A method for operating a hybrid si-sic switch

By coordinating the gate current and turn-ON delay time for SiC transistors in hybrid Si-SiC switches, the method ensures safe operation and reduces thermal stress, enhancing reliability and efficiency.

WO2026238791A1PCT designated stage Publication Date: 2026-11-19SCHAEFFLER TECHNOLOGIES AG & CO KG
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
PCT/EP2026/063893
Authority / Receiving Office
WO · WO
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2025-05-16
Filing Date
2026-05-12
Publication Date
2026-11-19

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Hybrid Si-SiC switches experience significant losses and high temperatures in SiC components during high load conditions, potentially exceeding their safe operating area, leading to potential damage or failure, and adding additional components increases size and cost.

Method used

A method to operate a hybrid Si-SiC switch by determining a relation between the gate current and turn-ON gate signal delay time for the SiC transistor, ensuring it switches after the Si transistor, using an active current controlled gate driver to adjust the gate current and slew rate, optimizing the switching process to maintain safe operating conditions.

Benefits of technology

The method reduces peak current and power dissipation in SiC chips, maintaining safe operating conditions and reducing thermal stress, allowing for smaller and more reliable hybrid switches.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure EP2026063893_19112026_PF_FP_ABST
    Figure EP2026063893_19112026_PF_FP_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

A method for operating a hybrid switch including at least one silicon (Si) insulated-gate bipolar transistor (IGBT) and at least one active current controlled silicon carbide (SiC) metal-oxide semiconductor field-effect transistor (MOSFET) arranged in parallel to one another is proposed. The method comprising the steps of: determining a turn-ON gate signal delay time (tDI) of the Si transistor, wherein the turn-ON gate signal delay time (tDI) is a time difference between a start-time (t1) of a voltage gate signal for the Si transistor and an onset-time (t3) of a load current-buildup (ICE) of the Si transistor for switching-ON, determining a relation between a gate current (Igs) applied to a current controlled active gate driver for the SiC transistor and a turn-ON gate signal delay time (tDM) of the SiC transistor resulting from the applied gate current (Igs), wherein the turn-ON gate signal delay time (tDM) is a time difference between a start-time (t1) of a voltage gate signal for the SiC transistor and an onset-time (tth)of a load current-buildup (IDS) of the SiC transistor for switching-ON, and operating the current controlled active gate driver for the SiC transistor with such a gate current (Igs) obtained from the determined relation that the onset-time (tth) of switch-ON of the SiC transistor is equal to or greater than the onset-time (t3) of switch-ON of the Si transistor.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[0001] 202500616

[0002] 1

[0003] Description

[0004] A method for operating a hybrid Si-SiC switch

[0005] The present invention relates to a method for controlling a hybrid silicon-silicon carbide (Si-SiC) switch. The present invention further relates to a hybrid Si-SiC switch. The present invention further relates to an AC / DC inverter or DC / DC converter including such a switch, and to an onboard-charging unit including such an inverter and / or converter.

[0006] Hybrid silicon-silicon carbide (Si-SiC) switches are becoming more and more interesting, also in the field of automotive applications.

[0007] Hybrid Si-SiC switches combine silicon (Si) insulated-gate bipolar transistors (IGBTs) with silicon carbide (SiC) metal-oxide semiconductor field-effect transistors (MOSFET). Such hybrid switches offer advantages in terms of switching speed, losses and cost-effectiveness.

[0008] In the pursuit of enhanced efficiency and performance in power electronic applications, the hybrid silicon-silicon carbide (Si-SiC) switch has emerged as a promising candidate for use in inverter applications or other power electronic applications. The architecture of the hybrid switch leverages the complementary advantages of silicon (Si) and silicon carbide (SiC) technologies. Silicon, with its established use in semiconductor devices, offers robust performance at lower costs. In contrast, silicon carbide provides superior thermal conductivity, higher breakdown voltage, and enhanced efficiency in high-temperature environments.

[0009] Hybrid Si-SiC switch designs and / or architectures integrate and cooperate Si and SiC materials to optimize switching characteristics and reduce conduction losses, making it particularly suitable for electric vehicles and / or electric industrial motor drives. By enabling faster switching frequencies and improved thermal management, the hybrid Si-SiC switch allows for smaller, lighter, and more efficient power inverters. Given the global shift towards sustainable energy solutions, the development and commercialization of the hybrid Si-SiC switch represent a significant advancement in the field, positioning it as a vital component in next-generation inverter systems.

