Can bottom having improved pressure resistance and apparatus for making same

MYPI1999002228A0Inactive Publication Date: 1999-12-03CROWN CORK & SEAL TECH CORP
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
MYPI1999002228
Authority / Receiving Office
MY · MY
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
1998-06-03
Filing Date
1999-06-03
Publication Date
1999-12-03
Estimated Expiration
Not applicable · inactive patent

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Conventional can bottoms for carbonated beverages lack optimal geometry for enhanced buckle resistance, drop resistance, stackability, and manufacturability, with existing methods focusing on reducing the radius of curvature of the nose to increase strength but compromising stackability and potentially leading to metal cracking.

Method used

A can bottom design featuring a frustoconical portion, an annular nose with a specific radius of curvature, a central domed section, and a forming apparatus with corresponding die and punch configurations to optimize the geometry for increased buckle strength and maintain stackability, while reducing metal thickness and cracking risks.

Benefits of technology

The proposed design significantly increases buckle strength by up to 10% and maintains stackability by adjusting the nose radius and diameter, reducing metal thickness, and minimizing cracking, thereby enhancing the overall performance and manufacturing efficiency of can bottoms.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

A CAN BOTTOM (6) HAVING AN APPROXIMATELY FRUSTOCONICAL PORTION (8) EXTENDING DOWNWARDLY AND INWARDLY FROM THE CAN SIDE WALL (4), AN ANNULAR NOSE PORTION (16) EXTENDING DOWNWARDLY FROM THE APPROXIMATELY FRUSTOCONICAL PORTION, AND A CENTRAL PORTION (24) EXTENDING UPWARDLY AND INWARDLY FROM THE NOSE. THE NOSE (16) IS FORMED BY INNER AND AUTER CIRCUMFERENTIALLY EXTENDING FRUSTOCONIICAL WALLS (12,13) THAT ARE JOINED BY A DOWNWARDLY CONVEX ARCUATE PORTION (18).THE INNER SURFACE (29) OF THE ARCUATE PORTION OF THE NOSE (16) HAS A RADIUS OF CURVATURE ADJACENT THE NOSE INNER WALL OF AT LEAST 1.52 MM (0.060 INCH). THE CENTRAL PORTION (24) OF THE CAN BOTTOM HAS A SUBSTANTIALLY FLAT DISC-SHAPED CENTRAL SECTION (26) , HAVING A DIAMETER OF AT LEAST ABOUT 1.40 INCHES, AND APPROXIMATELY DOME-SHAPED AND DOWNWARDLY CONCAVE HAVING A RADIUS OF CURVATURE NO GREATER THAN 37.47 MM (1.475 INCHES).IN A PREFERRED EMBODIMENT OF THE INVENTION, THE INNER SURFACE OF THE ARCUATE PORTION (18) OF THE NOSE (16) IS FORMED BY A SECTOR OF A CIRCLE AND HAS RADIUS OF CURVATURE IS NO GREATER THAN ABOUT 1.88MM (0.070 INCH). AN APPARATUS FOR MAKING THE CAN BOTTOM COMPRISES A NOSE PUNCH (52) WHOSE DISTAL END HAS A RADIUS OF CURVATURE THAT IS EQUAL TO THE RADIUS OF CURVATURE OF THE CAN BOTTOM NOSE (16) AND A DIE WHOSE RADIUS OF CURVATURE EQUALS THAT OF THE DOME (24).(FIG 2)
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

