Method for recovering protein meal from black soldier fly
Patent Information
- Application Number
- MYPI2025002968
- Authority / Receiving Office
- MY · MY
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2022-12-09
- Filing Date
- 2023-12-08
- Publication Date
- 2024-06-09
AI Technical Summary
Current methods for recovering protein from Black Soldier Fly larvae are inefficient, time-consuming, and costly, with low purity of protein and fat fractions, and high non-proteinaceous nitrogen content, making them unsuitable for animal feed and other applications.
A method involving mechanical processing steps such as pressing, filtration, heating, and drying to separate protein and fat fractions from Black Soldier Fly larvae, achieving high protein yield and purity with reduced non-proteinaceous nitrogen and fat content, using solely mechanical and heating processes without additional solvents.
The method achieves up to 90% total protein extraction with high purity and low non-proteinaceous nitrogen content, producing a high-quality protein meal suitable for animal feed, while being cost-effective and environmentally friendly.
Smart Images

Figure PI2025002968_DRAWING_001
Abstract
Description
[0001] Method for recovering protein meal from Black Soldier Fly
[0002] Field of the Invention
[0003] The present invention relates to methods for processing Black Soldier Fly (BSF) larvae to recover protein.
[0004] Background
[0005] The United Nations predicts that the world's population will grow more than 2 billion people annually. Due to the rapid population growth and economic growth, the demand for food and especially protein will also increase. Protein is typically obtained from livestock such as chicken and beef. Livestock farming is associated with a number of problems including: 1) difficulty in upscaling to meet global food needs as it requires a large area of land; 2) dependency on a stabile climate which is increasingly unpredictable and unstable; and 3) air and soil pollution due to livestock excretion, which is difficult or expensive to manage and will result in excessive methane and carbon dioxide emissions and a decrease in soil quality. Apart from livestock, other sources of protein include the fish industry producing fish, crabs, and shrimps. However, the increasing water pollution leads to the contamination of these sources. Hence, better or alternative protein sources is desired.
[0006] Even when producing the above animal protein sources, there is also a need for providing a protein rich feed for the animal in order to have efficient production. For example, the feed used in fish farming is associated with a number of problems. In general, the conventional feed utilized in fish farming comes from fish sources, i.e., fish meal. This is problematic as this practice might increase the risk of heavy metal contamination from industrial wastes that are not properlytreated. This then leads to a higher risk of fish-based feeds for the health and growth of fish that is to be cultivated. Moreover, other creatures that feed on those fish are also at risk due to the possible transmission of disease or accumulated contamination from one fish to another. Due to these problems, better or alternative protein sources are needed to aid in filling the rapidly growing global food needs. Hence, a good source protein for use in animal feed is needed.
[0007] In the development of alternative protein sources, it is ideal if the alternative protein sources can be grown effectively with a limited amount of land, do not have a negative or limited impact on the environment, and possess a good nutritional content. Insect-based proteins are a promising alternative protein source. Several studies have been conducted regarding the utilization of insects as a substitute for feed of livestock. These insects include beetles, crickets, and caterpillars. Research on insectbased feeds has been carried out on several animals, such as cattle, chicken, and fish. This has highlighted both advantages and drawbacks in the utilization of insects in feeds. However, it is known that insects are very potential as an alternative for feed ingredients as the breeding of insects can be carried out on relatively small areas and they produce very low greenhouse gas emissions. A type of insect that are of focus of the present invention are the larvae and adult flies of Black Soldier Fly (BSF).
[0008] Cultivation of the Black Soldier Fly has several advantages when compared to the cultivation of other insects such as silkworms that require more land, specific feeds and water for its rearing. On the other hand, Black Soldier Flies do not require a specific feed and has a short life span. This short life span enables the larvae to be harvested in less than a month of rearing period. Moreover, the rearing of Black Soldier Fly does not require a very large area as it can be reared vertically so that insect production can be obtained more effectively and efficiently per square meter. Additionally, when compared to other animals, insect rearing is more environmentally friendly as insects do not produce high amounts of carbon and methane emissions. Another advantage of the utilization of BSF is that in the adult phase, BSF does not feed, rely merely on the fat stored in the larval stage, and it has a short life span, so they do not tend to spread diseases. Moreover, in the larval stage, BSF has a high feed conversion ratio. Black Soldier Fly also possesses a good protein and fat content. For example, BSF contains a complete amino acid, both essential and non-essential ones.
[0009] A possible application of BSF-based feed is in fish farming. Feed is a very crucial element, both for fish physiology and water quality in aquaculture ponds. Feed plays an important role in regulating metabolic activity, movement, body maintenance, and support the growth and survival rate of fish. The essential components of fish feed include protein, fat, carbohydrates, vitamins and minerals. However, whole BSF larvae have certain drawbacks if utilized for feed as they are. First, indigestible chitin is present in the skin of BSF in a significant portion. It has been found that feed from whole BSF larvae had a lower digestibility when compared to conventional fish feed which is partly due to the presence of chitin in the whole BSF larvae. Secondly, whole BSF larvae or adult BSF flies contain a high amount of non-proteinaceous nitrogen, due to the presence of chitin. Other causes for high non-proteinaceous nitrogen are feed remnants or nitrogen contamination during the rearing process of BSF. Non- proteinaceous nitrogen is all nitrogen components that are not protein but are still quantified when measuring crude protein according to the typical measurement methods, such as the Kjeldahl method. When measuring crude protein, all nitrogen content, including the non-proteinaceous nitrogen, is measured. As both protein and non-proteinaceous nitrogen are quantified in crude protein analysis, the crude protein value tends to be higher than the actual protein value. Generally, a protein source with amino acid content with levels of at least 80% of the total crude protein is desired in animal feeds. This is desired as the presence of non-proteinaceous nitrogen may hinder digestibility of the protein and has no role in growth. The chitin present in BSF skin is one of the non-proteinaceous nitrogen sources that is included in the crude protein measurement. Other sources of non-proteinaceous nitrogen can come from ammonia, residual excretion from the digestive tract of larvae, and others.
