Technology readiness level (TRL)
Also called technology readiness levels, TRL
Technology readiness level (TRL) is a rating of technology maturity within the measurement system described on NASA's 2023 TRL page1.
The European Commission's Horizon 2020 Work Programme 2014-2015, General Annex G, supplies its own level definitions when a topic refers to a TRL, unless otherwise specified2. GAO's 2020 guide describes technology readiness assessments as evaluations of technology maturity and readiness for integration into a system3.
NASA explanatory page and formal TRL criteria
NASA's 2023 page describes nine levels, with TRL 1 the lowest and TRL 9 the highest1.
| Level | NASA descriptions and criteria, paraphrased |
|---|---|
| TRL 11 | NASA 2023: scientific research begins, with results informing future research and development1. |
| TRL 21 | NASA 2023: studied basic principles have possible practical applications, but experimental proof remains limited or absent1. |
| TRL 31 | NASA 2023: active research and design use analytical and laboratory studies to investigate viability, often with a proof-of-concept model1. |
| TRL 41 | NASA NPR 7123.1D (2023): components or a breadboard undergo validation in the laboratory4. |
| TRL 51 | NASA NPR 7123.1D (2023): components or a brassboard undergo validation in a relevant environment4. |
| TRL 61 | NASA NPR 7123.1D (2023): a system or subsystem model or prototype demonstrates performance in a relevant environment4. |
| TRL 71 | NASA NPR 7123.1D (2023): a system prototype is demonstrated in its operational environment4. |
| TRL 81 | NASA 2023: testing and flight qualification are complete, making the technology ready for implementation in an existing technology or system1. |
| TRL 91 | NASA 2023: a successful mission has demonstrated the technology in flight1. |
EU scale: Horizon 2020 General Annex G, 2014-2015
The European Commission's 2014-2015 Annex G applies the following definitions to topic descriptions referring to TRLs, unless the topic specifies otherwise2.
| Level | European Commission 2014-2015 description, paraphrased |
|---|---|
| TRL 12 | European Commission 2014-2015: observation of basic principles2. |
| TRL 22 | European Commission 2014-2015: formulation of the technology concept2. |
| TRL 32 | European Commission 2014-2015: experimental evidence of the concept2. |
| TRL 42 | European Commission 2014-2015: validation of the technology in a laboratory2. |
| TRL 52 | European Commission 2014-2015: validation in a relevant environment, specifically an industrially relevant one for key enabling technologies2. |
| TRL 62 | European Commission 2014-2015: demonstration in a relevant environment, specifically an industrially relevant one for key enabling technologies2. |
| TRL 72 | European Commission 2014-2015: demonstration of a system prototype in an operational environment2. |
| TRL 82 | European Commission 2014-2015: completion and qualification of the system2. |
| TRL 92 | European Commission 2014-2015: proof of the actual system in an operational environment, including competitive manufacturing for key enabling technologies, or in space2. |
GAO technology readiness assessment context
GAO's 2020 guide describes technology readiness assessments as examining maturity and whether technologies are sufficiently developed for integration into a system3.
GAO's 2020 guide provides a framework for program managers, technology developers and governance bodies to understand maturity and conduct technology readiness assessments3.
Questions people ask
Plan R&D
R&D AI Agent
An AI technical research assistant for R&D and engineering problems, with every answer traced to its sources.
Ask Eureka EngineeringHow many TRLs does NASA describe?
NASA's 2023 page describes nine levels, from TRL 1 through TRL 91.
Does TRL 7 always require a space demonstration?
No. NASA's 2023 NPR 7123.1D includes ground, airborne and space platforms at TRL 74. The European Commission's 2014-2015 Annex G also specifies an operational environment2.
What is a technology readiness assessment?
GAO's 2020 guide describes it as an assessment of technology maturity and readiness for integration into a system3.