Control method, system and apparatus, and electronic device

By using at least two controllers to generate control commands simultaneously in the vehicle control system and using a weighted average algorithm to generate a third control command, the time delay and safety risks during controller switching are resolved, and the high reliability and safety of the vehicle control system are achieved.

WO2026237007A1PCT designated stage Publication Date: 2026-11-19YINWANG INTELLIGENT TECHNOLOGIES CO LTD
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
PCT/CN2025/095161
Authority / Receiving Office
WO · WO
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2025-05-15
Publication Date
2026-11-19

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

In existing vehicle control systems, there are time delays and safety risks during controller switching, and the loss of control caused by controller failure cannot be effectively avoided.

Method used

At least two controllers are used to generate control commands online simultaneously, and a third control command is generated through a weighted average algorithm. This ensures that the correct control command can still be output when the controller fails, avoiding time delays and safety risks during controller switching.

Benefits of technology

It improves the safety and reliability of the vehicle control system, avoids the loss of control when the controller malfunctions, reduces the probability of control errors and the amount of data processing, and improves control efficiency.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN2025095161_19112026_PF_FP_ABST
    Figure CN2025095161_19112026_PF_FP_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The present application relates to the field of vehicle control. In view of the problem of how to improve the reliability of a vehicle control system, the present application provides a control method, system and apparatus, and an electronic device. The control method provided in the present application is applied to a control system. The control system comprises at least a first controller and a second controller. The method comprises: acquiring a first control instruction generated by a first controller; acquiring a second control instruction generated by a second controller, wherein an input and control instruction generation logic of the second controller are the same as those of the first controller; and obtaining a third control instruction on the basis of the first control instruction and the second control instruction. On the basis of the method in the embodiments of the present application, the safety of a control system can be improved, and safety risks can be effectively avoided.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

A control method, system, device, and electronic device Technical Field

[0001] This application relates to the field of vehicle control, and in particular to a control method, system, device and electronic device. Background Technology

[0002] In daily life and production, vehicles have become an indispensable tool. Among vehicle usage scenarios, driving safety is the most crucial factor. To ensure driving safety, it is necessary to maximize the reliability of vehicle control.

[0003] The vehicle control system is an essential component for achieving vehicle control. Therefore, to improve the reliability of vehicle control, it is necessary to improve the reliability of the vehicle control system itself.

[0004] Therefore, a control method is needed to improve the reliability of vehicle control systems. Summary of the Invention

[0005] One feasible technical solution to improve the reliability of vehicle control systems is to enhance the safety level of the controllers within these systems. However, achieving a high level of safety for the controller requires significant costs, and even controllers with high safety levels are not immune to failure.

[0006] To address the issue of improving the reliability of vehicle control systems, another feasible technical solution is to employ a redundant controller approach. Specifically, multiple controllers are configured in the control system. One controller generates control commands to achieve vehicle control; when the controller generating the control commands fails, another controller is activated to generate control commands to achieve vehicle control.

[0007] While the above solution ensures that a usable controller is always present in the control system through controller switching, switching off a failed controller involves an interaction process between them. This requires a complex mechanism to ensure that the controller switching does not result in both controllers being online simultaneously. Furthermore, the controller switching process inevitably introduces a time delay issue; during the short period of switching, neither controller is in control, which could potentially introduce safety risks to the entire vehicle.

[0008] To address the aforementioned problems, this application provides a control method, system, apparatus, and electronic device. This application also provides a computer program product and a computer-readable storage medium.

[0009] The embodiments of this application adopt the following technical solutions:

[0010] Firstly, this application provides a control method in which the control system includes at least two controllers that simultaneously generate control commands online. The control system then obtains a third control command for implementing control based on the control commands generated by the at least two controllers.

[0011] Specifically, the control method provided in this application is applied to a control system, which includes at least a first controller and a second controller, and the method includes:

[0012] Obtain the first control command generated by the first controller;

[0013] Obtain the second control command generated by the second controller, wherein the input of the second controller and the control command generation logic are the same as those of the first controller;

[0014] The third control command is obtained based on the first control command and the second control command.

[0015] In the first aspect of the method, the inputs to the first controller and the second controller are the same, and the control command generation logic of the first controller and the second controller is the same. That is, when both the first controller and the second controller are operating normally, the first control command and the second control command are the same.

[0016] Furthermore, under normal operating conditions, both the first and second control commands generated by the first and second controllers can achieve correct control. Therefore, the third control command obtained based on the first and second control commands can also achieve correct control.

[0017] Furthermore, when one of the first and second controllers malfunctions, since both controllers were operational before the error occurred, no controller switching is required. In other words, a valid control command is always available before and after the error occurs, allowing a third control command to be generated to achieve correct control. The output of this third control command is time-delayed, effectively avoiding safety risks.

[0018] The method according to the embodiments of this application can avoid the loss of control state caused by switching the controller when the controller malfunctions, improve the safety of the control system, and effectively avoid safety risks.

[0019] Furthermore, in one implementation of the first aspect, the control instruction used to implement control is one of at least two control instructions output by at least two controllers; that is, one of multiple control instructions is selected as the control instruction used to implement control.

[0020] Specifically, in one implementation of the first aspect, the third control instruction is one of the first control instruction and the second control instruction.

[0021] Based on the above implementation method, selecting one of multiple control instructions as the control instruction for implementation can conveniently and quickly obtain the control instruction for implementation, reduce the amount of data processing for implementation, and improve control efficiency.

[0022] In the event of a controller malfunction, the control commands it generates based on the input information may be invalid or erroneous.

[0023] Specifically, in the embodiments of this application, invalid instructions include instructions with incomplete structure, missing parameters, or inability to perform normal control functions; erroneous instructions include instructions with incorrect parameters (e.g., parameter values ​​exceeding the normal range) or logical errors (e.g., the control logic corresponding to the current control instruction conflicts with the control logic of the previous control instruction).

[0024] Therefore, in one implementation of the first aspect, after receiving multiple control commands output by multiple controllers, invalid and erroneous commands among the multiple control commands are identified, thereby determining the correct command among the multiple control commands, and using the correct command as the control command to implement control.

[0025] Specifically, in one implementation of the first aspect, when one of the first control instruction and the second control instruction is an invalid instruction or an erroneous instruction, the third control instruction is the other of the first control instruction and the second control instruction.

[0026] Furthermore, in the absence of significant performance differences, the time taken for different controllers to generate control commands based on the same input and control logic is the same or similar. Therefore, in one implementation of the first aspect, when some controllers output control commands while others do not, control commands for control are obtained based on the received control commands.

[0027] Furthermore, in the first aspect of the method, multiple controllers in the control system generate multiple control commands respectively. If the multiple control commands are identical, two cases exist:

[0028] (1) Only when multiple controllers have errors and their error patterns are exactly the same can identical error instructions be generated.

[0029] (2) All controllers are working normally.

[0030] Considering that the probability of multiple controllers malfunctioning simultaneously and in exactly the same manner is very small, in one implementation of the first aspect, when multiple controllers in the control system generate multiple control commands, and these commands are identical, any one of the multiple control commands is selected as the control command to implement the control.

[0031] Furthermore, if multiple control instructions comprise two parts (a first part and a second part), where the first part contains multiple identical control instructions and the second part contains one or more control instructions, and the control instructions in the second part differ from those in the first part, and are all distinct from each other, then in one implementation of the first aspect, any one of the control instructions in the first part is selected as the control instruction for implementing control.

[0032] Based on the above implementation method, when there are multiple identical control instructions, selecting one of them as the control instruction to implement control can conveniently and quickly obtain the control instruction used to implement control, reduce the amount of data processing for control implementation, and improve control efficiency.

[0033] In control scenarios with complex control instructions, it is difficult to determine whether there are errors in the control instructions. This can lead to the actuator selecting the wrong control instruction when choosing from multiple control instructions, ultimately resulting in a control error.

[0034] In response to the above situation, in one implementation of the first aspect, a new control instruction is generated based on multiple control instructions, and the newly generated control instruction is used as the control instruction to implement control.

[0035] Specifically, in one implementation of the first aspect, the third control instruction is a new instruction generated based on the first control instruction and the second control instruction.

[0036] Because the newly generated control commands reference all control commands generated by the controllers, it effectively avoids missing correct control commands. Based on this implementation method, control reliability can be improved and the probability of control errors can be reduced.

[0037] Furthermore, multiple control commands generated by multiple controllers may contain erroneous control commands. If erroneous control commands cannot be accurately identified, during the process of generating new control commands based on all existing commands, erroneous commands may be included in the reference range, resulting in newly generated control commands containing incorrect execution parameters.

[0038] To address the above situation, in one implementation of the first aspect, a corresponding weight is assigned to each control instruction based on the probability of the control instruction being erroneous. The higher the probability of a control instruction being erroneous, the lower its corresponding weight. During the process of the actuator generating new control instructions based on all existing control instructions, the weights of the control instructions are introduced, ensuring that control instructions with lower weights have less impact on the newly generated control instructions, thereby reducing the probability and severity of errors in the newly generated control instructions.

[0039] Specifically, in one implementation of the first aspect, a third control instruction is obtained based on the first control instruction and the second control instruction, including:

[0040] Determine the weight of the control command, wherein the weight of the control command includes at least a first weight corresponding to the first control command and a second weight corresponding to the second control command;

[0041] The third control instruction is generated based on the first control instruction, the second control instruction, and the weights of the control instructions.

[0042] Based on the above implementation method, it is possible to effectively avoid missing correct control commands, reduce the probability of control commands containing errors, reduce the severity of control command errors, and improve the level of control security.

