Rapid pile loading test method utilizing case method

MYPI2025006244A0Undetermined Publication Date: 2024-10-13JIBANSHIKENJO CO LTD
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
MYPI2025006244
Authority / Receiving Office
MY · MY
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2023-04-13
Publication Date
2024-10-13

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Conventional rapid loading test methods for piles face challenges in obtaining accurate load-displacement relationships, particularly with longer piles, due to assumptions of rigid mass points and limitations in relative loading time, leading to overestimated ground resistance and increased costs.

Method used

The method incorporates the Case method based on one-dimensional wave theory into the unloading point connection method, allowing multiple rapid loading tests to determine penetration resistance and unloading point loads, thereby relaxing application restrictions and improving accuracy.

Benefits of technology

This approach provides a more accurate load-displacement relationship without needing to correct inertial forces, reducing equipment scale and costs, and aligning better with static loading test results.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure PI2025006244_DRAWING_001
    Figure PI2025006244_DRAWING_001
  • Figure PI2025006244_DRAWING_002
    Figure PI2025006244_DRAWING_002
  • Figure PI2025006244_DRAWING_003
    Figure PI2025006244_DRAWING_003
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

ABSTRACT RAPID PILE LOADING TEST METHOD UTILIZING CASE METHOD The present invention is to provide a rapid load test method for a pile, with which a more highly precise load-displacement relation can be determined by use of a newly developed analysis method, on the premise that a plurality of rapid load tests shall be conducted on the pile head. The pile is subjected to a plurality of rapid load tests, and then, a w-Rsoil relation is determined from both the soil resistance Rsoil obtained from a Case method used for a conventional impulsive load test and the temporal changes of a directly measured pile displacement w to obtain an unloading point load RULP and an unloading point displacement from the determined w-Rsoil relation. After that, two or more unloading points are connected; likewise, an Unloading Point Connection (ULPC) method is used for a conventional rapid load test, with the result that a static load-displacement relation can be finally determined. FIG. 8
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Rapid load testing method for piles using the CASE method

[0001] The present invention relates to a rapid loading test method for piles, in which a weight is dropped onto the pile head and the static load-displacement relationship of the pile is determined from the relationship between the load caused by the weight drop and the displacement of the pile head. More specifically, the present invention relates to a rapid loading test method for piles, in which a weight is dropped from different heights to perform multiple rapid loading tests on the pile head, and the relationship between the pile head load and pile head displacement is determined from the measurement results. By using a new analytical method, the rapid loading test can determine the load-displacement relationship with higher accuracy. The new analytical method enables rapid loading tests using a weight lighter than before.

[0002] Patent documents relating to conventional methods for rapid load testing and analysis of piles include, for example, Patent Documents 1 to 3.

[0003] Patent Document 1 discloses a rapid loading test method in which a weight is dropped onto the head of a pile to apply an impact force to the head and determine the settlement rigidity and bearing capacity of the pile. The method involves placing a buffer material made of a material with a specific gravity of 0.35 to 0.5 between the weight and the head of the pile, thereby enabling highly accurate test results to be obtained with a smaller load.

[0004] Patent Document 2 discloses a rapid load testing device for piles that can easily and quickly obtain highly reliable data necessary to estimate the bearing capacity of piles driven into the ground. The rapid load testing device for piles has a weight that strikes the pile head and a cushioning material formed by stacking multiple metal plates and a polymer material sandwiched between the metal plates, between the pile head and the weight.

[0005] Patent Document 3 discloses a rapid load testing device for piles that, when a cushioning material is interposed between the pile head and the weight striking the pile head, can quickly catch the weight that falls onto the pile head and bounces up, stopping it from repeatedly bouncing, thereby enabling highly reliable data to be obtained easily and in a short time.

