Method and device for controlling a paper bag machine
Patent Information
- Application Number
- PCT/EP2026/064287
- Authority / Receiving Office
- WO · WO
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2025-05-16
- Filing Date
- 2026-05-15
- Publication Date
- 2026-11-19
Smart Images

Figure EP2026064287_19112026_PF_FP_ABST
Abstract
Description
[0001] Windmöller & Hölscher SE & Co. KG May 15, 2026
[0002] WUH-P10109PC
[0003] Method and device for controlling a paper bag machine
[0004] The invention relates to a method for determining control data for a paper bag machine and / or for calibrating a control unit of the paper bag machine in which setpoint values are stored on the basis of which the paper bag machine is controlled, wherein the paper bag machine is set up to produce paper bags from roll material, and a corresponding system.
[0005] A paper sack machine is used for the automated production of sturdy paper sacks, such as those used for packaging cement, flour, or animal feed. The production process begins with the unwinding of large sheets of paper, which are continuously fed into the machine. For particularly tear-resistant sacks, several layers of paper are glued together. Optionally, the paper can be printed during or after this process – for example, with manufacturer logos, product information, or warning symbols. The paper is then folded into a tube in a tubing machine and glued along the longitudinal seam to create the basic shape of the sack. This is followed by bottom formation in a machine called a bottom layer, where one or both ends of the tube are folded into a flat, stable bottom and firmly glued – for example, in the form of a cross bottom.Depending on the intended use, additional elements such as valves for machine filling or plastic liners can also be integrated. At the end of the process, the finished paper bags are generally stacked automatically so that they can be processed or packaged directly.
[0006] Traditionally, the production speed of a paper bag line, which includes the paper bag machine, is set by a machine operator. Thus, the machine's calibration depends on the operator's subjective assessment, particularly their evaluation of the prevailing production conditions and the impact of any calibration changes on the production process. This often leads to losses in time, material, and efficiency. Document CN 117619757 A discloses a paper bag machine for sorting good and bad bags and a control method, wherein the paper bag machine is sequentially equipped with a plurality of stations, each station being equipped with a detection mechanism, a reference mechanism, a conveying mechanism, and a removal mechanism, and wherein the detection mechanism is located at the initial sectioning station to detect the good and bad paper bags.that enter the paper bag machine; the removal mechanism is located at the end station and is used to remove the defective bags; the reference mechanisms are located at all stations between the detection mechanism and the removal mechanism and are used to perform corresponding actions; and the conveying mechanisms are located at all stations and are used to continuously convey the paper bags from the starting station to the end station.
[0007] The invention aims to simplify the calibration of a paper bag machine. In particular, it aims to objectify the calibration of a paper bag machine, i.e., to define it as universally validly as possible, independent of the assessment of a machine operator.
[0008] This problem is solved by the doctrine of independent claims. Advantageous embodiments are claimed in dependent claims.
[0009] A first aspect of the invention relates to a method for determining control data for a paper bag machine and / or for calibrating a control unit of the paper bag machine in which setpoint values are stored on the basis of which the paper bag machine is controlled, wherein the paper bag machine is set up to produce paper bags from roll stock, and wherein the method comprises:
[0010] Recording operational data of at least one paper bag machine on a time basis, which includes values of a machine speed in sampling intervals and a quantity of paper bags produced;
[0011] Checking the operating data for a dependency between machine speed and a resulting good production rate; determining a target value for the machine speed based on a detected dependency; and
[0012] Output of the target value for the machine speed, especially to the control unit of the paper bag machine.
[0013] The production rate is preferably determined or calculated from operational data, in particular the quantity of goods per unit of time. Therefore, the method preferably further comprises: calculating the production rate based on the recorded operational data.
[0014] A second aspect of the invention relates to a computer program or computer program product, wherein the computer program or computer program product contains instructions, in particular stored on a computer-readable and / or non-volatile storage medium, which, when executed by a computer, cause the computer to perform the steps of a method for determining control data for a paper bag machine and / or for calibrating a control unit of the paper bag machine. Preferably, the method according to the first aspect of the invention is therefore at least partially computer-implemented.
[0015] A third aspect of the invention relates to a system for calibrating a control unit of a paper bag machine, in which setpoint values are stored on the basis of which the paper bag machine is controlled, wherein the paper bag machine is set up to produce paper bags from roll material, and wherein the device comprises:
[0016] a first interface for reading in operating data of at least one paper bag machine with respect to a time basis, which includes values of a machine speed in sampling intervals and a quantity of paper bags produced;
[0017] An electronic evaluation unit, configured to check the operating data for a dependency between the machine speed and a resulting product production rate, and to determine a target value for the machine speed based on a detected dependency; and a second interface for outputting the target value for the machine speed, in particular to the control unit of the paper bag machine. In one embodiment, the electronic evaluation unit has means for checking the operating data for a dependency between the machine speed and a resulting product production rate, and means for determining a target value.
[0018] An evaluation unit within the meaning of the invention is a computer or a part of a computer. A means within the meaning of the present disclosure can be configured in hardware and / or software and, in particular, comprises a processing unit, preferably a microprocessor (CPU), preferably data- or signal-connected to a storage and / or bus system, and / or one or more programs or program modules. The CPU can be configured to execute instructions implemented as a program stored in a storage system, to acquire input signals from a data bus, and / or to output signals to a data bus. A storage system can comprise one or more, in particular different, storage media, in particular optical, magnetic, solid-state, and / or other non-volatile media. The program can be configured to embody the methods described herein.is capable of executing such procedures, so that the CPU can perform the steps of such procedures and thus, in particular, analyze at least one technical device or train a classification algorithm.
