Differential RF Front End Filtering for Harmonic Cancellation
Find Innovative SolutionsGenerate Solutions
Solution Overview
Problem
Power amplifier architectures in radio frequency circuits experience performance degradation due to self-generated carrier signals, noise from external sources, and spurious emissions, particularly from harmonic distortion caused by differential power amplifiers and passive components like acoustic wave filters, leading to interference between transmitter and receiver channels.
Innovation Solution
Implementing a pair of band pass filters in a differential topology within the power amplifier signal path, using bulk acoustic wave filters, to cancel even order harmonics and improve RF isolation, thereby reducing the need for aggressive filtering and associated insertion losses.
Engineering Contradictions & Design Principles
Engineering Contradiction Analysis
1Reliability
If a differential power amplifier is used to provide natural isolation from RF interference, then RF isolation is improved, but harmonic distortion and spurious emissions are generated
Solution Approach 1:
The patent converts the harmful even-order harmonics generated by the differential power amplifier into a beneficial cancellation mechanism. By using a differential filter configuration where identical even-order harmonics are generated in both differential signal paths and then subtracted from each other, the harmful harmonics are canceled out while the desired fundamental signal is preserved and enhanced.
2Object-generated harmful factors
If aggressive filtering is used to reduce harmonic distortion, then harmonic suppression is improved, but insertion losses increase
Solution Approach 1:
Instead of using aggressive filtering to suppress harmonics, the patent converts the harmonic problem into a benefit by utilizing the harmonics themselves for cancellation. The differential filter generates identical even-order harmonics in both paths, which then cancel each other out through differential subtraction, achieving harmonic suppression without the need for aggressive filtering and associated insertion losses.
Solution Approach 2:
The patent changes the approach from filtering (removing harmonics) to cancellation (using harmonics). By modifying the filter configuration to a differential topology, the system changes the parameter of harmonic handling from suppression to exploitation, where the same harmonic components that were previously harmful are now used constructively for cancellation.
3Ease of operation
If a balun is used to convert differential output to single ended signal, then signal conversion is achieved, but harmonic cancellation is limited
Solution Approach 1:
The patent segments the filtering function into two identical differential paths, each containing its own bandpass filter. This segmentation allows each filter to generate identical even-order harmonics that can then be canceled through differential subtraction, providing superior harmonic cancellation compared to a single filter followed by a balun conversion.
Solution Approach 2:
The patent employs asymmetric signal paths in terms of their function within the differential pair. While the physical structure may be symmetric, the signal processing is asymmetric - one path's harmonics are subtracted from the other path's harmonics, creating a differential cancellation effect that is more effective than symmetric single-ended filtering.
Data Source
AI summary
A radio frequency circuit includes a transmit power amplifier, a differential transmit signal path having first and second paths, and first and second baluns. The first balun can be configured to convert a single ended transmit signal into a differential transmit signal, and the second balun can be configured to convert the differential transmit signal back to a single ended transmit signal. The circuit can also include a pair of transmit filters between the first and second baluns and including a first transmit filter connected in the first path and a second transmit filter connected in the second path. The second balun cancels harmonic noise generated by the pair of transmit filters.


