Methanol production method and methanol production apparatus

Multi-point control of methanol production using multiple reference trays in a distillation column stabilizes the side-cut tray temperature, addressing the challenge of maintaining high-purity methanol output during unstable operations.

WO2026240058A1PCT designated stage Publication Date: 2026-11-19MITSUBISHI GAS CHEM CO INC
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
PCT/JP2026/017777
Authority / Receiving Office
WO · WO
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2025-05-15
Filing Date
2026-05-11
Publication Date
2026-11-19

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Conventional methanol production methods struggle to maintain high-purity methanol output during unstable operations such as startup or disturbances, as single-point temperature control of the side-cut stage in distillation columns is ineffective in stabilizing ethanol concentration.

Method used

Implementing multi-point control based on the measured temperatures of multiple reference trays within the distillation column, adjusting the supply flow rate to stabilize the side-cut tray temperature, using a control unit to manage a deviation parameter that converges to a set value.

Benefits of technology

This approach enhances the efficiency of ethanol removal, ensuring high-purity methanol production even during unstable conditions by stabilizing the side-cut tray temperature more rapidly, thereby reducing ethanol concentration in purified methanol.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure JP2026017777_19112026_PF_FP_ABST
    Figure JP2026017777_19112026_PF_FP_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

Provided is a methanol production method for producing methanol from a mixture containing methanol, water, and ethanol supplied to a distillation column, using a distillation column equipped with a plurality of trays. In the method, measured temperatures of a plurality of reference trays including a side cut tray among the plurality of trays from which an intermediate fraction containing ethanol is withdrawn are acquired, and a temperature of the side cut tray is controlled based on the measured temperatures of the plurality of reference trays.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Method and apparatus for producing methanol

[0001] This invention relates to a methanol production method and a methanol production apparatus.

[0002] The production of methanol involves a process of purifying methanol by distillation from a methanol mixture containing synthesized methanol and other components (hereinafter also referred to as crude methanol). Conventionally, a process called side cutting is sometimes performed, in which the middle distillate is extracted from the trays at positions with high ethanol concentrations in the distillation column (see, for example, Patent Document 1). This process can reduce the concentration of ethanol in the purified methanol obtained from the top of the distillation column.

[0003] Special Publication No. 59-006846

[0004] Patent Document 1 discloses a technique for stabilizing the ethanol concentration in the middle distillate by measuring the temperature of the middle distillate and controlling the reboiler heating rate according to that temperature. However, while this method may not have problems during stable operation, it was difficult to properly control the process during unstable operation, such as when the distillation column is started or when there are disturbances such as rainfall.

[0005] This invention has been made in view of the above circumstances, and aims to provide a methanol production method and methanol production apparatus capable of producing high-purity methanol even during unstable operation.

[0006] As a result of diligent research to solve the above problems, the inventors of the present invention have found that the present invention, having the following configuration, can produce high-purity methanol even during unstable operation, and have completed the present invention. That is, the present invention is as follows.

[0007] [1] A methanol production method for producing methanol from a mixture containing methanol, water, and ethanol supplied to a distillation column, using a distillation column equipped with a plurality of trays, wherein the measured temperatures of a plurality of reference trays, including a side-cut tray for extracting the middle distillate containing ethanol, are obtained, and the temperature of the side-cut tray is controlled based on the measured temperatures of the plurality of reference trays. [2] The methanol production method according to [1], wherein the temperature of the side-cut tray is controlled by adjusting the supply flow rate of the mixture to the distillation column based on the measured temperatures of the plurality of reference trays. [3] The methanol production method according to [1] or [2], wherein a measured deviation parameter PV is calculated based on the difference between the set temperature and the measured temperature for each of the plurality of reference trays, and the temperature of the side-cut tray is controlled based on the measured deviation parameter PV. [4] A methanol production method according to [3], wherein the temperature of the side cut stage is controlled by adjusting the flow rate of the mixture supplied to the distillation column so that the measured deviation parameter PV converges to the set value SV over time, based on the set value SV of the measured deviation parameter PV. [5] A methanol production method according to [4], wherein the set value SV is changed at least once within a predetermined time after the start of the distillation column. [6] A methanol production method according to any one of [1] to [5], wherein the number of reference shelves is 5 or more and 12 or less. [7] A methanol production method according to any one of [1] to [6], wherein the reference shelves are selected from the shelves from the 6th shelf above to the 6th shelf below the side cut stage. [8] A methanol production method according to any one of [1] to [7], wherein the reference shelves include a plurality of shelves located above the side cut stage and a plurality of shelves located below the side cut stage.[9] A methanol production apparatus for producing methanol from a mixture containing methanol, water and ethanol, comprising: a distillation column having a plurality of trays; a supply pipe for supplying the mixture to the distillation column; a temperature sensor for acquiring the measured temperatures of a plurality of reference trays, including a side-cut tray for extracting the middle distillate containing ethanol; and a control unit for controlling the temperature of the side-cut tray based on the measured temperatures of the plurality of reference trays.

[10] The methanol production apparatus according to [9], wherein the control unit controls the temperature of the side-cut tray by adjusting the supply flow rate of the mixture to the distillation column based on the measured temperatures of the plurality of reference trays.