[0019] The term "means" as used herein encompasses all structures, materials, or actions set forth herein, as well as all equivalents thereof. Furthermore, the structures, materials, or actions and their equivalents include everything described in the abstract, the brief description of the figures, the detailed description, the summary, and the claims themselves. A system and / or its means may preferably take the form of a pure hardware variant, a pure software variant (including firmware, resident software, microcode, etc.), or a combination of software and hardware aspects, generally referred to as a "circuit," "module," or "system." Any combination of one or more computer-readable media may be used. The computer-readable medium may be a computer-readable signaling medium or a computer-readable storage medium.The systems and methods according to the present disclosure can preferably be implemented in conjunction with a suitably configured computer, a programmed microprocessor or microcontroller and one or more peripheral integrated circuit elements, an ASIC or other integrated circuit, a digital signal processor, a hard-wired electronic or logic circuit, such as a circuit with discrete elements, a programmable logic device or gate arrangement, such as a programmable logic device (PLD), a programmable logic array (PLA), a field-programmable gate array (FPGA), a programmable logic arrangement (PAL), or a comparable means.In general, any device or means capable of implementing the methodology presented herein may be used to implement the various aspects of this disclosure. Exemplary hardware includes computers, handheld devices, telephones (e.g., cellular, internet-enabled, digital, analog, hybrid, and others), and other hardware known in engineering. Some of these devices include processors (e.g., a single or multiple microprocessors), memory, non-volatile memory, input devices, and output devices. Furthermore, alternative software implementations, including but not limited to distributed processing or distributed processing of components / objects, parallel processing, or processing by virtual machines, may be developed to implement the procedures described herein.
[0020] A fourth aspect of the invention relates to a paper bag line comprising a paper bag machine and a device for calibrating a control unit of the paper bag machine, wherein the production line further comprises a control unit, sensors for measuring the operating data and a storage unit for storing the operating data.
[0021] The invention is based on the understanding that machine speed, which essentially determines production speed, plays a crucial role in operating a paper bag machine, which forms part of a paper bag line, with the highest possible productivity. If the paper bag machine is run too slowly, its capacity is not fully utilized. Conversely, if it is run too fast, problems such as increased rejects and jams occur, which can negatively impact overall productivity. As explained at the outset, the responsibility for setting this critical parameter currently generally lies with the machine operator. For them, it is often more advantageous to run the machine somewhat slower in order to have to correct fewer jams.
[0022] This is where the invention comes in: The operating data, which is available at a control unit or a data bus system of the paper bag machine and includes at least the good production rate and the machine speed, is recorded and collected. Recording, as defined in the present disclosure, preferably involves reading measured operating data via a data interface. Alternatively or additionally, recording includes determining, in particular measuring, a measurement signal using a sensor and / or post-processing a measurement signal to generate the operating data. This operating data is then analyzed for a relationship between the machine speed and a resulting good production rate. The good production rate preferably indicates the number of good paper bags produced in a predefined unit of time. Good paper bags are preferably those that are not rejects.The quantity or number of good paper bags is therefore preferably derived from the total quantity or number of good paper bags in a production batch, also called the good quantity, minus the quantity or number of paper bags in the production batch that are defective, also called the defective quantity. Based on this relationship, a target value for the machine speed is determined. Instead of the good production rate, the capacity utilization rate, which is directly proportional to it, can also be considered. For this, the respective good production rate is divided by a predefined maximum value for the machine speed.
[0023] When setting or determining the target value for the machine speed, boundary conditions can be taken into account. Such boundary conditions can be optimization criteria. If the good production rate or capacity utilization is being optimized, the target value is the machine speed at which a maximum good production rate and / or maximum capacity utilization was achieved. Furthermore, a target value for the machine speed can be chosen in such a way that it best fulfills a predefined optimization criterion, e.g., a minimum quantity of goods with limited scrap and limited downtime. The target value is then output. Output, as defined in this disclosure, preferably means making the information available. Preferably, this is done via a data interface. However, it is also possible to output information via a user interface, such as a screen.In particular, the specified target value is output to the control unit of the paper bag machine.
[0024] The invention takes advantage of the fact that the values of the good production rate can be determined discreetly and without conversion directly at the machine, since the respective number of paper bags produced, which were not sorted out by the paper bag machine and are therefore "good", can be counted at the end of the floor layer.
[0025] By precisely determining an optimal production speed or machine speed with respect to at least one criterion, efficiency can be maximized and the machine capacity of a paper bag machine can be optimally utilized. Subjective assessments by the operating personnel are not necessary for this. The target value is based solely on data-driven analyses. The invention also makes it possible to continuously optimize the production speed based on current operating data. Such regular adjustment of the target speed ensures that the paper bag machine is always operated optimally.
[0026] In one embodiment, the procedure further features the following:
[0027] Defining a calibration function based on a dependency between machine speed and a resulting good production rate;
[0028] where the target value for the machine speed is determined using the calibration function.
[0029] Accordingly, the electronic evaluation unit in one embodiment of the system is configured and / or includes means to define a calibration function based on a relationship between machine speed and a resulting output rate, wherein the target value for the machine speed is determined by means of the calibration function. A calibration function within the meaning of this disclosure is an assignment rule that assigns a value to at least one machine speed as a function of the value of a resulting output rate. Any type of mathematical function is possible here, for example, constant functions, Boolean functions, or statistical functions that allow statistical statements about the data set. The use of a calibration function makes it possible to represent relationships in a general way and to optimize them by means of curve sketching.
[0030] In a further embodiment, the procedure also features the following:
[0031] Determining downtime of the paper bag machine based on the values of the operating data, in particular the machine speed,
[0032] where downtime during the checking of operating data is taken into account in relation to the dependency between machine speed and the resulting good production rate.
[0033] Accordingly, the electronic evaluation unit is set up in a configuration of the system and / or has means to determine downtimes of the paper bag machine based on the values of the operating data, in particular the machine speed, whereby the downtimes when checking the operating data take into account the dependence between the machine speed and the resulting product production rate.
[0034] In this way, an effective output rate, also called the total output rate, can be calculated, which takes downtime into account.
[0035] In a further embodiment of the procedure, the operational data also reveal reasons for downtime, and the procedure further exhibits the following:
[0036] Identify, based on the operating data, first downtimes lasting less than a predefined period, in particular about 5 minutes, and second downtimes caused during operation by a first fault indicating a crease in the paper, or by a second fault indicating a fault in a paper bag valve; the first and second downtimes being taken into account when checking the operating data for differences between the machine speed and the resulting good production rate.
[0037] Accordingly, in one configuration of the system, the operating data further indicates reasons for downtime, and the electronic evaluation unit of the system is equipped and / or has means to identify, based on the operating data, first downtimes lasting less than a predefined period, in particular about 5 minutes, and second downtimes triggered during operation by a first fault indicating a crease in the paper or by a second fault indicating a defect in a valve for paper bags, whereby only the first downtimes and / or the second downtimes are considered when checking the operating data for dependencies between the machine speed and the resulting good production rate.