[0010] A further issue associated with using whole BSF larvae as feed is the relatively large fat content above the levels recommended in the manufacture of feed in general. Fish generally require feed with a true protein content above 40% and a fat content of less than 15%. However, the whole BSF larvae may typically have a fat content of more than 30%. Due to its high fat content, whole BSF larvae cannot be utilized as the main ingredient in feed formulation. Hence, it is desirable to process the BSF larvae or flies to recover protein, fat and chitin fractions, preferably at sufficient purity and cost-efficiently. EP2863762A1 discloses a method for obtaining protein, fat and solid fractions from insects or worms by enzymatic hydrolysis, specifically by squashing the BSF larvae in a micro-cutter mill, hydrolyzing the resulting pulp and separating the hydrolysis mixture into a fat fraction, and aqueous protein fraction (hydrolysate) and a solid fraction. While enzymatic hydrolysis is one method by which protein can be extracted from BSF larvae, it is also time-consuming to treat the entire larvae material enzymatically, may require costly enzymes, and may requires energy to maintaining the hydrolysis mixture at the reaction temperature during the treatment. Hence, there is a need for an alternative process for recovering protein from BSF Larvae, which is more efficient.
[0011] In addition, there is also a need to increase the purity of both protein-containing and fat-containing fractions. For example, the purity of the fat fraction obtained in EP2863762A1 is still relatively low as it contains not more than 85% fat content and 15% impurities from protein, minerals, or carbohydrates. These impurities may cause the fat to be difficult to process directly for the manufacture of derivative products in the fields of feed, cosmetics, and pharmaceutical.
[0012] WO2021 / 123077A1 discloses another method for recovering protein from insect larvae, using mechanical means, where the larvae are crushed and separated into a solid phase which is dried to a protein product and liquid phase which liquid phase is further separated into a lipid and aqueous phase. Such mechanical processing is efficient, but there remains a need to increase the purity of the obtained fractions and improve the yield.
[0013] Hence, there is need for improved or alternative methods for recovering protein, fat and / or chitin fractions from BSF.
[0014] Summary of the Invention
[0015] In view of these objectives, a first aspect of the present invention provides a method for processing Black Soldier Fly (Hermetic / illucens, abbreviated BSF) larvae and / or flies to recover protein, which method comprises the steps of: a) pressing fresh BSF larvae and / or BSF flies to obtain a pulp, b) filtrating the pulp to provide a filtrate and a residual portion, which filtrate comprises liquid and solid matter, c) adding water to the filtrate to provide a water mixture and heating to a holding temperature of at least 60 °C, preferably at least 95°C, d) separating the water mixture to obtain a solid phase and a liquid phase, and e) drying the solid phase to obtain a first protein meal.
[0016] The first protein meal obtained in this way is a protein-rich solid material extracted from the inner guts of BSF larvae and / or adult flies through a mechanical process. The pressing in step a) provides a liquid portion or "extract" which comprises both solid and liquid matter which is separated from the residual portion as the filtrate in step b). The residual portion is a chitin-rich fraction which comprises the skin of the larvae and / or adult flies. In step c) the filtrate is mixed with water and heated, and it has been found that this step allows for more solid matter to be recovered in the following separation in step d), improving the yield of first protein meal. It also increases the purity of first protein meal as a greater portion of fat is separated in step d). This also allows for a simple separation of the solid from the mixture, for example by decantation. These results may be achieved even with a short treatment time in step c), such as less than 1 hour. Recovering first protein meal in this way may have several advantages: (a) the extraction process employed are solely heating and mechanical processes, providing a high production rate at low cost; (b) the mechanical extraction process is highly efficient as it can extract up to 90% total protein from the inner guts of BSF larvae and adult flies; (c) the first protein meal contains all essential and non-essential amino acids; and (d) only water needs to be added and hence there is zero possibility of residual solvent contamination as no additional solvent is utilized in the extraction process of BSF protein meal. The first protein meal acquires increased protein content with sufficiently low content of non-proteinaceous nitrogen as well as low fat content when compared to whole BSF. The first protein meal is typically not entirely pure protein, but it is sufficiently purified. Hence allowing it to be used as a protein feed. Therefore, the method provides the desired level of quality product in an efficient and inexpensive manner. This is highly desirable in the context of protein meals for animal feed, which is a relatively low cost, but high-volume product, where efficient production is crucial. In some embodiments of the invention which are described in greater detail below, further protein products and by-products are obtained from the raw material, to extract additional value from the raw material.
[0017] Additionally, the method may provide valuable by-products which can be further utilized for various applications, as will be described in greater detail below.
[0018] The term "fresh" BSF larvae or flies refers to larvae or flies which are not dried.
[0019] The BSF larvae or flies used in the invention are preferably alive.
[0020] The BSF larvae or flies are whole BSF larvae or flies, meaning that they have not been comminuted. Comminuting the BSF larvae or flies will increase the amount chitin-rich skin portion in the filtrate as the comminuted skin difficult to keep in the residual fraction in the separation step. Hence, the pressing of the whole larvae provides a filtrate with less chitinous skin material, compared to for example grinding or blending the material prior to solid-liquid separation.
[0021] In some embodiments, the method further comprises steps of: c2) adding water to the solid phase obtained from step d) to provide a further water mixture and heating to a holding temperature of at least 60 °C, preferably at least 95 °C, d2) separating the further water mixture to obtain a further solid phase and a further liquid phase, and in step e) drying the further solid phase to obtain the first protein meal.
[0022] By subjecting the solid phase from step d) to a further heat-treatment with water in step c2), which is comparable to the treatment in step c), the lipid content of the further solid phase from step d2) may be further reduced, providing a more pure first protein meal. BSF, larvae especially, can have a high lipid content, sometimes more than 30 % by weight, making this second heat-treatment with water suited for this feed. This reduction in lipid content may be achieved while still providing a high quality protein meal. The quality of the protein meal can be evaluated by its pepsin digestibility, e.g. as measured by the modified Torry Method, or non-proteinaceous nitrogen-content. The pepsin digestibility of the first protein meal may even be improved by the steps c2) and d2).