.!CAN BOTTOM HAVING IMPROVED PRESSURE RESISTANCE AND APPARATUS FOR MAKING SAME • iRelated ApplicationsThis application is a continuation-in-part of U.S. application Serial No.09 / 090,000, filed June 3, 1998, entitled Can Bottom Having Improved PressureResistance and Apparatus for Making Same, hereby incorporated by reference in its entirety.Field of the InventionThe current invention is directed to a can, such as a metal can used to 10 package carbonated beverages. More specifically, the current invention is directed to a can bottom having improved strength.Background of the InventionIn the past, cans for packaging carbonated beverages, such as soft drinks or beer, have been formed from metal, typically aluminum. Such cans are conventionallyIS made by attaching a'can end, or lid, to a drawn and ironed can body that has an integrally formed bottom.Certain parameters relating to the geometry of the can bottom play an important role in the performance of the can. In can bottoms employing an annularPl 99002228 nose, discussed further below, the diameter of the nose affects the ability to stack or nest the bottom of one can into the top end of another can. Nose diameter also affects the resistance of the can to tipping over, such as might occur during filling.In addition to stacking ability and anti-tipping stability, strength is also an 5 important aspect of the performance of the can bottom. For example, since its contents are under pressure, which may be as high as 6.33 kg / sq cm (90 psi), the can must be sufficiently strong to resist excessive deformation due to internal pressurization. Therefore, an important strength parameter for the can bottom is buckle strength, which is commonly defined as the minimum value of the internal pressure required toOcause reversal, or inversion, of the domed portion of the can bottom — that is, the minimum pressure at which the center portion of the can bottom flips from being concave downward to convex downward. Another important parameter is drop resistance, which is defined as the minimum height required to cause dome inversion when a can filled with water and pressurized to 4.22 kg / sq cm (60 psi) is dropped onto a hard surface.In addition to satisfying performance requirements, there is tremendous economic incentive for can makers to reduce the amount of metal used. Since billions of such cans are sold each year, even slight reductions in metal usage are desirable.The overall size and general shape of the can is specified to the can maker by the beverage industry. Consequently, can makers are constantly striving to reduce the thickness of the metal by refining the details of the can geometry to obtain a stronger structure. Only a few years ago, aluminum cans were formed from metal having a thickness of about 0.284 mm (0.0112 inch). However, aluminum cans having thicknesses as low as 0.274 mm (0.0108 inch) are now available.One technique for increasing the strength of the can bottom that has enjoyed considerable success is the forming of a outwardly concave dome in the can bottom. Beverage cans, such as those for soft drinks and beer, typically have a side wall diameter of about 66 mm (2.6 inches). Conventionally, the radius of curvature of the bottom dome is at least 39.37 mm (1.550 inch). For example, U.S. Patent No. 4,685,582 (Pulciani et al.), assigned at issue to National Can Corporation, discloses aPI 99002228 can having a side wall diameter of 65.96 mm (2.597 inches) and a dome radius of curvature of 53.85 mm (2.120 inches). Similarly, U.S. Patent No. 4,885,924 (Claydon et al.), assigned at issue to Metal Box pic, discloses a can having a side wall diameter of 65.79 mm (2.59 inches) and a dome radius of curvature of 50.8 mm (2.0 inches), while U.S. Patent No. 4, 412,627 (Houghton et al.), assigned at issue to MetalContainer Corp, discloses a can having a side wall diameter of 66 mm (2,600 inches) and a dome radius of curvature of 44.45 mm (1.750 inches).The strength of a domed can bottom is further increased by forming a downwardly and inwardly extending frustoconical wall on the periphery of the bottom that terminates in an annular bead, or nose. The nose has circumferentially extending inner and outer walls, which may also be frustoconical. The inner and outer walls are joined by an outwardly convex arcuate portion, which may be formed by a sector of a circle. The base of the arcuate portion forms the surface on which the can rests when in the upright orientationAccording to conventional can making technology, the radius of curvature of the inner surface of the arcuate portion of the nose in such domed, conically walled can / bottoms was generally 1.27 mm (0.050 inch) or less. For example, prior to the development of the current invention, the parent of the assignee of the instant application, Crown Cork & Seal Company, sold aluminum cans with 202 ends (i.e., the diameter of the can end opposite the bottom is 53.9875 mm (2-2 / 16 inch)) in which the radius of curvature of the inside surface of the nose was 1.27 mm (0.050 inch). Similarly, U.S. Patent Nos. 3,730,383 (Dunn et al.), assigned at issue to Aluminum ' Company of America, and U.S. Patent No. 4,685,582 (Pulciani et al.), assigned at issue to National Can Corporation, disclose a nose having a radius of curvature of 1.016 mm (0.040 inch).Moreover, it was heretofore generally thought that the smaller the radius of curvature of the nose, the greater the pressure resistance of the can bottom, as discussed, for example, in the aforementioned U.S. Patent No. 3,730,383.Consequently, U.S. Patent No. 4,885,924 (discussed above), U.S. Patent No. 5,069,052 (Porucznik et al.), assigned at issue to CMB Foodcan pic, and U.S. Patent No.Pl 990022285,351,852 (Trageser et al.), assigned at issue to Aluminum Company of America, all disclose methods for reducing the radius of curvature of the nose in order to increase the strength of the can bottom. U.S. Patent No. 5,351,852 suggests reworking the nose so as to reduce its radius of curvature to 0.381 mm (0.015 inch), while U.S. Patent No.5,069,052 suggests reworking the nose so as to reduce its radius of curvature on the inside surface to zero and on the outside surface to 1.016 mm (0.040 inch) or less.In addition to its geometry, the manufacturing apparatus and techniques employed in forming the can bottom can affect its strength. For example, small surface cracks can be created in the chime area of the can bottom if the metal is stretched excessively when the nose is formed. If, as sometimes occurs, these cracks do not initially extend all the way through the metal wall, they may go undetected during inspection by the can maker. This can result in failure of the can after it has been filled and closed, which is very undesirable from the standpoint of the beverage seller or the ultimate customer. The smaller the radius of curvature of the nose, the more likely that such cracking will occur. Since the radius of curvature of the nose adjacent its inner