Protein fortification of chocolate and fillings

By dispersing and milling protein in oil to a fine particle size for integration into chocolate, the method addresses the challenge of increasing protein content in chocolate, achieving a high-protein, smooth, and indulgent product with improved nutritional value.

WO2026239011A1PCT designated stage Publication Date: 2026-11-19SOCIETE DES PRODUITS NESTLE SA
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
PCT/EP2026/064298
Authority / Receiving Office
WO · WO
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2026-01-28
Filing Date
2026-05-15
Publication Date
2026-11-19

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing chocolate products face challenges in increasing protein content without compromising taste, texture, and quality, particularly due to the use of new protein sources which require recipe rebalancing and can lead to issues like dryness, chewiness, stickiness, and poor melting behavior.

Method used

A method involving dispersing protein in oil and milling it to a fine particle size (D4,3 < 60 µm) for seamless integration into chocolate, allowing concentrations up to 30% protein, using mills like ball mills or roller refiners, and forming the chocolate through methods like moulding or enrobing.

Benefits of technology

The method achieves a high-protein chocolate with enhanced nutritional value and indulgent taste, maintaining smooth consistency and texture, suitable for various protein sources and dietary preferences.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure IMGF000014_0001
    Figure IMGF000014_0001
  • Figure IMGF000015_0001
    Figure IMGF000015_0001
  • Figure IMGF000017_0001_TABLE
    Figure IMGF000017_0001_TABLE
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The present invention relates to a method of making a protein-fortified chocolate or compound product, or a filling, preferably a protein-fortified milk chocolate product, said method comprising dispersing protein in oil, for example a protein concentrate or a protein isolate; milling the protein dispersion to further reduce the particle size; mixing the milled protein into a chocolate or compound mass or a filling, preferably to a final concentration of at least 15% milled protein expressed as a percentage of the chocolate or compound mass or filling; and forming a protein-fortified chocolate product from the chocolate or compound mass, or forming a protein-fortified filling.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[0001] Protein fortification of chocolate and fillings

[0002] Field of the invention

[0003] The invention relates to the field of confectionery, particularly to a method of producing a protein-fortified chocolate product. The invention targets the ever-growing market demand for healthier snack options without compromising the taste and texture of traditional chocolate.

[0004] Introduction

[0005] In today's health-conscious society, there is a significant trend towards foods that offer not only indulgence but also nutritional benefits. Chocolate, being one of the most popular treats globally, presents a unique opportunity to combine pleasure with health. Protein is a vital macronutrient essential for numerous bodily functions, including muscle repair, immune response, and the production of enzymes and hormones.

[0006] A standard milk chocolate typically comprises between 12-14% of milk solids content, depending on the market and corresponding regulations. Together with protein from cocoa, the final protein content in a chocolate is usually less than 5%, but sometimes up to 10% protein. Increasing protein content in a chocolate typically has a detrimental effect on chocolate characteristics. Likewise, totally (or even partially) replacing milk powder with a new plant protein-containing material is challenging with regards to functionality and flavour in chocolate.

[0007] The use of different protein containing materials in chocolate, requires rebalancing of the recipe, both due to regulatory constraints, but also due to the physicochemical characteristics that each of these ingredients have on the processing of the chocolate or compound mass. In addition, the use of new protein containing materials can range from being affordable to being several times more expensive than milk powder, and the rebalance needed in the recipe. Usually more fat needs to be added which renders them rather costly and with poor taste and texture and quality problems over shelf life, for example bloom formation.

[0008] In the last decades, many chocolate products have appeared in the market, that use dairy or plant proteins as a vehicle for providing lower sugar contents, replacing milk powder, or as a way of providing the intrinsic benefits of the proteins. However, preserving the characteristics of chocolate amid protein reformulation remains a challenge. Some of the consumer top complaints for this type of products are dryness, chewiness, stickiness, and different melting behaviour.

[0009] The challenge lies within balancing these components without compromising texture or flavour perception by consumers. This requires an understanding of the recipe from an ingredient mixing requirements perspective as well as the processing conditions required to achieve the desired product quality attributes like smoothness mouthfeel taste. Additionally, other factors influencing final product characteristics include particle sizedistribution degree and conching time temperature control during the manufacturing process.

[0010] Achieving protein claims is not straightforward depending on the market. It is generally easier to do it when the addition of protein is independent of the product serving size, because not as much protein is needed in the product. In some countries like the USA, in order to achieve high protein claims, there is a need to consider how much of the protein in the serving size or the reference amount customarily consumed, contributes to the Daily Value recommended per day. In other countries like Australia, the high protein claim is regulated per serving size. In China, high protein claims can be per 100 g. In Europe, it is calculated how much energy in the final product is obtained from the added protein. High protein claims in some countries could mean as little as between 10 to 12% protein in the final product.

[0011] Summary of the Invention

[0012] The invention relates to a method of making a protein-fortified chocolate or compound product which avoids the poor sensory attributes normally associated with high protein chocolate.

[0013] By integrating high-quality protein into chocolate, this invention also addresses the dietary needs of various consumer segments, such as athletes, fitness enthusiasts, and individuals seeking to boost their protein intake.

[0014] The method involves dispersing a protein, which could be a concentrate or an isolate, separately in oil. This step ensures that the protein integrates seamlessly into the chocolate or compound mass, maintaining the desired smooth consistency.

[0015] Using milling, preferably a ball mill, bead mill or roller refiner, the protein dispersion is milled to achieve a particle size (D4,3) of less than 60 m, with a preference for sizes under 20 pm. Such fine milling ensures an even distribution of protein throughout the chocolate, resulting in an indulgent product.

[0016] The milled protein is mixed into the chocolate or compound mass to a final concentration of at least 15%, potentially increasing to 20% or even 30%, when expressed as a percentage of the chocolate or compound mass. This is a much higher concentration than that found in conventional chocolate products, providing enhanced nutritional value without sacrificing taste.

[0017] The method is suitable for a variety of protein sources, both non-dairy (such as sunflower or pea protein) and dairy-based (whey protein). This flexibility allows the product to cater to different dietary preferences and restrictions.

[0018] The chocolate product can be formed through various methods such as moulding, enrobing, or panning. This versatility opens up numerous possibilities for product differentiation and market segmentation.

[0019] The milled protein contributes significantly to the caloric content of the chocolate, with at least 12%, and preferably about 20%, of the total calories derived from protein. The milledprotein may contribute between 12% to 31% of the total calories derived from protein. This substantially improves the nutritional profile, making the product appealing to healthconscious consumers.

[0020] Embodiments of the invention

[0021] The present invention relates to a method of making a confectionery product, for example a chocolate or compound product, or a filling.

[0022] In some embodiments, the invention relates to a method of making a chocolate or compound product.

[0023] The invention further relates to a method of making a protein-fortified chocolate or compound product, preferably a protein-fortified milk chocolate product, said method comprising

[0024] a. Dispersing protein in oil, for example a protein concentrate or a protein isolate; b. Milling the protein dispersion to further reduce the particle size;

[0025] c. Mixing the milled protein into a chocolate or compound mass, preferably to a final concentration of at least 15%, or between 20% to 35% milled protein, when expressed as a percentage of the chocolate or compound mass; and

[0026] d. Forming a protein-fortified chocolate or compound product from the chocolate or compound mass.

[0027] The invention further relates to a method of making a protein-fortified filling, said method comprising

[0028] a. Dispersing protein in oil, for example a protein concentrate or a protein isolate; b. Milling the protein dispersion to further reduce the particle size;

[0029] c. Mixing the milled protein into a filling, preferably to a final concentration of at least 15%, or between 20% to 35% milled protein, when expressed as a percentage of the filling; and

[0030] d. Forming a protein-fortified filling.

[0031] In some embodiments, milling the protein dispersion in step b) is performed using a ball mill, bead mill, air classifier or roller refiner.

[0032] In some embodiments, the protein is milled to a particle size D4,3 of less than 60 pm in step b).

[0033] In some embodiments, the protein is milled to a particle size D4,3 of less than 20 pm in step b).In some embodiments, the protein is milled to a particle size D4,3 of between 10 to 20 pm in step b).

[0034] In some embodiments, the protein dispersed in oil and milled according to the method of the invention comprises at least one protein selected from whey protein isolate and plant protein isolate, preferably pea protein isolate, wherein the protein is milled to a particle size D4,3 of less than 20 pm in step b).

[0035] In some embodiments, the product or filling is obtained by separately milling the protein in oil prior to incorporation into the chocolate or compound mass or filling, such that the protein is pre-dispersed in a fat phase before contact with the remaining ingredients.