[0043] In one implementation of the first aspect, a weighted average algorithm is used to calculate the weighted average of the control parameter values ​​of the same parameter items in all control instructions according to the weight of each control instruction, and a new control instruction is generated based on the weighted average calculation result of each parameter item.

[0044] Specifically, in one implementation of the first aspect, a third control instruction is generated based on the first control instruction, the second control instruction, and the weights of the control instructions, including:

[0045] Based on the weighted average algorithm, the control parameter values ​​in the first and second control instructions are calculated by weighting according to the weight of the control instructions, and the third control instruction is generated based on the weighted average calculation result.

[0046] According to the method described above, a weighted average algorithm is used to calculate the weighted average of the control parameter values ​​in the control commands. This allows all control parameter values ​​from all control commands to be included in a reference range to generate new control commands, based on their respective weights. The method described in this application effectively avoids omitting correct control commands, reduces the probability of incorrect control commands, decreases the severity of errors in control commands, and improves control safety.

[0047] In one implementation of the first aspect, the probability of an error in the control instruction is determined based on the control instruction itself.

[0048] In some control scenarios, control commands include control parameter values. Since all actual conditions cannot be predicted in advance, it's impossible to accurately determine whether a control parameter value is erroneous simply by its magnitude if the value is within its limit threshold. However, when the control parameter value is too large or too small, the larger or smaller the value, the greater the likelihood of an erroneous control parameter.

[0049] Therefore, in one implementation of the first aspect, a preset range for the control parameter values ​​is predetermined, and the weight of the control command is determined based on the degree of deviation between the control parameter values ​​in the control command and the preset range. The greater the deviation between the control parameter values ​​in the control command and the preset range, the greater the possibility that the control parameter values ​​in the control command are erroneous, and the smaller the weight of the control command.

[0050] Specifically, in one implementation of the first aspect, determining the weight of the control instructions includes:

[0051] The first weight is determined based on the degree of deviation between the control parameter value in the first control command and the preset range;

[0052] And / or,

[0053] The second weight is determined based on the degree of deviation between the control parameter value in the second control command and the preset range.

[0054] Specifically, in one implementation of the first aspect, the preset range of control parameter values ​​is determined based on factors such as historical control records, ideal control scenarios, and preset control logic.

[0055] Based on the above implementation method, determining the weight of the control command according to the control parameter value in the control command can effectively reduce the impact of erroneous control parameter values ​​on the final control command, reduce the probability of the control command containing errors, reduce the severity of the control command containing errors, and improve the level of control safety.

[0056] In another implementation of the first aspect, the probability that the control command is erroneous is determined based on the controller that generates the control command.

[0057] Specifically, in another implementation of the first aspect, the confidence level of a controller is determined based on the probability that each controller in the control system generates an erroneous control command. The higher the confidence level of a controller, the lower its probability of generating an erroneous control command.

[0058] The weight of the control commands generated by the controller is determined based on the controller's confidence level. The higher the controller's confidence level, the lower the probability of it generating erroneous control commands, which means that the current control commands generated by the controller are less likely to be erroneous, and therefore the greater the weight of the control commands.

[0059] Specifically, in one implementation of the first aspect, determining the weight of the control instructions includes:

[0060] Obtain a first confidence level for the first controller, and determine a first weight based on the first confidence level, wherein the first confidence level is associated with the device parameters of the first controller;

[0061] And / or,

[0062] Obtain a second confidence level for the second controller, and determine a second weight based on the second confidence level, wherein the second confidence level is associated with the device parameters of the second controller.

[0063] Based on the above implementation method, the weight of the control command is determined according to the state (confidence) of the controller that generates the control command. This can accurately determine the probability of the control command containing errors, reduce the probability of the control command containing errors, reduce the severity of the errors in the control command, and improve the level of control safety.

[0064] In one implementation of the first aspect, the confidence level of the controller is determined based on its error history. For example, the higher the probability of generating erroneous control commands in the controller's error history, the lower the confidence level of the controller.

[0065] Furthermore, in control scenarios, controllers with the same structure and performance have approximately the same probability of experiencing logical calculation errors. Therefore, in one implementation of the first aspect, the confidence level of a controller is determined based on its error history. And, based on the confidence level of that controller, the confidence level of a controller of the same model is determined.

[0066] Based on the above implementation method, the accurate probability of the controller generating erroneous control commands can be obtained from the controller's error history, thereby obtaining a confidence level that can accurately describe the probability of the controller generating erroneous control commands, and thus further accurately determining the weight of the control commands.

[0067] In control scenarios, the probability of a controller generating erroneous control commands is directly related to the controller's own device parameters. For example, controllers with different structures and performance levels have different probabilities of logical calculation errors; a controller with higher security has a lower probability of generating erroneous control commands. Therefore, in one implementation of the first aspect, the controller's confidence level is determined based on its device parameters, including the controller's security level. The higher the controller's security level, the higher the confidence level.

[0068] Based on the above implementation method, the confidence level of the current controller is determined by the confidence level of the same type of controller. This yields a confidence level that can accurately describe the probability of the controller generating erroneous control commands, thereby allowing for a more accurate determination of the weight of the control commands.

[0069] In control scenarios, as the controller is used, its operating time increases, and so does its wear and tear. This increased operating time and wear leads to a decrease in device performance and safety levels, increasing the likelihood of the controller generating erroneous control commands. Therefore, in one implementation of the first aspect, the controller's confidence level is determined based on its device parameters, including operating time and / or wear and tear. A longer operating time corresponds to a lower confidence level, and higher wear and tear corresponds to a lower confidence level.

[0070] Specifically, in one implementation of the first aspect, the device parameters of the first controller include the operating time of the first controller and / or the wear and tear of the device; and / or, the device parameters of the second controller include the operating time of the second controller and / or the wear and tear of the device.

[0071] Based on the above implementation method, the confidence level of the controller is determined based on the controller's operating time and / or equipment wear level. This yields a confidence level that accurately describes the probability of the controller generating erroneous control commands, thereby enabling a more accurate determination of the weights of the control commands.

[0072] Secondly, one embodiment of this application provides a control system, which includes at least a first controller and a second controller, wherein the first controller is used to generate a first control command, the second controller is used to generate a second control command, and the input and control command generation logic of the second controller are the same as those of the first controller.

[0073] The control system also includes an actuator, which is used to obtain a third control command based on the first control command and the second control command, wherein the third control command is used to control the vehicle.

[0074] In one implementation of the second aspect, the actuator is configured such that the third control instruction is one of the first control instruction and the second control instruction.

[0075] In one implementation of the second aspect, the actuator is configured such that, when one of the first control instruction and the second control instruction is an invalid or erroneous instruction, the third control instruction is the other of the first control instruction and the second control instruction.

[0076] In one implementation of the second aspect, the actuator is configured such that the third control instruction is a new instruction generated based on the first control instruction and the second control instruction.

[0077] In one implementation of the second aspect, the executor is configured as follows:

[0078] Determine the weight of the control command, wherein the weight of the control command includes at least a first weight corresponding to the first control command and a second weight corresponding to the second control command;

[0079] The third control instruction is generated based on the first control instruction, the second control instruction, and the weights of the control instructions.

[0080] In one implementation of the second aspect, the executor is configured as follows:

[0081] Based on the weighted average algorithm, the control parameter values ​​in the first and second control instructions are calculated by weighting according to the weight of the control instructions, and the third control instruction is generated based on the weighted average calculation result.

[0082] In one implementation of the second aspect, the executor is configured as follows:

[0083] The first weight is determined based on the degree of deviation between the control parameter value in the first control command and the preset range;

[0084] And / or,

[0085] The second weight is determined based on the degree of deviation between the control parameter value in the second control command and the first preset range.

[0086] In one implementation of the second aspect, the executor is configured as follows:

[0087] Obtain a first confidence level for the first controller, and determine a first weight based on the first confidence level, wherein the first confidence level is associated with the device parameters of the first controller;

[0088] And / or,

[0089] Obtain a second confidence level for the second controller, and determine a second weight based on the second confidence level, wherein the second confidence level is associated with the device parameters of the second controller.

[0090] In one implementation of the second aspect:

[0091] The device parameters of the first controller include the operating time of the first controller and / or the degree of wear and tear of the device;

[0092] And / or,

[0093] The device parameters of the second controller include the operating time of the second controller and / or the wear and tear of the device.

[0094] Thirdly, one embodiment of this application provides an execution device, the device comprising:

[0095] A control instruction receiving module is used to receive control instructions from the controller. The control instructions from the controller include at least a first control instruction from the first controller and a second control instruction from the second controller. The input and control instruction generation logic of the second controller are the same as those of the first controller.

[0096] The control instruction generation module is used to obtain a third control instruction based on the first control instruction and the second control instruction.

[0097] Fourthly, one embodiment of this application provides a vehicle that includes the control system described in the second aspect.

[0098] Fifthly, one embodiment of this application provides an electronic device, which includes a memory and a processor;

[0099] The processor executes instructions stored in memory to cause the electronic device to perform the method as described in the first aspect.

[0100] In a sixth aspect, one embodiment of this application provides a computer program product containing instructions that, when executed by a computing device system, cause a cluster of computing devices to perform the method as described in the first aspect.