wall is thought to have a greater impact oh buckle strength than the radius adjacent the outer wall, some can manufacturers have utilized a nose shape that is more complex than a simple circle sector by employing two radii of curvature — a first inside surface radius of curvature adjacent the outer wall that is above 1.52 mm (0,060 inch) and a second inside surface radius of curvature adjacent the inner wall that is below 1.52 mm (0.060 inch). For example, U.S. Patent No. 4,431,112 (Yamaguchi), assigned at issue to Daiwa Can Company, discloses a domed can bottom, although one that does not have a conical peripheral wall, with a nose having a first radius of curvature adjacent its inner wall of about 0.89 mm (0.035 inch) and a second radius of curvature adjacent its outer wall of about 2.31 mm (0.091 inch). Another can manufacturer has employed a domed, conically walled bottom in a 204 end can in which the inner surface of the nose, whose outer wall is inclined at an angleof about-3.056C (26.5°) with respect to the can axis, has a first radius of curvature adjacent the nose inner wall of about 1.37 mm (0.054 inch) and a second radius of curvature adjacent the outer wall of about 1.63 mm (0.064 inch).1PI 99002228Notwithstanding the improvements heretofore achieved in the art, it would be desirable to provide a can bottom having a geometry that optimized performance, especially with respect to buckle resistance, drop resistence, and stackability and manufacturability.Summary of the InventionIt is an object of the current invention to provide a can bottom having a geometry that optimized performance, especially with respect to buckle resistance, stackability and manufacturability. This and other objects is accomplished in a can comprising a side wall portion and a bottom portion formed integrally with the side wall portion. The bottom portion comprises (i) an approximately frustoconical portion extending downwardly and inwardly from the side wall portion, (ii) an annular nose portion extending downwardly from the approximately frustoconical portion, the nose portion formed by inner and outer circumferentially extending walls joined by a downwardly convex arcuate portion, and (iii) a central portion extending upwardly and inwardly from the nose inner wall, the central portion being approximately domeshaped and downwardly concave. In one embodiment of the invention, the arcuate portion has inner and outer surfaces, the inner surface of the arcuate portion has a radius of curvature adjacent the nose inner wall of at least 1.52 mm (0.060 inch). In a preferred embodiment of the invention, the radius of curvature is also no greater than about 1.78 mm (0.070 inch).The invention also encompasses a can bottom portion that comprises (i) an approximately frustoconical portion that extends downwardly and inwardly from the side wall portion, (ii) an annular nose portion that extends downwardly from the approximately frustoconical portion, (iii) a substantially flat disc-shaped central section, and (iv) an annular dome section disposed between the substantially flat central section and the nose, the annular dome section being arcuate in transverse cross-section and downwardly concave, the annular dome section having a radius of curvature no greater than about 37.47 mm (1.475 inches). In a preferred embodiment, the can side wall has a diameter of about 66 mm (2.6 inches), the radius of curvature of the annular dome section is about 36.8 mm (1.45 inches), the substantially flat discPI 99002228 shaped central section has a diameter of at least about 3.56 mm (0.14 inches), and the substantially flat disc-shaped central section is displaced from a base portion of the nose by a height that is at least about 10.41 mm (0.41 inches).The invention also encompasses an apparatus for forming can bottom that has an annular nose formed therein. The apparatus comprises (i) a centrally disposed die having a forming surface that is approximately dome-shaped and upwardly convex, (ii) a nose punch movable relative to the die, the nose punch having a distal end, the distal end formed by inner and outer circumferentially extending walls joined by a downwardly convex arcuate portion, the arcuate portion having a radius of curvature adjacent the inner wall of at least 1.52 mm (0.060 inch), and (iii) a ram for causing relative motion between the nose punch and the die.The invention also encompasses an apparatus in which a centrally disposed die has a forming surface having a radius of curvature no greater than about 37.47 mm (1.475 inches).Brief Description of the DrawingsFigure 1 is an isometric view of a can having a bottom according to the current invention.Figure 2 is a cross-sectioii taken through line II-II shown in Figure 1, showing the can bottom according to the current invention.1'Figure 3 is a cross-section through the can bottom of the current invention nested into the end of a similar can.Figure 4 is a graph showing the effect of varying the radius of curvature of the inner surface of the nose on the buckle strength of a can bottom.Figure 5 is a graph showing the effect of varying the radius of curvature of the inner surface of the nose on the buckle strength of a can bottom when the diameter of the nose is varied so as to maintain approximately constant depth of penetration at nesting.Figure 6 is a longitudinal cross-section taken through a bottom forming station according to the current invention.PI 99002228Figure 7 is a longitudinal cross-section taken through the nose punch according to the current invention shown in Figure 6.Description of the Preferred EmbodimentA can 1 according to the current invention is shown in Figure 1. As is conventional, the can comprises an end 3, in which an opening is formed, and a can body. The can body is formed by a cylindrical side wall 4 and a bottom 6 that is integrally formed with the side wall. The side wall 4 has a diameter D,.' As is also convention, the can body is made from a metal, such as steel or, more preferably, aluminum, such as type 3204, 3302 or 3004 aluminum plate having an H-l9 temper.As shown in Figure 2, the can bottom 6 comprises an approximately frustoconical portion 8 that extends downwardly and inwardly from the side wall 4. The frustoconical portion 8 includes an arcuate section 10, having a radius of curvature Rj, that forms a smooth transition into the side wall 4. The frustoconical portion 8 also preferably includes a straight section that forms an angle a with respect to the axis 7 of the side wall 4.As also shown in Figure 2, an annular nose 16 extends downwardly from the frustoconical portion 8. The nose 16 preferably comprises inner and outer approximately frustoconical walls 12 and 13, respectively. It should be noted that the inner wall 12 is sometimes referred to in the art as the “chime.” Preferably, the inner wall 12 has a straight section that forms an angle γ with respect to the axis 7 of the side wall 4, while the outer wall 13 has a straight