Energy storage multi-scene applicability analysis method and system based on subjective and objective weights
Through the multi-scene applicability analysis method for energy storage based on subjective and objective weights, combined with DEMATEL and anti-entropy weight method, the problem of insufficient consideration of the application scenario diversity and error of the existing multi-scene applicability analysis method in energy storage is solved, and the problem of insufficient consideration of the application scenarios of the existing multi-scene applicability analysis method is achieved. Scientific and reliable energy storage solution evaluation has improved the configuration efficiency of energy storage devices and the operating stability of the power system.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202410878040.X
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-07-02
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-19
- Estimated Expiration
- Not applicable · inactive patent
AI Technical Summary
The existing multi-scenario applicability analysis methods for energy storage are insufficient in the construction of application scenarios, resulting in insufficient applicability of the evaluation system, and fluctuations and errors in the connection between mathematical models and system data, which fails to fully consider the changes in the actual physical system.
Using a multi-scenario applicability analysis method for energy storage based on subjective and objective weights, the optimal energy storage solution is determined by establishing a technical index set, constructing an evaluation index data matrix, calculating subjective and objective weights, and fusion. The power law is used to improve the scientificity and objectivity of weight calculations.
A more accurate and objective energy storage plan evaluation was achieved, taking into account the relative importance and differences between technical indicators, avoiding the subjective risk of expert scoring, and obtaining a more scientific and reliable comprehensive weight, which improves the energy storage device. scientific configuration and efficient operation of power systems.
Smart Images

Figure CN118982132A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Background Art
[0002] Grid-side energy storage technology plays a vital role in the current energy transformation and modernization of the power system. For example, it can quickly respond to changes in grid demand, provide necessary frequency regulation and peak regulation services, and help the grid maintain balance and stability under load fluctuations and unstable renewable energy output. However, different types of energy storage have certain performance differences in terms of economy, technology, environment, safety, etc. In addition, the operation scenarios of new power systems tend to be diversified. Researching and designing a process-based multi-scenario applicability analysis method for energy storage to clarify the fit between different types of energy storage and different system operation scenarios is of great significance to the scientific configuration of energy storage devices and the efficient operation of power systems.
[0003] The Chinese invention patent proposes a method and system for evaluating the suitability of energy storage in a power system (CN201610907609). By establishing a comprehensive application scenario including the power system generation side, transmission side, distribution side and user side, combined with the basic evaluation data of the energy storage device, each indicator is evaluated independently and comprehensively; and the above functions are realized by a data collection module for the application scenario of the energy storage device and an evaluation module system. It overcomes the problem that there are many evaluation factors for energy storage devices and it is difficult to integrate the evaluation, making the evaluation results more scientific and reasonable, and obtaining a multi-faceted fitness evaluation system, but it mainly relies on the connection between mathematical models and system data, and does not take into account the fluctuations and errors that may exist in the actual physical system.
[0004] The Chinese invention patent provides a comprehensive evaluation method for power supply side energy storage system (CN202310834422). In this method, a comprehensive evaluation index system for energy storage power station is first established, and the comprehensive weight of the index is determined based on fuzzy set theory and hierarchical analysis method theory. The energy storage scheme is evaluated based on the comprehensive evaluation index system for energy storage power station and the comprehensive weight of each layer of evaluation index, and the results are obtained and the corresponding cases are presented. The disadvantage is that the diversity in the construction of application scenarios is insufficient, resulting in insufficient applicability of the evaluation system. Summary of the invention
[0005] The technical problem to be solved by the present invention is to address the deficiencies of the prior art and specifically provide a method and system for analyzing the applicability of energy storage in multiple scenarios based on subjective and objective weights, as follows:
[0006] 1) In the first aspect, the present invention provides a method for analyzing the applicability of energy storage in multiple scenarios based on subjective and objective weights. The specific technical solution is as follows:
[0007] Establish a set of technical indicators for analyzing the applicability of energy storage solutions in multiple scenarios;
[0008] Obtain and construct an evaluation indicator data matrix based on the data of each technical indicator in the technical indicator set;
[0009] Process the direct impact matrix corresponding to the technical indicator set and calculate the subjective weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios;
[0010] Based on the evaluation index data matrix, calculate the objective weight of each technical index in different scenarios;
[0011] The subjective weight and objective weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios are integrated to obtain the comprehensive weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios;
[0012] According to the comprehensive weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios, the optimal energy storage solution in different scenarios is determined.