[11] The methanol production apparatus according to [9] or

[10] , wherein the control unit calculates a measured deviation parameter PV based on the difference between the set temperature and the measured temperature for each of the plurality of reference trays, and controls the temperature of the side-cut tray based on the measured deviation parameter PV.

[12] The methanol production apparatus according to

[11] , wherein the control unit controls the temperature of the side cut stage by adjusting the flow rate of the mixture supplied to the distillation column so that the measured deviation parameter PV converges to the set value SV over time, based on the set value SV of the measured deviation parameter PV.

[13] The methanol production apparatus according to

[12] , wherein the control unit changes the set value SV at least once within a predetermined time after the start of the distillation column.

[14] The methanol production apparatus according to any one of [9] to

[13] , wherein the number of reference shelves is 5 or more and 12 or less.

[15] The methanol production apparatus according to any one of [9] to

[14] , wherein the reference shelves are selected from the shelves from the 6th shelf above to the 6th shelf below the side cut stage.

[16] The methanol production apparatus according to any one of [9] to

[15] , wherein the reference shelves include a plurality of shelves located above the side cut stage and a plurality of shelves located below the side cut stage.

[0008] The present invention provides a methanol production method and methanol production apparatus capable of producing high-purity methanol even during unstable operation.

[0009] This is a schematic diagram showing an example of a methanol production apparatus. This is a flowchart showing an example of a methanol production method. This is a schematic diagram showing an example of a methanol production system. This is a graph showing the results of Comparative Example 1. This is a graph showing the results of Example 1. This is a graph showing the results of Comparative Example 2. This is a graph showing the results of Example 2.

[0010] The following describes in detail embodiments for carrying out the present invention (hereinafter simply referred to as "this embodiment"), with reference to the drawings as necessary, but the present invention is not limited to the embodiments described below. The present invention can be modified in various ways without departing from its essence. In the drawings, the same elements are denoted by the same reference numerals, and redundant explanations are omitted. Unless otherwise specified, positional relationships such as up, down, left, and right are based on the positional relationships shown in the drawings. The dimensional ratios in the drawings are not limited to the ratios shown.

[0011] [Methanol Production Method] The methanol production method of this embodiment will be described below using the methanol production apparatus 10 shown in Figure 1 as an example. However, the methanol production method of this embodiment is not limited to the embodiment using the methanol production apparatus 10 shown in Figure 1. Hereinafter, the top 113 side of the methanol production apparatus 10 may be referred to as the "upper side" or "top," and the bottom 114 side may be referred to as the "lower side" or "bottom."

[0012] In the methanol production method of this embodiment, a distillation column 11 equipped with multiple trays 110 is used, and methanol is purified from a mixture containing methanol, water, and ethanol supplied to the distillation column 11. Hereinafter, the purified methanol will also be referred to as "purified methanol." Purified methanol may contain components other than methanol, such as ethanol, but it is preferable that the purity of methanol be as high as possible.

[0013] The mixture containing methanol, water, and ethanol supplied to the distillation column 11 is also called crude methanol. Crude methanol may be, for example, a methanol mixture produced from synthesis gas obtained by steam reforming natural gas. The mixture supplied to the distillation column 11 may have undergone one or more distillation processes in other distillation columns located upstream of the distillation column 11.

[0014] The concentration of methanol in the mixture supplied to the distillation column 11 is not particularly limited, but is, for example, 60% by mass or more and 97% by mass or less. The concentration of water in the mixture is not particularly limited, but is, for example, 1% by mass or more and 30% by mass or less. The concentration of ethanol in the mixture is not particularly limited, but is, for example, 1% by mass or more and 10% by mass or less. The mixture may also contain components other than methanol, water, and ethanol, for example, in amounts of about 1% by mass or more and 10% by mass or less.

[0015] The distillation column 11 is equipped with multiple shelves 110 arranged vertically. The number of shelves 110 is not particularly limited, but for example, it is between 20 and 150. A vapor-liquid equilibrium state is maintained in each shelf 110. For example, when considering one shelf 110, the gas phase components, which contain many components with relatively low boiling points, rise to the upper shelf 110, while the liquid phase components, which contain many components with relatively high boiling points, fall to the lower shelf 110. The temperature of each shelf 110 is lower in the upper shelf 110 and higher in the lower shelf 110. The gas phase components that have risen to the top of the column 113 are discharged from the top of the column 113. The gas phase components discharged from the top of the column 113 are cooled by the condenser 14 and become liquid, which is then refluxed to the distillation column 11 or recovered as purified methanol. The liquid phase component that falls to the bottom 114 of the column mainly consists of water and is discharged from the bottom 114. The liquid phase component discharged from the bottom 114 of the column is either discharged out of the system or heated by the reboiler 16 and returned to the distillation column 11 in a high-temperature gaseous or liquid state.

