Two-phase coolants and two-phase cooling systems and methods
The use of tailored coolant compositions in two-phase pumped cooling systems addresses inefficiencies in single-phase cooling by enhancing latent heat transfer and pressure drop, enabling effective heat management for modern electronics.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- PCT/US2026/028235
- Authority / Receiving Office
- WO · WO
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2025-05-14
- Filing Date
- 2026-05-14
- Publication Date
- 2026-11-19
AI Technical Summary
Conventional single-phase liquid cooling systems for electronics are inefficient and costly for removing the increasing heat generated by modern chips and microprocessors, while existing two-phase cooling systems face challenges in selecting coolant fluids that provide efficient latent heat transfer with simple and cost-effective equipment.
The development of two-phase pumped cooling systems using specific compositions of HFO-1234yf or HFO-1234ze(E) with additional components like R125, R227ea, R1132E, R1336mzzE, R134a, R161, and R152a, which offer improved latent heat transfer and pressure drop characteristics.
The proposed coolant compositions enable efficient latent heat transfer and reduced pressure drop, effectively managing the high heat fluxes generated by modern electronics with simpler and more cost-effective cooling systems.
Smart Images

Figure US2026028235_19112026_PF_FP_ABST
Abstract
Description
TWO-PHASE COOLANTS AND TWO-PHASE COOLING SYSTEMS AND METHODSCROSS REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS
[0001] The present application is related to and claims the priority benefit of U.S. Provisional Application No. 63 / 805,330, filed May 14, 2025, which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety.FIELD
[0002] The present invention relates to coolant compositions and to methods and systems for cooling. The present compositions, methods and systems can be utilized to cool one or more heat sources, including but not limited to electrical and electronic components that generate heat during operation and to direct-to-chip cooling.BACKGROUND
[0003] Modern data centers frequently house numerous servers, including in the range of thousands of servers, and each server will generally have two or more heat-generating microprocessors. Microprocessors (and chips which contain them) can easily produce more than 40 thermal watts per square centimeter, and future microprocessors / chips are expected to produce even higher heat fluxes as semiconductor technology and electronic packaging continues to progress. Collectively, the amount of heat generated by all servers in a data center is substantial. Unfortunately, removing this heat from the data center using conventional air conditioning systems is costly and inefficient, and frequently requires significant upfront capital expenditures as well as ongoing operating expenditures to service and maintain the systems.
[0004] Single phase pumped and thermosyphon liquid cooling systems are known and can provide improved thermal performance over conventional air-cooling systems. Such single phase direct-to-chip liquid cooling systems are advantageous since they do not require the use of a vapor compressor and they typically include the following items connected by tubing: a heat sink or cold plate attached to the chip / microprocessor, a liquid-to-air or liquid-to-liquid heat exchanger, and a pump that circulates liquid coolant through the system and / or a thermosyphon that uses natural convection to circulate the coolant. As the liquid coolant passes through channels in the heat sink / cold plate (or impinges directly on the microchip in the case of direct contact evaporative14907-6102-3658, v. 1cooling), heat from the chip / microprocessor is transferred through the thermally conductive heat sink (or directly from the microchip in the case of direct contact evaporative cooling) to the coolant, thereby increasing the temperature of the coolant and transferring heat away from the microprocessor. The heat sink or cold-plate is typically designed to maximize heat transfer by maximizing the surface area of the channels through which the liquid passes. In some examples, the heat sink can be a micro-channel heat sink that utilizes fine fin channels through which the liquid coolant flows. The heated liquid coolant exiting the heat sink is then circulated through a liquid-to-air heat exchanger where the heat is expelled to the surrounding air to reduce the temperature of the liquid coolant before it circulates back to the pump for another cycle. While more effective than air cooling, transferring heat by single phase heating (i.e., sensible heating) of the circulating coolant requires significant flow rates of liquid coolant. Consequently, a liquid cooling system designed to cool a modem chip / microprocessor using only sensible heating of the coolant can require relatively large pumps, or a large number of smaller pumps positioned throughout the liquid cooling system, to ensure an adequate liquid coolant pressure and flow rate. Such systems are not well suited, however, for efficient and cost-effective removal of the increasing large amounts of heat generated by modern chips / microprocessors, and this heat generation is expected to increase as new generations of chips and microprocessors are introduced. This is because single phase liquid cooling systems rely solely on transferring sensible heat by increasing the temperature of a liquid coolant as it absorbs heat from the operating electronic component. The amount of heat that can be transferred depends on the thermal conductivity of the fluid and the flow rate of the fluid, and possibly other factors.
[0005] Two-phase cooling systems have been proposed to overcome the deficiencies of singlephase cooling of electronics, including ships and microprocessors. In such two-phase cooling systems, a liquid coolant is pumped to a heat sink or cold plate attached to a chip / microprocessor (or impinges directly on the electronic component in the case of direct contact evaporative cooling), where at least a portion of the liquid absorbs heat from the operating electronic component and in so doing changes phase from liquid to vapor, i.e., by boiling. Because the amount of heat required to boil the liquid (i.e., latent heat of vaporization) is large compared to sensible heat transfer, and because boiling of the liquid occurs without much change, if any, in the temperature of the coolant relative to single phase cooling, cooling of electronics in this mode has substantial advantages. The heat which has been transferred is thus contained in the coolant liquid-vapor mixture as it24907-6102-3658, v. 1leaves the heat sink or cold plate of the chip / microprocessor. This heat is removed from the coolant by condensing the vapor by transferring heat to an abundant source of fluid, such as air or water, at a temperature below the temperature of coolant vapor.
[0006] The use of pumped two-phase cooling systems to cool operating electronics, including microprocessors, has been disclosed. For example, US 2024 / 0365513 (which is incorporated herein by reference) discloses the use of several materials as two-phase coolants, including R-1234ze, R-134a, R-744 (Carbon Dioxide, CO2), R-410A, R-32, Ammonia (NH3), R-290 (Propane), R-1234yf, and R-1233zd. US Patent No. 10,563,937 (which is incorporated herein by reference) discloses both single phase and two-phase cooling systems for cooling electronics, and water and R-1234ze are mentioned as potential coolant fluids. U.S. 2024 / 0098945 (which is incorporated herein by reference) discloses two-phase cooling systems and identifies 2, 3,3,3-tetrafluoropropene, 1,1,1,2-tetrafluoroethane, and water as exemplary two-phase coolants. Each of HFO-1234ze(E), HFO-1234yf and R515B (a blend of HFO-1234ze(E) and R227ea) were studied for use in pumped, two phase on-chip cooling in the paper by Heydari et al presented at the 23rdIEEE ITHERM Conference in 2024. The Heydari et al paper recognizes the complexities of two-phase cooling and the difficulties arising from the sensitivity to the thermodynamic properties of the coolant on many performance and operating parameters, such as operating pressures and temperatures.
[0007] For two-phase cooling of electronics, a myriad of requirements and constraints exist that make the particular selection of coolant fluid a significant technical challenge. Applicants have come to appreciate, for example, that it is a difficult technical challenge to develop coolant fluids that have a desirable combination of properties that will allow its use in relatively simple and cost effective equipment while at the same time providing an ability to provide the high levels of efficient latent heat cooling in the appropriate operating temperature range of the electronic component being cooled. Furthermore, applicants have found that unexpected advantage in the amount of heat transferred and / or in the pressure drop of the coolant flow can be achieved using the coolants, systems and methods of the present invention as described herein.34907-6102-3658, v. 1SUMMARY
[0008] The present invention includes coolants for two-phase pumped cooling of electronics comprising:a) from about 50% to about 96% percent by weight of a first component selected from HFO-1234yf or HFO-1234ze(E); andb) from about 4% by weight to about 55% by weight of a second component selected from the group consisting essentially of R125, R227ea, R1132E, R1336mzzE, R134a, R161, R152a and combinations of two or more of these.For the purpose of convenience, coolants according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Coolant 1.
[0009] The present invention includes coolants for two-phase pumped cooling of electronics comprising:a) from about 50% to about 96% percent by weight of a first component selected from HFO-1234yf or HFO-1234ze(E);b) from about 4% by weight to about 55% by weight of a second component selected from the group consisting essentially of R125, R227ea, R1132E, R1336mzzE, R134a, R161 and R152a: andc) from about 4% by weight to about 35% by weight of a third component that is not the same as said selected first component or said selected second component and which is selected from the group consisting of R1336mzzE, R161 and R152a.For the purpose of convenience, coolants according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Coolant 2.
[0010] The present invention includes coolants for two-phase pumped cooling of electronics comprising:a) from about 50% to about 96% percent by weight of HFO-1234yf; andb) from about 4% by weight to about 55% by weight of a second component selected from the group consisting essentially of R125, R227ea, R1132E, R1336mzzE, R134a. R161 and R152a.44907-6102-3658, v. 1For the purpose of convenience, coolants according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Coolant 3A1.
[0011] The present invention includes coolants for two-phase pumped cooling of electronics comprising:a) from about 89% to about 95% percent by weight of HFO-1234yf; andb) from about 5% by weight to about 11% by weight of a second component selected from the group consisting essentially of R1132E.For the purpose of convenience, coolants according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Coolant 3A2A.
[0012] The present invention includes coolants for two-phase pumped cooling of electronics consisting essentially of:a) from about 89% to about 95% percent by weight of HFO-1234yf; andb) from about 5% by weight to about 11% by weight of a second component selected from the group consisting essentially of R1132E.For the purpose of convenience, coolants according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Coolant 3A2B.
[0013] The present invention includes coolants for two-phase pumped cooling of electronics consisting of:a) from about 89% to about 95% percent by weight of HFO-1234yf; andb) from about 5% by weight to about 11% by weight of a second component selected from the group consisting essentially of R1132E.For the purpose of convenience, coolants according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Coolant 3A2C.
[0014] The present invention includes coolants for two-phase pumped cooling of electronics comprising:a) from about 76% to about 95% percent by weight of HFO-1234yf; and54907-6102-3658, v. 1b) from about 5% by weight to about 24% by weight of a second component selected from the group consisting essentially of R1336mzzE.For the purpose of convenience, coolants according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Coolant 3A3A.
[0015] The present invention includes coolants for two-phase pumped cooling of electronics consisting essentially of:a) from about 76% to about 95% percent by weight of HFO-1234yf; andb) from about 5% by weight to about 24% by weight of a second component selected from the group consisting essentially of R1336mzzE.For the purpose of convenience, coolants according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Coolant 3A3B.
[0016] The present invention includes coolants for two-phase pumped cooling of electronics consisting of:a) from about 76% to about 95% percent by weight of HFO-1234yf; andb) from about 5% by weight to about 24% by weight of a second component selected from the group consisting essentially of R1336mzzE.For the purpose of convenience, coolants according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Coolant 3A3C.
[0017] The present invention includes coolants for two-phase pumped cooling of electronics comprising:a) from about 52% to about 92% percent by weight of HFO-1234yf;b) from about 4% by weight to about 23% by weight of a second component selected from the group consisting essentially of R125, R227ea, R1132E, R134a, R161 and R152a; and c) from about 4% by weight to about 25% by weight of a third component that is not the same as said selected first component or said selected second component and which is selected from the group consisting of R1336mzzE, R161 and R152a.64907-6102-3658, v. 1For the purpose of convenience, coolants according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Coolant 3B1
[0018] The present invention includes coolants for two-phase pumped cooling of electronics comprising:a) from about 52% to about 92% percent by weight of HFO-1234yf;b) from about 4% by weight to about 23% by weight of a second component selected from the group consisting essentially of R125, R227ea, R134a, R161 and R152a; and c) from about 4% by weight to about 25% by weight of R1336mzzE.For the purpose of convenience, coolants according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Coolant 3B2.