[0036] In some embodiments, the protein dispersion is milled using a ball mill.

[0037] In some embodiments, the protein dispersion is milled using a bead mill.

[0038] In some embodiments, the protein dispersion is milled using an air classifier.

[0039] In some embodiments, the protein dispersion is milled using a roller refiner.

[0040] In some embodiments, the protein dispersion further comprises sugar particles. In some embodiments, the 40 wt% sugar may be milled with between about 10-20 % wt% protein, for example about 10 wt%, 13.3 wt% or about 20 wt.% protein of the total suspension, typically up to about 60 wt.% solids.

[0041] In some embodiments, the protein comprises a blend of at least one fermentation-derived protein and at least one dairy protein.

[0042] In some embodiments, the protein is or comprises a blend of yeast protein and whey protein, preferably yeast protein isolate and whey protein isolate.

[0043] In some embodiments, the weight ratio of fermentation-derived protein to dairy protein is from 10:90 to 90:10, preferably from 30:70 to 70:30.

[0044] In some embodiments, the protein is whey protein concentrate or whey protein isolate. In some embodiments, the protein concentrate or protein isolate is derived from one or more non-dairy sources, for example sunflower or pea or yeast or soy.

[0045] In some embodiments, pea protein isolate is dispersed in cocoa butter in step a).

[0046] In some embodiments, the protein is pea protein, the oil is cocoa butter, and the pea protein is milled to about 18 pm.

[0047] In some embodiments, the protein is pea protein, the oil is cocoa butter, and the pea protein is milled to about 17 pm.

[0048] In some embodiments, the protein is pea protein, the oil is cocoa butter, and the pea protein is milled to about 1 pm.

[0049] In some embodiments, about 10 wt% milled protein is used.

[0050] In some embodiments, about 20 wt% milled protein is used.In some embodiments, between 20 to 35 wt% milled protein is used.

[0051] In some embodiments, between 25 to 30 wt% milled protein is used.

[0052] In some embodiments, particle size is measured using small- and wide-angle X-ray scattering.

[0053] In some embodiments, the milled protein is mixed into the chocolate mass or compound mass to a final concentration of at least 20% milled protein, expressed as a percentage of the chocolate mass or compound mass.

[0054] In some embodiments, the milled protein is mixed into the chocolate mass or compound mass to a final concentration of between 20% to 35%, or between 25% to 30% milled protein, expressed as a percentage of the chocolate mass or compound mass.

[0055] In some embodiments, the milled protein is mixed into the filling to a final concentration of at least 20% milled protein, expressed as a percentage of the filling.

[0056] In some embodiments, the milled protein is mixed into the filling to a final concentration of between 20% to 30%, or between 25% to 35% milled protein, expressed as a percentage of the filling.

[0057] In some embodiments, the final product or filling comprises from 25 g to 32 g protein per 100 g of product and / or wherein from 18% to 25% of the total energy is derived from protein. In some embodiments, the chocolate product is formed by moulding, enrobing, or panning. The invention further relates to a chocolate product, preferably a milk chocolate product, made by a method according to the invention.

[0058] In some embodiments, said chocolate product further comprises inclusions.

[0059] In some embodiments, the protein has a particle size D4,3 of less than 60 pm.

[0060] In some embodiments, the protein has a particle size D4,3 of less than 20 pm.

[0061] In some embodiments, the protein is whey protein concentrate or whey protein isolate. In some embodiments, the protein concentrate or protein isolate is derived from one or more non-dairy sources, for example sunflower or pea.

[0062] In some embodiments, the protein is pea protein, the oil is cocoa butter, and the pea protein is about 18 pm.

[0063] In some embodiments, the protein is pea protein, the oil is cocoa butter, and the pea protein is about 17 pm.

[0064] In some embodiments, the protein is pea protein, the oil is cocoa butter, and the pea protein is about 1 pm.

[0065] In some embodiments, particle size is measured using small- and wide-angle X-ray scattering.In some embodiments, the chocolate product is formed by moulding, enrobing, or panning. In some embodiments, the milled protein contributes at least 12% of the total calories of the chocolate product, preferably at least 15%, or at least 20% of the total calories of the product or filling.

[0066] In some embodiments, the milled protein contributes between 15% to 30% of the total calories of the product or filling.

[0067] In some embodiments, the milled protein contributes between 15% to 25% of the total calories of the product or filling.

[0068] In some embodiments, the milled protein contributes between 20% to 30% of the total calories of the product or filling.

[0069] In some embodiments, the milled protein contributes between 20% to 25% of the total calories of the product or filling.

[0070] In some embodiments, the confectionery product is a filling, and the protein is yeast protein, for example yeast protein isolate.

[0071] In some embodiments, the confectionery product is a filling, and the protein is whey protein, for example whey protein isolate.

[0072] In some embodiments, the confectionery product is a filling, and the protein is a blend of yeast protein and whey protein.

[0073] In some embodiments, the confectionery product is a filling, and the protein is wheat protein, for example wheat protein isolate.

[0074] In some embodiments, the confectionery product is a filling, and the protein is soy protein, for example soy protein isolate.

[0075] Detailed description of the invention

[0076] Preparation of protein suspensions

[0077] The suspension or dispersion of protein in oil may be prepared by milling. The mill may consist of a rotating agitator and grinding media within a chamber. Different milling apparatus may be used. The first type may consist of a grinding chamber, preferably a stainless steel grinding chamber. The chamber may be of about volume 365 mL. The mill may be operated with a grinding media to fill ratio of about 0.5. Yttrium stabilised zirconium oxide milling beads, for example of 600 - 800 pm diameter, may be used. Suspensions may be transferred to the grinding chamber and the spindle configurated to allow the suspension to coat the milling beads. The mill may be operated at about 4000 rpm and the suspension milled for 60 to 240 min. A Wiener ball mill may be operated with a grinding media to fill ratio of about 0.68. Chrome steels balls, for example of diameter 9.5 mm, may be used. Suspensions are then transferred to the grinding chamber and milled, for example at a speed of about 219.4 rpm for about two hours.Additional methods may be used to prepare larger volumes and higher particle concentrations of milled PPI, that were then diluted to the desired protein concentration. A suspension of PPI particles in oil with volume weighted mean diameter (D4,3) of about 19 pm may be obtained.

[0078] Particle size

[0079] Preferably, the particle size distribution (PSDs) of protein particles are measured by light scattering, for example with a Mastersizer 3000. It may be equipped with a Hydro SM wet sample dispersion unit. Suspensions may be dispersed in sunflower oil until the laser obscuration reached over 1%. PSDs may be obtained using Mie theory as a mathematical model. Preferably, the particle size distribution (PSDs) of chocolate is measured by light scattering, for example with a Mastersizer 3000. It may be equipped with the Hydro SM oil sample dispersion unit. A suspension of liquid chocolate in oil may be subjected to ultrasound to eliminate aggregates. Preferably, the particle size of the final chocolate is between 15 to 25 pm.

[0080] Rheological analysis

[0081] Rheological analysis of the PPI suspensions may be performed using an Anton Paar MCR 302 rheometer. Measurements may be performed using a 50 mm diameter circular plate-plate geometry. Oscillation measurements may be conducted during crystallisation. This may follow a controlled heating and cooling protocol. Samples can first be heated to about 80 °C and equilibrated for about 10 minutes. They may then be cooled to about 20 °C at a constant rate of about 3 °C / min. Upon reaching 20 °C, oscillatory measurements can be performed at about every minute at a fixed frequency of 1 Hz and strain amplitude of 0.1 %.

[0082] Small- and Wide-angle X-ray Scattering

[0083] Small- and Wide-angle X-ray scattering experiments (SAXS / WAXS) can be performed using a SAXSpace instrument (Anton Paar GmbH, Graz, Austria). The copper anode may operate at about 40 kV and about 50 mA (A = 0.154 nm). The sample chamber may have a temperature-controlled stage capable of maintaining temperatures from -30 to 150 °C (± 0.1 °C). Simultaneous SAXS / WAXS measurements can be performed at a sample-detector distance of about 130 mm, covering a scattering vector q range from 0.1 to 17.6 nm-1 where q = 4TT(sin 0) / A, with 20 being the scattering angle. The 1D scattering patterns may be recorded with a Mythen microstrip X-ray detector (Dectric Ltd., Baden, Switzerland). Samples can first be melted on a hot plate and then injected into 1.5 mm quartz disposable capillaries (Capillary Tube Supplies Ltd., Cornwall, UK). The capillaries can subsequently be sealed with wax. Samples can be equilibrated at about 20 °C for 5 min, then heated to 80 °C at a constant rate of 3 °C / min. Upon reaching 80 °C, the samples can be equilibrated for 10 min in order to completely melt and erase any crystal memory. This may be followed by cooling at 3 °C / min to 20 °C after which the sample remained under isothermal conditions for 24h. Once 20 °C is reached, measurements can be performed continuously for 10 min, with an exposure time of 1 min. After the first 10 min of isothermal conditions, measurements can be taken every 10 min for 120 min, after which measurements were taken every 30 min for 24h. After 24h, samples can remain in a temperature-controlledroom, with further measurements after 2, 3, 4, 7, 10, 16, 21, and 28 days under isothermal conditions.

