IP Document Annotation System Using Nested Structures
Find Innovative SolutionsGenerate Solutions
Solution Overview
Problem
Current systems lack the ability to effectively manage and associate intellectual property assets, making it difficult for professionals to analyze, access, and present related information, particularly in scenarios involving multiple intellectual property documents and complex relationships between them.
Innovation Solution
A computer-based system that allows for the annotation, linking, and management of intellectual property documents, enabling users to mark-up, edit, and traverse document relations, manage multiple versions, and associate annotations with specific document elements, using features like XML format, binary format, and audio data, while supporting user-defined attributes and references.
Engineering Contradictions & Design Principles
Engineering Contradiction Analysis
1Loss of information
If conventional systems are used to manage intellectual property assets, then basic document storage is possible, but the ability to associate, analyze, and traverse relationships between multiple intellectual property documents is lost
Solution Approach 1:
The patent implements nested structures where annotations can contain references to other annotations, and documents can contain references to other documents, creating a hierarchical nested system. This allows complex relationships to be represented through multiple levels of nesting, where each level adds another dimension of association without requiring a completely new system structure.
Solution Approach 2:
The patent introduces annotations as intermediary elements that mediate between intellectual property documents. These annotations serve as connectors that can reference multiple documents and contain descriptive information about the relationships, effectively acting as intermediaries that link disparate assets without requiring direct complex inter-document relationships.
2Adaptability or versatility
If multiple intellectual property documents are associated to capture complex relationships, then comprehensive analysis capability is improved, but the complexity of determining and managing associations grows geometrically
Solution Approach 1:
The patent segments complex relationships into individual annotation elements, each handling a specific relationship or aspect. Rather than managing one large complex association structure, the system breaks down relationships into discrete, manageable annotation units that can be independently created, modified, and traversed.
Solution Approach 2:
The patent adds the annotation dimension as an intermediate layer between documents, transforming the relationship management problem from direct document-to-document links into document-to-annotation-to-document paths. This dimensional addition provides a buffer that simplifies the overall system complexity while enabling versatile analysis.
3Loss of information
If manual annotation and linking of intellectual property documents is performed, then detailed associations can be documented, but the process becomes extremely time-consuming and difficult to integrate information
Solution Approach 1:
The patent implements self-service capabilities where the system automatically traverses and retrieves linked documents and annotations based on user actions. Once annotations and links are created, the system autonomously manages the complexity of traversing relationships, retrieving related information, and presenting integrated views without requiring manual intervention for each information retrieval task.
Solution Approach 2:
The patent incorporates feedback mechanisms where the system provides users with automated information about associations and relationships as they work with documents. This feedback loop helps users understand the integrated information structure and makes the annotation process more efficient by showing the immediate impact and connections of their actions.
Data Source
AI summary
A computer-enabled system, method, and medium is provided to support analyzing intellectual property documents by linking and annotating patents, copyrights, trademarks, license agreements, and other types of intellectual property documents. The invention is suitable for use by intellectual property professionals in memorializing their thought processes, work products, and reasoning, whether in preliminary or final form, and is flexible to support development and use of a rich linked set representing complex relationships in an intellectual property portfolio. Optionally, marked up, linked documents are divided into data streams, one of the data streams containing the original document for mark-up, and one other data stream containing the annotation data. The marked-up document may be further revised and/or annotated, even by multiple users. The system provides that the same document such as a patent may be centrally stored but independently marked-up by different users (or groups of users). The system further extracts from such a marked-up document such annotation data with any changes thereto, and provides one or more data streams, containing the annotation data for storage and or later use.