Patent misuse
Also called patent misuse defense, misuse of a patent
Patent misuse is a US defense to patent infringement that can make the asserted patent unenforceable, as the en banc Federal Circuit explained in Princo v. ITC (2010)1.
Scope of the defense
The en banc Federal Circuit in Princo (2010) described the general inquiry as whether a condition impermissibly broadened the physical or temporal scope of the asserted patent with anticompetitive effects1. The en banc Federal Circuit in Princo (2010) explained that anticompetitive conduct alone does not establish misuse of the patent in suit1.
When a court withholds enforcement
In Morton Salt (1942), the US Supreme Court held that equity could withhold infringement relief where a patentee used the patent to restrain competition in the sale of an unpatented product2. The US Supreme Court in Morton Salt (1942) said relief should remain withheld at least until it was shown that the patentee had abandoned the practice and that the consequences of the misuse had dissipated2.
Conduct addressed by 35 U.S.C. 271(d)
Under 35 U.S.C. 271(d), a patent owner otherwise entitled to relief for infringement or contributory infringement cannot be denied relief or found to have committed misuse or illegal extension of the patent right by reason of one or more of the listed acts3. The market-power exception applies to the tying conduct in paragraph (5)3.
- Under paragraph (1), deriving revenue from acts that would constitute contributory infringement of the patent if performed by someone else without the owner's consent3.
- Under paragraph (2), licensing or authorizing another person to perform acts that would constitute contributory infringement of the patent if performed without the owner's consent3.
- Under paragraph (3), seeking to enforce the owner's patent rights against infringement or contributory infringement3.
- Under paragraph (4), refusing to license or use any rights to the patent3.
- Under paragraph (5), conditioning a license of any rights to the patent or the sale of the patented product on acquiring a license to rights in another patent or buying a separate product, unless, in view of the circumstances, the owner has market power in the relevant market for the patent or patented product on which the license or sale is conditioned3.
Related licensing rule for post-expiration use
In Brulotte v. Thys (1964), the US Supreme Court refused to enforce royalties accruing for use after the last patent incorporated in the machines expired4. In Kimble v. Marvel (2015), the US Supreme Court reaffirmed that contract rule for royalties based on post-expiration use of the patented invention5. The en banc Federal Circuit in Princo (2010) discussed Brulotte when explaining how use of patent leverage can reach beyond the patent term1.
| Payment provision | Treatment under Kimble |
|---|---|
| Royalty for use after patent expiration | Under the US Supreme Court's 2015 Kimble decision, a patent royalty is unenforceable to the extent it charges for post-expiration use of the patented invention5 |
| Payment after expiration for pre-expiration use | The US Supreme Court in Kimble (2015) explained that parties may defer payment for use during the patent term5. |
Questions people ask
Check a product
FTO Search AI Agent
Turn product details into a reviewable search strategy, focused patent candidates, and evidence your IP team can take further.
Run FTO SearchIs refusing to license a patent enough by itself to establish misuse?
No, 35 U.S.C. 271(d)(4) protects an otherwise entitled patent owner against denial of relief or a finding of misuse or illegal extension of the patent right on that basis3.
Can payments for use during the patent term be deferred until after expiration?
Yes, the US Supreme Court in Kimble (2015) said Brulotte permits deferring payment for pre-expiration use into the period after expiration5.
In Morton Salt, what had to be shown before a court could resume granting infringement relief?
The US Supreme Court in Morton Salt (1942) said relief should be withheld at least until it was shown that the practice had been abandoned and the consequences of the misuse had dissipated2.
How it connects
Go from the term to the task
Read how the method works, run it on your own product or idea, then try a free tool.
- 01 / How-toHow to run a freedom-to-operate analysisScope, search, claim review and the report counsel will ask for.Read
- 02 / AI agentFTO Search AI AgentTurn product details into a reviewable search strategy, focused patent candidates, and evidence your IP team can take further.Run it
- 03 / Free toolAI prior art searchDescribe an idea, get the closest patents.Try tool