[0038] This approach allows for the identification of downtimes that are highly likely attributable to the order currently being processed by the paper bag machine. The effective production rate determined in this way therefore excludes downtimes that can be attributed to the general operation of the paper bag machine. This increases the reliability of the determined target value.
[0039] In a further embodiment, the procedure also features the following:
[0040] Assigning machine speed values to speed levels in predefined operating intervals, especially with interval durations of approximately 1 minute;
[0041] Calculating level durations, which indicate how long the paper bag machine was operated at each speed level, in particular where idle times of a level duration are added to the preceding speed level; and
[0042] Calculating the product production rate for each speed level, wherein the quantity of product produced during a speed level is divided by the respective level duration. Accordingly, the electronic evaluation unit in one embodiment of the system is configured and / or has means to assign the machine speed values to speed levels at predefined operating intervals, in particular with interval durations of approximately 1 minute, in order to calculate level durations which indicate how long the paper bag machine was operated at each speed level, in particular wherein downtimes of a level duration are attributed to the preceding speed level, and to calculate the product production rate for each speed level, wherein the quantity of product produced during a speed level is divided by the respective level duration.
[0043] By combining machine speed values into speed levels, the amount of data is increased, leading to statistically more precise and reliable results.
[0044] In a further embodiment, the procedure also features the following:
[0045] Check whether the level durations exceed or fall below a threshold, whereby the good production rate is only calculated for those speed levels whose level duration exceeds the threshold and / or whereby the good production rate of those speed levels whose level duration falls below the threshold is not used to identify the maximum good production rate.
[0046] Accordingly, the electronic evaluation unit is set up in a system configuration and / or has means to check whether the level durations exceed or fall below a threshold, whereby the good production rate is calculated only for those speed levels whose level duration exceeds the threshold and / or whereby the good production rate of those speed levels whose level duration falls below the threshold is not used to identify the maximum good production rate.
[0047] Exceeding the threshold within the meaning of this disclosure includes the threshold itself. By taking into account the durations of the individual speed levels, it can be ensured that a sufficient amount of data is available for a speed level to make statistically representative statements for that speed level. In a further embodiment, the method also features the following:
[0048] Calculating a capacity utilization rate for each speed level, where the good production rate of the speed levels is divided by a predefined maximum value of the machine speed.
[0049] Accordingly, in a further embodiment of the system, the electronic evaluation unit is set up and / or has means to calculate a capacity utilization rate for each speed level, whereby the good production rate of the speed levels is divided by a predefined maximum value of the machine speed.
[0050] This generates a percentage value that is more easily understood by the user. The percentage value indicates what percentage of the theoretically maximum possible machine speed for producing good paper bags was achieved.
[0051] In a further embodiment of the process and the system, the target value of the machine speed is that machine speed and / or lies at that speed level in which a maximum good production rate and / or a maximum capacity utilization is achieved.
[0052] This ensures maximum production as a boundary condition.
[0053] In a further embodiment, the procedure also features the following:
[0054] Check whether a maximum good production rate and / or a maximum capacity utilization is achieved at the highest available speed level; if so, the target machine speed is set at the next higher speed level.
[0055] Accordingly, in a further embodiment of the system, the electronic evaluation unit is configured and / or includes means to check whether a maximum product production rate and / or maximum capacity utilization is achieved at the highest available speed level, whereby, if this is the case, the target value of the machine speed is set at the next higher speed level. This ensures that the production optimum of the paper bag machine is not located at a higher machine speed that has not yet been reached.
[0056] In a further embodiment, the procedure also features the following:
[0057] Controlling the paper bag machine based on the setpoint.
[0058] This allows not only the control unit of the paper bag machine to be calibrated, but also the paper bag machine to be operated in a control loop.
[0059] In a further embodiment of the method and the system, operational data from production processes of paper bags with the same machine speed-relevant product characteristics are recorded, whereby the machine speed-relevant product characteristics are selected from the following product characteristics:
[0060] Dimensions of the paper bags;
[0061] Floor construction, in particular straight-cut hose or stepped-cut hose; number of layers of paper bags;
[0062] Valve type, in particular the number of layers in the valve, insertion position, valve tube formed in the apparatus, warped valve, valve opening outside the base square.
[0063] These product characteristics have proven to be particularly relevant and critical for the stability of the paper bag production process on paper bag machines. Therefore, it is advisable to categorize operational data from the production of different paper bags and / or on different machines according to these characteristics. Here, too, the increased data volume resulting from product grouping leads to more precise and reliable results regarding the target values.
[0064] In a further embodiment of the method and the system, only operating data from the last 12 months of the paper bag machine are recorded and / or considered, and / or only operating data in a predefined maintenance state of the paper bag machine are recorded and / or considered. In a further embodiment of the method and the system, operating data from several paper bag machines of the same type are recorded.
[0065] These measures also lead to more precise and reliable results regarding target values due to the increased data volume resulting from product grouping. In particular, considering the maintenance status can be used to optimally adjust production speed.
[0066] In a further embodiment of the method and the system, the operating data also include values for the reject quantity of paper bags produced at sampling intervals. The good production rate depends on at least one of two parameterizable scalar evaluation factors, namely a downtime factor, which specifies a weighting of the downtime of the paper bag machine in the good production rate, and a reject factor, which specifies a weighting of a reject quantity produced by the paper bag machine in the good production rate. The downtime factor and / or the reject factor are parameterized on the basis of predefined, in particular operational, boundary conditions, so that the good production rate is weighted with respect to these boundary conditions.
[0067] One such boundary condition could be a comparatively high wear risk of a particular machine or limited availability of operating personnel. In this case, the downtime factor would be increased, thus weighting downtime more heavily to penalize it more severely during optimization. Another or alternative boundary condition could be the use of comparatively expensive materials. In this case, the scrap factor would be increased to penalize material losses more severely during optimization.
[0068] According to this further development, a key performance indicator (KPI) is determined that is not solely productivity-related, such as the pure good production rate or the pure capacity utilization rate. Instead, the effects of downtime and scrap are also considered in a single, combined KPI. This aims to provide a more universal recommendation or target value for machine speed that better reflects the actual operational and / or economic constraints and is therefore closer to the decisions of experienced machine operators. The parameterizability of the evaluation factors allows, in particular, flexible adaptation to different production environments and cost structures.
