5G Authentication Commit Message Exchange for DoS Mitigation
Find Innovative SolutionsGenerate Solutions
Solution Overview
Problem
The 5G security model faces vulnerabilities such as denial-of-service attacks due to the computational intensity of asymmetric algorithms used for protecting SUPI, which can lead to overloading of authentication servers and potential exposure of user identities.
Innovation Solution
Implementing a request commit message and response commit message exchange between user equipment and network nodes to determine whether to proceed with authentication, including optional liveness checks, cryptographic puzzles, or authentication priority tokens to enhance security and defend against denial-of-service attacks.
Engineering Contradictions & Design Principles
Engineering Contradiction Analysis
1Reliability
If asymmetric algorithms (public key cryptography) are used to encrypt SUPI for privacy protection, then user identity privacy is improved, but computational load on authentication servers increases significantly
Solution Approach 1:
The patent applies preliminary action by having the UE compute and include a commit message (cryptographic puzzle solution) in the authentication request before the server performs heavy decryption operations. This preliminary computational step by the UE prepares the authentication context in advance, allowing the server to verify authenticity without immediately engaging in computationally intensive asymmetric decryption for every authentication attempt.
Solution Approach 2:
The commit message acts as an intermediary mechanism between the UE and the authentication server. Instead of directly performing expensive SUPI decryption on every authentication request, the server first verifies the commit message, which serves as a lightweight preliminary verification layer that filters out invalid requests before committing server resources to full authentication processing.
2Reliability
If the network requests UE to send permanent identifier (IMSI) for authentication, then authentication reliability is improved, but vulnerability to IMSI catching attacks increases
Solution Approach 1:
The patent extracts the permanent identifier (SUPI) from direct transmission in plaintext form. Instead of sending IMSI or SUPI in cleartext during authentication, the system uses the SUCI (concealed identifier) which contains encrypted or hashed representations of the permanent identifier. This extraction of the sensitive identifier from its vulnerable plaintext form eliminates the direct exposure to IMSI catching attacks while maintaining authentication reliability.
3Reliability
If computational intensity of asymmetric algorithms is used for identity protection, then security against identity exposure is improved, but susceptibility to denial-of-service attacks increases
Solution Approach 1:
The commit message mechanism serves as a preliminary action that requires the UE to perform computational work before initiating full authentication. This creates a deterrent against DoS attacks because attackers would need to invest computational resources in generating valid commit messages for each targeted authentication attempt, rather than simply flooding the server with authentication requests that require expensive asymmetric decryption.
Solution Approach 2:
The patent converts the computational intensity of asymmetric cryptography from a vulnerability (DoS susceptibility) into a security feature. By requiring UEs to perform similar computational work (generating commit messages) as the server performs (verification and decryption), the system creates a more balanced security model where both parties demonstrate computational commitment, thereby filtering out automated DoS attacks that cannot sustain the required computational effort.
Data Source
AI summary
Methods of operating a user equipment (UE) in a mobile communication network are disclosed. An authentication process start message may be transmitted from the UE to the mobile communication network, wherein the authentication process start message includes an identifier for the UE. After transmitting the authentication process start message from the UE, a request commit message may be received from the mobile communication network. Responsive to receiving the request commit message, a response commit message may be transmitted to the mobile communication network. After transmitting the response commit message, an authentication challenge message may be received corresponding to the authentication process start message. Related methods of operating network nodes are also discussed.


