Conversion method for measurement values for saliva, information processing device, and program
The method converts saliva test values using a regression model to predict oral disease risk or level, addressing inaccuracies and inefficiencies in existing test strip methods, enhancing accuracy and efficiency.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- PCT/JP2026/014523
- Authority / Receiving Office
- WO · WO
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2025-05-12
- Filing Date
- 2026-04-08
- Publication Date
- 2026-11-19
AI Technical Summary
Existing saliva tests for oral disease risk or level rely on test strips with color reactions, leading to inaccuracies and are time-consuming and costly when performed individually for precise measurements.
A method to convert saliva test values using a regression model to predict measurement values of one item from other items, utilizing a control measurement method, allowing for more accurate predictions without individual control measurements.
Enables accurate and efficient prediction of oral disease risk or level by converting saliva test values using a regression model, improving measurement accuracy and reducing time and cost.
Smart Images

Figure JP2026014523_19112026_PF_FP_ABST
Abstract
Description
Method for converting saliva measurement values, information processing device, and program
[0001] The present invention relates to a method for converting saliva measurement values, an information processing device, and a program.
[0002] Knowing the risk or level of oral disease is important for the prevention or treatment of oral diseases. Oral disease risk refers to, for example, the risk of dental caries, i.e., the degree to which the mouth is susceptible to tooth decay, and the risk of periodontal disease, i.e., the degree to which the mouth is susceptible to periodontal disease. Oral disease level refers to, for example, the degree of dental caries risk and periodontal disease level. Oral disease risk or level of oral disease is tested by using saliva collected from the subject as a test sample and measuring the individual components or properties in the sample that reflect the risk or level of oral disease.
[0003] Devices that measure individual components or properties using saliva are also known (for example, Patent Document 1). Patent Document 1 lists the number of caries-causing bacteria (Streptococcus mutans), pH and buffering capacity, calcium concentration, occult blood volume, white blood cell count, ammonia concentration and total protein concentration as individual components or properties that reflect the risk or level of oral disease, and discloses analytical instruments, devices and programs for analyzing these components or properties.
[0004] International Publication No. 2012 / 090995
[0005] Traditionally, saliva tests to determine oral disease risk or level have primarily relied on measurements using test strips. However, these measurements were based on the color reaction of reagents contained in the test strips, leaving room for improvement in the accuracy of the measurement results for accurate prediction of oral disease risk or level. On the other hand, accurate prediction of oral disease risk or level requires more precise measurement methods for each measurement item, but performing such measurements individually is time-consuming and costly.
[0006] This disclosure aims to provide a conversion method, an information processing device, and a program that can convert measurement values obtained using a test specimen for a predetermined measurement item into measurement values obtained using a more accurate control measurement method.
[0007] As a result of diligent efforts, the inventors of this application have discovered that, for a given measurement item, the measurement value in a control measurement method can be predicted from the measurement value of that item using a test specimen and the measurement value of other items using the same test specimen, and have come to the following invention.
[0008] In other words, the present invention can be illustrated as follows: [1] A method for converting measured values of one or more items selected from the group consisting of buffering capacity, acidity, caries-causing bacteria, ammonia, occult blood, leukocytes, and protein, obtained by a saliva test using a test piece, into measured values obtained by a control measurement method, wherein the conversion is performed by a regression model in which the measured value obtained by a control measurement method of one of the items selected from the items is the dependent variable, and the measured values of the item to be predicted and other measured items obtained by a saliva test using a test piece are the independent variables. [2] The method according to [1], wherein the sample used for the saliva test is a mouthwash spit, the other measurement item is one measurement item, and the combination of the predictive item and the other measurement item is: the predictive item is buffering capacity and the other measurement item is acidity or ammonia; the predictive item is acidity and the other measurement item is buffering capacity, caries bacteria, occult blood, ammonia or protein; the predictive item is caries bacteria and the other measurement item is occult blood or white blood cells; the predictive item is ammonia and the other measurement item is buffering capacity, caries bacteria, occult blood, white blood cells or protein; the predictive item is occult blood and the other measurement item is buffering capacity, acidity, caries bacteria, white blood cells or protein; the predictive item is white blood cells and the other measurement item is buffering capacity, occult blood or protein; or the predictive item is protein and the other measurement item is buffering capacity, occult blood or white blood cells.[3] The method according to [1], wherein the sample used for the saliva test is resting saliva, the other measurement item is one measurement item, and the combination of the predictive item and the other measurement item is: the predictive item is buffering capacity and the other measurement item is acidity, caries bacteria or ammonia; the predictive item is acidity and the other measurement item is buffering capacity, caries bacteria, occult blood or protein; the predictive item is caries bacteria and the other measurement item is acidity, ammonia, occult blood, white blood cells or protein; the predictive item is ammonia and the other measurement item is buffering capacity or caries bacteria; the predictive item is occult blood and the other measurement item is buffering capacity, acidity, caries bacteria, ammonia or white blood cells; or the predictive item is white blood cells and the other measurement item is buffering capacity, occult blood or protein. [4] The method according to [1], wherein the sample used for the saliva test is stimulated saliva, the other measurement item is one measurement item, and the combination of the predictive item and the other measurement item is: the predictive item is buffering capacity and the other measurement item is acidity or caries bacteria, the predictive item is caries bacteria and the other measurement item is occult blood, the predictive item is occult blood and the other measurement item is caries bacteria, the predictive item is leukocytes and the other measurement item is buffering capacity, acidity, occult blood or protein, or the predictive item is protein and the other measurement item is acidity or caries bacteria.[5] The method according to [1], wherein the sample used for the saliva test is a mouthwash spit, the other measurement items are two or more measurement items, and the combination of the predictor item and the other measurement items is: the predictor item is buffering capacity and the other measurement items are acidity and ammonia; the predictor item is acidity and the other measurement items are protein and ammonia; the predictor item is ammonia and the other measurement items are protein and buffering capacity, protein and buffering capacity and caries bacteria, or protein and buffering capacity, caries bacteria and acidity; the predictor item is occult blood and the other measurement items are acidity and leukocytes; the predictor item is leukocytes and the other measurement items are occult blood and protein; or the predictor item is protein and the other measurement items are leukocytes and buffering capacity, or leukocytes and buffering capacity and acidity. [6] The method according to [1], wherein the sample used for the saliva test is resting saliva, the other measurement items are two or more measurement items, and the combination of the predictor item and the other measurement items is: the predictor item is buffering capacity and the other measurement items are acidity and ammonia, the predictor item is acidity and the other measurement items are ammonia and protein, the predictor item is caries-causing bacteria and the other measurement items are acidity and occult blood, or the predictor item is occult blood and the other measurement items are acidity and caries-causing bacteria. [7] The method according to [1], wherein the sample used for the saliva test is stimulated saliva, the other measurement items are two or more measurement items, and the combination of the predictor item and the other measurement items is: the predictor item is buffering capacity and the other measurement items are acidity and ammonia, or the predictor item is protein and the other measurement items are caries-causing bacteria and acidity, caries-causing bacteria, acidity and buffering capacity, or caries-causing bacteria, acidity and buffering capacity and occult blood. [8] A method for assisting in the determination of an oral disease level or oral disease risk, wherein the oral disease level or oral disease risk is one or more selected from the group consisting of periodontal disease stage, caries stage, periodontal disease risk, and caries risk, and the assistance in the determination is performed using a measurement value converted by the method in [1].[9] An information processing device including a controller that performs the following actions: obtaining a value obtained by converting the measured values of one or more measurement items selected from the group consisting of buffering capacity, acidity, caries-causing bacteria, ammonia, occult blood, leukocytes, and protein, obtained by a saliva test using a test piece, to values obtained by a control measurement method, and outputting the converted value, wherein the conversion is performed by a regression model in which the measured value obtained by a control measurement method of one prediction target item selected from the measurement items is the dependent variable, and the measured values of the prediction target item and other measurement items obtained by a saliva test using a test piece are the independent variables.
[10] The information processing device according to [9], wherein the measured values obtained by a saliva test using a test piece are data indicating optical information of a test pad on which a test sample used for the saliva test is applied, and which has a reaction system corresponding to the measurement item.
[11] A program that causes a computer to perform the following actions: obtain a value obtained by converting the measured values of one or more items selected from the group consisting of buffering capacity, acidity, caries-causing bacteria, ammonia, occult blood, white blood cells, and protein, obtained by a saliva test using a test piece, to the measured values obtained by a control measurement method, and output the converted value, wherein the conversion is performed by a regression model in which the measured value obtained by a control measurement method of one of the items selected from the items is the dependent variable, and the measured values of the item to be predicted and other measured items obtained by a saliva test using a test piece are the independent variables.
[0009] According to the present invention, it is possible to predict the measured value of a predetermined measurement item (measurement target item) by a control measurement method from the measurement results of a predetermined measurement item (measurement target item) in a saliva test using a test piece and the measurement results of other measurement items using the test piece. As a result, the measured value of a saliva test using a test piece can be converted to the measured value of a control measurement method, and a more accurate value can be obtained without performing a control measurement method.
[0010] Figure A shows a strip-shaped test piece with test pads for each measurement item attached. Figure B shows the components involved in the reaction system contained in the test pads for each measurement item. Figure 2 shows an example of the configuration of the inspection device. Figure 3 is a flowchart showing an example of processing by the information processing device.