[0006] Twenty years have passed since rapid pile loading tests were added to the Geotechnical Society of Japan's standard (JGS1815-2002) as a dynamic load testing method. At the time rapid pile loading tests were added to the load testing standard in 2002, the reaction body inertia force method was the mainstream method for rapid load testing. However, with improvements in loading devices, most tests are now conducted using the soft cushion weight drop method. Accordingly, the number of loads has also changed from a single load equivalent to the ultimate bearing capacity to multiple loads, with the hammer drop height gradually increased and the final load equivalent to the ultimate bearing capacity applied.

[0007] In the reaction body inertia force method, the load-displacement relationship was calculated using the unloading point method (ULP method) from the dynamic signal measured in a single loading (see Figure 1). However, by loading multiple times, the unloading point load, which can be considered as static resistance, and the pile displacement at that time can be obtained for each drop. Therefore, the load-displacement relationship of the pile is mainly calculated using the unloading point connection method (ULPC method), which simply connects the load and displacement at multiple unloading points (see Figure 2).

[0008] [Unloading point method (ULP method)] In the unloading point method, the effect of wave propagation in the pile body is assumed to be negligible in the rapid loading test of the pile. In the rapid loading test, the pile is treated as a rigid mass point and a dynamic load F is applied to the pile. rapid When (t) acts, the pile is subjected to static ground resistance R w (t) and dynamic ground resistance R v Assume that (t) acts.

[0009] These relationships are expressed in equations (1) and (2) and in FIG.

[0010]

[0011]

[0012] Here, F rapid : Load at pile head R soil :Soil resistance R a : Inertia force of pile body R w :Static ground resistance component R v: Dynamic ground resistance component m: Mass of pile α: Acceleration of pile C: Damping constant v: Velocity of pile

[0013] Maximum value of displacement w max is called the unloading point. At the unloading point, the pile velocity v becomes 0, so the load at the unloading point (unloading point load R ULP ) is the static ground resistance R w becomes equal to

[0014] R other than the unloading point w To find this, it is necessary to determine the damping constant C. Non-Patent Document 1 proposes to determine C by equation (3).

[0015]

[0016] Here, R soil(max) is R soil The maximum value of v * is R soil(max) If we assume that C is constant regardless of the displacement or velocity of the pile, then we can use equation (4) to calculate R w The -w relationship can be determined.

[0017]

[0018] [Unloading Point Connection Method (ULP Method)] The unloading point connection method (ULP Method) described above assumes that a load equivalent to the ultimate bearing capacity will be applied once, so it is necessary to determine the damping constant C. However, the value of C may change depending on the displacement and speed of the pile.

[0019] In the soft cushion weight drop method, the hammer drop height is increased stepwise and multiple loads are applied. Therefore, for each impact, multiple unloading point loads and corresponding unloading point displacements are obtained. Therefore, by simply connecting the unloading points, it is not necessary to calculate the damping constant C required in the unloading point method (ULP method), and simply connecting the unloading points allows for easy calculation of R as shown in Figure 2. w -w relationship can be obtained.

[0020] However, in the unloading point method (ULP method) and unloading point connection method (ULPC method), the pile is assumed to be a rigid mass point, so the longer the pile length, the greater the effect of the pile's elastic deformation. For example, the estimated load-displacement relationship is affected by the position where the pile acceleration is measured.

[0021] [Case method based on one-dimensional wave theory] The Case method described in Non-Patent Document 2 is a method that has been used in impact loading tests, and is based on one-dimensional wave theory to calculate the penetration resistance force and J of a pile during impact. c It calculates static penetration resistance using an empirical coefficient called a coefficient, but does not take into account the load-displacement relationship obtained in a rapid loading test.

[0022] First, the downward wave F is calculated from the measurement signal (axial force F and pile velocity v). d and rising wave F u (Equations (5) and (6)). Then, using equation (7), the penetration resistance of the pile R soil The time change of is obtained (see Figure 3).

