Patent interference
Also called interference proceeding, patent priority interference
Patent interference is a US proceeding under pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. 135(a) that determines priority of invention between a patent application and another pending application or an unexpired patent when their claims interfere1,2. Claims interfere if the subject matter of each claim, treated as prior art, would anticipate or render obvious the subject matter of the other claim2.
Under 37 CFR 41.200(a), a patent interference is a contested case subject to the procedures in Part 41, Subpart D3. Under section 41.200(b), references in Subpart E to 35 U.S.C. 102 or 135 use the statutes in force on March 15, 2013, unless expressly indicated otherwise3. Section 3(n) of the Leahy-Smith America Invents Act controls transitional applicability, including applications to which both the AIA amendments and specified pre-AIA provisions apply4.
Which applications remain subject to the old provisions
Under pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. 135(a), an interference may be declared when the Director considers a patent application to interfere with a pending application or an unexpired patent1. The Director must notify both applicants, or the applicant and the patentee, as applicable1. The Board decides priority of invention and may decide questions of patentability1.
Except as otherwise provided in section 3, section 3(n)(1) of the AIA makes its amendments effective after the 18-month period beginning on enactment, with applicability to an application and any patent issuing on it that contains or ever contained either a claim with an effective filing date on or after that effective date or a specific reference under 35 U.S.C. 120, 121 or 365(c) to a patent or application that contains or ever contained such a claim4.
Section 3(n)(2) preserves pre-AIA sections 102(g), 135 and 291 for each claim of an application and any patent issued on it to which the section 3 amendments also apply, if the application or patent contains or ever contained either a claim with an effective filing date before that effective date or a specific reference under sections 120, 121 or 365(c) to a patent or application that contains or ever contained such a claim4.
MPEP 2301.04 identifies the relevant transition date as March 16, 2013 and explains that an application containing both earlier-effective-date and later-effective-date claims can remain subject to interference while also being examined under AIA sections 102 and 1031.
Interfering claims and priority evidence
Under 37 CFR 41.203(a), interference exists if the subject matter of one party's claim, treated as prior art, would anticipate or render obvious the opposing party's claim, and vice versa2.
Under 37 CFR 41.201, a count is the Board's description of interfering subject matter that sets the scope of admissible priority proofs; multiple counts must describe patentably distinct inventions5.
37 CFR 41.207(a)(1) presumes invention in the order of the accorded-benefit dates for each count, but neither party receives a priority presumption against the other when both have the same earliest constructive-reduction-to-practice date7.
Under section 41.207(a)(2), priority is proved by a preponderance of the evidence, except that clear and convincing evidence is required if a party's earliest constructive-reduction-to-practice date is after the issue date of an involved patent or the section 122(b) publication date of an involved application or patent7.
Suggesting and declaring an interference
Under 37 CFR 41.202(a), an applicant, including a reissue applicant, may suggest an interference with another application or a patent8. The suggestion must identify that application or patent, identify every claim the applicant believes interferes, propose one or more counts, and explain which claims correspond to which counts8. For each count, the applicant must chart at least one corresponding claim from each party and explain why the claims interfere under 37 CFR 41.203(a)2,8. The suggestion must also explain in detail why the applicant will prevail on priority8. For each claim added or amended to provoke an interference, the applicant must chart the written-description support in its specification8. For each constructive reduction to practice whose benefit the applicant seeks, the applicant must chart where the disclosure provides that reduction to practice within the scope of the interfering subject matter8.
A patentee cannot suggest an interference under section 41.202, but may alert an examiner to one to the extent permitted by section 1.2918.
Under section 41.203(b), an administrative patent judge declares the interference on behalf of the Director, identifying the interfering subject matter, involved applications, patents and claims, accorded benefit for each count, and claims corresponding to each count2.
An examiner may require the applicant to add a claim that, apart from priority, is patentable to the applicant and covers patentable subject matter claimed by another applicant or patentee8. Failure to satisfy the examiner’s requirement within the period set by the examiner, which must be at least one month, concedes priority for the subject matter of that claim8. If the interference would be with a patent, the applicant must also comply with section 41.202(a)(2) through (a)(6)8. The applicant must show why it would prevail on priority if its earliest constructive reduction to practice is later than the apparent earliest constructive reduction to practice for a patent or published application claiming the interfering subject matter8. The showing must support a finding of priority in favor of the party making it if unrebutted8. If necessary testimony or production requires authorization under section 41.150(c) or 41.156(a), the showing must include any necessary interrogatories, requests for admission or production, or deposition requests8. It must also describe the expected responses in detail and explain their relevance to priority8. If the applicant fails to make the required showing under section 41.202(d)(1), an administrative patent judge may still declare an interference and order the applicant to show cause why judgment on priority should not be entered against it8. New priority evidence then requires good cause8.
Interference and derivation
| Point | Interference | Derivation proceeding |
|---|---|---|
| Question | Which party first invented the commonly claimed invention under pre-AIA law1. | Whether an inventor in an earlier application derived the claimed invention from an inventor in the petitioner's application and filed without authorization6. |
| Statutory basis | Pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. 135(a), subject to the AIA transition provisions1,4. | Current 35 U.S.C. 135 governs Derivation proceeding6. |
MPEP 2301 identifies the Board as the Patent Trial and Appeal Board and describes final judgment on priority and patentability questions in interference1.
Questions people ask
Search before filing
Novelty Search AI Agent
Turn an invention disclosure into ranked prior art and feature-level evidence, so IP teams can review novelty risk with clearer context.
Run Novelty SearchDid the AIA eliminate every possibility of an interference?
Pre-AIA interference practice can still apply to applications governed by pre-AIA law1. It can also apply to an application or resulting patent governed by the AIA if it now contains or ever contained a claim with an effective filing date before March 16, 2013, or a specific reference under 35 U.S.C. 120, 121, or 365(c) to a patent or application that now contains or ever contained such a claim1,4.
Does the party with the earlier accorded-benefit date automatically win?
No; section 41.207(a) creates a presumption, states the same-earliest-date exception, and provides evidentiary standards for proving priority7.
Can a patent owner suggest an interference under section 41.202?
No; section 41.202(b) prohibits a patentee from suggesting one under that section, while allowing the patentee to alert an examiner to the extent section 1.291 permits8.
How it connects
Go from the term to the task
Read how the method works, run it on your own product or idea, then try a free tool.
- 01 / How-toHow to run a freedom-to-operate analysisScope, search, claim review and the report counsel will ask for.Read
- 02 / AI agentFTO Search AI AgentAn AI agent that finds in-force patents that could read on your product, with a claim chart for each one.Run it
- 03 / Free toolAI prior art searchDescribe an idea, get the closest patents.Try tool