[0011] <Saliva Collection Method> Saliva collected from the oral cavity as a test sample (also called a specimen) can be in the form of resting saliva, stimulated saliva, or mouthwash spit. Resting saliva is collected by spitting out saliva that has accumulated in the oral cavity for a certain period of time (for example, 5 minutes). Stimulated saliva is collected, for example, by chewing saliva collection gum for 5 minutes and spitting out the saliva that has accumulated in the oral cavity. Mouthwash spit is collected, for example, by taking purified water into the mouth and spitting it out. For example, it can be collected by taking 3 mL of purified water (mouthwash water) into the mouth and rinsing the oral cavity for 10 seconds, and then spitting out the resulting mouthwash. The volume of purified water and the time it is held in the mouth can be changed as needed. The obtained test sample can be used in subsequent operations without any special pretreatment, but additional operations such as dilution may be performed as needed. In this invention, the saliva sample is not particularly limited, but mouthwash spit, stimulated saliva, or resting saliva can be used.
[0012] <Saliva Test Using Test Specimens> A saliva test using test specimens involves applying a test sample to a test specimen containing a reagent to induce a reaction, and then quantifying the reaction. Preferably, the reaction is a color reaction, and the test is performed using a colorimetric method to quantify the concentration of the target substance in the test sample based on the degree of color development. For example, after the reaction, the test specimen is irradiated with a specific wavelength, and the concentration is quantified by its absorbance or reflectance. Preferably, the test specimen has an absorbent carrier attached to it. Any method that a person skilled in the art can generally use to impregnate the test specimen or the absorbent carrier attached to the test specimen (sometimes referred to as the test specimen, etc.) with the reagent may be used. For example, the reagent may be impregnated, attached, coated, or dropped onto the test specimen, etc., or the test specimen, etc. may be immersed in the reagent, or the process may include a step of drying the test specimen, etc. after these operations. Specific measurement methods for each measurement item using the colorimetric method with test specimens will be described later.
[0013] <Control Measurement Method> The control measurement method is not particularly limited, but it should be a more accurate measurement method than saliva testing using test pieces and should be selected from known measurement methods. The specific measurement methods for each measurement item using the control measurement method will be described later.
[0014] <Measurement Items> The measurement items for saliva testing include buffering capacity, acidity, caries-causing bacteria, occult blood, protein, white blood cells, and ammonia. Details of the indicator formulation (measurement principle) for measuring these items using test strips are as follows as an example. An example of a control measurement method for these items is also shown below.
[0015] <Buffering Capacity> The buffering capacity of saliva (sometimes called acid buffering capacity) is preferably measured using a pH indicator, for example. The measurement principle involves contacting the test sample with an absorbent carrier containing an acid buffer and a pH indicator beforehand. The pH indicated by the indicator approaches the original pH of saliva as the acid buffering capacity is higher, and approaches the original pH of saliva as the acid buffering capacity is lower. The pH indicator may also be a mixture of multiple reagents. For example, a compound reagent of bromocresol green and bromoxylenol blue can be used. As an acid buffer, for example, a non-volatile organic acid can be used. Examples of non-volatile organic acids include citric acid, malic acid, tartaric acid, malonic acid, oxalic acid, sulfosalicylic acid, sulfanylic acid, benzoic acid, and tricarbaryl acid. Among these, tartaric acid is more preferred. Inorganic acids such as metaphosphoric acid can also be used as an acid buffer. Furthermore, the acidic buffering agent may be, for example, a mixture of potassium bituminate and potassium phosphate. The reagent concentration can be set as appropriate, and the reaction time can be set as appropriate. Also, the detection conditions when detecting the buffering capacity using a detection device such as the measuring device 20 described later can be set as appropriate. For example, when using a composite reagent of bromocresol green and bromoxylenol blue and tartaric acid as an acidic buffering agent, the concentration of bromocresol green in the reagent solution into which the absorbent carrier is immersed is preferably 0.1 to 0.6 mM, more preferably 0.1 to 0.4 mM, the concentration of bromoxylenol blue is preferably 0.6 to 2 mM, more preferably 0.8 to 1.8 mM, and the concentration of tartaric acid is preferably 0.1 to 10 mM, more preferably 1 to 6 mM. For example, the measurement can be performed with a reaction time of 30 to 300 seconds, a measurement wavelength of 635 nm, and a reference wavelength of 760 nm. For measuring acid buffering capacity using a pH indicator, an absorbent carrier can be used, for example, by placing a test pad prepared by the following procedure on a support carrier: (1) Immerse the filter paper in the reagent solution.The reagent solution contains 0.2 mM bromocresol green, 1.2 mM bromoxylenol blue, 0.05% polyoxyethylene sorbitan monolaurate, 0.5% hydroxypropyl cellulose, and 2 mM tartaric acid. (2) Dry the filter paper at 50°C for 15 minutes. (3) Cut the filter paper into 5 mm wide strips. (4) Attach the strips to the PET film. (5) Cut into 5 mm wide strips to make test strips. Note that by substituting the composition of the reagent solution with the composition of reagents for measuring other parameters in the above procedure, absorbent carriers for measuring other parameters can be produced.
[0016] An electrode method can be used as a control method for measuring buffering capacity. For example, the electrode method involves adding a fixed amount of acid (e.g., hydrochloric acid) to a test sample and measuring the pH using a pH meter equipped with an electrode for pH measurement. Since the change in pH when a fixed amount of acid is added to a sample is inversely proportional to the sample's buffering capacity, the pH value measured by this method can be used as the measured value for the buffering capacity control method.
[0017] <Acidity> The acidity of saliva is preferably measured using a pH indicator, for example. Any known pH indicator can be used as the pH indicator, and it is preferable to use a pH indicator that has a color change range in the pH range of 2 to 9, and more preferably a pH indicator that has a color change range in the pH range of 3 to 8. For example, bromothymol blue sodium or a composite reagent of bromocresol green and bromoxylenol blue can be suitably used. The concentration of the pH indicator can be set as appropriate, and the reaction time can be set as appropriate. Furthermore, the detection conditions when detecting with a detection device such as the measuring device 20 described later can be set as appropriate. For example, the concentration of bromocresol green in the reagent solution into which the absorbent carrier is immersed is preferably 0.1 to 0.6 mM, more preferably 0.1 to 0.4 mM, and the concentration of bromoxylenol blue is preferably 0.6 to 2 mM, more preferably 0.8 to 1.8 mM. For example, measurements can be performed with a reaction time of 30 to 300 seconds, using a measurement wavelength of 635 nm and a reference wavelength of 760 nm. As an absorbent carrier for pH measurement using a pH indicator, for example, pH test strips from Arkray, Inc. (manufactured by Arkray, Inc.) can be used. Each 100 strips of these test strips contain 0.07 mg of bromocresol green and 0.72 mg of bromoxylenol blue.
[0018] An electrode method can be used as a control method for measuring acidity. For example, the electrode method involves measuring the pH of a test sample using a pH meter equipped with a glass electrode for pH measurement. The pH meter may be equipped with a microelectrode or be a compact type. The pH value measured by the above method can be used as the measured value for the control method of acidity.
[0019] <Caries-causing bacteria> The measurement value of caries-causing bacteria (Streptococcus mutans) is, for example, the number of caries-causing bacteria. Caries-causing bacteria can be measured, for example, by a method that utilizes the reduction reaction of resazurin or by a method that uses antibodies against Streptococcus mutans. The method that utilizes the reduction reaction of resazurin is called the resazurin method. Resazurin is a redox indicator and normally exists as an oxidized blue dye, resazurin (maximum absorption wavelength 605 nm), but it is reduced by NADH produced by the metabolism of Gram-positive bacteria, including Streptococcus mutans, and converted to resorphine, a reddish-purple dye (maximum absorption wavelength 573 nm). In other words, the reduction of resazurin proceeds in accordance with the number of viable Streptococcus mutans. Furthermore, when using the resazurin method, it is preferable that the measurement reagent contains 1-methoxy-5-methylphenadinium methyl sulfate (methoxy-PMS) in addition to resazurin. When methoxy-PMS is included, it is effective for measurement under short reaction conditions at room temperature compared to when it is not included. The reagent concentration and reaction time can be set as appropriate. Furthermore, the detection conditions when detecting using a detection device such as the measuring device 20 described later can be set as appropriate. For example, the concentration of methoxy PMS in the reagent solution into which the absorbent carrier is immersed is preferably 0.1 to 1 mM, more preferably 0.1 to 0.5 mM, and the concentration of resazurin is preferably 0.05 to 1 mM, more preferably 0.05 to 0.5 mM. For example, measurement can be performed with a reaction time of 60 to 600 seconds, a measurement wavelength of 635 nm, and a reference wavelength of 760 nm. As an absorbent carrier for measuring the number of Streptococcus mutans by the resazurin method, for example, a test pad prepared by the following procedure can be used by placing it on a support carrier. (1) Immerse the filter paper in the reagent solution. The reagent solution contains 30 mM sucrose, 0.2% polyvinyl alcohol, 100 mM phosphate buffer (pH 6), 0.1 mM methoxy PMS, and 0.12 mM resazurin. (2) Dry the filter paper at 50°C for 15 minutes. (3) Cut the filter paper into 5 mm wide strips. (4) Attach the strips to the PET film. (5) Cut into 5 mm wide strips to make test strips.Furthermore, by replacing the reagent solution composition with that of a reagent for measuring other parameters in the above procedure, an absorbent carrier for measuring other parameters can be manufactured.