[0016] The distillation column 11 according to this embodiment includes a side-cut stage 112 as one of the trays 110. An intermediate distillate containing ethanol is withdrawn from the side-cut stage 112. This removes ethanol from the distillation column 11, reducing the concentration of ethanol in the gas phase component discharged from the top of the column 113, and consequently reducing the concentration of ethanol in the purified methanol. The side-cut stage 112 is located below the supply pipe 18 that supplies a mixture containing, for example, methanol, water, and ethanol. To efficiently remove ethanol from the distillation column 11, it is preferable that the side-cut stage 112 is the tray 110 with the highest concentration of ethanol in the liquid phase. The intermediate distillate withdrawn from the side-cut stage 112 may contain methanol, water, etc., in addition to ethanol.

[0017] In the methanol production method of this embodiment, the measured temperatures of multiple trays 110, including the side-cut tray 112, are acquired, and the temperature of the side-cut tray 112 is controlled based on these measured temperatures. In this embodiment, the tray 110 from which the measured temperature is acquired for the purpose of controlling the temperature of the side-cut tray 112 is called the reference tray 111. That is, in the methanol production method of this embodiment, the measured temperatures of multiple reference trays 111, including the side-cut tray 112, are acquired from among the multiple trays 110, and the temperature of the side-cut tray 112 is controlled based on the measured temperatures of the multiple reference trays 111. The methanol production method of this embodiment is performed by automatic control, for example, by a control unit 20. The temperature of the reference tray 111 is acquired, for example, by a temperature sensor 12 corresponding to that reference tray 111. The temperature sensor 12 is electrically connected to the control unit 20, for example, and outputs the acquired temperature data of the reference tray 111 (for example, "measured temperature" below). The temperature of the reference shelf 111 obtained by the temperature sensor 12 may be the temperature near the surface of the reference shelf 111, or it may be the temperature of the liquid phase adhering to the reference shelf 111.

[0018] In conventional methanol production methods, the temperature of the side-cut stage 112 was controlled based on the measured temperature of a single tray 110. This method is also referred to as "single-point control." With this single-point control, even if there were no problems during stable operation, during unstable operation, such as when the distillation column 11 was started or when there was an external disturbance like rainfall, the control would be disrupted, and it would take time for the temperature of the side-cut stage 112 to stabilize. As a result, ethanol could not be efficiently removed from the distillation column 11 during unstable operation, and consequently, the ethanol concentration in the purified methanol did not become sufficiently low. In contrast, in the methanol production method of this embodiment, as described above, the temperature of the side-cut stage 112 is controlled based on the measured temperatures of multiple reference trays 111. This method is also referred to as "multi-point control." In this multi-point control, because there are multiple reference trays 111, changes in the temperature profile within the distillation column 11 are detected at an earlier timing compared to the single-point control case. As a result, the temperature control of the side-cut stage 112 based on the measured temperatures of multiple reference trays 111 is performed at an earlier timing compared to the single-point control case. As a result, in the methanol production method of this embodiment, the time it takes for the temperature of the side cut stage 112 to stabilize during unstable operation is shorter compared to conventional methods. The temperature of the side cut stage 112 affects the ethanol concentration in the side cut stage 112. When the temperature of the side cut stage 112 is appropriately controlled so that the ethanol concentration in the side cut stage 112 is as high as possible, the efficiency of ethanol removal is improved. Therefore, in the methanol production method of this embodiment, because there are multiple reference shelf stages 111, the ethanol concentration in the purified methanol is less likely to become too high even during unstable operation, making it easier to obtain high-purity methanol. Furthermore, since the methanol production method of this embodiment can be performed by automatic control by the control unit 20, this can improve, for example, the stability and consistency of the process.

[0019] The temperature of the side-cut stage 112 is controlled by adjusting, for example, the flow rate of the mixture supplied to the distillation column 11, the heating temperature in the reboiler 16, and the reflux flow rate from the condenser 14. Of these, it is preferable that the temperature of the side-cut stage 112 be controlled by adjusting the flow rate of the mixture supplied to the distillation column 11, because the flow rate of the mixture supplied to the distillation column 11 can be adjusted relatively easily. Specifically, for example, the temperature of the side-cut stage 112 can be lowered by increasing the flow rate of the mixture, and the temperature of the side-cut stage 112 can be raised by decreasing the flow rate of the mixture.

[0020] The temperature of the side cut stage 112 is controlled to be, for example, near the boiling point of ethanol, but it can be controlled to any temperature determined considering the pressure and other components. The temperature of the side cut stage 112 is controlled to be, for example, within the range of 75 to 90°C.

[0021] The following describes a specific example in which the temperature of the side cut stage 112 is controlled based on the measured temperatures of multiple reference shelf stages 111.

[0022] In a methanol production method, for example, an "actual deviation parameter PV" may be calculated based on the difference between the set temperature and the actual temperature for each of the multiple reference shelf stages 111, and the temperature of the side cut stage 112 may be controlled based on this actual deviation parameter PV.

[0023] The measured deviation parameter PV is, for example, the sum of the differences between the set temperature and the measured temperature for each of the multiple reference shelf stages 111. Alternatively, the measured deviation parameter PV may be the sum of the values ​​obtained by multiplying the difference between the set temperature and the measured temperature for each of the multiple reference shelf stages 111 by an arbitrary coefficient. In these cases, the closer the measured deviation parameter PV is to 0°C, the closer the measured temperature of the reference shelf stage 111, including the side cut stage 112, is to the set temperature.