[0084] The position of the primary beam of all scattering patterns can be set to zero using SAXStreat software (Anton Paar GmbH, Graz, Austria). All data can then be normalised for their transmission using SAXSquant software (Anton Paar GmbH, Graz, Austria), setting the scattering intensity at q = 0 to unity. The normalised empty capillary scattering can then be subtracted from the normalised sample patterns.

[0085] Protein

[0086] Pea protein is a coproduct of starch extraction from peas. Pea proteins may be used in the form of concentrates (60-80% protein), and isolates (>80% protein). Pea protein consists mainly of globulins (65%-80%) and two minority fractions: albumins and glutelins. Globulins comprise three different proteins: legumin, vicilin, and convicilin. Pea protein isolate mainly consists of albumin (2S) and globulin. The molecular weight of albumin is in the range of 5 to 80 kDa, with 6 and 25 kDa as the principal. Globulin, a salt-soluble protein, is divided into 3 categories: legumin (11S), vicilin (7S), and convicilin.

[0087] Traditionally, whey protein products such as Whey protein concentrates (WPG) and isolates were produced from cheese whey. At present, whey protein products can also be manufactured from ultrafiltration (UF) or microfiltration (MF), utilizing whey from skimmed milk through milk protein fractionation, the protein content of whey protein concentrate can range from 35- 80% protein, but achieving higher protein content than 50% requires the use of diafiltration. Whey protein isolate (WPI) is a highly purified form of whey protein that contains more than 80% protein by weight. The main component of WPI is p-lactoglobulin, which constitutes more than 75% of the protein content. Other proteins included are a-lactalbumin, Glycomacropeptides, Bovine Serum Albumin (BSA), immunoglobulins, lactoferrin and lactoperoxidases.

[0088] Sunflower protein is obtained from the seeds of sunflower, which inherently have high amounts of protein (30-50%). After dehulling of seed and extracting oil, the protein content may reach 50-66% in the meal. This may be used directly, obtaining a sunflower protein concentrate. Further extraction processes may achieve protein contents up to 90% to create sunflower protein isolate (60-90% protein). Sunflower protein powder is composed of two main protein types, i.e, water soluble albumins (Sunflower albumins, 2S) and salt soluble globulins (helianthinin, 11S). These two types are present in a ratio of 2:1 (11S:2S respectively)

[0089] Oil

[0090] The oil can be, for example, sunflower oil or cocoa butter. Cocoa butter equivalents may also be used. Cocoa Butter Equivalents are combinations of other exotic fats which have the physical properties and molecular structure which are nearly identical to cocoa butter. They are neutral in taste, and are typically deodorised. Nutritionally they are identical to cocoa butter (9 kcal / g, 60-65% SFA). They can add functionality to finished product depending on quality used.

[0091] Recipe ingredientsPreferably, the sucrose, skimmed milk powder, cocoa butter, cocoa mass, lecithin, sunflower protein, whey protein isolate, and pea protein isolate have the macronutrient contents substantially the same as described in Table 1, Table 2 and Table 3.

[0092] Product of the invention

[0093] Preferably, the product of the invention comprises the same ingredients in substantially the same amounts as described for Recipe 2, Recipe 5, Recipe 6, Recipe 9, and / or Recipe 34. Preferably, the product of the invention has the same protein type, is processed using substantially the same method and has substantially the same particle size as described for Recipe 2, Recipe 5, Recipe 6, Recipe 9, and / or Recipe 34.

[0094] Preferably, the product of the invention comprises the same ingredients in substantially the same amounts as described for any one of Recipes 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 34.

[0095] Preferably, the product of the invention has the same protein type, is processed using substantially the same method and has substantially the same particle size as described for any one of Recipes 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 34. Preferably, the product or filling of the invention comprises between 500 to 600 Kcal / 100g; 15 to 40g Protein / 100g; 25 to 40g Fat / 100g; 25 to 50g Carbohydrate / 100g; and 25 to 50g Sugar / 100g.

[0096] Preferably, the product or filling of the invention comprises between 500 to 600 Kcal / 100g; 15 to 25g Protein / 100g; 25 to 40g Fat / 100g; 25 to 50g Carbohydrate / 100g; and 25 to 50g Sugar / 100g.

[0097] Preferably, the product or filling of the invention comprises between 500 to 600 Kcal / 100g; 25 to 40g Protein / 100g; 30 to 40g Fat / 100g; 25 to 35g Carbohydrate / 100g; and 25 to 35g Sugar / 100g.

[0098] Preferably, the product or filling of the invention comprises about 549.51 Kcal / 100g; about 30.54g Protein / 100g; about 35.00g Fat / 100g; about 29.51g Carbohydrate / 100g; and about 28.96g Sugar / 100g.

[0099] Preferably, the product or filling of the invention comprises about 550.20 Kcal / 100g; about 30.20g Protein / 100g; about 35.00g Fat / 100g; about 27.79g Carbohydrate / 100g; and about 27.17g Sugar / 100g.

[0100] Preferably, the product or filling of the invention comprises about 523.23 Kcal / 100g; about 15.21g Protein / 100g; about 29.12g Fat / 100g; about 49.62g Carbohydrate / 100g; and about 48.99g Sugar / 100g.

[0101] Preferably, the product or filling of the invention comprises about 523.48 Kcal / 100g; about 22.04g Protein / 100g; about 35.00g Fat / 100g; about 27.24g Carbohydrate / 100g; and about 26.69g Sugar / 100g.

[0102] In some embodiments, the product is a composite wafer product comprising a filling and a chocolate coating, for example between 35 - 40% wafer, 35 - 40% filling, and 20 - 30%chocolate, for example about 38% wafer, about 38% filling and about 24% chocolate coating.

[0103] Definitions

[0104] As used herein, the singular forms "a," "an" and "the" include plural unless the context clearly dictates otherwise.

[0105] The words "comprise," "comprises" and "comprising" are to be interpreted inclusively rather than exclusively. Likewise, the terms "include," "including" and "or" should all be construed to be inclusive, unless such a construction is clearly prohibited from the context.

[0106] The compositions disclosed herein may lack any element that is not specifically disclosed. Thus, a disclosure of an embodiment using the term "comprising" includes a disclosure of embodiments "consisting essentially of and "consisting of the components identified. Similarly, the methods disclosed herein may lack any step that is not specifically disclosed herein. Thus, a disclosure of an embodiment using the term "comprising" includes a disclosure of embodiments "consisting essentially of” and "consisting of” the steps identified.

[0107] The term "and / or" used in the context of "X and / or Y" should be interpreted as "X," or "Y," or "X and Y." Where used herein, the terms "example" and "such as," particularly when followed by a listing of terms, are merely exemplary and illustrative and should not be deemed to be exclusive or comprehensive. Any embodiment disclosed herein can be combined with any other embodiment disclosed herein unless explicitly stated otherwise. As used herein, "about" and "approximately" and “substantially” are understood to refer to numbers in a range of numerals, for example the range of -20% to +20% of the referenced number, for further example the range of -10% to +10% of the referenced number, preferably within -5% to +5% of the referenced number, more preferably within -1% to +1% of the referenced number, most preferably within -0.1 % to +0.1 % of the referenced number.

[0108] As used herein, “chocolate”, for example in the European Union, typically comprises at least 25% cocoa solids, at least 14% milk solids, at least 3.5% milk fat, and less than 5% cocoa butter equivalents. The total fat from link and cocoa is typically at least 25%.

[0109] The invention will now be illustrated by way of examples, which should in no way be thought to limit the scope of the invention as herein described.

