of the testing procedures, great reduction in the number of testing man-hours, shortening of testing time, etc. It is also possible to improve the accuracy of testing by adopting a method of testing slide electrical noise by quantifying the noise as numerical data, and a method of measuring contact resistance and insulation resistance for the test of the switch of a variable resistor having a switch.BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGSFig. 1 is an external view of a variable resistor testing apparatus in an exemplary embodiment of the present invention.Fig. 2 is an external view of a connecting jig being an essential part of the testing apparatus of Fig. 1.Fig. 3 is a functional block diagram of the testing apparatus.Fig. 4 is a diagram of a simplified slide electrical noise testing circuit in an exemplary embodiment of the present invention.Fig. 5 is an example of output voltage characteristic of the slide electrical noise testing circuit shown in Fig. 4.Fig. 6 is a diagram of a simplified circuit for testing operation of a switch in an exemplary embodiment of the present invention.Fig. 7 is a view of an example of what is displayed on a display section of the testing apparatus shown in Fig. 1.Fig. 8 is an external view of a rotary single-shaft dual-resistor type variable resistor having a push switch.Fig. 9 is a diagram showing structure of testing apparatuses in an example of traditional testing method.Fig. 10 is a slide electrical noise testing circuit diagram in a prior art.Fig. 11 is a circuit diagram for testing switch operation in a prior art.DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTSReferring to drawings, an exemplary embodiment of the present invention is described below.Fig. 1 shows a configuration of an apparatus in an exemplary embodiment of a variable resistor testing apparatus in accordance with the present invention. In Fig. 1, an input unit 31 is connected to a main measuring unit 34 and provides testing conditions including part number and circuit construction of an object to be tested, signals concerning testing specifications for characteristics such as total resistance value and residual resistance value, sequence of testing each of the characteristics, signal output required for testing, and signals to control operation such as taking in measured values and making a judgment.A personal computer 32 is connected to the main measuring unit 34 and includes a control section and a judging section which are programmed to perform processes of setting testing conditions in accordance with an input signal fed through the input unit 31, controlling operation of the testing apparatus, and making pass or fail judgment on a measurement.A floppy disc drive unit 33 is used for storing the above-mentioned input signal, operation control signal, and processing programs on recording media, and for inputting the stored data to the personal computer 32.The main measuring unit 34 is provided with a mother board section 35 which works as a measuring unit and comprises an electronic circuit to generate signals for testing and to take in measured values of an object to be tested, a display section 36 to display the above-mentioned various input signals, testing procedures, measured values, and results of judgment, a jig receiving unit 37, a reset switch 39 to proceed testing, and a buzzer 40 to notify failure in a test.A connecting connector 38 is provided inside the jig receiving unit 37 so that a connecting jig 41 shown in Fig. 2 can be inserted and installed. Fig. 2 is an external view of an example of the connecting jig 41. The connecting jig 41 is provided with a multiplicity of contact pins 42 corresponding to the types of variable resistors.Procedure of characteristics testing work of a variable resistor using the above configured testing apparatus is described for the case of testing a rotary single-shaft dual-resistor type variable resistor (Fig. 8) having a push switch. First, the testing apparatus is turned on, and a program made to proceed tests in a predetermined sequence and stored on a floppy disc is loaded on the personal computer 32 via the floppy disc drive 33. Next, by operating a keyboard being the input unit 31, part number of the product to be tested and values of testing specifications, namely, criteria of judgment, of the variable resistor unit (Fig. 8) such as total resistance value, residual resistance value, resistance-value change characteristic, mutual deviation, contact resistance at on time and insulation resistance at off' time of the push switch are input.Next, a connecting jig 41 corresponding to the variable resistor to be tested is inserted in the jig receiving unit 37; when the connecting jig 41 is securely connected to the connecting connector 38 inside the jig receiving unit 37, testing work is ready to be started.Now, the variable resistor is first placed on the connecting jig 41 and is held with its terminal 6 (Fig. 8) made in contact with contact pins 42 disposed on the upper surface of the connecting jig 41. Upon pressing the reset switch 39, the testing apparatus starts to operate and testing is started. Total resistance values of each of the variable resistor units 3 and 4 are then tested. If the result of this test is successful, a GO sign and a downward arrow sign are respectively displayed in the Result column and the Proceed column of a table displayed on the display section 36 as shown in Fig. 7. The testing procedure is now ready to proceed to the next test, namely, test of residual resistance value, and an instruction is displayed on the display area of the display section 36 to set the operating shaft of the variable resistor to the starting position. On rotating the operating shaft 1 manually or by a driving mechanism and pressing the reset switch 39 in accordance with this instruction, the residual resistance values at the starting position of the two variable resistor units are tested. When the result of this test is successful, a GO sign and a downward anow sign are respectively displayed in the Result column and the Proceed column of the table displayed on the display area of the display section 36 in the same manner as set forth above.Likewise, subsequent testing work is also proceeded in accordance with instructions displayed on the display area of the display section 36. When a series of tests are finished, the object to be tested is removed from the connecting jig 41 and replaced with next object to