Method for tightening bolted joints subject to relaxation
Patent Information
- Application Number
- PCT/BR2025/050183
- Authority / Receiving Office
- WO · WO
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2025-05-15
- Publication Date
- 2026-11-19
AI Technical Summary
Existing methods for controlling axial tightening force in bolted joints, particularly in aeronautical structures with liquid interface sealant, suffer from high uncertainty and are costly, failing to accurately maintain structural integrity and watertight seals due to sealant extrusion and other factors.
A method involving recording a reference curve, applying pre-torque, allowing joint relaxation, measuring screw elongation, converting to tightening force, calculating an angle for target tightening, and applying this angle using angle control to ensure precise tightening.
Reduces uncertainty to 5% and allows non-destructive verification at any point in the joint's service life, ensuring structural integrity and watertightness at a lower cost without specialized equipment.
Smart Images

Figure BR2025050183_19112026_PF_FP_ABST
Abstract
Description
"Tightening method for bolted joints subject to relaxation"
[0001] The present invention relates to a tightening method that ensures a precise tightening force for bolted joints, particularly in aeronautical structural joints subject to loosening during torque application, often due to the presence of liquid interface sealant between the joined structural components. Description of the state of the art
[0002] High-responsibility structural joints, such as those used in the wing-fuselage junction of an aircraft, require specific clamping forces to ensure the structural requirements of preventing component separation and ensuring a watertight seal. In this case, the general goal is to improve the accuracy of the coupling, specifically by improving the accuracy of the clamping force commonly known as "preload," "pre-torque," or "pre-tightening," generated when tightening a bolt.
[0003] Therefore, when assembling components using bolts, it is important to apply appropriate and precise pre-tension. Pre-tension makes it possible to keep the components in contact and usually aims to compensate for external forces that will be transmitted through the joint, such as: vibration, thermal expansion, impact, structural stresses arising from aerodynamic loads in the case of aircraft.
[0004] A screw is generally a metal fastener that employs an external thread and is connected by rotation to an internal thread manufactured in a piece or existing in a mechanical element such as a nut. Pretension is the axial force applied to the screw and created by the friction between the threads when rotating one element against the other, with rotation being limited by structural elements that inhibit axial displacement between the mechanical elements.
[0005] Controlling the value of this axial force is very important for the long-term reliability of the assembly. In this case, control means achieving good tightening accuracy, with a small deviation from a target value.
[0006] It is common to find in industries the use of angle-based clamping force control, that is, a rotation is applied to the element to be tightened through a predefined angle from a given initial position, which tightens it in a controlled manner.
[0007] However, one of the most widely used methods for controlling axial force is torque control, where a tool allows for the direct measurement of the applied torque, which is applied until a predefined tightening torque is reached. Additionally, tightening can also be carried out until the elastic limit is reached or until the onset of plastic deformation of the screw, nut, bolt, or pin.
[0008] Another known method employs a device called a "hydraulic tensioner" coupled to the bolt. This type of tensioner is a relatively complex device that uses a hydraulic circuit to generate physical clearance between the nut and the flange of the connection, allowing for tightening of the nut and subsequently fine-tuning of the tension applied to the assembly. There are some commercial options for this device, such as the Tentec® from Atlas Copco.
[0009] The methods described above can be applied iteratively for greater accuracy or even combined, for example, by performing a pre-tightening by torque followed by tightening at the required angle.
[0010] Another approach to controlling the axial tightening force involves instrumenting the assembly to determine the applied preload. Several instruments are known for this purpose, for example, a washer equipped with a piezoelectric sensor or a washer called a preload indicator. Another control option is the use of screws with active tightening range indicators that have a force indicator on the head. There are some commercial options for these screws, such as SmartBoIts®.
[0011] Additionally, dedicated devices can be used to monitor tightness, such as ultrasound devices, fiber Bragg grating (fiber optic) sensors, and strain gauges.
[0012] The MIL-HDBK-60 and Machiner's Handbook (military manual) publication presents typical accuracy values measured for different methods. In this publication, the uncertainties regarding tightening force in the methods considered were as follows: (i) control by operator experience resulted in an uncertainty of ±35%, (ii) torque control presented an uncertainty of ±25%, (iii) angle control had an uncertainty of ±15%, (iv) use of a load-sensing washer resulted in an uncertainty of ±10%, (v) measurement of screw elongation presented an uncertainty of ±3 to 5%, (vi) use of extensometers resulted in an uncertainty of ±1%, and finally, (vii) control by ultrasonic sensor presented an uncertainty of ±1%.