[0019] The present invention includes coolants for two-phase pumped cooling of electronics comprising:a) from about 70% to about 80% percent by weight of HFO-1234yf;b) from about 10% by weight of R134a; andc) from about 10% by weight to about 20% by weight of R1336mzzE.For the purpose of convenience, coolants according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Coolant 3B3A.
[0020] The present invention includes coolants for two-phase pumped cooling of electronics consisting essentially of:a) from about 70% to about 80% percent by weight of HFO-1234yf;b) from about 10% by weight of R134a; andc) from about 10% by weight to about 20% by weight of R1336mzzE.For the purpose of convenience, coolants according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Coolant 3B3B.
[0021] The present invention includes coolants for two-phase pumped cooling of electronics consisting of:74907-6102-3658, v. 1a) from about 70% to about 80% percent by weight of HFO- 1234yf;b) from about 10% by weight of R134a; andc) from about 10% by weight to about 20% by weight of R1336mzzE.For the purpose of convenience, coolants according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Coolant 3B3C.
[0022] The present invention includes coolants for two-phase pumped cooling of electronics comprising:a) from about 52% to about 68% percent by weight of HFO- 1234yf;b) from about 10% by weight to about 23% by weight of R152a; andc) from about 22% by weight to about 25% by weight of R1336mzzE.For the purpose of convenience, coolants according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Coolant 3B4A.
[0023] The present invention includes coolants for two-phase pumped cooling of electronics consisting essentially of:a) from about 52% to about 68% percent by weight of HFO- 1234yf;b) from about 10% by weight to about 23% by weight of R152a; andc) from about 22% by weight to about 25% by weight of R1336mzzE.For the purpose of convenience, coolants according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Coolant 3B4B.
[0024] The present invention includes coolants for two-phase pumped cooling of electronics consisting of:a) from about 52% to about 68% percent by weight of HFO-1234yf;b) from about 10% by weight to about 23% by weight of R152a; andc) from about 22% by weight to about 25% by weight of R1336mzzE.For the purpose of convenience, coolants according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Coolant 3B4C.84907-6102-3658, v. 1
[0025] The present invention includes coolants for two-phase pumped cooling of electronics comprising:a) from about 74% to about 92% percent by weight of HFO-1234yf;b) from about 4% by weight of R227ea; andc) from about 4% by weight to about 22% by weight of R1336mzzE.For the purpose of convenience, coolants according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Coolant 3B5 .
[0026] The present invention includes coolants for two-phase pumped cooling of electronics consisting essentially of:a) from about 74% to about 92% percent by weight of HFO-1234yf;b) from about 4% by weight of R227ea; andc) from about 4% by weight to about 22% by weight of R1336mzzE.For the purpose of convenience, coolants according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Coolant 3B5B.
[0027] The present invention includes coolants for two-phase pumped cooling of electronics consisting of:a) from about 74% to about 92% percent by weight of HFO-1234yf;b) from about 4% by weight of R227ea; andc) from about 4% by weight to about 22% by weight of R1336mzzE.For the purpose of convenience, coolants according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Coolant 3B5C.
[0028] The present invention includes coolants for two-phase pumped cooling of electronics comprising:a) from about 53% to about 96% percent by weight of HFO-1234ze(E); and94907-6102-3658, v. 1b) from about 4% by weight to about 42% by weight of a second component selected from the group consisting essentially of R-1234yf, R125, R227ea, R1132E, R1336mzzE, R134a, R161 and R152a.For the purpose of convenience, coolants according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Coolant 4A1.
[0029] The present invention includes coolants for two-phase pumped cooling of electronics comprising:a) from about 58% to about 95% percent by weight of HFO-1234ze(E); andb) from about 5% by weight to about 42% by weight of R1336mzzE.For the purpose of convenience, coolants according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Coolant 4A2A.
[0030] The present invention includes coolants for two-phase pumped cooling of electronics consisting essentially of:a) from about 58% to about 95% percent by weight of HFO-1234ze(E); andb) from about 5% by weight to about 42% by weight of R1336mzzE.For the purpose of convenience, coolants according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Coolant 4A2B.
[0031] The present invention includes coolants for two-phase pumped cooling of electronics consisting of:a) from about 58% to about 95% percent by weight of HFO-1234ze(E); andb) from about 5% by weight to about 42% by weight of R1336mzzE.For the purpose of convenience, coolants according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Coolant 4A2C.
[0032] The present invention includes coolants for two-phase pumped cooling of electronics comprising:a) from about 67% to about 80% percent by weight of HFO-1234ze(E);b) about 10% by weight of R-1234yf; and104907-6102-3658, v. 1c) from about 10% by weight to about 23% by weight of a third component selected from R134a, R161 and R152a4.For the purpose of convenience, coolants according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Coolant 4B1.
[0033] The present invention includes coolants for two-phase pumped cooling of electronics comprising:a) from about 53% to about 92% percent by weight of HFO-1234ze(E);b) about 10% by weight of R134a; andc) from about 10% by weight to about 30% by weight of R1336mzzE.For the purpose of convenience, coolants according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Coolant 4C1A.
[0034] The present invention includes coolants for two-phase pumped cooling of electronics consisting essentially of:a) from about 53% to about 92% percent by weight of HFO-1234ze(E);b) about 10% by weight of R134a; andc) from about 10% by weight to about 30% by weight of R1336mzzE.For the purpose of convenience, coolants according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Coolant 4C1B.
[0035] The present invention includes coolants for two-phase pumped cooling of electronics consisting of:a) from about 53% to about 92% percent by weight of HFO-1234ze(E);b) about 10% by weight of R134a; andc) from about 10% by weight to about 30% by weight of R1336mzzE.For the purpose of convenience, coolants according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Coolant 4C1C.114907-6102-3658, v. 1
[0036] The present invention includes coolants for two-phase pumped cooling of electronics comprising:a) from about 53% to about 71% percent by weight of HFO-1234ze(E);b) about 10% by weight to about 20% by weight of R152a; andc) from about 10% by weight to about 32% by weight of R1336mzzE.For the purpose of convenience, coolants according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Coolant 4D1A.
[0037] The present invention includes coolants for two-phase pumped cooling of electronics consisting essentially of:a) from about 53% to about 71% percent by weight of HFO-1234ze(E);b) about 10% by weight to about 20% by weight of R152a; andc) from about 10% by weight to about 32% by weight of R1336mzzE.For the purpose of convenience, coolants according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Coolant 4D1B.
[0038] The present invention includes coolants for two-phase pumped cooling of electronics consisting of:a) from about 53% to about 71% percent by weight of HFO-1234ze(E);b) about 10% by weight to about 20% by weight of R152a; andc) from about 10% by weight to about 32% by weight of R1336mzzE.For the purpose of convenience, coolants according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Coolant 4D1C.
[0039] The present invention includes coolants for two-phase pumped cooling of electronics comprising:a) from about 73% to about 72% percent by weight of HFO-1234ze(E);b) about 4% by weight of R227ea; andc) from about 4% by weight to about 23% by weight of R1336mzzE.124907-6102-3658, v. 1For the purpose of convenience, coolants according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Coolant 4E1A.
[0040] The present invention includes coolants for two-phase pumped cooling of electronics consisting essentially of:a) from about 73% to about 72% percent by weight of HFO-1234ze(E);b) about 4% by weight of R227ea; andc) from about 4% by weight to about 23% by weight of R1336mzzE.For the purpose of convenience, coolants according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Coolant 4E1B.
[0041] The present invention includes coolants for two-phase pumped cooling of electronics consisting of:c) from about 73% to about 92% percent by weight of HFO-1234ze(E);d) about 4% by weight of R227ea; ande) from about 4% by weight to about 23% by weight of R1336mzzE.For the purpose of convenience, coolants according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Coolant 4E1C.
[0042] The present invention includes coolants for two-phase pumped cooling of electronics comprising:a) from about 50% to about 96% percent by weight of a first component selected from HFO-1234yf or 1234ze(E); andb) from about 4% by weight to about 55% by weight of a second component selected from the group consisting essentially of R125, R227ea, R1132E, R1336mzzE, R134a. R161, R 152a and combinations of two or more of these,wherein said coolant has a bubble point at 150 psi of from about 29°C to about 60°C. For the purpose of convenience, coolants according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Coolant 5.
[0043] The present invention includes heat transfer systems for cooling electronic components comprising:134907-6102-3658, v. 1a) an electronic component;b) a fluid flow path bringing coolant into heat transfer contact with said electronic component;c) a liquid coolant in said flow path for removing heat from said electronic component by latent heat transfer in which at least a portion of liquid coolant in heat transfer contact with said electronic component is vaporized to form coolant vapor, wherein said coolant is a coolant according to any of Coolant 1 -6; andd) a heat exchanger that is: (1) fluidly connected to said coolant vapor; and (2) fluidly connected to a supply of heat sink fluid at a temperature below the condensing temperature of said coolant vapor for absorbing heat from said coolant vapor by condensing said coolant vapor to produce condensed coolant liquid: ande) a pump or thermosyphon receiving said condensed coolant liquid and moving said condensed coolant liquid into heat transfer contact with said electronic component.For the purpose of convenience, heat transfer systems according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Heat Transfer System 1A.
[0044] The present invention includes heat transfer systems for cooling electronic components comprising:a) an electronic component;b) a cold plate thermally connected to said electronic component;c) a liquid coolant fluidly connected to said cold plate for removing heat from said electronic component by latent heat transfer in which at least a portion of liquid coolant entering said cold plate is vaporized to form coolant vapor, wherein said coolant is a coolant according to any of Coolant 1 - 6; andd) a cooling water heat exchanger that is: (1) fluidly connected to said cold plate for receiving coolant vapor from said cooling plate; and (2) fluidly connected to a supply of cooling water for absorbing heat from said coolant vapor by condensing said coolant vapor to produce condensed coolant liquid; and144907-6102-3658, v. 1e) a pump for receiving said condensed coolant liquid and pumping said condensed coolant liquid to said cold plate.For the purpose of convenience, heat transfer systems according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Heat Transfer System 1.
[0045] The present invention includes improved methods of cooling operating electronic components by exposing said electronic component, directly or indirectly, to a coolant liquid under pressure for removing heat therefrom by vaporization of said coolant liquid, said improvement comprising:a) said coolant liquid being a coolant according to any of Coolant 1 - 64, wherein at least a portion of said coolant liquid is vaporized by absorbing heat from said electronic component; andb) removing heat from said vaporized liquid by condensing said vapor by heat transfer contact with a heat sink fluid.For the purpose of convenience, heat transfer systems according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Heat Transfer Method 1A.