be tested, and the same test is started upon pressing the reset switch again.In the event a failure or trouble is detected during the course of testing, an NG sign is displayed in the Result column conesponding to the currently tested characteristic in the table displayed on the display area of the display section 36. At the same time, progress of test is stopped and an alarm sound is produced by a buzzer 40 provided on the main measuring unit 34. Thereupon, the inappropriate product is removed from the connecting jig 41 and next object to be tested is installed on the connecting jig 41. In testing this object to be tested, the reset switch 39 is pressed again, and the test is started from the first characteristic to be tested and proceeded.By the way, the testing apparatus of a variable resistor which is described in an exemplary embodiment of the present invention may be made to display and print measured data as they are obtained by operating the input unit 31, or to display and print data after statistically processing a large amount of measured data.Furthermore, by incorporating, for example, 6 channels of testing circuits, it becomes possible to simultaneously test by a series of operations a product in which up to six pieces of variable resistor units, switch units, or their combinations have been coupled. Besides, even when each of the units is based on different values of specifications, it is possible to input individual testing conditions to allow the same testing work as has been set forth above.Next, a method of testing slide electrical noise as adopted in the testing apparatus of a variable resistor in accordance with an exemplary embodiment of the present invention is described below in reference to a simplified slide electrical noise testing circuit diagram shown in Fig. 4. As shown in Fig. 4, a constant-current source 46 is connected to one end of a variable resistor 45 being an object to be tested leaving the other end open, and a movable contact brush 47 is connected to a ground. When the movable contact brush 47 is slidden on the surface of a resistor element 48 of the variable resistor 45 while connecting a voltage-detecting circuit to the intersection of the constant-current source 46 and the variable resistor 45, an output voltage characteristic as shown in Fig. 5, for example, is obtained at the output end of the slide electrical noise testing circuit in Fig. 4 in accordance with the direction of sliding operation. The output voltage characteristic as shown in Fig. 5 indicates a case in which the output voltage increases with increasing angle of rotation of the operating shaft (Fig. 8) of a rotary type variable resistor. Conversely, there can be a case in which the output voltage decreases with increasing angle of rotation but it is not shown here.In the output voltage vs. angle of rotation characteristic shown in Fig. 5, if there exists local voltage variations in the reverse direction such as a and b despite the characteristic of increasing output voltage with increasing angle of rotation as above, these variations are detected as slide electrical noises, and the magnitude of the voltage variation in the reverse direction is converted to a percentage relative to the magnitude of the overall voltage variation so that pass or fail judgment can be made by comparing with a criterion for judgment. In this way, it is made possible to make a clearer judgment based on quantified value of slide electrical noise when compared with traditional method of auditory or visual judgment of pass or fail.The method of testing on-off operation of a switch is based on measurement using a circuit as shown in a simplified switching operation testing circuit of Fig. 6(a). In fig. 6(a), a switch 60 is a switch to automatically change over measuring circuits corresponding to the on state and off state of a switch 49 to be tested.Namely, when measuring at the on state, a constant-cunent source 50 and the switch 49 are connected by the switch 60 as shown in Fig. 6(a), and the value of contact resistance is measured by the value of a voltage measured across the switch 49 and the value of a current supplied by the constant-current source 50.Next, in the off state, the range of measurement of contact resistance is exceeded, and the circuit is automatically changed over to an insulation resistance measuring circuit as shown in Fig. 6(b), and insulation resistance is calculated. Judgment of pass or fail is made by comparing each of the calculated values with a criterion for judgment. With this method, it is possible to eliminate products having contact resistance values higher than the criterion for judgment or products having insulation resistance values lower than the criterion for judgment, thereby realizing testing of switching operation with an accuracy higher than traditional methods.Needless to say, the burden to the operator can be greatly reduced when compared with the traditional method and work that depend on visual and auditory senses.*In this way, according to this embodiment, testing of various testing characteristics of a variety of variable resistors that couple and combine various functional units or on-off switches, etc., can be performed with a set of testing apparatuses by changing over to a program or changing connecting jigs corresponding to each individual product, thereby minimizing changeover operation of testing apparatuses, moving and putting aside for a while of products to be tested, and repetition of insertion into and taking out from the connecting jig. It is also possible to realize a great reduction in the number of testing manhours by simplification of procedures. Furthermore, it is possible to realize a high-accuracy testing by adopting quantifying method for the testing of slide electrical noise and on-off operation of a switch.Although reference has been made to a rotary single-shaft dual-resistor type variable resistor in the description of a practical embodiment of the present invention, needless to say, it is applicable to a multi-shaft type rotary resistor having an outer shaft and inner shaft instead of a single shaft or to a slide type variable resistor.Although the invention has been described by way of example of a specific embodiment, many variations and modifications therein will readily occur to those skilled in the art. Accordingly, all such variations and modifications are within the intended scope of the invention as defined by the following claims.