[0069] The speed recommendation therefore explicitly considers not only pure productivity but also the negative effects of downtime and scrap. This brings the specified or recommended machine speed closer to the actual operating behavior of experienced machine operators, resulting in greater acceptance and practical applicability. Material losses due to scrap and wear-related disadvantages caused by excessive downtime and malfunctions can thus be reduced.
[0070] In one embodiment of the system, the operating data also includes values of a reject quantity of produced paper bags at sampling intervals, and the system also has a user interface via which two scalar evaluation factors of the good production rate can be parameterized, namely a downtime factor that indicates a weighting of the downtime of the paper bag machine in the good production rate, and a reject factor that indicates a weighting of a reject quantity produced by the paper bag machine in the good production rate.
[0071] The enhanced visualization of relative downtime rate and relative scrap in the speed histogram increases transparency for the operator regarding the consequences of different speed levels.
[0072] Further features and advantages will become apparent from the following description in relation to the figures. They show, at least partially schematically:
[0073] Figure 1 shows an embodiment of a production line with a paper bag machine and a calibration system;
[0074] Figure 2 shows an embodiment of a method for determining control data for a paper bag machine; Figure 3 shows a first histogram relating to level durations of different speed levels and capacity utilization at different speed levels;
[0075] Figure 4 shows two tables with numerical examples for calculating the output rate and capacity utilization rate, as well as the weighted output rate and weighted capacity utilization rate; and
[0076] Figure 5 shows a second histogram in relation to level durations of different speed levels and a speed rating by a weighted capacity utilization rate at different speed levels.
[0077] Figure 1 shows an embodiment of a production line 20 for paper bags, comprising a paper bag machine 1 and a system 10 for calibrating a control unit 2 of the paper bag machine 1. The paper bag machine 1 includes a tube forming machine 1A and a bottom layer 1B. Furthermore, sensors 3A, 3B, 3C, and 3D are provided on the production line 20 for acquiring operating data BD of the paper bag machine 1. The acquired operating data BD preferably includes values for the machine speed of the paper bag machine 1, in particular the tube forming machine 1A and / or the bottom layer 1B, values for the quantity of good paper bags produced, values for the quantity of reject paper bags produced, values for the total quantity of paper bags produced, and / or wear data, e.g., regarding the wear of components.
[0078] The following types of sensors for recording operational data (BD) are given as examples.
[0079] Flow sensors, particularly optical sensors or light barriers, are suitable for recording machine speed and / or total quantity. These sensors count units produced, such as bags, per unit of time. Alternatively, speed sensors can be used on drive shafts to measure the rotational speed of conveyor belts or production rollers and derive the machine speed and / or total quantity from this measurement. Inductive proximity sensors or capacitive sensors are suitable for metallic or non-metallic materials. Optical inspection systems, such as cameras with image processing, are suitable for recording the quantity of good and / or defective products. These systems detect defective products, such as incorrectly sized or damaged bags, and count the rejects. Examples include industrial cameras with AI-based analysis.Additionally, weight sensors, such as load cells, can be used to check whether the products reach the target weight, with deviations being considered rejects. Color sensors are also suitable for detecting color variations, for example, in the printing of bags.
[0080] Vibration sensors, particularly accelerometers, can be used to detect standstill events by recording unusual vibrations that indicate downtime or mechanical problems. Current sensors on motors can measure power consumption, with a sudden drop indicating a standstill. Temperature sensors, such as PT100s or thermocouples, monitor critical components like bearings or gears, as overheating can lead to downtime. Pressure sensors in hydraulic or pneumatic systems detect pressure drops that indicate leaks or blockages.
[0081] Ultrasonic sensors are suitable for capturing wear data. They measure the material thickness of components such as conveyor belts or rollers to detect wear. Vibration sensors, especially for bearings, analyze frequency spectra to identify wear in bearings or gears at an early stage. Particle sensors in lubricants detect metal particles that indicate abrasion.
[0082] RFID or barcode scanners can record material consumption, such as rolls of raw material, and assign it to specific orders. Time tracking systems, such as NFC chips on machines, can track operator activity to monitor staffing levels. Energy monitoring sensors measure energy consumption per machine to allocate costs.
[0083] The sensors 3A, 3B, 3C, 3D can be part of the paper bag machine 1, as shown in Figure 1. Alternatively, the sensors 3A, 3B, 3C, 3D can also be part of the calibration system 10. Cameras and measuring sensors can be used as sensors 3A, 3B, 3C, 3D. The operating data acquired by the sensors 3A, 3B, 3C, 3D can be temporarily stored in a first data storage device 4 of the production line 20, as shown in Figure 1. This data storage device 4 can also be part of the paper bag machine 1 or part of the calibration system 10.
[0084] The control unit 2 of the paper bag machine 1 contains setpoint values on which the paper bag machine 1 is controlled. In particular, these setpoint values can be stored depending on the operating data BD of the paper bag machine 1, for example in a so-called lookup table or in the form of a mathematical function.
[0085] The operating data BD, as indicated by the ones and zeros in Figure 1, are at least partially transmitted to the calibration system 10 via a data connection. This data connection can be wired or wireless.
[0086] In the illustrated embodiment, the calibration system 10 has a first interface 11 for reading in the operating data BD, which is provided by the sensors 3A, 3B, 3C, 3D. The operating data BD is specifically assigned to a time base. Furthermore, the calibration system 10 has an electronic evaluation unit 12, which can perform data processing based on the operating data BD. In particular, control data SD for the paper bag machine 1 can be determined by means of the data processing by the electronic evaluation unit 12.
[0087] A second data interface 14 of the calibration system 10 is provided to output the control data SD determined by the evaluation unit to the controller 2 of the paper bag machine 1. The transmission of the control data from the second interface 14 to the controller 2 can also be wired or wireless. Alternatively, the determined control data is stored in the second data storage device 13 and is available there for further use in controlling the paper bag machine 1 and calibrating the controller 2 of the paper bag machine 1. In Figure 1, the calibration system 10 is shown as a separate unit from the paper bag machine 1. In another embodiment, the calibration system 10 can be operated on a server. In particular, the calibration system 10 can be operated in the cloud.Furthermore, in one embodiment, it is possible that one or more paper bag machines from which the operating data are recorded and collected are different paper bag machines than the paper bag machine 1, which is calibrated or controlled based on the specific control data SD. In an alternative embodiment, it is also possible to integrate the calibration system 10 into the paper bag machine 1, in particular into the control unit 2 of the paper bag machine 1.