[0023] In the following, steps c) and d) is sometimes referred to as a first cycle of heat treatment with water and steps c2) and d2) as a second cycle of heat treatment with water. When describing embodiments having the second cycle, the nomenclature: steps c) and d) is used to refer the first cycle, but the nomenclature: steps cl) and dl) respectively could be adopted.
[0024] In some embodiments, the method further comprises the steps of: f) separating the liquid phase obtained in step d) in a tricanter to obtain a second solid phase, a lipid phase and an aqueous phase, and drying the second solid phase to obtain a second protein meal. Drying the second solid phase may comprise combining it with the solid phase obtained in step d) and drying the mixture of solid phase and second solid phase together in step e) to provide a combined protein meal, comprising the first and second protein meal. Alternatively, the solid phase and second solid phase are dried separately to provide the first and second protein meals separately. The first and second protein meals may then be combined to provide the combined protein meal. Further processing the liquid phase obtained in step d) using a tricanter provides an additional protein meal product, which has substantially the same composition as the first protein meal. In addition, a lipid phase having a high fat purity is obtained, which can be used a raw material in other products.
[0025] In some embodiments, soluble protein in the aqueous phase obtained in step f) is recovered to obtain a third protein product. Recovering the soluble protein may be achieved by drying the aqueous phase.
[0026] In some embodiments, steps a) and b) are performed as one step in a pressing apparatus, such as a screw-press. In such embodiments the larvae and / or flies are pressed against a screen to provide the pulp which is then separated into the residual portion and filtrate at the same time. This is both efficient and provides a mild pressing and separation which reduces the amount of skin material in the filtrate and thus in the first and second protein meal. In a further development, the pressing apparatus used in steps a) and b) is a screw press with a single screw and a screen having openings, wherein the smallest of dimension of the opening is in the range 0.5 to 2 mm, preferably 0.5 to 1.5 mm even more preferably 0.8 to 1.2 mm. Such screw press and size has been found to be effective in retaining the skin material in the residual portion and provide a filtrate which is rich in protein and fat, and has a low content of chitin. It also provides a filtrate containing solid matter, which can then be separated out as the solid phase (first protein meal) by decantation.
[0027] In some embodiments, the separation in step d) is a decantation. The combination of the pressing step a) providing a filtrate with solid and liquid matter which is heat-treated in step c) provides a mixture from which solid protein matter may efficiently be separated by decantation.
[0028] In some embodiments, the drying in step e) and / or step f) is microwave drying. Using microwaves for drying provides a fast drying which is beneficial in terms of preventing oxidation and stopping enzymatic processes. Microwave drying may be achieved with a microwave intensity a range of 0.2-0.8 kW / kg for 1 to 4 hours, preferably 2-3 hours.
[0029] In an alternative embodiment, the drying steps of the invention is carried out at temperature of at least 60 °C. The target moisture content is below 10%, irrespective of the drying method used.
[0030] In some embodiments, the method further comprises the steps of: g) hydrolyzing the residual portion obtained in step b) by adding an alkali solution to obtain a hydrolyzed protein solution and residual solid portion, h) precipitating protein from the hydrolyzed protein solution and separating the principate to obtain a protein hydrolysate product.
[0031] By hydrolyzing the residual portion, the protein yield of the method is increased. Hence, efficient mechanical processing is used to recover a majority of protein from the filtrate, providing the first protein, second protein and possibly combined protein meal which has been sufficiently purified to serve as for example animal feed, whereas chemical extraction, specifically alkaline extraction, is only used for the protein left in the residual portion, where hydrolysis is needed. In this way, the raw material is efficiently processed. Prior to precipitation in step h), the hydrolyzed protein solution is separated from the residual solid portion, for example by filtration.
[0032] The protein hydrolysate is a low molecular weight protein-rich solid material extracted from the skins of BSF larvae and adult flies through alkali processing and protein precipitation, such as isoelectric precipitation. The protein hydrolysate in this invention also acquires various superiorities, mainly: the protein hydrolysate contains more than 85% true protein content with all essential and non-essential amino acids present; the protein hydrolysate is a low molecular weight protein which may contain various bioactive compounds due to the presence of peptides; and the protein hydrolysate do not contain any chitinous material as protein hydrolysate is obtained through precipitation.
[0033] In some embodiments, the alkali solution is a dilute alkali solution, having a concentration of 0.1 to 0.5 M of an alkali such as sodium hydroxide, potassium hydroxide, or a combination thereof.
[0034] In some embodiments, wherein step h) is isoelectric precipitation and comprises adjusting the pH of the hydrolyzed protein solution to 4 to 5.5, preferably by addition of a weak acid, such as acetic acid. In some embodiments, the solid residual portion obtained in step g), is further processed to obtain chitin or chitosan.
[0035] The protein hydrolysate precipitated in step h) may be referred to as "first protein hydrolysate" as a remaining protein liquid from which the first protein hydrolysate is precipitated, may contain residual protein. In some embodiments, residual protein in the protein liquid from which the first protein hydrolysate is precipitated, is recovered by drying to provide a second protein hydrolysate. This drying may for example be lyophilization or spray drying. The protein liquid may also be referred to as the "mother liquor" or the "supernatant".
[0036] In some embodiments, step c) comprises holding the water mixture at the holding temperature for at least 30 minutes. Preferably the water mixture is held at the holding temperature for 30 to 60 minutes, even more preferably 45 to 60 minutes. This time is referred to as a the holding time. As will be described below, when step c) is part of the first cycle of heat-treatment followed by the second cycle, the holding time in step c) can be shorter than described above.
[0037] In some embodiments, the holding temperature is preferably in the range of 60 to 95 °C, even more preferably 80 to 95 °C.
[0038] In some embodiments, wherein step c) comprises adding water in a ratio of water volume to liquid portion (i.e. filtrate) volume of 1:5 to 2:1, or 1:4 to 2:3.