[0013] Therefore, improving the accuracy of tightening force in bolted joints is the subject of constant and varied approaches, mainly with the aim of making the application of force with precision and control cheaper and faster in production lines.
[0014] In this regard, document US 9,500,544 describes a process for verifying whether threads are fully engaged when tightening an assembly or joint. This process uses the torque method and the angle control method together, proposing a comparison of the curve generated during tightening with archived reference curves. The proposal is to evaluate the tightening achieved by comparing the quality of the curve generated during tightening with the reference curve. However, the process does not explain how to apply the solution to joints subject to relaxation due to interface sealant and does not use ultrasonic elongation measurement.
[0015] US patent document 11,486,781 describes a method that, through torque measurement during tightening and loosening of a bolt, calculates characteristic points on a torque curve. These points provide a linear relationship that allows estimating the torque required to achieve the established target tightening. However, this method does not allow for calculating the torque of a joint that relaxes after the application of pre-torque due to extrusion of the interface sealant. This phenomenon of interface sealant extrusion implies a loss of reference to the calculated initial point, which, in this case, would result in an erroneous estimate of the force-torque relationship.
[0016] Document US 2020 / 0039038 presents the development of a torque wrench with an attached ultrasound device, allowing for real-time measurement of tightening force. In this document, the bolts need to have a flat surface on the head side for the ultrasound to be applied. However, this geometry is not found in high-strength bolts used in critical joints, such as the NAS14181 or NAS21134 bolts exemplified in Figure 2. These bolts are usually manufactured by forging, a process that does not generate this type of well-finished surface on the bolt head. Although this solution is accurate, it is probably the most expensive, as it combines two tools (torque wrench and ultrasound) into one and requires significant automation to eliminate the need for a specialist to evaluate the ultrasound measurement.
[0017] Thus, the greatest challenge for the industry today, especially for the aeronautical industry, is to find the right balance between the uncertainty in tightening bolts in bolted joints and the cost of applying tightening control solutions. Particularly in the aeronautical sector, a method with greater uncertainty is often selected to meet manufacturing requirements; however, due to the responsibility attributed to these joints, it is necessary to oversize the torques to guarantee structural requirements due to this greater uncertainty of the chosen method. Objectives of the invention
[0018] Thus, the present invention aims to provide a tightening method for bolted joints subject to relaxation, capable of reducing the uncertainty of the final tightening generated, ensuring the required structural specifications and meeting manufacturing conditions.
[0019] It is also an objective of this invention to provide a tightening method for bolted joints subject to relaxation that is low-cost, non-destructive, and allows for tightening checks at any point in the joint's service life. Brief description of the invention
[0020] The present invention relates to a tightening method for bolted joints subject to relaxation, comprising the following steps: (i) recording of a reference curve for each screw to be used in a no-load condition; (ii) applying a pre-torque to the bolts in step (i); (iii) rest time for joint relaxation; (iv) measuring the elongation of the screws after applying the pre-torque and converting the elongation into tightening force; (v) calculation of an angle to achieve a target tightening on the screws in step (iv); and (vi) applying the angle calculated in step (v) to obtain the target tightening on the joint bolts. Brief description of the drawings
[0021] Figure 1 - is a cross-sectional view of a typical section of a bolted joint between a wing and the fuselage of an aircraft, a region that needs to be sealed to prevent fuel leakage and therefore shows extruded sealant residue from the interface;
[0022] Figure 2 - illustrates the screws typically used in joints in the aeronautical industry MS14181 and MS21134;
[0023] Figure 3 - is a flowchart of the tightening method for bolted joints subject to relaxation, the subject of the present invention;
[0024] Figure 4 illustrates the DeltaSigma ultrasound equipment used to measure screw elongation in one of the steps of the tightening method for bolted joints subject to relaxation, which is the subject of the present invention;
[0025] Figure 5 - schematically illustrates the principle of calculating the elongation of the screw as a function of the time difference (AT) by ultrasound reflection between the two screw loading configurations in the tightening method for bolted joints subject to relaxation, which is the subject of the present invention;
[0026] Figure 6 illustrates an electric torque wrench that enables the execution of different torque strategies, such as torque control and angle control, in one of the steps of the tightening method for bolted joints subject to relaxation, which is the subject of this invention;
[0027] Figure 7 - is a graph that illustrates curves acquired by the torque wrench shown in Figure 6, in which all curves were subjected to the same pre-torque, but subsequently at different angles;
[0028] Figure 8 - is a graph that illustrates the data composition relating the tightening force to the applied angle after pre-torque for a tested configuration;
[0029] Figure 9 - is a graph that illustrates the impracticality of applying equation (3) to obtain the angle required to achieve the target tightening, due to mechanical coupling phenomena not contemplated in that equation; and
[0030] Figure 10 - is a graph that illustrates the development of the function ([3) through the correlation between the experimental stiffnesses and those calculated by equation (3). Detailed description of the invention
[0031] According to a preferred embodiment, and as can be seen in the attached figures, the object of the present invention consists of a tightening method for bolted joints subject to relaxation due to the extrusion of sealant applied to the interface of the parts to be joined. However, the tightening method that is the subject of this invention can also be applied to joints where the parts do not have sealant at the interface, to joints with any fastener distribution, and to joints employing different types of materials, such as metals and composites.
