Method for evaluating feeling of use of solid component

The method uses a rheometer to measure and calculate rheological properties for evaluating and selecting solid components, addressing the challenges of assessing feel on irregular surfaces and blended materials, achieving accurate sensory evaluations.

WO2026239989A1PCT designated stage Publication Date: 2026-11-19SHIN ETSU CHEMICAL CO LTD
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
PCT/JP2026/017367
Authority / Receiving Office
WO · WO
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2025-05-12
Filing Date
2026-05-01
Publication Date
2026-11-19

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing methods for evaluating the feel of solid components, such as cosmetics, struggle with irregular surfaces like human skin, temperature reproduction, and the evaluation of blended materials, leading to inaccurate assessments of melt sensation, spreadability, and finish.

Method used

A method using a rheometer to measure storage modulus G', loss modulus G'', and loss coefficient tanδ at varying temperatures to evaluate the feel of solid components, with specific calculations to select components providing optimal meltability, spreadability, and finish.

Benefits of technology

Enables accurate evaluation and selection of solid components for cosmetics based on sensory criteria, ensuring desirable meltability, spreadability, and finish, correlating well with user experience.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure JPOXMLDOC01-APPB-T000001
    Figure JPOXMLDOC01-APPB-T000001
  • Figure JPOXMLDOC01-APPB-T000002
    Figure JPOXMLDOC01-APPB-T000002
  • Figure JPOXMLDOC01-APPB-T000003
    Figure JPOXMLDOC01-APPB-T000003
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

A method for evaluating the feeling of use of a solid component comprises measuring, using a rheometer, a storage modulus G', loss modulus G", or loss tangent tan δ of the solid component at each temperature, and evaluating the feeling of use of the solid component on the basis of the measured values.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Method for evaluating the feel in use of a solid component

[0001] The present invention relates to an evaluation method for evaluating the feel in use of a solid component, and a method for selecting a solid component with good feel in use by this evaluation method.

[0002] It is known to perform measurement with an instrument such as a dynamic friction meter to evaluate the feel in use of cosmetics (Patent Documents 1 and 2). On the other hand, these instruments are preferable for measurement on smooth specimens such as simulated skin models, but they are difficult to use for measurement on specimens with irregularities such as human skin, which have significant individual differences and site-to-site differences, as the errors become extremely large. Furthermore, it is also difficult to reproduce the temperature of human skin and the temperature generated by friction between fingers and the skin, making it difficult to evaluate the melt sensation of cosmetic components.

[0003] Patent Document 3 discloses a method for evaluating the mechanical feel perceived by the lips or hands by crushing a sliced rod-shaped cosmetic and measuring the strain dependence of dynamic viscoelasticity. However, the temperature-dependent feel in use has not been evaluated, nor have the raw materials blended into cosmetics been evaluated, which was insufficient as an evaluation in the cosmetics field.

[0004] JP 2005-127717 A JP 2019-219257 A JP 2003-83873 A

[0005] The present invention has been made in view of the above circumstances, and aims to provide an evaluation method that has a correlation with the sensory evaluation of the "feel in use" such as "melt sensation", "spreadability" and "finish" when a solid component is applied to the skin, and can evaluate the feel in use of a solid component by a simple method, as well as a method for selecting a solid component with good feel in use that is particularly suitable for cosmetic formulation by using this evaluation method.

[0006] As a result of intensive studies to solve these problems, the present inventors found that by measuring a solid component with a rheometer at each temperature, it is possible to evaluate the "melt sensation", "spreadability" and "finish" of the solid component when applied to the skin, select a solid component with good feel in use, and evaluate the feel in use when the solid component is blended into a cosmetic, thereby completing the present invention.