[0039] In some embodiments, steps c) and d) are repeated, by adding water to the solid phase obtained in step d) to repeat step c) and then separating as in step d), for example by decantation. This may further increase the purity of the first protein meal. The repeated step c) is described above as step c2) while the repeated step d) is described as step d2) and referred to as the second cycle heat-treatment. Holding temperatures discussed above in relation to the step c) also apply to the step c2). Although, term "holding temperature" is used for the temperature in both steps c) and c2), it is understood that the holding temperature in the two steps are not necessarily the same. Similarly, the ratio of water volume added to the solid phase weight may be in the range of 1:5 to 2:1, or 1:4 to 2:3. In some embodiments comprising steps c2) and d2) (i.e. the second cycle heat-treatment, step c) comprises holding the water mixture at the holding temperature for at least 5 minutes, at least 10 minutes or at least 20 minutes, and step c2) comprises holding the further water mixture at the holding temperature for at least at least 5 minutes, at least 10 minutes or at least 20 minutes.
[0040] When using the heat-treatment is repeated in the second cycle, shorter holding times in each cycle can be used compared to a single-cycle embodiment. The combined holding times of the first and second cycle, may be less than 60 minutes. The holding time of each of the first and second cycles, may be less than 30 minutes.
[0041] In some embodiments, the method further comprises a pre-treatment step of the fresh BSF larvae and / or adult flies.
[0042] In some embodiments the pre-treatment is a holding step, wherein the fresh larvae are held in a vessel for a pre-determined time prior to pressing in step a). The pre-determined time may be at least 0.5 day, such as 0.5 to 3 days, preferably 1 to 2 days. During the holding step the larvae will empty their bowels, resulting in more pure protein products. The pre-determined time in the vessel may be evaluated as the time during which the larvae do not have access to feed, hence a time spent in a rearing vessel in which the larvae were reared, is not a holding step according to the invention. After the holding step and prior to step a), the larvae may be rinsed with water.
[0043] Alternatively or additionally, the pre-treatment step may comprise a cooling step where the fresh larvae are cooled. This provides docile larvae which may reduce detrimental stress-related effects on the protein products.
[0044] Hence, the fresh larvae of step a) may have a temperature which is less than 10 °C, preferably less than 8 °C, such as in the range 1 to 10 °C or 2 to 8 °C and even more preferably 4 to 6 °C or 5°C.
[0045] In a preferred embodiment of the invention, there is provided a method for processing Black Soldier Fly (Hermetic / illucens, abbreviated BSF) larvae and / or flies to recover protein, which method comprises the steps of: a) pressing fresh, preferably live, BSF larvae and / or BSF flies to obtain a pulp, b) filtrating the pulp to provide a filtrate and a residual portion, which filtrate comprises liquid and solid matter, c) adding water to the filtrate to provide a water mixture and heating to a holding temperature of at least 60 °C, preferably at least 95°C, for at least 30 minutes, d) separating the water mixture by decantation to obtain a solid phase and a liquid phase, e) drying the solid phase to obtain a first protein meal, f) separating the liquid phase obtained in step d) in a tricanter to obtain a second solid phase, a lipid phase and an aqueous phase, drying the second solid phase to obtain a second protein meal, and drying the aqueous phase obtained in step to obtain a third protein product, g) hydrolyzing the residual portion obtained in step b) by adding an alkali solution to obtain a hydrolyzed protein solution, and h) precipitating protein from the hydrolyzed protein solution and separating the principate to obtain a protein hydrolysate product, wherein steps a) and b) are performed as one step in a screw-press, which screw press has a single screw and a screen having openings, wherein the smallest dimension of each of the openings is in the range 0.5 to 2 mm, preferably 0.5 to 1.5 mm even more preferably 0.8 to 1.2 mm, most preferably 1 mm.
[0046] As previously disclosed, steps a) and b) are preferably performed as a single step. Moreover, step c) preferably follows directly from step b) (or combined steps a) and b)). Step d) preferably follows step c) directly. Step f) preferably follows step d) directly. The term "follows directly" as used herein means that portion obtained in one step is further processed in a second step without intermediate processing.
[0047] The first protein meal, second protein meal and combined protein produced according to methods disclosed herein may have a non-proteinaceous nitrogen content of less than 10% and a fat content of less than 32% from the total dry weight of the protein meal. Non-proteinaceous nitrogen content is obtained by comparing the total amino acid content with crude protein content of the protein meal.
[0048] Citric acid and / or other weak acid at a concentration of at least 3% may be added to the first protein meal, second protein meal or combined protein meal prior to drying in an amount ofleast 300 mL per kg of protein meal to inhibit the oxidation process of protein meal prior to drying process.
[0049] As will be appreciated from the above disclosure, the present invention provides a protein rich material, namely the first protein meal and possibly the second protein meal, which are sufficiently free from chitinous material and have a low non- proteinaceous nitrogen content, a low-fat content and a high true protein content. The present invention also efficiently collects non-proteinaceous nitrogen in soluble protein, along with minerals and low molecular weight protein, thereby keeping sources of non-proteinaceous nitrogen content out of the first and second protein meals. The high nitrogen content and mineral content in the soluble protein renders it suitable as supplemental ingredient in feed and fertilizer. In the present invention, the skins of BSF larvae and / or adult flies are separated from rest of the larvae and / or flies, which may be called the "extract", using the pressing step, prior to recovering protein as protein extraction from the skin of BSF larvae and adult flies through mechanical separation process is not efficient but requires hydrolysis treatment to recover protein trapped in the chitinous matrix. The pressing step and subsequent separation step also provide a residual portion which is rich in chitinous material and can be processed separately, while the extract (filtrate) is processed mechanically to efficiently recover protein. The protein extraction from the liquid extract (filtrate) of BSF larvae and adult flies can be efficiently conducted by mechanical separation with a total protein yield of up to 60% of the protein in the raw material (larvae and / or flies). In this way, the majority of the protein is recovered by efficient mechanical separation, and is not purified beyond what is needed, while the remaining portion left in the skin (residual portion) can be extracted by hydrolysis.