[0013] On the basis of the above scheme, the energy storage multi-scenario applicability analysis method based on subjective and objective weights of the present invention can also be improved as follows.
[0014] Furthermore, based on the data of each technical indicator in the technical indicator set, an evaluation indicator data matrix is constructed, including:
[0015] According to the data of each technical indicator in the technical indicator set, the original indicator scheme data matrix is constructed, and the original indicator scheme data matrix is defuzzified to obtain the evaluation indicator data matrix.
[0016] Furthermore, the acquisition process of the matrix directly affects the following:
[0017] Multiple rounds of fuzzy evaluations of each technical indicator by preset personnel are obtained, and defuzzification is performed to obtain the direct impact matrix.
[0018] Furthermore, multiple rounds of fuzzy evaluations of each technical indicator by preset personnel are obtained and defuzzified to obtain a direct impact matrix, including:
[0019] Obtain the importance evaluation of each technical indicator in different scenarios from multiple preset personnel, use interval type-2 fuzzy sets to represent the evaluation language variables, construct an intermediate direct impact matrix, defuzzify the intermediate direct impact matrix, and obtain the direct impact matrix.
[0020] Furthermore, the direct impact matrix corresponding to the technical indicator set is processed to calculate the subjective weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios, including:
[0021] The direct impact matrix is normalized to obtain a normalized direct impact matrix;
[0022] The sum of the direct impact matrix of the specification from 1 to the kth power is taken as the comprehensive impact matrix, where k is a positive integer;
[0023] According to the comprehensive impact matrix, the subjective weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios is calculated.
[0024] Furthermore, based on the evaluation index data matrix, the objective weight of each technical index in different scenarios is calculated, including:
[0025] The anti-entropy weight method is used in combination with the evaluation index data matrix to calculate the objective weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios.
[0026] Furthermore, the subjective weight and objective weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios are integrated to obtain the comprehensive weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios, including:
[0027] The comprehensive weight calculation formula is used to calculate the comprehensive weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios. The comprehensive weight calculation formula is: w total,n 、w obj,n and w sub,n They respectively represent: the comprehensive weight, objective weight and subjective weight of the nth technical indicator in the same scenario; Q represents: the total number of technical indicators in the technical indicator set.
[0028] 2) In the second aspect, the present invention also provides a multi-scenario applicability analysis system for energy storage based on subjective and objective weights, and the specific technical solution is as follows:
[0029] It includes a technical indicator set establishment module, an evaluation indicator data matrix construction module, a subjective weight determination module, an objective weight determination module, a subjective and objective weight fusion module and an optimal energy storage solution determination module;
[0030] The technical indicator set establishment module is used to: establish a technical indicator set for analyzing the applicability of energy storage solutions under multiple scenarios;
[0031] The evaluation index data matrix construction module is used to: obtain and construct the evaluation index data matrix according to the data of each technical index in the technical index set;
[0032] The subjective weight determination module is used to: process the direct impact matrix corresponding to the technical indicator set and calculate the subjective weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios;
[0033] The objective weight determination module is used to: calculate the objective weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios based on the evaluation indicator data matrix;
[0034] The subjective and objective weight fusion module is used to: fuse the subjective weight and objective weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios to obtain the comprehensive weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios;
[0035] The optimal energy storage solution determination module is used to determine the optimal energy storage solution in different scenarios based on the comprehensive weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios.