[0023]

[0024]

[0025]

[0026] Here, x: Coordinate along the pile axis (pile head is 0) x m : Measurement position v: Pile speed L m : Length from the measurement position to the tip of the pile F: Axial force F d :Downward wave F u : Upward wave Z: Impedance of pile body (EA / c) c: Longitudinal wave propagation velocity E: Young's modulus of pile material A: Cross-sectional area of ​​pile R soil :Penetration resistance

[0027] The Case method evaluates the penetration resistance of a pile when it is driven, but it cannot obtain the load-displacement relationship of the pile by itself. However, because the Case method is based on one-dimensional wave theory, it can evaluate the penetration resistance of a pile almost accurately even if the pile length is long.

[0028] In Non-Patent Document 3, a numerical analysis of a rapid loading test of a pile is performed, and the ground resistance obtained by the Case method and the ground resistance obtained by the unloading point method (ULP method) analysis are compared and examined. As a result, the relative loading time T r = t L / (2L m / c) (where t L It shows that the soil resistance obtained from the latter analysis overestimates the value obtained from the former analysis when the loading duration (is the loading duration) is less than 5. However, it does not mention the effect on the load-displacement relationship.

[0029] In Non-Patent Document 4, a rapid loading test of a tip-supported pile was conducted, and the static load-displacement relationship of the pile was determined using the CASE method. In this test, a single impact with a relatively large impact force was performed. Therefore, it was necessary to determine the damping constant C.

[0030] Japanese Patent Publication No. 2002-303570 Japanese Patent Publication No. 2005-068802 Japanese Patent Publication No. 6613430

[0031] Kusakabe O., Matsumoto T. (1995):Statnamic tests of Shonan test program with review of signal interpretation, Proc. 1st Int. Statnamic Seminar, Vancouver, Canada, pp.113-122. Raushe F. Goble G., Likins GE Jr. (1985):Dynamic determination of pile capacity, ASCE Jour. Geotech. Div., 111(3), pp.367-383. Kojima and Nishimura (2021):On the analysis method of soil resistance in rapid load tests, 56th Geotechnical Engineering Research Presentation Workshop. Matsuzawa, Nakashima, Nakayama, Matsumoto (2008):A piling method accompanying rapid load testing, Proc. the 8th Int. Conf. on the Application of Stress-Wave Theory to Piles, Lisbon, Portugal, pp.487-495.

[0032] In the unloading point method and the unloading point connection method, the relative loading time T r If the time is shorter, the accuracy of the analysis will be lower. r In order to extend the test time, the test equipment must be very large-scale, which poses a problem that the cost per test is very high.

[0033] The present invention aims to develop a new analytical method that incorporates the concepts of the Case method used in impact loading tests into the conventional unloading point connection method (ULPC method), assuming that multiple rapid loading tests will be conducted on the pile head, and to provide a rapid loading test method for piles that can determine the load-displacement relationship with higher accuracy.

[0034] The present invention relates to a method for rapid loading tests of piles, in which a weight is dropped onto the head of a pile and the static load-displacement relationship of the pile is determined from the relationship between the load caused by the dropped weight and the displacement of the head of the pile, and includes the steps of: performing a plurality of rapid loading tests on the head of the pile by changing the drop height h of the weight; and calculating the penetration resistance R of the pile during driving by the following steps (a) and (b) using a Case method based on one-dimensional wave theory for each of the plurality of rapid loading tests. soil and calculating the displacement w of the pile head and the ground resistance R from the time change of the displacement w of the pile head that is directly measured. soil The step of finding the relationship between the maximum displacement w max Ground resistance R at time soil(max) is the static resistance force R w Considering this, the unloading point load P h and unloading point displacement w h and a step of calculating the unloading point load P obtained for each different drop height h. h and the unloading point displacement w h The pile head load P h -Displacement w h and a step of determining the relationship between

