Inequitable conduct
Also called inequitable conduct defense, inequitable conduct before the USPTO
Inequitable conduct is an equitable defense to patent infringement in US courts that can render the entire patent unenforceable, as the en banc Federal Circuit explained in Therasense v. Becton, Dickinson (2011)1.
Specific intent to deceive
In Therasense (2011), the en banc Federal Circuit held that the accused infringer must prove specific intent to deceive the USPTO by clear and convincing evidence1. For nondisclosure of a reference, the en banc Federal Circuit in Therasense (2011) required proof that the applicant knew of the reference and its materiality and deliberately withheld it1.
The en banc Federal Circuit in Therasense (2011) allowed an inference of intent from circumstantial evidence only if specific intent to deceive is the single most reasonable inference from the evidence1. The en banc Federal Circuit in Therasense (2011) required courts to assess intent and materiality separately and barred inferring intent from materiality alone1.
But-for materiality and the exception
The en banc Federal Circuit in Therasense (2011) explained that the accused infringer must prove both intent and materiality by clear and convincing evidence and that materiality generally requires but-for proof1. For withheld prior art, the en banc Federal Circuit in Therasense (2011) directed courts to ask whether the USPTO would have allowed the claim had it known of the art, applying a preponderance-of-the-evidence standard for patentability and the broadest reasonable construction of the claims1.
The en banc Federal Circuit in Therasense (2011) treated affirmative acts of egregious misconduct, such as filing an unmistakably false affidavit, as material without but-for proof1. The en banc Federal Circuit in Therasense (2011) required but-for materiality for mere nondisclosure of prior art to the USPTO or omission of prior art references from an affidavit1. The Federal Circuit applied the exception in Intellect Wireless v. HTC (2013) to an unmistakably false declaration that the applicant failed to correct4.
What happens to the patent
The en banc Federal Circuit in Therasense (2011) explained that once the accused infringer meets the burden on intent and materiality, the court weighs the equities to decide whether the conduct warrants unenforceability of the entire patent1. The en banc Federal Circuit in Therasense (2011) explained that inequitable conduct as to any claim makes the entire patent unenforceable1.
| Legal standard | What it addresses |
|---|---|
| 37 CFR 1.56 | The USPTO disclosure duty and the rule's definition of material information2 |
| Therasense (en banc Federal Circuit, 2011) | The separate intent and materiality requirements for the defense in court, including the general but-for rule and the exception for affirmative egregious misconduct1 |
Effect of supplemental examination
Under 35 U.S.C. 257(c)(1), subject to the exceptions below, a patent cannot be held unenforceable based on conduct relating to information that was unconsidered, inadequately considered or incorrect in an earlier examination of that patent if the information was considered, reconsidered or corrected during supplemental examination of the patent3. Making or omitting a request under section 257(a) is irrelevant to enforceability under section 2823.
- Prior allegations: Under section 257(c)(2)(A), paragraph (1)'s protection does not apply to an allegation if, before the date of the section 257(a) request to consider, reconsider or correct the information underlying the allegation, it was pleaded with particularity in a civil action or set out with particularity in a notice the patent owner received under 21 U.S.C. 355(j)(2)(B)(iv)(II)3.
- Patent enforcement actions: In an action under 19 U.S.C. 1337(a) or 35 U.S.C. 281, section 257(c)(2)(B) withholds paragraph (1)'s protection as to a defense raised in the action based on information considered, reconsidered or corrected pursuant to a section 257(a) request unless the supplemental examination and any reexamination ordered pursuant to the request are concluded before the action is brought3.
Questions people ask
Check a product
FTO Search AI Agent
Turn product details into a reviewable search strategy, focused patent candidates, and evidence your IP team can take further.
Run FTO SearchIs a failure to disclose material information enough to establish inequitable conduct?
No, the en banc Federal Circuit in Therasense (2011) separately requires clear and convincing proof of specific intent to deceive the USPTO1.
Does a finding of inequitable conduct affect only the claim involved?
No, the en banc Federal Circuit in Therasense (2011) explained that inequitable conduct as to even one claim makes the entire patent unenforceable1.
Does USPTO materiality under Rule 56 establish materiality for the court defense?
No. Rule 56(b) defines materiality for the USPTO disclosure duty2. The en banc Federal Circuit in Therasense (2011) declined to adopt that definition for inequitable conduct and generally requires but-for materiality, with an exception for affirmative egregious misconduct1,2.
How it connects
Go from the term to the task
Read how the method works, run it on your own product or idea, then try a free tool.
- 01 / How-toHow to run a freedom-to-operate analysisScope, search, claim review and the report counsel will ask for.Read
- 02 / AI agentFTO Search AI AgentTurn product details into a reviewable search strategy, focused patent candidates, and evidence your IP team can take further.Run it
- 03 / Free toolAI prior art searchDescribe an idea, get the closest patents.Try tool