[0032] Specifically regarding bolted joints subject to relaxation due to sealant extrusion, these are joints where the parts to be joined receive sealant because they are in a region of the aircraft that needs to be sealed to prevent fuel leaks, for example, or for other reasons. As can be seen in the example in Figure 1, joint 30 is formed by the wing flange 2 to be joined to the fuselage flange 4 by means of bolt 1. Also comprising the joint are a structural interface rib 7, a bolt contact washer 8, a tightening nut 5, and a nut contact washer 6. Both the wing flange 2 and the fuselage flange 4 contain sealant on their surfaces; thus, when a pre-torque is applied to bolt 1 and tightening nut 5, the sealants of each flange undergo extrusion, generating an extruded sealant residue 3.
[0033] This extruded sealant residue 3 is one of the factors influencing the relaxation of the initially applied clamping force, resulting in uncertainty regarding the final tightening generated at the joint 30. Other uncertainty factors are the geometry of the joined components, the rigidity of the components, and the tightening sequence during the joining of the structural components.
[0034] The tightening method for bolted joints subject to relaxation, which is the subject of the present invention, reduces this uncertainty in the final tightening generated. To this end, the method comprises the following steps illustrated in the flowchart in Figure 3: (i) recording a reference curve for each bolt to be used in a no-load condition; (ii) applying a pre-torque to the bolts in step (i); (iii) rest time for joint relaxation; (iv) measuring the elongation of the screws after applying the pre-torque and converting the elongation into tightening force; (v) calculation of an angle to achieve a target tightening on the screws in step (iv); and (vi) applying the angle calculated in step (v) to obtain the target tightening on the joint bolts.
[0035] In step (i) of recording a reference curve, bolts 1 are decoupled from the joint, i.e., in the unloaded condition, and the recording is made for each bolt 1 that will be used in the bolted joint.
[0036] In this step, a commercial device is used that measures the length of screw 1 by reflecting the ultrasonic signal at the opposite end from where the sound was introduced into screw 1. Several devices that use this principle are commercially available, such as the Delta Sigma from Resonic Instruments, illustrated in Figure 4.
[0037] The ultrasound equipment used for recording the reference curve will take into account the mechanical and geometric properties of screws 1 that are necessary for calculating the sound propagation time in screw 1. Additionally, the equipment should also consider ambient temperature information to compensate for the length of screw 1 due to thermal expansion. This feature allows tightening to be performed at different times or even measured over time under any environmental condition.
[0038] For engraving, the end opposite the screw head will be used, which has adequate flatness for proper support of the equipment tip (figure 4).
[0039] After recording a reference curve for each bolt 1, these bolts 1 are positioned in the joint 30 and step (ii) occurs, applying a pre-torque to all bolts 1 that make up the joint 30 and whose length was recorded in the reference curve of step (i). This pre-torque is applied using the torque control method.
[0040] Thus, to determine the value of the torque to be applied to each screw 1, equation (1) is used: = F.dn.k Equation (1) where T is the torque to be applied, F corresponds to 60% of the target tightening force, dn is the screw diameter, and ek is a torque factor that is a constant equal to 0.14.