[0035] (a) From the axial force F and pile velocity v in the rapid loading test, the downward wave F is calculated using the following equations (5) and (6). d and rising wave F u Calculate. (b) Next, using equation (7), the penetration resistance R of the pile soil Obtain the time change of Here, x: Coordinate along the pile axis (pile head is 0) x m : Measurement position v: Pile speed L m : Length from the measurement position to the tip of the pile F: Axial force F d :Downward wave F u : Upward wave Z: Impedance of pile body (EA / c) c: Longitudinal wave propagation velocity E: Young's modulus of pile material A: Cross-sectional area of ​​pile R soil :Penetration resistance

[0036] That is, in the present invention, a pile is subjected to multiple impacts (rapid loading test) and the penetration resistance R obtained by the Case method is soil From the time change of the pile displacement w measured directly, w-R soil The relationship is found, and from this, the unloading point load R ULP and the unloading point displacement are obtained. Then, by connecting multiple unloading points in the same way as in the unloading point connection method (ULPC method), the static load-displacement relationship can finally be obtained.

[0037] According to the rapid loading test method for piles of the present invention, a new analytical method is developed and utilized that incorporates the concept of the Case method used in impact loading tests into the conventional unloading point connection method (ULPC method), assuming that multiple rapid loading tests will be performed on the pile head. This makes it possible to provide a rapid loading test method for piles that can determine a more accurate load-displacement relationship.

[0038] The rapid loading test method for piles of the present invention is based on one-dimensional wave theory, so correction of the inertial force of the pile is not necessary. Therefore, it has the advantage that the application restriction due to the pile length, i.e., the application restriction due to the relative loading time, is relaxed. In the conventional unloading point method and unloading point connection method, T r In order to extend the test time, the test equipment has to be very large and the cost per test has to be very high, but this solves the problem.

[0039] This is a graph showing the load-displacement relationship in the unloading point method (ULP method), which is an example of a conventional rapid loading test method. This is a graph showing the load-displacement relationship in the unloading point connection method (ULPC method), which is an example of a conventional rapid loading test method. This is a diagram showing an overview of the Case method used in conventional impact loading tests. This is a diagram showing the N-value distribution at the test point and the embedded state of the pile. Pile head load P calculated using the conventional unloading point method (ULP method) h - displacement w relationship. Pile head load P obtained by the conventional unloading point connection method (ULPC method) h - displacement w relationship. r = 3, h = 1.0 m). h10 is a graph showing the relationship between the pile head load P and the displacement w. h 10 is a graph showing a comparison of the relationship between T and displacement w. r F in the rapid loading tests of 3, 4, and 5 rapid , R soil(Case) , R soil(ULP) 1 is a graph showing the time history of

[0040] The following describes tests that were conducted to examine the rationality of the rapid loading test method of the present invention.

[0041] First, the relative loading time T r For rapid loading tests of =5, 4, and 3, the load-displacement relationships of piles obtained from static loading tests, the unloading point method (ULP method), the unloading point connection method (ULPC method), and the analysis method of this invention (referred to as the "ULPC_CM method") were compared and examined.

[0042] [Test pile specifications, ground overview, and load test procedure] A static loading test (SLT) and a rapid loading test (RLT) were conducted on the steel pipe test piles shown in Table 1, using a soft cushion weight drop type rapid loading test device (a cushion material consisting of a steel plate and elastomer was installed at the pile head). The test piles had a total length of 48.0 m, and were embedded in a bearing layer with an N-value of 50 or more (see Figure 4).

[0043]

[0044] In the rapid loading test, mass m h The weight of the soft cushion was adjusted to a spring constant of 0.05 to 1.80 m. L The relative loading time T r = t L / (2L / c) = 3, 4, 5. In this rapid loading test, dynamic signals (load, acceleration) were measured only at the pile head.

[0045] (1) Analysis results using the unloading point method (ULP method) Figure 5 shows the T r = Pile head load P by unloading point method (ULP method) analysis for rapid loading tests 3 to 5 h - Comparison of displacement w relationship and static loading test results.

[0046] In the analysis of each rapid loading test, the dynamic signal of one impact was used to determine the damping constant C, and then P h The P-w relationship was calculated using the unloading point method (ULP method) using the dynamic signal of only one impact. h The -w relationship deviated significantly from the static loading test results.