[0010] 202500616

[0011] 2

[0012] It has been found, however, that under certain circumstances, such as under high load conditions, losses in the wide band gap components, particularly in the SiC component, such as the MOSFET, can be considerable. High losses can result in high (junction) temperatures which may exceed maximal specified ratings of the component. Moreover, this high peak current might exceed the safe operating area (SOA) of SiC chips, potentially causing damage or failure. This may limit the lifetime of the component. It is possible to add further IGBTs and / or MOSFETs on the same device, such as the inverter, so as to limit the losses and maintain safe operating (junction) temperatures on each of the IGBTs or MOSFETs. However, this comes at the cost of increased size, weight, and / or production costs.

[0013] It is thus an object of the present invention, to propose a method for operating a hybrid Si-SiC switch that not only allows to use a minimal number of chips (Si, SiC) but also ensures a reduced level of losses and / or safe operation of SiC chips during operation of the switch, especially during high load conditions. It is further an object of the present invention to propose a hybrid Si-SiC switch which offers reduced loss levels, especially during high load conditions, at a comparably small packing size and / or cost-fingerprint, as well as an AC / DC inverter, a DC / DC converter including such a switch, and an onboard-charging unit including such an inverter and / or converter.

[0014] The above objects are solved by the subject-matters of the independent claims. Preferred embodiments are given in the dependent claims.

[0015] According to a first aspect of the present invention, a method for operating a hybrid switch including at least one silicon (Si) insulated-gate bipolar transistor (IGBT) and at least one active current controlled silicon carbide (SiC) metal-oxide semiconductor field-effect transistor (MOSFET) arranged in parallel to one another, the method comprising the steps of: determining a turn-ON gate signal delay time tDIof the Si transistor, wherein the turn-ON gate signal delay time tDIis a time difference between a start-time

[0016]

[0017] of a voltage gate signal for the Si transistor and an onset-time t3of a load current-buildup ICEof the Si transistor for switching-ON as a result of the applied voltage signal; determining a relation between a gate current lgsapplied to a current controlled active gate driver for the SiC transistor and a turn-ON gate signal delay time tDMof the SiC transistor resulting from the applied gate current Igs, wherein the turn-ON gate signal delay time tDMis a time difference between a start-time

[0018]

[0019] of a voltage gate signal for the SiC transistor and an onset-time tthof a load current-buildup IDSof the SiC

[0020] 202500616

[0021] 3

[0022] transistor for switching-ON, and; operating the current controlled active gate driver for the SiC transistor with such a gate current Igsobtained from the determined relation that the onset-time tthof switch-ON of the SiC transistor is equal to or greater than the onset-time t3of switch-ON of the Si transistor.

[0023] The present invention is based on the idea that the turn-ON gate signal delay time of IGBTs (Si chips) are larger than that of MOSFETs (SiC chips). In other words, the SiC chip has a faster response time compared to the Si chip when both receive the gate signal at the same time. The present invention is based on the idea that an active current controlled SiC transistor may be applied with such a gate current that a switch-ON of the SiC transistor does not occur earlier than that of the Si transistor. It is proposed to determine a relation between the gate current that is applied to the current controlled active gate driver of the SiC transistor and the turn-ON gate signal delay time of the SiC transistors in response to the applied gate current. It is believed, without being bound by theory, that reduced gate currents increase the turn-ON gate signal delay time of the SiC transistor and that by operating the SiC transistor with an “optimal” gate current, the turn-ON gate signal delay time of the SiC transistor can be “delayed” such that the SiC transistor does not turn on prior to the Si transistor. In other words, it is believed that the SiC turn-ON can be delayed on purpose by using an appropriate gate current taken from the determined relation. This coordinated approach enhances current handling capabilities and optimizes performance during critical switching events. By strategically tuning the turn-ON gate signal delay time of the SiC transistor, the method mitigates the risks associated with exceeding rated values and ensures operation remains within the safe operating area.