[0110] EXAMPLES

[0111] Example 1

[0112] Preparation of protein suspensions

[0113] Miling was explored as a method to reduce the reduce the size of pea protein isolate (PPI) particles in oil. The method consisted of a rotating agitator and grinding media within achamber generating shear, impact, and frictional forces to break aggregates towards the primary particle size.

[0114] Two milling apparatus were used. The first type was a bead mill, consisting of a stainless steel grinding chamber (of volume 365 mL excluding spindle) plus a ceramic spindle that were fabricated for use with a Silverson high shear mixer (L5M-A, Silverson, Chesham, UK). The mill was operated with a 0.5 grinding media to fill ratio, using yttrium stabilised zirconium oxide milling beads of 600 - 800 pm diameter. Suspensions of volume 92 mL were transferred to the grinding chamber and the spindle set to 100 rpm for 1 min to allow the suspension to coat the milling beads. The mill was then operated at the 4000 rpm-and the suspension milled for 60 to 240 min. Milling was also conducted using industrial scale apparatus, a Wiener ball mill (Royal Duyvis Wiener B.V., Koog aan de Zaan, Netherlands) operated with a 0.68 grinding media to fill ratio, using chrome steels balls of diameter 9.5 mm. Suspensions of 1 kg were transferred to the grinding chamber and milled at a speed of 219.4 rpm for two hours.

[0115] This method was used to prepare larger volumes and higher particle concentrations of milled PPI, that were then diluted to the desired protein concentration. A suspension of PPI particles in oil was generated with volume weighted mean diameter (D4,3) = 19 pm. Since the mechanisms of the two methods are identical and the particle size distributions produced by both processes were comparable, the only distinction was that the first method achieved the similar particle size distribution (PSD) in shorter times due to the higher speed and grinding media to fill ratio, increasing the frequency of stress events. The results from both methods can therefore be compared.

[0116] Example 2

[0117] Comparison of milling type

[0118] PPI suspensions were milled using a bead mill and a ball mill, and compared to a non-milled suspension. The suspensions were prepared according to Example 1. As shown in Figure 1 , similar results were obtained when different mills were used for reduction of particle size, although lower times are needed. This will depend on, for example, the size of balls and volume of equipment.

[0119] Example 3

[0120] Small- and Wide-angle X-ray Scattering (SAXS / WAXS)

[0121] Samples were prepared using the bead mill as described in Example 1. Small- and Wide-angle X-ray scattering experiments (SAXS / WAXS) were performed using a SAXSpace instrument (Anton Paar GmbH, Graz, Austria). The instrument is equipped with a copper anode and operates at 40 kV and 50 mA (A = 0.154 nm). The sample chamber has a temperature-controlled stage (TCStage 150, Anton Paar, Graz, Austria) capable of maintaining temperatures from -30 to 150 °C (± 0.1 °C). Simultaneous SAXS / WAXS measurements were performed at a sample-detector distance of 130 mm, covering a scattering vector q range from 0.1 to 17.6 nm-1 where q = 4TT(sin 0) / A, with 20 being thescattering angle. The 1D scattering patterns were recorded with a Mythen microstrip X-ray detector (Dectric Ltd., Baden, Switzerland).

[0122] Samples were first melted on a hot plate and then injected into 1.5 mm quartz disposable capillaries (Capillary Tube Supplies Ltd., Cornwall, UK). The capillaries were subsequently sealed with wax.

[0123] SAXS / WAXS measurements were carried out following a similar heating protocol to that used for rheological and PLM measurements. Samples were first equilibrated at 20 °C for 5 min, then heated to 80 °C at a constant rate of 3 °C / min. Upon reaching 80 °C, the samples were equilibrated for 10 min in order to completely melt and erase any crystal memory. This was followed by cooling at 3 °C / min to 20 °C after which the sample remained under isothermal conditions for 24h. Once 20 °C were reached, measurements were performed continuously for 10 min, with an exposure time of 1 min. After the first 10 min of isothermal conditions, measurements were taken every 10 min for 120 min, after which measurements were taken every 30 min for 24h. After 24h, samples remained in a temperature-controlled room, with further measurements after 2, 3, 4, 7, 10, 16, 21, and 28 days under isothermal conditions.

[0124] The position of the primary beam of all scattering patterns was set to zero using SAXStreat software (Anton Paar GmbH, Graz, Austria). All data were then normalised for their transmission using SAXSquant software (Anton Paar GmbH, Graz, Austria), setting the scattering intensity at q = 0 to unity. The normalised empty capillary scattering was then subtracted from the normalised sample patterns. It must be noted that resulting diffraction patterns contained smeared peaks due to the line-focus collimation system. For identification of the polymorphs, and TAG chain packing and stacking distances, no desmearing procedure was required.

[0125] Table 1. Long and short spacings of cocoa butter crystals with and without milled pea protein particles, measured by small- and wide-angle X-ray scattering.

[0126] ~ CB on ;ly CB + 10 wt.% milled CB + 20 wt.% milled CB + 10 wt.% milled pea protein (18 pm) pea protein (17 pm) pea protein (1 pm)a long, o , 49.5 49.8 49.9 50.1 spacing (A)

[0127] a short ' 4.21 4.22 4.21 4.24 spacing (A)

[0128] long44.4 44.4 44.5 45.1 spacing (A)

[0129] 6r’ short 4 , 35- 4 1R- spacings 0-7 4.36; 4.17; 3.88 4.36; 4.17; 3.88 4.36; 4.18; 3.88 (A)3 87

[0130] spa Pc .ionngg(.A..) 64.3 64.6 64.5 64.4

[0131] B

[0132] pshort 4 59 3 98

[0133] . „ ’ „ ' 4.59; 3.98; 3.86; 3.75; 4.60; 3.99; 3.87; 3.76; 4.60; 3.98; 3.86; 3.75; spacings 3.87; 3.75;

[0134] 3.66 3.67 3.67

[0135] (A) 3.66Both pure cocoa butter, and cocoa butter containing milled PPI particles of various sizes and concentration initially crystallised into the a-polymorph, followed by the sequential transformation to P’ and ultimately the stable p-polymorph. This indicates that the presence of protein particles does not alter therefore the polymorphic transition pathway of cocoa butter.

[0136] The presence of milled PPI particles also does not significantly affect the long spacings (lamellar stacking) distances of the cocoa butter TAG molecules within the crystal. In the wide-angle regime, the short spacings (chain packing) were also unchanged, indicating comparable chain packing between the different systems. This suggests that PPI is not integrated into the cocoa butter crystal lattice, as the fat crystal structure is not disturbed in the presence of the protein. The desired p polymorph forms without significant lattice distortion, indicating similar resistance to bloom and fat migration as in pure cocoa butter, with no increased risk of instability caused by the protein particles in this model system.

[0137] Example 4

[0138] Rheology

[0139] Rheological analysis of the PPI, sugar and mixed suspensions was performed using an Anton Paar MCR 302 rheometer (Anton Paar GmbH, Graz, Austria). PPI suspensions were prepared using the ball mill as outlined in Example 1. Sugar and WPI suspensions were milled for 1 hour using the same apparatus. The resulting protein and sugar suspensions were then combined to achieve a 2:1 sugarprotein ratio, corresponding to 40 wt.% sugar and 20 wt.% protein relative to the total suspension mass. All measurements were performed using a 50 mm diameter circular plate-plate geometry, sandblasted to avoid slip (Upper plate PP50 / S, lower plate Inset I-PP50 / SS / S). Oscillation measurements were conducted during crystallisation following a controlled heating and cooling protocol. Samples were first heated to 80 °C and equilibrated for 10 min, before being cooled to 20 °C at a constant rate of 3 °C / min. Upon reaching 20 °C, oscillatory measurements were performed every minute at a fixed frequency of 1 Hz and strain amplitude of 0.1 %. This low strain was selected to ensure the measurements were within the linear viscoelastic region and to minimize shear disturbance on the crystallisation process. Measurements were performed in triplicate using a new sample loading and the mean values are presented in all rheology figures with the standard deviations about these means shown as the error bars.

[0140] Figure 2 shows the development of elastic modulus (G’) with time for cocoa butter and cocoa butter with added milled particles during isothermal crystallisation at 20 °C. PPI, WPI and sugar particles had 04,3 values of 17, 11, and 5 pm respectively.

[0141] In the early stages of crystallisation, when the solid fat content is low, the addition of milled particles increases the elastic modulus (G’) of the system by an order of magnitude compared to pure cocoa butter. This is likely due to particle aggregation and structure formation, as well as potential interactions between the particles and fat crystals. As more fat crystals form and grow, the elastic moduli reach equilibrium values, which are the sameorder of magnitude regardless of the presence of particles. This suggests that the particles have an effect in molten fat, but as the fat crystallises this effect diminishes as the mechanical properties become dominated by the fat crystals. Notably, even with substitution of fat by up to 20 wt.% protein, and 40 wt.% sugar, the G’ at high Solid Fat Content (SFC) remains largely unaffected.