[0007] Accordingly, the present invention provides the following inventions: 1. An evaluation method for evaluating the feel of a solid component, wherein the storage modulus G', loss modulus G'', or loss coefficient tanδ of the solid component at each temperature is measured using a rheometer, and the feel of the solid component is evaluated based on these measured values. 2. The evaluation method according to 1, wherein the evaluation is based on a comparison of the integral value of measured values ​​in an arbitrary temperature range with the integral value of measured values ​​in another arbitrary temperature range, a comparison of the average value of measured values ​​in an arbitrary temperature range with the average value of measured values ​​in another arbitrary temperature range, or a comparison of the decrease value of measured values ​​in an arbitrary temperature range with the decrease value of measured values ​​in another arbitrary temperature range. 3. A method for selecting a solid component with a good feel, wherein, in the evaluation method described in 1 or 2 above, the storage modulus of elasticity G', loss modulus of elasticity G'', or loss coefficient tanδ is measured at a starting temperature of 27°C ± 0.5°C and increasing in intervals of 1°C ± 0.2°C, and (A) the average value from the 1st to the 4th time, (B) the average value from the 5th to the 8th time, (C) the average value from the 9th to the 12th time, and (D) the average value from the 13th to the 16th time are calculated, and (i) the ratio of (B) to (A) expressed as (B) / (A) × 100, (ii) the ratio of (C) to (B) expressed as (C) / (B) × 100, and (iii) the ratio of (D) to (C) expressed as (D) / (C) × 100 are calculated, and a solid component with a good feel is selected from the above values ​​(i) to (iii). 4. A method for selecting a solid component that provides a good user experience, wherein, in the evaluation method described in 1 or 2 above, the storage modulus G' is measured by raising the temperature at intervals of 1°C ± 0.2°C, starting from 27°C ± 0.5°C, and (A) the average value from the 1st to 4th measurements, (B) the average value from the 5th to 8th measurements, (C) the average value from the 9th to 12th measurements, and (D) the average value from the 13th to 16th measurements are calculated, and (i) the ratio of (B) to (A) expressed as (B) / (A) × 100, (ii) the ratio of (C) to (B) expressed as (C) / (B) × 100, and (iii) the ratio of (D) to (C) expressed as (D) / (C) × 100 are calculated, and a solid component is selected such that (i) is 13 to 30%, (ii) is 2.0 to 6.0%, and (iii) is 0 to 1.0%.5. A method for selecting a solid component that provides a good user experience, wherein, in the evaluation method described in 1 or 2 above, the loss modulus of elasticity G'' is measured by raising the temperature at intervals of 1°C ± 0.2°C, starting from 27°C ± 0.5°C, and (A) the average value from the 1st to 4th measurements, (B) the average value from the 5th to 8th measurements, (C) the average value from the 9th to 12th measurements, and (D) the average value from the 13th to 16th measurements are calculated, and (i) the ratio of (B) to (A) expressed as (B) / (A) × 100, (ii) the ratio of (C) to (B) expressed as (C) / (B) × 100, and (iii) the ratio of (D) to (C) expressed as (D) / (C) × 100 are calculated, and a solid component is selected such that (i) is 20-28%, (ii) is 5.0-7.0%, and (iii) is 0-0.1%. 6. A method for selecting a solid component with a good feel to use, wherein in the evaluation method described in 1 or 2 above, the storage modulus of elasticity G', loss modulus of elasticity G'', or loss coefficient tanδ is measured by raising the temperature in intervals of 1°C ± 0.2°C starting from 27°C ± 0.5°C, and (a) the value obtained by subtracting the first measurement from the fourth measurement, (b) the value obtained by subtracting the fifth measurement from the eighth measurement, (c) the value obtained by subtracting the ninth measurement from the twelfth measurement, and (d) the value obtained by subtracting the thirteenth measurement from the sixteenth measurement are calculated, and the ratio of (b) to (a) expressed as (iv)(b) / (a) × 100, the ratio of (c) to (b) expressed as (v)(c) / (b) × 100, and the ratio of (d) to (c) expressed as (vi)(d) / (c) × 100 are calculated, and a solid component with a good feel to use is selected from the above values ​​(iv) to (vi).7. A method for selecting a solid component with good usability, wherein the evaluation method described in claim 1 above, the storage modulus G' is measured by raising the temperature in increments of 1°C ± 0.2°C starting from 27°C ± 0.5°C, and (a) the value obtained by subtracting the first measurement from the fourth measurement, (b) the value obtained by subtracting the fifth measurement from the eighth measurement, (c) the value obtained by subtracting the ninth measurement from the twelfth measurement, and (d) the value obtained by subtracting the thirteenth measurement from the sixteenth measurement are calculated, and the ratio of (b) to (a) expressed as (iv)(b) / (a) × 100, the ratio of (c) to (b) expressed as (v)(c) / (b) × 100, and the ratio of (d) to (c) expressed as (vi)(d) / (c) × 100 are calculated, and (iv) is 15 to 50%, (v) is 1.0 to 8.0%, and A method for selecting solid components such that (vi) is 0-1.0%. 8. A method for selecting solid components with good usability, wherein in the evaluation method described in 1 above, the loss modulus of elasticity G'' is measured by raising the temperature in increments of 1°C ± 0.2°C starting from 27°C ± 0.5°C, and (a) the value obtained by subtracting the 1st measurement from the 4th measurement, (b) the value obtained by subtracting the 5th measurement from the 8th measurement, (c) the value obtained by subtracting the 9th measurement from the 12th measurement, and (d) the value obtained by subtracting the 13th measurement from the 16th measurement are calculated, and the ratio of (b) to (a) expressed as (iv)(b) / (a) × 100, the ratio of (c) to (b) expressed as (v)(c) / (b) × 100, and the ratio of (d) to (c) expressed as (vi)(d) / (c) × 100 are calculated, and (iv) is 30-50%, (v) is 12-13%, and A method for selecting a solid component such that (vi) is 0 to 0.1%. 9. A method for producing a cosmetic composition containing a solid component, comprising the steps of selecting a solid component by the selection method described in any of 3 to 8, and blending the selected solid component. 10. The method for producing a cosmetic composition according to 9, wherein the cosmetic composition contains 0.1 to 20% by mass of the selected solid component. 11. The method for producing a cosmetic composition according to 9 or 10, wherein the solid component is silicone wax.

[0008] According to the present invention, it is possible to evaluate the "meltability," "spreadability," and "finish" of solid components when applied to the skin, and the evaluation of the "meltability," "spreadability," and "finish" of solid components is correlated with the sensory evaluation when applied to the skin, and the usability when those solid components are incorporated into cosmetics can be evaluated.

[0009] The present invention will be described in detail below. In this invention, ingredient names may be described using cosmetic ingredient names or International Nomenclature of Cosmetic Ingredient (INCI). If the cosmetic ingredient name and the INCI correspond, the cosmetic ingredient name or English description may be omitted.

[0010] [Evaluation Method] The method for evaluating the usability of a solid component according to the present invention involves measuring the storage modulus G', loss modulus G'', or loss coefficient tanδ of the solid component at each temperature using a rheometer, and evaluating the usability based on these measured values. In this invention, "meltability," "spreadability," and "finish" are collectively referred to as "usability."