[0024] Preferably, the Si transistor and the SiC transistor are operated such that the start-time of the voltage gate signal for the Si transistor and the start-time

[0025] of the voltage gate signal for the SiC transistor are the same. In other words, voltage gate signals may be sent at the same time, i.e. with no time delay, for using the proposed switching strategy. The reason is that even though the voltage gate signals are sent at the same time (start-time), the tuned turn-ON gate signal delay time ensures that the switch-ON of the SiC transistor does not occur earlier than the switch-ON of the Si transistor.

[0026] Preferably, the step of determining a relation between the applied current and the turn-ON gate signal delay time tDMof the SiC transistor includes determining a slew rate di / dt of the load current-buildup IDSof the SiC transistor in dependence202500616

[0027] 4

[0028] of the applied gate current Igs, wherein the current controlled active gate driver for the SiC transistor is operated with such a gate current Igsobtained from the determined relation that the slew rate di / dt of the load current-buildup IDSof the SiC transistor deviates from a slew rate di / dt of a load current-buildup ICEof the Si transistor by not more than a predetermined threshold. Preferably, the predetermined threshold is in a range between 1% and 10%, preferably 1% and 5%. It is believed that, without being bound by theory, that the gate current applied to the current controlled active gate drive has an effect on the slew rate of the load current-buildup of the SiC transistor and that an “optimal” gate current may be found in which not only the turn-ON gate signal delay time of the SiC transistor is on or after that of the Si transistor, but also the slew rate of the load currentbuildup of the SiC transistor is close to or matches (within boundaries) that of the Si transistor. In other words, it is believed that by choosing the “right” gate current for the SiC transistor from the determined relation, the slew rate of the load current-buildup may be tuned to that of the Si transistor.

[0029] Preferably, the determined relation is provided as a look-up table, the look-up table providing the turn-ON gate signal delay time tDMof the SiC transistor as a function of the applied load current, and preferably providing both the turn-ON gate signal delay time tDMof the SiC transistor and the slew rate di / dt of the load currentbuildup IDSas a function of the applied gate current Igs.

[0030] Preferably, the step of determining the relation between the applied gate current and the turn-ON gate signal dealy time tDMof the SiC transistor includes measuring or simulating the turn-ON gate signal delay time tDMand preferably the slew rate di / dt for various gate currents applied to the current controlled active gate driver.

[0031] According to another, or second aspect of the present invention, a hybrid switch is proposed. The switch comprises: at least one silicon (Si) insulated-gate bipolar transistors (IGBT or Si chip), at least one active current controlled silicon carbide (SiC) metal-oxide semiconductor field-effect transistors (MOSFET) arranged in parallel to the at least one silicon (Si) insulated-gate bipolar transistors (IGBTs), a current controlled active gate driver configured for at least operating the SiC transistor, and a control unit (may be implemented in the gate driver) operably connected to at least the SiC transistor, and preferably also to the Si transistor, for operating the hybrid switch with the method according to the first aspect or embodiments thereof.

[0032] 202500616

[0033] 5

[0034] According to another, or third aspect of the present invention, an AC / DC inverter is proposed. The AC / DC inverter comprises: a hybrid switch according to the second aspect, preferably wherein the AC / DC converter is adapted for use in an onboard-charging unit of an electric vehicle.

[0035] According to another, or fourth aspect of the present invention, a DC / DC converter is proposed. The DC / DC converter comprises: a hybrid switch according to the second aspect, preferably wherein the DC / DC converter is adapted for use in a wallbox or in an onboard-charging unit of an electric vehicle.

[0036] According to another, or fifth aspect of the present invention, an onboard-charging unit comprising an inverter according to third aspect and / or a converter according to fourth aspect is proposed.

[0037] Embodiments of the first aspect may be applicable to embodiments of the second, third, fourth and / or fifth aspect, and vice versa.

[0038] Exemplary embodiments of the invention are described by the accompanying drawings, which are incorporated herein and constitute a part of the specification. In the drawings:

[0039] FIG 1 is a schematic drawing of a hybrid switch according to the present invention;

[0040] FIGs 2A-B are schematic drawings of a gate signal and gate voltage,

[0041] respectively, for operating the hybrid switch;

[0042] FIG 3 is a schematic drawing of a turn-ON gate signal delay time and a slew-rate of a load current-buildup of the SiC transistor for various gate currents;

[0043] FIG 4 is a schematic drawing showing that by applying an appropriate gate current the turn-ON of the SiC transistor can be tailored;

[0044] FIG 5 is a schematic drawing showing one example of a switching concept for operating the hybrid switch;

[0045] 202500616

[0046] 6

[0047] FIGs 6A-B are schematic drawings of a current versus time plot without applying the switching concept (FIG 6A) and with applying the switching concept (FIG 6B);

[0048] FIGs 7A-B are schematic drawings of applying the switching concept to a turn- OFF process.