section that forms an angle β with respect to the axis. The inner and outer walls 12 and 13 are joined by a circumferentially extending arcuate section 18. The inner wall 12 includes an arcuate section 22, having a radius of curvature R5, that forms a smooth transition into a center portion 24 of the bottom 6. The outer wall 13 includes an arcuate section 14, having a radius of curvature R2, that forms a smooth transition into the frustoconical portion 8.In transverse cross-section, the portion of the inner surface 29 of the arcuate section 18 of the nose 16 adjacent the inner wall 12 has a radius of curvature R3.Similarly, the portion of the inner surface 29 of the arcuate section 18 adjacent thePI 99002228 outer wall 13 has a radius of curvature R4. The radii of curvature of the outer surface 30 of the nose 16 will be equal to the radii of curvature of the inner surface 29 plus the thickness of the metal in the arcuate portion 18 of the nose, which is generally essentially the same as the starting metal plate. Preferably, R3equals R4. Most preferably, the inner surface 29 of the arcuate portion 18 is entirely formed by a sector of a circle so that only one radius of curvature forms the entirety of the arcuate portion 18 of inner surface of the nose 16, as shown in Figure 2. The center 19 of the radius of curvature R3forms a circle of diameter D2as it extends around the circumference of the bottom 6. The base 27 of the nose 16, on which the can 1 rests when in the upright orientation, is also formed around diameter D2. The center 21 of radius of curvature Rj ofthe arcuate section 10 is displaced from the center 19 of radius of curvature R3in the axial direction by a distance Y. Preferably, as the value of R3is increased, as discussed below, the value of Y is decreased so that the sum of Y + R3remains constant.An approximately dome-shaped center portion 24 extends upwardly and inwardly from the nose 16. The most central section 26 of the center portion 24 is disc-shaped, having a diameter D3and being substantially flat. An annular portion 25 of the center portion 24 is arcuate in transverse cross-section, having a radius of curvature R6, and connects the central section 26 to the inner wall 12 of the nose 16.The can bottom 6 has a dome height H that extends from the base 27 of the nose 16 to the top of the center portion 24.As shown in Figure 3, when two similarly constructed cans are stacked one atop the other, the bottom 6 of the upper can will penetrate into the end 3 of the lower can so that the base 27 of the nose 16 of the upper can extends a distance d below the lip formed on the seaming panel 40 of the lower can.Figure 4 shows the results of a finite element analysis, or FEA, aimed at showing how the buckle strength, defined as discussed above, varies with the radius of curvature of the nose 16 in the bottom of a can having a 202 end and employing the geometry defined in Table I and shown in Figure 2:PI 99002228Table I — Can Bottom Geometric Parameters For FEADiameter D, Diameter D2Diameter D3Cj Radius R,Radius R2Radius R3Radius R4Radius R5Radius R6Distance Y + R3Dome Height H Angle a Angle β }5 Angle γ66.24 mm (2.608 inches)48.36 mm (1.904 inches) 2.54 mm (0.100 inch) 4.32 mm (0.170 inch) 2.03 mm (0.080 inch) VariableEquals R31.52 mm (0.060 inch)39.37 mm (1.550 inch) 9.17 mm (0.361 inch) 10.29 mm (0.405 inch) 60°25°8°A 202 end can having a bottom defined by the geometry specified in Table I and with a nose 16 having an inner surface 29 with a radius of curvature R3of 1.27 mm (0.050 inch) is known in the prior art. As shown in Figure 4, increasing the radius of curvature R3of the nose inner surface 29 to 1.52 mm (0.060 inch) results in a dramatic increase in buckle strength. Specifically, the finite element analysis predicted that, contrary to the conventional wisdom in the can making art, increasing the nose inner surface radius from 1.27 mm (0.050 inch) to 1.52 mm (0.060 inch) in such a can bottom would increase the buckle strength by almost 10%, from 6.68 kg / sq cm (95 psi) to 7.31 kg / sq cm (104 psi).$5 Unfortunately, increases in the nose inner surface radius of curvature beyond1.52 mm (0.060 inch) did not yield continued increases in buckle strength, but actually reduced buckle strength, although the buckle strength remained above that obtained with the 1.27 mm (0.050 inch) radius of curvature previously employed for such a can bottom.PI 99002228In order to check these theoretical predictions, twelve ounce beverage cans having 202 ends were made using bottom geometries specified in Table I and shown in Figure 2 with three different radii of curvature R3for the inner surface 29 of the nose arcuate portion 18 — 1.27, 1.40 and 1.52 mm (0.050, 0.055 and 0.060 inch). Cans with each size radius of curvature were made using two different dome heights H and from two different types of 0.274 mm (0.0108 inch) thick aluminum plate — type 3204 H-19 and type 3304C5 H-19 so that, altogether, there were twelve different types of cans. The cans were tested for four strength related parameters — (i) buckle strength, defined as discussed above, (ii) bottom strength, obtained by measuring the minimum axial load required to collapse the can bottom when the side wall is supported, (iii) drop resistance, obtained by dropping water-filled cans pressurized to 4.22 kg / sq cm (60 psi) from varying heights, and (iv) axial load, obtained by measuring the minimum axial load required to collapse the unsupported can side wall. The results of these tests, which are averaged for at least six cans of each type, are shown in Table II. In addition, the penetration depth d at stacking was measured and is shown in Table III.Table II — Comparative Test Results — Variable Nose Radius Of CurvatureBuckle Streneth Bottom Streneth Drop Resistance Axial Load Kg / sq cm Kg mm Kg (psi) (lbs) (inches) (lbs) Type 3204 H-19 AluminumH=l.29 mm (Ό.0405 inches) R3=. 1.27 mm 6.80 kg / sq cm 124.15 kg 170.18 mm 105.60 kg (0.050 inches) (96.7 psi) (273.7 lbs.) (6.7 inches) (232.80 lbs.) R3= 1.40 mm 6.91 kg / sq cm 124.60 kg 175.26 mm 104.14 kg (0.055 inches) (98.3 psi) (274.7 lbs.) (6.9 inches) (229.60 lbs.) R3= 1.52 mm 7.3 kg / sq cm 129.14 kg 193.04 mm 93.03 kg (0.060 inches) (103.8 psi) (284.7 lbs.) (7.6 inches) (205.1 lbs.)PI 99002228 ioH=1.54 mm (0.0415 inches')R3= 1.27 mm 6.87 kg / sq cm 123.83 kg 170.180 mm 103.24 kg (0.050 inches) (97.7 psi) (273.0 lbs.) (6.7 inches ) (227.6 lbs.) R3= 1.40 mm 7.0 kg / sq cm 125.51 kg 172.72 mm 104.87 kg (0.055 inches) (99.5 psi) (276.70 lbs.) (6.8 inches) (231.2 lbs.) R3= 1.52 mm 7.38 kg / sq cm 128.68 kg 172.72 mm 100.20 kg (0.060 inches) (105.0 psi) (283.70 lbs.) (6.8 inches) (220.9 lbs.)Type 3304C5 H-19 Aluminum H=1.29 mm (0.0405 inches)R3= 1.27 mm 6.73 kg / sq cm 121.88 kg 149.86 mm 111.27 kg (0.050 inches) (95.7 psi) (268.7 lbs.) (5.9 inches) (245.3 lbs.) R3= 1.40 mm 7.00 kg / sq cm 126.10 kg 149.86 mm 107.86 kg (0.055 inches) (99.5 psi) (278.0 lbs.) (5.9 inches) (237.8 lbs.) R3= 