Ductile Patch B-Pillar Structure for Controlled Lateral Impact Deformation
Find Innovative SolutionsGenerate Solutions
Solution Overview
Problem
Existing methods for manufacturing vehicle body-in-white components, such as B-pillars, face challenges in creating zones with varying ductility to effectively absorb impact energy without adding unnecessary weight or compromising structural integrity, as they often result in excessive deformation or breakage during lateral crashes.
Innovation Solution
A method involving a U-shaped metal structural component with a ductile patch welded to a steel blank, where the patch covers an opening in the component, enhancing mechanical continuity and energy absorption by deforming upon impact, while maintaining structural strength and reducing weight.
Engineering Contradictions & Design Principles
Engineering Contradiction Analysis
1Strength
If a higher ductility material is used across the whole width of the controlled intrusion zone in the B-pillar, then the shock absorption capability is improved, but the B-pillar becomes prone to overall fold and breakage during lateral impact crashes
Solution Approach 1:
The patent applies local quality by creating a ductility gradient within the B-pillar structure. A higher-ductility patch is strategically positioned only in the controlled intrusion zone where shock absorption is needed, while the rest of the B-pillar maintains high-strength material properties. This localized application of different material properties allows the structure to absorb impact energy in specific regions without compromising overall structural integrity.
Solution Approach 2:
The patent employs composite materials by combining two different steel grades with distinct ductility characteristics. The high-strength steel provides structural integrity and load-bearing capacity, while the higher-ductility steel patch provides controlled deformation and energy absorption. This composite approach creates a multi-functional B-pillar that simultaneously achieves strength and controlled ductility in different regions.
2Reliability
If reinforcing members are added to prevent B-pillar breakage, then the structural integrity is improved, but the vehicle weight increases and the overall form is affected
Solution Approach 1:
The patent merges the reinforcement function directly into the B-pillar structure by integrating the higher-ductility patch as an inherent component during the forming process. Instead of adding separate reinforcing members that would increase weight and complexity, the ductile patch is welded to the blank before forming, creating a unified structure where the patch and blank together form the load-bearing B-pillar. This integration eliminates the need for additional discrete reinforcement elements.
Solution Approach 2:
The patent applies preliminary action by pre-welding the higher-ductility patch to the blank before the forming process. This preliminary preparation ensures that the ductile reinforcement is already in place to prevent breakage during subsequent forming operations and to provide structural integrity before the component is installed in the vehicle, avoiding the need for post-assembly reinforcement additions.
3Strength
If cut-outs are made in the blank to accommodate reinforcement patches, then the shock absorption is improved, but the overall integrity of the part is reduced
Solution Approach 1:
The patent inverts the conventional approach by instead of cutting out sections to add reinforcement, it welds the higher-ductility patch to the intact blank and then forms the entire assembly. This inversion maintains the continuity of the blank material and avoids creating discontinuities or cut-outs that would compromise structural integrity, while still achieving the desired shock absorption through the ductile patch.
Applied Scientific Principles
This section explains which scientific principles are used to turn an abstract innovation direction into a practical engineering solution.
Function Achieved in This Case
The solution effectively absorbs a high amount of impact energy by deforming the ductile patch and connected lateral walls, maintaining the component's integrity and reducing the risk of breakage, while simplifying the manufacturing process and minimizing material usage.
Implementation Method 1
The patch is made of a metal having greater ductility than the material of the blank... upon an impact on a portion of the bottom in which the patch covers the opening, the metal structural component, and more in particular the patch, deforms absorbing a high amount of the impact energy
Implementation Method 2
Welding a patch to the blank, for example by means of spot welding, so as to cover the opening... The welding process generates a mechanical joint between the patch and the blank
Data Source
Figure 1~2
Figure 3A~3B
Figure 4A~4B
AI summary
Method of manufacturing a metal structural component (E) for a vehicle, comprising the steps of a) providing a planar blank (B); b) cutting out the blank (B) to create an opening (A) having a first portion (Q) and wherein the first portion (Q) of the opening (A) has a second length (lt) in a first transverse direction (T); c) welding a patch (P) to the blank (B) so as to cover the opening (A), the patch (P) being made of the metal having greater ductility than the material of the blank (B); d) stamping the assembly formed by the blank (B) and the patch (P) to obtain the component (E).