[0046] The present invention includes improved methods of cooling operating electronic components of the type having a cold plate for receiving coolant liquid under pressure for removing heat therefrom by vaporization of said coolant liquid, said improvement comprising:a) said coolant liquid being a coolant according to any of Coolant 1 - 6, wherein at least a portion of said coolant liquid is vaporized by absorbing heat transmitted from said electronic component through said cold plate; andb) removing heat from said vaporized liquid by condensing said vapor by heat transfer contact with cooling water.For the purpose of convenience, heat transfer systems according to this paragraph are referred to herein as Heat Transfer Method IB.154907-6102-3658, v. 1BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0047] Figure 1 is a schematic representation of a heat transfer system of the present invention able to perform heat transfer methods of the present invention.
[0048] Figure 2 is a generalized representation of a heat transfer system of the present invention able to perform heat transfer methods of the present invention.DEFINITIONS:
[0049] The terms HFO-1234ze(E), “R-1234ze(E)”, 1234zeE, and transR-1234ze each mean the trans isomer of 1,3,3,3-tetrafluoropropene.
[0050] The terms HFO-1234yf, “R-1234yf” and 1234yf means 2,3,3,3-tetrafluoropropene.
[0051] The terms “R-1336mzz(E)”, 1336mzzE, and transR-1336mzz each mean the trans isomer of 1 , 1 , 1 ,4,4,4-hexafluorobut-2-ene.
[0052] The terms “R-l 132(E)”, “1132(E)” and “transHFO- 1132(E)” each means the trans isomer of 1,2-difluorethylene.
[0053] The terms “R-161”, 161, and “HFC-161” as used herein each means fluoroethane.
[0054] The terms “R-152a”, 152a, and “HFC-152a” as used herein each mean 1,1 -difluoroethane.
[0055] The terms “R-l 34a”, 134a, and “HFC-134a” as used herein each means 1.1.1,2-tetrafluoroethane.
[0056] The terms “R-125”, 125, and “HFC-125” means pentafluoroethane.
[0057] The terms “R-227ea”, 227ea, and “HFC-227ea” each mean 1, 1,1, 2, 3,3,3-heptafluoropropane.
[0058] As used herein, the term “pumped cooling” means cooling systems in which liquid coolant is moved from the condenser to the evaporator by a mechanical or thermosyphon pump.
[0059] As used herein, the terms “direct-to-chip cooling" and “D2C cooling” mean cooling in which a cold-plate that touches and is in thermal communication with the surface of the chip to be cooled and liquid coolant passes through channel(s) in the cold plate to remove heat from the chip as heat moves from the operating chip to the material of the cold plate and then to the coolant, which is pumped through a coolant circuit.164907-6102-3658, v. 1
[0060] As the term is used herein, “cold plate” is used in its broadest sense to mean a heat exchange device which is mechanically and thermally connected to at least a portion of an electronic component and which during operation thermally conducts heat from said operating electronic component to a liquid coolant in thermal contact with at least a portion of said cold plate .
[0061] As the term is used herein, “two-phase cold plate” is used in its broadest sense to mean a heat exchange device which is mechanically and thermally connected to at least a portion of an electronic component, and which thermally conducts heat from said operating electronic component by vaporizing at least a portion of a liquid coolant in thermal contact with said two-phase cold plate.
[0062] As used herein, the terms “thermal communication” and “thermal contact” between a first body, fluid, surface or the like and a second body, fluid, surface or the like means that the first body, fluid, surface or the like and the second body, fluid, surface or the like are separated, if at all, only by thermally conductive materials so as to permit ready transfer of heat from the first body, fluid, surface or the like to the second body, fluid, surface or the like as is well understood by those skilled in the art.
[0063] As used herein, the term “coolant operating temperature range” refers to a temperature range that encompasses the evaporating temperature of the coolant in a two-phase cold plate. Thus, for example, a two-phase cold plate that is said to have an operating temperature range of from 60°C - 75 °C means that during normal operation the coolant liquid is evaporating at a temperature in the range of from about 60°C - 75°C at least during a portion of the time that the electronic component is being cooled.
[0064] The phrase “Global Warming Potential” (herein abbreviated as “GWP”) was developed to allow comparisons of the global warming impact of different gases. It compares the amount of heat trapped by a certain mass of a gas to the amount of heat trapped by a similar mass of carbon dioxide over a specific time period of time. Carbon dioxide was chosen by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) as the reference gas and its GWP is taken as 1. The larger GWP, the more that a given gas warms the Earth compared to CO2 over that time period. As used herein, the term GWP means the value of GWP as measured in accordance with IPCC Fourth174907-6102-3658, v. 1Assessment Report, 20141, referred to and abbreviated herein as AR4, except for components that did not have a GWP value measured in AR4 (such as R1233zd(E) and R1234ze(E)), then the values used are according to the Fifth Assessment Report.
[0065] The phrase “acceptable toxicity” as used herein means the composition is classified as class “A” by ASHRAE Standard 34-2016 Designation and Safety Classification of Refrigerants and described in Appendix Bl to ASHRAE Standard 34-2016 (as each standard exists as of the filing date of this application). A substance which is flammable and has acceptable-toxicity, would be classified as “A3” by ASHRAE Standard 34-2016 Designation and Safety Classification of Refrigerants and described in Appendix B 1 to ASHRAE Standard 34-2016 (as each standard exists as of the filing date of this application).
[0066] As used herein, the term “about” in relation to the amount expressed in weight percent means that the amount of the component can vary by an amount of + / - 10% on a relative basis by weight. Thus, if an amount is described as being “about 10 wt. %,” then it is intended to cover amounts of 10 wt.% + / - 1 wt.%, and if an amount is described as being “about 20 wt. %,” then it is intended to cover amounts of 20 wt. % + / - 2 wt. %, etc.
[0067] As used herein, reference to a group of defined coolants, heat transfer methods and heat transfer systems means each and every one included within the defined group. Thus, for example, reference to “each of Coolants 1 - 3” is intended to refer separately to each of coolants 1, 2, 3A1, 3A2A, 3A2B, 3A2C, 3A3A, 3A3B, 3A3C, 3B1, 3B2, 3B3A, 3B3B, 3B3C, 3B4A, 3B4B, 3B5A, 3B5B and 3B5C.1Myhre, G., D. Shindell, F.-M. Breon, W. Collins, J. Fuglestvedt, J. Huang, D. Koch, J.-F. Lamarque, D. Lee, B. Mendoza, T. Nakajima, A. Robock, G. Stephens, T. Takemura and H. Zhang, 2013: Anthropogenic and Natural Radiative Forcing. In: Climate Change 2013: The Physical Science Basis. Contribution of Working Group I to the Fifth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change [Stocker, T.F., D. Qin, G.-K. Plattner, M. Tignor, S.K. Allen, J. Boschung, A. Nauels, Y. Xia, V. Bex and P.M. Midgley (eds.)] . Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, United Kingdom and New York, NY, USA.https: / / www.ipcc.ch / pdf / assessmentreport / ar5 / wgl / WGlAR5_Chapter08_FINAL.pdf (p. 73-79)184907-6102-3658, v. 1DETAILED DESCRIPTIONCOOLANTS
[0068] Applicants have unexpectedly found that certain unmet needs of the prior art and / or unexpected advantages can be achieved by the coolants of the present invention, including each of Coolants 1 - 5. Applicants have found that 41 coolant compositions (identified in first column of Table 1 below by Coolant Nos. 6-3 through 6-43) of the present invention and / or useful in the methods and / or systems of the present invention (Coolant Nos. 6-1, 6-2 and 6-44) can provide particular advantage in the two-phase cold plate cooling methods of the present invention, including Heat Transfer Method 1, and when used in two-phase cooling systems of the present invention, including Heat Transfer System 1. The reference in column 2 of Table 1 to “CEO” means that the defined coolant “consists essentially of’ the indicated components in the indicated amounts and “CO” means that the defined coolant “consists of’ the indicated components in the indicated amounts. The reference “-” in a column for a component means that the component is not required to be present but may be present. For efficient use of space, the preceding “R” in the component designation has been omitted in Table 1.Coolant CEO Component, wt.% of CoolantorNo. 1234yf 1234ze(E) 1336mzzE 1132E 152a 134a 161 227ea 125 CO6-1A CEO 100 - - - - - - - - 6-1B CO 100 - - - - - - - - 6-2A CEO - 100 - - - - - - - 6-2B CEO - 100 - - - - - - - 6-3A CEO 89 - - 11 - - - - - 6-3B CO 89 - - 11 - - - - - 6-4A CEO 95 - - 5 - - - - - 6-4B CO 95 - - 5 - - - - - 6-5A CEO 76 - 24 - - - - - - 6-5B CO 76 - 24 - - - - - - 6-6A CEO 95 - 5 - - - - - - 6-6B CO 95 - 5 - - - - - - 6-7A CEO 77 - - - 23 - - - -194907-6102-3658, v. 1Coolant CEO Component, wt.% of CoolantorNo. 1234yf 1234ze(E) 1336mzzE 1132E 152a 134a 161 227ea 125 CO6-7B CO 77 - - - 23 - - - - 6-8A CEO 90 - - - - 10 - - - 6-8B CO 90 - - - - 10 - - - 6-9A CEO 89 - - - - - 11 - - 6-9B CO 89 - - - - - 11 - - 6-10A CEO - 93 - 7 - - - - - 6-1 OB CO - 93 - 7 - - - - - 6-11A CEO 58 42 - - - - - - 6-11B CO 58 42 - - - - - - 6-12A CEO 95 5 - - - - - - 6-12B CO 95 5 - - - - - - 6-13A CEO - 77 - - 23 - - - - 6-13B CO - 77 - - 23 - - - - 6-14A CEO 90 - - - 10 - - - 6-14B CO 90 - - - 10 - - - 6-15A CEO 89 - - - - 11 - - 6-15B CO 89 - - - - 11 - - 6-16A CEO - 96 - - - - - - 4 6-16B CO - 96 - - - - - - 4 6-17A CEO 96 - - - - - - 4 6-17B CO 96 - - - - - - 4 6-18A CEO - 96 - - - - - 4 - 6-18B CO - 96 - - - - - 4 - 6-19A CEO 96 - - - - - - 4 - 6-19B CO 96 - - - - - - 4 - 6-20A CEO 71 - - 15 14 - - - - 6-20B CO 71 - - 15 14 - - - - 6-21A CEO 70 - 20 - - 10 - - -204907-6102-3658, v. 1Coolant CEO Component, wt.% of CoolantorNo. 1234yf 1234ze(E) 1336mzzE 1132E 152a 134a 161 227ea 125 CO6-21B CO 70 - 20 - - 10 - - - 6-22A CEO 80 - 10 - - 10 - - - 6-22B CO 80 - 10 - - 10 - - - 6-23A CEO 79 - - - - 10 11 - - 6-23B CO 79 - - - - 10 11 - - 6-24A CEO 52 - 25 - 23 - - - - 6-24B CO 52 - 25 - 23 - - - - 6-25A CEO 68 - 22 - 10 - - - - 6-25B CO 68 - 22 - 10 - - - - 6-26A CEO 72 - 17 - - - 11 - - 6-26B CO 72 - 17 - - - 11 - - 6-27A CEO 71 - - 10 19 - - - - 6-27B CO 71 - - 10 19 - - - - 6-28A CEO - 71 - 10 19 - - - - 6-28B CO - 71 - 10 19 - - - - 6-29A CEO 10 80 - - - 10 - - - 6-29B CO 10 80 - - - 10 - - - 6-30A CEO 10 67 - - 23 - - - - 6-30B CO 10 67 - - 23 - - - - 6-31 A CEO 10 79 - - - - 11 - - 6-3 IB CO 10 79 - - - - 11 - - 6-32A CEO - 60 30 - - 10 - - - 6-32B CO - 60 30 - - 10 - - - 6-33A CEO - 80 10 - - 10 - - - 6-33B CO - 80 10 - - 10 - - - 6-34A CEO - 80 - - - 10 10 - - 6-34B CO - 80 - - - 10 10 - - 6-35A CEO - 53 32 - 15 - - - -214907-6102-3658, v. 1Coolant CEO Component, wt.% of CoolantorNo. 1234yf 1234ze(E) 1336mzzE 1132E 152a 134a 161 227ea 125 CO6-35B CO - 53 32 - 15 - - - - 6-36A CEO - 70 10 - 20 - - - - 6-36B CO - 70 10 - 20 - - - - 6-37A CEO - 71 19 - 10 - - - - 6-37B CO - 71 19 - 10 - - - - 6-38A CEO 78- 18 - - - - - 4 6-38B CO 78- 18 - - - - - 4 6-39A CEO - 70 26 - - - - - 4 6-39B CO - 70 26 - - - - - 4 6-40A CEO - 73 23 - - - - 4 - 6-40B CO - 73 23 - - - - 4 - 6-41A CEO - 92 4 - - - - 4 - 6-4 IB CO - 92 4 - - - - 4 - 6-42A CEO 74 - 22 - - - - 4 - 6-42B CO 74 - 22 - - - - 4 - 6-43A CEO 92 - 4 - - - - 4 - 6-43B CO 92 - 4 - - - - 4 - 6-44A CEO - 91 - - - - - 9 - 6-44B CO - 91 - - - - - 9 -HEAT TRANSFER SYSTEMS
[0069] It is contemplated that while the coolants of the present invention, including each of Coolants 1 - 6, may be used to advantage in many heat transfer applications. Applicants have found that the coolants of the present invention have significant and unexpected advantage in connection with pumped, two-phase on-chip cooling of operating electronic components, including of the type illustrated schematically in Figure 1. As is known, pumped, two-phase on-chip cooling systems comprise the use of relatively low power liquid pump(s) 20 to transport coolant in the liquid phase, typically preferably supplied from an accumulator 10, to deliver the224907-6102-3658, v. 1liquid coolant to an electronic component that generates heat during operation. As is known, this heat of operation is frequently significant and must be removed from many electronic components, including particularly microchips, for those components to operate effectively, efficiently and reliably. Two-phase systems are arranged with appropriate piping / tubing / valving and controls to bring the liquid coolant safely into thermal contact with the operating electronic component. One particularly useful device for achieving appropriate and effective thermal contact is a cold plate, which is a device that is typically mounted in heat transfer contact with the electronic component. The cold plate includes heat transfer surface(s) that are designed to contact the liquid coolant and transfer heat from the operating electronic component to the liquid coolant. Alternatively, the coolant may come in direct contact with the electronic component such that heat is transferred directly to the coolant, resulting in vaporization of the coolant. Examples of such direct contact systems include spraying the coolant directly onto the chip, or the use of convective boiling mechanisms such as parallel flow, cross flow, impingement and capillary flow. Of course, any given system of the present invention can use of combination of any two or more of these techniques to effect vaporization of the coolants of the present invention, including each of Coolant 1 - 6.