[0049] Within the figures, same reference numerals refer to the same components.

[0050] Figure 1 a schematic drawing of a hybrid switch 10. In the exemplary embodiment shown in FIG 1, the switch includes one Si chip (IGBT) and two SiC chips (MOSFET) arranged in parallel to one another. In other embodiments not shown, the switch 10 may include a different number of Si chips and / or SiC chips. A diode is used in the switch and arranged in parallel, as is known to a person skilled in the art for such a hybrid switch. The SiC chips are active current controlled SiC chips. The SiC chips may be controlled by a current controlled active gate driver.

[0051] Figures 2A-B show schematic drawings of a gate signal (FIG 2A) and a gate voltage (FIG 2B). As can be seen, when both the silicon (Si) and silicon carbide (SiC) components (chips) are switched simultaneously (indicated by the arrow 12), the SiC switch operates at a faster switching speed than the Si switch and has to handle the full current for a brief period. This can be seen, for example, by a SiC peak voltage portion 14 which occurs during a ramp-up phase (turn on phase) of the Si switch. This disadvantage of share of current may be more prominent during high load conditions, such as during 720 A current conditions. This disadvantage of share of current may lead to premature failure of the MOSFET and / or may result in an temperature of the MOSFET that may exceed a predetermined (safe operating) temperature. Such a distribution of current may thus be avoided, particularly during high load conditions.

[0052] Figure 3 shows a schematic drawing of a turn-ON gate signal delay time tDMand a slew-rate (di / dt) of a load current-buildup IDSof the SiC transistor for various gate currents Igs. Three examples of gate currents are shown, Igs1, Igs2, Igs3.

[0053] As can be seen, by decreasing the gate current from, for example, Igs1to Igs3, indicated by arrow 16, the turn-ON gate signal delay time tDMincreases, indicated by arrow 18, and the slew rate di / dt of the load current-buildup lDS, indicated by arrow 20, decreases. The slew rate may decrease in a different proportion than202500616

[0054] 7

[0055] the turn-ON gate signal delay time tDMincreases. The relation between the gate current Igsthat is applied to the current controlled active gate driver and the turn-ON gate signal delay time tDM, and the slew rate, di / dt, may be determined and provided in a look-up table. The relation may be determined, for example, by measuring or simulating the turn-ON gate signal delay time tDMand the slew rate di / dt of the load current-buildup IDSfor various gate currents Igsapplied to the current controlled active gate driver.

[0056] Figure 4 shows a schematic drawing illustrating the idea.

[0057] At the top of FIG 4 is shown the turn-ON switching of the SiC and the Si transistor under normal conditions and without applying an “optimized” gate current. As can be seen, the SiC chip switches on faster than the Si chip due to a shorter turn-ON gate signal delay time.

[0058] At the bottom of FIG 4 is shown the turn-ON switching of the SiC and the Si transistor when an appropriate or “optimized” gate current is chosen for operating the SiC chip. As can be seen, the SiC chip switches on after the Si transistor switches on. Also, the slew rate of the SiC chip changed from being higher than the slew rate of the Si chip (see FIG 4A) to being lower than the slew rate of the Si chip (see FIG 4B).

[0059] The basic idea is to use the determined relation between the gate current that is applied to the SiC transistor and the resulting turn-ON gate signal delay time and slew rate of load current-buildup to “tune” the slew rate and the turn-ON gate signal delay time such that the SiC transistor does not switch on prior to the Si transistor and such that the SiC transistor can operated in its safe operation area.