[0101] In a seventh aspect, one embodiment of this application provides a computer-readable storage medium including computer program instructions, which, when executed by a computer system, cause the computer system to perform the method as described in the first aspect. Attached Figure Description

[0102] Figure 1 shows a schematic diagram of a control system structure according to an embodiment of this application;

[0103] Figure 2 is a flowchart of a control method according to an embodiment of this application;

[0104] Figure 3 is a partial flowchart of a method according to an embodiment of this application;

[0105] Figure 4 is a partial flowchart of a method according to an embodiment of this application;

[0106] Figure 5 is a partial flowchart of a method according to an embodiment of this application;

[0107] Figure 6 is a partial flowchart of a method according to an embodiment of this application;

[0108] Figure 7 is a partial flowchart of a method according to an embodiment of this application;

[0109] Figure 8 shows a schematic diagram of a control system structure according to an embodiment of this application;

[0110] Figure 9 is a partial flowchart of a method according to an embodiment of this application;

[0111] Figure 10 shows a schematic diagram of a control system structure according to an embodiment of this application;

[0112] Figure 11 shows a schematic diagram of a control system structure according to an embodiment of this application;

[0113] Figure 12 shows a schematic diagram of a control system structure according to an embodiment of this application;

[0114] Figure 13 shows a schematic diagram of a control system structure according to an embodiment of this application;

[0115] Figure 14 is a schematic diagram of the structure of an execution device according to an embodiment of this application;

[0116] Figure 15 is a schematic diagram of an electronic device structure according to an embodiment of this application. Detailed Implementation

[0117] To make the objectives, technical solutions, and advantages of this application clearer, the technical solutions of this application will be clearly and completely described below in conjunction with specific embodiments and corresponding drawings. Obviously, the described embodiments are only a part of the embodiments of this application, and not all of them. Based on the embodiments in this application, all other embodiments obtained by those skilled in the art without creative effort are within the scope of protection of this application.

[0118] The terminology used in the implementation section of this application is for the purpose of explaining specific embodiments of this application only, and is not intended to limit this application.

[0119] A critical component in a vehicle control system is the controller, which generates control commands. When the controller becomes unavailable, the entire vehicle control system malfunctions. Therefore, one feasible technical solution to improve the reliability of vehicle control systems is to enhance the security level of the controller. This can be achieved by using high-security components throughout the controller, employing multiple embedded chips for mutual verification, or using a lockstep core to ensure the validity of calculations.

[0120] However, achieving a high level of security for a controller requires significant costs, and even controllers with high security levels cannot avoid controller failures.

[0121] To address the issue of improving the reliability of vehicle control systems, another feasible technical solution is to employ a redundant controller approach. Specifically, multiple controllers are configured in the control system. One controller generates control commands to achieve vehicle control; when the controller generating the control commands fails, another controller is activated to generate control commands to achieve vehicle control.

[0122] While the above solution ensures that a usable controller is always available in the control system through controller switching, switching to another controller when one fails involves an interaction process between the controllers. This requires a complex mechanism to ensure that the controller switching does not result in a scenario where both controllers are online simultaneously. Furthermore, the controller switching process inevitably introduces a short-term loss of control, during which no controller is in a controlling state, which may pose a safety risk to the entire vehicle.

[0123] To address the aforementioned problems, one embodiment of this application provides a control method and a control system using the method.

[0124] In the control method provided in this application, the control system includes at least two controllers, which simultaneously generate control commands online. Based on the control commands generated by the at least two controllers, the control system obtains a third control command ultimately used to implement control.

[0125] Figure 1 shows a schematic diagram of a control system structure according to an embodiment of this application.

[0126] As shown in Figure 1, in one embodiment, the control system 100 includes at least a controller 101 (first controller) and a controller 102 (second controller).

[0127] When both controllers 101 and 102 are operating normally, both controllers 101 and 102 are simultaneously in operation. Controller 101 generates a first control command based on input. Controller 102 generates a second control command based on input.

[0128] The control system 100 also includes an actuator 103, which is used to obtain a third control command for implementing control based on the first control command and the second control command.

[0129] Figure 2 shows a flowchart of a control method according to an embodiment of the present application. The control system 100 shown in Figure 1 executes the following process as shown in Figure 2 to obtain a third control command for implementing control.

[0130] S200, the control system 100 receives input information for generating control commands.

[0131] S201, the controller 101 generates the first control command based on the input information.

[0132] S202, the controller 102 generates a second control command based on the input information.

[0133] S203, the actuator 103 obtains a third control instruction for implementing control based on the first control instruction and the second control instruction.

[0134] In this embodiment, the inputs to controller 101 and controller 102 are the same, and the control command generation logic for controller 101 and controller 102 is the same. That is, when both controller 101 and controller 102 are operating normally, the first control command and the second control command are the same.

[0135] Furthermore, under normal operating conditions, the first and second control commands generated by controllers 101 and 102 can achieve correct control. Therefore, the third control command obtained by actuator 103 based on the first and second control commands can also achieve correct control.

[0136] Furthermore, when one of controllers 101 and 102 malfunctions, since both controllers 101 and 102 were always operational before the error occurred, no controller switching is required. In other words, before and after the malfunction of either controller 101 or 102, there is always a correct control command input to actuator 103, allowing actuator 103 to maintain the output of a third control command that achieves correct control. The process of actuator 103 outputting the third control command is delay-free, effectively avoiding safety risks.

[0137] The method according to the embodiments of this application can avoid the loss of control state caused by switching the controller when the controller malfunctions, improve the safety of the control system, and effectively avoid safety risks.

[0138] Furthermore, provided that the control system includes at least two controllers, the embodiments of this application do not impose specific limitations on the number of controllers included in the control system.

[0139] For example, in one embodiment, the control system includes two or more controllers (e.g., three or more). This way, even if two controllers malfunction, the remaining controllers can still ensure that the control system performs correctly, thereby effectively improving the safety of the control system.

[0140] For example, in another embodiment, the control system contains only two controllers (as shown in Figure 1), thereby effectively controlling the cost of the control system.

[0141] Furthermore, in this embodiment, the controller in the control system can be any hardware device capable of loading preset operational logic and generating control commands through logical operations based on input. This embodiment does not impose specific limitations on the hardware device used to implement the controller in the control system; those skilled in the art can select appropriate hardware devices to implement the controller according to actual needs.

[0142] For example, in one embodiment, the controller can be implemented using, for example, a central processing unit (CPU), a digital signal processor (DSP), a microcontroller (MCU), or a microprocessor unit (MPU).

[0143] Furthermore, in the field of control, controllers with different hardware parameters have varying computational performance, and certain types of controllers possess unique functions. This necessitates engineers designing matching computational logic (software code) for each controller to effectively utilize its capabilities. According to the method in this application embodiment, the control system includes at least two controllers. Therefore, if the hardware parameters of different controllers in the control system differ, matching computational logic needs to be designed for each controller, which undoubtedly increases the development difficulty and workload.

[0144] Therefore, in one embodiment, the multiple controllers included in the control system are controllers with the same or similar hardware parameters. In this way, only one set of operational logic needs to be designed to match all controllers in the control system. For example, in the embodiment shown in Figure 1, controller 101 and controller 102 have the same or similar hardware parameters.

[0145] In this application embodiment, identical hardware parameters refer to identical hardware characteristics such as structure, function, and computing efficiency. For example, controllers of the same product model from the same manufacturer.

[0146] In this embodiment, similar hardware parameters refer to similar hardware features such as structure and function. Controllers with similar hardware parameters can load the same software code. After loading the same software code, controllers with similar hardware parameters can receive the same input, perform calculations with the same or similar computational efficiency, use the same computational logic, and generate the same control instructions. Controllers with similar hardware parameters may contain different functional modules, but the differences in their functional modules do not affect the control instruction generation process.

[0147] For example, controllers from different batches produced by the same manufacturer on the same product line; or, for example, controllers from different versions within the same product series produced by the same manufacturer.

[0148] According to the method in the embodiments of this application, using multiple controllers with the same hardware parameters as controllers in the control system can effectively reduce development difficulty and workload.

[0149] Furthermore, in this embodiment, the actuator in the control system is any hardware device capable of loading preset operational logic and obtaining control instructions for implementing control based on input control instructions. This embodiment does not impose specific limitations on the hardware device used to implement the actuator in the control system; those skilled in the art can select appropriate hardware devices to implement the actuator in the control system according to actual needs.

[0150] For example, in one embodiment, the actuator can be implemented using, for example, a central processing unit (CPU), a digital signal processor (DSP), a microcontroller (MCU), or a microprocessor unit (MPU).

[0151] Furthermore, in one embodiment, the actuator further includes a drive module that drives the execution device according to control instructions and / or an execution device that directly performs operations according to direct control instructions.

[0152] Furthermore, in this embodiment, the actuator in the control system (e.g., actuator 103) is used to obtain a control instruction (third control instruction) for implementing control based on control instructions output by at least two controllers (including at least a first control instruction and a second control instruction). This embodiment does not specifically limit the implementation logic of the actuator obtaining the third control instruction. Those skilled in the art can design the implementation logic of the actuator obtaining the third control instruction according to actual needs.

[0153] For example, in one embodiment, a control instruction for implementing control is one of at least two control instructions output by at least two controllers; that is, the actuator of the control system selects one of a plurality of control instructions as the control instruction for implementing control.

[0154] For example, in a control system that includes two controllers, which output a first control command and a second control command respectively, the third control command is one of the first control command and the second control command.

[0155] Taking the control system shown in Figure 1 as an example, in one embodiment, in S203, the actuator 103 selects one of the first control command and the second control command as the third control command.

[0156] According to the method of the embodiments of this application, selecting one of a plurality of control instructions as the control instruction for implementing control can conveniently and quickly obtain the control instruction for implementing control, reduce the amount of data processing for implementing control, and improve control efficiency.

[0157] Specifically, the following examples illustrate the process by which an actuator selects one of multiple control instructions as the control instruction to implement control, using application scenarios as examples.