1.52 mm 7.68 kg / sq cm 121.7 kg 172.72 mm 111.45 kg (0.055 inches) (99.5 psi) (278.0 lbs.) (5.9 inches) (237.8 lbs.) R3= 1.52 mm 7.68 kg / sq cm 121.7 kg 172.72 mm 111.45 kg (0.060 inches) (100.5 psi) (268.3 lbs.) (6.8 inches) (245.7 lbs.)H=1.54 mm (0.0415 inches)R3= 1.27 mm 6.80 kg / sq cm 122.15 kg 152.40 mm 108.32 kg (0.050 inches) (96.7 psi) (269.3 lbs.) (6.0 inches) (238.8 lbs.) R3= 1.40 mm 7.00 kg / sq cm 125.06 kg 154.94 mm 110.09 kg (0.055 inches) (99.5 psi) (275.7 lbs.) (6.1 inches) (242.7 lbs.) R3= 1.52 mm 7.09 kg / sq cm 123.38 kg 160.02 mm 107.50 kg (0.060 inches) (100.8 psi) (272.0 lbs.) (6.3 inches) (237.0 lbs.)PI 99002228Table III — Comparative Test Results — Nose Radius vs. Stacking DepthRadius of Curvature, R?Stacking Depth, d1.27 mm (0.050 inch) 2.11 mm 1.40 mm (0.055 inch) 1.75 mm 1.52 mm (0.060 inch) 1.57 mmThe comparative strength test results shown in Table II confirm the fact that, contrary to the conventional wisdom, increasing the radius of curvature R3of the inner surface 29 of the arcuate portion IS of the nose 16 on can bottoms of the type specified in Table I and shown in Figure 2, at least up to 1.52 mm (0.060 inch), increases, rather than decreases, the buckle resistance.Unfortunately, as shown in Table III, it was found that although increasing the radius of curvature R3of the nose 16 at its inner surface 29 from 1.27 mm (0.050 inch) to 1.52 mm (0.060 inch) dramatically increased buckle strength, it reduced the depth of penetration at stacking from 2.11 mm (0.083 inch) to 1.57 nun (0.062 inch).This undesirable aspect, which compromises the stackability of the can, occurred because increasing the radius R.3of the nose inner surface 29 pushes the nose outer wall 13 radially outward.Figure 5 shows the results of a finite element analysis of a can bottom having the geometry specified in Table I and shown in Figure 2 except that the diameter D2of the nose 16 was decreased as its radius of curvature R3at the nose inner surface increased in the manner shown in Table IV:Pl 99002228Table IV — Variation of Nose Diameter With Nose Radius of CurvatureNose Radius, R3mm (inches)1.27 mm (0.050 inches)1.52 mm (0.060 inches)1.65 mm (0.065 inches)1.78 mm (0.070 inches)Nose Diameter. D-, mm (inches)48.36 mm (1.904 inches)48.10 mm (1.890 inches)47.85 mm (1.884 inches)47.68 mm (1.877 inches)As can be seen in Figure 5, coupling increases in the nose radius of curvature R3with appropriate decreases in the nose diameter D2theoretically results in constantly increasing buckle strength within the 1.27 mm (0.050 inch) to 1.78 mm io (0.070 inch) nose radius range. In fact, the most dramatic increase occurs as the radius of curvature of the inside surface of the nose is increased from 1.65 mm (0.065 inch) to 1.78 mm (0.070 inch).In order to test the theoretical predictions from the finite element analysis discussed above, twelve ounce cans having 202 ends, and bottoms as shown in Figure2, were made from Alcoa 3004 H-19 aluminum plate having an initial thickness of Ό.274 mm (0.0108 inch). Half of the cans were made using a bottom geometry that is known in the prior art, which is designated A in Table V, and the other half were made Using One embodiment of the geometry of the current invention, which is designated B. Consistent with the theoretical analysis discussed above, the two can bottom geometries differed in two respects. First, contrary to conventional thinking, the radius of curvature R3of the nose 16 at its inner surface 29 was increased to 1.52 mm (0.060 inch). Second, the diameter D2of the nose was decreased to 48.10 mm (1.890 inch).Table V — Can Bottom Geometric Parameters For Comparative Testing - Nose Dim,Can Bottom A Can Bottom B Diameter Dj 66.24 mm (2.608 inches) 66.24 mm (2.608 inches) Diameter D2 48.36 mm (1.904 inches) 45.95 mm (1.890 inches) Diameter D3 2.54 mm (0.100 inch) 2.54 mm (0.100 inches) Radius Rj 4.32 mm (0.170 inch) 4.32 mm (0.170 inch)PI 99002228Radius R2 2.03 mm (0.080 inch) 2.03 mm (0.080 inch) Radius R3 1.27 mm (0.050 inch) 1.52 mm (0.060 inch) Radius R4 1.27 mm (0.050 inch) 1.52 mm (0.060 inch) Radius R5 1.52 mm (0.060 inch) 1.52 mm (0.060 inch) Radius R6 39.37 mm (1.550 inch) 39.37 mm (1.550 inch) Distance Y + R3 9.17 mm (0.361 inch) 9.17 mm (0.361 inch) Height H 0.405 inch (10.29 mm) 0.405 inch (10.29 mm) Angle a 60° 60° ' Angle β 24° 25° . Angle γ 8° 8°Comparative testing was again preformed on the two groups of cans and the results, which are reported as the average for at least six cans, are shown in Table VLTable VI - Comparative Test Results - Varying Nose Radius And Nose DiameterCan Bottom ABuckle Strength Bottom Strength Drop Resistance Axial Load Penetration Depth d6.59 kg / sq cm (93.7 psi) 121.20 kg (267.2 lbs.) 185.42 mm (7.3 inches) 101.65 mm (224.1 lbs.) 2.16 mm (0.085 inch)Can Bottom B 7.04 kg / sq cm (100.1 psi) 122.33 kg (269.7 lbs) 172.72 mm (6,8 inches) 107.41 kg (236.8 lbs) 2.18 mm (0.086 inch)As can be seen, the buckle strength of the cans made according to the current invention was almost 7% greater than that of the prior art cans (i.e., 7.04 kg / sq cm (100.1 psi) versus 6.59 kg / sq cm (93.7 psi)). Such an increase is very significant. For example, it is expected that this increase in buckle strength will allow the 6.33 kg / sq cm (90 psi) buckle strength requirement commonly imposed by carbonated beverage bottlers to be satisfied even if the thickness of the initial metal plate is reduced from .274 mm (0.0108 inch) to .264 mm (0.0104 inch) — a reduction of almost 4%. Such aPl 99002228 reduction in plate thickness will yield a significant cost savings. The slight reduction in drop resistance is not thought to be statistically significant.The thickness of the metal in the inner chime wall 12 was also measured for the two types of cans. These measurements showed that the chime wall thickness for ' the can bottom according to the current invention (type B) was 0.0076 mm (0.0003 inch) greater than that for the can bottom of the prior art (type A) — i.e. ,. 