[0011] A rheometer is a type of rotational viscometer that applies periodic strain or stress due to vibration to a sample and measures various viscoelastic moduli, such as storage elasticity (G') and loss elasticity (G''), from the waveform of the shear stress as a response and the phase difference between them. The ratio of storage elasticity to loss elasticity, G'' / G', is called the loss tangent or loss coefficient, and is expressed as tanδ, indicating how much energy the material absorbs when it deforms.

[0012] The strain (γ) and angular frequency (ω) applied to the measurement sample during rheological measurement are not particularly limited. Specifically, the strain (γ) is preferably 0.01 to 10%, more preferably 0.01 to 5%, and even more preferably 0.01 to 2%. By keeping it below the above upper limit, the sample is less affected by strain, and the effect of temperature becomes more visible. The angular frequency (ω) is preferably 0.1 to 100 rad / s, more preferably 0.1 to 10 rad / s, and even more preferably 0.5 to 5 rad / s. By keeping it below the above upper limit, the sample is less affected by strain, and the effect of temperature becomes more visible.

[0013] While there are no particular limitations on the starting temperature for rheological measurements, a temperature 1 to 10°C lower than the melting point of the sample is preferred. While there are no particular limitations on the measurement temperature range, it is preferable to measure values ​​near the surface temperature of human skin. Specifically, this range is 20 to 50°C, and by evaluating the numerical changes within this temperature range obtained by rheometer measurement, the melting sensation, spreadability, and stickiness of the finish on the skin can be evaluated. As a method for evaluating the feel of solid components, the values ​​of G', G'', and tanδ at each temperature may be evaluated individually or in combination of two or more. While there are no particular limitations on the evaluation of numerical changes, methods include comparing the obtained values ​​graphically or calculating the obtained values. Specifically, examples of calculations include comparing the integral values ​​of arbitrary temperature ranges, comparing the average values ​​of arbitrary temperature ranges, and comparing the decrease values ​​between arbitrary temperatures. More specifically, examples include comparing the integral value of a measured value in an arbitrary temperature range with the integral value of a measured value in another arbitrary temperature range, comparing the average value of a measured value in an arbitrary temperature range with the average value of a measured value in another arbitrary temperature range, or comparing the decrease value of a measured value in an arbitrary temperature range with the decrease value of a measured value in another arbitrary temperature range. Comparing integral values ​​is preferable because it closely resembles the changes shown in the graph. Comparing average values ​​is preferable because the calculation formula is simpler, and it is particularly suitable for evaluating differences in solubility. Comparing decrease values ​​is preferable because the formula is even simpler, and it is particularly suitable for evaluating spreadability. The temperature range and temperature intervals used in the calculation are not particularly limited, but for example, when solid components are incorporated into sunscreen formulations, summer or high skin surface temperatures are anticipated, and the temperature is set higher, taking into account the cosmetic formulation being incorporated, the sales period, and the usage environment. More accurate information can be obtained by combining multiple values ​​obtained by a rheometer. For example, the smoothness after application can be evaluated by determining whether tanδ shows a rapid increase near the skin surface temperature and comparing the difference between G' and G''. On the other hand, if you want to simplify the formula and evaluate it simply, it is also possible to evaluate it from any one of the values. A simple and preferable method is to use only G' to evaluate the change in properties of the solid component by formulating an equation from the values ​​for each temperature.

[0014] [Method for selecting solid components] As a comparison of average values ​​over an arbitrary temperature range, one method is to consider the changes in properties on the skin from a static state. A method for selecting a solid component with a good feel to use, wherein in the evaluation method of 1 or 2 above, the storage modulus of elasticity G', loss modulus of elasticity G'', or loss coefficient tanδ is measured with a starting temperature of 27°C ± 0.5°C and an increase in temperature in intervals of 1°C ± 0.2°C, and (A) the average value from the 1st to the 4th time, (B) the average value from the 5th to the 8th time, (C) the average value from the 9th to the 12th time, and (D) the average value from the 13th to the 16th time are calculated, and (i) the ratio of (B) to (A) expressed as (B) / (A) × 100, (ii) the ratio of (C) to (B) expressed as (C) / (B) × 100, and (iii) the ratio of (D) to (C) expressed as (D) / (C) × 100 are calculated, and a solid component with a good feel to use is selected from the above values ​​(i) to (iii).

[0015] In particular, for storage modulus G', it is preferable to select solid components such that (i) is 13-30%, (ii) is 2.0-6.0%, and (iii) is 0-1.0%.

[0016] (i) is more preferably between 13.0% and 30%. If (i) is less than 13%, the initial melting sensation may not be obtained, resulting in no feeling of melting or difficulty in application. If it exceeds 30%, it will melt the moment it is placed on the skin, resulting in no variation in the feel of use, which may make it difficult to feel luxurious. If (i) is between 13% and 30% but (ii) exceeds 6.0%, it may feel like it does not spread well. If (i) is between 13% and 30% and (ii) is between 2.0% and 6.0% but (iii) exceeds 1.0%, it may feel heavy and sticky afterwards, or the finish may feel light and unsatisfying. Furthermore, if (iii) exceeds 1%, it may not feel like it leaves a film, or the finish may be unsatisfactory. Furthermore, when evaluating the feel of the solid components, in addition to the conditions of (i) being 13-30%, (ii) being 2.0-6.0%, and (iiii) being 0-1.0%, components in which (iiii) is 5% or more higher than (i) are evaluated as more preferable solid components, and components in which (iiii) is 20% or more higher than (ii) are also evaluated as more preferable solid components.