Claims

Claims:

1. An apparatus for testing a variable resistor comprising: a) input means (31) for inputting information for setting testing conditions of various types of variable resistors and for control of the operation of said testing apparatus; b) a personal computer (32) programmed to perform processings such as setting testing conditions, control of operation of testing apparatus, pass or fail judgment of measured data, and the like; c) display means (36) to display information on setting conditions, control of operation, pass or fail judgment on measured data and the like; d) connecting jig (41) to electrically connect and hold a variable resistor including a variable resistor having an on-off switch via contact pins (42) corresponding to a multiplicity of terminals (6) of said variable resistor; and e) a mother board section (35) to supply to said variable resistor signals necessary for measurement of characteristics through said connecting jig (41), and to supply to said personal computer (32) signals obtained by taking out and processing characteristics data; wherein characteristic of said variable resistor which can be tested at an arbitrary state of said variable resistor is tested in a state where said variable resistor is connected and held, characteristic which is to be tested at the starting position, middle position, and the ending position of the operating range of said variable resistor is tested in a state where the operating section of said variable resistor is moved to respective positions, and characteristic which is to be tested while the operating section (1) is moved from the starting position to the ending position is tested continuously by moving the operating section (1) of said variable resistor manually or by a driving mechanism.

2. The apparatus for testing a variable resistor as recited in claim 1, wherein programs of said personal computer (32) are made possible to be changed with programs of testing conditions, control of operation, and criterion of judgment stored on a recording media by using rewriting means in accordance with the types of variable resistors or characteristics to be tested.

3. The apparatus for testing a variable resistor as recited in claim 1, wherein said mother board section (35) is provided with jig receiving means (37) to allow exchange of jigs (41) with different contact pin (42) configurations corresponding to different types of variable resistors or testing characteristics.

4. The method of testing slide electrical noise of a variable resistor as performed in the apparatus for testing a variable resistor as recited in claim 1, wherein said mother board section (35): has a circuit to connect one end of a constant-current source (46) to one end of a resistor element (48) of a variable resistor (45) connected to and held by said connecting jig (41), to leave the other end of said resistor element (48) open, and to connect a movable contact brush (47) that slides on said resistor element and the other end of said constant-current source (46) to a ground; successively measures variation of a voltage developed between said constant-current source (46) and said movable contact brush (47) when said movable contact brush (47) is slidden starting from that end of said resistor element (48) of said variable resistor (45) which is connected to said constant-current source (46) and ending at said other end which is left open, detects a voltage that varies in a direction reverse to the direction of a voltage that gradually increases, and sends the information to said personal computer (32); and said personal computer (32) calculates percentage of said voltage variation relative to the voltage obtained when said movable contact brush (47) reaches at said other end, and makes judgment of pass or fail comparing said percentage with a criterion for judgment.

5. The method of testing slide electrical noise of a variable resistor as performed in the apparatus for testing a variable resistor as recited in claim 1, wherein said mother board section (35): has a circuit to connect one end of a constant-current source (46) to one end of a resistor element (48) of a variable resistor (45) connected to and held by said connecting jig (41), to leave the other end of said resistor element open, and to connect a movable contact brush (47) that slides on said resistor element (48) and the other end of said constant-current source (46) to a ground; successively measures variation of a voltage developed between said constant-current source (46) and said movable contact brush (47) when said movable contact brush (47) is slidden starting from said end left open and ending at that one end of said resistor element (48) which is connected to said constant-current source (46) of said variable resistor (45), detects a voltage that varies in a direction reverse to the direction of a voltage that gradually decreases, and sends the information to said personal computer (32); and said personal computer (32) calculates percentage of said voltage variation relative to the voltage obtained when said movable contact brush (47) is at said other end left open, and makes judgment of pass or fail comparing said percentage with a criterion for judgment6. The method of testing a switch of a variable resistor having an on-off switch (49) as performed in the apparatus for testing a variable resistor as recited in claim 1, wherein said mother board section (35) detects a voltage across both ends of said switch (49) at the time said switch (49) is on in a circuit in which one end of said switch (49), being an object to be tested, of a variable resistor having an on-off switch (49) connected to and held by said connecting jig (41) is connected to one end of a constant-current source (50) and the other ends of said switch (49) and said constant-current source (50) are connected to a ground, and sends information on this detected voltage and the current supplied by said constant-current source (50) to said personal computer (32), whereupon said personal computer (32) calculates the value of contact resistance at the time said switch (49) is on, and makes judgment on pass or fail by comparing with a criterion for judgment.

7. The method of testing a switch of a variable resistor having an on-off switch (49) as performed in the apparatus for testing a variable resistor as recited in claim 1, wherein said mother board section (35) detects a voltage across both ends of said switch (49) at the time said switch (49) is off in a circuit in which both ends of a voltage source are connected to first resistor and second resistor and second resistor which are connected in series, and both ends of said switch (49) are connected in parallel to one of said first and second resistors, and sends information on this detected voltage and the voltage applied by said voltage source to said personal computer (32), whereupon said personal computer (32) calculates the value of insulation resistance at the time said switch (49) is off, and makes judgment on pass or fail by comparing with a criterion for judgment.