[0142] Example 5

[0143] Particle size analysis by laser diffraction

[0144] The particle size distribution (PSDs) of milled PPI, WPI and sugar particles were measured by light scattering with a Mastersizer 3000 equipped with the Hydro SM wet sample dispersion unit (Malvern Instruments, Worcestershire, UK). The particle suspensions were prepared as described in Example 1. Suspensions were dispersed in sunflower oil until the laser obscuration reached > 1%. PSDs were obtained using Mie theory as a mathematical model; the refractive index for sunflower oil was set to 1.464, and 1.54 for PPI in oil. The volume weighted mean diameter (D4,3) is calculated according to:

[0145]

[0146] where ni is the number of particles of diameter Di.

[0147] Table 2Sample

[0148]

[0149] D10 D50 D90 Non-milled PPI 57.0 ± 1.8 13.8 ± 0.5 50.1 ± 1.4 109.3 ± 3.8 Non-milled WPI 56.6 ± 3.5 13.5 ± 0.4 44.7 ± 1.6 116.7 ± 9.7 10 wt.% PPI 1 hr 18.3 ± 0.2 8.3 ± 0.0 16.3 ± 0.0 30.8 ± 0.1 (bead mill)

[0150] 20 wt.% PPI 1 hr 17.4 ± 0.3 6.4 ± 0.1 14.3 ± 0.4 32.1 ± 1.5 (bead mill)

[0151] 10 wt.% PPI 4 hr 2.9 ± 0.2 0.5 ± 0.0 1.2 ± 0.1 7.6 ± 0.5 (bead mill)

[0152] Milled PPI 2 hr (ball 16.5 ± 0.5 6.7 ± 0.2 14.5 ± 0.5 29.3 ± 0.9 mill)

[0153] Milled WPI 1 hr (ball 10.6 ± 0.2 3.9 ± 0.2 9.3 ± 0.2 19.3 ± 0.4 mill)

[0154] Milled sugar 1 hr 5.1 ± 0.2 0.8 ± 0.0 2.9 ± 0.2 12.6 ± 0.2 (ball mill)

[0155] The particle size distribution (PSDs) of chocolate was measured by light scattering with a Mastersizer 3000 equipped with the Hydro SM oil sample dispersion unit (Malvern Instruments, Worcestershire, UK). A suspension of liquid chocolate in oil is subjected to ultrasound to eliminate aggregates. A portion of this suspension is added into the dispersion unit, where oil is placed, until obtaining approximately 20% of obscuration. PSDs were obtained using Mie theory as a mathematical model. The refractive index for the oil used at 20C was set 1.449, and 1.55 for chocolate in oil. Results were expressed in micrometers (pm) as follows: D10: The size of particles, at 10 % of the cumulative distribution, D50: The size of particles, at 50 % of the cumulative distribution and D90: The size of particles, at 90 % of the cumulative distribution

[0156] Example 6

[0157] Differential Scanning Calorimetry

[0158] Chocolate samples were melted fully at 60 °C prior to testing. Samples were then stirred thoroughly and approximately 1.350 mg of chocolate was placed into 30|JL pans with another pan on top (double pan) for better thermal contact. The sample was then placed in a PerkinElmer DSC 8000, subjected to temperature program that will mimic the water jacket temperatures in a factory environment and aim to understand what the best temperature is for tempering a chocolate and aim the highest proportion of Beta V crystal growth. The sample was first held for 5 min at 70°C. Then cooled down from 70 to 45°C at 20C / min. Then, the sample was held for 120 min at 18°C, to then be heated from 18 to 25°C at200°C / min. The sample was then held for 5 min at 25°C. The protocol was then repeated to achieve a final temperature of 19°C and 20°C, respectively.

[0159] Example 7

[0160] Sensory analysis

[0161] Chocolate moulded samples were tasted by an untrained panel (10 people), with a random allocation of samples. Each panelist had to rate how different each chocolate sample was compared to a Reference chocolate, using several texture attributes. The chosen Reference was a chocolate sample with a source of protein claim (12% of total energy coming from protein addition) and manufactured using standard chocolate practices. An example of this type of reference chocolate can be seen in Table 3. The texture attributes were pre-selected by the sensory panel lead, as important to explain the texture of chocolates and more precisely, protein containing chocolates. These attributes were: Overall texture, Hardness, Dryness, Grittiness, Powderiness, Stickiness and Melting time. Finally, the panelists could also give comments about overall perception of the chocolates.

[0162] Overall texture is defined as “Overall perception of texture in the mouth”. Hardness is defined as “Strength required to break the product”. Dryness is defined as “Product that breaks into bits when chewed (dry) as opposed to a product that forms a paste (moist)”. Grittiness is defined as “The perception of particle size as evaluated between the tongue and palate or between the tongue and teeth”. Powderiness is defined as “A tactile sensation in the mouth provoked by the presence of tiny particles like undissolved powder or flour. Especially perceivable on teeth surface, the upper front teeth and in the throat while chewing”. Stickiness is defined as “Extent to which the product sticks to the teeth or palate during biting and chewing or during movement in the mouth”. Melting time is defined as “Time necessary for the product to melt in mouth”.

[0163] Example 8

[0164] Chocolate with high protein content and improved crystallisation

[0165] A chocolate with high protein was produced by using the method of the invention. First, a suspension was created mixing whey protein with 50% of the cocoa butter in the recipe and milled using a ball mill down to <20pm. Alternatively, a roll refiner can also be used for this purpose to obtain the same D90 but different particle size distribution. The remaining ingredients in the chocolate mass shown in were mixed with the remaining fat fraction and milling continued to obtain a chocolate particle size of less than 20pm.

[0166] Without wishing to be bound by theory, it is believed that the process allows for the protein particles to increase in surface hydrophobicity as the particle size is reduced in oil, due to exposure of hydrophobic groups. This is desired for the proteins to be dispersed effectively in the oil phase and thus improve final sensory perception. Potential protein denaturation may also occur due to localised temperature during milling. Particle sizes of the finalchocolate around 20 m seem to be best to have a mass that is fit for moulding and enrobing purposes.

[0167] This chocolate (Recipe 2) was compared to a chocolate recipe with source of protein (Reference) and high protein (Recipe 1) that were both manufactured using standard chocolate making practices where all ingredients are mixed and refined at once, and where the surface characteristics of the protein particles are likely to be randomly exposed rather than targeted by the two step milling.

[0168] After the milling step, the chocolate mass was sieved.

[0169] Alternatively, if a roller refiner is used for milling, the chocolate flake obtained during milling is subjected to conching for 3.5 hours, where the remaining fat and lecithin were used to obtain the right rheological properties and flavour profile.

[0170] Afterwards, the liquefied chocolate was hand tempered at around 30 C to obtain the right stable crystals. Then the mass is poured into square moulds and cooled down to 8C. After a minimum of 1 hour, the chocolate squares were demoulded, metal detected and stored at 18C until further analyses.

[0171] As shown in Table 3, the recipes generated in this example were named as Prior Art Reference, Recipe 1, and Recipe 2. The final chocolate could be moulded, enrobed or deposited into chocolate shells at 28-31 °C. Once consumed, it provided a smooth mouth coating sensory sensation.

[0172] Table 3

[0173] Ingredients (%) Prior Art Recipe 1 Recipe 2

[0174] Reference

[0175] (%) Recipe of the

[0176] (%) invention (%)

[0177] Sucrose 34.66 25.05 25.05

[0178] Skimmed milk powder 9.20 6.08 6.08

[0179] Milk fat 4.08 4.08 4.08

[0180] Cocoa butter 24.13 24.06 24.06

[0181] Cocoa mass 11.50 11.50 11.50

[0182] Lecithin sunflower 0.56 0.56 0.56

[0183] Whey protein isolate 15.87 28.67 28.67

[0184] Total 100.00 100.00 100.00

[0185]

[0186] Kcal / 100g 553.23 549.51 549.51

[0187]

[0188] Ingredients (%) Prior Art Recipe 1 Recipe 2

[0189] Reference

[0190] (%) Recipe of the

[0191] (%) invention (%) Protein / 100g 19.65 30.54 30.54

[0192] Fat / 100g 35.00 35.00 35.00

[0193] Carbohydrate / 100g 40.58 29.51 29.51

[0194] Sugar / 100g 40.02 28.96 28.96

[0195]

[0196] The DSC results (Figure 3) showed that upon tempering, the chocolate of the invention (Recipe 2), developed an initial stronger network of Beta V crystals (most stable crystal form), as a high peak was formed at around 32°C. This peak was larger than that corresponding to the Beta IV crystals (peak at around 22°C). During the following 2-week maturation phase in chocolate, it is expected that those Beta IV crystals evolve towards the highest stable form Beta V, due to the fact the graph shows a connection between those two peaks, i.e., there is not a deep dip between them, and both crystal forms may work together to develop a strong crystal network.