[0017] In particular, for the loss modulus G'', it is preferable to select a solid component such that (i) is 20-28%, (ii) is 5.0-7.0%, and (iii) is 0-0.1%. Furthermore, in addition to the above conditions, a solid component is considered even more preferable if the difference between (iii) and (ii) is 20% or more.

[0018] In particular, for the loss coefficient tanδ, it is preferable to select solid components such that (i) is 125-200%, (ii) is 100% or more and the difference with (i) is less than 50%, and (iii) is 100% or more, or the difference with (ii) is less than 10%.

[0019] As a method for comparing the decrease in temperature over an arbitrary temperature range, the following are examples of selection methods related to changes in properties on the skin from a static state. A method for selecting a solid component with a good feel to use, wherein in the evaluation method of 1 or 2 above, the storage modulus of elasticity G', loss modulus of elasticity G'', or loss coefficient tanδ is measured by raising the temperature in intervals of 1°C ± 0.2°C starting from 27°C ± 0.5°C, and (a) the value obtained by subtracting the first measurement from the fourth measurement, (b) the value obtained by subtracting the fifth measurement from the eighth measurement, (c) the value obtained by subtracting the ninth measurement from the twelfth measurement, and (d) the value obtained by subtracting the thirteenth measurement from the sixteenth measurement are calculated, and the ratio of (b) to (a) expressed as (iv)(b) / (a) × 100, the ratio of (c) to (b) expressed as (v)(c) / (b) × 100, and the ratio of (d) to (c) expressed as (vi)(d) / (c) × 100 are calculated, and a solid component with a good feel to use is selected from the above values ​​of (iv) to (vi).

[0020] In particular, for storage modulus G', it is preferable to select a solid component such that (iv) is 15-50%, (v) is 1.0-8.0%, and (vi) is 0-1.0%.

[0021] If (iv) is less than 15%, the initial melting sensation may not be obtained, and the feeling of melting may not be perceived, making application difficult. If it exceeds 50%, it may melt the moment it is placed on the skin, resulting in a lack of variation in the feel of use, and it may not give a sense of luxury. If (iv) is between 15% and 50%, but (v) is less than 1.0% or greater than 8.0%, it may feel like it does not spread well. If (iv) is between 15% and 50%, and (v) is between 1.0% and 8.0%, but (vi) exceeds 1%, it may feel heavy and sticky afterwards, or the finish may feel light and unsatisfying. Furthermore, if (vi) exceeds 1%, the feeling of a post-film may not be perceived, and the finish may be undesirable. A difference of 20% or more between (v) and (vi) is preferable.

[0022] In particular, for storage modulus G'', it is preferable to select a solid component such that (iv) is 30-50%, (v) is 12-13%, and (vi) is 0-0.1%. Furthermore, in addition to the above conditions, a solid component is considered even more preferable if the difference between (vi) and (v) is 20% or more.

[0023] In the above measurements, (i) and (iv) are suitable for evaluating "meltability," (ii) and (v) are suitable for evaluating "spreadability," and (iii) and (vi) are suitable for evaluating "finish."

[0024] [Solid Components] In the present invention, solid components are components that are solid or semi-solid at 25°C. In the present invention, "semi-solid" refers to a state of a substance that is plastic and, when molded into a specific shape, can maintain that shape for at least one hour, preferably eight hours or more, at 25°C. Therefore, for example, a fluid substance that has a very high viscosity at room temperature is essentially fluid, but due to its very high viscosity, when no change (i.e., collapse) in the applied shape can be observed with the naked eye in a short time of at least one hour, that substance is in a semi-solid state.

[0025] The present invention provides a solid component as defined in the method for selecting the solid component described above. Specifically, in the method for selecting the solid component described above, (I) in the evaluation method described in 1 or 2 above, the storage modulus G', loss modulus G'', or loss coefficient tanδ is measured with a starting temperature of 27°C ± 0.5°C and an increase in temperature in intervals of 1°C ± 0.2°C, and (A) the average value from the 1st to the 4th time, (B) the average value from the 5th to the 8th time, (C) the average value from the 9th to the 12th time, and (D) the average value from the 13th to the 16th time are calculated, and (i) the ratio of (B) to (A) expressed as (B) / (A) × 100, (ii) the ratio of (C) to (B) expressed as (C) / (B) × 100, and (iii) the ratio of (D) to (C) expressed as (D) / (C) × 100 are calculated, and a solid component is provided selected from the above values ​​(i) to (iii). Furthermore, (II) In the evaluation method of 1 or 2 above, the storage modulus G', loss modulus G'', or loss coefficient tanδ is measured by raising the temperature in intervals of 1°C ± 0.2°C starting from 27°C ± 0.5°C, and (a) the value obtained by subtracting the first measurement from the fourth measurement, (b) the value obtained by subtracting the fifth measurement from the eighth measurement, (c) the value obtained by subtracting the ninth measurement from the twelfth measurement, and (d) the value obtained by subtracting the thirteenth measurement from the sixteenth measurement are calculated, and the ratio of (b) to (a) expressed as (iv)(b) / (a) × 100, the ratio of (c) to (b) expressed as (v)(c) / (b) × 100, and the ratio of (d) to (c) expressed as (vi)(d) / (c) × 100 are calculated, and a solid component selected from the above values ​​(iv) to (vi) is provided. The preferred ranges for values ​​and components are the same as above.