[0036] On the basis of the above scheme, the energy storage multi-scenario applicability analysis system based on subjective and objective weights of the present invention can also be improved as follows.
[0037] Furthermore, the evaluation index data matrix construction module is specifically used for:
[0038] According to the data of each technical indicator in the technical indicator set, the original indicator scheme data matrix is constructed, and the original indicator scheme data matrix is defuzzified to obtain the evaluation indicator data matrix.
[0039] Furthermore, it also includes a direct impact matrix acquisition module, which is used to: obtain multiple rounds of fuzzy evaluations of each technical indicator by preset personnel, and perform defuzzification processing to obtain a direct impact matrix.
[0040] Furthermore, the direct impact matrix acquisition module is specifically used to: obtain the importance evaluation of each technical indicator in different scenarios by multiple preset personnel, use interval type-2 fuzzy sets to represent the evaluation language variables, construct an intermediate direct impact matrix, defuzzify the intermediate direct impact matrix, and obtain the direct impact matrix.
[0041] Furthermore, the subjective weight determination module is specifically used for:
[0042] The direct impact matrix is normalized to obtain a normalized direct impact matrix;
[0043] The sum of the direct impact matrix of the specification from 1 to the kth power is taken as the comprehensive impact matrix, where k is a positive integer;
[0044] According to the comprehensive impact matrix, the subjective weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios is calculated.
[0045] Furthermore, the objective weight determination module is specifically used to: use the anti-entropy weight method and combine the evaluation index data matrix to calculate the objective weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios.
[0046] Furthermore, the subjective and objective weight fusion module is specifically used to: fuse the subjective weight and objective weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios to obtain the comprehensive weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios, including:
[0047] The comprehensive weight calculation formula is used to calculate the comprehensive weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios. The comprehensive weight calculation formula is: w total,n 、w obj,n and w sub,nThey respectively represent: the comprehensive weight, objective weight and subjective weight of the nth technical indicator in the same scenario; Q represents: the total number of technical indicators in the technical indicator set.
[0048] 3) In a third aspect, the present invention further provides an electronic device, comprising a processor, the processor being coupled to a memory, the memory storing at least one computer program, and the at least one computer program being loaded and executed by the processor, so that the electronic device can implement any of the above-mentioned energy storage multi-scenario applicability analysis methods based on subjective and objective weights.
[0049] 4) In a fourth aspect, the present invention further provides a computer-readable storage medium, in which at least one computer program is stored, and the at least one computer program is loaded and executed by a processor so that the computer implements any of the above-mentioned energy storage multi-scenario applicability analysis methods based on subjective and objective weights.
[0050] The beneficial effects of the present invention are as follows: the linguistic variables of the importance of technical indicators evaluated by experts are converted into interval type-2 fuzzy sets, which are more accurate than other general evaluation methods. The DEMATEL method is used in the calculation of subjective weights, and the relative importance of each technical indicator can be taken into account. The influence of each technical indicator is obtained by calculating the comprehensive influence matrix, so that the assignment of the subjective weight of the technical indicator is more reasonable and scientific. The anti-entropy weight method is used in the calculation of objective weights. Based on the idea of information entropy, it can objectively reflect the differences and importance of different technical indicators, is not affected by subjective factors, does not exist The risk of expert scoring or excluding certain technical indicators, and the calculation results are more objective and reliable. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0051] Other features, objects and advantages of the present invention will become more apparent from the detailed description of non-limiting embodiments made with reference to the following drawings:
[0052] Figure 1 A schematic flow chart of a method for analyzing the applicability of energy storage in multiple scenarios based on subjective and objective weights according to an embodiment of the present invention;
[0053] Figure 2 A corresponding relationship diagram between multiple operating scenarios and technical indicators of new energy stations equipped with energy storage;
[0054] Figure 3 It is a simplified diagram of the energy storage solution response curve;
[0055] Figure 4 A schematic diagram of a flow chart of a system for analyzing the applicability of energy storage in multiple scenarios based on subjective and objective weights according to an embodiment of the present invention;
[0056] Figure 5 The figure is a schematic diagram of the structure of an electronic device according to an embodiment of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0057] In order to make the objectives, technical solutions and advantages of the present invention more clear, the embodiments of the present invention will be further described in detail below with reference to the accompanying drawings.