0.249 mm (0.0098 inch) versus 0.241 mm (0.0095 inches). The increase in chime wall thickness is also significant because it shows that the current invention results in less stretching of the metal in the critical chime area (the more the metal is stretched, the thinner it becomes). Manufacturing trials have shown that this reduction in metal stretching reduces the incidence of can failure due to chime surface cracking.Finally, by decreasing the nose diameter D2, the depth of penetration d was maintained, thereby ensuring that the increase in nose radius of curvature did not compromise stackability even in a can having a relatively small end (i.e., size 202). In this regard, the relatively small· angle β of the nose outer wall 13 (i.e. , 25°) also aids in obtaining good penetration. Thus, according to the current invention, if good stackability is a requirement, (i) the radius of curvature R3of the inner surface 29 of the arcuate portion 18 of the nose 16 should be maintained within the 1.52 mm (0.060 inch) to 1.78 mm (0.070 inch range), (ii) the angle β of the outer wall 13 of the nose2Q should be no greater than about 25°, and (iii) the diameter D2of the nose should be no greater than 48.01 mm (1.89 inch) for cans having ends of size 202 or smaller.Unfortunately, decreasing the nose diameter D2will reduce the tipping stability of the can when oriented in the upright position. Tipping stability is important since a wobbly can may not fill properly during processing and may cause an annoyance to the ultimate consumer. Therefore, it may be undesirable to increase the nose radius of curvature to values beyond 1.78 mm (0.070 inch) in cans having 202 ends, since that would result in nose diameters less than 47.68 mm (1.877 inch) if the stacking penetration is maintained constant. Moreover, although the greatest increase in buckle strength was obtained with a 1.78 mm (0.070 inch) value for the nose inner surface radius R3, this value also results in the smallest nose diameter D2. Therefore,PI 99002228 depending on the relative importance of the stackability versus the tipping stability requirements, the optimum value of the radius of curvature R3of the inner surface 29 of the arcuate portion 18 of the nose 16 may be less than 1.78 mm (0.070 inch), such as about 1.52 mm (0.060 inch) or about 1.65 mm (0.065 inch).* According to another aspect of the invention, the strength of the bottom 6 can also be increased by careful adjustment of the radius R6of the center portion 24. Specifically, it has been found that a surprising increase in the drop resistence can be achieved by reducing the radius R6. This reduction in R6is preferably accompanied by an increase in the diameter D3of the substantially flat central section 26 and an increase in the dome height H. ‘Table VII shows the results of drop resistance and buckle Strength testing for ounce 202 cans having three different bottom geometries. The bottom geometries were the same as those of Can Bottom B shown in Table V unless otherwise indicated. Each can bottom was formed from aluminum (Alcoa 3104) of three different initial thicknesses on a pilot line. Twelve cans were tested in each geometry / thickness. The results of tests on these cans are shown in Tables VI and VII below.Table VI - Comparative Test Results - Varying Dome Dimensions - Pilot LineCan Bottom C 37.47 mm (1.475 in)Can Bottom B 39.37 mm (1.550 in) 2,54 mm (0.100 in) 10.29 mm (0.405 in)Radius R6Diameter D3Height H3.56 mm (0.140 in) 10.29 mm (0.405 in)Can Bottom D 36.83 mm (1.450 in) 3.53 mm (0.139 in) 10.41 mm (0.410 in)Remaining parameter the same as Table I .2743 mm (0.0108 inch) ThicknessDrop ResistanceAverage 154.18 mm 168.66 mm 203.20 mm (6.07 inches) (6.64 inches) (8 inches) Maximum 177.8 mm 203.2 mm 228.6 mm (7 inches) (8 inches) (9 inches)PI 99002228Minimum 127.0 mm 152.4 mm 1 177.8 mm Buckle Streneth (5 inches) (6 inches) (7 inches) Average 7.02 kg / sq cm 7.00 kg / sq cm 7.00 kg / sq cm (99.8 psi) (98.2 psi) ’ (98.7 psi) Maximum 7.07 kg / sq cm 7.00 kg / sq cm 7.00 kg / sq cm (100.4 psi) (99.5 psi) , (99.5 psi) Minimum 7.00 kg / sq cm 6.87 kg / sq cm 6.86 kg / sq cm (99.2 psi) (97.6 psi) (97.5 psi).26924 mm (0.0106 -inch) ThicknessDrop ResistanceAverage 139.70 mm 154.18 mm ; 185.17 mm (5.50 inches) (6.07 inches) (7.29 inches) Maximum 152.4 mm 177.8 mm 203.2 mm Γ6 inr.hp.c'J Cl inrkoo) / jjjvijvc J ι / 0 luviica) Minimum 127.0 mm 127.0 mm ‘ 152.4 mm Buckle Streneth (5 inches) (5 inches) (6 inches) Average 6.69 kg / sq cm 6.61 kg / sq cm 6.65 kg / sq cm (95.2 psi) (94.0 psi) ; (94.6 psi) Maximum 6.73 kg / sq cm 6.72 kg / sq cm 1 6.74 kg / sq cm (95.7 psi) (95.6 psi) (95.8 psi) Minimum 6.62 kg / sq cm 6.55 kg / sq cm 6.59 kg / sq cm (94.2 psi) (93.7 psi) j (93.7 psi)PI 99002228 .26416 mm (0.0104 inch Thickness)Drop ResistanceAverage 121.67 mm 147.07 mm 161.54 mm (4.79 inches) (5.79 inches) (6.36 inches) 5 Maximum 127.0 mm 177.8 mm 177.8 mm (5 inches) (7 inches) (7 inches) Minimum 101.6 mm 101.6 mm 152.4 mm (4 inches) (4 inches) (6 inches) Buckle Strength 10 Average 6.62 kg / sq cm 6.5 kg / sq cm 6.56 kg / sq cm (94.1 psi) (92.3 psi) (93.3 psi) Maximum 6.74 kg / sq cm 6.57 kg / sq cm 6.60 kg / sq cm (95.9 psi) (93.4 psi) (93.8 psi) Minimum 6.59 kg / sq cm 6.44 kg / sq cm 6.50 kg / sq cm IS / 93.7 nsil / 01 A nc-ΐλ / OO Q nQi'iTable VII - % Change In Drop Resistance and Buckle Strength Over Bottom BBottom C Bottom DMetal Thickness Dron Buckle Dron Buckle .274 mm (0.0108 inch) + 8.6% - 1.6% + 31.8% -I.T% .269 mm (0.0106 inch) + 10.4% - 1.2% + 32.5% -0.6% .264 mm (0.0104 inch) + 20.9% - 1.9% +32.8% -0.8%As can be readily seen, by reducing the dome radius R6to values no greater than 37.47 mm (1.475 inches) results in increased drop resistance. Specifically, reducing the dome radius R6by 1.91 mm (0.075 inches) from 39.37 mm (1.550 inches)ΕξA'-' to 37.47 mm (1.475 inches), while simultaneously increasing the diameter D3of the substantially flat central dome section 26 by 3.56 mm (0.040 inches) from 2.54 mmPl 99002228 (0.10 inches) to about 3.56 mrii (0.14 inches) (bottom C), results in an increase in drop resistance of about 10 to 20% depending on the metal thickness and a reduction in buckle strength of only about 1 to 2%. Further reducing the dome radius R6another .64 mm (0.025 inches) to about 36.83 mm (1.45 inches), while maintaining D3at about 3.56 mm (0.14 inches) and simultaneously increasing the dome height H by . 13 mm (0.005 inches) to about 10.41 mm (0.41 inches) (bottom D) increases the improvement in drop resistance to over 30%.for all three metal thickness without further decreases in buckle strength.In order to confirm these results, 12 ounce 202 cans were made having bottom geometries B and D, as above, as well as geometries E and F, defined generally in Table VIII below, at two different commercial can manufacturing plants from 3004 aluminum having an initial thickness of .269 mm (0.0106 inches).Table VIII - Bottom Geometries - Varying Dome Dimensions - Manufacturing PlantsCan Bottom E Can Bottom F Radius R6 39.37 mm (1.55 in) 38.10 mm (1.50 in) Diameter D3 2.54 mm (0.100 in) 2.79 mm (0.110 in) Height H 10.41 mm (0.41 in) 10.41 mm (0.41 in) Remaining parameters the same as Table ITwelve can were made in each of the four geometries. The results of testing on these cans is shown in Table IX below.Table IX- Comparative Tests Results - Varying Dome DimensionsPlant #1Bottom B Bottom E Bottom F Bottom D Avg. Height H (0.406 in) (0.411 in) (0.410 in) (0.411 in) 10.31 mm 10.44 mm 10.41 mm 10.44 mmPI 99002228Drop Resistance Average (5.5 inches.) (5.3 inches) (6.0 inches) (6.9 inches) 139.7 mm 134.6 mm 152.4 mm 175.3 mm Maximum (6 inches). (6 inches) (7 inches) (8 inches) 152.4 mm 152.4 mm 177.8 mm 203.2 mm Minimum (5 inches) (5 inches) (5 inches) (6 inches) Buckie Strength 127.0 mm 127.0 mm 127.0 mm 152.4 mm Average (96.9 psi) (97.5 psi) (96.2 psi) (96.4 psi) 6.81 kg / sq cm 6.86 kg / sq cm 6.77 kg / sq cm 6.78 kg / sq cm Maximum (97.6 psi) (98.2 