[0026] The solid component selected by the evaluation method of the present invention may be a water-soluble or water-insoluble component. The melting point of the solid component is not particularly limited, but when evaluating the feeling of dissolving on the skin, 32 to 44°C is preferred, 35 to 44°C is more preferred, and 35 to 42°C is even more preferred. Specifically, examples include hydrocarbons, esters, higher alcohols, higher fatty acids, silicone waxes, etc. Among these, silicone waxes are most preferred, including acrylic silicone resins such as acrylic-silicone graft or block copolymers (manufactured by Shin-Etsu Chemical Co., Ltd.: acrylic-silicone graft copolymer: KP-561P, 562P, etc.) and polyoxyethylene-methylpolysiloxane copolymers (manufactured by Shin-Etsu Chemical Co., Ltd.: KF-6004, KF-6070W, etc.).

[0027] [Method for Selecting Solid Components to be Incorporated into Cosmetics] The evaluation method and selection method of the present invention can be used as a method for selecting solid components to be incorporated into cosmetics. For example, in the manufacturing of cosmetics, a method for selecting solid components to be incorporated can be used to evaluate the feel of the cosmetic, such as "luxury (meltability)", "appropriate weight (spreadability)", and "post-film feeling (finish)", when solid components are incorporated into the cosmetic. It is preferable to use solid components because the difference in rheometer readings due to temperature becomes clear, but it is also possible to similarly evaluate the relationship between skin temperature and the properties of the cosmetic even for cosmetics that do not contain solid components.

[0028] [Method for Manufacturing Cosmetics] The present invention provides a method for manufacturing cosmetics containing solid components, comprising the steps of selecting solid components using the selection method described above, and blending the selected solid components. The details are the same as the selection method described above.

[0029] Cosmetics containing solid components may also contain various other components commonly used in cosmetics. These other components may include, for example, (1) oils, (2) aqueous components, (3) surfactants, (4) powders, (5) compositions consisting of cross-linked organopolysiloxanes and oils that are liquid at room temperature, (6) film-forming agents, (7) UV-absorbing and scattering agents, and (8) other additives. These may be used individually or in combination of two or more as appropriate. The components and their amounts are appropriately selected and used depending on the type of cosmetic, etc.

[0030] The solid components of the present invention can be applied to various cosmetics, but are particularly preferred to be applied to skin cosmetics, makeup cosmetics, antiperspirant cosmetics, UV protection cosmetics, and other cosmetics applied to the skin, as well as to hair cosmetics and nail cosmetics. Examples of skin cosmetics include lotions, emulsions, creams, cleansers, packs, oil liquids, massage products, serums, beauty oils, cleansing agents, deodorants, hand creams, lip balms, wrinkle concealers, and scalp care products. Examples of makeup cosmetics include makeup bases, foundations, concealers, face powders, blushes, eye colors, eyeshadows, mascaras, eyeliners, eyebrow products, and lipsticks. Examples of antiperspirant cosmetics include roll-on type, cream type, solution type, and stick type antiperspirant cosmetics. Examples of UV protection cosmetics include sunscreen oils, sunscreen emulsions, sunscreen creams, and formulations that provide sunscreen effects to the aforementioned makeup cosmetics. Examples of hair cosmetics include shampoos, conditioners, treatments, styling agents, hair dyes, hair fragrances, and eyelash serums. The evaluation method of the present invention correlates with sensory evaluation when incorporated into these cosmetics and can be applied not only to skin application but also to hair use. For example, it is possible to set temperatures targeting hair irons, hair dryers, water temperatures, and finger temperatures for evaluation.

[0031] The form of the cosmetic composition may be any of the following: aqueous liquid, oily cosmetic, powder, water-in-oil emulsion, oil-in-water emulsion, non-aqueous emulsion, W / O / W type, O / W / O type multi-emulsion, etc. Among these, a cosmetic composition in which the solid component is a continuous phase is particularly preferred. Furthermore, the properties of the cosmetic composition of the present invention can be selected from a variety of forms, such as liquid, emulsion, cream, solid, paste, gel, powder, pressed, multilayer, mousse, spray, stick, pencil, balm, etc. The pH, viscosity, etc. of the cosmetic composition are appropriately selected according to the form and dosage form of the cosmetic composition.

[0032] The amount of the solid component of the present invention incorporated into the cosmetic composition is not particularly limited, but it is preferably selected appropriately from 0.1 to 20% by mass in the cosmetic composition, more preferably from 0.1 to 10% by mass, even more preferably from 0.1 to 5% by mass, and particularly preferably from 0.1 to 2% by mass. Even when the amount incorporated is small, such as 0.1 to 2% by mass, and evaluation by sensory evaluation is difficult, highly correlated data can be obtained using the evaluation method of the present invention.

[0033] The present invention will be specifically described below with reference to examples, but the present invention is not limited to the following examples. Unless otherwise specified in the following examples, the "%" in the composition refers to mass percent. The amounts used refer to the amounts used in the described formulations.

[0034] The following characteristics were evaluated for the solid components of the formulations shown in the table below. <Examples of Solid Components 1-5>

[0035]

[0036] (1) Sensory evaluation of solid components A sensory evaluation was conducted on the above solid components. Ten expert panelists evaluated the following items after application of the solid components, based on the evaluation criteria shown in Table 2: solubility (magnitude of initial change in usability), spreadability (appropriate weight for solid components), and finish (appropriate weight and solidity for solid components). The results were judged according to the following criteria based on the average values ​​of the ten expert panelists. The results are shown in Tables 3 to 5.

[0037] <Judging Criteria> A: Average score of 2.5 points or higher B: Average score of 1.5 points or higher but less than 2.5 points C: Average score of less than 1.5 points A was considered a pass.