[0058] like Figure 1 As shown, a method for analyzing the applicability of energy storage in multiple scenarios based on subjective and objective weights in an embodiment of the present invention includes the following steps:
[0059] S1. Establish a set of technical indicators for analyzing the applicability of energy storage solutions in multiple scenarios;
[0060] In order to meet the increasingly diverse needs of power systems, new energy stations equipped with energy storage are gradually moving towards Figure 2 The multi-scenario control development shown includes a site operation data management system and a multi-mode control management system module, which integrates multiple types of control strategies and switches according to different energy storage application requirements.
[0061] In order to analyze the adaptability of different types of energy storage solutions on the grid side in multiple application scenarios, the weight calculation method of each technical indicator in the energy storage solution is scientifically studied, the weight of each indicator is accurately calculated, and the technical characteristics adopted in different scenarios are analyzed to obtain the energy storage indicator weight set. The indicator content involves the typical technical characteristics, safety, service life and other aspects of the energy storage solution. The method for determining the technical indicators of the energy storage solution, that is, the technical indicators used to analyze the applicability of the energy storage solution in multiple scenarios, is as follows:
[0062] According to the specific application of energy storage devices in multiple application scenarios of new energy stations, the application scenarios of grid-side energy storage solutions are subdivided and explained using three categories as examples. The three categories specifically include: 1) long-term peak shaving and valley filling; 2) extending service life; 3) energy storage participating in primary frequency regulation.
[0063] By analyzing the operating mechanisms of different energy storage devices and investigating the actual configuration of energy storage devices in existing engineering applications, the typical power range indicators of different types of energy storage are determined. By establishing a simulation model of the energy storage device and performing a step response test on the energy storage, the response speed indicator results of different types of energy storage are determined. Specifically:
[0064] 1) Under the condition of long-term peak shaving and valley filling, the energy storage solution needs to continuously absorb energy from the grid when the grid has a surplus of electricity and release energy back to the grid when the grid is short of electricity, so as to slow down the fluctuation of the grid and improve the reliability of electricity use. Under this condition, the energy conversion efficiency of the energy storage solution is particularly important. If the energy conversion efficiency is insufficient, the compensated energy will gradually be lost under long-term peak shaving and valley filling, and the initial capacity of the energy storage solution itself plus the energy absorbed from the grid will not be enough to compensate for the energy required by the grid during the valley. According to the analysis, the energy conversion efficiency of the energy storage solution shown in formula (1) is used as the technical indicator of the energy storage solution under the condition of long-term peak shaving and valley filling:
[0065]
[0066] In formula (1), η represents the energy conversion efficiency, E Bf (t) is the discharge power of the station storage in the tth period, E1 is the total power released by the energy storage during the entire mission cycle, E Bc (t) is the charging capacity of the station storage in the tth period, E2 is the total capacity released by the energy storage during the entire mission cycle, T is the task period of energy storage participating in the peak load shifting and valley filling of the power grid. Depending on the sampling time step, it can be 24 (hourly sampling), 48 (30-minute sampling), 96 (15-minute sampling) or other positive integer values. φ2 is the efficiency of the power conversion system, including rectification efficiency and inverter efficiency. According to the market PCS production situation, it is generally taken as 98.5% (unidirectional); φ3 is the power line efficiency, which takes into account the efficiency of the AC and DC cable bidirectional transmission loss; φ4 is the transformer efficiency, which takes into account the efficiency of the transformer bidirectional transformation loss.