[0070] A thermosyphon system can be used instead of (or in addition to) the pump 20 to move the coolant of the present invention, including each of Coolant 1 -6, through the cooling circuit. As is known, a thermosyphon system uses gravity to move (or help move) liquid coolant from the heat exchanger as shown in Figure 1 to the electronic component, and in such case the electronic component to be cooled must be physically located below the condenser. In such a case, an accumulator 10 is still preferably used but pump 20 is not required and / or pump 20 can be used to supplement the thermosyphon.
[0071] The coolants of the present invention facilitate removal of this heat of operation as a result of a substantial portion of the liquid coolant which enters the cold plate undergoing a phase change to the vapor state. This coolant vapor, together with unvaporized liquid coolant, leaves the cold plate and is delivered appropriate piping / tubing / valving and controls, to a coolant condenser. The coolant condenser is a heat exchanger which is connected to a cooling fluid source, preferably cooling water provided by a cooling tower or a chiller, that absorbs heat from the coolant and condenses the vapor back to liquid, where is available to returned to the pump 20 via accumulator 10.234907-6102-3658, v. 1
[0072] Although Figure 1 illustrates a single cold plate and a single electronic component, it will be appreciated by those skilled in the art that the systems of the present invention are most frequently used to cool multiple electronic components. In such systems, a liquid coolant distribution system, illustrated schematically as 30, is provided for directing multiple paths of coolant flow through appropriate piping / tubing / valving and controls to direct the desired amount of coolant to a large number of electronic component / cold plate, and a vaporous coolant removal system illustrated schematically as 40, is provided for directing multiple paths of vaporous coolant, through appropriate piping / tubing / valving and controls, to the coolant condenser. Many examples of such systems are known and are described, for example in each of US 2024 / 0098945, US 2024 / 0365513 and US Patent 10,563,937, each of which is incorporated herein by reference.
[0073] For example, Figure 2 is a reproduced from US 2024 / 0098945 and illustrates a data center infrastructure layer that includes grouped computing resources, and a cooling system described therein. In such a data center infrastructure, grouped computing resources 214, which may include M racks 3802(l)-3802(M), include electronic components to be cooled. Each rack may house one or more of the node C.R.s 216(1)-216(N), with the groups of node C.R.s 216 that is housed within the respective racks 3802(l)-3802(M) being indicated as node CRs 3804(l)-3804(M). The node CRs 3804 may include any appropriate type of computing resource, at any level of granularity. For example, the node CRs 3804 may be considered as being servers, each of which may include multiple processors. In another example, the node CRs 3804 may be considered to be individual processors. Each of the node CRs 3804 may be separately cooled and may furthermore be selectively enabled. Thus, as workloads within the data center change, individual resources among the node CRs 3804 may be turned on and off according to the disclosed system.
[0074] Further, each rack 3802 includes a respective cooling module 3806. The cooling modules 3806 can distribute liquid coolant, including each of Coolants 1 - 6 of the present invention, within the rack 3802, and may include any appropriate manifolds, piping, pumps, heat sinks, valves, and coolant that may be used to cool the computing resources of the respective node CRs 3804 in the rack 3802. Thus, each of the racks 3802 in the grouped computing resources 214 has its own internal cooling system implemented by the respective cooling module 3806. Coolant in each cooling module 3806 circulates within the respective rack 3802, but is exchanged with a cooling system 3810 that is in fluid communication with the racks 3802.244907-6102-3658, v. 1
[0075] As coolants of the present invention, including Coolants 1 - 6, circulate within a given rack 3802, it takes waste heat from the node CRs 3804. The amount of coolant flow that is needed to cool a rack 3802 will depend on the number of node CRs 3804 that are enabled within the rack. As node CRs 3804 are disabled, for example because they are not needed to process a given workload, coolant circulation to the disabled node CRs 3804 may be turned off.
[0076] When coolant which has absorbed heat from rack 3802, for example as a mixture of gaseous coolant and liquid coolant, the coolant may enter a cooling manifold, where it may combine with warm coolant from other racks 3802. The warm coolant passes from the cooling manifold 3812 to a coolant distribution unit (CDU) 3816. The CDU 3816 manages heat exchange between the coolant from the cooling manifold 3812 and a secondary cooling fluid, such as cooling water supplied by a cooling tower or chiller, within a heat rejector 3818, for example a coolant condenser as described in connection with Figure 1 where the coolant of the present invention that has absorbed heat from the racks 3802 leaves the cooling manifold 3812 and in the condenser / heat rejector transfers heat to the secondary cooling fluid. The two-phase coolant, including Coolants 1 - 6, condenses in the condenser into a single liquid phase, and the CDU 3816 returns the condensed coolant of the present invention, including Coolants 1 -6, back to the cooling manifold, where it may pass along a separate cool coolant path to the cooling modules 3806. The cooling modules of the present invention preferably comprise a cold plate associated with one or more electronic components to be cooled.
[0077] It is noted that the cold plates may produce a range of vapor quality values for two-phase coolant of the present invention, including Coolants 1 - 6, that provide the best performance for a particular electronic component to be cooled. Coolant flow may be managed to ensure that the electronic component(s) operate within a predetermined temperature range, including below a maximum operating temperature, or to maintain a pressure drop within a predetermined pressure difference range, to prevent coolant dry-out where the coolant evaporates completely at the cold plate, and to maintain vapor quality of the coolant output within a predetermined vapor quality range.HEAT TRANSFER METHODS
[0078] The present methods, including Heat Transfer Method 1, use coolants of the present invention, including Coolants 1 - 6, that absorb heat from the operating electronic component by254907-6102-3658, v. 1changing the phase of the coolant from the liquid phase to a gaseous phase. The coolant leaving the electronic component, which can comprise both gaseous phase and liquid phase coolant, is directed to a condenser where a heat sink fluid supplied at a temperature below the condensing temperature of the coolant is provided. This heat sink fluid causes the gaseous phase coolant to condense, thereby producing liquid refrigerant that can then be circulated, for example by one or more pumps, back to the electronic component(s). The proportion of gaseous coolant to the total coolant mass that exits the cold plate may be characterized as the vapor quality.
[0079] The quality of the coolant exiting the cold plate may vary according to the needs of a particular electronic component or group of electronic components, and all such quality values are within the scope of the present invention.
[0080] With respect to the operating temperature of the electronic component(s), including particularly microprocessors, it is frequently the case that as the temperature of the microprocessor increases, it consumes more power to provide the same performance. In air cooling systems, it is common for fully utilized microprocessors to operate at or near their maximum rated temperature. Providing a consistently lower operating temperature for the microprocessor, preferably in the range of from about 40°C to about 60°C according to the present invention, can also extend its useful life and can avoid unnecessary throttling (dynamic frequency scaling) or downtime of the computer. In at least some embodiments, the vapor quality of the coolant leaving the cold plate is from about 50% to about 70%.
[0081] As will be appreciated, the ability to remove heat within the above noted preferred parameters is subject to certain constraints. For example, the bubble temperature of the refrigerant at the cold plate is a function of the pressure of the refrigerant at the cold plate, and this temperature will typically need to be at least about 5 °C below the maximum desired operating temperature of the electronic component to achieve sufficiently fast heat transfer. Further, the ability to remove the heat effectively from operating component is related to latent heat of vaporization, with the high the latent heat values being generally advantageous to rapid and effective heat removal.