[0038] [Example 1-1] [Evaluation conditions for solid components: Storage modulus G'] The storage modulus G' was measured using a viscosity and viscoelasticity measuring device (HAAKE MARS rheometer, 20 mmφ cone plate, manufactured by Anton Paar) with a strain (γ) of 0.02% applied to the sample and an angular frequency of 1 [1 / s]. The starting temperature was 20°C and the ending temperature was 50°C, with the temperature being increased in increments of 1°C ± 0.2°C, starting from 27°C ± 0.5°C. (A) The average value from the 1st to the 4th time, (B) The average value from the 5th to the 8th time, (C) The average value from the 9th to the 12th time, and (D) The average value from the 13th to the 16th time were calculated, and for each, (i) the ratio of (B) to (A) expressed as (B) / (A) × 100, (ii) the ratio of (C) to (B) expressed as (C) / (B) × 100, and (iii) the ratio of (D) to (C) expressed as (D) / (C) × 100 were calculated. Furthermore, the following values ​​were calculated: (a) the value obtained by subtracting the first measurement from the fourth measurement, (b) the value obtained by subtracting the fifth measurement from the eighth measurement, (c) the value obtained by subtracting the ninth measurement from the twelfth measurement, and (d) the value obtained by subtracting the thirteenth measurement from the sixteenth measurement. The ratio of (b) to (a), expressed as (iv)(b) / (a)×100, the ratio of (c) to (b), expressed as (v)(c) / (b)×100, and the ratio of (d) to (c), expressed as (vi)(d) / (c)×100.

[0039] (Based on the value of Formula (i), judgment was made according to the following criteria. The results are also shown in the table. <Evaluation Criteria for Dissolution Feel of Solid Component> A: 13 to 30% B: 8% or more and less than 13%, or more than 30% and less than 50% C: Less than 8%, 50% or more Based on the value of Formula (ii), judgment was made according to the following criteria. The results are also shown in the table. <Evaluation Criteria for Spreadability of Solid Component> A: 2.0 to 6.0% B: Less than 2.0%, or more than 6.0% and less than 10% C: 10% or more Based on the value of Formula (iii), judgment was made according to the following criteria. The results are also shown in the table. <Evaluation Criteria for Finish of Solid Component> A: 0 to 1.0% B: More than 1.0%, and the difference from (ii) is 20% or more C: More than 1.0%, and the difference from (ii) is less than 20% Based on the value of Formula (iv), judgment was made according to the following criteria. The results are also shown in the table. <Evaluation Criteria for Dissolution Feel of Solid Component> A: 15 to 50% B: 5% or more and less than 15%, or more than 50% and less than 80% C: Less than 5%, or 80% or more Based on the value of Formula (v), judgment was made according to the following criteria. The results are also shown in the table. <Evaluation Criteria for Spreadability of Solid Component> A: 1.0 to 8.0% B: Less than 1.0%, or more than 8.0% and less than 20% C: 20% or more Based on the value of Formula (vi), judgment was made according to the following criteria. The results are also shown in the table. <Evaluation Criteria for Finish of Solid Component> A: 0 to 1.0% B: More than 1.0%, and the difference from (v) is 20% or more C: More than 1.0%, and the difference from (v) is less than 20%

[0040]

[0041]

[0042]

[0043] From the results in Tables 3 to 5 above, it was found that according to the evaluation method of the present invention, the "dissolution feel", "spreadability" and "finish" of the solid component have high correlation with sensory evaluation, and the pass / fail judgment can be easily evaluated. It was found that in the case of calculation based on the storage elastic modulus G', the correlation is particularly high with respect to spreadability and finish. Furthermore, it was found to be particularly preferable for evaluation of polyether-modified silicone.

[0044] [Example 2] [Sensory Evaluation of Cosmetics] Cosmetics described in Table 7 below (Formulation Examples 1 to 5) containing the solid components 1 to 5 described in Table 1 were prepared, and the following sensory evaluation was performed. The evaluation items were a luxurious feel (melting feel: magnitude of change in initial usability), spreadability (appropriate heaviness), and post-film feel (goodness of finish) after application of the cosmetic, which were evaluated by 10 expert panelists according to the evaluation criteria shown in Table 6. The results were determined based on the average value of the 10 expert panelists in accordance with the following determination criteria. The results are also shown in the table.

[0045] <Determination Criteria> A: Average score of 2.5 points or more B: Average score of 1.5 points or more and less than 2.5 points C: Average score of less than 1.5 points A was regarded as passing.

[0046] From the results in Table 7 above, it was found that Polyether-modified Silicone A and Polyether-modified Silicone B, which received favorable evaluations as solid components, also had good evaluations in cosmetics. Furthermore, it was found that there is a high correlation between "luxurious feel", "spreadability" and "post-film feel" and "melting feel", "spreadability" and "finish" in the evaluation of solid components.