[0047] (2) Analysis results using the unloading point connection method (ULPC method) Figure 6 shows the T r P = 3 to 5 for rapid loading tests by unloading point connection method (ULPC method) analysis h A comparison of the -w relationship and static loading test results is shown.

[0048] Compared with the results in Figure 5, the analysis results using the unloading point connection method (ULPC method) can better represent the static loading test results. However, at a certain pile displacement w, T r decreases and P h is overestimated.

[0049] (3) Analysis results using the analysis method of the present invention (ULPC_CM method) Figure 7 shows the T r = 3, rapid load F in the rapid loading test with weight drop height h = 1.0 m rapid The time history of the displacement w, velocity v, and acceleration α is shown. The ground resistance R obtained by the Case method and the unloading point method (ULP method) is soil(Case) and R soil(ULP) F rapid is also shown.

[0050] At the time of maximum pile displacement, the velocity v = 0. soil(Case) The static resistance force R is calculated in the same way as the unloading point method (ULP method). w (R ULP ) is defined as follows. A static load-displacement relationship is constructed by connecting the unloading point load and displacement obtained by the analytical method of the present invention, which are obtained from a series of rapid loading tests with varying h.

[0051] Figure 8 shows the T r P = 3 to 5 for the rapid load test by the analysis method according to the present invention h A comparison of the -w relationship and static loading test results is shown.

[0052] In both rapid loading tests, the analytical results obtained by the analytical method according to the present invention are almost identical to the results of the static loading tests. r Even if P decreases to 3, h -w relationship is T r It can be seen that the effect of

[0053] In order to facilitate a comparison between the results of the analysis method according to the present invention and the unloading point connection method (ULPC method), the results of FIGS. 6 and 8 are shown together in FIG. 9.

[0054] (4) Comparison and consideration of the analysis results Figure 10 shows the results of T r F in the rapid loading tests of 3, 4, and 5 rapid , R soil(Case) , R soil(ULP) The time history of T r = 5, R soil(Case) and R soil(ULP) There is no significant difference between them.

[0055] T r = 4, 3, and so on, R soil(Case) and R soil(ULP) In this test result, the analysis by the unloading point connection method (ULPC method) is r On the other hand, in the analysis method according to the present invention, T r =3 could be applied.

[0056] Therefore, the rapid load testing and analysis method for piles of the present invention makes it possible to obtain a more accurate load-displacement relationship.

Claims

1. A method for rapid load testing of piles, in which a weight is dropped on the head of a pile and a static load-displacement relationship of the pile is obtained from the relationship between the load caused by the weight drop and the displacement of the head of the pile, comprising the steps of: performing a plurality of rapid load tests on the head of the pile by changing the drop height h of the weight; and calculating the penetration resistance R of the pile during each of the plurality of rapid load tests by the following steps (a) and (b) using the Case method based on the one-dimensional wave theory. soil and calculating the displacement w of the pile head and the ground resistance R from the time change of the displacement w of the pile head which is directly measured. soil The step of determining the relationship between the maximum displacement w max Ground resistance at time R soil(max) The static resistance R w Considering that, the unloading point load P h and the unloading point displacement w h and obtaining the unloading point load P obtained for each different drop height h. h and the unloading point displacement w h The pile head load P h - Displacement w h (a) determining the relationship between the axial force F and the pile velocity v in the rapid load test by the following equations (5) and (6): d and rising wave F u Calculate. (b) Next, using equation (7), the penetration resistance R of the pile soil Obtain the time change of Here, x: Coordinate along the pile axis (pile head is 0) x m : Measurement position v: Pile speed L m : Length from the measurement position to the tip of the pile F: Axial force F d :Downward wave F u : Upward wave Z: Impedance of pile body (EA / c) c: Longitudinal wave propagation speed E: Young's modulus of pile material A: Cross-sectional area of ​​pile R soil : Penetration resistance