[0041] Once the torque value to be applied to each bolt 1 as pre-torque has been determined and the calculated pre-torque has been applied to each bolt 1 of joint 30, we have step (iii) of the rest time for the relaxation of joint 30. This rest time can vary between 5 and 20 minutes, preferably between 10 and 15 minutes.
[0042] For joints where components are sealed, this resting time is the time it takes for the extrusion of the sealant applied at the interface between the components of the joint to stabilize. In this case, the preferred time is 15 minutes for joints between the wing and fuselage of an aircraft, for example. The variation in this resting time depends on the viscosity of the sealant applied, the tightening sequence, the joint geometry, and the tightening force applied.
[0043] Once the sealant extrusion has stabilized and the resting time for joint relaxation 30 has ended, step (iv) is performed to measure the elongation of the screws 1 after applying the pre-torque and converting the elongation into tightening force.
[0044] The measurement of the elongation 17 of the screws 1 due to pre-torque, as illustrated in figure 5, is performed by means of an ultrasound signal applied to each screw with the same commercial ultrasound equipment used for the recordings in step (i), i.e., the measurement is performed using the principle of ultrasonic reflection, and a calculation of the difference in ultrasonic reflection time 16 compared to the ultrasonic reference curve 15 obtained in step (i) is performed to obtain the elongation value 17 in the length of each screw 1.
[0045] With the elongation value 17 and the data for screw 1 entered into the equipment, the elongation 17 is converted into tightening force. The values obtained will be archived for analysis in the next step.
[0046] The next step (v) consists of calculating an angle (6) needed to achieve a target tightening on screws 1 from step (iv). This calculation makes use of an empirical equation, equation (3).
[0047] For the development of equation (3), several tests were carried out, which consisted of performing tightening with fixed pre-torques and subsequently different tightening angles, for a wide variety of joint configurations 30, which were selected to evaluate different parameters that interfere with the tightening force generated as a function of torque, such as: plate materials, thicknesses, diameters, friction pairs, etc. In these tests, torque-angle curves were obtained, illustrated in figure 7, using an electric torque wrench with a data acquisition system 100, illustrated in figure 7, and simultaneously the tightening force with ultrasound equipment.
[0048] Torque-by-angle curves allow for the definition of an optimized pre-torque for different joint configurations. This pre-torque aims to ensure that after the sealant is extruded from the interface, a tensile force will still be exerted on the bolts. As can be seen in Figure 6, torque-by-angle curves are not linear and clearly identify three zones of the tightening process: connection zone 19, seating, alignment and sealant extrusion zone 20, and tightening zone 21.
[0049] In the tightening method, object of this invention, it is necessary to ensure that after the relaxation of joint 30 there is residual tightening, that is, being in the linear tightening zone 21 of the curve illustrated in figure 6. In this case and with this premise, the experiments converged to the application of a value of 60% of the final tightening force in equation (1) of the pre-torque calculation.
[0050] By combining the torque-by-angle data with the clamping force measurements, a clamping force-by-angle curve was constructed for each configuration tested, as illustrated in Figure 8. From these curves, the relationship between clamping force and clamping angle was obtained.
[0051] Regarding the calculation of the angle (9) required to achieve a target tightening on the bolts 1, several literature sources use equation (2) instead of equation (3). Equation (2) is applied to calculate the joint (Kj) which is the result of combining the bolt stiffness (Kb) and the equivalent stiffness of the plates (km): Equation (2)
[0052] The combination of screw stiffness (Kb) and equivalent plate stiffness (km) makes the connection between tightening force and elongation in equation (3): 36 & — Equation (3) where p refers to the thread pitch, F is the tightening force, and 0 is the tightening angle.
[0053] However, these correlations demonstrated that equation (3) does not adhere well to the experimental results 22 illustrated in figure 9, that is, it is not feasible, due to unquantified physical factors, such as: screw torsion and resistances generated by thread friction and friction between the contact planes of the other components.
[0054] Thus, after correlating all experimental data with the prediction of equation (3) as shown in figure 9, a possible pattern was found that could be adjusted, which would be to correlate the analytical stiffness calculated by equation (2) and the experimentally measured stiffness, obtained by the slope of the curves of the clamping force vs. angle graph, as indicated as 23 in figure 9, for all 30 joints tested.