[0060] Figure 5 shows one example of a switching concept for a hybrid switch, such as the one shown in FIG 1, which is based on the above approach. As can be seen, when both the Si IGBT and the SiC MOSFET are switched on at the same starttime of the voltage gate signal, the turn-ON signal delay time of the IGBT is tDI. The turn-ON signal delay time of the IGBT tDIis the time difference between the start-time

[0061]

[0062] of the voltage gate signal and an onset-time tthof a load currentbuildup ICEof the IGBT. In the example shown, this onset-time of the IGBT is t3. The idea is that the onset-time of the MOSFET occurs not earlier than the onsettime of the IGBT. In other words, the onset-time of the MOSFET shall occur at or after t3.

[0063] 202500616

[0064] 8

[0065] Figure 5 shows two examples of gate currents, Igs1, Igs2, that may be applied to the current controlled active gate driver of the MOSFET. If gate current Igslis applied, the MOSFET has a turn-ON gate signal delay time tDM1measured as time difference between the start-time

[0066]

[0067] of the voltage gate signal (which is in this case the same as for the IGBT) and the onset-time tthof the load current-buildup IDSbelonging to Igsl. As can be seen, when Igslis used a gate current for the MOSFET, the MOSFET turns on prior to the IGBT. The turn-ON gate signal delay time tDM1of the MOSFET is smaller than the turn-ON gate signal delay time tDIof the IGBT.

[0068] When Igs2is used as gate current for the MOSFET, the load current-buildup starts later and thus the turn-ON gate signal delay time tDM2of the MOSFET is increased. The idea is to choose such a gate current that the resulting turn-ON gate signal delay time tDM2of the MOSFET is equal to or larger than the turn-ON gate signal delay time tDIof the IGBT. In the example shown, the MOSFET needs to be operated with gate current Igs2so that the gate signal delay time tDM2is achieved.

[0069] In addition and as mentioned with reference to FIG 3, the gate current not only changes the turn-ON gate signal delay time tDMbut also the slew rate of the load current-buildup IDSof the MOSFET. The switching concept of the hybrid switch may be such that the slew rate of the load current-buildup IDSof the MOSFET is tuned (by choosing the appropriate gate current Igs) to be within limits of the slew rate of the load current-buildup ICEof the IGBT. For example, the gate current may be chosen such that the slew rate of the load current-buildup IDSof the MOSFET deviates by not more than a predetermined threshold from the slew rate of the load current-buildup ICEof the IGBT. The threshold may be in a range between 1% and 10%, preferably between 1% and 5%.

[0070] Figures 6A-B are schematic drawings of a current versus time plot for high-load conditions without applying the switching concept (FIG 6A) and with applying the switching concept (FIG 6B). In FIG 6A “normal” operation is shown with no appropriate gate current and no slew rate tuning. In FIG 6B an “optimized” gate current with tuned slew rate was used.

[0071] When the electric motor operates at high power, the current flowing through each phase becomes substantial. During switching events with “normal” operation (FIG202500616

[0072] 9

[0073] 6A), the silicon carbide (SiC) component must handle more current as it switches faster than the silicon (Si) component.

[0074] Specifically, at higher current levels (see FIG 6A), the associated losses in the SiC increase, resulting in elevated temperatures. Additionally, the peak current can exceed the rated values, placing the operation outside the safe operating area (SOA). This condition poses significant risks to the reliability and longevity of the components involved.

[0075] With the proposed solution of “optimized” gate current and tuned slew rate (FIG 6B), however, the SiC MOSFET turn-ON gate signal delay time can be increased and the slew rate can be decreased, effectively reducing the peak current in the SiC MOSFET and ensuring that the MOSFET remains within a Safe Operating Area.

[0076] By comparing FIGs 6A and 6B, it can be seen that the peak 20 of the SiC MOSFET current reduces significantly when using the switching concept and that the IGBT takes up some of the current in the hybrid switch. In other words, the total current is shared between the SiC MOSFET and the Si IGBT.

[0077] Figures 7A-B illustrate how the switching concept may be applied to the turn-OFF process in a similar way. Figure 7A shows a time versus current plot without applying the concept. Figure 7B shows the time versus current plot with applying the concept.

[0078] During turn-OFF process, the slew rate of the Si IGBT is “tuned”. During turn-OFF process, the sink current capacity of the Si device’s gate driver is reduced resulting in a slower gate voltage discharge. Consequently, the slower switching of the Si component allows the SiC device remain within its Safe Operating Area (SOA). Moreover, it also reduces the voltage overshoot.