psi) (96.0 psi) (97.0 psi) 6.86 kg / sq cm 6.91 kg / sq cm 6.75 kg / sq cm 6.82 kg / sq cm Minimum (96.0 psi) (96.2 psi) (94.5 psi) (96.0 psi) Axial Load 6.75 kg / sq cm 6.77 kg / sq cm 6.65 kg / sq cm 6.75 kg / sq cm Average 97.84 kg 106.78 kg 108.77 kg 94.85 kg (215.7 lbs) (235.4 lbs) (239.8 lbs) (209.1 lbs) Maximum 112.94 kg; 113.40 kg 116.57 kg '· 111.58 kg (249 lbs) (250 lbs) (257 lbs) (246 lbs) Minimum 87.09 kg 87.09 kg 99.79 kg 83.46 kg (192 lbs) (192 lbs) Plant #2 (220 lbs) (184 lbs) Bottom B Bottom E Bottom F Bottom D Avg. Height H 10.29 mm; 10.44 mm 10.44 mm 10.44 mm (0.405 in) (0.411 in) (0.411 in) (0.411 in)Pl 99002228IDroo Resistance Average 160.1 mm (6.3 inches) Maximum 177.8 mm: 5 (7 inches) Minimum 127.0 mm (5 inches) Buckle Strength Average 6.80 kg / sq cm 10 (96.7 psi): Maximum 6.86 kg / sq cin (97.6 psi): Minimum 6.75 kg / sq cm (96.0 psi) 15 Axial Load Average 101.83 kg: (224.5 lbs) Maximum 107.96 kg (238 lbs) 20 Minimum 98.88 kg ' (218 lbs)146.0 mm 162.6 mm 167.6 mm (5.75 inches) (6.4 inches) ; (6.6 inches) 152.4 mm 177.8 mm , 203.2 mm (6 inches) (7 inches) (8 inches) 127.0 mm 152.4 mm 152.4 mm (5 inches) (6 inches) (6 inches) 6.80 kg / sq cm 6.80 kg / sq cm 6.77 kg / sq cm (96.7 psi) ' (96.7 psi) (96.2 psi) 6.86 kg / sq cm 6.88 kg / sq cm 6.81 kg / sq cm (97.6 psi) (97.8 psi) . (96.9 psi) 6.74 kg / sq cm 6.74 kg / sq cm 6.67 kg / sq cm (95.8 psi) (95.9 psi) (94.9 psi) 106.78 kg 105.46 kg 101.42 kg (235.4 lbs) (232.5 lbs) έ (223.6 lbs) 111.13 kg 111.58 kg ' 105.23 kg ’ (245 lbs) (246 lbs) : (232 lbs) 102.97 kg 81.65 kg 94.80 kg (180 lbs) (180 lbs) i (209 lbs)Since plant #1 had been running .274 mm (0.0108 inch) thick metal just prior to the test, it was suspected that the reduction in axial load for bottom geometry D may have been due to insufficient time to stabilize the process. Consequently, a second batch of geometry D cans were run and found to have about the same drop resistance 172.72 mm (6.8 inches average) and buckle strength 6.68 kg / sq cm (95 psi average) but significantly higher axial load 110.68 kg (244 lbs average).PI 99002228 >Γ.As can be seen by comparing the test results for bottom geometry D with those for bottom geometry B, reducing the dome radius R6to 36.83 mm (1.450 inches), along with simultaneously increasing the substantially flat central section diameter D3to 3.56 mm (0.140 inches) and increasing the dome height H to 10.41 (0.410 inches), resulted in a 25.5% increase in drop resistance at plant #1, although only a 4.8% increase at plant #2, with minimal effect on buckle strength (less than 1%). Also, comparing the results for bottom geometry E to bottom geometry B shows that increasing the dome height H without reducing the dome radius R6actually decreases drop resistance.Therefore, according to the current invention, in order to optimize the strength of the bottom of a can, such as a can having a sidewall diameter of about 66 mm (2.6 inches), the radius R6of the dome should be no greater than about 37.47 mm (1.475 inches) and. more preferably, should be about 36.8 mm (1.45 inches. In addition, the diameter D3of the substantially flat central section should be at least about 3.6 mm (0.14 inches), and preferably should equal about 3.56 mm (0.14 inches), and the dome height H should be at least about 10.4 mm (0.41 inches), and preferably ^should be equal to about 10.41 mm (0.41 inches).A preferred apparatus and method for forming the can bottom 6 disclosed above is discussed below.In conventional can forming processes, metal stock is placed into a press in which it is deformed into the shape of a cup. The cup is then conveyed to a wall ironing machine and redrawn into the general shape of the side wall ahd bottom of the finished can. Next, the redrawn cup is passed through ironing stations that eventually form the side wall into the final shape of the finished can. In addition, a bottom forming station is employed to shape the bottom of the can. A can bottom forming station is disclosed in aforementioned U.S. Patent No. 4,685,582 (Pulciani et al.), hereby incorporated by reference.As shown in Figure 6, an apparatus 41 fqr making the can bottom 6 of the current invention comprises (i) a ram 42, (ii) a nose punch 52, discussed further below, (iii) a substantially cylindrical punch sleeve 44 encircling the nose punch, (iv) aPI 99002228 centrally disposed doming die 50 having an upwardly convex forming surface, (v) a support surface 48, (vi) an extractor 46, and (vii) a central retaining bolt 54.In operation, the unformed bottom metal stock is placed over the punch sleeve 44 and nose punch 52. The travel of the ram 42 then moves the punch sleeve 44 and nose punch 52 toward the doming die 50 so that the metal stock is eventually pressed against the doming die forming surface and drawn over the distal surfaces of the punch sleeve and the nose punch, as shown in Figure 6, thereby forming the can bottom 6.As shown in Figure 6, the doming die 50 has a radius of curvature R6' that 10 approximates the radius R6of curvature of the dome section 24. The radius of curvature R6' is displaced from the axial centerline by a distance X that approximates one half the diameter D3of the substantially flat central section 26. Thus, in a preferred embodiment of the invention, the radius of curvature R6' of the doming die 50 should be no greater than about 37.47 mm (1.475 inches), and more preferably about36.8 mm (1.45 inches). In addition, the center of R6' should be displaced'from the axial centerline by at least about 1.8 mm (0.07 inches) and the dome height H should be at least about 10.4 mm (0.41 inches).As shown in Figure 7, according to the current invention, the distal end 61 of the nose punch 52 has (i) a radius of curvature R3' adjacent its inner wall 62, (ii) a radius of curvature R4' adjacent its outer wall 63, and (iii) a diameter D2'. According to the current invention, (i) the radii of curvature R3' and R4' of the nose punch 52 are equal to the radii of curvature R3and R4of the inner surface 29 of the nose 16 of the can bottom 16 discussed above, and (ii) the diameter D2' of the nose punch is equal to the diameter D2of the nose of the can bottom discussed above. Thus, preferably, the radius of curvature R3' of the distal end 61 of the nose punch 52 adjacent its inner wall 62 is greater than 1.5 mm (0.060 inch). Most preferably, (i) the distal end 61 of the nose punch 52 is formed by a sector of a circle so that the radius of curvature R4' adjacent the outer wall 64 is equal to R3', (ii) the radius of curvature R3' is also less than 1.78 mm (0.070 inch), and (iii) the diameter D2' is no greater than 49:0 mm (1.89 inch) when making a can having a size 202 end or smaller.Pl 99002228The present invention may be embodied in other specific forms without departing from the spirit or essential attributes thereof and, accordingly, reference should be made to the appended claims, rather than to the foregoing specification, as indicating the scope of the invention.