[0020] Control methods for measuring caries-causing bacteria include culture on a selective medium and PCR. Culturing on a selective medium involves spreading a saliva sample onto a selective medium and culturing it at approximately 37°C for 1 to 5 days. The colonies formed on the selective medium are then counted to determine the number of caries-causing bacteria. Examples of selective media include those commonly used for culturing Streptococcus mutans, such as Mitis salivarius bacitracin (MSB) agar. PCR involves applying PCR to a saliva sample using synthetic DNA with a DNA sequence that specifically binds to the genomic DNA of Streptococcus mutans as a primer. The DNA fragments amplified by PCR can then be detected and quantified by electrophoresis using an agarose gel.
[0021] <Ammonia> The measured value of ammonia is, for example, the concentration of ammonia in a test sample obtained from the oral cavity (ammonia concentration). The more actively bacteria, including periodontal disease bacteria, are proliferating in the oral cavity, the higher the ammonia concentration will be, so ammonia is an item that reflects the number of oral bacteria. The higher the ammonia concentration, the more advanced the stage of periodontal disease tends to be. The method for measuring the measured value of ammonia is not particularly limited and can be carried out by known methods. For example, it is preferable to use the microdiffusion method (Conway method). The microdiffusion method is a method used for the quantitative determination of volatile components, in which volatile components emitted from a test sample made alkaline with an alkaline buffer such as boric acid are trapped in an absorbent solution, and then quantified by a method such as colorimetric analysis. When the ammonia concentration is measured by the microdiffusion method, the ammonia quantification area of the test piece is provided with an absorbent carrier (sample layer) for which the test sample is applied, in addition to the absorbent carrier (reagent layer) that holds the reagent, and the two absorbent carriers are set up so that they do not come into contact with each other. The two absorbent carriers are positioned so that they do not come into contact with each other, for example, by placing a spacer, such as a PET film with fine holes, between them. The sample layer holds an alkaline buffer, such as a boric acid buffer. When the test sample is applied to the sample layer of the test piece, the alkaline buffer in the sample layer dissolves, making the sample alkaline. Ammonium ions in the sample become ammonia molecules under alkaline conditions, volatilize as ammonia gas, and migrate to the reagent layer, for example, by passing through the holes in the spacer. The indicator in the reagent layer reacts with the ammonia gas to produce a color change. Any known pH indicator can be used as the indicator. Examples of pH indicators include bromocresol green, bromocresol purple, and chlorphenol red, with bromocresol green being preferred. If necessary, multiple pH indicators may be mixed and used. The concentration of the reagent can be set as appropriate, and the reaction time can be set as appropriate. Furthermore, the detection conditions when detecting using a detection device such as the measuring device 20 described later can be set as appropriate.For ammonia measurement using the micro-diffusion method, an absorbent carrier can be used, for example, the test strips included in the AmiCheck ammonia measurement kit (manufactured by Arkray, Inc.). Each 100-sheet test strip contains 42.6 mg of boric acid and 18.7 mg of sodium hydroxide in the sample layer, and 4.0 mg of bromocresol green in the reagent layer. For example, measurements can be performed with a reaction time of 10 to 300 seconds and a measurement wavelength of 635 nm.
[0022] The indophenol method is a control method for measuring ammonia. The indophenol method involves adding phenol and pentacyanonitrosylferrate(III) disodium to the test sample, then maintaining alkaline conditions, followed by the addition of an oxidizing agent such as hypochlorite. The resulting blue indophenol is then quantified using colorimetric or other methods. In this example, salicylic acid can be used instead of phenol. The ammonia quantification kit, Ammonia-Test Wako (manufactured by Fujifilm Wako Pure Chemical Industries, Ltd.), may also be used in this method.
[0023] <Occult Blood> The measurement value for occult blood is, for example, the amount or concentration of blood in a test sample obtained from the oral cavity. It is known that occult blood can be detected in saliva when gum tissue is destroyed due to periodontal disease, and occult blood is an item that reflects the degree of destruction of periodontal tissue. The greater the amount of occult blood (occult blood volume), the higher the degree of destruction of periodontal tissue and the more advanced the stage of periodontal disease tends to be. The method for measuring the value of occult blood is not particularly limited and can be carried out by known methods. For example, it is preferable to use the hemoglobin contact activity method. The hemoglobin contact activity method utilizes the fact that hemoglobin, myoglobin, or their breakdown products, which are blood components, have the ability (peroxidase-like activity) to catalyze the transfer of oxygen from oxygen donors such as peroxides to oxygen acceptors. By using an indicator that changes color upon oxidation as the oxygen acceptor, occult blood is measured by measuring the color reaction and thereby measuring the concentration of hemoglobin, etc. The indicator is not particularly limited as long as it exhibits a color reaction with blood components such as hemoglobin, myoglobin, or their breakdown products. For example, anilines, phenols, o-toluidine, p-toluidine, o-phenylenediamine, N,N'-dimethyl-p-phenylenediamine, N,N'-diethyl-p-phenylenediamine, p-anisidine, dianisidine, o-tolidine, o-cresol, m-cresol, p-cresol, α-naphthol, β-naphthol, catechol, guaiacol, pyrogallol, etc., can be used. As for phenols, for example, 3,3',5,5'-tetramethylbenzidine (TMBZ) can be preferably used. Furthermore, peroxides are preferred as oxygen donors, and examples of preferred peroxides include cumene hydroperoxide, diisopropylbenzene peroxide, paramentane hydroperoxide, and 2,5-dimethylhexane-2,5-dihydroperoxide. For example, cumene hydroperoxide can be suitably used as an oxygen donor. The concentration of the reagent can be set as appropriate, and the reaction time can be set as appropriate. In addition, the detection conditions when detecting with a detection device such as the measuring device 20 described later can be set as appropriate.As the absorbent carrier for occult blood measurement by the hemoglobin contact activity method, for example, the test paper for occult blood measurement of Aution Sticks (manufactured by Arkray, Inc.) can be used. The test paper contains 30.0 mg of cumene hydroperoxide and 15.0 mg of TMBZ per 100 sheets. For example, the measurement can be performed at a measurement wavelength of 635 nm with a reaction time of 30 to 300 seconds.
[0024] As a reference measurement method for occult blood, the immunoturbidimetric method may be mentioned. Examples of the immunoturbidimetric method include a method in which the turbidity of a sample changes in a hemoglobin concentration-dependent manner, and the turbidity is measured with a spectrophotometer or the like to quantify the amount of occult blood in a test sample. The method may be, for example, a method that utilizes the aggregation of latex particles caused by the binding of an anti-hemoglobin antibody bound to the surface of latex particles to hemoglobin in a test sample. In this method, as the occult blood quantification kit, LZ Test "Eiken" HbA 0 (manufactured by Eiken Chemical Co., Ltd.) may be used.
[0025] <White Blood Cells> The white blood cell count is, for example, the number of white blood cells in a test sample obtained from the oral cavity. It is known that white blood cells accumulate in the affected area (inflammatory area) of periodontal disease, and the white blood cell count is an item that reflects the degree of inflammation in the periodontal tissue. The higher the white blood cell count, the higher the degree of inflammation in the periodontal tissue and the more advanced the stage of periodontal disease tends to be. The method for measuring the white blood cell count is not particularly limited and can be carried out by known methods. For example, it is preferable to use the leukocyte esterase method. The leukocyte esterase method utilizes the fact that when tissue becomes inflamed, the number of white blood cells increases, and consequently, esterase production by white blood cells also increases. This method uses an ester compound as a substrate and measures esterase activity by directly coloring the alcohol (phenol) component produced when this is hydrolyzed by esterase produced by white blood cells (leukocyte esterase), or by coupling the alcohol (phenol) with a diazonium salt and coloring it. The white blood cell count can be calculated based on the measured esterase activity. As the ester compound used as the substrate, sulfonphthalein esters or azo dye esters can be used when direct color development is required, and phenoxy-amino acid esters, indoxyl esters, or phenylpyroxyl esters can be used when coupling with other indicators to produce color. As an indoxyl ester, for example, 3-(N-toluenesulfonyl-L-alaniloxy)indole (TAI) can be suitably used. As the indicator when color development is required by coupling, a diazonium salt can be used, for example, 2-methoxy-4-(N-morpholino)benzenediazonium salt can be suitably used. When 3-(N-toluenesulfonyl-L-alaniloxy)indole is used as the ester compound, the indoxyl produced by the reaction can be coupled with, for example, 2-methoxy-4-(N-morpholino)benzenediazonium salt (MMB) to produce color. The concentration of the reagents can be set as appropriate, and the reaction time can be set as appropriate. Furthermore, the detection conditions when detecting using detection equipment such as the measuring device 20 described later can be set as appropriate.For leukocyte measurement using the leukocyte esterase method, for example, test strips for leukocyte measurement from Arkray, Inc. (Arcray, Inc.) can be used as an absorbable carrier. Each 100 test strips contain 0.49 mg of TAI and 0.17 mg of MMB. For example, measurements can be performed with a reaction time of 30 to 300 seconds, a measurement wavelength of 565 nm, and a reference wavelength of 760 nm.
[0026] A control method for measuring leukocyte activity is spectrophotometric analysis using a chromogenic substrate. This method utilizes the reaction in which elastase produced by leukocytes (leukocyte elastase) releases p-nitroaniline bound to a chromogenic substrate, such as an amino acid or peptide. In this case, the amount of p-nitroaniline released per unit time is measured using a spectrophotometer, and the leukocyte elastase activity value calculated from this measurement may be used as the control measurement for leukocyte activity. For example, N-methoxysuccinyl-alanine-alanine-proline-valine-p-nitroanilide (MeOSuc-AAPV-pNA) can be used as the chromogenic substrate.