[0082] It is further noted, however, that values of latent heat for a coolant are also a function of the pressure at which evaporation takes place, typically the pressure at the cooling plate, and in turn the pressure at the cooling plate is a function of other parameters of the system and method,264907-6102-3658, v. 1including the ratio of the liquid density to the vapor density at the pressure at which the coolant leaves the cold plate. Generally, higher ratios of liquid density to the vapor density are disadvantageous since the pressure drop increases as the coolant travels to the condenser
[0083] Another factor influencing the performance of the cooling system and methods is the source and temperature of the heat sink fluid used to condense the coolant vapor. In particular, warm water, which can be provided for example by a dry cooler and / or a cooling tower, is generally in the range of from about 35°C to about 45°C. Chilled water, which can be provided for example by a chiller, is generally in the range of from about 5 °C to about 35 °C. Of course, for any given system or method, a combination of any of these heat sink fluid sources could be used. Where it is available, cooling tower water is generally preferred since its cost of production is generally lower and since it requires less energy to produce than chiller cooling water. In contrast, chilled water is frequently produced by a vapor compression refrigeration system, which has a much higher cost and energy of production than cooling tower water. These heat sink fluid sources should be at least 5 °C lower than the condensing temperature of the coolant, although it will be appreciated that this temperature difference may be lower in embodiments in which a high efficiency heat exchanger is used to condense the coolant. . The following Table 2 provides a listing of preferred coolants to be used for certain operating conditions of the present systems and methods. In the following table, the entry “any” in the column for the heat sink fluid (including combinations of different heat sink fluids) can be used. For example, the fluid may not be water in some cases and may be, for example, propylene glycol (such as PG25).TABLE 2Heat Sink Fluid Temperature Range, Coolant Max Operating Coolant Pressure atNo. Temperature, °C Cold Plate, psia Fluid Fluid Temperature Range, °C 1 95 50 - 200 Any 5 -45 2 95 50 - 200 Any 5 -45 3A1 95 50 - 200 Any 5 -45 3A2A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 -45 3A2B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 -45 3A2C 95 50 - 200 Any 5 -45 3A3A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 -453A3B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 -45274907-6102-3658, v. 13A3C 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 3B 1 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 3B2 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 3B3A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 3B3B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 3B3C 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 3B4A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 3B4B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 3B4C 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 3B5A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 3B5B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 3B5C 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 4A1 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 4A2A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 4A2B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 4A2C 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 4B 1 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 4C1A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 4C1B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 4C1C 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 4D1A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 4D1B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 4D1C 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 4E1A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 4E1B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 4E1C 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 5 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-1 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-1A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-1B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-2A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-2B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-3A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-3B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-4A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-4B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-5A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-5B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-6A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-6B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-7A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-7B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-8A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-8B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 456-9A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45284907-6102-3658, v. 16-9B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-10A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-10B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-11A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-11B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-12A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-12B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-13A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-13B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-14A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-14B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-15A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-15B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-16A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-16B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-17A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-17B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-18A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-18B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-19A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-19B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-20A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-20B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-21A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-21B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-22A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-22B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-23A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-23B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-24A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-24B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-25A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-25B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-26A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-26B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-27A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-27B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-28A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-28B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-29A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-29B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-30A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-30B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-31A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 456-31B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45294907-6102-3658, v. 16-32A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-32B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-33A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-33B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-34A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-34B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-35A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-35B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-36A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-36B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-37A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-37B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-38A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-38B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-39A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-39B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-40A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-40B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-41A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-41B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-42A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-42B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-43A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-43B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-44A 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 6-44B 95 50 - 200 Any 5 - 45 1 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 2 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 3A1 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 3A2A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 3A2B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 3A2C 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 3A3A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 3A3B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 3A3C 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 3B 1 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 3B2 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 3B3A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 3B3B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 3B3C 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 3B4A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 3B4B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 3B4C 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 3B5A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 453B5B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45304907-6102-3658, v. 13B5C 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 4A1 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 4A2A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 4A2B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 4A2C 95 50 - 200 Wann water 35 - 45 4B 1 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 4C1A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 4C1B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 4C1C 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 4D1A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 4D1B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 4D1C 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 4E1A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 4E1B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 4E1C 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 5 95 50 - 200 Warn water 35 - 45 6-1 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-1A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-1B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-2A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-2B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-3A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-3B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-4A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-4B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-5A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-5B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-6A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-6B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-7A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-7B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-8A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-8B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-9A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-9B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-10A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-1 OB 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-11A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-11B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-12A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-12B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-13A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-13B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-14A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 456-14B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45314907-6102-3658, v. 16-15A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-15B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-16A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-16B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-17A 95 50 - 200 Wann water 35 - 45 6-17B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-18A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-18B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-19A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-19B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-20A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-20B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-21A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-21B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-22A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-22B 95 50 - 200 Warn water 35 - 45 