[0067] 2) Under the condition of extending the service life, the number of cycles is an important characteristic quantity of the energy storage battery, which is closely related to the battery service life assessment and charge state calculation. At present, there are mainly methods such as charge and discharge number statistics and available capacity testing. The former calculates the number of cycles by counting the number of charge and discharge times of the battery, taking into account the complete charge and discharge process; the latter estimates the number of cycles by testing the available capacity and combining the test parameters, which is suitable for maintenance occasions. The simple calculation formula for the number of cycles is shown in formula (2):
[0068]
[0069] In formula (2), N represents the number of cycles, Q h ΔQ is the remaining capacity of the battery for normal operation in the hth stage; h It is the loss capacity of the battery after one cycle in the hth stage; the value of h changes with the change of battery type parameters in the energy storage scheme.
[0070] 3) Under the condition where energy storage participates in primary frequency regulation, due to the volatility and uncertainty of the output of renewable energy sources such as wind power and photovoltaics. When the installed capacity of wind power and photovoltaics in the power system reaches a certain scale, power fluctuations or the overall withdrawal of the electric field for some reason may lead to a dynamic imbalance between the system's active output and load, resulting in system frequency deviation. In severe cases, it will cause the system frequency to exceed the limit, thereby endangering the safe operation of the power grid. In addition, the increase in the proportion of new energy power generation such as wind power and solar power has led to a large number of thermal power units bearing heavy AGC regulation tasks for a long time, resulting in a series of negative effects such as increased coal consumption for power generation and severe equipment wear. Within the rated power range, the battery energy storage solution can complete the output of the specified power with an accuracy of more than 99% within the second range. Its comprehensive response capability fully meets the power conversion requirements within the time scale of AGC frequency regulation, which greatly exceeds the regulation capacity of conventional thermal power plants. The simplified diagram of the energy storage solution response curve is shown below Figure 3 As shown, the function corresponding to the energy storage solution response curve is formula (3):
[0071]
[0072] In formula (3), T0 is the response time; r(t) is the response input at time t; c(t) is the response output at time t. When it rises to 63.2% of the steady-state value, it is considered to have reached the steady-state value. Performing Laplace transform, we get The independent variable changes from t to s, where s is a complex variable. c(s) represents the response input corresponding to s, and r(s) represents the response output corresponding to s. The response input and response output have different physical meanings in different energy storage schemes and can be set according to actual conditions. For example, if the response input is voltage, the response output is also voltage.
[0073] Similarly, by analyzing other scenarios in the same way as the above cases, we can obtain technical indicators with different scenario characteristics.
[0074] S2. Obtain and construct an evaluation indicator data matrix based on the data of each technical indicator in the technical indicator set, specifically:
[0075] According to the data of each technical indicator in the technical indicator set, the original indicator scheme data matrix is constructed, and the original indicator scheme data matrix is defuzzified to obtain the evaluation indicator data matrix.
[0076] By unifying the technical indicator data involved in various scenarios into a matrix, a scheme indicator set with multi-scenario adaptability (i.e., the original indicator scheme data matrix) can be constructed. Assuming that there are P energy storage schemes involved in the evaluation and Q technical indicators, the original indicator scheme data matrix Z can be constructed, as shown in formula (4):
[0077]
[0078] In formula (4), z ij The data representing the jth technical indicator under the ith energy storage scheme is the performance parameter obtained by various control strategies or from the energy storage equipment body and simulation model.