[0027] <Protein> The protein measurement is, for example, the total protein concentration in a test sample obtained from the oral cavity. The total protein concentration is higher as the number of periodontal disease bacteria in the oral cavity increases, so the total protein concentration is an item that reflects the number of periodontal disease bacteria. The higher the total protein concentration, the more advanced the stage of periodontal disease tends to be. The method for measuring protein is not particularly limited and can be carried out by known methods. For example, it is preferable to use the protein error method. The protein error method is a method that utilizes the fact that a pH indicator shows a pH higher than the true pH of the solution in proportion to the protein concentration, and the protein can be quantified from the color change of the indicator. Examples of pH indicators that can be used in the protein error method include 4,5,6,7-tetrachloro-2',4',5',7'-tetraiodofluorescein disodium salt (TCTIF), tetrabromophenol blue (TBPB), tetrabromophenolphthaleine, 5',5''-dinitro-3',3''-diiodo-3,4,5,6-tetrabromophenolsulfophthaleine (DINDB), Coomassie Brilliant Blue, First Green FCF, and Light Green SF (see, for example, U.S. Patent No. 4013416). If the indicator is insoluble in water, the reagent solution may be prepared using an organic solvent such as acetone, ethanol, or methyl cellosolve. Furthermore, since color development can also occur due to pH fluctuations, it is preferable to include a pH buffer. Also, since the reaction is preferably carried out under acidic conditions, it is preferable to use an acidic buffer as the pH buffer. As the acidic buffer, non-volatile organic acids can preferably be used. Examples of non-volatile organic acids include citric acid, malic acid, tartaric acid, malonic acid, oxalic acid, sulfosalicylic acid, sulfanylic acid, benzoic acid, and tricarbaryl acid. Inorganic acids such as metaphosphoric acid can also be used as the acidic buffer. Alternatively, a buffer such as a mixture of potassium bituminate and potassium phosphate may be used. The concentration of the reagents can be set as appropriate, and the reaction time can be set as appropriate.The concentration of the acidic buffer is preferably a concentration sufficient to prevent the protein error indicator from discoloring upon contact with the sample even in the absence of a significant amount of protein in the sample, and for example, it is preferably contained at 50 to 1500 mM, more preferably 1000 to 1200 mM, in a reagent solution for dipping, spotting, or coating. In addition, detection conditions for detection by a detection device such as the measurement apparatus 20 described later can be set as appropriate. As the absorbent carrier for protein measurement by the protein error method, for example, the test paper for protein measurement of Aution Sticks (manufactured by Arkray, Inc.) can be used. The test paper contains 0.35 mg of TBPB per 100 sheets. For example, the measurement can be performed with a reaction time of 30 to 300 seconds, a measurement wavelength of 635 nm, and a reference wavelength of 760 nm.
[0028] Methods for the controlled measurement of proteins include the BCA (Bicinchoninic acid assay), the Lowry assay, and the Bradford assay (also known as the Coomassie assay). In the BCA assay, when Cu(II) is added under alkaline conditions, the protein forms a complex with Cu(II). The cysteine, tyrosine, and tryptophan in the protein reduce the Cu(II) to Cu(I), and the amount of Cu(I) produced is proportional to the amount of protein. When Cu(I) bicinchoninic acid is added, two molecules of bicinchoninic acid coordinate with Cu(I), forming a blue-violet complex that shows strong absorption at 562 nm. The absorbance at this time is measured, and the protein can be colorimetrically quantified using a calibration curve created with standard proteins. A kit for the BCA assay, such as the Pierce BCA Protein Assay Kit (Thermo Fisher Scientific), may also be used. In the Lowry method, similar to the BCA method described above, when Cu(II) is added under alkaline conditions, it is reduced to Cu(I) through interaction with the protein, and the amount of Cu(I) produced is proportional to the amount of protein. When the Folin-Ciocalteu reagent is added to the Cu(I), the phosphomolybdic acid and phosphotungstic acid in the reagent are reduced, forming a blue complex that exhibits strong absorbance at 750 nm. By measuring the absorbance at this time and using a calibration curve created with standard proteins, the protein can be quantified colorimetrically. In the Bradford method, the Coomassie Brilliant Blue (CBB) G-250 dye binds to the protein through interaction with basic or aromatic amino acid residues in the protein under acidic conditions. The CBB dye bound to the protein exhibits blue color, and the absorption maximum wavelength changes from 465 nm to 595 nm, so the protein can be quantified colorimetrically by measuring the absorbance at this time.
[0029] <Prediction of Measurement Values by Reference Measurement Method Using Multiple Regression Model> The measurement value of one prediction target item selected from the group consisting of buffering capacity, acidity, cariogenic bacteria, ammonia, occult blood, leukocytes, and protein obtained by a reference measurement method can be predicted from the measurement values of the prediction target item and other measurement items obtained using test strips.
[0030] That is, the measurement value of a specific item (prediction target item) selected from the group consisting of buffering capacity, acidity, cariogenic bacteria, ammonia, occult blood, leukocytes, and protein, obtained by a saliva test using a test strip, is converted into a measurement value by the reference measurement method by a multiple regression model in which the measurement value of the prediction target item obtained by the reference measurement method is set as the objective variable, and the measurement values of the prediction target item and other measurement items obtained by the saliva test using test strips are set as explanatory variables.
[0031] Here, since the multiple regression model has two or more explanatory variables, for example, it can be represented using a multiple regression equation (when there are two explanatory variables, y = ax 1 + bx 2 + γ, and when there are three explanatory variables, y = ax 1 + bx 2 + cx 3 + γ, and so on). In the multiple regression equation, x 1 , x 2 , x 3 ... are explanatory variables, y is the objective variable, a, b, c... are multiple regression coefficients, and γ is the intercept. The explanatory variable x 1 is the measurement value of the prediction target item obtained using the test strip, the explanatory variables x 2 , x 3 ... are measurement values of measurement items other than the prediction target item (other measurement items) obtained using test strips, and the objective variable y indicates the measurement value of the prediction target item obtained by the reference measurement method. As the multiple regression model, a linear model such as the multiple regression equation described above may be used, or a non-linear model such as a support vector machine may be used.
[0032] By first determining the measured values of the item to be predicted using a control measurement method, the measured values of the item to be predicted using a test specimen, and the measured values of items other than the item to be predicted using a test specimen, and then applying the relationships between these (sometimes called influence relationships) to the above-mentioned multiple regression model to set up a multiple regression equation, it is possible to predict the measured value of the item to be predicted using a control measurement method from the measured values of the item to be predicted and other measurement items using test specimens.
[0033] Using the above multiple regression equation as the conversion formula, the measurement values from saliva test pieces collected from the subjects are used as explanatory variables x. 1 , x 2 , x 3 ...is substituted into the multiple regression equation. The dependent variable y is calculated by this substitution, and the calculated dependent variable y is treated as the converted value of the measurement taken using the control method.
[0034] In this specification, the measured values obtained using each test specimen to derive (create) the above-described multiple regression equation are referred to as index measurements. In other words, the measured values of the target item and other measurement items using the test specimen measured to determine the multiple regression line in the above-described multiple regression equation correspond to index measurements. The number of measurements of index measurements to obtain the multiple regression model can be any number. In addition, mouthwash spit, resting saliva, or stimulated saliva can be used as saliva samples, but it is preferable that the type of saliva sample used to obtain index measurements using test specimens and the type of saliva sample used to obtain measurements by the control measurement method are the same. That is, it is preferable to prepare multiple regression models according to the type of saliva sample.
[0035] The index measurement value of a measurement item may be a value that indicates the primary data used to calculate the measurement value of the predetermined measurement item. The primary data may be, for example, data that indicates optical information such as the reflectance or transmittance of a test pad on which a saliva sample is applied, having a reaction system corresponding to the predetermined measurement item. Alternatively, the index measurement value may be a value that indicates the quantity of the predetermined measurement item obtained from the primary data using a calibration curve or calculation formula. In other words, the index measurement value may be information that directly indicates the quantity of the measurement item, or information that indirectly indicates the quantity of the measurement item, such as reflectance. The sample provider for obtaining the index measurement value and the subject from whom the measurement value is obtained may be the same person or different people.
[0036] The measured values of the target parameters of a saliva sample collected from a subject using a control measurement method may, like index measurements, represent primary data used to calculate the measured values of the specified parameters. Primary data may, for example, represent optical information such as absorbance or turbidity obtained from a reaction system corresponding to the specified parameter. Alternatively, the measured values may represent the quantities of the specified parameters obtained from the primary data using calibration curves or calculation formulas. In other words, the measured values may directly represent the quantities of the parameters, or they may indirectly represent quantities of the parameters, such as optical information.