[0197] On the other hand, Recipe 1 (Chocolate with high protein produced with standard manufacturing techniques) showed two similar peaks for Beta IV and V crystals, as well as a dip between those peaks, suggesting that there is not a good connection network between those two group of crystals and thus, the strength of the crystal network produced is not as good as that shown in Recipe 2 (Chocolate with high protein produced according to the invention). Upon repeated heat shock during storage, or through the supply chain, chocolates manufactured with Recipe 2 are expected to have a higher resistance towards possible bloom.

[0198] In Figure 4, differences in sensory attributes between chocolates and a Reference chocolate with source of protein are shown. If there is no difference with the Reference, then a flat line would be shown at the 0 point in the X scale. Chocolates manufactured according to the invention (Recipe 2) showed improved sensory attributes compared to chocolates manufactured with standard techniques (Recipe 1). Chocolates of the invention (Recipe 2) were perceived as less hard, less dry, less powdery and with overall better texture than the high protein chocolates produced with standard techniques (Recipe 1).

[0199] Example 9

[0200] Chocolate with high protein content and improved sensory

[0201] The same procedure was followed as described in Example 8, but using pea protein. The method of the invention using targeted particle size milling techniques was performed (Recipe 5) and compared to a reference, Recipe 3 and Recipe 4. The processing was also done in a recipe with 6% less total fat content, Recipe 6.Table 4

[0202] Recipe 3 Recipe 4 Recipe 5 Recipe 6 (%) (%) Recipe of the Recipe of the invention invention Ingredients (%) (%) Sucrose 34.62 21.96 21.96 40.63 Skimmed milk

[0203] 9.00 9.05 9.05 15.22 powder

[0204] Milk fat 4.08 4.08 4.08 4.08 Cocoa butter 22.75 21.55 21.55 16.82 Cocoa mass 11.50 11.50 11.50 12.69 Lecithin sunflower 0.56 0.56 0.56 0.56

[0205] Pea protein isolate 17.39 31.30 31.30 10.00 Total 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00

[0206]

[0207] Kcal / 100g 554.38 550.20 550.20 523.23 Protein / 100g 18.85 30.20 30.20 15.21 Fat / 100g 35.00 35.00 35.00 29.12 Carbohydrate / 100g 40.42 27.79 27.79 49.62 Sugar / 100g 39.82 27.17 27.17 48.99

[0208]

[0209] Surprisingly, high protein contents were easily processable, even when using lower fat contents. After the mass was created, the chocolate masses were tempered and moulded. Figure 5 shows that upon tempering, the high protein chocolates (Recipe 5) made according to the method of the invention, developed an initial stronger network of Beta V crystals (most stable crystal form), as a high peak was formed at around 32°C. This peak was larger than that corresponding to the Beta IV crystals (peak at around 22°C). Moreover, the DSC graph shows a connection between the first and the second peaks (corresponding to Beta IV and Beta V crystals). This is a desired feature, since it will mean that during the following 2-week maturation phase in chocolate, those Beta IV crystals will evolve towards the highest stable form Beta V, creating an even stronger crystal network against bloom and fat migration, rendering them more stable upon heat shock.On the other hand, chocolates manufactured using the standard chocolate making technique (Recipe 4), showed two similar peaks for Beta IV and V crystals, as well as a dip between those peaks, i.e., no connection between those two peaks. This suggests that there is not a good connection network between those two groups of crystals and thus, the strength of the crystal network produced is not as good as that shown in Recipe 5 (Chocolate with high protein produced according to the invention). Upon repeated heat shock during storage, or through the supply chain, chocolates manufactured with Recipe 5 are expected to have a higher resistance towards possible bloom.

[0210] Example 10

[0211] Chocolate with high protein content and improved sensory

[0212] The same method was followed as set out in Example 8, but using sunflower protein. The method using targeted particle size milling techniques was performed (Recipe 9) and compared to a reference Recipe 7 and Recipe 8.

[0213] Table 5

[0214] Ingredients Recipe 7 Recipe 8 Recipe 9

[0215] (%) (%) Recipe of the

[0216] invention

[0217] (%)

[0218] Sucrose 31.82 24.75 24.75

[0219] Milk fat 4.08 0.00 0.00

[0220] Cocoa butter 21.22 24.52 24.52

[0221] Cocoa mass 11.50 11.50 11.50

[0222] Lecithin sunflower 0.56 0.56 0.56

[0223] Sunflower protein 31.05 38.90 38.90

[0224] Total 100.00 100.00 100.00

[0225]

[0226] Kcal / 100g 531.53 523.48 523.48

[0227] Protein / 100g 17.88 22.04 22.04

[0228] Fat / 100g 35.00 35.00 35.00

[0229] Carbohydrate / 100g 33.93 27.24 27.24

[0230]

[0231] Ingredients Recipe 7 Recipe 8 Recipe 9

[0232] (%) (%) Recipe of the

[0233] invention

[0234] (%)

[0235] Sugar / 100g 33.37 26.69 26.69

[0236]

[0237] Figure 6 shows the differences in sensory attributes between chocolates and a Reference chocolate with source of protein are shown. If there is no difference with the Reference, then a flat line would be shown at the 0 point in the X scale. High protein chocolates manufactured using the method of the invention (Recipe 9), were perceived as smoother, with a better melting in the mouth and overall texture than those high protein chocolates manufactured with standard chocolate techniques (Recipe 8), which were perceived as drier, grainier, and more powdery.

[0238] Example 11

[0239] Chocolate with high protein content using a multiple step milling approach

[0240] A premium chocolate with high protein was produced by using the method of the invention, as explained in Example 1, using a ball mill.

[0241] First, a suspension was created mixing protein and a fraction of the fat, in this case, cocoa butter. The suspension was then milled using a ball mill down to 20pm. A roll refiner can also be used for this purpose to obtain the same D90 but different particle size distribution. The proteins used were pea, yeast, whey, wheat or soy protein isolates (Recipe 10). Yeast protein is a 100% yeast protein extracted from fermentation of yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, and considered a complete protein, since it contains all essential amino acids. Table 6

[0242] Recipe

[0243] Ingredients 10

[0244] Cocoa butter (wt.%) 40%

[0245] Protein isolate (wt.%), i.e.,

[0246] pea, yeast, whey, wheat, soy 60%

[0247]

[0248] Total mass (%) 100%

[0249] Protein / 100g 60.00

[0250] Fat / 100g 40.00

[0251] Sugar / 100g 00.00

[0252]

[0253] Milling of remaining ingredients, i.e., sugar, cocoa butter, cocoa mass and lecithin (Recipe 11), was also done following procedure explained in Example 1 , to achieve a D90 <30pm. Table 7

[0254] Ingredients Recipe 11

[0255] Cocoa butter (wt.%) 25.56 %

[0256] Sugar content (wt.%) 68%

[0257] Cocoa mass (wt.%) 11%

[0258] Lecithin (wt.%) 0.50%

[0259]

[0260] Total mass (%) 100%

[0261] Protein / 100g 0.00

[0262] Fat / 100g 32.00

[0263] Sugar / 100g 68.00

[0264]

[0265] Mixing of both suspensions shown in Recipe 10 and Recipe 11 was then done following Recipe 12 shown in Table 8, to obtain a total content of 19.90% protein.

[0266] Table 8

[0267] Ingredients Recipe 12

[0268] Recipe 10 33.17 %

[0269] Recipe 11 58.53 %

[0270] Cocoa butter 8.30 %

[0271]

[0272] Total 100%

[0273] Protein / 100g 19.90%

[0274] Fat / 100g 40.00%

[0275] Sugar / 100g 39.80%

[0276]

[0277] The final chocolate could be moulded, enrobed or deposited into chocolate shells at 28-31°C. Once consumed, it provided a smooth mouth coating sensory sensation.