[0024] If the measured deviation parameter PV is defined as the sum of the differences between the set temperature and the measured temperature for each of the multiple reference shelf levels 111, the measured deviation parameter PV can be calculated using the following formula (1). In formula (1), "n" is the number of reference shelf levels 111. Formula (1) PV = (A1 −B 1 )+(A 2 −B 2 )+…+(A n −B n ) A 1 、A 2 、…、A n : Measured temperature of each reference tray 111 B 1 、B 2 、…、B n : Set temperature of each reference tray 111

[0025] When the measured deviation parameter PV is defined as the sum of values obtained by multiplying the difference between the set temperature and the measured temperature for each of the plurality of reference trays 111 by an arbitrary coefficient, the measured deviation parameter PV is determined by the following equation (2). In equation (2), "n" is the number of reference trays 111. Equation (2) PV=(A 1 −B 1 )C 1 +(A 2 −B 2 )C 2 +…+(A n −B n )C n A 1 、A 2 、…、A n : Measured temperature of each reference tray 111 B 1 、B 2 、…、B n : Set temperature of each reference tray 111 C 1 、C 2 、…、C n : Arbitrary coefficient to be multiplied to the difference between the set temperature and the measured temperature of each reference tray 111

[0026] When the measured deviation parameter PV is determined by equation (2), the arbitrary coefficient to be multiplied to the difference between the set temperature and the measured temperature of each reference tray 111 may be arbitrarily determined. For example, the coefficient multiplied to the difference between the set temperature and the measured temperature of the side cut tray 112 among the reference trays 111 may be made larger than the coefficients multiplied to the difference between the set temperature and the measured temperature of the other reference trays 111.

[0027] The temperature of the side cut stage 112 may be controlled by being adjusted based on the set value SV of the measured deviation parameter PV so that the measured deviation parameter PV converges to the set value SV over time. In this case, when the set value SV is, for example, 0°C, the measured deviation parameter PV is adjusted so as to converge to 0°C over time. In order to bring the measured temperature of the reference tray 111 including the side cut stage 112 close to the set temperature, the set value SV is preferably set to 0°C. However, the set value SV does not necessarily need to be set to 0°C, and may be arbitrarily determined according to the operating conditions of the distillation column 11.

[0028] The set value SV may be appropriately changed during the operation of the distillation column 11. For example, the set value SV may be changed at least once within a predetermined time after the startup of the distillation column 11. For a period of time shortly after the startup of the distillation column 11, for example, the measured temperature of each reference tray 111 including the side cut stage 112 may be significantly distant from the set temperature. In such a case, if the set value SV is set to 0°C from the beginning, the settling of the measured deviation parameter PV may instead be delayed. Therefore, for example, after the startup of the distillation column 11, while the measured deviation parameter PV is in the process of decreasing, the set value SV is intentionally set to a value higher than the value to be settled, and the set value SV may be changed to 0°C at the timing when the measured deviation parameter PV starts to increase toward the set value SV. As a result, at the time of startup of the distillation column 11, the settling of the measured deviation parameter PV is accelerated, and ethanol is efficiently removed from the distillation column 11. As a result, the ethanol concentration in the purified methanol is less likely to become excessively high, and high-purity methanol is easily obtained.

[0029] The aforementioned "within a predetermined time after the startup of the distillation column 11" is not particularly limited, and may be arbitrarily determined according to the size of the distillation column 11, the number of trays 110, the supply flow rate of the mixture to the distillation column 11, and the like. The "within a predetermined time after the startup of the distillation column 11" may be, for example, within 1 hour after the startup of the distillation column 11, or within 30 minutes.

[0030] The number of reference shelves 111 is not particularly limited, but it is preferably 5 to 12. This results in an appropriate number of reference shelves 111, which tends to shorten the time it takes for the temperature of the side cut shelves 112 to stabilize during unstable operation.

[0031] The closer a shelf 110 is to the side-cut stage 112, the more useful its measured temperature becomes for controlling the temperature of the side-cut stage 112. Therefore, it is preferable that the reference shelf 111 be selected from the shelves 110 from the sixth shelf above to the sixth shelf below the side-cut stage 112.

[0032] The reference shelf 111 preferably includes one or more shelf 110 located above the side cut step 112 and one or more shelf 110 located below the side cut step 112. More preferably, the reference shelf 111 includes multiple shelf 110 located above the side cut step 112 and multiple shelf 110 located below the side cut step 112. This makes it easier to shorten the time it takes for the temperature of the side cut step 112 to stabilize during unstable operation. The reference shelf 111 is not particularly limited, but can be selected, for example, from shelf 110 that are continuous above and below the side cut step 112.