[0037] <When the item to be predicted is buffering capacity> For example, when the item to be predicted is buffering capacity, the measurement result of the control measurement method for buffering capacity can be predicted from the measurement value using a buffering capacity test piece and the measurement value using a test piece for one or more measurement items other than buffering capacity, i.e., acidity, caries-causing bacteria, ammonia, occult blood, leukocytes, and protein. Preferably, when the saliva sample is mouthwash spit, the measurement result of the control measurement method for buffering capacity can be predicted from the measurement value using a buffering capacity test piece and either acidity or ammonia (two explanatory variables). Preferably, when it is resting saliva, the measurement result of the control measurement method for buffering capacity can be predicted from the measurement value using a buffering capacity test piece and either acidity, caries-causing bacteria, or ammonia (two explanatory variables). Preferably, when it is stimulated saliva, the measurement result of the control measurement method for buffering capacity can be predicted from the measurement value using a buffering capacity test piece and either acidity or caries-causing bacteria (two explanatory variables). Preferably, when the saliva sample is a mouthwash spit, the measurement result of the buffering capacity controlled by the control method can be predicted from the measured values of buffering capacity, acidity, and ammonia using test pieces (three explanatory variables). Preferably, when the sample is resting saliva, the measurement result of the buffering capacity controlled by the control method can be predicted from the measured values of buffering capacity, acidity, and ammonia using test pieces (three explanatory variables). Preferably, when the sample is stimulated saliva, the measurement result of the buffering capacity controlled by the control method can be predicted from the measured values of buffering capacity, acidity, and ammonia using test pieces (three explanatory variables).
[0038] <When the item to be predicted is acidity> For example, when the item to be predicted is acidity, the measurement result of the control method for acidity can be predicted from the measured values using test pieces of acidity and one or more measurement items selected from buffering capacity, caries-causing bacteria, ammonia, occult blood, leukocytes, and protein. Preferably, when the saliva sample is mouthwash spit, the measurement result of the control method for acidity can be predicted from the measured values using test pieces of acidity and any of buffering capacity, caries-causing bacteria, occult blood, ammonia, or protein (two explanatory variables). Preferably, when it is resting saliva, the measurement result of the control method for acidity can be predicted from the measured values using test pieces of acidity and any of buffering capacity, caries-causing bacteria, occult blood, or protein (two explanatory variables). Preferably, when it is mouthwash spit, the measurement result of the control method for acidity can be predicted from the measured values using test pieces of acidity, ammonia, and protein (three explanatory variables). Preferably, in the case of resting saliva, the measurement result of the control method for acidity can be predicted from the acidity and the measured values of ammonia and protein using test pieces (three explanatory variables).
[0039] <When the item to be predicted is caries-causing bacteria> For example, when the item to be predicted is caries-causing bacteria, the measurement result of the control measurement method for caries-causing bacteria can be predicted from the measurement values obtained using test pieces of caries-causing bacteria and one or more measurement items selected from buffering capacity, acidity, ammonia, occult blood, white blood cells, and protein. Preferably, when the saliva sample is mouthwash spit, the measurement result of the control measurement method for caries-causing bacteria can be predicted from the measurement values obtained using test pieces of caries-causing bacteria and either occult blood or white blood cells (two explanatory variables). Preferably, when it is resting saliva, the measurement result of the control measurement method for caries-causing bacteria can be predicted from the measurement values obtained using test pieces of caries-causing bacteria and either acidity, ammonia, occult blood, white blood cells, or protein (two explanatory variables). Preferably, when it is stimulated saliva, the measurement result of the control measurement method for caries-causing bacteria can be predicted from the measurement values obtained using test pieces of caries-causing bacteria and occult blood (two explanatory variables). Preferably, in the case of resting saliva, the measurement results of caries-causing bacteria using a control method can be predicted from the measurements of caries-causing bacteria, acidity, and occult blood using test pieces (three explanatory variables).
[0040] <When the item to be predicted is ammonia> For example, when the item to be predicted is ammonia, the measurement result of the control method for ammonia can be predicted from the measurement values obtained using test pieces of ammonia and one or more measurement items selected from buffering capacity, acidity, caries-causing bacteria, occult blood, white blood cells, and protein. Preferably, when the saliva sample is mouthwash spit, the measurement result of the control method for ammonia can be predicted from the measurement values obtained using test pieces of ammonia and any of buffering capacity, caries-causing bacteria, occult blood, white blood cells, or protein (two explanatory variables). Preferably, when it is resting saliva, the measurement result of the control method for ammonia can be predicted from the measurement values obtained using test pieces of ammonia and any of buffering capacity or caries-causing bacteria (two explanatory variables). Preferably, if the saliva sample is a mouthwash spit, the measurement result of the control method for ammonia can be predicted from the measurement values using ammonia, protein and buffering capacity test strips, ammonia, protein and buffering capacity and caries-causing bacteria test strips, or ammonia, protein and buffering capacity and caries-causing bacteria and acidity test strips (three, four, or five explanatory variables).
[0041] <When the item to be predicted is occult blood> For example, when the item to be predicted is occult blood, the measurement result of the control method for occult blood can be predicted from the measured values using test pieces of occult blood and one or more measurement items selected from buffering capacity, acidity, caries-causing bacteria, ammonia, white blood cells, and protein. Preferably, when the saliva sample is mouthwash spit, the measurement result of the control method for occult blood can be predicted from the measured values using test pieces of occult blood and any of buffering capacity, acidity, caries-causing bacteria, white blood cells, or protein (two explanatory variables). Preferably, when it is resting saliva, the measurement result of the control method for occult blood can be predicted from the measured values using test pieces of occult blood and any of buffering capacity, acidity, caries-causing bacteria, ammonia, or white blood cells (two explanatory variables). Preferably, when it is stimulated saliva, the measurement result of the control method for occult blood can be predicted from the measured values using test pieces of occult blood and caries-causing bacteria (two explanatory variables). Preferably, when the saliva sample is mouthwash spit, the measurement result of the control method for occult blood can be predicted from the measurements of occult blood, acidity, and white blood cells using test pieces (three explanatory variables). Preferably, when the sample is resting saliva, the measurement result of the control method for occult blood can be predicted from the measurements of occult blood, acidity, and caries-causing bacteria using test pieces (three explanatory variables).
[0042] <When the item to be predicted is leukocytes> For example, when the item to be predicted is leukocytes, the measurement result of the control method for leukocytes can be predicted from the measured values using test strips of leukocytes and one or more measurement items selected from buffering capacity, acidity, caries-causing bacteria, ammonia, occult blood, and protein. Preferably, when the saliva sample is mouthwash spit, the measurement result of the control method for leukocytes can be predicted from the measured values using test strips of leukocytes and any of buffering capacity, occult blood, or protein (two explanatory variables). Preferably, when it is resting saliva, the measurement result of the control method for leukocytes can be predicted from the measured values using test strips of leukocytes and any of buffering capacity, occult blood, or protein (two explanatory variables). Preferably, when it is stimulated saliva, the measurement result of the control method for leukocytes can be predicted from the measured values using test strips of leukocytes and any of buffering capacity, acidity, occult blood, or protein (two explanatory variables). Preferably, if the saliva sample is a mouthwash spit, the measurement results of the leukocyte control method can be predicted from the measurements using test pieces for leukocytes, occult blood, and protein (three explanatory variables).
[0043] <When the item to be predicted is protein> For example, when the item to be predicted is protein, the measurement result of the control measurement method for protein can be predicted from the measured values using test pieces of protein and one or more measurement items selected from buffering capacity, acidity, caries-causing bacteria, ammonia, occult blood, and leukocytes. Preferably, when the saliva sample is mouthwash spit, the measurement result of the control measurement method for protein can be predicted from the measured values using test pieces of protein and any of buffering capacity, occult blood, or leukocytes (two explanatory variables). Preferably, when the saliva sample is stimulated saliva, the measurement result of the control measurement method for protein can be predicted from the measured values using test pieces of protein and any of acidity or caries-causing bacteria (two explanatory variables). Preferably, when the saliva sample is mouthwash spit, the measurement result of the control measurement method for protein can be predicted from the measured values using test pieces of protein, leukocytes, and buffering capacity, or from the measured values using test pieces of protein, leukocytes, buffering capacity, and acidity (three or four explanatory variables). Preferably, in the case of stimulated saliva, the measurement results of the protein control method can be predicted from the measurement values of protein, caries-causing bacteria, and acidity using test pieces, protein, caries-causing bacteria, acidity, and buffering capacity using test pieces, or protein, caries-causing bacteria, acidity, buffering capacity, and occult blood using test pieces (three, four, or five explanatory variables).
[0044] The following describes, with reference to the drawings, a method for converting saliva measurement values according to this embodiment, and an information processing device used therefor. The embodiments described below are examples, and the present invention is not limited to these embodiments.
[0045] Figure 1A shows an example of a strip-shaped test piece 31 with test pads (absorbent carriers) 31a to 31g attached, each impregnated with an indicator (component involved in the reaction system) for measuring the seven measurement items described above. Test pad 31a is used to measure buffering capacity. Test pad 31b is used to measure acidity. Test pad 31c is used to measure caries bacteria. Test pad 31d is used to measure occult blood. Test pad 31e is used to measure protein. Test pad 31f is used to measure white blood cells. Test pad 31g is used to measure ammonia. Figure 1B shows the components involved in the reaction system contained in the test pads 31a to 31g for each measurement item. When a test sample is applied to the test pads 31a to 31g of the strip-shaped test piece 31, the color changes according to the reaction principle related to each measurement item described above. The color is measured by the measuring device 20 (Figure 2).
[0046] Figure 2 shows an example configuration of the inspection device 30. The inspection device 30 comprises an information processing device 10 and a measuring device 20. The information processing device 10 is a dedicated or general-purpose computer such as a personal computer (PC), workstation, or smart device (smartphone, tablet terminal). The information processing device 10 includes a processor 11 (corresponding to a control unit or controller), a storage device 15, an input device 12, a display device 14, and a communication interface (communication IF) 16, all connected to bus B. The measuring device 20 and the output device 40 are electrically connected to bus B of the information processing device 10 via an interface circuit (I / F).