[0158] In the event of a controller malfunction, the control commands it generates based on the input information may be invalid or erroneous.

[0159] Specifically, in the embodiments of this application, invalid instructions include instructions with incomplete structure, missing parameters, or inability to perform normal control functions; erroneous instructions include instructions with incorrect parameters (e.g., parameter values ​​exceeding the normal range) or logical errors (e.g., the control logic corresponding to the current control instruction conflicts with the control logic of the previous control instruction).

[0160] Therefore, in one embodiment, after the actuator receives multiple control commands output by multiple controllers, it identifies invalid and erroneous commands among the multiple control commands, thereby determining the correct command among the multiple control commands, and using the correct command as the control command to implement control.

[0161] Taking the control system shown in Figure 1 as an example, in one embodiment, in S203, the actuator 103 receives a first control command and a second control command, identifies an invalid or erroneous command in the first and second control commands, and when one of the first and second control commands is an invalid or erroneous command, the third control command is the other of the first and second control commands.

[0162] Figure 3 shows a partial method flowchart according to an embodiment of this application.

[0163] S300, actuator 103 receives the first control command output by controller 101 and the second control command output by controller 102.

[0164] S301, Actuator 103 identifies invalid and erroneous instructions in the first and second control instructions.

[0165] When the first control instruction is an invalid or erroneous instruction, execute S302.

[0166] S302, actuator 103 uses the second control command as the third control command.

[0167] When the second control instruction is an invalid or erroneous instruction, execute S303.

[0168] S303, actuator 103 uses the first control command as the third control command.

[0169] Furthermore, in the absence of significant performance differences, the time taken for different controllers to generate control commands based on the same input and control logic is the same or similar (the time difference is very small and can be ignored). Therefore, in one embodiment, if at a certain moment (or within a very short time period, for example, within 2ms), if some controllers output control commands while others do not, it is considered that the controllers that did not output control commands have an error, and the actuator obtains control commands for control based on the received control commands.

[0170] Taking the control system shown in Figure 1 as an example, in one embodiment, in S203, at a certain moment (or within a very short time period, for example, within 2ms), the actuator 103 receives only the first control command or the second control command, and then the received first control command or the second control command is used as the third control command.

[0171] Figure 4 shows a partial method flowchart according to an embodiment of this application.

[0172] S400, actuator 103 receives control commands output by controller 101 and controller 102.

[0173] When actuator 103 receives only the first control command or the second control command, it executes S401.

[0174] S401, the actuator 103 uses the received first control command or second control command as the third control command.

[0175] When the actuator 103 receives the first control command and the second control command, it executes S402.

[0176] S402, Actuator 103 identifies invalid and erroneous instructions in the first and second control instructions.

[0177] When the first control instruction is an invalid or erroneous instruction, execute S403.

[0178] S403, actuator 103 uses the second control command as the third control command.

[0179] When the second control instruction is an invalid or erroneous instruction, execute S404.

[0180] S404, actuator 103 uses the second control command as the third control command.

[0181] Furthermore, according to the method of this application embodiment, multiple controllers in the control system generate multiple control commands respectively. If the multiple control commands are completely identical, there are two possibilities:

[0182] (1) Only when multiple controllers have errors and their error patterns are exactly the same can identical error instructions be generated.

[0183] (2) All controllers are working normally.

[0184] Considering that the probability of multiple controllers malfunctioning simultaneously, and that the malfunctions are exactly the same, in one embodiment, when multiple controllers in the control system generate multiple control commands, and these multiple control commands are identical, the actuator selects any one of the multiple control commands as the control command to implement the control.

[0185] Taking the control system shown in Figure 1 as an example, in one embodiment, in S203, the actuator 103 receives a first control instruction and a second control instruction. If the first control instruction and the second control instruction are exactly the same, then the first control instruction or the second control instruction is selected as the third control instruction.

[0186] If multiple control commands are different, in one embodiment, the correct command among the multiple control commands is identified and used as the control command to implement control. For example, invalid and erroneous commands among the multiple control commands are eliminated, and the remaining control command is the correct command.

[0187] Taking the control system shown in Figure 1 as an example, in one embodiment, in S203, the actuator 103 receives a first control command and a second control command, identifies an invalid or erroneous command in the first and second control commands, and when one of the first and second control commands is an invalid or erroneous command, the third control command is the other of the first and second control commands.

[0188] Figure 5 shows a partial method flowchart according to an embodiment of this application.

[0189] S500, actuator 103 receives control commands output by controller 101 and controller 102.

[0190] When the actuator 103 receives only the first control command or the second control command, it executes S501.

[0191] S501, the actuator 103 uses the received first control command or second control command as the third control command.

[0192] When the actuator 103 receives the first control command and the second control command, it executes S502.

[0193] S502, Actuator 103 compares the first control command and the second control command.

[0194] If the first control instruction and the second control instruction are exactly the same, execute S503.

[0195] S503, the actuator 103 uses the first control command or the second control command as the third control command.

[0196] If the first control instruction and the second control instruction are different, execute S504.

[0197] S504, Actuator 103 identifies invalid and erroneous instructions in the first and second control instructions.

[0198] When the first control instruction is an invalid or erroneous instruction, S505 is executed.

[0199] S505, actuator 103 uses the second control command as the third control command.

[0200] When the second control instruction is an invalid or erroneous instruction, execute S506.

[0201] S506, actuator 103 uses the second control command as the third control command.

[0202] According to the method of the embodiments of this application, when there are multiple identical control instructions, one of them is selected as the control instruction to implement control, which can conveniently and quickly obtain the control instruction to implement control, reduce the amount of data processing to implement control, and improve control efficiency.

[0203] Furthermore, if multiple control instructions comprise two parts (a first part and a second part), where the first part contains multiple identical control instructions and the second part contains one or more control instructions, and the control instructions in the second part differ from those in the first part, and are mutually exclusive, then in one embodiment, given the low probability that multiple controllers will simultaneously malfunction in the same manner, the actuator selects any one of the control instructions from the first part as the control instruction to implement control.

[0204] In the above embodiments, the actuator of the control system selects one control command from multiple control commands generated by multiple controllers to implement control. However, in control scenarios with complex control commands, it is difficult to determine whether the control command is erroneous. This can lead to the actuator selecting an incorrect control command when choosing from multiple control commands, ultimately resulting in a control error.

[0205] To address the above situation, in one embodiment, the actuator does not select one of multiple control instructions as the control instruction to implement control. Instead, it generates a new control instruction based on the multiple control instructions and uses this newly generated control instruction as the control instruction to implement control. Since the newly generated control instruction references all control instructions generated by the controller, it can effectively avoid omitting correct control instructions. The method according to the embodiments of this application can improve control reliability and reduce the probability of control errors.

[0206] Furthermore, multiple control instructions generated by multiple controllers may contain erroneous control instructions. If erroneous control instructions cannot be accurately identified, the actuator may include erroneous control instructions in the reference range during the process of generating new control instructions based on all control instructions, resulting in erroneous execution parameters in the newly generated control instructions.

[0207] To address the above situation, in one embodiment, control instructions are assigned corresponding weights based on the probability of errors. The higher the probability of an error in a control instruction, the lower its corresponding weight. During the process of the actuator generating new control instructions based on all existing control instructions, the weights of the control instructions are introduced, ensuring that control instructions with lower weights have less impact on the newly generated control instructions. This reduces the probability and severity of errors in the newly generated control instructions.

[0208] Taking the control system shown in Figure 1 as an example, Figure 6 shows a partial method flowchart according to an embodiment of this application.

[0209] S600, actuator 103 receives the first control command output by controller 101 and the second control command output by controller 102.

[0210] S601, the actuator 103 determines the first weight corresponding to the first control instruction and the second weight corresponding to the second control instruction.

[0211] S602, the actuator 103 generates a third control instruction based on the first control instruction, the second control instruction, the first weight corresponding to the first control instruction, and the second weight corresponding to the second control instruction.

[0212] The method according to the embodiments of this application can effectively avoid missing correct control commands, reduce the probability of control commands containing errors, reduce the severity of control commands containing errors, and improve the level of control safety.

[0213] This application does not impose specific limitations on the implementation method for determining the probability of errors in control commands and assigning corresponding weights to the control commands. Those skilled in the art can design implementation methods for determining the probability of errors in control commands and assigning corresponding weights to the control commands according to actual needs.

[0214] In one embodiment, the probability that the control command is erroneous is determined based on the control command itself.

[0215] Specifically, in some control scenarios, control commands include control parameter values. Since all actual situations cannot be predicted in advance, if the control parameter value does not exceed the limit threshold, it is impossible to accurately determine whether the control parameter value is erroneous simply by its magnitude. However, if the control parameter value is too large or too small, the larger or smaller the control parameter value, the greater the possibility of an erroneous control parameter value.

[0216] Therefore, in one embodiment, a preset range for the control parameter value is determined in advance. The weight of the control command is determined based on the degree of deviation between the control parameter value in the control command and the preset range. The greater the deviation between the control parameter value in the control command and the preset range, the greater the possibility of an error in the control parameter value in the control command, and the smaller the weight of the control command.

[0217] Specifically, in one embodiment, the preset range of control parameter values ​​is determined based on factors such as historical control records, ideal control scenarios, and preset control logic.

[0218] Taking the control system shown in Figure 1 as an example, Figure 7 shows a partial method flowchart according to an embodiment of this application.

[0219] S700, actuator 103 receives the first control command output by controller 101 and the second control command output by controller 102.

[0220] S701, Actuator 103 calls the preset range of control parameter values.

