On-Board Message Repeater for Vehicle Consist Communications
Find Innovative SolutionsGenerate Solutions
Solution Overview
Problem
In distributed power railroad train operations, the emergency brake application is not uniformly applied across the entire train due to the time it takes for brake pipe pressure reduction to propagate, leading to inconsistent braking forces at railcars distant from the lead unit.
Innovation Solution
Implementing a priority message protocol that allows messages to leapfrog down the train, with remote units retransmitting commands and status messages, and using an on-board message repeater system to ensure message delivery and error correction, especially in environments where direct communication between the lead unit and remote units is obstructed.
Engineering Contradictions & Design Principles
Engineering Contradiction Analysis
1Device complexity
If brake pipe pressure reduction is used to apply brakes at remote units, then the braking system can be simplified, but the brake application becomes non-uniform and slower at distant railcars
Solution Approach 1:
The patent replaces the purely mechanical pneumatic brake pipe pressure reduction system with a hybrid system that uses radio frequency electromagnetic communication to transmit brake commands to remote units. This substitution allows simultaneous brake application at all units without relying on pressure propagation speed through the brake pipe, thereby increasing brake application speed while maintaining system simplicity.
Solution Approach 2:
The patent introduces a radio frequency communication system as an intermediary between the lead unit and remote units to transmit brake commands. This intermediary enables fast, simultaneous communication of brake application instructions to all units without relying on the slow propagation of pneumatic pressure through the brake pipe, thus resolving the contradiction between system simplicity and brake application speed.
2Speed
If radio frequency communication is used to transmit brake commands to remote units, then brake application speed increases, but communication reliability decreases in obstructed environments
Solution Approach 1:
The patent implements message repeating where each remote unit receives and retransmits the brake command message to subsequent units. This copying mechanism ensures that even if a message is obstructed or lost between two units, adjacent units can still receive and forward the message, thereby maintaining communication reliability while preserving the fast propagation speed of radio frequency communication.
Solution Approach 2:
The patent incorporates status reply messages that provide feedback about message reception and execution status at each remote unit. This feedback mechanism allows the lead unit to verify that brake commands were successfully transmitted and executed, enabling reliability monitoring and correction of any communication failures in obstructed environments while maintaining the speed advantage of RF communication.
3Ease of operation
If multiple remote units are directly coupled via MU lines, then control coordination is improved, but the system cannot handle obstructed communication environments
Solution Approach 1:
The patent creates a universal communication system that combines both MU line coupling for local coordination and radio frequency communication for distant units. This multi-functional approach allows the system to handle diverse operating conditions including both directly coupled and remotely located units, as well as both clear and obstructed communication environments, thereby improving environmental adaptability while maintaining control coordination.
Solution Approach 2:
The patent segments the train communication system into multiple independent communication paths: MU lines for directly coupled units and radio frequency links for remote units. This segmentation allows each path to function independently based on its suitability for the specific operational condition, enabling the system to adapt to various environments while maintaining overall control coordination through the distributed architecture.
Data Source
AI summary
A communications method for a vehicle consist (10) comprising a lead vehicle (14) having a first (29A) and second (29B) antenna associated with a respective first (28A) and second (28B) transceiver and a remote vehicle (12A/12B/12C) having a third (29A) and fourth (29B) antenna associated with a respective third (28A) and fourth (28B) transceiver. The method further comprises transmitting an outbound message from the first transceiver (28A) via the first antenna (29A) or from the second transceiver (28B) via the second antenna (29B), the outbound message comprising a plurality of message bytes, receiving the outbound message at the third (29A) and fourth (29B) antennas and associated third (28A) and fourth (28B) transceivers, determining correct bytes and error bytes in the outbound message as received at the third transceiver (28A), determining correct bytes and error bytes in the outbound message as received at the fourth transceiver (28B), and assembling a reconstructed message using correct bytes from the message received at the third transceiver (28A) and the fourth transceiver (28B).