[0047] The measuring device 20 measures the following predetermined measurement items in a test sample obtained from the oral cavity of a subject: buffering capacity, acidity, caries-causing bacteria, occult blood, protein, leukocytes, and ammonia. The measuring device 20 measures the color tone of test pads 31a to 31g on which the test sample is applied using the reflectance photometric method and calculates (detects) the reflectance. The measurement value for each measurement item is obtained from the reflectance. As the measuring device 20, for example, the measuring device "SillHa" capable of measuring six of the above seven measurement items excluding occult blood, or the measuring device "ST-4910" (both manufactured by Arkray Corporation) capable of measuring all seven of the above items can be used. In addition, strip-shaped test pieces 31 capable of measuring each measurement item according to these measuring devices can be used. The measuring device 20 can be composed of one or more measuring devices capable of measuring one or more measurement items. Furthermore, the number of strip-shaped test pieces and the number of test pads on each strip-shaped test piece are arbitrary, as long as the measurement results for the predetermined measurement items can be obtained. However, the reflectance photometric method is merely one example of a method for measuring each measurement item, and other measurement methods may be used. The measuring device 20 is also not limited to the configuration described above. Furthermore, the measurement method can be appropriately set according to the prescription (measurement principle) of the indicator for the measurement item.
[0048] The storage device 15 includes a main memory and an auxiliary storage device. The storage device 15 stores programs executed by the processor 11 and data used in the execution of those programs. The storage device 15 includes ROM (Read Only Memory), RAM (Random Access Memory), hard disk, SSD (Solid State Drive), etc. The storage device 15 may be installed (fixed) on the information processing device 10, or it may be detachable from the information processing device 10 via a USB (Universal Serial Bus) connector, etc. (such as a USB memory). As described later, the storage device 15 stores information showing the relationship between the measured values using test pieces of the item to be predicted and other measurement items (other measurement items), and the measured values of the item to be predicted using a control measurement method. For example, if the information showing this relationship is a multiple regression equation, the information showing this multiple regression equation can also be stored as data. The information showing this relationship is the explanatory variable x 1 , x 2 , x 3 ...The format of a program that calculates the dependent variable y (converted value) by substituting (measured value), or the explanatory variable x 1 , x 2 , x 3 ...In response to the input, the corresponding dependent variable y can be stored in a format that reads it from the corresponding table. Alternatively, the information showing the relationship can be stored in a format that reads the input independent variable x. 1 , x 2 , x 3 ...The target variable y corresponding to ... can also be stored in the form of a program that queries a communication partner (such as a server connected to the information processing device 10 via a network) and receives the corresponding target variable y as a response to the query.
[0049] The input device 12 is a key, button, touch panel, etc., and is used for data input. The measured values from the measuring device 20 may be input (received) from the measuring device 20 to the information processing device 10 via an interface, or they may be manually input using the input device 12. The display 14 displays data and information. The communication IF 16 can also be used to communicate with external devices and to acquire information indicating influence relationships through communication with external devices. The data showing the measured values may be obtained via wireless communication with the measuring device 20. The communication IF 16 may be fixedly installed on the information processing device 10 or it may be detachable via a USB connector or the like.
[0050] The controller, processor 11, is a CPU (Central Processing Unit) and performs various processes by executing programs stored in the storage device 15. For example, by executing a program, processor 11 can convert measured values from test specimens to converted values based on the aforementioned influence relationships. That is, it can perform a process to convert measured values using test specimens for the predicted item and other measurement items to converted values using the control measurement method, based on a multiple regression model.
[0051] The conversion from measured values obtained from test specimens (hereinafter sometimes simply referred to as "measured values") to converted values is performed, as described above, for example, by using a multiple regression equation that shows the relationship between the two variables (when there are two explanatory variables, y = ax). 1 +bx 2 +γ, when there are 3 explanatory variables, y = ax 1 +bx 2 +cx 3 +γ (and so on), explanatory variable x 1 , x 2 , x 3...This can be done by substituting the measured values and calculating the target variable y as a converted value. The storage device 15 can store a program that includes an algorithm (multiple regression model) for finding the converted value using a conversion formula from the measured values. For example, the processor 11, by executing the program, inputs to the information processing device 10, or receives by the information processing device 10, and the explanatory variable x 1 , x 2 , x 3 ...When a measurement value is obtained, this explanatory variable x 1 , x 2 , x 3 ...and by performing a calculation procedure to find the target variable y using the regression coefficients a, b, c, ... and intercept γ that were previously stored in the memory device 15, the converted value of the target variable y can be calculated. Furthermore, the conversion from measured values to converted values can be performed, for example, by using the influence relationship (multiple regression equation) described above, and the measured values (explanatory variable x 1 , x 2 , x 3 The correspondence between the measured value and the converted value (target variable y) may be stored in advance in the storage device 15, and when a measured value is acquired, the processor 11 may read the converted value corresponding to the measured value from the storage device 15. The correspondence can be stored using various data structures, such as a correspondence table between measured values and converted values, or a relational database. Alternatively, when a measured value is acquired, the processor 11 may request or inquire about the converted value from another device (communication partner), and receive (acquire) the converted value transmitted in response to the request or inquiry. Output of the converted value may be by displaying it on the display 14, outputting it from an output device such as a printer, or transmitting data or a signal indicating the converted value. Alternatively, in order to perform the above-mentioned conversion, the information processing device 10 may acquire information indicating the relationship of influence through communication using the communication IF 16, and perform the above-mentioned conversion using the acquired information indicating the relationship of influence.
[0052] Furthermore, the processor 11 can determine the level of oral disease or the risk of oral disease (for example, one or more selected from periodontal disease stage, caries stage, caries risk, and periodontal disease risk) from the measured values and / or converted values of the measurement items, and generate information indicating the determination result of the level of oral disease or the risk of oral disease. Alternatively, the processor 11 can generate information to assist in determining the level of oral disease or the risk of oral disease (calculating index values for evaluating the level of oral disease or the risk of oral disease (e.g., risk score, classification level based on the risk score), and generating information to assist in the determination, including said index values) from the measured values and / or converted values of the measurement items. The generated information may be displayed on the display 14. Alternatively, the information may be printed by an output device 40, such as a printer. The information may also be transmitted to a communication partner using a communication IF 16 or the like. Note that the processor 11 may be something other than a CPU (such as a DSP (Digital Signal Processor) or a GPU (Graphical Processing Unit)). Furthermore, the processing performed by the processor 11 may be carried out by a combination of multiple types of processors, an FPGA (Field Programmable Gate Array), a CPLD (Complex Programmable Logic Device), or an integrated circuit such as an ASIC (Application Specific Integrated Circuit) or a SoC (System-on-a-Chip).
[0053] The present invention will be described in detail below with reference to examples, but the present invention is not limited to the embodiments of the following examples.
[0054] Resting saliva, stimulated saliva, or mouthwash spit was prepared from the subject's oral cavity according to the saliva collection method described above. Specifically, resting saliva was collected by spitting out saliva accumulated in the subject's oral cavity for 5 minutes. Stimulated saliva was collected by having the subject chew a saliva collection gum for 5 minutes and then spitting out the saliva accumulated in their oral cavity. Mouthwash spit was collected by spitting out mouthwash obtained by rinsing the oral cavity with 3 mL of purified water for 10 seconds. For the measurement samples, the mouthwash spit was used in its undiluted form, while the resting saliva and stimulated saliva were used after being diluted five times with purified water (distilled water).
[0055] When resting saliva was used as the test sample, the number of samples (n=88) for measuring buffering capacity was 88 (n=88), the number of samples for measuring acidity was 88 (n=88), and the number of samples for measuring the number of Streptococcus mutans was 85 (n=85). In addition, the number of samples (n=85) for measuring occult blood volume was 85 (n=85), the number of samples (n=81) for measuring total protein concentration was 81 (n=81), the number of samples (n=85) for measuring white blood cell count was 85 (n=85), and the number of samples (n=86) for measuring ammonia concentration was 86 (n=86). When stimulated saliva was used as the test sample, the number of samples (n=93) for measuring buffering capacity was 93 (n=93), the number of samples (n=93) for measuring acidity was 93 (n=93), and the number of samples (n=92) for measuring the number of Streptococcus mutans was 92 (n=92). Furthermore, 88 samples (n=88) were used for measuring occult blood volume, 92 samples (n=92) for measuring total protein concentration, 92 samples (n=92) for measuring white blood cell count, and 93 samples (n=93) for measuring ammonia concentration. When mouthwash sputum was used as the test sample, 94 samples (n=94) were used for measuring buffering capacity, 231 samples (n=231) for measuring acidity, and 92 samples (n=92) for measuring Streptococcus mutans count. In addition, 91 samples (n=91) were used for measuring occult blood volume, 94 samples (n=94) for measuring total protein concentration, 93 samples (n=93) for measuring white blood cell count, and 94 samples (n=94) for measuring ammonia concentration.
[0056] Using a strip-shaped test piece 31 (Figure 1) and a measuring device 20 (SillHa, ST-4910 for occult blood), buffering capacity, acidity, caries-causing bacteria, occult blood, protein, leukocytes, and ammonia were measured for each sample. The strip-shaped test piece 31 has test pads 31a to 31g corresponding to each measurement item. The test pads 31a to 31g contain components involved in the reaction system corresponding to each measurement item (Figure 1B), and the reflectance of the test pads 31a to 31g of the strip-shaped test piece 31, to which the saliva sample was applied, was measured using the measuring device 20. In this embodiment, for each measurement item, the measurement value obtained in a single measurement corresponds to the index measurement value.