[0221] S702, the actuator 103 determines the first weight corresponding to the first control instruction based on the degree of deviation between the control parameter value in the first control instruction and the preset range.

[0222] S703, the actuator 103 determines the second weight of the corresponding second control instruction based on the degree of deviation between the control parameter value in the second control instruction and the preset range.

[0223] S704, the actuator 103 generates a third control instruction based on the first control instruction, the second control instruction, the first weight corresponding to the first control instruction, and the second weight corresponding to the second control instruction.

[0224] According to the method in the embodiments of this application, the weight of the control instruction is determined based on the control parameter value in the control instruction. This can effectively reduce the impact of erroneous control parameter values ​​on the final control instruction, reduce the probability of the control instruction containing errors, reduce the severity of the errors in the control instruction, and improve the level of control safety.

[0225] Furthermore, in the embodiment shown in Figure 7, the weight of the corresponding control command is determined by the actuator. In another embodiment, a module specifically for assigning weights to control commands can be configured in the control system.

[0226] For example, Figure 8 shows a schematic diagram of a control system structure according to an embodiment of this application.

[0227] As shown in Figure 8, in one embodiment, the control system 800 includes at least a controller 801 (first controller) and a controller 802 (second controller). Controller 801 and controller 802 can be referenced to controller 101 and controller 102, respectively.

[0228] Controller 801 is used to generate a first control command based on the input. Controller 802 is used to generate a second control command based on the input.

[0229] The control system 800 also includes a weight calculation module 804 and an actuator 803.

[0230] The weight calculation module 804 is used to receive the first control instruction and the second control instruction, determine the first weight corresponding to the first control instruction and the second weight corresponding to the second control instruction, and send the first control instruction, the second control instruction, the first weight corresponding to the first control instruction and the second weight corresponding to the second control instruction to the actuator 803.

[0231] The actuator 803 is used to generate a third control instruction for implementing control based on the first control instruction, the second control instruction, the first weight corresponding to the first control instruction, and the second weight corresponding to the second control instruction.

[0232] In one embodiment, the controller that generates the control command determines the probability that the control command is erroneous.

[0233] Specifically, in one embodiment, the confidence level of a controller is determined based on the probability that each controller in the control system generates an erroneous control command. The higher the confidence level of a controller, the lower the probability that it will generate an erroneous control command.

[0234] The weight of the control commands generated by the controller is determined based on the controller's confidence level. The higher the controller's confidence level, the lower the probability of it generating erroneous control commands, which means that the current control commands generated by the controller are less likely to be erroneous, and therefore the greater the weight of the control commands.

[0235] Taking the control system shown in Figure 1 as an example, Figure 9 shows a partial method flowchart according to an embodiment of this application.

[0236] S900, actuator 103 receives the first control command output by controller 101 and the second control command output by controller 102.

[0237] S901, the actuator 103 obtains the first confidence level of the controller 101 and the second confidence level of the controller 102.

[0238] This application does not impose specific limitations on the method or process for determining the confidence level of a controller. Those skilled in the art can design a method for determining the confidence level of a controller according to actual needs.

[0239] For example, in one embodiment, the confidence level of the controller is determined based on its error history. For instance, the higher the probability of generating erroneous control commands in the controller's error history, the lower the confidence level of the controller. Furthermore, in a control scenario, controllers with the same structure and performance have approximately the same probability of experiencing logical calculation errors. Therefore, in one embodiment, the confidence level of a controller is determined based on its error history. And, based on the confidence level of this controller, the confidence level of controllers of the same model is determined.

[0240] According to the method in the embodiments of this application, based on the controller's error history, the accurate probability of the controller generating erroneous control commands can be obtained, thereby obtaining a confidence level that can accurately describe the probability of the controller generating erroneous control commands, and thus the weight of the control commands can be further accurately determined.

[0241] For example, in a control scenario, the probability of a controller generating erroneous control commands is directly related to the controller's own device parameters. For instance, controllers with different structures and performance levels have different probabilities of logical calculation errors; a controller with higher security has a lower probability of generating erroneous control commands. Therefore, in one embodiment, the controller's confidence level is determined based on its device parameters, including its security level. The higher the security level of the controller, the higher the confidence level.

[0242] According to the method in the embodiments of this application, the confidence level of the current controller is determined based on the confidence level of controllers of the same model. This can obtain a confidence level that can accurately describe the probability of the controller generating erroneous control commands, thereby further accurately determining the weight of the control commands.

[0243] For example, in a control scenario, as the controller is used, its operating time increases, and so does its wear and tear. This increased operating time and wear leads to a decrease in device performance and safety levels, increasing the likelihood of the controller generating erroneous control commands. Therefore, in one embodiment, the controller's confidence level is determined based on its device parameters, including operating time and / or wear and tear. A longer operating time corresponds to a lower confidence level, and higher wear and tear corresponds to a lower confidence level.

[0244] According to the method of the embodiments of this application, the confidence level of the controller is determined based on the controller's working time and / or equipment wear, which can obtain a confidence level that can accurately describe the probability of the controller generating erroneous control commands, thereby further accurately determining the weight of the control commands.

[0245] Furthermore, in control scenarios, controllers with different functions are better suited to different types of logical operations. When the algorithm logic invoked to generate control commands is a type of logical operation the controller is good at, the probability of logical calculation errors is relatively low; conversely, when the algorithm logic invoked to generate control commands is a type of logical operation the controller is not good at, the probability of logical calculation errors is relatively high. Therefore, in one embodiment, the controller's confidence level is determined based on the controller's device parameters and the type of control command. When the algorithm logic invoked to generate control commands is a type of logical operation the controller is good at, the controller's confidence level is relatively high; when the algorithm logic invoked to generate control commands is a type of logical operation the controller is not good at, the controller's confidence level is relatively low.

[0246] Furthermore, in one embodiment, the controller determines its own confidence level and sends its confidence level to the actuator.

[0247] In another embodiment, a module specifically designed to determine the controller confidence level can be configured in the control system.

[0248] For example, Figure 10 shows a schematic diagram of a control system structure according to an embodiment of this application.

[0249] As shown in Figure 10, in one embodiment, the control system 1000 includes at least a controller 1001 (first controller) and a controller 1002 (second controller). Controller 1001 and controller 1002 can be referenced to controller 101 and controller 102, respectively.

[0250] Controller 1001 is used to generate a first control command based on the input. Controller 1002 is used to generate a second control command based on the input.

[0251] The control system 1000 also includes a confidence calculation module 1004 and an actuator 1003.

[0252] The confidence calculation module 1004 is used to calculate the first confidence level of controller 1001 and the second confidence level of controller 1002, and send the first confidence level of controller 1001 and the second confidence level of controller 1002 to actuator 1003.

[0253] The actuator 1003 is used to determine the first weight corresponding to the first control instruction and the second weight corresponding to the second control instruction based on the first confidence level of the controller 1001 and the second confidence level of the controller 1002, and to generate a third control instruction for implementing control based on the first control instruction, the second control instruction, the first weight corresponding to the first control instruction and the second weight corresponding to the second control instruction.

[0254] This application does not impose specific limitations on the process by which the actuator acquires the controller confidence level. Those skilled in the art can design a similar process based on actual needs.

[0255] For example, in one embodiment, the actuator obtains the confidence level of the controller each time it receives a control command. For example, after the controller 101 generates a first control command, it sends the first control command and the first confidence level of the controller 101 to the actuator 103; after the controller 102 generates a second control command, it sends the second control command and the second confidence level of the controller 102 to the actuator 103.

[0256] For example, in another embodiment, the actuator periodically acquires and saves the confidence level of the controller, and replaces the old confidence level with the latest confidence level each time a new confidence level is received; when the actuator receives a control command, it calls the saved confidence level.

[0257] S902, the actuator 103 determines a first weight corresponding to the first control instruction based on a first confidence level, and determines a second weight corresponding to the first control instruction based on a second confidence level.

[0258] This application does not impose specific limitations on the algorithm for calculating the weight of control commands based on the controller's confidence level. Those skilled in the art can design algorithms for calculating the weight of control commands based on the controller's confidence level according to actual needs.

[0259] For example, in one embodiment, the confidence level of the controller is directly used as the weight of the control command.

[0260] For example, in another embodiment, the confidence level of the control command is determined based on the control command, and the weight of the control command is calculated based on the confidence level of the control command and the confidence level of the controller; the higher the confidence level of the control command, the higher the weight of the control command; the higher the confidence level of the controller, the higher the weight of the control command. For example, the confidence level of the control command is multiplied by the confidence level of the controller, and the product is used as the weight of the control command.

[0261] Specifically, in one embodiment, the process of determining the confidence level of a control command can refer to judging the probability of the control command being erroneous based on the control command itself. The higher the probability of the control command being erroneous, the lower the confidence level of the control command. For example, a preset range for a control parameter value is predetermined, and the confidence level of the control command is determined based on the degree of deviation between the control parameter value in the control command and the preset range. The greater the deviation between the control parameter value in the control command and the preset range, the greater the possibility that the control parameter value in the control command is erroneous, and the lower the confidence level of the control command.

[0262] S903, the actuator 103 generates a third control instruction based on the first control instruction, the second control instruction, the first weight corresponding to the first control instruction, and the second weight corresponding to the second control instruction.

[0263] According to the method in the embodiments of this application, the weight of the control command is determined based on the state (confidence) of the controller that generates the control command. This can accurately determine the probability that the control command contains errors, reduce the probability that the control command contains errors, reduce the severity of the errors in the control command, and improve the level of control safety.