6-23A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-23B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-24A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-24B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-25A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-25B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-26A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-26B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-27A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-27B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-28A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-28B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-29A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-29B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-30A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-30B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-31A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-31B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-32A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-32B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-33A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-33B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-34A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-34B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-35A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-35B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-36A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-36B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 456-37A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45324907-6102-3658, v. 16-37B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-38A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-38B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-39A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-39B 95 50 - 200 Wann water 35 - 45 6-40A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-40B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-41A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-41B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-42A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-42B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-43A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-43B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-44A 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 6-44B 95 50 - 200 Warm water 35 - 45 1 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 2 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 3A1 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 3A2A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 3A2B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 3A2C 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 3A3A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 3A3B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 3A3C 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 3B 1 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 3B2 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 3B3A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 3B3B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 3B3C 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 3B4A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 3B4B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 3B4C 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 3B5A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 3B5B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 3B5C 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 4A1 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 4A2A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 4A2B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 4A2C 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 4B 1 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 4C1A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 4C1B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 4C1C 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 4D1A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 354D1B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35334907-6102-3658, v. 14D1C 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 4E1A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 4E1B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 4E1C 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 5 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-1 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-1A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-1B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-2A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-2B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-3A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-3B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-4A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-4B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-5A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-5B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-6A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-6B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-7A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-7B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-8A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-8B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-9A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-9B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-10A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-1 OB 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-11A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-11B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-12A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-12B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-13A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-13B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-14A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-14B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-15A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-15B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-16A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-16B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-17A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-17B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-18A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-18B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-19A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-19B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 356-20A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35344907-6102-3658, v. 16-20B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-21A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-21B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-22A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-22B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-23A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-23B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-24A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-24B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-25A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-25B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-26A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-26B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-27A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-27B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-28A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-28B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-29A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-29B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-30A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-30B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-31A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-31B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-32A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-32B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-33A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-33B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-34A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-34B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-35A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-35B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-36A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-36B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-37A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-37B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-38A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-38B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-39A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-39B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-40A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-40B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-41A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-41B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-42A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 356-42B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35354907-6102-3658, v. 16-43A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-43B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35 6-44A 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 356-44B 95 50 - 200 Chilled water 5 - 35EXAMPLES
[0084] Applicants have evaluated each of Coolants 6-1 through 6-44 and have determined the properties indicated in the following Coolant Property Tables at pressures of 75 psi, 100 psi, 150 psi and 200 psi.Coolant Property Table at 75 PSIALiquid / vaporLatent heat Bubble Point Liquid density Coolant No. density ratio at(J / g) at 75psia (°C) at 75psia at 75psia 75psia6-1B 152.71 15.4 48.7088 1.108 6-2B 166.00 26.2 46.2850 1.092 6-3B 169.96 5.3 46.4631 1.099 6-4B 161.35 10.1 45.9434 1.089 6-5B 152.11 20.1 45.9511 1.085 6-6B 152.70 16.3 46.3256 1.103 6-7B 180.92 14.9 46.5688 1.115 6-8B 155.40 14.8 45.9602 1.101 6-9B 177.08 12.4 45.3644 1.108 6-10B 178.53 18.3 43.6472 1.069 6-11B 154.50 34.1 43.5163 1.096 6-12B 164.90 27.0 44.0078 1.085 6-13B 192.62 23.1 44.9169 1.168 6-14B 168.05 24.5 43.2017 1.094 6-15B 191.02 21.3 43.2515 1.076 6-16B 166.15 24.5 43.2528 1.141 6-17B 152.83 14.2 43.1886 1.145 6-18B 163.67 26.2 42.8781 1.138 6-19B 151.12 15.8 43.1118 1.167 6-20B 191.60 4.3 42.7655 1.165 6-21B 155.41 18.5 42.6218 1.168 6-22B 155.55 16.6 42.4646 1.159 6-23B 179.70 11.9 42.6181 1.177 6-24B 180.67 19.3 42.2062 1.1646-25B 164.56 18.8 40.9767 1.126364907-6102-3658, v. 16-26B 177.39 14.8 42.1456 1.166 6-27B 191.16 7.6 41.9378 1.170 6-28B 203.83 14.8 41.0167 1.133 6-29B 166.83 22.7 41.3791 1.196 6-30B 191.27 21.5 41.7498 1.175 6-31B 189.54 19.6 41.1096 1.192 6-32B 161.01 29.3 40.7603 1.187 6-33B 165.98 26.0 40.0572 1.149 6-34B 190.62 20.0 39.9052 1.162 6-35B 175.61 28.4 40.1163 1.137 6-36B 186.99 24.6 39.6481 1.195 6-37B 173.25 27.2 39.2519 1.157 6-38B 152.87 17.4 39.4761 1.135 6-39B 160.18 28.6 39.2990 1.126 6-40B 158.05 30.2 39.2466 1.131 6-41B 162.80 26.9 38.8566 1.154 6-42B 150.55 20.1 39.1276 1.134 6-43B 151.12 16.5 39.0820 1.1396-44B 160.82 26.3 38.7079 1.160Coolant Property Table at 100 PSIALatent heat Liquid / vaporBubble Point Liquid density Coolant No. (J / g) at density ratio at(°C) at lOOpsia at lOOpsia lOOpsia lOOpsia6-1B 145.08 25.4 28.4621 1.091 6-2B 158.06 36.2 30.8621 1.125 6-3B 162.16 15.1 31.1843 1.104 6-4B 153.61 20.0 29.7680 1.099 6-5B 144.25 30.3 28.0774 1.118 6-6B 145.02 26.3 28.4093 1.096 6-7B 172.34 24.7 31.6988 1.037 6-8B 147.72 24.7 29.0723 1.101 6-9B 168.73 22.3 31.4414 1.044 6-10B 170.35 28.3 32.7169 1.134 6-11B 146.57 44.4 28.6835 1.158 6-12B 156.96 37.0 30.6593 1.129 6-13B 183.80 32.9 33.6987 1.060 6-14B 160.09 34.4 31.3433 1.134 6-15B 182.31 31.2 33.7662 1.0726-16B 158.24 34.4 30.9824 1.134374907-6102-3658, v. 16-17B 145.24 24.1 28.5995 1.099 6-18B 155.81 36.2 30.6218 1.132 6-19B 143.54 25.7 28.3327 1.099 6-20B 183.17 14.0 33.8660 1.068 6-21B 147.54 28.6 28.8692 1.126 6-22B 147.77 26.5 29.0026 1.113 6-23B 171.29 21.6 32.0061 1.053 6-24B 171.92 29.4 31.5506 1.063 6-25B 156.34 28.9 29.6610 1.091 6-26B 168.88 24.8 31.3656 1.061 6-27B 182.58 17.4 33.4614 1.054 6-28B 194.90 24.7 35.5446 1.077 6-29B 158.86 32.5 31.0782 1.131 6-30B 182.46 31.3 33.4377 1.058 6-31B 180.84 29.5 33.4877 1.069 6-32B 153.05 39.4 29.9963 1.160 6-33B 158.01 35.9 30.9556 1.143 6-34B 181.94 29.9 33.9442 1.084 6-35B 167.09 38.6 31.3803 1.107 6-36B 178.28 34.5 32.9932 1.076 6-37B 164.93 37.3 31.3590 1.112 6-38B 145.10 27.5 28.3891 1.120 6-39B 152.25 38.8 29.8061 1.157 6-40B 150.19 40.3 29.5447 1.151 6-41B 154.94 36.8 30.4586 1.136 6-42B 142.76 30.3 27.9694 1.124 6-43B 143.49 26.5 28.2879 1.1036-44B 153.05 36.2 30.3235 1.141Coolant Property Table at 150 PSIALatent heat Liquid / vaporBubble Point Liquid density Coolant No. (J / g) at density ratio at(°C) at 150psia at 150psia 150psia 150psia6-1B 131.69 40.6 17.5604 1.031 6-2B 144.29 51.4 19.1886 1.068 6-3B 148.50 30.3 19.4119 1.048 6-4B 140.04 35.3 18.4484 1.041 6-5B 130.52 46.0 17.2559 1.055 6-6B 131.55 41.6 17.5135 1.0366-7B 157.43 39.8 19.6836 0.983384907-6102-3658, v. 16-8B 134.27 39.8 17.9636 1.042 6-9B 154.16 37.4 19.5452 0.990 6-1 OB 156.20 43.7 20.4411 1.079 6-11B 132.80 60.4 17.6696 1.096 6-12B 143.20 52.3 19.0450 1.072 6-13B 168.58 48.1 21.0405 1.008 6-14B 146.29 49.6 19.5044 1.076 6-15B 167.27 46.4 21.1183 1.020 6-16B 144.51 49.7 19.2718 1.076 6-17B 131.92 39.3 17.6571 1.040 6-18B 142.16 51.5 19.0278 1.074 6-19B 130.24 41.0 17.4741 1.039 6-20B 168.51 28.9 21.1848 1.015 6-21B 133.83 44.0 17.7880 1.064 6-22B 134.18 41.8 17.8949 1.053 6-23B 156.64 36.6 19.9185 0.999 6-24B 156.76 44.8 19.5376 1.007 6-25B 142.02 44.5 18.3001 1.032 6-26B 154.09 40.2 19.4602 1.006 6-27B 167.65 32.4 20.8934 1.001 6-28B 179.54 39.8 22.2997 1.026 6-29B 145.06 47.7 19.3224 1.073 6-30B 167.25 46.5 20.8617 1.005 6-31B 165.82 44.8 20.9282 1.017 6-32B 139.25 55.1 18.5597 1.099 6-33B 144.21 51.2 19.2295 1.084 6-34B 166.99 45.0 21.2330 1.031 6-35B 152.37 54.2 19.4544 1.050 6-36B 163.26 49.8 20.5572 1.022 6-37B 150.52 52.7 19.4703 1.055 6-38B 131.51 43.1 17.4794 1.059 6-39B 138.49 54.5 18.4470 1.096 6-40B 136.53 55.9 18.2729 1.091 6-41B 141.29 52.2 18.9123 1.077 6-42B 129.15 45.9 17.1881 1.061 6-43B 130.13 41.8 17.4350 1.0436-44B 139.54 51.5 18.8283 1.0824907-6102-3658, v. 1Coolant Property Table at 200 PSI ALatent heat Liquid / vaporBubble Point Liquid density Coolant No. (J / g) at density ratio at(°C) at 200psia at 200psia 200psia 200psia6-1B 119.46 52.4 12.0824 0.979 6-2B 131.88 63.3 13.3187 1.018 6-3B 136.11 42.0 13.4939 0.999 6-4B 127.71 47.1 12.7599 0.990 6-5B 118.05 58.1 11.8295 1.000 6-6B 119.28 53.5 12.0416 0.984 6-7B 144.00 51.5 13.6511 0.936 6-8B 122.03 51.5 12.3825 0.990 6-9B 141.00 49.1 13.5626 0.943 6-10B 143.53 55.6 14.2694 1.030 6-1 IB 120.34 72.7 12.1414 1.040 6-12B 130.77 64.2 13.2067 1.021 6-13B 154.98 59.8 14.6815 0.963 6-14B 133.86 61.3 13.5528 1.026 6-15B 153.83 58.3 14.7555 0.975 6-16B 132.13 61.5 13.3837 1.026 6-17B 119.77 51.1 12.1584 0.988 6-18B 129.83 63.3 13.1980 1.024 6-19B 118.10 52.8 12.0179 0.986 6-20B 155.32 40.5 14.8110 0.970 6-21B 121.40 56.0 12.2306 1.010 6-22B 121.84 53.6 12.3202 1.000 6-23B 143.46 48.3 13.8403 0.952 6-24B 143.14 56.8 13.5161 0.958 6-25B 129.08 56.5 12.6040 0.980 6-26B 140.77 52.2 13.4812 0.958 6-27B 154.24 44.0 14.5792 0.956 6-28B 165.87 51.6 15.6440 0.982 6-29B 132.62 59.5 13.4138 1.023 6-30B 153.64 58.2 14.5450 0.960 6-31B 152.40 56.6 14.6107 0.971 6-32B 126.79 67.2 12.8187 1.045 6-33B 131.77 63.1 13.3381 1.033 6-34B 153.64 56.8 14.8398 0.985 6-35B 139.15 66.3 13.4707 0.999 6-36B 149.80 61.6 14.3128 0.9766-37B 137.58 64.7 13.5012 1.005404907-6102-3658, v. 16-38B 119.17 55.1 12.0067 1.005 6-39B 126.08 66.6 12.7432 1.042 6-40B 124.19 68.0 12.6119 1.037 6-41B 128.96 64.0 13.1079 1.026 6-42B 116.78 58.1 11.7810 1.006 6-43B 117.94 53.7 11.9841 0.9906-44B 127.34 63.3 13.0482 1.031Comparative Example I2- Use of HFO-1234yf, HFO-1234ze(E) and R515B For Data Center Cooling