[0088] In another embodiment, the first interface 11 and the second interface 14 can be configured as a single interface.
[0089] Figure 2 shows an embodiment of a method 100 for determining control data SD for the paper bag machine 1 and / or for calibrating the control unit 2 of the paper bag machine 1.
[0090] In the first step, operating data BD of paper bag machine 1 are recorded. This operating data BD is assigned to a time base, which specifically defines the operating time of paper bag machine 1. Based on this time base, the operating data BD is recorded at sampling intervals.
[0091] The operational data (BD) includes at least machine speed and production quantity values, each recorded at sampling intervals based on time. Furthermore, the operational data (BD) can also include reasons for downtime, likewise based on time. In addition, the operational data (BD) can already specify the downtimes themselves based on time.
[0092] Alternatively, in a second work step 102, the downtimes are determined based on the operating data BD, in particular on the machine speed values.Downtime can be categorized, for example, downtime shorter than a predefined duration, particularly five minutes, and downtime due to malfunctions such as malfunctions in the gluing system, paper web breakage, electrical malfunctions, roll changes, paper jams, valve or label detection errors, cleaning downtime, preventive maintenance, repairs, a faulty glue contour or a defective glue die, full storage belts, missing hoses, missing material, missing tools, missing order information, incorrect pallet pattern, poor hose quality, poor glue quality, poor paper quality, a faulty preprint, a production break, a changeover process, malfunctions in the compressed air supply, malfunctions in the glue supply, malfunctions in the water supply, or a power outage.
[0093] Downtime can be divided into order-related and general downtime resulting from routine operations. Order-related downtime is characterized by lasting less than a predefined period, typically around five minutes, and / or being caused by an order-related issue. Such issues might include a paper jam, a roll change, a valve or label detection error, a valve malfunction, and / or order-related cleaning.
[0094] In one embodiment, the first step 101 exclusively records and / or considers operating data BD from the last 12 months of the paper bag machine 1 and / or exclusively operating data BD in a predefined maintenance state of the paper bag machine 1. Similarly, in another embodiment, exclusively operating data BD from several paper bag machines 1 of the same type are recorded. In yet another embodiment, exclusively operating data BD from production processes of paper bags with identical product characteristics relevant to machine speed are recorded.Here, the machine speed-relevant product characteristics can be selected from the following product characteristics: dimensions of the paper bags, bottom construction, in particular straight-cut tubing or stack-cut tubing, number of layers of the paper bags, valve type, in particular the number of layers in the valve or their insertion positions, valve tubing formed in the apparatus, warped valve, valve opening outside the bottom square. In a third step 103, downtimes are identified based on the operating data BD, which are particularly relevant for good production, i.e. the production of good paper bags, especially order-related downtimes.This includes, in particular, initial downtimes lasting less than a predefined period, especially around five minutes, and / or secondary downtimes triggered during operation by a first fault, characterized by a crease in the paper, or by a second fault, characterized by a defect in the paper bag valve. In this way, downtimes can be identified that affect the quantity of good paper bags produced for the currently processed order.
[0095] This has the advantage that only downtimes directly related to the current production order, such as material changes or order-specific malfunctions, are considered. Unplanned or external downtimes, such as maintenance or power outages, do not distort the good production rate. The good production rate then reflects solely the machine's efficiency in relation to the specific order. This allows for a fairer comparison between different orders or machines. Since the evaluation of machine performance, for example, within the framework of the weighted speed recommendation with downtime and scrap factors, is based on order-relevant data, speed recommendations can be more precisely adapted to the actual production conditions. Downtimes that are not related to the order, such as...General maintenance or breaks would otherwise artificially worsen the good production rate, even though they make no statement about performance in the context of the order.
[0096] In a fourth step (104), the machine speed values are assigned to speed levels at predefined operating intervals, which have a duration of approximately one minute. Speed levels group similar speeds into categories, for example, into speed values rounded to the nearest ten. A speed level might therefore, for example, group speeds from 155 pieces / min to 164 pieces / min in one speed level, speeds from 165 pieces / min to 174 pieces / min in another, speeds from 175 pieces / min to 184 pieces / min in another, and so on. In a fifth step (105), level durations are then calculated, indicating how long the paper bag machine operated at each speed level.The specified downtimes, particularly the first and second downtimes, are assigned to a level duration corresponding to the speed level of a preceding operating interval. The operating interval preferably represents the production time of the paper bag machine, i.e., the time during which it is actually operating without downtimes. Therefore, the downtimes are assigned to the speed level that existed in an operating interval before the paper bag machine 1 stopped. The level duration of this speed level is thus extended by the duration of the downtime following an operating interval with that speed level.
[0097] In a sixth step 106, it is checked whether the level durations exceed or fall below a threshold.
[0098] In a seventh step (107), the quantity of goods produced during a speed level—that is, the quantity of good paper bags produced during the level duration, which can also be obtained from the operating data BD—is divided by the respective level duration. This yields the so-called good production rate, which preferably has the unit pieces / min. If downtimes, especially order-related downtimes, are taken into account when determining the good production rate, then the good production rate corresponds to an effective good production rate, which can also be referred to as the total good production rate.
[0099] A preferred formula for calculating the rate of good production can be expressed as follows:
[0100] Good quantity n Good production rate (speed level ri) = - — - Level duration n
[0101] where a level duration for the good production rate can preferably be calculated as follows: Level duration n Operating interval^Speed level n )
[0102]
[0103] If downtime is taken into account in the good production rate, an effective level duration for the effective good production rate can preferably be calculated as follows:
[0104] Level duration n e = ^ (ß e1:r '- e bsinterval i (Speed lev. n ) + downtime i+1 )
[0105] Table 1 of Fig. 4 shows various numerical examples of a calculation of the good production rate based on values of the farm data BD, which are also given in Table 1.
[0106] In one embodiment, this calculation is performed exclusively for those speed levels whose level durations exceed the threshold, with exceeding the threshold being a condition. The remaining speed levels are discarded for determining the control data in this embodiment.
[0107] In an eighth step 108, the operating data BD are then analyzed to determine how a resulting good production rate depends on the respective machine speed.