[0050] There are several advantages of this invention: the separation process can be carried out on both BSF larvae and adult flies; the protein meal has significantly reduced non-proteinaceous nitrogen content and is free of chitinous material, and is thus suitable for use as an animal feed; and the protein hydrolysate does not contain residual chitinous material. The protein meal and protein hydrolysate acquire low non-proteinaceous nitrogen content. The residual portion from which protein hydrolysate is extracted may be further processed effectively and efficiently into chitin and chitosan as partial deproteinization process has been conducted. Such chitosan can then be utilized as additives for the protein meal to further increase protein digestibility. Fat is removed from the filtrate in the present invention to provide a protein meal with reduced fat content compared to the whole larvae, which is desirable in for example animal feeds as it does not match the recommended nutritional need. The lipid phase obtained by the fat separation from protein is also an advantageous byproduct with a purity level above 94%, which can be applied in various fields such as cosmetics, pharmaceuticals and others. The residual liquor following protein meal and lipid extraction is efficiently collected as soluble protein together with non- proteinaceous nitrogen sources and minerals. Such soluble protein can then be used as additives in feed ingredients or fertilizer.
[0051] These and other features of the present invention will be better understood from the following detailed description along with detailed figures of the present invention.
[0052] Throughout this document, the terms "illustrates", "discloses", "demonstrates", "displays", "shows", "comprising" or "comprises" do not exclude other possible steps, process, and / or elements. Additionally, the use of "a" or "an" herein in the disclosed invention should not be interpreted as excluding any plurality.
[0053] Brief Description of the drawings
[0054] In the following, embodiments of the invention will be described with reference to the schematic drawings in which Figure 1 shows a flow diagram of a method for processing Black Soldier Fly larvae and / or adult flies according to the invention. Detailed Description
[0055] An embodiment of the present invention shown in Fig 1, where a raw material 1 comprising Black Soldier Fly larvae and / or adult flies is processed into combined protein meal 10, soluble protein 11, first protein hydrolysate 16, second protein hydrolysate 17, residual solid portion 15 and lipid phase 8. The BSF larvae 1 used as raw material have at least undergone 5thinstar stage on the 13th day of rearing. The freshly harvested BSF larvae are naturally allowed to settle, in a pre-treatment holding step (not shown) before being processed with the aim of separating feed remains and excrements from the BSF larvae. Adult flies 1 that are utilized for protein extraction are fresh imagoes that are collected and cleaned from dirt or other possible contamination.
[0056] Initially, the BSF larvae or adult flies are subjected to a combined pressing and separation step (steps a) and b)) 100, providing filtrate 2 and residual portion 13. The pressing and separation process 100 are performed in a screw press which provides filtrate with a low content of chitinous material, e.g., skin. More generally, suitable screw presses are of the single-screw type wherein an axially extending screw rotates within a cylindrical screen, where feed material is supplied at one axial end and the rotation of the screw transports feed material axially and gradually presses the feed material against the screen, thereby yielding the filtrate and residual portion. The screen has openings having a smallest dimension, which preferably have a smallest dimension of about 0.8 to 1.2 mm, preferably about 1mm. The screen may be a cylindrical plate with holes, a mesh or a plurality of bars spaced apart and arranged cylindrically and defining openings in between the bars. As is understood by the skilled practitioner the relevant dimensions, in the context of the "smallest dimension" of the openings, are those dimension that define the available open area through which the filtrate flows and not for example the depth of the screen. The openings typically have a circular in which case the smallest dimension is the diameter or rectangular shape in which case the smallest dimension is the smallest among the rectangular sides. When pressing and separating the BSF larvae and / or flies in such a screw press, a tension setting of the screw press may be in the range of 1 to 2 tons.
[0057] Returning to the embodiment shown in Fig. 1, the residual portion 13 is then further processed by alkaline hydrolysis 600 (steps g) and h) according to invention) to obtain first protein hydrolysate 16, second protein hydrolysate 17 and residual solid portion 15, which may be further processed to obtain chitin or chitosan (not shown). To begin the protein hydrolysate extraction process, dilute alkali (not shown) is added to the residual portion 13. Alkali treatment is carried out using dilute alkali with a concentration of 0.1 to 0.5M for about 0.5 to 2 hours, preferably about 1 hour. Afterwards, the hydrolyzed protein solution 14 is separated from the residual solid portion 15, and the hydrolyzed protein solution 14 subjected to a protein precipitation process by pH adjustment to pH 4-5.5 by adding weak acid. The precipitated soluble protein is then separated from the protein liquid and collected as the first protein hydrolysate 16. The remaining protein liquid, which may also be referred to as the supernatant or mother liquor, is dried (e.g., lyophilization, spray drying) and collected as the second protein hydrolysate 17. The first protein hydrolysate may then be dried e.g. by lyophilization. Prior to protein hydrolysis, the residual portion 15 may be washed with warm water and dried.
[0058] Returning to the filtrate 2 obtained from the pressing step 100, which is further processed to recover protein, initially in step c), indicated by reference 200, where water is added to the filtrate and the mixture is heated and held for at least 30 minutes. This may be implemented in suitable vessel with a means of heating, e.g. a heating jacket. Means of agitating the contents of the vessel may be used. The resulting water mixture 3 is then separated by decantation 300 (step d)) to provide solid phase 4 and liquid phase 5.
[0059] In this embodiment the solid phase 4 and liquid phase 5 are separated using a decanter 300. The solid phase 4 is dried (not shown) to provide a first protein meal 9. Optionally, as indicated by the dashed line, solid portion 4 or part thereof may be subjected to an additional treatment by water and heat 200 and separation 300. In such an embodiment, the first treatment with water and heat is referred to as the first cycle, and the additional treatment with water and heat is referred to as the second cycle. It is understood that while Fig. 1 may show the solid phase 4 being returned to step c), the second cycle can in practice be implemented in a separate vessel (not shown) where the solid phase 4 is mixed with waterto provide a further water mixture which is then heated and held for at least 5, at least 10 or at least 20 minutes. In these embodiments having the second cycle, the first cycle also comprising holding the water mixture at the holding temperature for at least 5, at least 10 or at least 20 minutes. The combined holding time of the first and second cycle is preferably kept below 60 minutes. The further water mixture is then separated, for example by a decanter, suitably a decanter centrifuge, to provide a further liquid phase and a further solid phase (not shown). This further solid phase from the second cycle heat treatment (instead of the solid phase 4 from the first cycle), is then dried to provide the first protein meal 9.