[0079] In fact, the elements in the original indicator scheme data matrix Z involve many data types such as quantitative values and interval values. If you want to use interval type-2 fuzzy sets to represent their values, you must pre-design the mapping relationship between element values and interval type-2 fuzzy sets. Assuming that the data type of a certain indicator is an interval value, when designing the mapping relationship between the indicator and the interval type-2 fuzzy set, first count the values of all energy storage schemes in this indicator, determine the lower limit and upper limit, and then appropriately select the middle value to divide it into more detailed levels, so that the values of this indicator of the energy storage scheme can correspond to a certain level, and finally specify a corresponding interval type-2 fuzzy set for each level, thereby establishing the mapping relationship between the value of each indicator and the interval type-2 fuzzy set, that is, the interval type-2 fuzzy set represented by the linguistic variable / interval. Table 1 is an example of division according to 5 levels:
[0080] Table 1:
[0081]
[0082] In Table 1, V1 to V5 represent five levels. V x The four horizontal coordinates of the membership function on the interval type-2 fuzzy set corresponding to the level, are the two non-zero ordinates of the upper membership function. V x The four horizontal coordinates of the membership function under the interval type-2 fuzzy set corresponding to the level, are the two non-zero ordinates of the lower membership function.
[0083] Then, the defuzzification method of formula (8) is used to obtain the specific quantitative description content, and the resulting matrix is shown in formula (5):
[0084]
[0085] In formula (5), Z′ is the matrix after defuzzification, i.e., the evaluation index data matrix, i ' j =D TraT (z ij ) represents the defuzzified data of the jth technical indicator under the i-th energy storage scheme.
[0086] S3. Process the direct impact matrix corresponding to the technical indicator set and calculate the subjective weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios;
[0087] The process of obtaining the direct impact matrix includes: obtaining multiple rounds of fuzzy evaluations of each technical indicator by preset personnel, and performing defuzzification processing to obtain the direct impact matrix, specifically:
[0088] Obtain the importance evaluation of each technical indicator in different scenarios from multiple preset personnel, use interval type-2 fuzzy sets to represent the evaluation language variables, construct an intermediate direct impact matrix, defuzzify the intermediate direct impact matrix, and obtain the direct impact matrix.
[0089] Among them, the preset personnel are experts or engineers, etc.
[0090] A comparative study on the relative importance of the technical indicators in the energy storage applicability analysis indicator set is conducted. The importance of each two technical indicators is compared based on the scene characteristics in different scenarios by expert scoring. First, an interval type-2 fuzzy set linguistic variable table is constructed as shown in Table 2. In Table 1, the relative importance is divided into levels (F1 to F9), such as equally important, slightly important, etc., and an interval type-2 fuzzy set is assigned to each linguistic variable. This linguistic variable is then used to evaluate the importance of each two technical indicators, and an intermediate direct impact matrix is constructed. Under the premise that there are Q technical indicators in total, the intermediate direct impact matrix As shown in formula (6), since different scenarios have different technical characteristics requirements, the intermediate direct impact matrix of different application scenarios is The specific value of is also different.
[0091] Table 2:
[0092]
[0093]
[0094]
[0095] In formula (6), Indicates the importance of technical indicator a compared to technical indicator b, and The conditions satisfying formula (7) are:
[0096]
[0097] In formula (7), Interval type-2 fuzzy sets The four horizontal coordinates of the membership function, are the two non-zero ordinates of the upper membership function. Interval type-2 fuzzy sets The four horizontal coordinates of the membership function are: are the two non-zero ordinates of the lower membership function.
[0098] Next, we need to obtain the intermediate direct impact matrix Defuzzification is performed to obtain the direct influence matrix M. Specifically, the defuzzification method in equation (8) is used:
[0099]
[0100] In formula (8), is an interval type-2 fuzzy set The deblurred value of , that is, the element in the a-th row and b-th column of the matrix M.
[0101] S3 specifically includes:
[0102] S30, normalizing the direct impact matrix to obtain a normalized direct impact matrix;
[0103] Using the method in formula (9), each element in the direct influence matrix is divided by the maximum value of the sum of each row, and the obtained direct influence matrix is normalized to obtain the normalized direct influence matrix N.