[0278] Example 12

[0279] Compound chocolate with high protein content using a multiple step milling approachA compound chocolate with high protein was produced by using the method of the invention, as explained in Example 1, using a ball mill.

[0280] First, a suspension was created mixing protein and a fraction of the fat, in this case, cocoa butter. The suspension was then milled using a ball mill down to 20pm. A roll refiner can also be used for this purpose to obtain the same D90 but different particle size distribution. The proteins used were pea, yeast, whey, wheat or soy protein isolates (Recipes 13). Yeast protein is a 100% Yeast protein extracted from fermentation of yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, and considered a complete protein, since it contains all essential amino acids. Table 9

[0281] Ingredients Recipe 13

[0282] Cocoa butter (wt.%) 50%

[0283] Protein isolate (wt.%), i.e.,

[0284] pea, yeast, whey, wheat, soy 50%

[0285]

[0286] Total mass (%) 100%

[0287] Protein / 100g 50.00

[0288] Fat / 100g 50.00

[0289] Sugar / 100g 00.00

[0290]

[0291] Addition of the remaining ingredients, i.e., sugar, cocoa butter, cocoa powder and lecithin (Recipe 14) were added into the ball mill, to achieve a D90 <30pm.

[0292] Table 10

[0293] Ingredients Recipe 14

[0294] Recipe 19 50.00%

[0295] Sugar content (wt.%) 42.00%

[0296] Cocoa powder (wt.%) 3.00%

[0297] Cocoa butter equivalent (wt.%) 4.50%

[0298] Lecithin (wt.%) 0.50%

[0299] Total mass (%) 100%

[0300]

[0301] Protein / 100g 25.57

[0302] Fat / 100g 30.36

[0303] Sugar / 100g 42.01

[0304]

[0305] The final compound could be moulded, enrobed or deposited into chocolate shells at 28-31°C. Once consumed, it provided a smooth mouth coating sensory sensation.

[0306] Example 13

[0307] High protein cocoa filling with improved sensory and functionality

[0308] The same procedure was followed as described in Example 8 but using yeast, whey, wheat or soy protein isolates or mixtures of whey and yeast protein isolate. The method of the invention using targeted particle size milling techniques was performed (Recipe 16 to 20) and compared to a reference with no protein, Recipe 15.

[0309] Table 12

[0310] Ingredients Recipe 15 Recipe 16 Recipe 17 Recipe 18 Recipe 19 Recipe 20

[0311] Reference Recipe of Recipe of Recipe of Recipe of Recipe of no protein the the the the the invention invention invention invention invention (%)

[0312] (%) (%) (%) (%) (%) Sucrose 39.53 28.96 28.11 27.11 28.41 29.08 Skimmed milk 24.00 9.00 9.00 9.00 9.00 9.00 powder

[0313] Vegetable fat 32.58 31.65 32.50 31.10 31.80 32.13 Cocoa powder 3.00 3.00 3.00 3.00 3.00 3.00 Yeast protein 0.00 26.50 0.00 0.00 0.00 12.95 isolate

[0314] Whey protein 0.00 0.00 26.50 0.00 0.00 12.95 isolate

[0315] Wheat protein 0.00 0.00 0.00 28.90 0.00 0.00 isolate

[0316] Soy protein 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 26.90 0.00 isolate

[0317] Sunflower 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.50 lecithin

[0318] Flavouring 0.39 0.39 0.39 0.39 0.39 0.39 Total 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00

[0319]

[0320] Ingredients Recipe 15 Recipe 16 Recipe 17 Recipe 18 Recipe 19 Recipe 20 Reference Recipe of Recipe of Recipe of Recipe of Recipe of no protein the the the the the invention invention invention invention invention (%)

[0321] (%) (%) (%) (%) (%) Kcal / 100g 551.91 559.23 547.85 551.55 548.78 553.82 Protein / 100g 9.32 28.10 27.65 27.66 27.45 27.78 Fat / 100g 33.50 33.41 33.41 33.52 33.47 33.46 Carbohydrate / 53.75 34.25 33.87 34.74 33.70 34.10 100g

[0322] Sugar / 100g 52.25 33.75 33.38 31.93 33.20 33.61 % energy 6.80 20.10 20.20 20.10 20.00 20.01 coming from

[0323] protein

[0324]

[0325] The final fillings were able to be layered or deposited in a wafer or chocolate containing product, or being eaten on its own. No crocodile effect was seen after several hours or in the following weeks of storage. Crocodile effect is when separation of the wafer and filling occurs due to changes in moisture balance, internal stresses, and adhesion of the filling and wafer.

[0326] The final wafer composite products were crispy, with a smooth soft creamy filling, with an even melt. Recipe 20 had the best flavour delivery due to the mixture of both yeast and whey proteins, that balanced any off-notes, typically from alternative proteins.

[0327] Example 14

[0328] Wafer product with a high protein cocoa filling with improved sensory and functionality

[0329] The high protein filling was created following the same procedure as described in Example 8 but using yeast protein, whey protein, wheat protein, or mixtures of yeast and whey protein. The method of the invention using targeted particle size milling techniques was performed (Recipe 22-25) and compared to a reference filling, Recipe 21.

[0330] Table 12Ingredients Recipe 21 Recipe 22 Recipe 23 Recipe 24 Recipe 25 Reference Recipe of Recipe of Recipe of Recipe of no protein the the the the invention invention invention invention (%)

[0331] (%) (%) (%) (%) Sucrose 39.53 25.21 23.99 23.13 25.49 Skimmed milk 24.00 2.00 2.00 2.00 2.00 powder

[0332] Vegetable fat 32.58 31.40 32.62 30.48 32.02 Cocoa powder 3.00 3.00 3.00 3.00 3.00 Yeast protein 0.00 37.50 0.00 0.00 18.30 isolate

[0333] Whey protein 0.00 0.00 37.50 0.00 18.30 isolate

[0334] Wheat protein 0.00 0.00 0.00 40.50 0.00 isolate

[0335] Sunflower 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.50 lecithin

[0336] Flavouring 0.39 0.39 0.39 0.39 0.39 Total 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00

[0337] Kcal / 100g 551.91 563.25 547.23 551.65 555.35 Protein / 100g 9.32 35.62 34.97 34.67 34.48 Fat / 100g 33.50 33.51 33.51 33.50 33.50 Carbohydrate / 1 52.75 26.80 26.25 28.00 27.41 00g

[0338] Sugar / 100g 52.25 26.30 25.75 24.26 29.91

[0339]

[0340] The filling was used to create a composite product using: 4 layers of wafer and 3 layers of filling at a ratio of 60% filling, 40% wafer. The nutritional values of the wafer used to create the final composite produce is shown in Table 13.

[0341] Table 13Nutritional Values Wafer Wheat flour wafer (%)

[0342] Total Kcal / 100g 383.14

[0343] Total Fat / 100g 3.08

[0344] Total Protein / 100g 9.13

[0345] Total SFA / 100g 0.65

[0346] Total Fibre / 100g 3.46

[0347] Total Sugar / 100g 1.26

[0348]

[0349] Total Carbohydrate / 100g 65.87

[0350] The filling was easy to layer, that flowed easily and set relatively fast to ensure wafers stick together before cutting into final product shapes. After approximately 1 hour at room temperature, the layered wafer sheets were cut to rectangular shapes with a final weight of 30 g (serving size).

[0351] The final wafer filled products had a smooth and creamy taste. The nutritional values of the final product are shown in Table 14. All of them can be classed as high protein cocoa filling wafers in Europe, since at least 20% of the energy is obtained from the protein ingredients.

[0352] Table 14

[0353] Nutritional Recipe 21 Recipe 22 Recipe 23 Recipe 24 Recipe 25 values

[0354] Product Reference Recipe of Recipe of Recipe of Recipe of Total (60% no protein the the the the filling:40% invention invention invention invention wafer) (%)

[0355] (%) (%) (%) (%) Kcal / 100g 484.40 491.21 481.59 484.25 486.46 Protein / 100g 9.25 25.02 24.64 24.46 24.34 Fat / 100g 21.33 21.34 21.34 21.33 21.33 Carbohydrat 58.00 42.43 42.10 43.15 42.79 e / 100g

[0356] Sugar / 100g 31.85 16.28 15.96 15.06 16.65 % energy 7.60 20.40 20.50 20.20 20.00 coming from

[0357] protein

[0358]

[0359] Example 15

[0360] Chocolate covered wafer product with high protein content and improved sensory

[0361] 1A composite wafer product with high protein cocoa filling and high protein chocolate coating was created. The final product was created using 38% wafer, 38% protein cocoa filling and 24% of high protein coating. The wafer had the nutritional values shown in Table 13. The protein cocoa filling used was described in Recipe 22.