[0060] The liquid phase 5 from the decantation process 300 is in this embodiment separated into three phases: a second solid phase 6, lipid phase 8, and aqueous phase 7 using a tricanter 500. In embodiments comprising the second cycle heat treatment as described above, the further liquid phase from the second cycle can be combined with the liquid phase 5 from the first cycle. The second solid phase 6 is dried (not shown) to provide a second protein meal which is combined with the first protein meal 9 to obtain a combined protein meal 10. The aqueous phase 7 is collected and soluble protein 11 is recovered, e.g., by drying (not shown).
[0061] As exemplified by the embodiment of Fig. 1, the invention provides an efficient method for recovering protein from BSF larvae / flies, where a majority of the protein is recovered by efficient mechanical processes in the combined protein meal, which has a composition which is suitable for use as an animal feed. In addition, protein which cannot be recovered mechanically, is extracted by alkaline hydrolysis.
[0062] The combined protein meal obtained through the process is a protein meal with a non-proteinaceous nitrogen content of less than 10% and a fat content of less than 32% of the total dry weight of the protein meal. Non-proteinaceous nitrogen content is evaluated by comparing the total amino acid content with crude protein content of protein meal.
[0063] The drying steps may be carried out at an elevated temperature of at least 60 °C, or may utilize other drying processes such as spray drying and freeze drying. Generally, a fast drying process is desired, as it reduces the risk of oxidation. Microwave drying is therefore advantageous. Oxidation of BSF protein meal is characterized by an unpleasant odor and potential growth of mold during storage which can reduce the quality of the product.
[0064] The lipid phase obtained from the tricanter machine may have a lipid purity of at least 94 % and may be further purified with a polishing process. The purity of the lipid phase is evaluated by the water and protein content.
[0065] The aqueous phase obtained from the tricanter can be used directly in the aqueous form containing soluble protein, high nitrogen content, and high mineral content. Alternatively, it can also be processed further to concentrate the solution by partial drying or to obtain its powder form by freeze-drying or spray-drying. One specific application of the aqueous phase is as supplemental fertilizer or additional ingredient in feed manufacture. Features and advantages of the present invention is now illustrated by way of the following non-limiting examples.
[0066] When describing the composition of various portions throughout this application, any values disclosed were obtained by or refer to values obtainable by the following methods, unless otherwise specified:
[0067] Crude protein: SNI 01-2891-1992
[0068] Total fat: SNI 01-2891-1992
[0069] Total mineral: SNI 01-2891-1992
[0070] Total carbohydrate: by-difference method (portion which is not fat, mineral or crude protein),
[0071] Amino acid content: Acquity UPLC H-Class and H-Class bio amino acid analysis by Waters (2012). L-tryptophan may be evaluated using a method in AOAC 988.15 (2005).
[0072] Fatty acid composition: AOCS Ce 2-66 (1993)
[0073] EXAMPLE I
[0074] This example demonstrates the levels of protein, fat, minerals and carbohydrates as well as the levels of amino acids contained in BSF larvae and flies based on its dry weight. BSF larvae utilized in this embodiment is the fifth instar larva or larvae that has been reared for 13 days. The adult fly that is utilized in this embodiment is the dead Black Soldier Fly. The samples were analyzed with respect to crude protein, total fat, total mineral, total carbohydrate and amino acid content, and the results are shown in Table I. Based on the measured crude protein content and the measure of total amino acid, the non-proteinaceous nitrogen value in BSF larvae is 42.02% and in BSF flies is 48.97%. The non-proteinaceous nitrogen value is calculated as follows:
[0075] Non — proteinaceous nitrogen %
[0076] % crude protein — % total amino acid
[0077] = -:- x 100%
[0078] % crude protein
[0079] Table I
[0080] EXAMPLE II
[0081] This example shows the resulting residual portion from the pressing and separation BSF larvae and adult flies, which is called "BSF Larvae Skin" and BSF Adult Flies Skin". The pressing and separation were performed in a screw press. The residual portion was then washed with warm water, dried thermally, and packaged. The dried BSF skin samples thus obtained were then analyzed for their protein content, fat content, total mineral content, carbohydrate content, as well as their amino acid composition and the results are shown in Table II. Based on the calculation of non-proteinaceous nitrogen and total amino acid, it is found that non-proteinaceous nitrogen in the skin of BSF larvae is 9.84%, while the non-proteinaceous nitrogen in the skin of adult flies is 26.33%.