[0055] With this, a new empirically adjusted equation (4) was developed to satisfy the relationship between applied angle and generated clamping force. In this case, the adjustment was performed by the function |3(tm, p) as illustrated in figure 10. 360. (Fa — Fp) f 1 1 \ , , F ni l arãn ízH Equation (4)
[0056] In equation (4), 0 is the tightening angle required to achieve the target tightening that will complete the tightening method of this invention, Fa is the target tightening force, Fp is the tightening force generated by the pre-torque, p is the thread pitch of the screw, Kb is the stiffness of the screw, Km is the equivalent stiffness of the assembly that will be coupled through the frustum method, p is an empirical function that uses geometric data of the joint as input, where tm is the total thickness of the plates that will be coupled and the thread pitch of the screw is p, the empirical adjustment being illustrated in the graph of figure 10.
[0057] Once the angle to achieve the target tightening has been calculated, step (vi) occurs, applying this tightening using the angle control method. To apply this calculated angle, it is necessary to use tools that apply angle control, such as the 100 torque wrench equipped with a data acquisition system.
[0058] The tightening method, the subject of this invention, is able to address the physical behavior of the joint 30 relaxation, achieving an uncertainty of 5%. Another advantage of the tightening method of the present invention compared to others already known is that it can be measured at any point in the service life of joint 30, that is, it allows verification of whether the required tightening is within the limits established during aircraft maintenance procedures.
[0059] Additionally, the tightening method, which is the subject of this invention, meets cost requirements because it did not require the development of specific equipment for its application and makes use of a non-destructive elongation measurement method at the end of the screws, which traditionally have a flat surface.
[0060] Having described a preferred embodiment, it should be understood that the scope of the present object encompasses other possible variations, being limited only by the content of the appended claims, including possible equivalents.
Claims
CLAIMS 1. A tightening method for bolted joints subject to relaxation, characterized by comprising the following steps: (i) recording of a reference curve for each screw to be used in a no-load condition; (ii) applying a pre-torque to the bolts in step (i); (iii) rest time for joint relaxation; (iv) measuring the elongation of the screws after applying the pre-torque and converting the elongation into tightening force; (v) calculation of an angle to achieve a target tightening on the screws of step (iv); (vi) applying the angle calculated in step (v) to obtain the target tightening on the joint bolts.
2. Tightening method, according to claim 1, characterized in that in the step of recording a reference curve, the screws are decoupled and the ultrasonic reference curve is obtained from measuring the length of each screw using an ultrasonic signal applied to one end of the screw.
3. Tightening method according to claim 2, characterized in that the measurement for recording step (i) takes into account mechanical and geometric properties of the screws and ambient temperature for compensations due to thermal expansion.
4. Tightening method according to claim 1, characterized in that the pre-torque application step is performed by a torque control method that is determined by an equation (1) T = F. dn. k where T is the torque to be applied, F corresponds to 60% of the target tightening force, dn is the diameter of the screw, and k is a torque factor that is a constant equal to 0.
14.
5. Tightening method according to claim 1, characterized in that the resting time of step (iii) varies between 5 and 20 minutes, preferably between 10 and 15 minutes, the resting time varying as a function of sealant viscosity, tightening sequence, joint geometry and applied tightening force.
6. Tightening method according to claim 1, characterized in that the measurement of an elongation value of the screws after the application of pre-torque is done by means of an ultrasound signal applied to each screw; and a calculation of the difference in ultrasonic reflection time compared to the ultrasonic reference curve obtained in step (i).
7. A tightening method according to claim 6, characterized in that the calculated elongation values are converted into tightening force and then recorded.
8. Tightening method according to claim 1, characterized in that the calculation of an angle to achieve a target tightening on the screws of step (iv) is done from the equation where 0 is the angle to achieve a target tightening, Fa is the target tightening force, Fp is the tightening force generated by the pre-torque, p is the thread pitch of the screw, Kb is the screw stiffness, Km is the equivalent stiffness of the assembly to be coupled through a frustum method, is an empirical function that uses geometric data of the joint and tm is the total thickness of the plates to be coupled.
9. Tightening method, according to claim 8, characterized in that for step (v) torque x angle curves were obtained for different joint configurations.
10. Tightening method according to claim 1, characterized in that step (vi) is performed using a torque wrench (100) equipped with a data acquisition system.