[0057] Using the same sample used for the above-mentioned indicator measurements, buffering capacity, acidity, caries-causing bacteria, occult blood, protein, leukocytes, and ammonia were measured using the control measurement method described above. Specifically, buffering capacity was measured by the electrode method (pH meter) at the time of hydrochloric acid addition, acidity was measured by the electrode method (pH meter), and caries-causing bacteria were measured by calculating the bacterial concentration (CFU / mL) based on the number of colonies cultured from the test sample using a selective medium. Occult blood was measured by immunoturbidimetric method using the LZ Test 'Eiken' HbA0 (manufactured by Eiken Chemical Co., Ltd.), protein was measured by the BCA method using the Pierce BCA Protein Assay Kit (manufactured by Thermo Fischer Scientific), and ammonia was measured by the indophenol method using the Ammonia-Test Wako (manufactured by Fujifilm Wako Pure Chemical Corporation). For leukocytes, the test sample was added to a measurement reagent prepared with the composition described in Table 1, and the leukocyte elastase activity value was calculated from the absorbance measured under conditions of a reaction time of 15 minutes and a measurement wavelength of 405 nm. For the measurement of occult blood, protein, ammonia, and leukocytes, an automated analyzer, the BioMajesty JCA-BM6010G (manufactured by JEOL Ltd.), was used.
[0058]
[0059] In the prediction of measured values using regression analysis described below, the values obtained by the above method, or their common logarithms, were used as the measured values by the control method for each measurement item. Specifically, for buffering capacity and acidity, the pH values measured by the above method were used; for caries-causing bacteria, the common logarithm of the bacterial concentration (CFU / mL) calculated by the above method was used; for occult blood, the common logarithm of the occult blood volume (mg / dL) measured by the above method was used; for protein, the common logarithm of the protein concentration (mg / dL) measured by the above method was used; for leukocytes, the common logarithm of the leukocyte elastase activity value (U / L) obtained by the above method was used; and for ammonia, the common logarithm of the ammonia concentration (N-μg / dL) measured by the above method was used.
[0060] The measured values of each measurement item using the control method were predicted using the following procedure. The target items for prediction were buffering capacity, acidity, caries-causing bacteria, occult blood, protein, leukocytes, and ammonia, using either resting saliva, stimulated saliva, or mouthwash sputum as the test sample. A simple linear regression analysis was performed with the measured value of the target item using the control method as the dependent variable and the index measured value of the target item as the independent variable. The coefficient of determination was calculated based on the resulting regression line. For example, when buffering capacity was the target item when the test sample was resting saliva, a simple linear regression analysis was performed with the measured value of buffering capacity in resting saliva using the control method as the dependent variable and the measured value using the buffering capacity measuring device 20 in resting saliva as the independent variable, and the coefficient of determination was calculated. In this specification, the coefficient of determination calculated based on the above simple linear regression analysis is referred to as the controlled coefficient of determination. For example, in the above example, the controlled coefficient of determination for buffering capacity when the test sample was resting saliva was calculated. Next, a multiple regression analysis (i.e., a multiple regression analysis with two explanatory variables) was performed with the measured value of the target item using the control method as the dependent variable and the indicator measured values of the target item and one other measurement item as explanatory variables, and the predicted value when using the control method for the target item was calculated. In the obtained multiple regression equation, the multiple regression coefficient relating to the other measurement item added as an explanatory variable was tested to see if it was statistically significant. If the multiple regression coefficient in the multiple regression equation was statistically significant, the measurement item relating to that coefficient was determined to be effective for prediction by that multiple regression equation. Furthermore, the adjusted coefficient of determination was calculated based on the obtained multiple regression equation. The adjusted coefficient of determination is the coefficient of determination corrected for the effect of increasing the number of explanatory variables on the increase in the coefficient of determination. Tables 2 to 4 show the results of multiple regression analysis performed for all combinations of the target item and the other measurement item added as an explanatory variable, using the above procedure, for resting saliva, stimulated saliva, and mouthwash sputum, respectively.
[0061]
[0062]
[0063]
[0064] Tables 2-4 show that combinations of explanatory variables that improve the predictive accuracy of the target item were identified. For example, when the test sample was resting saliva and the target item was buffering capacity, the coefficient of determination based on the simple regression analysis described above was 0.666. Here, by adding measurements using acidity, caries-causing bacteria, or ammonia test specimens as explanatory variables to the measurements using the buffering capacity test specimens and performing multiple regression analysis, the measured values when using the control measurement method for buffering capacity could be predicted with higher accuracy. The adjusted coefficients of determination when acidity, caries-causing bacteria, and ammonia were added as explanatory variables were 0.764, 0.692, and 0.693, respectively. When the target item for resting saliva is buffering capacity and one other measurement item is added as an explanatory variable, it was found that the predictive accuracy was highest when acidity was added as an explanatory variable.
[0065] Furthermore, predictions when two or more other measurement items were added as explanatory variables were performed using the following procedure. When multiple measurement items were determined to be effective in predicting the target item using the above procedure, in addition to the explanatory variable that yielded the largest adjusted coefficient of determination in the multiple regression equation, another measurement item was added as an explanatory variable and a multiple regression analysis was performed. For example, if the test sample was resting saliva and the target item was buffering capacity, the combination that yielded the highest prediction accuracy with two explanatory variables, namely buffering capacity and acidity, was used, and for example, caries-causing bacteria were added as an explanatory variable to perform a multiple regression analysis. In this case, there are three explanatory variables. Also, in the same manner as above, the multiple regression coefficient for the additional measurement item (caries-causing bacteria in the above example) was tested to see if it was statistically significant, and the adjusted coefficient of determination for the obtained multiple regression equation was calculated. Even with three explanatory variables, when multiple measurement items were determined to improve the prediction accuracy of the target item, the number of explanatory variables was increased to four, and a multiple regression analysis was performed. Similarly, the number of explanatory variables was increased to five or more as needed, and a multiple regression analysis was performed. Tables 5-7 show the results of multiple regression analysis performed on resting saliva, stimulated saliva, and mouthwash spit using the procedure described above, with various combinations of the predictor item and two or more other measurement items added as explanatory variables.
[0066]
[0067]
[0068]
[0069] Tables 5-7 show that when two or more other measurement items are added as explanatory variables, combinations were found that improved the predictive accuracy of the target item. For example, when the test sample was resting saliva and the target item was buffering capacity, the coefficient of determination based on the simple regression analysis described above was 0.666. Furthermore, among the combinations of two explanatory variables effective for prediction, the highest adjusted coefficient of determination based on multiple regression analysis was obtained when the explanatory variables were buffering capacity and acidity, as shown in Table 2. Here, by adding measurements using ammonia, leukocytes, or protein test pieces to buffering capacity and acidity as explanatory variables and performing multiple regression analysis, the measured values when using the control measurement method for buffering capacity could be predicted with higher accuracy. The adjusted coefficients of determination when ammonia, leukocytes, or protein were added to buffering capacity and acidity as explanatory variables were 0.805, 0.774, and 0.778, respectively. In resting saliva, when buffering capacity is the predictor, it was found that the highest predictive accuracy was achieved when buffering capacity, acidity, and ammonia were used as explanatory variables.
[0070] Tables 8-10 show the combinations of predictor items and other measurement items added as explanatory variables that were found to improve predictive accuracy when multiple regression analyses were performed on resting saliva, stimulated saliva, and mouthwash spit, respectively, as shown in Tables 2-7.
[0071]
[0072]
[0073]
[0074] Tables 8-10 show that combinations of explanatory variables that improve the prediction accuracy of the target item can be found when one or more other measurement items are added. For example, when the test sample is mouthwash spit and the target item is buffering capacity, it was found that by performing multiple regression analysis with the measurement values obtained using a buffering capacity test piece, along with the measurement values obtained using acidity, ammonia, or acidity and ammonia test pieces, as explanatory variables, the measurement values obtained using the control measurement method for buffering capacity can be predicted with higher accuracy. Furthermore, among the above combinations, it was found that the prediction accuracy was highest when acidity and ammonia were added as explanatory variables (a total of three explanatory variables). The storage device 15 of the information processing device 10 has a program installed that can convert the measurement values (reflectance) of the target item and one or more other items selected from buffering capacity, acidity, caries bacteria, occult blood, protein, leukocytes, or ammonia, measured using test pieces with resting saliva, stimulated saliva, or mouthwash spit, into the equivalent values obtained using the control measurement method for the target item.
[0075] <Measurement using the inspection device> Next, a measurement method using the strip-shaped test piece 31 and the inspection device 30 will be described. Figure 3 is a flowchart showing an example of processing in the information processing device 10. The processing in each step in Figure 3 is performed by the processor 11, which is the controller.
[0076] (1) Information about the subject (patient, etc.) is input to the information processing device 10 using the input device 12 and stored in the storage device 15 (S01 in Figure 3). (2) A sample of saliva is collected from the subject. (3) The sample to be used for measurement is prepared according to the method of collecting the saliva used for collection. For example, if the collected sample is resting saliva or stimulated saliva, the sample is diluted five times with purified water. (4) The sample is applied to the test pads 31a to 31g (Figure 1) of the strip-shaped test piece 31 for each measurement item. (5) The strip-shaped test piece 31 after application is placed in the measuring device 20. (6) The measuring device 20 measures predetermined measurement items (in this embodiment, buffering capacity, acidity, caries bacteria, occult blood, protein, leukocytes, and ammonia) and obtains the measured values for each.