[0082] Table II
[0083] EXAMPLE III
[0084] This example shows the results of recovering protein meal from the filtrate of the pressing and separation step. The filtrate recovered from the BSF larvae or adult flies are substantially free of chitinous material as chitinous material can solely be found in the skin part of the BSF larvae or adult flies, which have been separated prior to protein meal recovery. The filtrates obtained from the separation of BSF larvae or adult flies with a screw press machine was added with water at a volume of 30% (v / v) of the filtrate. After water addition, the mixture was heated to 85 °C and held for 20 minutes. Afterwards, the water mixture was fed to a decanter, specifically a decanter centrifuge, for separation. Two phases were obtained from this: a solid phase and liquid phase. The solid phase was protein rich. The solid phase was collected, dried, and packaged. The drying was carried out at an elevated temperature not more than 80 °C. Afterwards, a dried first protein meal was obtained and analyzed for its protein, fat, minerals, carbohydrates, and their amino acid composition, the results of which is shown in Table III. Based on the calculation between the measured crude protein content and total amino acid, the non-proteinaceous nitrogen value of the protein meal extracted from BSF larvae is 0.68%. On the other hand, the non-proteinaceous nitrogen value of the protein meal extracted from BSF adult flies is 14.06%. Table III
[0085] EXAMPLE IV
[0086] This example shows the mineral, fat, carbohydrate, crude protein content and amino acid profile of protein isolated from the skins of BSF larvae by alkaline hy- drolysis. The first protein hydrolysate and second protein hydrolysate was obtained from the skins of BSF larvae, i.e., from the dried residual portions of Example II, by: i) grinding of the skins of BSF larvae to obtain a powder; ii) adding 0.25M NaOH at a ratio of (1:15) to the powder and further incubation at 40 °C for 1 hour; iii) solid was separated from the NaOH solution by vacuum filtration process; iv) the deproteinized BSF powder was washed with distilled water, filtered, and dried to obtain a chitinous material which is a by-product which can be further processed to chitin; v) acid was added to the separated NaOH solution to reduce its pH to pH 4 ; vi) pH-adjusted NaOH solution was centrifuged at 3580 xg for 10 minutes to separate protein hydrolysate pellets from the supernatant; vii) protein hydrolysate pellets were collected and freeze dried for 1-2 days; viii) the freeze-dried protein hydrolysate pellets thus obtained are denoted first protein hydrolysate; ix) the supernatant after centrifugation process was collected and spray dried to obtain the second protein hydrolysate. The first protein hydrolysate from the skins of BSF larvae, i.e., residual portion from the pressing and separation step, contained 1.60% mineral, 5.72% fat, 0.5% carbohydrate, crude protein content of 92.18%, and true protein content of 94.87%. On the other hand, second protein hydrolysate collected through lyophilization process of super- natant after protein centrifugation process contained 61.90% mineral, 0% fat, 1.66% carbohydrate, 35.31% crude protein, and 32.75% true protein content. Crude protein content was analyzed using Kje Ida h I method, using an N-factor of 6.25 while true protein content was analyzed through the total amino acid present in the sample. The first protein hydrolysate showed crude protein contents that were very similar to its true protein content. This was caused by the absence of chitin in protein hydrolysate as chitin contains nitrogen that might affect the reading in Kjeldahl. BSF protein hydrolysate also contained all essential and non-essential amino acids. Moreover, BSF protein hydrolysate acquired branched chain amino acids (BCAAs) at a significant amount as seen from its L-Leucine (8.42%), L-lsoleucine (3.70%), and L-Valine contents (9.12%). The results of the analysis are shown in Table IV.
[0087] Table IV
[0088] EXAMPLE V
[0089] In this example, the fat by-product obtained by the process using BSF larvae or adult flies as raw material is analyzed. The fat by-product is the lipid phase obtained from the tricantation step. The liquid phase produced from the decanter machine in Example III was further centrifuged in the tricanter, thereby providing the lipid phase which is also denoted "BSF fat". The BSF fat produced contained more than 95% total fat and a water content of less than 1%. The fatty acid profiles of BSF fat obtained from BSF larvae had higher content of saturated fatty acids than unsaturated fatty acids, i.e., approximately 61% and 35%, respectively. Furthermore, BSF fat has omega- 3 fatty acids and omega-6 fatty acids approximately 2.5% and 7%, respectively. Moreover, the fat proportion of BSF larvae also contains arachidonic acid, EPA (eicosapentaenoic acid) and DHA (docosahexaenoic acid) with a proportion of approximately 0.2%, 1% and 0.4%, respectively. BSF fat also contains approximately 22% of lauric acid. Based on the lipid profile, BSF fat that is extracted from BSF larvae and adult flies can be utilized as raw material in derivative products such as cosmetics, additives in veterinary drugs and other derivative products. The fatty acid analysis is shown in Table V. Table V
[0090]
[0091] EXAMPLE VI
[0092] In this example, the soluble protein by-product obtained from BSF larvae and adult flies were analyzed with respect to their protein, fat, mineral and carbohydrate contents. As in the preceding examples, the liquid phase obtained from the decanter was further centrifuged in a tricanter. In the tricanter, the liquid phase was separated into 3 phases: the lipid, the second solid and the aqueous phase. The aqueous phase obtained contained soluble protein. Soluble protein can be utilized directly or further processed as supplement or other derivative products. The results of the analysis are shown in Table VI. Table VI.
[0093] Example VII
[0094] In this example, thorough breakdown of protein products and lipid phase products from BSF larvae are listed in detail. The BSF larvae were processed as described in the preceding examples to provide five protein products: the first protein meal, second protein meal, first protein hydrolysate, second protein hydrolysate, and soluble protein, and lipid phase which were analyzed with respect to their protein, fat, mineral, and carbohydrate contents and the results are shown in Table VII. In terms of crude protein, the fresh BSF larvae contained 11.45 kg crude protein, where 7.55 kg was recovered in the five protein products, providing a yield of 66 %. In terms of total amino acid content, the larvae contained 8.84 kg and 5.57 kg were recovered in the five protein products, providing a yield of 63 % by total amino acid.
[0095] The first protein meal showed the highest yield at 6.79 kg with crude protein content of 48.49% and total true protein content of 49.01%. Hence, about 29 % of the crude protein in the larvae was recovered in the first protein meal. This first protein meal was efficiently produced, by mechanical pressing and thermal treatment, and matches the requirements for Barramundi feed, as the nutritional target values are 45-50% crude protein content with 15-18% lipid. First protein meal can then be directly supplied as Barramundi feed without any further nutrient supplementation.
[0096] The second protein meal yielded 0.93 kg with a crude protein content of 38.47% and true protein content of 36.56%. Hence, a further 3 % of the crude protein in the larvae was recovered in the second protein meal. The second protein meal was efficiently produced with higher mineral macronutrients at 39%. The second protein meal is then suitable as protein supplementation with additional minerals for various feed formulations.