[0108] In one embodiment, if a good production rate has been calculated at all, this analysis is performed exclusively for those speed levels whose level durations exceed the threshold, whereby exceeding the threshold itself is included. The remaining speed levels are discarded in this embodiment for determining the control data.
[0109] Such an analysis can be performed, in particular, on the basis of a histogram, as shown in Figure 3. In the histogram, the respective calculated level durations of the individual speed levels are indicated as bars. For example, a level duration of 8 hours is given for the speed level of 220 units / min.
[0110] The histogram, on the other hand, shows the so-called capacity utilization rate of paper bag machine 1 for various speed levels between 0 pieces / min and 400 pieces / min. The capacity utilization rate is directly proportional to the product production rate and can be calculated in a ninth step 109 by dividing the respective product production rate by a predefined maximum value for the machine speed.
[0111] A preferred formula for calculating the capacity utilization rate can be expressed as follows:
[0112] Good production rate (^speed level ri) Capacity utilization grade = - : - : - : — : - Machine speed max
[0113] In this case, the maximum machine speed is 400 pieces / min. Accordingly, a capacity utilization rate of 100% would be achieved at a given speed level if a machine speed of 400 pieces / min were reached there.
[0114] Table 1 of Fig. 4 shows various numerical examples of a calculation of the capacity utilization rate.
[0115] The capacity utilization rate in the histogram of Fig. 3 is only shown for those speed levels that exceed the threshold value. In the example shown, the threshold is 0.5 h, so only the capacity utilization rates for speed levels 40 and 200 to 260 units / min are shown in the histogram. The values for the level durations of the other speed levels can be disregarded.
[0116] The histogram shows that the output rate, which is directly proportional to the capacity utilization rate, increases with speed up to a speed of 260 units / min and then decreases again. Based on this identified relationship, a calibration function F can be defined in a tenth step between the machine speed and a resulting output rate. Such a calibration function F can be generated, for example, using a regression model based on a polynomial function. In particular, such a polynomial function can be fitted to the data points in the histogram from Figure 3. In Figure 3, this is indicated by the line F, which connects the individual data points of the capacity utilization rate.
[0117] In an eleventh step 111, it can be checked whether a maximum good production rate or a maximum capacity utilization, depending on whether the conversion according to the ninth step 109 was carried out, lies in the highest speed level, namely in any level defined by the predefined maximum value of the machine speed. As already mentioned, this maximum value of the machine speed in the illustrated embodiment is 400 pieces / min.
[0118] If this is not the case, the maximum production rate or maximum capacity utilization may lie outside the measured range. In this case, a target value SD is determined for the machine speed, which lies in the next higher, as yet unmeasured, speed level. Referring to the histogram in Figure 3, if the maximum production rate or maximum capacity utilization in the last measured speed level were 260 units / min, the determined target value SD would be 280 units / min. Although this speed has already been reached, the level duration does not exceed the predefined threshold. As shown in Figure 2, this target value SD would be output in a thirteenth work step, 113.
[0119] Furthermore, in the eleventh step (111), it can also be checked whether a minimum good production rate or a minimum capacity utilization is achieved at the lowest available speed level. If this is the case, it could also be that a minimum lies outside the investigated range of machine speed. In this case, that is, if this is true, the target value of the machine speed would be at the next lower speed level. In Figure 3, this would be at a machine speed of 20 pieces / min.
[0120] In a twelfth step 112, if no setpoint SD has yet been determined, a setpoint SD for the machine speed is determined based on the dependency identified in the eighth step 108. Alternatively, if a calibration function F has been determined, the setpoint SD can also be determined in the eighth step 108 based on this calibration function F. Preferably, the setpoint SD for the machine speed is the machine speed or lies within the speed level at which a maximum good production rate or maximum capacity utilization occurred, depending on which value was considered.
[0121] Preferably, the setpoint represents the mean value of the speed level in which the setpoint lies.
[0122] Subsequently, this setpoint is output in the thirteenth step 113, in particular via the second data interface 14. Preferably, the setpoint SD is output to the control unit 2 of the paper bag machine 1. In a fourteenth step 114, the paper bag machine 1 can finally be controlled by the control unit 2 on the basis of the determined setpoint, so that the method 100 forms a closed control loop.
[0123] In the previously described embodiment of a method for determining control data for a paper bag machine, a speed recommendation is derived from productivity-related parameters to determine an optimal machine speed for continuously operating production plants for the manufacture of bags or pouches. For this purpose, for example, as explained above, the product output rate or a capacity utilization rate derived from it is evaluated as a function of the machine speed, and a speed value with maximum product output rate and / or capacity utilization is determined as the target value.
[0124] Practical trials and prototype tests have shown that a speed recommendation based solely on productivity metrics often leads to the conclusion that the machine should be operated "even faster" from the algorithm's perspective. Experienced machine operators often disregard such recommendations in practice, even though the underlying productivity-related evaluation is formally correct.
[0125] The reason for this is that, as speed increases, so too do the frequency and / or duration of downtimes and the amount of scrap. These effects have additional negative consequences that go beyond the mere loss of net production time:
[0126] Downtime ties up operating personnel who cannot perform other tasks during this time and can promote increased wear and tear on the machine.
[0127] Rejection not only leads to a reduced number of good products, but also causes a loss of material, e.g. scrapped paper, which is directly associated with costs.
[0128] These aspects are currently taken into account implicitly by operators, leading to the machine being deliberately driven at a lower speed than a purely productivity-oriented recommendation would suggest.
[0129] In one variant of the embodiment of method 100 described above, the recommendation or specification of a target value for the machine speed for different speed ranges or speed levels of the machine is therefore not determined exclusively on the basis of a throughput-related benefit, e.g. a quantity of good parts per unit of time, but additionally a weighting of the negative effects of downtime and / or downtime frequency and of scrap quantity and / or scrap rate is taken into account via explicit evaluation factors in the good production rate indicator.
[0130] The following weighting factors are introduced into the formula for calculating the good production rate:
[0131] • a downtime factor SF, which adjusts the relative importance of downtime compared to productivity, and • a scrap factor AF, which adjusts the relative importance of scrap compared to productivity.
