Circuit Breaker Trip Diagnosis Using Temperature and Magnetic Triggers

Resolve Bottlenecks,
Find Innovative Solutions
Generate Solutions

Solution Overview

Problem

Existing diagnostic devices for magnetothermal circuit breakers face challenges in reliably determining the cause of switching events, especially when current sensors saturate, and in varying operational conditions, leading to inaccurate diagnoses.

Innovation Solution

A diagnostic system that includes a switching device with a diagnostic module capable of detecting switching events and transmitting diagnostic data to external devices, using sensors to measure current and temperature, and a controller to differentiate between magnetic and thermal triggers, as well as manual interventions, while accounting for varying environmental conditions.

Engineering Contradictions & Design Principles

VSEngineering Contradiction Analysis

1Reliability

If current sensors are used to measure current intensity for diagnosing switching events, then diagnostic capability is provided, but measurement precision deteriorates when currents are very high causing sensor saturation

Engineering Contradiction:
Improvediagnostic reliabilityVSAvoidcurrent measurement precision
Core Design Contradiction:
ReliabilityVSMeasurement precision

Solution Approach 1:

The patent introduces an intermediary computational model that relates bimetallic strip deformation to current characteristics without requiring direct measurement of the current itself. The model uses the equation d²x/dt² + α(dx/dt) + βx = γI², where the bimetallic strip displacement x and its derivatives serve as intermediaries to infer current intensity and duration, avoiding sensor saturation issues while maintaining diagnostic accuracy.

Inventive Principle:
Principle #24Intermediary (Mediator)

Solution Approach 2:

The patent replaces the electrical measurement system (current sensors) with a mechanical measurement system (bimetallic strip displacement sensors). By measuring the mechanical displacement of the bimetallic strip and its derivatives, the system infers electrical current characteristics without directly measuring the current, thereby avoiding sensor saturation at high currents.

Inventive Principle:
Principle #28Mechanics substitution (Replace mechanical system)

2Adaptability or versatility

If bimetallic strip operation is used for thermal tripping, then response to lower current overloads is achieved, but diagnostic accuracy varies under real conditions compared to nominal operation

Engineering Contradiction:
Improveresponse range to different overload conditionsVSAvoiddiagnostic accuracy
Core Design Contradiction:
Adaptability or versatilityVSMeasurement precision

Solution Approach 1:

The patent implements a feedback mechanism where the actual bimetallic strip displacement is measured and fed back into the computational model. By continuously monitoring the displacement and its derivatives, the system adjusts its diagnosis to account for real operating conditions, ensuring accurate differentiation between magnetic and thermal tripping regardless of environmental variations from nominal conditions.

Inventive Principle:
Principle #23Feedback

Solution Approach 2:

The patent performs preliminary characterization of the bimetallic strip behavior by establishing the computational model parameters (α, β, γ) before actual operation. This preliminary action creates a reference framework that accounts for the specific bimetallic strip characteristics, enabling accurate diagnosis under varying real-world conditions by comparing actual measurements against the pre-established model.

Inventive Principle:
Principle #10Preliminary action

3Speed

If magnetic field mechanisms are used for rapid switching, then switching speed is improved for high current faults, but diagnostic differentiation from thermal tripping becomes more difficult

Engineering Contradiction:
Improveswitching speedVSAvoiddiagnostic differentiation reliability
Core Design Contradiction:
SpeedVSReliability

Solution Approach 1:

The patent applies dynamics by measuring not only the static displacement of the bimetallic strip but also its first derivative (velocity) and second derivative (acceleration). This dynamic measurement approach captures the transient behavior characteristics that differ between magnetic and thermal tripping, enabling reliable differentiation even when both mechanisms operate rapidly.

Inventive Principle:
Principle #15Dynamics

Solution Approach 2:

The patent establishes preliminary thresholds and behavioral patterns for magnetic versus thermal tripping responses before actual operation. By pre-characterizing the expected dynamic response patterns (displacement, velocity, acceleration profiles) for each tripping mechanism, the system can rapidly and reliably differentiate between them during actual switching events.

Inventive Principle:
Principle #10Preliminary action

Applied Scientific Principles

This section explains which scientific principles are used to turn an abstract innovation direction into a practical engineering solution.

Function Achieved in This Case

The system provides precise and reliable diagnosis of switching causes, even in conditions deviating from nominal temperatures, ensuring accurate intervention and safety by distinguishing between different trigger mechanisms and environmental influences.

Implementation Method 1

A first part of the switching system controls the opening of the switch when a magnetic field generated by the current (all or part of which circulates, for example, in a coil) is greater than or equal to a threshold

Methodology Applied
Scientific EffectMagnetic field: Magnetic Field

Implementation Method 2

when the magnetic field is greater than or equal to the threshold, the force exerted by this magnetic field on a moving element exceeds another force

Methodology Applied
Scientific EffectLorentz force: Lorentz Force

Implementation Method 3

A second part controls the opening of the switch when a circuit breaker temperature (caused by an overload) is greater than or equal to another threshold

Methodology Applied
Scientific EffectJoule heating: Joule Heating

Implementation Method 4

a bimetallic strip in contact with the conductor in which the current flows (or a bimetallic strip itself crossed by the current) deforms, beyond a certain temperature, to cause the opening of the switch

Methodology Applied
Scientific EffectBimetallic strip deformation: Bi-Metallic Strip

Implementation Method 5

a bimetallic strip in contact with the conductor in which the current flows deforms, beyond a certain temperature

Methodology Applied
Scientific EffectThermal expansion: Thermal Expansion

Data Source

PatentEP4016578B1Device for diagnosing a switching event, associated switching device and diagnostic method
Publication Date: 2025.01.29 SCHNEIDER ELECTRIC IND SAS
  • EP4016578B1 patent drawingFigure 1
  • EP4016578B1 patent drawingFigure 2

AI summary

Diagnostic device (20) for a switching device (10) comprising a switching element (35), a controller (80) and a triggering system (40), the switching element (35) being configured to switch between a first position and a second position, the triggering system (40) being suitable for controlling a switch when a first criterion or a second criterion is met, the first criterion being a first temperature greater than or equal to a temperature threshold, the second criterion being a magnetic field greater than or equal to a field threshold, the magnetic field being generated by an electric current flowing when the switching element (35) is in the first position.The diagnostic device (20) includes a sensor (70) configured to estimate values ​​of a second temperature, the controller (80) being configured to diagnose a switching as being due to the first criterion based on a value of the second temperature.