Immutable EHR Ledger Architecture Without Blockchain Mining
Find Innovative SolutionsGenerate Solutions
Solution Overview
Problem
Conventional database systems lose historical data changes due to overwrite operations, and existing blockchain implementations for immutability require costly mining processes, making them impractical for efficient electronic health record storage.
Innovation Solution
A system utilizing a blockchain with a transaction blockchain API, formatting module, and messaging module to serialize and store data operations on an immutable ledger, optimizing data storage without costly mining systems.
Engineering Contradictions & Design Principles
Engineering Contradiction Analysis
1Reliability
If blockchain technology based on proof of work is used to achieve true immutable database operation history, then data immutability is improved, but resource consumption and cost increase significantly
Solution Approach 1:
The patent extracts the core immutability function from the resource-intensive proof of work consensus mechanism. It implements a simplified immutable ledger that records database operations without requiring mining, validation nodes, or complex consensus protocols. The system achieves immutability through cryptographic hashing and sequential block chaining while removing the energy-consuming proof of work element entirely.
Solution Approach 2:
The patent replaces expensive, resource-intensive blockchain mining with a lightweight, efficient data structure that achieves the same immutability goal at minimal cost. The immutable ledger uses simple cryptographic operations and sequential writing rather than repeated mining attempts, dramatically reducing computational resources and energy consumption while maintaining data integrity.
2Productivity
If database update operations are used to apply changes to data records, then data modification efficiency is improved, but historical data loss occurs
Solution Approach 1:
The patent performs preliminary recording of the current data state before applying updates. Each database operation is first captured as an immutable record in the ledger, preserving the historical state. Then the update is applied to the current data. This preliminary action ensures that historical information is preserved while allowing efficient modifications to proceed.
Solution Approach 2:
The patent introduces an intermediary immutable ledger that sits between the database and the update operations. Instead of directly overwriting data, updates are mediated through the ledger which records the operation. This intermediary layer preserves historical data by capturing each change while still allowing efficient updates to be applied to the current state.
3Loss of information
If database operation logging is enabled to preserve change history, then data recovery capability is improved, but data integrity and immutability are compromised
Solution Approach 1:
The patent inverts the traditional approach by making the log immutable rather than the database state. Instead of maintaining a mutable database with optional logging, the system creates an immutable ledger that records all operations. The ledger becomes the source of truth, and the database state is derived from it. This inversion ensures both complete history preservation and data integrity simultaneously.
Solution Approach 2:
The patent replaces expensive, complex logging mechanisms with a simple, lightweight immutable ledger structure. The ledger uses basic cryptographic hashing and sequential block writing rather than complex logging infrastructure. This simplified approach achieves complete history preservation and data integrity at minimal resource cost, unlike traditional logging systems that compromise integrity.
Data Source
AI summary
A system and method of immutable electronic health record data storage is presented. The present disclosure provides for a system integrated into a practical application with meaningful limitations to provide a system having an ‘immutable data storage protocol’ used to capture database operations on an immutable ledger. The protocol can consist of one or more ‘operation codes.’ The immutable electronic health record data storage system can provide a blockchain, transaction blockchain API, a blockchain writer API, a formatting module, and a messaging module, among others, that can format, process, and store data according to an immutable data storage protocol.