[0132] A preferred formula for calculating a good production rate weighted to include the rejection factor AF can be expressed as follows:
[0133] Total production n — AF x reject quantity n Good production rate gew (Speed level n) = - - - — -
[0134]
[0135] tz 1 / tz V Vv VV Vvtz /
[0136] A level duration for the good production rate can preferably be calculated as follows:
[0137] Level duration n Operating intervals (speed levels)
[0138]
[0139] 1
[0140] If downtimes weighted by the downtime factor SF are taken into account in the good production rate, an effective level duration for the effective good production rate can preferably be calculated as follows:
[0141] Level duration n e = ^(ßs^^bsintervcdl^Speed level n ~) + SF x downtime i+1 )
[0142] Table 2 of Fig. 4 shows numerical examples of the calculation of different weighted good production rates, each with a downtime factor SF of 1.5 and / or a scrap factor AF of 2, where the underlying values of the operational data BD are identical to those in Table 1. Here, the good production rate (SF) is a weighted good production rate weighted solely by the downtime factor SF, the good production rate (AF) is a weighted good production rate weighted solely by the scrap factor AF, and the good production rate (SF, AF) is a weighted good production rate weighted by both the downtime factor SF and the scrap factor AF.
[0143] The weighted good production rate provides an abstracted rating for each speed level, combining the positive contribution of good production with the negative contributions of downtime and scrap into an overall rating. The recommendation or specification of a target value for machine speed is then no longer determined solely based on a maximum good production rate or maximum capacity utilization, but rather on this abstract overall rating.
[0144] The weighting factors are initially specified by the system provider or manufacturer, but can preferably be parameterized by the user to reflect different operational and economic conditions.
[0145] Based on a weighted good production rate, a weighted capacity utilization rate can be calculated, analogous to the equation given above for calculating the capacity utilization rate. Table 2 of Fig. 4 shows the weighted capacity utilization rate (AF, SF), which is weighted by the downtime factor SF and the scrap factor AF.
[0146] Preferably, a variant of the method 100 for determining control data SD for a paper bag machine 1 and / or for calibrating a control unit 2 of the paper bag machine 1 comprises the following steps, which are carried out additionally or at least partially as an alternative to the steps already described for determining the product production rate and the capacity utilization rate:
[0147] • Recording of operational data BD:
[0148] For several different speed levels of machine 1, operating data are recorded over an observation period, which includes at least the following quantities:
[0149] o Quantity of goods, i.e., number of produced, not rejected products per speed level;
[0150] o Rejection quantity, i.e., number or mass of rejected or
[0151] unusable products per speed level;
[0152] o Standstill events, in particular their cumulative duration and / or frequency per speed level.
[0153] • Calculating relative key figures for each speed level:
[0154] From the operating data BD, at least a relative scrap value (e.g., scrap quantity in relation to total production and / or operating time) and a relative downtime rate (e.g., downtime in relation to total operating time and / or number of downtimes per unit of time) are determined for each speed level.
[0155] • Defining weighting factors:
[0156] At least two scalar weighting factors are specified:
[0157] o a standstill factor SF, which specifies the weight with which the standstill rate should be included in the overall assessment of the speed class, and o a reject factor AF, which specifies the weight with which the reject rate should be included in the overall assessment.
[0158] These weighting factors can be preset by the system and preferably changed by the user via a user interface, for example to reflect different material costs or different tolerances to downtime.
[0159] • Calculating an abstracted speed rating value:
[0160] For each speed level, a weighted good production rate is determined based on the good production rate, the relative downtime rate, and the relative scrap rate, as well as the associated evaluation factors. This evaluation value forms a combined key performance indicator that reflects both the productivity-related benefits and the negative effects of downtime and scrap with regard to a predefined operational target.
[0161] The calculation can be performed, for example, by combining a positive component, which correlates with the good production rate or capacity utilization, and negative components for downtime and scrap, scaled with the downtime factor or scrap factor, to form the weighted good production rate.
[0162] • Determining an abstract speed recommendation:
[0163] The machine 1 or an evaluation device 10 connected to the machine 1 determines a speed recommendation from the abstracted evaluation values of the different speed levels by selecting the speed level with the highest value of the weighted good production rate and / or by determining a speed corridor that best fulfills a given optimization criterion, e.g. minimum output with limited scrap and downtime.
[0164] The recommendation thus determined can then be output as a target value to a control unit 2 of the machine 1 and used for an automatic or semi-automatic adjustment of the machine speed.
[0165] In the embodiment of system 10 for calibrating the control unit 2 of a paper bag machine 1 shown in Fig. 1, a speed histogram can be displayed to the operator on a display unit (not shown), in which the operating data BD are visualized for each speed level and which is shown according to a numerical example in Fig. 5. In contrast to a representation that shows only the level durations, as in Fig. 3, or the capacity utilization rate, the extended histogram for each speed level additionally includes a value for the relative reject rate and a value for the relative downtime rate.
[0166] This gives the operator a transparent overview of how the selection of a specific speed level affects not only productivity, but also the frequency of downtime and the amount of scrap. The abstract speed recommendation determined by the method can also be highlighted in the histogram.
[0167] Furthermore, in system 10, the standstill factor SF and the reject factor AF can be set via a parameterization surface of a user interface (not shown).
[0168] This allows the user, in particular, to increase or decrease the impact of scrap relative to productivity, e.g., for particularly expensive materials; to vary the impact of downtime relative to productivity, e.g., for machines subject to particularly high wear or with limited operator resources; and to select pre-configured profiles with different combinations of evaluation factors, e.g., "maximum productivity," "material-friendly operation," "wear-friendly operation." The underlying optimization process remains unchanged; only the weighting of the contributing criteria is adapted to company-specific and customer-specific requirements.
[0169] It should be noted that the exemplary embodiments are merely examples and are not intended to restrict the scope of protection, applications, or structure in any way. Rather, the preceding description provides the person skilled in the art with a guideline for implementing at least one exemplary embodiment, whereby various modifications, particularly with regard to the function and arrangement of the described components, can be made without departing from the scope of protection as defined by the claims and these equivalent combinations of features. Reference numeral list
[0170] 1 paper bag machine
[0171] 2 Control unit
[0172] 3A, 3B, 3C, 3D Sensor
[0173] 4 first data storage
[0174] 10 System
[0175] 11 first interface
[0176] 12 electronic evaluation unit 13 second data storage
[0177] 14 second interface
[0178] 20 production lines
Claims
-33 - Claims 1. Method (100) for determining control data (SD) for a paper bag machine (1) and / or for calibrating a control unit (2) of the paper bag machine (1) in which setpoint values are stored on the basis of which the paper bag machine (1) is controlled, wherein the paper bag machine (1) is set up to produce paper bags from roll stock, and wherein the method (100) comprises: Acquisition (101) of operating data (BD) of a paper bag machine (1 ) with respect to a time basis which includes, at sampling intervals, values of a machine speed and values of a quantity of paper bags produced; Checking (108) the operating data (BD) for a dependency between the machine speed and a resulting good production rate; Determine (112) a setpoint (SD) for the machine speed based on a detected dependency; and Output (113) of the setpoint (SD) for the machine speed, in particular to the control unit (2) of the paper bag machine (1).