[0033] An example of the flow of the methanol production method of the present embodiment will be described. FIG. 2 is a flowchart showing an example of the methanol production method of the present embodiment. As shown in FIG. 2, when the temperature control of the side cut stage 112 is started in response to the startup of the distillation column 11 or the like, in step S1 by the control unit 20, for example, each temperature sensor 12 acquires a "measured temperature" from the corresponding reference tray 111, and further collectively transmits the acquired plurality of measured temperatures of the reference trays 111 to the control unit 20 as measured temperature information. The acquisition of the measured temperature of the reference tray 111 by the temperature sensor 12 may be performed continuously, or may be performed intermittently at predetermined time intervals or the like. In step S2, the control unit 20 calculates the "difference" between the "set temperature" preset for each reference tray 111 and the "measured temperature" of the reference tray 111 acquired from the temperature sensor 12 for each reference tray 111, and further calculates the measured deviation parameter PV, for example, as in the above formula (1), formula (2), etc., based on the "difference between the set temperature and the measured temperature" for each reference tray. In step S3, the control unit 20 determines the supply flow rate of the mixture to the distillation column 11 based on the "measured deviation parameter PV" and the preset "set value SV" so that the measured deviation parameter PV converges to the set value SV. In step S4, the control unit 20 sends a control signal to, for example, the supply valve 19 installed in the middle of the supply pipe 18, and adjusts the supply flow rate of the mixture to the supply flow rate determined in step S3. In this case, the control unit 20 can control the temperature of the side cut stage 111 by adjusting the supply flow rate of the mixture. Thereafter, in step S5, the control unit 20 determines whether or not distillation is continued. When the control unit 20 determines that distillation is to be continued (Yes in step S5), the flow returns to step S1, and the temperature control of the side cut stage 112 by the control unit 20 is continued. When the control unit 20 determines that distillation is not to be continued (No in step S5), the control unit 20 stops the temperature control of the side cut stage 112, stops the supply of the mixture and the like as necessary, and the methanol production ends. Although omitted in the example shown in FIG. 2, the set value SV may be appropriately changed at a desired stage such as during startup of the distillation column 11 or after a certain period of time as described above.

[0034] [Methanol Production Apparatus] The methanol production apparatus 10 of this embodiment is an apparatus for carrying out the methanol production method described above. Figure 1 is a schematic diagram showing an example of the methanol production apparatus 10 of this embodiment.

[0035] As shown in Figure 1, the methanol production apparatus 10 includes a distillation column 11 with a plurality of trays 110, a supply pipe 18 for supplying a mixture to the distillation column 11, a temperature sensor 12 for acquiring the measured temperatures of a plurality of reference trays 111, including a side-cut tray 112, and a control unit 20 for controlling the temperature of the side-cut tray 112 based on the measured temperatures of the plurality of reference trays 111. The methanol production apparatus 10 may also include a supply flow rate adjustment means for adjusting the supply flow rate of the mixture. As shown in Figure 1, the supply valve 19 is installed, for example, in the middle of the supply pipe 18. The supply valve 19 may also be configured to receive control signals from the control unit 20. Details of the reference trays 111 are as described above. In Figure 1, an example is shown in which the methanol production apparatus 10 is equipped with a supply valve 19 as a supply flow rate adjustment means, but the methanol production apparatus 10 of this embodiment is not limited to this embodiment, and the supply flow rate of the mixture may be adjusted using a plurality of means, such as pumps or other valves, which are not shown.

[0036] For example, a thermocouple can be used as the temperature sensor 12. The temperature sensor 12 may be directly connected to the reference shelf 111, or it may be installed so as to be in contact with the liquid phase in the reference shelf 111. The temperature sensor 12 may be configured to transmit the acquired measured temperature information of the reference shelf 111 to the control unit 20.

[0037] The configuration of the control unit 20 is not particularly limited, but the control unit 20 may include, for example, a CPU (Central Processing Unit), RAM (Random Access Memory), ROM (Read Only Memory), etc. The control unit 20 controls the operation of the methanol production apparatus 10 so that the methanol production method described above is carried out.

[0038] As shown in Figure 1, the methanol production apparatus 10 may include a gas phase discharge pipe 13, a condenser 14, a liquid phase discharge pipe 15, a reboiler 16, and a side cut pipe 17. The gas phase discharge pipe 13 discharges the gaseous components from the top of the column 113. The condenser 14 cools the gaseous components discharged from the top of the column 113 via the gas phase discharge pipe 13. The liquid obtained by cooling with the condenser 14 is refluxed to the distillation column 11 or recovered as purified methanol. The liquid phase discharge pipe 15 discharges the liquid phase components from the bottom of the column 114. The reboiler 16 heats the liquid phase components discharged from the bottom of the column 114 via the liquid phase discharge pipe 15. The high-temperature gas or liquid obtained by heating with the reboiler 16 can be returned to the distillation column 11 and become a heat source inside the distillation column 11. The side cut pipe 17 extracts the middle distillate from the side cut stage 112.

[0039] [Methanol Production System] The methanol production apparatus 10 of this embodiment may be used in a methanol production system 30. Figure 3 is a schematic diagram showing an example of a methanol production system 30 including the methanol production apparatus 10 of this embodiment.