[0264] Furthermore, regarding the scheme of generating a single control command to implement control based on multiple control commands by combining the weights of the control commands, the embodiments of this application do not impose specific limitations on the algorithm for calculating the weights of the control commands. Those skilled in the art can design specific algorithms for generating a single control command to implement control based on multiple control commands, according to actual needs.

[0265] For example, in one embodiment, based on a weighted average algorithm, the control parameter values ​​of the same parameter items in all control instructions are calculated by weighting according to the weight of each control instruction, and a new control instruction is generated based on the weighted average calculation result of each parameter item.

[0266] Based on the weighted average algorithm, the control parameter values ​​in the first and second control instructions are calculated by weighting according to the weight of the control instructions, and the third control instruction is generated based on the weighted average calculation result.

[0267] For example, suppose the parameter value of parameter A in the first control instruction is a1, and the parameter value of parameter A in the second control instruction is a2. The weight of the first control instruction is Q1, and the weight of the second control instruction is Q2.

[0268] Therefore, the third control instruction generated based on the first and second control instructions includes parameter A. The value of parameter A in the third control instruction is a3. Where: a3=a1*Q1 / (Q1+Q2)+a2*Q2 / (Q1+Q2), (Formula 1)

[0269] For example, suppose the parameter value of parameter A in the first control instruction is a1, and the parameter value of parameter A in the second control instruction is a2. The weight of the first control instruction is Q1, and the weight of the second control instruction is Q2. Furthermore, the standard value of parameter A is a0.

[0270] Therefore, the third control instruction generated based on the first and second control instructions includes parameter A. The value of parameter A in the third control instruction is a3. Where: a3=a0+(a1-a0)*Q1 / (Q1+Q2)+(a2-a0)*Q2 / (Q1+Q2), (Formula 2)

[0271] According to the method of this application embodiment, a weighted average algorithm is used to calculate the control parameter values ​​in the control instructions. This allows all control parameter values ​​of all control instructions to be included in a reference range to generate new control instructions, based on their respective weights. The method of this application embodiment can effectively avoid omitting correct control instructions, reduce the probability of incorrect control instructions, decrease the severity of incorrect control instructions, and improve control safety.

[0272] The control method and control system provided in this application can be applied to the field of vehicle control, and can also be applied to other control fields, such as production line control.

[0273] The following describes the application flow of the control method and control system provided in the embodiments of this application based on different control scenarios in the field of vehicle control.

[0274] Figure 11 shows a schematic diagram of a control system structure according to an embodiment of this application.

[0275] As shown in Figure 11, the control system 1100 is a control system for controlling the vehicle motor 1111 according to the pedal signal of the vehicle accelerator pedal.

[0276] The control system 1100 includes a controller 1101 (first controller), a controller 1102 (second controller), and an actuator 1103.

[0277] The input to the control system 1100 is the pedal signal output from the accelerator pedal 1110. The pedal signal output from the accelerator pedal 1110 is input to controllers 1101 and 1102. Controller 1101 generates torque signal A based on the pedal signal. Controller 1102 generates torque signal B based on the pedal signal.

[0278] The controller 1101 inputs the torque signal A and its own confidence level X to the actuator 1103.

[0279] The controller 1102 inputs the torque signal B and its own confidence level Y to the actuator 1103.

[0280] Actuator 1103 receives torque signal A, confidence level X of controller 1101, torque signal B, and confidence level Y of controller 1102.

[0281] Actuator 1103 determines the weight of torque signal A based on the confidence level of controller 1101, and determines the weight of torque signal B based on the confidence level of controller 1102.

[0282] Actuator 1103 calculates the torque signal C by performing a weighted average calculation based on torque signal A, the weight of torque signal A, torque signal B, and the weight of torque signal B.

[0283] The final actuator 1103 outputs a torque signal C to the motor 1111 to control the torque output of the motor 1111 and realize the acceleration / deceleration of the vehicle.

[0284] In one application scenario, with both controllers 1101 and 1102 operating normally, both controllers 1101 and 1102 are simultaneously in operation. Controller 1101 generates torque signal A1 based on the pedal signal. Controller 1102 generates torque signal B1 based on the pedal signal.

[0285] The controller 1101 inputs the torque signal A1 and its own confidence level X1 (e.g., X1 is 1) to the actuator 1103.

[0286] The controller 1102 inputs the torque signal B1 and its own confidence level Y1 (e.g., Y1 is 1) to the actuator 1103.

[0287] Actuator 1103 receives torque signal A1, confidence level X1 of controller 1101, torque signal B1, and confidence level Y1 of controller 1102.

[0288] Actuator 1103 determines the weight of torque signal A1 based on the confidence level of controller 1101. For example, using the confidence level as the weight, the weight of torque signal A1 is determined to be 1 based on X1 being 1.

[0289] Actuator 1103 determines the weight of torque signal B1 based on the confidence level of controller 1102. For example, using the confidence level as the weight, the weight of torque signal B1 is determined to be 1 based on Y1 being 1.

[0290] Actuator 1103 calculates the torque signal C1 by performing a weighted average calculation based on the torque signal A1, the weight of torque signal A1 (weight is 1), the torque signal B1, and the weight of torque signal B1 (weight is 1). C1 = 1*A1 / (1+1) + 1*B1 / (1+1) = (A1+B1) / 2. (Formula 3)

[0291] The final actuator 1103 outputs a torque signal C1 to the motor 1111 to control the torque output of the motor 1111 and realize the acceleration / deceleration of the vehicle.

[0292] In one application scenario, under the conditions of normal operation of controller 1101, controller 1101 malfunction, or damage, controller 1101 generates torque signal A2 based on the pedal signal. Controller 1102 does not generate torque signal (considered as outputting a torque signal of 0).

[0293] The controller 1101 inputs the torque signal A2 and its own confidence level X2 (e.g., X2 is 1) to the actuator 1103.

[0294] If the controller 1102 does not output a torque signal or its own confidence level, it is considered that the torque signal output by the controller 1102 is 0 and the confidence level is 0.

[0295] Actuator 1103 receives torque signal A2 and confidence level X2 from controller 1101.

[0296] Actuator 1103 determines the weight of torque signal A2 based on the confidence level of controller 1101. For example, using the confidence level as the weight, the weight of torque signal A2 is determined to be 1 based on X2 being 1.

[0297] Actuator 1103 determines that the weight of the torque signal output by controller 1102 is 0 based on the fact that the torque signal output by controller 1102 is 0.

[0298] Actuator 1103 performs a weighted average calculation based on torque signal A2, the weight of torque signal A2 (weight is 1), the torque signal output by controller 1102 being 0, and the weight of the torque signal output by controller 1102 being 0, to obtain torque signal C2 (third control command). C2 = 1*A2 / (1+0) + 1*0 / (1+0) = A2. (Formula 3)

[0299] The final actuator 1103 outputs a torque signal C2 to the motor 1111 to control the torque output of the motor 1111 and realize the acceleration / deceleration of the vehicle.

[0300] In one application scenario, with both controllers 1101 and 1102 operating normally, both controllers 1101 and 1102 are simultaneously in operation. Controller 1101 generates torque signal A3 based on the pedal signal. Controller 1102 generates torque signal B3 based on the pedal signal.

[0301] Since controller 1101 is a newly installed controller, controller 1101 determines its own confidence level X3 to be 1 based on its own working time and equipment wear. Controller 1101 inputs the torque signal A3 and its own confidence level X3 (confidence level is 1) to actuator 1103.

[0302] Since controller 1102 has been operating for a period of time, compared to controller 1101, controller 1102 has a longer operating time and higher equipment wear. Based on its own operating time and equipment wear, controller 1102 determines its own confidence level Y3 to be 0.5. Controller 1102 inputs the torque signal B3 and its own confidence level Y3 (confidence level of 0.5) to actuator 1103.

[0303] Actuator 1103 receives torque signal A3, confidence level X3 (confidence level is 1) of controller 1101, torque signal B3, and confidence level Y3 (confidence level is 0.5) of controller 1102.

[0304] Actuator 1103 determines the weight of torque signal A3 (weight is 1) based on the confidence level of controller 1101.

[0305] Actuator 1103 determines the weight of torque signal B3 (weight is 0.5) based on the confidence level of controller 1102.

[0306] Actuator 1103 calculates the torque signal C3 by performing a weighted average calculation based on the torque signal A3, the weight of torque signal A3 (weight is 1), the torque signal B3, and the weight of torque signal B3 (weight is 0.5). C3 = 1*A1 / (1+0.5) + 0.5*B3 / (1+0.5). (Formula 3)

[0307] The final actuator 1103 outputs a torque signal C3 to the motor 1111 to control the torque output of the motor 1111 and realize the acceleration / deceleration of the vehicle.

[0308] Figure 12 shows a schematic diagram of a control system structure according to an embodiment of this application.

[0309] As shown in Figure 12, the control system 1200 is a control system for controlling the vehicle braking system 1211 according to the pedal signal of the vehicle brake pedal 1210.

[0310] The control system 1200 includes a controller 1201, a controller 1202, and an actuator 1203.

[0311] The input to the control system 1200 is the pedal signal output from the brake pedal 1210. The pedal signal output from the brake pedal 1210 is input to the controller 1201 and the controller 1202.

[0312] In one application scenario, with both controllers 1201 and 1202 operating normally, both controllers 1201 and 1202 are simultaneously in operation. Controller 1201 generates brake signal A4 based on the pedal signal. Controller 1202 generates brake signal B4 based on the pedal signal.

[0313] The controller 1201 inputs the braking signal A4 and its own confidence level X4 to the actuator 1203.