[0047] [Example 1-2] [Evaluation conditions for solid components: Loss modulus of elasticity G''] The solid components shown in Table 1 were measured using a viscosity and viscoelasticity measuring device (HAAKE MARS rheometer manufactured by Anton Paar, with a 20 mmφ cone plate) with a strain (γ) of 0.02% applied to the sample and an angular frequency of 1 [1 / s]. The loss modulus of elasticity G'' was measured with a starting temperature of 20°C and an ending temperature of 50°C, starting from 27°C ± 0.5°C and increasing in intervals of 1°C ± 0.2°C. (A) The average value from the 1st to the 4th time, (B) The average value from the 5th to the 8th time, (C) The average value from the 9th to the 12th time, and (D) The average value from the 13th to the 16th time were calculated, and for each, (i) the ratio of (B) to (A) expressed as (B) / (A) × 100 was calculated, (ii) the ratio of (C) to (B) expressed as (C) / (B) × 100, and (iii) the ratio of (D) to (C) expressed as (D) / (C) × 100 was calculated. Furthermore, the following values ​​were calculated: (a) the value obtained by subtracting the first measurement from the fourth measurement, (b) the value obtained by subtracting the fifth measurement from the eighth measurement, (c) the value obtained by subtracting the ninth measurement from the twelfth measurement, and (d) the value obtained by subtracting the thirteenth measurement from the sixteenth measurement. The ratio of (b) to (a), expressed as (iv)(b) / (a)×100, the ratio of (c) to (b), expressed as (v)(c) / (b)×100, and the ratio of (d) to (c), expressed as (vi)(d) / (c)×100.

[0048] Based on the value of formula (i), the following criteria were used for evaluation. The results are shown in the table. <Evaluation criteria for the solubility of solid components> A: 20-28% B: 5.0% or more and less than 20%, or more than 28% and less than 30% C: Less than 5.0%, 30% or more Based on the value of formula (ii), the following criteria were used for evaluation. The results are shown in the table. <Evaluation criteria for the spreadability of solid components> A: 5.0-7.0% B: Less than 5.0%, or more than 7.0% and less than 10% C: 10% or more Based on the value of formula (iii), the following criteria were used for evaluation. The results are shown in the table. <Evaluation criteria for the finish of solid components> A: 0-0.1% B: More than 0.1% and the difference from (ii) is 20% or more C: More than 0.1% and the difference from (ii) is less than 20% Based on the value of formula (iv), the following criteria were used for evaluation. The results are shown in the table. <Evaluation Criteria for Solubility of Solid Components> A: 30-50% B: 5.0% or more and less than 30%, or more than 50% and less than 80% C: Less than 5.0%, or 80% or more The results were determined based on the value of formula (v) according to the following criteria. The results are shown in the table. <Evaluation Criteria for Spreadability of Solid Components> A: 12-13% B: Less than 12%, or more than 13% and less than 30% C: 30% or more The results were determined based on the value of formula (vi) according to the following criteria. The results are shown in the table. <Evaluation Criteria for Finish of Solid Components> A: 0-0.1% B: More than 0.1%, and the difference from (v) is 20% or more C: More than 0.1%, and the difference from (v) is less than 20%

[0049]

[0050]

[0051]

[0052] From the results in Tables 8-10 above, it was found that the evaluation method of the present invention shows a high correlation between the solubility, spreadability, and finish of solid components and sensory evaluation, making it easy to determine whether a product is pass or fail.

[0053] [Examples 1-3] [Evaluation conditions for solid components: loss coefficient tanδ] The solid components shown in Table 1 were measured using a viscosity and viscoelasticity measuring device (HAAKE MARS rheometer manufactured by Anton Paar, with a 20 mmφ cone plate) with a strain (γ) of 0.02% applied to the sample and an angular frequency of 1 [1 / s]. The loss coefficient tanδ was measured with a starting temperature of 20°C and an ending temperature of 50°C, starting from 27°C ± 0.5°C and increasing in intervals of 1°C ± 0.2°C. (A) The average value from the 1st to the 4th time, (B) The average value from the 5th to the 8th time, (C) The average value from the 9th to the 12th time, and (D) The average value from the 13th to the 16th time were calculated, and for each, (i) the ratio of (B) to (A) expressed as (B) / (A) × 100, (ii) the ratio of (C) to (B) expressed as (C) / (B) × 100, and (iii) the ratio of (D) to (C) expressed as (D) / (C) × 100 were calculated.

[0054] Based on the value of formula (i), the following criteria were used for evaluation. The results are shown in the table. <Evaluation Criteria for Solubility of Solid Components> A: 125-200% B: Greater than 200% but less than 300% C: Less than 125%, or 300% or more Based on the value of formula (ii), the following criteria were used for evaluation. The results are shown in the table. <Evaluation Criteria for Spread of Solid Components> A: 100% or more, and the difference from (i) is less than 50% B: 100% or more, and the difference from (i) is 50% or more, or 30% or more but less than 100% C: Less than 30% Based on the value of formula (iii), the following criteria were used for evaluation. The results are shown in the table. <Evaluation Criteria for Finish of Solid Components> A: 100% or more, or the difference from (ii) is less than 10% B: 80% or more but less than 100% C: Less than 80%

[0055]

[0056]

[0057]

[0058] From the results in Tables 11-13 above, it was found that the solubility of solid components correlates highly with sensory evaluation using the evaluation method of the present invention, and that pass / fail determination can be easily made.

Claims

1. An evaluation method for evaluating the feel of a solid component, wherein the storage modulus G', loss modulus G'', or loss coefficient tanδ of the solid component are measured at each temperature using a rheometer, and the feel of the solid component is evaluated based on these measured values.

2. The evaluation method according to claim 1, which evaluates based on: comparing the integral value of measured values ​​in an arbitrary temperature range with the integral value of measured values ​​in another arbitrary temperature range; comparing the average value of measured values ​​in an arbitrary temperature range with the average value of measured values ​​in another arbitrary temperature range; or comparing the decrease in measured values ​​in an arbitrary temperature range with the decrease in measured values ​​in another arbitrary temperature range.