[0040] As shown in Figure 3, the methanol production system 30 may include a primary distillation column 31, a high-pressure rectification column 32, and an atmospheric-pressure rectification column 33. The primary distillation column 31 separates impurities from a methanol-containing mixture supplied, for example, from a synthesis system, and crudely purifies the methanol. This yields a low-purity methanol mixture. The high-pressure rectification column 32 uses the methanol mixture crudely purified by the primary distillation column 31 as a feedstock and distills high-purity purified methanol from the top of the column. A mixture containing methanol, water, and ethanol is obtained from the bottom of the high-pressure rectification column 32. The atmospheric-pressure rectification column 33 uses the mixture obtained from the bottom of the high-pressure rectification column 32 as a feedstock and purifies the methanol. The purified methanol distilled from the high-pressure rectification column 32 and the purified methanol distilled from the atmospheric-pressure rectification column 33 can be recovered as product methanol. The mass ratio (A:B) of purified methanol (A) distilled from the high-pressure rectification column 32 to purified methanol (B) distilled from the atmospheric pressure rectification column 33 in the product methanol is, for example, about 3:7 to 4:6. The methanol production apparatus 10 of this embodiment can be suitably used as the atmospheric pressure rectification column 33 in the methanol production system 30 shown in Figure 3.

[0041] The methanol production system 30 does not necessarily need to include all of the initial distillation column 31, the high-pressure rectification column 32, and the atmospheric pressure rectification column 33; for example, it may not have the high-pressure rectification column 32. If the methanol production system 30 does not have the high-pressure rectification column 32, the methanol mixture crudely purified by the initial distillation column 31 may be supplied to the atmospheric pressure rectification column 33 and further purified by the atmospheric pressure rectification column 33.

[0042] The methanol production apparatus 10 of this embodiment may be used in a methanol production system 30 having multiple distillation columns 11, or in a methanol production system 30 having only one distillation column 11. In a methanol production system 30 having multiple distillation columns 11, the methanol production apparatus 10 of this embodiment may be applied to any distillation column 11 having a side-cut stage 112. In a methanol production system 30 having multiple distillation columns 11, the methanol production apparatus 10 of this embodiment may be applied to the furthest downstream distillation column 11, as shown in Figure 3, or to the second-to-last downstream distillation column 11. In a methanol production system 30 having multiple distillation columns 11, the methanol production apparatus 10 of this embodiment may be applied to multiple distillation columns 11, or to only one distillation column 11.

[0043] The methanol production method and methanol production apparatus of the present invention will be described in detail below with reference to examples and comparative examples. However, the present invention is not limited to these examples.

[0044] In the following examples and comparative examples, a methanol production apparatus was used in which the number of trays in the distillation column was 79, and the side cut tray was located below the feed pipe.

[0045] [Comparative Example 1] In Comparative Example 1, the temperature of the side-cut stage at the start of the distillation column was controlled by single-point control. The graph in Figure 4 shows the time evolution of the target temperature of the side-cut stage, the measured temperature of the side-cut stage, and the ethanol concentration in the obtained purified methanol in Comparative Example 1. The horizontal axis of the graph represents the elapsed time from the start of the distillation column, i.e., from the start of the supply of the mixture from the feed pipe. For example, "1:00" in the elapsed time indicates the point in time when one hour has elapsed from the start of the supply of the mixture from the feed pipe.

[0046] The details of the single-point control in Comparative Example 1 will be explained below using the graph in Figure 4. Immediately after the distillation column is started, the mixture is supplied from the feed pipe, causing a temperature change to occur sequentially from the position closest to the feed pipe. At approximately 0:11 after the distillation column was started, when the measured temperature of the side-cut stage fell below 100°C, the target temperature of the side-cut stage was set to 100°C. Immediately after that, the feed flow rate of the mixture was reduced so that the measured temperature of the side-cut stage would converge to the target temperature (100°C). Subsequently, at approximately 0:20, the measured temperature of the side-cut stage began to rise due to the effect of the reduced feed flow rate of the mixture. At the moment when the measured temperature of the side-cut stage began to rise, the target temperature of the side-cut stage was changed to 88°C, which was the final temperature at which the measured temperature of the side-cut stage would converge. Immediately after that, the feed flow rate of the mixture was increased so that the measured temperature of the side-cut stage would converge to the target temperature (88°C). Subsequently, the measured temperature at the side-cut stage began to decrease around 0:50 due to the increase in the mixture supply flow rate. After that, the measured temperature at the side-cut stage was controlled by adjusting the mixture supply flow rate based on the target temperature, but it did not converge to the target temperature (88°C) even after 2:00. In addition, the ethanol concentration in the obtained purified methanol temporarily exceeded 2500 ppm and did not decrease to the specified value of 10 ppm or less even after 2:00.

[0047] [Example 1] In Example 1, the temperature of the side-cut stage at startup of the distillation column was controlled by the multi-point control according to this embodiment. In Example 1, a total of nine stages were used as reference stages: the side-cut stage and four stages above and below the side-cut stage. The graph in Figure 5 shows the time evolution of the set value SV of the measured deviation parameter PV, the measured deviation parameter PV, the measured temperature of the side-cut stage, and the ethanol concentration in the obtained purified methanol in Example 1. The measured deviation parameter PV is the sum of the values ​​obtained by multiplying the difference between the set temperature and the measured temperature for each of the multiple reference stages by an arbitrary coefficient.