[0079] The proposed switching strategy effectively reduces the peak current and power dissipation in SiC chips / transitors without compromising the efficiency of the hybrid switch. This innovative approach minimizes thermal stress on the SiC component, allowing for a smaller chip area in the hybrid design, thereby enhancing overall performance and reliability.

Claims

20250061610Patent claims1. A method for operating a hybrid switch including at least one silicon (Si) insulated-gate bipolar transistor (IGBT) and at least one current controlled silicon carbide (SiC) metal-oxide semiconductor field-effect transistor (MOSFET) arranged in parallel to one another, the method comprising the steps of:determining a turn-ON gate signal delay time (tD / ) of the Si transistor, wherein the turn-ON gate signal delay time (tDI) is a time difference between a start-time (t of a voltage gate signal for the Si transistor and an onset-time (t3) of a load current-buildup (ICE) of the Si transistor for switching-ON,determining a relation betweena gate current (Igs) applied to a current controlled active gate driver for the SiC transistor anda turn-ON gate signal delay time (tDM) of the SiC transistor resulting from the applied gate current (Igs), wherein the turn-ON gate signal delay time (tDM) is a time difference between a start-time (t of a voltage gate signal for the SiC transistor and an onset-time (tth) of a load current-buildup (IDS) of the SiC transistor for switching-ON, andoperating the current controlled active gate driver for the SiC transistor with such a gate current (Igs) obtained from the determined relation that the onset-time (tth) of switch-ON of the SiC transistor is equal to or greater than the onset-time (t3) of switch-ON of the Si transistor.

2. The method of claim 1, wherein the Si transistor and the SiC transistor are operated such that the start-time (t of the voltage gate signal for the Si transistor and the start-time (t of the voltage gate signal for the SiC transistor are the same.

3. The method of claims 1 or 2, wherein- the step of determining a relation between the applied current and the turn- ON gate signal delay time (tDM) of the SiC transistor includes determining a slew rate (di / dt) of the load current-buildup (IDS) of the SiC transistor in dependence of the applied gate current (Igs), and wherein- the current controlled active gate driver for the SiC transistor is operated with such a gate current (Igs) obtained from the determined relation that the slew rate (di / dt) of the load current-buildup (IDS) of the SiC transistor20250061611deviates from a slew rate (di / dt) of a load current-buildup (ICE) of the Si transistor by not more than a predetermined threshold, the threshold being in a range between 1% and 10%, preferably 1% and 5%.

4. The method of any one of claims 1 - 3, wherein the determined relation is provided as a look-up table, the look-up table providing the turn-ON gate signal delay time (tDM) of the SiC transistor as a function of the applied load current.

5. The method of claim 4 in combination with claim 3, wherein the look-up table provides the turn-ON gate signal delay time (tDM) of the SiC transistor and the slew rate (di / dt) of the load current-buildup (IDS) as a function of the applied gate current (Igs).

6. The method of any one of claims 1 - 5, wherein the step of determining the relation between the applied gate current and the turn-ON gate signal time (tDM) of the SiC transistor includes measuring or simulating the turn-ON gate signal delay time (tDM) and preferably the slew rate (di / dt) for various gate currents (Igs) applied to the current controlled active gate driver.

7. A hybrid switch comprising:at least one silicon (Si) insulated-gate bipolar transistors (IGBT),at least one active current controlled silicon carbide (SiC) metal-oxide semiconductor field-effect transistors (MOSFET) arranged in parallel to the at least one silicon (Si) insulated-gate bipolar transistors (IGBTs), a current controlled active gate driver configured for at least operating the SiC transistor, anda control unit operably connected to at least the SiC transistor, and preferably also to the Si transistor, for operating the hybrid switch with the method according to any one of the preceding claims.

8. An AC / DC inverter comprising:a hybrid switch according to claim 7, preferably wherein the AC / DC converter is adapted for use in an onboard-charging unit of an electric vehicle.

9. A DC / DC converter comprising:a hybrid switch according to claim 7, preferably wherein the DC / DC20250061612converter is adapted for use in a wallbox or in an onboard-charging unit of an electric vehicle.

10. An onboard-charging unit comprising an inverter according to claim 8 and / or a converter according to claim 9.