3. A method for selecting a solid component that provides a good user experience, wherein, in the evaluation method described in claim 1, the storage modulus of elasticity G', loss modulus of elasticity G'', or loss coefficient tanδ is measured at a starting temperature of 27°C ± 0.5°C, with an increase in temperature at intervals of 1°C ± 0.2°C, and (A) the average value from the 1st to the 4th time, (B) the average value from the 5th to the 8th time, (C) the average value from the 9th to the 12th time, and (D) the average value from the 13th to the 16th time are calculated, and (i) the ratio of (B) to (A) expressed as (B) / (A) × 100, (ii) the ratio of (C) to (B) expressed as (C) / (B) × 100, and (iii) the ratio of (D) to (C) expressed as (D) / (C) × 100 are calculated, and a solid component that provides a good user experience is selected from the above values ​​of (i) to (iii).

4. A method for selecting a solid component that provides a good user experience, wherein, in the evaluation method described in claim 1, the storage modulus G' is measured by raising the temperature at intervals of 1°C ± 0.2°C, starting from 27°C ± 0.5°C, and (A) the average value from the 1st to the 4th time, (B) the average value from the 5th to the 8th time, (C) the average value from the 9th to the 12th time, and (D) the average value from the 13th to the 16th time, and (i) the ratio of (B) to (A) expressed as (B) / (A) × 100, (ii) the ratio of (C) to (B) expressed as (C) / (B) × 100, and (iii) the ratio of (D) to (C) expressed as (D) / (C) × 100, and a solid component is selected such that (i) is 13 to 30%, (ii) is 2.0 to 6.0%, and (iii) is 0 to 1.0%.

5. A method for selecting a solid component that provides a good user experience, wherein, in the evaluation method described in claim 1, the loss modulus of elasticity G'' is measured by raising the temperature at intervals of 1°C ± 0.2°C, starting from 27°C ± 0.5°C, and (A) the average value from the 1st to the 4th time, (B) the average value from the 5th to the 8th time, (C) the average value from the 9th to the 12th time, and (D) the average value from the 13th to the 16th time, and (i) the ratio of (B) to (A) expressed as (B) / (A) × 100, (ii) the ratio of (C) to (B) expressed as (C) / (B) × 100, and (iii) the ratio of (D) to (C) expressed as (D) / (C) × 100, and a solid component is selected such that (i) is 20 to 28%, (ii) is 5.0 to 7.0%, and (iii) is 0 to 0.1%.

6. A method for selecting a solid component with a good feel, wherein, in the evaluation method described in claim 1, the storage modulus G', loss modulus G'', or loss coefficient tanδ is measured by raising the temperature in increments of 1°C ± 0.2°C starting from 27°C ± 0.5°C, and (a) the value obtained by subtracting the first measurement from the fourth measurement, (b) the value obtained by subtracting the fifth measurement from the eighth measurement, (c) the value obtained by subtracting the ninth measurement from the twelfth measurement, and (d) the value obtained by subtracting the thirteenth measurement from the sixteenth measurement are calculated, and the ratio of (b) to (a) expressed as (iv)(b) / (a) × 100, the ratio of (c) to (b) expressed as (v)(c) / (b) × 100, and the ratio of (d) to (c) expressed as (vi)(d) / (c) × 100 are calculated, and a solid component with a good feel is selected from the above values ​​of (iv) to (vi).

7. A method for selecting a solid component that provides a good feel, wherein the evaluation method described in claim 1 above is performed by measuring the storage modulus G' at intervals of 1°C ± 0.2°C starting from 27°C ± 0.5°C, and (a) the value obtained by subtracting the first measurement from the fourth measurement, (b) the value obtained by subtracting the fifth measurement from the eighth measurement, (c) the value obtained by subtracting the ninth measurement from the twelfth measurement, and (d) the value obtained by subtracting the thirteenth measurement from the sixteenth measurement are calculated, and the ratio of (b) to (a) expressed as (iv)(b) / (a) × 100, the ratio of (c) to (b) expressed as (v)(c) / (b) × 100, and the ratio of (d) to (c) expressed as (vi)(d) / (c) × 100 are calculated, and (iv) is 15 to 50%, (v) is 1.0 to 8.0%, and A method for selecting solid components such that (vi) is between 0% and 1.0%.

8. A method for selecting a solid component that provides a good feel, wherein the evaluation method described in claim 1 above is performed by measuring the loss modulus of elasticity G'' at intervals of 1°C ± 0.2°C starting from 27°C ± 0.5°C, and (a) the value obtained by subtracting the first measurement from the fourth measurement, (b) the value obtained by subtracting the fifth measurement from the eighth measurement, (c) the value obtained by subtracting the ninth measurement from the twelfth measurement, and (d) the value obtained by subtracting the thirteenth measurement from the sixteenth measurement are calculated, and the ratio of (b) to (a) expressed as (iv)(b) / (a) × 100, the ratio of (c) to (b) expressed as (v)(c) / (b) × 100, and the ratio of (d) to (c) expressed as (vi)(d) / (c) × 100 are calculated, and (iv) is 30-50%, (v) is 12-13%, and A method for selecting solid components such that (vi) is 0-0.1%.

9. A method for producing a cosmetic composition containing a solid component, comprising the steps of: selecting a solid component using the selection method described in any one of claims 3 to 8; and blending the selected solid component.

10. The method for producing a cosmetic composition according to claim 9, wherein the cosmetic composition contains 0.1 to 20% by mass of the selected solid component.

11. A method for producing a cosmetic composition according to claim 9, wherein the solid component is silicone wax.