[0085] A data center utilizes multiple chips including graphics processing units (GPUs) for an artificial intelligence application. Each GPU has a thermal design power (TDP) of 1.5 kW. Each server tray has a total power of 14 kW. Each server rack has a power density of 112 kW. Combination of cooling tower and chiller is used as primary heat rejection for the facility water system (FWS) in the data center based on the ambient air temperature. A two-phase direct-to-chip configuration is utilized for cooling of the high TDP chips, including GPUs, with an external two-phase coolant distribution unit (CDU) of the type generally illustrated in Figures 1 and 2 and in the patent documents incorporated herein by reference. The CDU has a liquid-to-liquid heat exchanger for condensation of the return line of the liquid-vapor refrigerant mixture and controlling the temperature and pressure of the system. The two server racks are connected to the two-phase CDU with refrigerant lines connected to a refrigerant tank with a capacity of 350 lbs. A two-phase direct-to-chip cold plate is installed on the GPUs and other high TDP chips. The two-phase cold plates operate at a pressure of about 150 psia. The low TDP components such as motherboard are cooled by air cooling available in the data center via cold aisle containment.
[0086] Each of 1234yf , 1234zeE and a mixture of 91 wt% 1234zeE and 9% 227ea (515B) are used in the system as the on-chip coolant fluid. Using 515B as the baseline operating coolant, the two-phase CDU has a cooling capacity of 250 kW and the following Table ExCi identifies the approximate relative amount of heat removed by the coolant fluid from the operating electronics for each of 1234zeE and 1234yf at a constant volumetric flow rate of refrigerant based on the heat removed by 515B as 100%.2The designation of an example as comparative is not an admission that the example represents prior art but instead is used only as a basis for comparison to preferred examples of the invention.414907-6102-3658, v. 1TABLE ExCiRelative % Example Coolant No. Component, wt% Heat Removed 1234zeE 1234yf 227eaExCIA 44 (515B) 91 — 9 100 ExClB 61-1 - 100 - 99 ExCIC 61-2 100 - - 105Example 1A - Use of Coolant 6-28 For Data Center Cooling to Obtain Higher levels of Heat Removal
[0087] Comparative Example 1 is repeated, except that Coolant 6-1 (including 6-1A and 6-1B) as identified in Table Exl below is used to provide cooling, and the heat removal results relative to the performance of 515B are reported.TABLE ExlCoolant Relative % Example Component, wt% Heat No.Removed 1234zeE 1132E 152a 227ea44ExCIA 91 — - 9 100(515B)Exl 61-28 100 10 19 - 122
[0088] The results of this example show that preferred coolants of the present invention provide an important and unexpected advantage in two-phase, direct-to-chip pumped cooling of electronic components, especially for cooling of electronics having a preferred operating temperature range below 50°C. For example, this result directly translates to lower junction to liquid thermal resistance due to more efficient heat transfer. The result shows the ability to provide lower silicon junction temperatures at 100% chip power utilization, which in turn improves reliability. Additionally, this result shows that it is possible to run the chips at higher computational performance by methods such as overclocking to gain extra computational benefits due to improved thermal budget. Furthermore, this advantageous result is provided by Coolant 6-28, which has an order of magnitude lower GWP compared to R515B and an a bubble temperature of4907-6102-3658, v. 139.8 °C at 150 psia, which is especially advantageous for cooling of electronics having operating temperature ranges that are below 85 °CExample IB - Use of Coolant 6-28 For Data Center Cooling to Obtain Higher levels of Heat Removal
[0089] Example 1A is repeated, except that a thermosyphon is used in place of the pump to move the coolant. Similar advantageous and unexpected results are achieved.Examples 2A-11A: Use of Preferred Coolants For Data Center Cooling to Obtain Higher levels of Heat Removal
[0090] Example 1 is repeated, except that each of the Coolants identified in Tables Ex2-11A and Ex2-11B below are used to provide cooling, and the heat removal results relative to the performance of 515B are reported.TABLE Ex2-11ACoolant Relative % Example Component, wt% Heat No.Removed 1234zeE 1234yf 1132E 152a 227ea 16144ExCIA 91 — — - 9 - 100 (515B)Ex2A 6-3 — 89 11 - - - 103 Ex3A 6-7 — 77 - 23 - - 102.5 Ex4A 6-9 - 89 - - - 11 101 Ex5A 6-10 93 - 7 - - 115 Ex6A 6-20 71 - 15 14 - - 113 Ex7A 6-27 - 71 10 19 - - 111 Ex8A 6-31 79 10 - - - 11 116.5TABLE Ex2-11BCoolant Relative Example Component, wt% % Heat No.Removed 1234yf 134a 1336mzzE 152a 227ea 161Ex9A 6-23 79 10 - - - 11 103.6434907-6102-3658, v. 1ExlOA 6-24 52 - 25 23 - - 104.5 ExllA 6-26 72 - 17 - - 11 102.6
[0091] The results of these examples show that preferred coolants of the present invention provide important and unexpected advantage in two-phase, direct-to-chip cooling of electronic components, especially for cooling of electronics having a preferred operating temperature range below 85°C since all of the inventive coolants in Table Ex2A and Ex2B have a bubble point of 45°C or less. In the addition, the other advantages describe in Example 1 are achievable with these coolants.Examples 2B - 11B - Use of Preferred Coolants For Data Center Cooling to Obtain Higher levels of Heat Removal
[0092] Examples 2A through 11A are repeated, except that a thermosyphon is used in place of the pump to move the coolant. Similar advantageous and unexpected results are achieved.Example 12A - Use of Coolant 6-15 For Data Center Cooling to Obtain Higher levels of Heat Removal
[0093] Comparative Example 1 is repeated, except that Coolant 6-15 (each of 6-15A and 16B) as identified in Table Exl2 below is used to provide cooling, and the heat removal results relative to the performance of 515B are reported.TABLE Exl2Coolant Relative % Example Component, wt% Heat No.Removed 1234ze(E) 161 227ea44ExCIA 91 - 9 100(515B)Exl2A 6-15 89 11 - 129.6
[0094] The results of this example show that preferred coolants of the present invention provide an important and unexpected advantage in two-phase, direct-to-chip cooling of electronic components, especially for cooling of electronics having a preferred operating temperature below about 85°C. For example, this result directly translates to lower junction to liquid thermal resistance due to more efficient heat transfer. The result shows the ability to provide lower silicon444907-6102-3658, v. 1junction temperatures at 100% chip power utilization, which in turn improves reliability. Additionally, this result shows that it is possible to run the chips at higher computational performance by methods such as overclocking to gain extra computational benefits due to improved thermal budget. Furthermore, this advantageous result is provided by Coolant 6-15, which has an order of magnitude lower GWP compared to R515B and a bubble temperature of 46.5 °C at 150 psia, which is advantageous for cooling of electronics having operating temperature ranges of from about 50°C to about 95°CExample 12B - Use of Coolant 6-15 For Data Center Cooling to Obtain Higher levels of Heat Removal
[0095] Example 12A is repeated, except that a thermosyphon is used in place of the pump to move the coolant. Similar advantageous and unexpected results are achieved.Examples 13A - 18A - Use of Preferred Coolants For Data Center Cooling to Obtain Higher levels of Heat Removal
[0096] Example 12A is repeated, except that each of the Coolants identified in Tables Exl3-18A and Exl3-18B below is used to provide cooling, and the heat removal results relative to the performance of 515B are reported.TABEE Exl3-18ACoolant Relative % Example Component Name and Amount, wt% Heat No.Removed 1234zeE 1234yf 1132E 152a 227ea 16144ExCIA 91 — — - 9 - 100 (515B)Exl3A 6-13 77 - - 23 - 112.5 Exl4A 6-30 67 10 - 23 - - 113TABLE Exl3-18BCoolant Relative Example Component Name and Amount, wt% % Heat No.Removed 1234zeE 134a 1336mzzE 152a 227ea 161454907-6102-3658, v. 1Exl5A 6-34 80 10 - - - 10 114 Exl6A 6-35 53 - 32 15 - - 105.8 Exl7A 6-36 70 - 10 20 - - 110.5 Exl8A 6-37 71 - 10 10 - - 105.1
[0097] As with Example 12 A, the results of these examples show that preferred coolants of the present invention provide important and unexpected advantage in two-phase, direct-to-chip pumped cooling of electronic components especially for cooling of electronics having a preferred operating temperature in the range of 50°C to about 95°C. In the addition, the other advantages described in Example 1 are achievable with these coolants.Examples 13B - 18B - Use of Preferred Coolants For Data Center Cooling to Obtain Higher levels of Heat Removal
[0098] Examples 13A - 18A is repeated, except that a thermosyphon is used in place of the pump to move the coolant. Similar advantageous and unexpected results are achieved.Example 19A - Use of Coolant 6-33 For Data Center Cooling Using Warmer Facility Water For Heat Rejection
[0099] Comparative Example 1 is repeated, except that Coolant 6-33 (including each of 6-33A and 6-33B) as identified in Table Exl9 below is used to provide cooling and that a combination of dry cooler, cooling tower and chiller is utilized to provide heat rejection for the coolant, with a 5 °C temperature differential required between facilities water and the bubble point of the coolant. The results are compared to the performance of 1234yf are reported in Table Ex 19 below.TABLE Exl9Facilities CoolantExample Water Component. wt%No. Temperature,°C 1234yf 1234zeE 1336mzzE 134a1 100 - - - 35.6 Exl 6-33 - 80 10 10 46.3464907-6102-3658, v. 1
[0100] As can be seen from the data reported above, the use of the preferred coolant 6-33 of the present invention is unexpectedly highly advantageous compared to the use of 1234yf. In particular, the use of Coolant 6-33 enables the use of a substantially warmer rejection fluid to condense the coolant, which directly results in energy and water saving benefits in the data center due to an increase in utilization of the dry cooler, and reduction in utilization of cooling tower and chiller. In addition, the use of Coolant 6-33 allows a reduction pumping energy compared to the use of 515B, which provides yet an additional unexpected advantage.Example 19B - Use of Coolant 6-33 For Data Center Cooling Using Warmer Facility Water For Heat Rejection
[0101] Example 19A is repeated, except that a thermosyphon is used in place of the pump to move the coolant. Similar advantageous and unexpected results are achieved.Examples 20A-40A: Use of Preferred Coolants For Data Center Cooling Using Warmer Facility Water For Heat Rejection
[0102] Example 19 is repeated, except that each of the Coolants identified in Tables Ex20-40A and Ex20-40B below are used to provide cooling, and the facilities water temperature that is used to condense the coolant are reported.TABLE Ex20-40AFacilities CoolantExample Water Component, wt%No. Temperature,°C 1234yf 1234zeE 1336mzzE 152a 161 134a6-1 100 - - - - - 35.6 Ex20A 6-2 - 100 - - - - 46.4 Ex21A 6-5 76 - 24 - - - 41 Ex22A 6-11 - 58 42 - - - 36.8 Ex23A 6-12 - 95 5 - - 47.3 Ex24A 6-13 - 77 - 23 - - 43.1 Ex25A 6-14 - 90 - - - 10 44.6 Ex26A 6-15 - 89 - - - 11 41.4474907-6102-3658, v. 1Facilities CoolantExample Water Component, wt%No. Temperature,°C 1234yf 1234zeE 1336mzzE 152a 161 134aEx27A 6-29 10 80 - - - 10 42.7 Ex28A 6-30 10 67 = 23 - - 41.5 Ex29A 6-32 - 60 30 - - 10 50.1 Ex30A 6-33 - 80 10 - - 10 46.2 Ex31A 6-34 - 80 10 10 40.Ex32A 6-35 - 53 32 15 - - 49.2 Ex33A 6-36 - 70 10 20 - - 44.8 Ex34A 6-37 - 71 19 10 - - 47.7TABLE Ex20-40BFacilities CoolantExample Water Component, wt%No. Temperature,°C 1234yf 1234zeE 1336mzzE 227ea 125 134a6-1 100 - - - - - 35.6 Ex35A 6-16 - 96 - - 4 - 44.7 Ex36A 6-18 - 96 - 4 - - 46.5 Ex37A 6-39 - 70 26 - 4 - 49.5 Ex38A 6-40 - 73 23 4 - - 50.9 Ex39A 6-41 - 92 4 4 - - 47.2 Ex40A 6-42 74 - 22 4 40.9
[0103] As with Example 19, the results of these examples show that preferred coolants of the present invention provide important and unexpected advantage in two-phase, direct-to-chip pumped cooling of electronic components, especially with the use of relatively warm facilities waters for heat rejection. In the addition, the other advantages described in Example 19 are achievable with these coolants.4907-6102-3658, v. 1Examples 20B - 40B - Use of Preferred Coolants For Data Center Cooling Using Warmer Facility Water For Heat Rejection
[0104] Examples 20A - 40A are repeated, except that a thermosyphon is used in place of the pump to move the coolant. Similar advantageous and unexpected results are achieved.Example 41 A - Use of Coolant 6-27 For Data Center Cooling to Obtain Higher Levels of Heat Removal and Lower Electronic Component Operating Temperature