Claims

What is claimed:

1. A can comprising: a) a side wall portion (4) having a diameter of about 66mm (2.6 inches); and t , b) a bottom portion (6) formed integrally with said side wall portion, said bottom portion comprising: , i (i) an approximately frustoconical portion (8) extending downwardly arid inwardly from said side wall portion (4); . ; (ii) an annular nose portion (16) extending downwardly from said approximately frustoconical portion (8), (iii) a substantially flat disc-shaped central section (26), and (iv) an annular dome section (24) disposed between said substantially fiat eeniral section and said nose (16), said annular dome section being arcuate in transverse crosssection and downwardly concave, said annular dome section having a radius of curvature no greater than about 37.5 mm (1.475 inches).

2. The can according to claim 1, wherein said radius of curvature of said annular dome section (24) is about 36.8 mm (1.45 inches).

3. The can according to claim 1, wherein said substantially flat disc-shaped central section (26) has a diameter of at least about 3.5mm (0.14 inches).

4. The can according to claim 1, wherein said nose (16) has a base portion (27), and wherein said substantially flat disc-shaped central section (26) is displaced from said nose base portion by a height that is at least about 10.4mm (0.41 inches). PI 990022285. The can according to claim 1, wherein said nose portion (16) is formed by inner and : outer circumferentially extending walls (12, 13) joined by a downwardly convex arcuate portion (18), said arcuate portion having inner and outer surfaces, said inner surface of said arcuate portion having a radius of curvature adjacent said nose inner wall of at least 1.5mm (0.060 inch).

6. The can according to claim 5, wherein said radius of curvature of said inner surface of said arcuate portion (18) of said nose (16) is no greater than about 1.8mm (0.070 inch).

7. The can according to claim 5, wherein said radius of curvature of said inner surface of said arcuate portion (18) of said nose (16) is about 1.5 mm (0.060 inch);8. The can according to claim 5, wherein said radius of curvature of said inner surface of said areuate portion (18) of said nose (16) is about 1.65mm (0.065 inch).

9. The can according to claim 5, wherein said radius of curvature of said inner surface of said arcuate portion (18) of said nose (16) is about 1.8 mm (0.070 inch).

10. The can according to claim 5, wherein in transverse cross-section said arcuate portion of said nose (16) is a sector of a circle.

11. The can according to claim 1, wherein said side wall (4) and bottom (6) portions are formed of aluminum.

12. The can according to claim 1, wherein said aluminum forming said nose (16) has a thickness, said thickness being less than 0.28 mm (0.011 inch).

13. A can (1) comprising: PI 99002228 a) a side wall portion (4) having a diameter of about 66mm (2.6 inches); and b) a bottom portion (6) formed integrally with said side wall portion, said bottom portion comprising: (i) an approximately frustoconical portion (8) extending downwardly and inwardly from said side wall portion (4); (ii) an annular nose portion (16) extending downwardly from said approximately 10 frustoconical portion (8) and fonning inner and outer walls (12,13) , , (iii) a substantially fiat disc-shaped central section (26) having a diameter of at least about 3.5 mm (0.14 inches), and ,15 (iv) an annular section (24) connecting said substantially flat central section (26) to said inner wall (12) of said nose (16), said annular section being arcuate in transverse crosssection and downwardly concave, said annular section having a radius of curvature no greater than about 37.5mm (1.475 inches). 20 14. The can according to claim 13, wherein said radius of curvature of said annular section (24) has a radius of curvature of about 36.8 (1.45 inches).

15. The can according to claim 13, wherein said substantially flat disc-shaped central section (26) has a diameter of 3.5mm (0.139 inches). , 25 '16. The can according to claim 13, wherein said nose (16) has a base portion (27), and wherein said substantially flat disc-shaped central section (26) is displaced from said nose base by a height that is at least about 10.4mm (0.41 inches). 3017. The can according to claim 13, wherein said nose portion (16) is formed by inner and outer circumferentially extending walls (12,13) joined by a downwardly convex PI 99002228 arcuate portion, said arcuate portion (18) having inner and outer surfaces, said inner surface of said arcuate portion having a radius of curvature adjacent said nose inner wall of at least 1.5mm (0.060 inch). I 5 18. The can according to claim 17, wherein said radius of curvature of said inner surface of said arcuate portion (18) of said nose (16) is no greater than about 1,8mm (0.070 inch).

19. The can according to claim 17, wherein said radius of curvature of said inner surface 10 of said arcuate portion (18) of said nose (16) is about 1.5mm (0.060 inch).