Restriction requirement
Also called requirement for restriction, requirement for division, patent restriction requirement
Restriction requirement is a US examination action requiring an applicant to elect an invention for prosecution1,3.
For applications filed under 35 U.S.C. 111(a), MPEP 803 requires independent or distinct inventions as claimed, capable of supporting separate patents, and a serious search or examination burden without restriction4,2. US national-stage applications under section 371 instead use unity-of-invention analysis under sections 1.475 and 1.4992,3.
When restriction is proper in section 111(a) applications
Section 121 permits the Director to require restriction when two or more independent and distinct inventions are claimed in one application5.
MPEP 803 expresses two criteria: the inventions must be independent or distinct as claimed, and examining them together would impose a serious search or examination burden4.
If all claims can be searched and examined without serious burden, MPEP 803 requires examination on the merits even if they concern independent or distinct inventions4.
Under section 1.142(b), unelected claims that are not canceled are withdrawn from further consideration, subject to reinstatement if the restriction requirement is withdrawn or overruled1.
Election with or without traverse
| Reply | What it means | Required election |
|---|---|---|
| Election without traverse6 | An election without a statement of traverse, or without specific reasons supporting traverse, is treated as without traverse6 | The applicant must elect an invention for examination6 |
| Election with traverse6 | A written request for reconsideration distinctly and specifically identifying the supposed errors in the restriction requirement6 | An election remains required even when the requirement is traversed6 |
Section 1.143 permits a reasoned request for reconsideration, withdrawal or modification, but requires a provisional election that becomes the elected invention if the requirement becomes final7.
To preserve review by petition, MPEP 818.01(c) requires all relied-on errors to be distinctly and specifically identified in a timely traverse6.
Under section 1.144, after a final restriction requirement the applicant may petition the Director while also making any reply due on the rest of the action, and may defer the petition until final action on or allowance of elected claims, but must file it no later than appeal; a petition will not be considered without a prior request for reconsideration8.
Election of species
MPEP 803.02 states that an election-of-species requirement is a type of restriction requirement and describes provisional election of a single disclosed species or a group of patentably indistinct species in a Markush claim4.
For a proper Markush group whose members are sufficiently few or closely related to permit search and examination without serious burden, MPEP 803.02 requires examination of all members rather than provisional election of a single species4.
Section 1.146 permits the examiner, in the first action on an application with a generic claim and claims to multiple patentably distinct species embraced by it, to require election of a species to which the claim will be restricted if no genus claim is allowable; it separately permits restriction to no more than a reasonable number of species when the application claims more than a reasonable number9.
Divisionals and the section 121 safe harbor
Under section 121, a divisional application directed to the other invention receives the benefit of the original filing date if it meets section 1205.
Section 121 bars use, in the USPTO or the courts, of a patent issuing on an application subject to a restriction requirement, or an application filed as a result of it, as a reference against the divisional, the original application or a patent issued on either, if the divisional was filed before the patent on the other application issued5.
MPEP 804.01 describes this protection for nonstatutory Double patenting and requires consonance with the line of demarcation drawn between the restricted inventions, without crossing that line10.
PCT and EPC unity texts
MPEP 1893.03(d) applies unity-of-invention analysis to US national-stage applications under section 371; applications filed under section 111(a) retain restriction practice under sections 1.141 to 1.146 even when they claim benefit of an earlier PCT or US national-stage application2.
| Text | What it requires |
|---|---|
| PCT Rule 13.111 | One invention, or a group linked to form a single general inventive concept11 |
| PCT Rule 13.211 | For a claimed group, a technical relationship involving one or more of the same or corresponding special technical features, meaning features defining each invention's contribution as a whole over the prior art11 |
| EPC Article 8212 | A European application relating to one invention, or a group linked to form a single general inventive concept12 |
Questions people ask
Draft and prosecute
Patent Drafting AI Agent
An AI agent that drafts claims and a full specification from a disclosure, with a compliance review before you finish.
Start draftingMust the applicant elect an invention even when contesting restriction?
Yes, section 1.143 and MPEP 818.01 require an election even with a traverse, and a traverse must distinctly and specifically identify the supposed errors6,7.
Are unelected claims automatically canceled?
No, section 1.142(b) withdraws unelected claims from further consideration if they are not canceled, subject to reinstatement when restriction is withdrawn or overruled1.
Is election of species a restriction requirement?
Yes, MPEP 803.02 expressly treats election of species as a type of restriction requirement4.
How it connects
Go from the term to the task
Read how the method works, run it on your own product or idea, then try a free tool.
- 01 / How-toPatentability search: a practical guideCheck whether an invention is new before you spend on a filing.Read
- 02 / AI agentNovelty Search AI AgentAn AI agent that searches prior art for your invention and compares each reference with it feature by feature.Run it
- 03 / Free toolPatent draft style studioRewrite a technical description in claim language.Try tool