Crushable Spacer Geometry for Predictable Bolted Joint Failure

Resolve Bottlenecks,
Find Innovative Solutions
Generate Solutions

Solution Overview

Problem

Bolted joints in gas turbine engines face issues with inconsistent failure of crushable spacers under excessive loads, leading to unpredictable stress transfer and potential component failure due to undesirable force/deflection characteristics.

Innovation Solution

Incorporating a crushable spacer with a peripheral wall featuring at least one weakening element, such as slots, an hourglass shape, or discrete thin sections, to reduce buckling strength and promote rapid, predictable failure when loads exceed a predetermined stress.

Engineering Contradictions & Design Principles

VSEngineering Contradiction Analysis

1Reliability

If a crushable spacer with uniform wall thickness is used, then the spacer can resist bolted joint preload while retaining structural integrity, but the spacer experiences large elastic deflection and yielding before failure, causing inconsistent failure timing across multiple spacers

Engineering Contradiction:
Improvepredictability of spacer failureVSAvoiddeflection period before failure
Core Design Contradiction:
ReliabilityVSDuration of action of moving object

Solution Approach 1:

The patent applies preliminary action by incorporating weakening features (such as notches, grooves, or reduced thickness sections) into the spacer wall before the spacer is installed. These pre-defined weak points are strategically placed to ensure that when excessive load occurs, the spacer will fail at these predetermined locations rather than undergoing extensive elastic deflection and yielding. This pre-prepared failure path eliminates the inconsistent failure timing observed in uniform spacers, as all spacers with identical weakening features will fail at approximately the same load level.

Inventive Principle:
Principle #10Preliminary action

Solution Approach 2:

The patent applies parameter changes by modifying the wall thickness parameter of the spacer. Instead of using uniform wall thickness throughout, the spacer incorporates sections with reduced thickness (t1) compared to the main body thickness (t2). This parameter variation creates controlled weak points that significantly reduce the load required to initiate failure at those specific locations, thereby shortening the deflection period before failure and ensuring consistent failure timing across multiple spacers subjected to overload.

Inventive Principle:
Principle #35Parameter changes

2Strength

If a crushable spacer is designed to retain structural integrity under normal operation, then it can mitigate forces during normal engine operation, but under excessive load it may transfer extreme forces to surrounding components causing unpredictable failures

Engineering Contradiction:
Improvestructural integrity of spacerVSAvoidunpredictable stress transfer to components
Core Design Contradiction:
StrengthVSObject-affected harmful factors

Solution Approach 1:

The patent applies preliminary action by pre-defining failure locations through weakening features in the spacer wall. This ensures that under excessive load, the spacer will fail in a controlled manner at these predetermined weak points rather than transferring unpredictable extreme forces to surrounding components. The weakening features act as sacrificial elements that absorb the excessive energy, protecting the main structural components from unpredictable failure modes.

Inventive Principle:
Principle #10Preliminary action

Solution Approach 2:

The patent applies the blessing in disguise principle by intentionally creating weak points (harmful features) in the spacer wall that reduce its overall strength. However, this apparent weakness becomes beneficial under excessive load conditions, as these weak points ensure controlled, predictable failure that protects surrounding components. The harmful feature (reduced wall thickness) transforms into a protective mechanism that prevents more serious damage to critical engine components.

Inventive Principle:
Principle #22Blessing in disguise (Convert harm into benefit)

Applied Scientific Principles

This section explains which scientific principles are used to turn an abstract innovation direction into a practical engineering solution.

Function Achieved in This Case

The design ensures consistent and controlled failure of the spacer, reducing the risk of unpredictable stress transfer and maintaining structural integrity during extreme events, thereby enhancing safety and reliability of the engine.

Implementation Method 1

the force/deflection characteristics are undesirable. Specifically, there is a region of elastic deflection, followed by yielding

Methodology Applied
Scientific EffectElastic deformation: Elasticity

Implementation Method 2

followed by yielding, followed by eventual tensile failure. The crushable spacer can experience a very large degree of yielding before spacer column buckling occurs

Methodology Applied
Scientific EffectPlastic deformation: Plasticity

Implementation Method 3

The crushable spacer can experience a very large degree of yielding before spacer column buckling occurs

Methodology Applied
Scientific EffectBuckling:

Data Source

PatentUS11066958B2Crushable spacer and bolted joint for a gas turbine engine
Publication Date: 2021.07.20 GENERAL ELECTRIC CO
  • US11066958B2 patent drawing
  • US11066958B2 patent drawing
  • US11066958B2 patent drawing

AI summary

A bolted joint apparatus includes: a first component including a first row of first bolt holes extending therethrough; a second component including a second row of second bolt holes extending therethrough wherein the second bolt holes are aligned coaxially with the first bolt holes, a plurality of fasteners, each of fasteners disposed through aligned pairs of the first and second bolt holes to couple together the first and second components, each of the fasteners including a shank; and crushable spacers disposed around the shanks of the fasteners, the crushable spacers clamped in compression between the fasteners and one of the components, wherein each of the crushable spacers has a tubular body interconnecting first and second enlarged ends, the tubular body being defined by a peripheral wall which incorporates at least one weakening feature.