Deer-Proof Garden Netting with Segmented Skeleton
Find Innovative SolutionsGenerate Solutions
Solution Overview
Problem
Current methods for protecting gardens from deer and other animal pests are either ineffective, costly, or restrictive, as they require tall fences, synthetic chemicals, or frequent reapplication of natural deterrents, and existing netting solutions are either too weak for deer or exclude pollinators.
Innovation Solution
A netting kit comprising a skeleton that can be configured in multiple shapes, panels with overlapping cells to prevent deer access while allowing pollinators, and webbing material that interconnects these panels to form a secure, flexible, and foldable seam without the need for posts or frequent reapplication.
Engineering Contradictions & Design Principles
Engineering Contradiction Analysis
1Reliability
If a tall fence (at least eight feet) is used to exclude deer, then deer-proof protection is achieved, but the structure requires deep poles or posts for stability and cannot be easily relocated
Solution Approach 1:
The fence is divided into multiple panels that can be assembled together to form the complete enclosure. Each panel is a separate, manageable component that can be easily transported and installed without requiring deep post installation, while collectively providing the full eight-foot height needed for deer-proof protection
Solution Approach 2:
The fence structure is designed to be dynamic and reconfigurable rather than static. Panels can be assembled and disassembled as needed, allowing the fence to be moved, stored, or adjusted throughout the growing season without permanent installation
2Ease of operation
If netting is used to protect plants, then the structure is portable and easy to install, but it is too weak to prevent deer from jumping over or knocking it down
Solution Approach 1:
The netting is organized into rigid panel structures with defined edges and corners that provide structural integrity. These segmented panels resist deformation from deer contact while maintaining overall portability through their modular design
Solution Approach 2:
The fence combines netting material with supporting panel frameworks to create a composite structure. The netting provides the protective barrier while the panel framework adds the necessary rigidity and strength to withstand deer pressure
3Reliability
If netting with small openings is used to exclude deer, then deer-proof protection is achieved, but pollinators cannot access the plants
Solution Approach 1:
The fence panels incorporate localized access points or larger opening sections at strategic locations where pollinator access is needed, while maintaining smaller openings in the majority of the structure for deer exclusion. This creates different functional zones within the same enclosure
4Reliability
If permanent fence structures are installed for deer protection, then effective deer-proofing is achieved, but covenant-controlled communities restrict the height and style of such structures
Solution Approach 1:
The fence is designed as a temporary, seasonal structure that can be installed and removed as needed, rather than a permanent installation. This dynamic approach allows compliance with community restrictions while providing effective protection during the growing season
Solution Approach 2:
The fence panels are designed to be configurable in different heights and configurations. The effective eight-foot height for deer exclusion can be achieved through panel assembly while the individual panel dimensions and overall structure style can be adjusted to meet community aesthetic requirements
Data Source
AI summary
A netting enclosure kit comprises a skeleton configured to operate in a plurality of configurations between a first, partially expanded configuration and a second, fully expanded configuration, a netting enclosure comprising a plurality of panels configured to be joined together to enclose or hang from the skeleton in each of the plurality of configurations, a first webbing configured to connect to a first portion of the netting enclosure, a second webbing configured to connect to a second portion of the netting enclosure, and a fastener configured to attached to the first webbing and to the second webbing to form an openable and closeable seam.