Comminutor Screen Tabs Eliminate Rag Accumulation
Find Innovative SolutionsGenerate Solutions
Solution Overview
Problem
The introduction of 'flushable' wipes and similar rag-like solids into wastewater treatment systems causes operational difficulties due to their mechanical strength, leading to accumulation and entanglement in piping and equipment, impeding flow and requiring frequent maintenance.
Innovation Solution
A comminutor screen with a straight-through rotating design featuring stationary cutter bars and smooth slots, with tabs spanning gaps to prevent accumulation, ensuring effective grinding and reduced maintenance by eliminating spaces for solids to snag.
Engineering Contradictions & Design Principles
Engineering Contradiction Analysis
1Ease of operation
If traditional comminutor designs are used, then grinding function is provided, but gaps and ledges form where rag-like materials can wrap and accumulate
Solution Approach 1:
The invention extracts and eliminates the harmful gaps, ledges, and transitions from the comminutor design by using a seamless screen with tabs that span between cutter bars, removing the spaces where materials can accumulate and wrap
Solution Approach 2:
Instead of having separate support structures that create gaps, the invention inverts the approach by making the screen itself the support structure with tabs that actively span and close the gaps between cutter bars
2Productivity
If stationary cutter bars are used for grinding, then size reduction is achieved, but gaps between cutter bars and supports create accumulation points
Solution Approach 1:
The invention merges the screen support structure with the gap-closing function by integrating tabs directly into the screen bars, combining structural support and gap elimination into a single component
Solution Approach 2:
The tabs are strategically positioned at specific locations where gaps between cutter bars and supports occur, providing localized gap closure precisely where needed without affecting overall grinding effectiveness
3Ease of manufacture
If screen slots have standard fabrication, then manufacturing is simple, but crevices form where solids can snag
Solution Approach 1:
The invention changes the geometric parameters of the screen slots by specifying smooth radii (e.g., R0.03 to R0.06 inches) at corners and transitions, eliminating sharp crevices that would cause solids to snag while maintaining manufacturability
4Reliability
If periodic maintenance is performed, then accumulation is cleared, but operational downtime occurs
Solution Approach 1:
The invention performs preliminary action by designing the comminutor to prevent accumulation in the first place through its seamless structure with spanned gaps, eliminating the need for periodic maintenance and operational downtime
Data Source
AI summary
A comminutor for shredding rag-like materials includes a frame member having a cutter bar that is affixed thereto and has a plurality of cutter teeth, and includes screen bars aligned with the cutter teeth. Each of the screen bars has an end that fits closely to its adjacent cutter tooth and the frame member so as to close a gap between the cutter tooth and the frame member. The end of the screen bar may include a flange that fits closely to the frame member and a tab proximate to the flange that fits closely to the cutter tooth. In an embodiment where the cutter tooth is flush with the frame member, the end of the screen bar includes a flange that fits closely to both frame member and the cutter tooth.