[0314] The controller 1202 inputs the braking signal B4 and its own confidence level Y4 to the actuator 1203.

[0315] Actuator 1203 receives braking signal A4, confidence level X4 of controller 1201, braking signal B4, and confidence level Y4 of controller 1202.

[0316] Actuator 1203 determines the weight of braking signal A4 based on the confidence level X4 of controller 1201.

[0317] Actuator 1203 determines the weight of braking signal B4 based on the confidence level Y4 of controller 1202.

[0318] The actuator 1203 calculates the braking signal C4 by performing a weighted average calculation based on the braking signal A4, the weight of braking signal A4, braking signal B4, and the weight of braking signal B4.

[0319] The final actuator 1203 outputs a braking signal C4 to the braking system 1211 to control the braking system 1211 to achieve vehicle braking.

[0320] Figure 13 shows a schematic diagram of a control system structure according to an embodiment of this application.

[0321] As shown in Figure 13, the control system 1300 is a control system for controlling the vehicle steering mechanism 1311 according to the steering angle signal output by the steering wheel 1310.

[0322] The control system 1300 includes a controller 1301, a controller 1302, and an actuator 1303.

[0323] The input to the control system 1300 is the steering angle signal output by the steering wheel 1310. The steering angle signal output by the steering wheel 1310 is input to the controllers 1301 and 1302.

[0324] In one application scenario, with both controllers 1301 and 1302 operating normally, both controllers 1301 and 1302 are simultaneously in operation. Controller 1301 generates steering signal A5 based on the steering angle signal. Controller 1302 generates steering signal B5 based on the steering angle signal.

[0325] The controller 1301 inputs the steering signal A5 and its own confidence level X5 to the actuator 1303.

[0326] The controller 1302 inputs the steering signal B5 and its own confidence level Y5 to the actuator 1303.

[0327] Actuator 1303 receives steering signal A5, confidence level X5 of controller 1301, steering signal B5, and confidence level Y5 of controller 1302.

[0328] Actuator 1303 determines the weight of steering signal A5 based on the confidence level X5 of controller 1301.

[0329] Actuator 1303 determines the weight of steering signal B5 based on the confidence level Y5 of controller 1302.

[0330] The actuator 1303 calculates the steering signal C5 by performing a weighted average calculation based on the steering signal A5, the weight of steering signal A5, steering signal B5, and the weight of steering signal B5.

[0331] The final actuator 1303 outputs a steering signal C5 to the braking system 1311 to control the steering mechanism 1311 to achieve vehicle steering.

[0332] Furthermore, in order to realize the actuator in the control system, one embodiment of this application also provides an execution device.

[0333] Figure 14 shows a schematic diagram of the structure of an execution device according to an embodiment of this application.

[0334] As shown in FIG14, in one embodiment, the execution device 1400 includes:

[0335] The control instruction receiving module 1401 is used to receive control instructions from the controller. The control instructions from the controller include at least a first control instruction from the first controller and a second control instruction from the second controller. The input and control instruction generation logic of the second controller are the same as those of the first controller.

[0336] The control instruction generation module 1402 is used to obtain a third control instruction based on the first control instruction and the second control instruction.

[0337] In the description of the embodiments of this application, for the sake of convenience, the device is described by dividing it into various modules according to its functions. The division of each module is only a logical functional division. When implementing the embodiments of this application, the functions of each module can be implemented in one or more software and / or hardware.

[0338] Specifically, the apparatus proposed in this application can be fully or partially integrated onto a single physical entity (e.g., a GPU or other type of processor), or it can be physically separated. These modules can be implemented entirely in software via processing element calls; entirely in hardware; or some modules can be implemented in software via processing element calls, while others are implemented in hardware. For example, the detection module can be a separate processing element or integrated into a chip in an electronic device. The implementation of other modules is similar. Furthermore, these modules can be fully or partially integrated together or implemented independently. During implementation, each step of the above method or each of the above modules can be completed through integrated logic circuits in the hardware of the processor element or through software instructions.

[0339] For example, these modules can be one or more integrated circuits configured to implement the above methods, such as one or more application-specific integrated circuits (ASICs), one or more digital signal processors (DSPs), or one or more field-programmable gate arrays (FPGAs). Alternatively, these modules can be integrated together as a system-on-a-chip (SOC).

[0340] An embodiment of this application also proposes a vehicle that includes the control system provided in the embodiment of this application.

[0341] An embodiment of this application also proposes an electronic device. This electronic device is used to execute the method flow or part of the method flow described in the embodiments of this application. This electronic device is a terminal device, base station device, or server device as described in the embodiments of this specification.

[0342] Figure 15 is a schematic diagram of an electronic device structure according to an embodiment of this application.

[0343] As shown in Figure 15, the electronic device 2500 includes a memory 2502 for storing computer program instructions and a processor 2501 for executing the program instructions. When the computer program instructions are executed by the processor 2501, the electronic device 2500 is triggered to execute the method steps performed by the terminal device, base station device, or server device as described in the embodiments of this application.

[0344] Specifically, in one embodiment of this application, the aforementioned one or more computer programs are stored in the aforementioned memory 2502. The aforementioned one or more computer programs include instructions that, when executed by the aforementioned electronic device 2500, cause the aforementioned electronic device 2500 to perform the method steps described in the embodiments of this application.

[0345] It is understood that the structural description of the electronic device 2500 in this application does not constitute a specific limitation on the electronic device 2500. In other embodiments of this application, the electronic device 2500 may include other components besides the processor 2501 and the memory 2502.

[0346] The processor 2501 may be a device-on-a-chip (SoC), which may include a central processing unit (CPU) and may further include other types of processors.

[0347] The processor 2501 may include, for example, a CPU, DSP, microcontroller, or digital signal processor, and may also include a GPU, embedded neural network processing units (NPUs), and image signal processors (ISPs). The processor may also include necessary hardware accelerators or logic processing hardware circuitry, such as an ASIC, or one or more integrated circuits for controlling the execution of the program in this application. Furthermore, the processor may have the function of operating one or more software programs, which may be stored in a storage medium.

[0348] Processor 2501 may include one or more processing units. For example, a processor may include an application processor (AP), a modem processor, a graphics processing unit (GPU), an image signal processor (ISP), a controller, a video codec, a digital signal processor (DSP), a baseband processor, and / or a neural network processing unit (NPU). Different processing units may be independent components or integrated into one or more processors. In some embodiments, electronic device 2500 may also include one or more processors 2501. The controller can generate operation braking signals based on instruction opcodes and timing signals to control instruction fetching and execution.

[0349] In some embodiments, the processor 2501 may include one or more interfaces. These interfaces may include an inter-integrated circuit (I2C) interface, an integrated circuit sound (I2S) interface, a pulse code modulation (PCM) interface, a universal asynchronous receiver / transmitter (UART) interface, a mobile industry processor interface (MIPI), a general-purpose input / output (GPIO) interface, a SIM card interface, and / or a USB interface, etc. The USB interface is a USB standard-compliant interface, specifically a Mini USB interface, a Micro USB interface, a USB Type-C interface, etc. The USB interface can be used to connect a charger to charge the electronic device, and can also be used for data transfer between the electronic device and peripheral devices.

[0350] Electronic device 2500 may also include an external memory interface for connecting an external memory card, such as a Micro SD card, to expand the storage capacity of the electronic device. The external memory card communicates with processor 2501 through the external memory interface to perform data storage functions. For example, music, video, and other files can be saved on the external memory card.

[0351] The memory 2502 may include a code storage area and a data storage area. The code storage area may store the operating system. The data storage area may store data created during the use of the electronic device 2500. Furthermore, the memory 2502 may include high-speed random access memory, and may also include non-volatile memory, such as one or more disk storage components, flash memory components, universal flash storage (UFS), etc.

[0352] The memory 2502 may be a read-only memory (ROM), other types of static storage devices that can store static information and instructions, random access memory (RAM), or other types of dynamic storage devices that can store information and instructions. It may also be an electrically erasable programmable read-only memory (EEPROM), a compact disc read-only memory (CD-ROM) or other optical disc storage, optical disc storage (including compressed optical discs, laser discs, optical discs, digital universal optical discs, Blu-ray discs, etc.), magnetic disk storage media, or other magnetic storage devices. Alternatively, it may be any computer-readable medium capable of carrying or storing desired program code in the form of instructions or data structures that can be accessed by a computer.

[0353] Processor 2501 and memory 2502 can be combined into a single processing device, but more commonly they are separate components.

[0354] An embodiment of this application also provides an electronic chip. This electronic chip is used to execute the method flow or part of the method flow described in the embodiments of this application.

[0355] Specifically, the electronic chip includes a processor for executing program instructions. When the computer program instructions are executed by the processor, the electronic chip is triggered to perform the steps described in the embodiments of this application. The processor of the electronic chip can refer to the processor of the above-described electronic device.

[0356] Optionally, the devices, apparatuses, and modules described in the embodiments of this application may be implemented by computer chips or physical entities, or by products with certain functions.

[0357] Those skilled in the art will understand that embodiments of this application can be provided as methods, apparatus, or computer program products. Therefore, the present invention can take the form of a completely hardware embodiment, a completely software embodiment, or an embodiment combining software and hardware aspects. Furthermore, the present invention can take the form of a computer program product embodied on one or more computer-usable storage media containing computer-usable program code.

[0358] In the several embodiments provided in this application, any function, if implemented as a software functional unit and sold or used as an independent product, can be stored in a computer-readable storage medium. Based on this understanding, the technical solution of this application, in essence, or the part that contributes to the prior art, or part of the technical solution, can be embodied in the form of a software product. This computer software product is stored in a storage medium and includes several instructions to cause a computer device (which may be a personal computer, a server, or a network device, etc.) to execute all or part of the steps of the methods described in the various embodiments of this application.