2. Method (100) according to claim 1, further comprising: Define (110) a calibration function (F) based on a dependency between machine speed and a resulting good production rate; where the target value for the machine speed is determined using the calibration function.
3. Method (100) according to claim 1 or 2, further comprising: Determining (102) downtimes of the paper bag machine (1) based on the operating data, in particular the machine speed values; wherein the downtimes are taken into account when checking the operating data (BD) on the dependence between the machine speed and the resulting product production rate, in particular wherein the downtimes are taken into account in a calculation of the product production rate.-34- 4. Method (100) according to claim 3, wherein the operating data further includes reasons for downtime and wherein the method (100) further comprises the following: Identify (103), based on the operating data, first downtimes which lasted less than a predefined period, in particular about five minutes, and second downtimes which are caused during operation by a first fault indicating a crease in the paper or by a second fault indicating a fault in a paper bag valve; where only the first downtimes and / or the second downtimes are considered when checking the operating data for dependencies between the machine speed and the resulting good production rate.
5. Method (100) according to any one of the preceding claims, further comprising: Assigning (104) the values of the machine speed in predefined operating intervals, in particular with interval durations of about 1 min, to speed levels; Calculating (105) level durations, which indicate how long the paper bag machine (1) was operated at each speed level, in particular wherein the specified downtimes, especially the first and second downtimes, are added to a level duration of the preceding speed level; and calculating (107) the good production rate for each speed level, wherein the good quantity produced during a speed level is divided by the respective level duration.
6. Method (100) according to claim 5, further comprising: Check (106) whether the level durations exceed or fall below a threshold, wherein the good production rate is calculated only for those speed levels whose level duration exceeds the threshold, and / or wherein the good production rate of those speed levels whose level duration falls below the threshold is not used to check the operational data (BD) for dependency.
7. Method (100) according to any one of the preceding claims, further comprising: Calculate (109) a capacity utilization rate for each speed level, dividing the good production rate of the speed levels by a predefined maximum value of the machine speed.
8. Method (100) according to any one of claims 5 to 7, wherein the setpoint of the machine speed is that machine speed and / or is at that speed level in which a maximum good production rate and / or a maximum capacity utilization was present.
9. Method (100) according to any one of claims 5 to 8, further comprising: Check (111) whether a maximum good production rate and / or a maximum capacity utilization is achieved at the highest available speed level, in particular at 400 units / min; where, if this is the case, the target value of the machine speed is in the next higher speed level.
10. Method (100) according to one of the preceding claims, wherein operating data (BD) from production processes of paper bags with the same machine speed-relevant product characteristics are recorded and wherein the machine speed-relevant product characteristics are selected from the following product characteristics: Dimensions of the paper bags; Floor construction, in particular straight-cut hose or stepped-cut hose; Number of layers of paper bags; Valve type, in particular the number of layers in the valve, insertion position, valve tube formed in the apparatus, distorted valve, valve opening outside the base square.
11. Method (100) according to one of the preceding claims, wherein only operating data (BD) of the last 12 months of the paper bag machine (1) and / or wherein only operating data in a predefined maintenance condition of the paper bag machine are recorded and / or taken into account.
12. Method (100) according to one of the preceding claims, wherein operating data (BD) of several paper bag machines (1) of the same type are recorded.
13. Method (100) according to any one of the preceding claims, where the good production rate depends on at least one of two parameterizable scalar valuation factors, namely a downtime factor (SF) which indicates a weighting of the downtime of the paper bag machine (1) in the good production rate, and a reject factor (AF) which indicates a weighting of a reject quantity produced by the paper bag machine (1) in the good production rate, and where the downtime factor (SF) and / or the scrap factor (AF) are parameterized or are parameterized on the basis of predefined, in particular operational, boundary conditions, so that the good production rate is weighted with respect to these boundary conditions.
14. Method (100) according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the good production rate depends on the reject quantity, and wherein the operational data (BD) further includes values of a reject quantity of paper bags produced at sampling intervals, or wherein the operational data (BD) further includes values of a total quantity of paper bags produced at sampling intervals, and the reject quantity can be calculated from the operational data (BD).
15. Computer program or computer program product, wherein the computer program or computer program product contains instructions, in particular stored on a computer-readable and / or non-volatile storage medium, which, when executed by a computer,-37- cause the computer to perform the steps of a method (100) according to any of the preceding claims.
16. System (10) for calibrating a control unit (2) of a paper bag machine (1), in which setpoint values are stored on the basis of which the paper bag machine (1) is controlled, wherein the paper bag machine (1) is set up to produce paper bags from roll stock, and wherein the device (10) comprises: a first interface (11) for reading in operating data (BD) of a paper bag machine (1) with respect to a time basis, which includes values of a machine speed in sampling intervals and a quantity of paper bags produced; electronic evaluation unit (12), configured to check the operating data (BD) for a dependency between the machine speed and a resulting good production rate and to determine a setpoint (SD) for the machine speed based on a detected dependency; and a second interface (13) for outputting the setpoint (SD) for the machine speed, in particular to the control unit (2) of the paper bag machine (1).
17. System (10) according to claim 16, wherein the operating data (BD) further comprises values of a reject quantity of produced paper bags at sampling intervals, and wherein the system (10) further comprises a user interface via which two scalar evaluation factors of the good production rate can be parameterized, namely a downtime factor which specifies a weighting of the downtimes of the paper bag machine (1) in the good production rate, and a reject factor which specifies a weighting of a reject quantity produced by the paper bag machine (1) in the good production rate.
18. Production line (20) comprising a paper bag machine (1) and a system (10) according to claim 16 or 17, wherein the production line (20) further comprises a control unit (2), sensors (3) for measuring the operating data (BD) and a storage unit (4) for storing the operating data (BD).