[0077] (7) Signals indicating each measurement value are sent from the measuring device 20 to the information processing device 10, and data indicating each measurement value is stored in the storage device 15 (S02 in Figure 3). (8) Information indicating the items to be predicted is input to the information processing device 10 using the input device 12, etc. (S03 in Figure 3). It is preferable to input information on the type of saliva sample used for measurement, that is, whether the saliva sample is mouthwash spit, resting saliva, or stimulated saliva, and to incorporate instructions so that a conversion formula for a multiple regression model corresponding to the type of saliva sample is used for conversion.
[0078] (9) When a conversion trigger occurs in the information processing device 10 (for example, when an instruction to perform a conversion is input, or when the input of the item to be predicted is confirmed), the processor 11 of the information processing device 10 performs a process to convert the measured value using the test piece to the converted value of the item to be predicted by the control measurement method by executing a program (S04 in Figure 3). As an example, the processor 11 calculates the converted value of the item to be predicted by the control measurement method from the measured value using the test piece by performing a calculation according to a calculation procedure that calculates the converted value from the measured value of the item to be predicted and other measured items. This conversion corrects the measured value using the test piece.
[0079] (10) If necessary, the converted value is output (S05 in Figure 3). The converted value may be displayed on the display 14 under the control of the processor 11, or printed by the output device 40. If there are measured values that were not subject to conversion, those measured values may be displayed or printed together with the converted value. The measured values before conversion may also be displayed together with the converted value. The conversion formula may also be displayed or printed together with the converted value.
[0080] (11) As other processing (S06 in Figure 3), the processor of the information processing device 10 can use the measured values from the test piece and / or the converted values obtained by correcting the measured values using the multiple regression model described above to make a determination or assist in such determination regarding the periodontal disease stage, caries stage, caries risk, periodontal disease risk, etc. For example, the relationship between the above converted values of one or more items selected from the group consisting of buffering capacity, acidity, caries-causing bacteria, ammonia, occult blood, leukocytes, and protein, and the periodontal disease stage, caries stage, caries risk, or periodontal disease risk or an index value for evaluating them (e.g., risk score), is determined in advance using saliva samples from subjects including healthy individuals and patients with periodontal disease, and the above converted values obtained using actual subject saliva samples can be applied to that relationship to determine or assist in determining the periodontal disease stage, caries stage, caries risk, or periodontal disease risk of the subject. Furthermore, all or part of these results can be displayed on the display 14 or printed by the output device 40. In this way, we provide tests and support for determining the risk or level of oral disease. By using corrected conversion values to perform the above-mentioned judgments and support, we can provide more accurate judgment results or judgment support results than when using the measurements from the test specimen directly.
[0081] In the above-described embodiment, the information processing device 10 acquires the reflectance, which is the primary data of the measurement item measured by the measuring device 20, as a measured value, and the processor 11 of the information processing device 10 converts the measured value (reflectance) to a converted value (reflectance). However, instead of reflectance, the information processing device may acquire a value indicating the quantity of the measurement item calculated from the reflectance from the measuring device 20 or the like as a measured value, and perform the conversion from the measured value to the converted value using a conversion formula based on the value indicating the quantity.
[0082] According to the information processing device of the embodiment, the seven measurement items described above can be converted from measured values using test pieces to the equivalent values obtained when the predictive item is measured using a control measurement method. By converting the measured values using test pieces to equivalent values, it is possible to obtain values equivalent to those obtained when using a more accurate control measurement method. This makes it possible to accurately perform various judgments (judgments related to caries risk and periodontal disease risk) using the results of saliva measurements using test pieces as an examination to determine oral disease risk or oral disease level. The configurations described in the embodiment can be combined as appropriate.
[0083] 10... Information processing device, 11... Processor, 15... Memory device, 20... Measuring device, 30... Inspection device, 40... Output device
Claims
1. A method for converting measured values of one or more items selected from the group consisting of buffering capacity, acidity, caries-causing bacteria, ammonia, occult blood, leukocytes, and protein, obtained by saliva testing using test specimens, into measured values obtained by a control measurement method, wherein the conversion is performed by a regression model in which the measured value obtained by a control measurement method for one of the items selected from the above items is the dependent variable, and the measured values of the predicted item and other measured items obtained by saliva testing using test specimens are the independent variables.
2. The method according to claim 1, wherein the sample used for the saliva test is a mouthwash spit, the other measurement item is one measurement item, and the combination of the predictive item and the other measurement item is: the predictive item is buffering capacity and the other measurement item is acidity or ammonia; the predictive item is acidity and the other measurement item is buffering capacity, caries bacteria, occult blood, ammonia or protein; the predictive item is caries bacteria and the other measurement item is occult blood or white blood cells; the predictive item is ammonia and the other measurement item is buffering capacity, caries bacteria, occult blood, white blood cells or protein; the predictive item is occult blood and the other measurement item is buffering capacity, acidity, caries bacteria, white blood cells or protein; the predictive item is white blood cells and the other measurement item is buffering capacity, occult blood or protein; or the predictive item is protein and the other measurement item is buffering capacity, occult blood or white blood cells.
3. The method according to claim 1, wherein the sample used for the saliva test is resting saliva, the other measurement item is one measurement item, and the combination of the predictive item and the other measurement item is: the predictive item is buffering capacity and the other measurement item is acidity, caries bacteria, or ammonia; the predictive item is acidity and the other measurement item is buffering capacity, caries bacteria, occult blood, or protein; the predictive item is caries bacteria and the other measurement item is acidity, ammonia, occult blood, white blood cells, or protein; the predictive item is ammonia and the other measurement item is buffering capacity or caries bacteria; the predictive item is occult blood and the other measurement item is buffering capacity, acidity, caries bacteria, ammonia, or white blood cells; or the predictive item is white blood cells and the other measurement item is buffering capacity, occult blood, or protein.
4. The method according to claim 1, wherein the sample used for the saliva test is stimulated saliva, the other measurement item is one measurement item, and the combination of the predictive item and the other measurement item is: the predictive item is buffering capacity and the other measurement item is acidity or caries bacteria, the predictive item is caries bacteria and the other measurement item is occult blood, the predictive item is occult blood and the other measurement item is caries bacteria, the predictive item is leukocytes and the other measurement item is buffering capacity, acidity, occult blood or protein, or the predictive item is protein and the other measurement item is acidity or caries bacteria.
5. The method according to claim 1, wherein the sample used for the saliva test is a mouthwash spit, the other measurement items are two or more measurement items, and the combination of the predictive item and the other measurement items is: the predictive item is buffering capacity and the other measurement items are acidity and ammonia; the predictive item is acidity and the other measurement items are protein and ammonia; the predictive item is ammonia and the other measurement items are protein and buffering capacity, protein and buffering capacity and caries-causing bacteria, or protein and buffering capacity, caries-causing bacteria and acidity; the predictive item is occult blood and the other measurement items are acidity and leukocytes; the predictive item is leukocytes and the other measurement items are occult blood and protein; or the predictive item is protein and the other measurement items are leukocytes and buffering capacity, or leukocytes and buffering capacity and acidity.
6. The method according to claim 1, wherein the sample used for the saliva test is resting saliva, the other measurement items are two or more measurement items, and the combination of the predictive item and the other measurement items is: the predictive item is buffering capacity and the other measurement items are acidity and ammonia; the predictive item is acidity and the other measurement items are ammonia and protein; the predictive item is caries-causing bacteria and the other measurement items are acidity and occult blood; or the predictive item is occult blood and the other measurement items are acidity and caries-causing bacteria.
7. The method according to claim 1, wherein the sample used for the saliva test is stimulated saliva, the other measurement items are two or more measurement items, and the combination of the predictive item and the other measurement items is such that the predictive item is buffering capacity and the other measurement items are acidity and ammonia, or the predictive item is protein and the other measurement items are caries-causing bacteria and acidity, caries-causing bacteria, acidity and buffering capacity, or caries-causing bacteria, acidity and buffering capacity and occult blood.
8. A method for assisting in the determination of an oral disease level or oral disease risk, wherein the oral disease level or oral disease risk is one or more selected from the group consisting of periodontal disease stage, caries stage, periodontal disease risk, and caries risk, and the assistance in the determination is performed using a measurement value converted by the method of claim 1.
9. An information processing device including a controller that performs the following functions: obtaining a value obtained by converting the measured values of one or more measurement items selected from the group consisting of buffering capacity, acidity, caries-causing bacteria, ammonia, occult blood, leukocytes, and protein, obtained by a saliva test using a test piece, to values obtained by a control measurement method, and outputting the converted value, wherein the conversion is performed by a regression model in which the measured value obtained by a control measurement method of one of the measurement items selected from the measurement items is the dependent variable, and the measured values of the prediction target item and other measurement items obtained by a saliva test using a test piece are the independent variables.
10. The information processing apparatus according to claim 9, wherein the measurement value obtained by a saliva test using the test piece is data representing optical information of a test pad on which a test sample used for the saliva test is applied, and which has a reaction system corresponding to the measurement item.
11. A program that causes a computer to perform the following actions: convert the measured values of one or more items selected from the group consisting of buffering capacity, acidity, caries-causing bacteria, ammonia, occult blood, leukocytes, and protein, obtained by a saliva test using a test specimen, into values obtained by a control measurement method, and output the converted values, wherein the conversion is performed by a regression model in which the measured value of one of the items selected by the control measurement method is the dependent variable, and the measured values of the item to be predicted and other measured items obtained by a saliva test using a test specimen are the independent variables.