[0105] Comparative Example 1 is repeated, except that Coolant 6-27 (including each of 6-27A and 6-27B) as identified in Table Ex41 below is used to provide cooling and that the electronic components being cooled are high thermal density chips with narrow thermal budget limited by components such as high bandwidth memory (HBM) which have lower max allowable operating temperature. The facility is able to provide facilities water at relatively low temperatures using a combination of cooling tower and chiller water to provide heat rejection for the coolant. Assuming a 5°C temperature differential is required between the coolant and the maximum operating temperature of the chip, the lowest temperature to which the chips that can be cooled are reported for Coolant 6-27 compared to 515B in Table Ex41 below.TABLE Ex41Coolant Lowest Temp, Example Component, wt% to which Chip Can No.be Cooled, °C 1234zeE 1234yf 1132E 152a 227ea44ExCIA 91 — - 9 56.5(515B)Ex41 61-27 71 10 19 37.4
[0106] The results of this example show that preferred coolants of the present invention provide an important and unexpected advantage in two-phase, on-chip pumped cooling of electronic components, especially for cooling of electronics to temperatures below 50°C having a preferred operating temperature range below 50°C. This ability can provide significant advantage, for example, running chips at higher utilization and enabling possible overclocking. In addition, Coolant 6-27 has the additional advantage of having an ability to absorb 11% higher amounts of heat compared to 515B on an equivalent volumetric flow basis.494907-6102-3658, v. 1Example 41B - Use of Coolant 6-27 For Data Center Cooling to Obtain Higher Levels of Heat Removal and Lower Electronic Component Operating Temperature
[0107] Example 41A is repeated, except that a thermosyphon is used in place of the pump to move the coolant. Similar advantageous and unexpected results are achieved.Examples 42A-60A: Use of Preferred Coolants For Data Center Cooling Using Warmer Facility Water For Heat Rejection
[0108] Example 41 is repeated, except that each of the Coolants identified in Tables Ex42-60A, Ex42-60B and Ex42-60C below are used to provide cooling, and the lowest temperature to which chip can be cooled using the coolant at the 150 psia operating pressure are reported.TABLE Ex42-60ALowest Coolant Temp, to Example Component. wt% which Chip No.Can be Cooled. °C 1234yf 1234ze(E) 1132E 152a 161 134aEx42A 6-3 89 - 11 - - - 35.6 Ex43A 6-4 95 - 5 - - - 40.3 Ex45A 6-7 77 - - 23 - - 44.8 Ex46A 6-8 90 - - - - 10 44.8 Ex47A 6-9 89 - - - 11 - 42.4 Ex48A 6-10 - 89 - - 11 48.7 Ex49A 6-20 71 - 15 14 - - 33.9 Ex50A 6-23 79 - - - 11 10 41.7 Ex51A 6-28 - 71 10 19 - - 44.8504907-6102-3658, v. 1TABLE Ex42-60BFacilities CoolantExample Water Component. wt%No. Temperature,°C 1234yf 1234ze(E) 1336mzzE 125 152a 227eaEx52A 6-6 95 - 5 - - - 46.6 Ex53A 6-17 96 - 4 - 44.3 Ex54A 6-19 96 - - - - 4 46 Ex55A 6-21 70 20 23 49 Ex56A 6-24 52 25 10 49.8 Ex57A 6-25 68 22 49.5 Ex58A 6-26 72 - 17 - 45.2 Ex59A 6-38 78 - 18 4 48.1 Ex60A 6-43 92 - 4 4 46.8TABLE Ex42-60CFacilities CoolantExample Water Component, wt%No. Temperature,°C 1234yf 1336mzzE 134a 125 152a 227eaEx61A 6-22 80 20 10 - - - 46.7
[0109] As with Example 41 A, the results of these examples show that preferred coolants of the present invention provide an important and unexpected advantage in two-phase, direct-to-chip pumped cooling of electronic components, especially for cooling of electronics to temperatures below 85°C having a preferred operating temperature range below 50°CExamples 42B - 60B - Use of Preferred Coolants For Data Center Cooling Using Warmer Facility Water For Heat Rejection
[0110] Examples 42A - 60A are repeated, except that a thermosyphon is used in place of the pump to move the coolant. Similar advantageous and unexpected results are achieved.4907-6102-3658, v. 1Example 61 A - Use of Coolant 6-42 For Data Center Cooling Enabling Electronic Components to Be Located Farther from the Coolant Distribution Unit
[0111] Comparative Example 1 is repeated, except that Coolant 6-42 (including each of 6-42A and 6-42B) as identified in Table Ex41 above is used to provide cooling, using a combination of dry cooler, cooling tower and chiller as the heat sink for condensing the coolant. A temperature difference of 5 °C between the facility water (which provides the heat sink for condensation in this example) and the coolant temperature for full condensation is utilized for this example. The facilities water in this example is maintained at 40.9°C. Unexpectedly, Coolant 6-42 has a significantly lower pressure drop in the line(s) returning coolant vapor / liquid to the condenser than 515B. As a result, the server racks containing the components to be cooled can advantageously be placed further away from the coolant distribution unit, which provides more flexibility in implementation and maintenance.Example 61B - Use of Coolant 6-42 For Data Center Cooling Enabling Electronic Components to Be Located Farther from the Coolant Distribution Unit
[0112] Example 61A is repeated, except that a thermosyphon is used in place of the pump to move the coolant. Similar advantageous and unexpected results are achieved.Examples 62A - 74A: Use of Preferred Coolants For Data Center Cooling Enabling Electronic Components to Be Located Farther from the Coolant Distribution Unit
[0113] Example 61A is repeated, except using each of Coolants 6-1, 6-5, 6-6, 6-8, 6-11, 6-17, 6-19, 6-21, 6-22, 6-38, 6-42 and 6-43. Similar unexpected advantages are achieved.Examples 62B - 74B: Use of Preferred Coolants For Data Center Cooling Enabling Electronic Components to Be Located Farther from the Coolant Distribution Unit
[0114] Examples 62A -74A are repeated, except that a thermosyphon is used in place of the pump to move the coolant. Similar advantageous and unexpected results are achieved.Examples 75A and 76A - Use of Preferred Coolants For Data Center Cooling Enabling Energy Savings in Coolant Pumping
[0115] Example 19 is repeated, except that Coolant 6-39 and 6-40 are each used in place of Coolant 6-33. Similar advantages relating to pumping energy are unexpectedly achieved.524907-6102-3658, v. 1Examples 75B and 7 B - Use of Preferred Coolants For Data Center Cooling Enabling Energy Savings in Coolant Pumping
[0116] Examples 75A and 75B are repeated, except that a thermosyphon is used in place of the pump to move the coolant. Similar advantageous and unexpected results are achieved.Comparative Example 2 - Direct- To- Chip Performance Testing Using 515B
[0117] A test rig was created and used to evaluate direct-to-chip cooling using R515B (91,1 wt.% R1234ze(E) and 8.9 wt.% R227ea) as the coolant. A schematic representation of the test rig is provided in Figure 3. The thermal test vehicle 2 comprises a silicon die having surface area of about 3 cm2and thirteen (13) temperature sensors located on the surface of the die as shown in Figure 4. The silicon thermal test vehicle is used to represent heat generating components such as CPUs, GPUs or application-Specific Integrated Circuits (ASICs). The silicon thermal test vehicle has the capability of measuring directly the silicon junction temperature while creating the desired heat flux. PSU Areas 0, 2, 3, and 5 of the silicon die as shown in Figure 4 are used to create the desired heat flux. Each area consists of pixels shown in Figure 5. Examples of the power calculations used include the following:T1sat inlet Tsat @ Psat (via thermodynamic software')TT1sat in+ T1out1sat mean2&Tsub T1sat in- T ‘ i-nHeat Flux q" ... Heat Flux at silicon W / cm2-Junction to liquid superheatTj ~ TtJunction to liquid thermal Tj ~ Tinietresistance Rjt(k / W) ([silicon534907-6102-3658, v. 1Overall Heat transfer qL" si -lIi'conCoefficient (W / cmA2-K) Tj ~ Tiniet
[0118] Based on the use of conditions comprising the refrigerant having a saturation temperature of °C. the test results as provided in Table ExC2 below were determined using R515B as the heat transfer fluid for comparison purposes.Table ExC2CoolantR515BMeasured Value / PropertyMax Heat Flux at throttling limit 204.8HTC (W / cm2) at throttling limit47634HTC at 400 W (132.11 W / cmA2) 45652Liquid to Junction R at max heat flux0.069Liquid to Junction R at 400 W (132.110.072W / cmA2)Average T junction at max heat flux 64.8Average Tjunction at 400 W (132.1151.1W / cmA2)Saturation Temperature25SubCooling 3GWP 300Outlet Pressure (psi)72Temperature Glide, 0Latent Heat at 15 Op si 139.5Density Ratio at 25C43.55Liquid Density at 25C 1179.8Vapor Density at 25 C27.09Density Ratio at 150 psi 18.82Liquid Density at 150 psi1082.4Vapor Density at 150 psi 47.5544907-6102-3658, v. 1Examples 76 A - 76E - Direct-To-Chip Performance Testing Using Each of Coolants 6-8B, 6-13B, 6-29B, 6-34B and 6-43B
[0119] Comparative Example 1 is repeated, except that each of Coolant 6-8B, 6-13B, 6-6-29B, 6-34B and 6- 43B as identified in Table Exl above, is used in test rig. The performance of each coolant, together with the results for the performance of 515B, are reported in Table Ex76 below.Table Ex76EXAMPLEExC2 Ex76A Ex76B Ex76C Ex76D Ex76E CoolantMeasuredR515B 6-7B 6-13B 6-28B 6-34B 6-42B Value / PropertyMax Heat Flux at204.8 199.8 204.8 201.5 204.8 208.1 throttling limitHTC (W / cm2) atthrottling limit 47634 45128 47066 45033 46658 42457 HTC at 400 W (132.1145652 44953 44755 42495 44634 39320 W / cmA2)Liquid to Junction R atmax heat flux 0.069 0.073 0.070 0.073 0.070 0.077 Liquid to Junction R at400 W (132.11 0.072 0.073 0.073 0.077 0.074 0.084 W / cmA2)Average Tj unction at64.8 66.22 65.26 66.24 66.44 70.54 max heat fluxAverage Tj unction at400 W (132.11 51.1 51.3 52.42 52.52 52.16 55.1 W / cmA2)Saturation Temperature25 25 25 25 25 25 SubCooling 3 3 3 3 3 3 GWP 300 29 29 24 144 130 Outlet Pressure (psi)72 100 79.2 99.9 71.3 85.7 Temperature Glide, 0 0.01 0.3 4.4 1.9 4.3 Latent Heat at 150psi 139.5 157.3 168.6 179.5 144.2 129.1 Latent Heat at Tsat161.8 172.1 190.8 192 164.6 143.6 (25C)Density Ratio at 25 C43.55 31.4 43.9 40.3 45.6 38.6Liquid Density at 25C 1179.8 1035.7 2085.6 1067.7 1178.7 1142.8554907-6102-3658, v. 1Vapor Density at 25 C27.09 33 24.8 26.5 25.8 29.6 Density Ratio at 150 psi 18.82 19.7 21.01 22.2 19.1 17.2 Liquid Density at 150psi 1082.4 982.8 1008.2 1018.8 1083.1 1060.9 Vapor Density at 15047.5 49.9 47.9 45.9 56.67.9 61.8psi
[0120] As can be seen from the data presented above, the exemplary coolants of the present invention exhibit a mosaic of properties that are unexpectedly advantageous for use in direct-to-chip cooling, including the ability to achieve desirable levels of cooling with relatively low GWP coolants and / or coolants with desirable glide properties.4907-6102-3658, v. 1
Claims
CLAIMSWhat is claimed is:
1. A coolant for two-phase cooling of electronics comprising:(a) from about 50% to about 96% by weight of a first component selected from R-1234yf or R-1234ze(E); and(b) from about 4% to about 55% by weight of a second component selected from the group consisting essentially of R-125, R-227ea, R-1132E, R-1336mzzE, R-134a, R- 161, R- 152a and combinations of two or more of these.
2. The coolant of claim 1 further comprising from about 4% to about 35% by weight of a third component that is not the same as said selected second component and which is selected from the group consisting of R1336mzzE, R161 and R152a.
3. The coolant of claim 1 comprising from about 50% to about 96% by weight of R-1234yf.
4. The coolant of claim 1 comprising from about 50% to about 96% by weight of R- 1234ze(E).
5. The coolant of claim 4 wherein said second component is selected from the group consisting essentially of R-l 336mzzE, R-l 52a and combinations of two or more of these.
6. The coolant of claim 1 consisting essentially of from about 70% to about 95% by weight of R-1234ze(E) and from about 5% to about 30% by weight of R-152a.
7. A heat transfer systems for two-phase direct-to-chip cooling of electronic components comprising:(a) an electronic component;(b) a fluid flow path bringing coolant into heat transfer contact with said electronic component;(c) a liquid coolant in said flow path for removing heat from said electronic component by latent heat transfer in which at least a portion of liquid coolant in heat transfer contact with said electronic component is vaporized to form coolant vapor, wherein said coolant is a coolant comprises:574907-6102-3658, v. 1a. from about 50% to about 96% by weight of a first component selected from R-1234yf or R-1234ze(E); andb. from about 4% to about 55% by weight of a second component selected from the group consisting essentially of R-125. R-227ea, R-1132E, R-1336mzzE, R-134a, R-161, R-152a and combinations of two or more of these;(d) a heat exchanger that is: (1) fluidly connected to said coolant vapor; and (2) fluidly connected to a supply of heat sink fluid at a temperature below the condensing temperature of said coolant vapor for absorbing heat from said coolant vapor by condensing said coolant vapor to produce condensed coolant liquid; and (e) a pump or thermosyphon receiving said condensed coolant liquid and moving said condensed coolant liquid into heat transfer contact with said electronic component.
8. An improved method of cooling an operating electronic component by exposing said electronic component, directly or indirectly, to a coolant liquid under pressure for removing heat therefrom by vaporization of said coolant liquid, said improvement comprising:(a) said coolant liquid comprising:a. from about 50% to about 96% by weight of a first component selected from R-1234yf or R-1234ze(E); andb. from about 4% to about 55% by weight of a second component selected from the group consisting essentially of R-125. R-227ea, R-1132E, R-1336mzzE, R-134a, R-161, R- 152a and combinations of two or more of these, wherein at least a portion of said coolant liquid is vaporized by absorbing heat from said electronic component; and(b) removing heat from said vaporized liquid by condensing said vapor by heat transfer contact with a heat sink fluid.
9. The method of claim 18 wherein said second component of said coolant is selected from the group consisting essentially of R-1336mzzE, R-152a and combinations of two or more of these.584907-6102-3658, v.
110. The method of claim 18 wherein said coolant consisting essentially of from about 70% to about 80% by weight of R-1234yf and / or R-1234ze(E) and from about 20% to about 30% by weight of one or more of R-1336mzzE, R-152a and R-134a.4907-6102-3658, v. 1