[0359] Specifically, one embodiment of this application also provides a computer-readable storage medium storing a computer program that, when run on a computer, causes the computer to execute the method provided in the embodiment of this application.

[0360] An embodiment of this application also provides a computer program product, which includes a computer program that, when run on a computer, causes the computer to perform the method provided in the embodiment of this application.

[0361] The embodiments described in this application are described with reference to flowchart illustrations and / or block diagrams of methods, apparatus (devices), and computer program products according to embodiments of this application. It will be understood that each block of the flowchart illustrations and / or block diagrams, and combinations of blocks in the flowchart illustrations and / or block diagrams, can be implemented by computer program instructions. These computer program instructions can be provided to a processor of a general-purpose computer, special-purpose computer, embedded processor, or other programmable data processing apparatus to produce a machine, such that the instructions, which execute via the processor of the computer or other programmable data processing apparatus, create means for implementing the functions specified in one or more flowchart illustrations and / or one or more block diagrams.

[0362] These computer program instructions may also be stored in a computer-readable storage medium that can direct a computer or other programmable data processing device to function in a particular manner, such that the instructions stored in the computer-readable storage medium produce an article of manufacture including instruction means that implement the functions specified in one or more flowcharts and / or one or more block diagrams.

[0363] These computer program instructions may also be loaded onto a computer or other programmable data processing apparatus to cause a series of operational steps to be performed on the computer or other programmable apparatus to produce a computer-implemented process, such that the instructions, which execute on the computer or other programmable apparatus, provide steps for implementing the functions specified in one or more flowcharts and / or one or more block diagrams.

[0364] It should also be noted that in the embodiments of this application, "at least one" refers to one or more, and "more than one" refers to two or more. "And / or" describes the relationship between related objects, indicating that three relationships can exist. For example, A and / or B can represent the existence of A alone, the simultaneous existence of A and B, or the existence of B alone. A and B can be singular or plural. The character " / " generally indicates that the preceding and following related objects are in an "or" relationship. "At least one of the following" and similar expressions refer to any combination of these items, including any combination of singular or plural items. For example, at least one of a, b, and c can represent: a, b, c, a and b, a and c, b and c, or a and b and c, where a, b, and c can be single or multiple.

[0365] In this application, the terms "comprising," "including," or any other variations thereof are intended to cover non-exclusive inclusion, such that a process, method, article, or apparatus that comprises a list of elements includes not only those elements but also other elements not expressly listed, or elements inherent to such a process, method, article, or apparatus. Without further limitation, an element defined by the phrase "comprising one..." does not exclude the presence of other identical elements in the process, method, article, or apparatus that includes said element.

[0366] This application can be described in the general context of computer-executable instructions, such as program modules, that are executed by a computer. Generally, program modules include routines, programs, objects, components, data structures, etc., that perform a specific task or implement a specific abstract data type. This application can also be practiced in distributed computing environments where tasks are performed by remote processing devices connected via a communication network. In distributed computing environments, program modules can reside in local and remote computer storage media, including storage devices.

[0367] The various embodiments in this application are described in a progressive manner. Similar or identical parts between embodiments can be referred to mutually. Each embodiment focuses on describing the differences from other embodiments. In particular, the device embodiments are basically similar to the method embodiments, so the description is relatively simple; relevant parts can be referred to the descriptions of the method embodiments.

[0368] Those skilled in the art will recognize that the units and algorithm steps described in the embodiments of this application can be implemented using electronic hardware, computer software, or a combination of electronic hardware. Whether these functions are implemented in hardware or software depends on the specific application and design constraints of the technical solution. Those skilled in the art can use different methods to implement the described functions for each specific application, but such implementation should not be considered beyond the scope of this application.

[0369] Those skilled in the art will clearly understand that, for the sake of convenience and brevity, the specific working processes of the devices, apparatuses, and units described above can be referred to the corresponding processes in the foregoing method embodiments, and will not be repeated here.

[0370] The above description is merely a specific embodiment of this application. Any variations or substitutions that can be easily conceived by those skilled in the art within the scope of the technology disclosed in this application should be included within the protection scope of this application. The protection scope of this application should be determined by the protection scope of the claims.

Claims

1. A control method characterized by, The method is applied to a control system, which includes at least a first controller and a second controller, and includes: Obtain the first control command generated by the first controller; Obtain the second control command generated by the second controller, wherein the input of the second controller and the control command generation logic are the same as those of the first controller; A third control instruction is obtained based on the first control instruction and the second control instruction.

2. The method of claim 1, wherein, The third control command is one of the first control command and the second control command.

3. The method of claim 2, wherein, When one of the first control instruction and the second control instruction is an invalid instruction or an erroneous instruction, the third control instruction is the other of the first control instruction and the second control instruction.

4. The method of claim 1, wherein, The third control instruction is a new instruction generated based on the first control instruction and the second control instruction.

5. The method of claim 4, wherein, The step of obtaining the third control instruction based on the first control instruction and the second control instruction includes: Determine the weight of the control command, wherein the weight of the control command includes at least a first weight corresponding to the first control command and a second weight corresponding to the second control command; The third control instruction is generated based on the first control instruction, the second control instruction, and the weights of the control instructions.

6. The method of claim 5, wherein, The step of generating the third control instruction based on the first control instruction, the second control instruction, and the weights of the control instructions includes: Based on the weighted average algorithm, the control parameter values ​​in the first control instruction and the second control instruction are calculated by weighting according to the weight of the control instruction, and the third control instruction is generated based on the weighted average calculation result.

7. The method according to claim 5 or 6, characterized in that, The determination of the weights of the control commands includes: The first weight is determined based on the degree of deviation between the control parameter value in the first control command and the preset range; And / or, The second weight is determined based on the degree of deviation between the control parameter value in the second control command and the preset range.

8. The method according to any one of claims 5-7, characterized in that, The determination of the weights of the control commands includes: Obtain a first confidence level for the first controller, and determine the first weight based on the first confidence level, wherein the first confidence level is associated with the device parameters of the first controller; And / or, A second confidence level is obtained for the second controller, and a second weight is determined based on the second confidence level, wherein the second confidence level is associated with the device parameters of the second controller.

9. The method according to claim 8, characterized in that: The device parameters of the first controller include the operating time of the first controller and / or the degree of device wear; And / or, The device parameters of the second controller include the operating time of the second controller and / or the wear and tear of the device.

10. A control system, characterized in that: The control system includes at least a first controller and a second controller, wherein the first controller is used to generate a first control command, the second controller is used to generate a second control command, and the input and control command generation logic of the second controller are the same as those of the first controller. The control system further includes an actuator, which is used to obtain a third control instruction based on the first control instruction and the second control instruction, wherein the third control instruction is used to control the vehicle.

11. The system of claim 10, wherein, The actuator is configured such that the third control instruction is one of the first control instruction and the second control instruction.

12. The system of claim 11, wherein, The actuator is configured such that, when one of the first control instruction and the second control instruction is an invalid instruction or an erroneous instruction, the third control instruction is the other of the first control instruction and the second control instruction.

13. The system of claim 10, wherein, The actuator is configured such that the third control instruction is a new instruction generated based on the first control instruction and the second control instruction.

14. The system of claim 13, wherein, The actuator is configured as follows: Determine the weight of the control command, wherein the weight of the control command includes at least a first weight corresponding to the first control command and a second weight corresponding to the second control command; The third control instruction is generated based on the first control instruction, the second control instruction, and the weights of the control instructions.

15. The system of claim 14, wherein, The actuator is configured as follows: Based on the weighted average algorithm, the control parameter values ​​in the first control instruction and the second control instruction are calculated by weighting according to the weight of the control instruction, and the third control instruction is generated based on the weighted average calculation result.

16. The system of claim 14 or 15, wherein, The actuator is configured as follows: The first weight is determined based on the degree of deviation between the control parameter value in the first control command and the preset range; And / or, The second weight is determined based on the degree of deviation between the control parameter value in the second control command and the first preset range.

17. The system of any of claims 14-16, wherein, The actuator is configured as follows: Obtain a first confidence level for the first controller, and determine the first weight based on the first confidence level, wherein the first confidence level is associated with the device parameters of the first controller; And / or, A second confidence level is obtained for the second controller, and a second weight is determined based on the second confidence level, wherein the second confidence level is associated with the device parameters of the second controller.

18. The system according to claim 17, characterized in that: The device parameters of the first controller include the operating time of the first controller and / or the degree of device wear; And / or, The device parameters of the second controller include the operating time of the second controller and / or the wear and tear of the device.

19. An execution device, characterized by The device includes: A control instruction receiving module is used to receive control instructions from a controller. The control instructions from the controller include at least a first control instruction from a first controller and a second control instruction from a second controller. The input and control instruction generation logic of the second controller are the same as those of the first controller. A control instruction generation module is used to obtain a third control instruction based on the first control instruction and the second control instruction.

20. A vehicle characterized by comprising: The vehicle includes a control system as described in any one of claims 10-18.

21. An electronic device, comprising: The electronic device includes a memory and a processor; The processor is configured to execute instructions stored in the memory to cause the electronic device to perform the method as described in any one of claims 1-9.

22. A computer program product comprising instructions, wherein: When the instructions are executed by the computing device system, the computing device cluster is caused to perform the method of any of claims 1-9.

23. A computer-readable storage medium, characterized in that, comprising computer program instructions, which when executed by a computer system, the computer system performs the method of any of claims 1-9.