[0362] The high protein cocoa compound was created following the same procedure as described in Example 8 but using yeast protein isolate. The method of the invention using targeted particle size milling techniques was performed (Recipe 26).

[0363] Table 15

[0364] Recipe 26

[0365] Sucrose 33.16

[0366] CBS (cocoa butter substitute), i.e., palm, shea 33.69

[0367] oil blend

[0368] Cocoa Powder 13.00

[0369] Yeast protein isolate 20.00

[0370] Sunflower lecithin 0.15

[0371] PGPR 0.0001

[0372] Total 100.00

[0373] Kcal / 100g 565.02

[0374] Fat / 100g 35.97 Protein / 100g 19.40

[0375] Total Sugar / 100g 33.30

[0376] Total Carbohydrate / 100g 35.43

[0377]

[0378] The final product nutritional values are shown in Table 16. At first bite, the chocolate coating had a snap, followed by a crispy wafer with a smooth soft creamy filling with an even melt.

[0379] Table 16

[0380] Nutritional Values Product Total Recipe 27

[0381] (38% wafer, 37% filling, 24% coating) (%)

[0382] Kcal / 100g 489.60 Protein / 100g 21.31

[0383] Fat / 100g 22.20 Carbohydrate / 100g 43.45

[0384]

[0385] Nutritional Values Product Total Recipe 27 (38% wafer, 37% filling, 24% coating) (%)

[0386] Sugar / 100g 18.20

[0387] % energy coming from protein 17.40%

[0388]

[0389] Example 16

[0390] Chocolate covered wafer product with high protein content and improved sensory A composite wafer product with high protein filling and high protein chocolate coating was created. The final product was created using 23% wafer, 49% protein filling and 28% of high protein coating. The wafer had the nutritional values shown in Table 13.

[0391] High protein chocolates were created following the same procedure as described in Example 8, but using yeast, wheat, whey protein, or blends of these proteins with whey. The method of the invention using targeted particle size milling techniques was performed (Recipe 28, 29, 30, 31 and 32). Recipe 28 was used as a reference

[0392] Table 17

[0393] Recipe Recipe Recipe 30 Recipe 31 Recipe 32 28 29

[0394] (%) (%) (%) Ingredients (%) (%)

[0395] Sucrose 26.28 25.28 26.24 26.65 26.80 Skimmed milk

[0396] 9.07 9.07 9.07 9.07 9.40 powder

[0397] Milk fat 3.00 3.00 3.00 3.00 3.00 Cocoa butter 23.98 22.49 22.89 23.45 23.30 Cocoa mass 11.50 11.50 11.50 11.50 11.50 Lecithin sunflower 0.56 0.56 0.56 0.56 0.56 Yeast protein

[0398] 0.00 0.00 26.97 13.00 0.00 isolate

[0399] Wheat protein

[0400] 0.00 28.33 0.00 0.00 13.00 isolate

[0401] Whey protein

[0402] 25.84 0.00 0.00 13.00 13.00 isolate

[0403]

[0404] Recipe Recipe Recipe 30 Recipe 31 Recipe 32 28 29

[0405] (%) (%) (%) Ingredients (%) (%)

[0406] Evaporation -0.23 -0.23 -0.23 -0.23 -0.23 Total 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00

[0407]

[0408] Kcal / 100g 543.56 546.55 548.49 546.05 545.30 Protein / 100g 27.85 27.99 28.08 27.62 27.03 Fat / 100g 33.73 33.73 33.73 33.73 33.73 Carbohydrate / 100g 32.13 32.96 32.57 32.72 33.47 Sugar / 100g 31.57 30.14 31.07 31.07 31.87

[0409]

[0410] Surprisingly, high protein contents were easily processable. After the mass was created, the chocolate masses were used for enrobing of the wafer sheets layered with high protein fillings.

[0411] The protein fillings used are described in Table 18 (Recipes 28-31). They were created following the same procedure as described in Example 8 but using yeast, wheat, whey protein isolate, or blends of these proteins. The method of the invention using targeted particle size milling techniques was performed.

[0412] Table 18

[0413] Recipe 28 Recipe 29 Recipe 30 Recipe 31 Sucrose 26.55 27.03 25.74 26.05 Palm oil fractions 29.95 29.47 26.00 25.40 Cocoa Powder 3.00 3.00 3.00 3.00 Yeast protein isolate 40.00 0.00 20.00 0.00 Wheat protein isolate 0.00 40.00 0.00 20.00 Whey protein isolate 0.00 0.00 20.00 20.00 Sunflower lecithin 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.50

[0414] Total 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00

[0415]

[0416] Recipe 28 Recipe 29 Recipe 30 Recipe 31 Kcal / 100g 558.66 546.66 549.66 543.91 Fat / 100g 32.00 32.00 32.00 32.00 Protein / 100g 37.18 33.54 36.83 35.01 Total Sugar / 100g 26.81 27.55 26.43 26.84

[0417] Total 27.31 31.25 26.93 28.94

[0418]

[0419] Carbohydrate / 100g

[0420] The final product nutritional values are shown in Table 19. At first bite, the chocolate coating had a snap, followed by a crispy wafer with a smooth soft creamy filling with an even melt.

[0421] Table 18

[0422] Nutritional Values Recipe 32 Recipe 33 Recipe 34 Recipe 35 Product Total

[0423] Yeast Wheat Yeast / Whey Wheat / Whey (23% wafer, 49%

[0424] filling, 28% (%) (%) (%) (%) coating)

[0425] Kcal / 100g 515.44 509.02 510.34 507.32 Protein / 100g 28.18 26.37 27.88 26.82 Fat / 100g 25.83 25.83 25.83 25.83 Carbohydrate / 100g 37.65 39.69 28.35 38.7 Sugar / 100g 22.23 22.13 21.94 22.36 % energy coming 21.87 20.72 21.85 21.15 from protein

[0426]

[0427] The final products were subjected to sensory tasting, with all products providing a balanced sensory performance, with a texture profile that does not differ too much between each other and with minimal impact on flavour

Claims

Claims1. A method of making a protein-fortified confectionery product, for example a chocolate or compound product, or a filling, preferably a protein-fortified milk chocolate product, said method comprisinga. Dispersing protein in oil, for example a protein concentrate or a protein isolate; b. Milling the protein dispersion to further reduce the particle size;c. Mixing the milled protein into a chocolate or compound mass or filling, preferably to a final concentration of at least 15%, or between 20% to 35% milled protein, when expressed as a percentage of the chocolate or compound mass or filling; andd. Forming a protein-fortified chocolate or compound product or a protein-fortified filling from the chocolate or compound mass or filling.

2. The method according to claim 1, wherein the protein is milled to a particle size D4,3 of less than 20 m in step b), preferably to between 15 to 20 pm in step b) .

3. The method according to any one of claims 1 and 2, wherein the protein dispersion is milled using a ball mill or a bead mill.

4. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 3, wherein the protein dispersion further comprises sugar particles.

5. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 4, wherein the protein is a blend of yeast protein and whey protein, preferably yeast protein isolate and whey protein isolate.

6. The method according to any one of claim 5, wherein pea protein isolate is dispersed in cocoa butter in step a).

7. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 6, wherein the protein is pea protein, and the oil is cocoa butter.

8. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 4, wherein the protein is whey protein concentrate or whey protein isolate.

9. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 8, wherein the protein is milled to between 1 pm to 18 pm.

10. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 9, wherein the milled protein is mixed to a final concentration of at least 20% milled protein, expressed as a percentage of the chocolate or compound mass.

11. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 10, wherein the chocolate product is formed by moulding, enrobing, or panning.

12. A chocolate or compound product, preferably a milk chocolate product, or a filling, made by a method according to any one of claims 1 to 11.

13. The chocolate or compound product or filling according to claim 12, wherein said chocolate product further comprises inclusions.

14. The chocolate or compound product according to any one of claims 12 and 13, wherein the milled protein contributes between 20% to 25% of the total calories of the chocolate or compound product or filling.

15. The chocolate or compound product or filling according to any one of claims 12 to 14, wherein the chocolate or compound product or filling comprises between 500 to 600 Kcal / 100g; 15 to 40g Protein / 100g; 25 to 40g Fat / 100g; 25 to 50g Carbohydrate / 100g; and 25 to 50g Sugar / 100g.