[0048] The details of the multi-point control by the control unit in Example 1 will be explained below using the graph in Figure 5. First, after the distillation column was started, at around 0:09 elapsed time, before the measured temperature of the side cut stage began to drop significantly, the set value SV of the measured deviation parameter PV was set to 66.5°C, which was the measured deviation parameter PV at that time. Immediately after that, the supply flow rate of the mixture was reduced so that the measured deviation parameter PV would converge to the set value SV (66.5°C). Subsequently, the measured deviation parameter PV began to rise at around 0:15 elapsed time due to the effect of the reduction in the supply flow rate of the mixture. At the timing when the measured deviation parameter PV began to rise, the set value SV was changed to 0°C, which was the temperature at which the measured deviation parameter PV was to ultimately converge. Immediately after that, the supply flow rate of the mixture was increased so that the measured deviation parameter PV would converge to the set value SV (0°C). Subsequently, the measured deviation parameter PV began to decrease around 0:20 due to the effect of increasing the supply flow rate of the mixture. After that, the measured deviation parameter PV increased and decreased several times as the supply flow rate of the mixture was controlled based on the set value SV, and converged to the set value SV (0°C) around 1:40. At the same time, the measured temperature of the side cut stage converged to 88°C.

[0049] In Example 1, the temperature of the side-cut stage was controlled not only based on the temperature of the side-cut stage but also on the temperature of the tray stage above the side-cut stage, resulting in the measured temperature of the side-cut stage converging to 88°C faster than in Comparative Example 1. In other words, in Example 1, the delay in temperature control (dead zone) of the side-cut stage that occurred with single-point control was improved. As a result, the ethanol concentration in the obtained purified methanol did not rise too high compared to Comparative Example 1, even immediately after starting the distillation column 11, and decreased to the specified value of 10 ppm or less after an elapsed time of approximately 2:00.

[0050] [Comparative Example 2] In Comparative Example 2, the temperature of the side-cut stage during disturbances was controlled by single-point control. When the ambient temperature fluctuates rapidly due to rainfall, etc., the top of the distillation column tends to be supercooled, causing the internal reflux ratio to fluctuate. Therefore, in Comparative Example 2, a disturbance was artificially generated by abruptly changing the internal reflux ratio from a stable operating state of the distillation column with a vapor load of 80.0% or more. The internal reflux ratio is the ratio of the reflux liquid flow rate L to the distillate liquid flow rate D (L / D). The graph in Figure 6 shows the time changes of the target temperature of the side-cut stage, the measured temperature of the side-cut stage, and the ethanol concentration in the obtained purified methanol in Comparative Example 2. The horizontal axis of the graph represents the elapsed time since the occurrence of the artificial disturbance. For example, "1:00" in the elapsed time indicates the point in time when one hour has elapsed since the occurrence of the artificial disturbance.

[0051] The details of the single-point control in Comparative Example 2 will be explained below using the graph in Figure 6. In Comparative Example 2, the target temperature of the side-cut stage is constant at 88°C. Immediately after the occurrence of a disturbance, the measured temperature of the side-cut stage rose sharply from the target temperature (88°C) to 111°C due to the influence of the disturbance. At the moment when the measured temperature of the side-cut stage rose above the target temperature (88°C), the supply flow rate of the mixture was increased so that the measured temperature of the side-cut stage would converge to the target temperature (88°C). Subsequently, the measured temperature of the side-cut stage began to decrease at around 1:05 due to the effect of the increased supply flow rate of the mixture. Then, at around 1:17, the measured temperature of the side-cut stage fell below the target temperature (88°C). At this point, the supply flow rate of the mixture was decreased so that the measured temperature of the side-cut stage would converge to the target temperature (88°C). However, the measured temperature of the side-cut stage did not rise even after some time had passed, and did not converge to the target temperature (88°C) even after 2 minutes and 40 seconds had elapsed. From this result, it was confirmed that in single-point control, the delay in temperature control of the side-cut stage (dead zone) is a problem even in the event of disturbances. In addition, the ethanol concentration in the obtained purified methanol temporarily exceeded the upper limit of the specified value, which is 10 ppm.

[0052] [Example 2] In Example 2, the temperature of the side-cut stage during disturbances was controlled by the multi-point control according to this embodiment. In Example 2, as in Example 1, a total of nine stages were used as reference stages: the side-cut stage and the four stages above and below the side-cut stage that are continuous with it. The graph in Figure 7 shows the time changes of the set value SV of the measured deviation parameter PV, the measured deviation parameter PV, the measured temperature of the side-cut stage, and the ethanol concentration in the obtained purified methanol in Example 2. The measured deviation parameter PV is calculated by summing the values ​​obtained by multiplying the difference between the set temperature and the measured temperature for each of the multiple reference stages by an arbitrary coefficient, as in Example 1. In Example 2, disturbances were generated in the same manner as in Comparative Example 2.

[0053] The details of the multi-point control by the control unit in Example 2 will be explained below using the graph in Figure 7. First, immediately after the occurrence of the disturbance, the measured temperature of the side cut stage rose sharply from 88°C to 111°C due to the disturbance, and the measured deviation parameter PV also rose sharply from the set value SV (0°C) to 23°C. At the moment when the measured deviation parameter PV became higher than the set value SV (0°C), the supply flow rate of the mixture was increased so that the measured deviation parameter PV would converge to the set value SV (0°C). Subsequently, the measured deviation parameter PV began to decrease around 0:08 due to the effect of the increased supply flow rate of the mixture. After that, the measured deviation parameter PV increased and decreased several times as the supply flow rate of the mixture was controlled based on the set value SV, and converged to the set value SV (0°C) around 1:35. At the same time, the measured temperature of the side cut stage converged to 88°C.

