Product-by-process claim
Also called product by process claim, product-by-process claims
Product-by-process claim is a Patent claim that defines the claimed product through the process by which it is made, as described in MPEP 2173.05(p) for US examination1. That section recognizes this as a proper claim form1.
For US patentability, MPEP 2113 directs attention to the product itself, including structure implied by the process steps2. For infringement, the Federal Circuit's en banc portion of Abbott Laboratories v. Sandoz holds that process terms in product-by-process claims limit the infringement inquiry3.
Patentability focuses on the product
MPEP 2113 states that a product-by-process claim is unpatentable if its product is the same as, or obvious from, a prior-art product, even if that earlier product was made by a different process2. The structure implied by process steps must still be considered, especially if the product can only be defined by those steps or the steps would be expected to impart distinctive structural characteristics2.
MPEP 2113 cites In re Garnero as an example in which interbonding by interfusion limited the structure of the claimed composite2.
When the evidentiary burden shifts
Under MPEP 2113, once an examiner supplies a rationale tending to show that the claimed product appears the same as or similar to a prior-art product despite a different production process, the applicant must come forward with evidence establishing a nonobvious difference between the products2.
The section also permits an alternative anticipation-or-obviousness rejection where the prior art discloses a product reasonably appearing identical or only slightly different, but requires Office personnel to explain both aspects of the rejection2.
Infringement and Abbott v. Sandoz
In section III.A.2 of its 2009 Abbott Laboratories v. Sandoz opinion, the Federal Circuit states that process terms in product-by-process claims serve as limitations in determining infringement3. It holds that such a claim is not infringed by products made by processes other than the one claimed3.
Product-by-process wording and definiteness
MPEP 2173.05(p) permits a device, apparatus, manufacture or composition claim to refer to a process in which it is intended to be used without objection under the definiteness provision, provided it is clear that the claim is directed to the product rather than the process1.
| Claim language | Treatment in MPEP 2173.05(p) |
|---|---|
| Product defined by how it is made | Recognized as a proper claim form1. |
| One claim to both an apparatus and the method steps of using it | Indefinite under 35 U.S.C. 112(b) or the corresponding pre-AIA provision1. |
| Product with limitations on system capabilities | May be definite where the additional limitations concern system capabilities rather than specific user actions or functions1. |
Questions people ask
Draft and prosecute
Patent Drafting AI Agent
An AI agent that drafts claims and a full specification from a disclosure, with a compliance review before you finish.
Start draftingDoes a different manufacturing process automatically establish patentability?
No, MPEP 2113 states that an identical or obvious prior-art product defeats patentability even when made by a different process2. Structure implied by the claimed process steps must nevertheless be considered2.
Can process terms limit infringement even though patentability focuses on the product?
Yes, the Federal Circuit's en banc holding in Abbott treats those process terms as limitations for infringement3. MPEP 2113 separately assesses patentability based on the product itself and structure implied by its process terms2.
How it connects
Go from the term to the task
Read how the method works, run it on your own product or idea, then try a free tool.
- 01 / How-toPatentability search: a practical guideCheck whether an invention is new before you spend on a filing.Read
- 02 / AI agentNovelty Search AI AgentAn AI agent that searches prior art for your invention and compares each reference with it feature by feature.Run it
- 03 / Free toolPatent draft style studioRewrite a technical description in claim language.Try tool
More next stepsAI prior art search