PLFOG99 Apple Tree Compact Growth and Early Maturity
Find Innovative SolutionsGenerate Solutions
Solution Overview
Problem
Existing apple tree varieties like 'Cripps Pink' lack compact growth habits and early maturity, limiting their fruit production efficiency and adaptability in different growing conditions.
Innovation Solution
The development of the 'PLFOG99' apple tree variety, which exhibits a compact growth habit and early maturity, achieved through propagation from a chance limb mutation on a 'Cripps Pink' tree, showcasing a unique combination of columnar growth and spur-bearing fruit production.
Engineering Contradictions & Design Principles
Engineering Contradiction Analysis
1Loss of time
If 'Cripps Pink' apple tree is used, then fruit quality is maintained, but growth habit is not compact and maturity is not early
Solution Approach 1:
The patent applies segmentation by identifying and isolating a specific mutated limb from the 'Cripps Pink' tree that exhibits compact columnar growth and early fruiting characteristics. This segmented approach allows the desired traits (early maturity and compact habit) to be separated from the parent variety's typical growth pattern, enabling propagation of only the beneficial segments through tissue culture techniques.
Solution Approach 2:
The patent applies local quality by focusing on a specific localized mutation within the tree - a particular limb that displays different growth characteristics compared to the rest of the tree. This mutated limb produces compact, columnar growth and early fruiting, while the rest of the tree maintains normal 'Cripps Pink' characteristics. The invention propagates only this specific local variant to achieve the desired traits.
2Productivity
If traditional apple tree varieties are used, then adaptability is maintained, but productivity is limited due to lack of compact growth and early maturity
Solution Approach 1:
The patent applies parameter changes by inducing and selecting for specific phenotypic parameters - namely compact columnar growth habit, early fruit maturity (up to two weeks earlier than 'Cripps Pink'), and spur-bearing fruit production. Through controlled propagation and selection, these parameter changes are fixed in the new variety, enabling higher productivity while maintaining adaptability through stable genetic characteristics.
Solution Approach 2:
The patent applies copying by creating multiple copies of the mutated limb through tissue culture and propagation techniques. Approximately 100 trees were propagated from the original mutated limb, and three generations have been observed to be stable and true to type. This copying process preserves the desirable traits while enabling widespread planting and evaluation.
3Reliability
If more trees are propagated for evaluation, then reliability of variety is improved, but complexity of propagation and evaluation process increases
Solution Approach 1:
The patent applies feedback by systematically evaluating the propagated trees over multiple generations and using this feedback to confirm stability and true-to-type characteristics. Three generations have been observed with no off-types, providing reliable feedback that the variety is stable. This feedback mechanism justifies the investment in propagating multiple trees for evaluation.
Solution Approach 2:
The patent applies preliminary action by propagating trees before full-scale planting to evaluate and confirm trait stability. The initial propagation of 100 trees and observation of three generations occurred before widespread commercial planting. This preliminary evaluation phase ensures reliability is established before the variety is deployed, preventing future problems.
Data Source
AI summary
‘PLFOG99’ is a new and distinct apple tree notable for its compact tree type, spur bearing habit, and early maturity as compared to ‘Cripps Pink’ and other known cultivars.