[0054] In Example 2, the temperature of the side-cut stage was controlled not only based on the temperature of the side-cut stage but also on the temperature of the shelf stage above the side-cut stage, resulting in the measured temperature of the side-cut stage converging to 88°C faster than in Comparative Example 2. In other words, in Example 2 as well, the delay in temperature control of the side-cut stage (dead zone) that occurred with single-point control was improved. As a result, the ethanol concentration in the obtained purified methanol did not exceed the upper limit of 10 ppm, even after the occurrence of disturbances.

[0055] From the above results, it can be confirmed that, in the methanol production method and methanol production apparatus of this embodiment, the presence of multiple reference shelves prevents the ethanol concentration in the purified methanol from becoming too high even during unstable operation, and thus enables the production of high-purity methanol.

[0056] This application claims priority to a Japanese patent application (Japanese Patent Application No. 2025-081890) filed on 15 May 2025, the entire contents of said application being deemed to be part of the disclosure of this application and incorporated herein by reference.

[0057] The present invention has industrial applicability as a methanol production method and methanol production apparatus.

[0058] 10...Methanol production apparatus, 11...Distillation column, 110...Tray, 111...Reference tray, 112...Side cut tray, 113...Top of column, 114...Bottom of column, 12...Temperature sensor, 13...Gas phase discharge pipe, 14...Condenser, 15...Liquid phase discharge pipe, 16...Reboiler, 17...Side cut pipe, 18...Feed pipe, 19...Feed valve, 20...Control unit, 30...Methanol production system, 31...Initial distillation column, 32...High-pressure rectification column, 33...Atmospheric pressure rectification column.

Claims

1. A methanol production method for producing methanol from a mixture containing methanol, water, and ethanol supplied to a distillation column, using a distillation column equipped with multiple trays, wherein the measured temperatures of multiple reference trays, including a side-cut tray for extracting the middle distillate containing ethanol, are obtained, and the temperature of the side-cut tray is controlled based on the measured temperatures of the multiple reference trays.

2. A methanol production method according to claim 1, wherein the temperature of the side-cut stage is controlled by adjusting the supply flow rate of the mixture to the distillation column based on the measured temperatures of a plurality of reference trays.

3. A methanol production method according to claim 1, comprising: calculating a measured deviation parameter PV based on the difference between the set temperature and the measured temperature for each of the multiple reference shelf stages; and controlling the temperature of the side cut stage based on the measured deviation parameter PV.

4. A methanol production method according to claim 3, wherein the temperature of the side cut stage is controlled by adjusting the flow rate of the mixture supplied to the distillation column so that the measured deviation parameter PV converges to the set value SV over time, based on the set value SV of the measured deviation parameter PV.

5. The methanol production method according to claim 4, wherein the set value SV is changed at least once within a predetermined time after the start of the distillation column.

6. The methanol production method according to claim 1, wherein the number of reference shelves is 5 or more and 12 or less.

7. The methanol production method according to claim 1, wherein the reference shelf is selected from the shelves ranging from the sixth row from the top to the sixth row from the bottom of the side cut shelf.

8. The methanol production method according to claim 1, wherein the reference shelf includes a plurality of shelves located above the side cut step and a plurality of shelves located below the side cut step.

9. A methanol production apparatus for producing methanol from a mixture containing methanol, water, and ethanol, comprising: a distillation column having a plurality of trays; a supply pipe for supplying the mixture to the distillation column; a temperature sensor for acquiring the measured temperatures of a plurality of reference trays, including a side-cut tray for extracting the middle distillate containing ethanol; and a control unit for controlling the temperature of the side-cut tray based on the measured temperatures of the plurality of reference trays.

10. The methanol production apparatus according to claim 9, wherein the control unit controls the temperature of the side cut stage by adjusting the supply flow rate of the mixture to the distillation column based on the measured temperatures of a plurality of reference tray stages.

11. The methanol production apparatus according to claim 9, wherein the control unit calculates a measured deviation parameter PV based on the difference between the set temperature and the measured temperature for each of the plurality of reference shelf stages, and controls the temperature of the side cut stage based on the measured deviation parameter PV.

12. The methanol production apparatus according to claim 11, wherein the control unit controls the temperature of the side cut stage by adjusting the supply flow rate of the mixture to the distillation column so that the measured deviation parameter PV converges to the set value SV over time, based on the set value SV of the measured deviation parameter PV.

13. The methanol production apparatus according to claim 12, wherein the control unit changes the set value SV at least once within a predetermined time after the start of the distillation column.

14. The methanol production apparatus according to claim 9, wherein the number of reference shelves is 5 or more and 12 or less.

15. The methanol production apparatus according to claim 9, wherein the reference shelf is selected from the shelves ranging from the sixth row from the top to the sixth row from the bottom of the side cut shelf.

16. The methanol production apparatus according to claim 9, wherein the reference shelf includes a plurality of shelves located above the side cut step and a plurality of shelves located below the side cut step.