[0097] The first protein hydrolysate yielded 0.6 kg with a very high purity of protein content with crude protein content of 92.18% and true protein content of 94.94%. The process yielded 0.67 kg of crude protein in the first protein hydrolysate and thus recovered a further 5.8 % of the crude protein in the larvae. The first protein hydrolysate is suitable as pure protein addition in various feed formulations.
[0098] The second protein hydrolysate yielded 1.56 kg with a crude protein content of 35.31% with true protein content of 32.75%. The process yielded 0.55 kg of crude protein content in the second protein hydrolysate and thus recovered a further 4.8 % of the crude protein in the larvae. The second protein hydrolysate acquired mineral macronutrients at 61.9%. This then indicates its suitability as protein and mineral supplementation for various feed formulations.
[0099] The soluble protein yield was 6.64 kg with a crude protein content of 43.07% and true protein content of 10.53%., suggesting a high non-proteinaceous nitrogen content in soluble protein. The inventors efficiently produced four protein products (first protein meal, second protein meal, first protein hydrolysate, and second protein hydrolysate) with negligible amount of non-proteinaceous nitrogen, while soluble protein was produced with the collected non-proteinaceous nitrogen, which was kept out of the four protein products. The high nitrogen content in the soluble protein may be beneficial as supplemental ingredient in some feed applications and useful as a fertilizer. Additionally, mineral content in soluble protein reached up to 13.86%, suggesting further benefits of soluble protein material as supplemental ingredient in some feed applications and fertilizer. Table VII
[0100] EXAMPLE VIII
[0101] In this example, the lipid content and protein quality is evaluated for a first protein meal prepared a first heat treatment water (first cycle) and for a protein meal prepared with a first and a second heat treatment with (first and second cycle).
[0102] BSF Larvae were pressed and filtrated in a screw press to provide a filtrate and residual portion. The filtrate had a lipid content of 43.12 % and a crude protein content of 23.81 %.
[0103] The filtrate was mixed with water at a ratio of 30% (v / v) of the filtrate and the resulting mixture was heated to 95 °C and held for 30 minutes. Then the mixture was separated into a solid phase and a liquid phase. The solid phase from this first cycle had a lipid content of 28.52 % and a crude protein content of 38.48 %.
[0104] The solid phase was then mixed with water at a ratio of 30% (v / w) of the solid phase and the resulting mixture was heated to 95 °C and held for 30 minutes. Then the mixture was separated into a further solid phase and a further liquid phase. The further solid phase from this second cycle had a lipid content of 16.15 % and a crude protein content of 48.97 %.
[0105] The protein quality of the solid phase from each cycle was evaluated by pepsin digestibility and non-proteinaceous nitrogen.
[0106] Measured by the modified Torry method, the first cycle solid phase had a pepsin digestibility of 80.3 % and the second cycle further solid phase had a pepsin digestibility of 83.5 %, providing an improvement of 4 % (3.2 %-points) by the second cycle.
[0107] The non-proteinaceous nitrogen content of the filtrate was 50.17 %. For the first cycle solid phase it was 6.40 % and for the second cycle further solid phase it was 1.05 %. Generally, a lower non-proteinaceous nitrogen content is desired as non-proteinaceous nitrogen may hinder digestibility of the protein.
[0108] These and more results are show in Table VIII. All measurements in this example were performed on dry samples of the filtrate, solid phase and further solid phase. Table VIII
Claims
C L A I M S1. A method for processing Black Soldier Fly (Hermetia illucens, abbreviated BSF) larvae and / or flies to recover protein, which method comprises the steps of: a) pressing fresh, preferably live, BSF larvae and / or BSF flies to obtain a pulp, b) filtrating the pulp to provide a filtrate and a residual portion, which filtrate comprises liquid and solid matter, c) adding water to the filtrate to provide a water mixture and heating to a holding temperature of at least 60 °C, preferably at least 95°C, d) separating the water mixture to obtain a solid phase and a liquid phase, and e) drying the solid phase to obtain a first protein meal.
2. The method according to claim 1, further comprising the steps of: c2) adding water to the solid phase obtained from step d) to provide a further water mixture and heating to a holding temperature of at least 60 °C, preferably at least 95 °C, d2) separating the further water mixture to obtain a further solid phase and a further liquid phase, and in step e) drying the further solid phase to obtain the first protein meal.
3. The method according to claim 2, wherein step c) comprises holding the water mixture at the holding temperature for at least 5 minutes, at least 10 minutes or at least 20 minutes, and step c2) comprises holding the further water mixture at the holding temperature for at least at least 5 minutes, at least 10 minutes or at least 20 minutes.
4. The method according to claim 2 or 3, wherein step c2) comprises adding water in a ratio of water volume to solid phase weight of 1:5 to 2:1.
5. The method according to claim 1, wherein step c) comprises holding the water mixture at the holding temperature for at least 30 minutes.
6. The method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein step c) comprises adding water in a ratio of water volume to filtrate volume of 1:5 to 2:1.
7. The method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the method further comprises the steps of: f) separating the liquid phase obtained in step d), optionally combined with the further liquid phase if present, in a tricanterto obtain a second solid phase, a lipid phase and an aqueous phase, and drying the second solid phase to obtain a second protein meal.
8. The method according to claim 7, wherein soluble protein in the aqueous phase obtained in step f) is recovered, preferably by drying, to obtain a third protein product.
9. The method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein steps a) and b) are performed as one step in a pressing apparatus, such as a screw-press.
10. The method according to claim 9, wherein the pressing apparatus used in steps a) and b) is a screw press with a single screw and a screen having openings, wherein the smallest of dimension of each the openings is in the range 0.5 to 2 mm, preferably 0.5 to 1.5 mm even more preferably 0.8 to 1.2 mm.
11. The method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the separation in step d) is a decantation.
12. The method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the drying in step e) or step f) is microwave drying.
13. The method according to any one of the preceding claims, further comprising the steps of: g) hydrolyzing the residual portion obtained in step b) by adding an alkali so- lution to obtain a hydrolyzed protein solution, h) precipitating protein from the hydrolyzed protein solution and separating the principate to obtain a protein hydrolysate product.
