Multilayer Nitride Coatings for Turbine Blade Erosion Resistance

Solution Overview

Problem

Conventional erosion-resistant coatings fail to provide adequate protection against both small and large particle erosion media, particularly large particle erosion, leading to premature failure and performance degradation in turbomachines.

Innovation Solution

A multilayer coating system comprising alternating sublayer systems with stoichiometric and nonstoichiometric nitride-containing layers separated by metal-containing interlayers, where each sublayer system has a thickness greater than 0.4 microns, enhancing both hardness and toughness to address the limitations of conventional coatings.

Engineering Contradictions & Design Principles

VSEngineering Contradiction Analysis

1Strength

If conventional single-layer or multi-material coatings are used to provide hardness, then erosion resistance to fine particles is improved, but toughness decreases and vulnerability to brittle fracture increases under large particle impact

Engineering Contradiction:
Core Design Contradiction:
StrengthVSReliability

Solution Approach 1:

The patent applies composite materials by creating a multilayer coating system with alternating hard compound layers (providing hardness) and metal-containing interlayers (providing toughness). This composite structure allows the coating to simultaneously exhibit high hardness for erosion resistance and high toughness to prevent brittle fracture under large particle impact, resolving the contradiction between these two properties.

Inventive Principle:
Principle #40Composite materials

Solution Approach 2:

The patent segments the coating into multiple thin layers with alternating properties rather than using a single homogeneous layer. The hard compound layers are separated by metal-containing interlayers, creating a segmented structure where each layer contributes different mechanical properties. This segmentation allows the overall coating to achieve both high hardness and high toughness, preventing catastrophic failure under particle erosion.

Inventive Principle:
Principle #1Segmentation

2Object-affected harmful factors

If coating hardness is increased to improve erosion resistance, then resistance to fine particle erosion is enhanced, but the coating becomes more brittle and susceptible to spalling under large particle impact

Engineering Contradiction:
Core Design Contradiction:
Object-affected harmful factorsVSStability of the object's composition

Solution Approach 1:

The coating uses a composite material structure with hard compound layers providing erosion resistance and metal-containing interlayers providing ductility. This composite approach allows the coating to resist fine particle erosion through the hard layers while the metal interlayers prevent brittleness and spalling under large particle impact by absorbing energy and preventing crack propagation.

Inventive Principle:
Principle #40Composite materials

Solution Approach 2:

The patent applies local quality by giving different regions of the coating different properties: the hard compound layers are positioned to provide local erosion resistance where particles impact, while the metal-containing interlayers are positioned to provide local toughness and prevent spalling. This spatial differentiation of properties allows the coating to simultaneously address erosion resistance and brittleness issues.

Inventive Principle:
Principle #3Local quality

3Quantity of substance

If thin coatings are applied to reduce material usage, then cost is reduced, but the coating becomes more susceptible to spalling and substrate exposure leading to premature failure

Engineering Contradiction:
Core Design Contradiction:
Quantity of substanceVSReliability

Solution Approach 1:

The patent segments the coating into multiple thin layers rather than using a single thick layer. This segmentation allows the total coating thickness to be reduced while maintaining durability, as each thin layer can be optimized for its specific function and the cumulative effect of multiple layers provides both protection and toughness to prevent spalling and substrate exposure.

Inventive Principle:
Principle #1Segmentation

Solution Approach 2:

The coating uses a composite material structure where thin alternating layers of hard compounds and metal-containing materials provide both protection and toughness. This composite approach allows reduced overall thickness while maintaining reliability, as the metal interlayers prevent spalling even in thin coating configurations, preventing substrate exposure and premature failure.

Inventive Principle:
Principle #40Composite materials

Applied Scientific Principles

This section explains which scientific principles are used to turn an abstract innovation direction into a practical engineering solution.

Function Achieved in This Case

The multilayer coating system significantly improves erosion resistance by extending the lifespan of the coating under large particle impact, maintaining performance across both small and large particle sizes, and offering cost advantages over conventional multi-material processes.

Implementation Method 1

Physical and chemical vapor deposited coatings, such as titanium nitride coatings and zirconium nitride coatings, have been used to provide a protective layer having good hardness characteristics.

Methodology Applied
Scientific EffectPhysical Vapour Deposition: Physical Vapour Deposition

Implementation Method 2

Physical and chemical vapor deposited coatings, such as titanium nitride coatings and zirconium nitride coatings, have been used to provide a protective layer having good hardness characteristics.

Methodology Applied
Scientific EffectChemical Vapour Deposition: Chemical Vapour Deposition

Implementation Method 3

Multilayer hard compound materials have been found to have simultaneously high hardness and high toughness. The high hardness is an inherent property of hard compounds and the high toughness is attributed to the formation of a coherent or partly coherent interface boundary between two different hard compound layers.

Methodology Applied
Scientific EffectComposite Materials: Composite Materials

Data Source

PatentUS8097129B2Multilayer nitride-containing coatings
Publication Date: 2012.01.17
  • US8097129B2 patent drawing
  • US8097129B2 patent drawing
  • US8097129B2 patent drawing

AI summary

This invention relates to erosion resistant coatings comprising at least 2 sublayer systems in which each sublayer system is separated from another by an interlayer, wherein (i) each sublayer system is the same or different and comprises at least 4 layers, (ii) said layers comprise alternating layers of a nitride-containing compound of stoichiometric composition and a nitride-containing compound of nonstoichiometric composition, (iii) each sublayer system has a thickness of greater than about 0.4 microns, and (iv) each interlayer is the same or different and comprises a metal-containing compound. This invention also relates to a method for producing the coatings and to articles, e.g., gas turbine compressor rotor blade and stator vanes, coated with the coatings.