[0104]
[0105] S31. The sum of the direct impact matrix of the specification from 1 to the kth power is taken as the comprehensive impact matrix, where k is a positive integer;
[0106] After obtaining the standard direct impact matrix N, the standard direct impact matrix is multiplied by itself to represent the added indirect impact between the elements. All the indirect impacts are summed using the method in formula (10) to obtain the comprehensive impact matrix:
[0107]
[0108] In formula (10), Γ is the comprehensive influence matrix; Ι is the unit matrix, that is, the matrix whose diagonal values are all 1 and other values are 0; the upper right subscript “-1” means to invert the matrix.
[0109] S32. Based on the comprehensive impact matrix, calculate the subjective weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios.
[0110] After obtaining the comprehensive influence matrix, the subjective weight is calculated using the method in equations (11) and (12), and each row of the comprehensive influence matrix is summed to obtain the influence degree D of each element. i ; Sum each column of the comprehensive influence matrix to obtain the influence degree C of each element iThe sum of the influence and the influence is the centrality of the element; the difference between the influence and the influence is the cause of the element; in the subjective weight calculation link of the present invention, the index influence D i As the subjective weight w of the i-th technical indicator sub,i The greater the influence, the greater the weight of the technical indicator.
[0111]
[0112]
[0113] In formula (11) and formula (12), t ij is the element in row i and column j of Γ, D i is the influence, C i is the degree of influence, M i is the centrality, R i is the cause degree, w sub,i is the subjective weight of the i-th technical indicator.
[0114] The above method of calculating the subjective weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios is called the DEMATEL method.
[0115] S4. Based on the evaluation index data matrix, calculate the objective weight of each technical index in different scenarios. Specifically:
[0116] The anti-entropy weight method is used in combination with the evaluation index data matrix to calculate the objective weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios.
[0117] In information theory, information is defined as a measure of the degree of order in a system, while entropy represents a measure of the degree of disorder in a system. The entropy weight method is based on this core idea. By measuring the information entropy of the indicator, the weight of each indicator in the comprehensive evaluation is determined. In the framework of information entropy, the smaller the entropy of a random variable, the greater the amount of information it provides, which means that the variable has higher accuracy and reliability in describing the state of the system. Therefore, in the comprehensive evaluation, if the information entropy of an indicator is small, the greater the amount of information provided by the indicator, the greater the role it plays in the evaluation, and the corresponding weight should be higher. However, in addition to the traditional entropy weight method, there is also a relative concept, namely the anti-entropy weight method. The anti-entropy weight method believes that the greater the difference in the indicator, the greater the anti-entropy. When a technical indicator shows a large difference in different samples or different situations, it may carry more information, so it should be given a higher weight in the comprehensive evaluation. The core idea of the anti-entropy weight method is to emphasize the variability and uniqueness of the indicator. The objective weight is calculated using formulas (13), (14) and (15).
[0118]
[0119]
[0120]
[0121] In formula (13), formula (14) and formula (15), z i ' j is the element in the evaluation index data matrix, r ij For z i ' j The normalized value, h j is the information content of the jth technical indicator; w obj,j is the objective weight of the j-th technical indicator.
[0122] S5. The subjective weight and objective weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios are integrated to obtain the comprehensive weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios. Specifically:
[0123] The comprehensive weight calculation formula is used to calculate the comprehensive weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios. The comprehensive weight calculation formula, that is, formula (16), is:
[0124]
[0125] Among them, w total,n 、w obj,n and w sub,n They respectively represent: the comprehensive weight, objective weight and subjective weight of the nth technical indicator in the same scenario; Q represents: the total number of technical indicators in the technical indicator set.
[0126] S6. Determine the optimal energy storage solution under different scenarios based on the comprehensive weight of each technical indicator under different scenarios.
[0127] After obtaining the subjective and objective weights of each technical indicator in each energy storage solution, the VIKOR ranking method can be introduced for comprehensive evaluation. The VIKOR ranking method is an effective multi-attribute decision-making method that comprehensively considers the performance of each energy storage solution in all technical indicators. First, the normalized distance between each technical indicator and the positive ideal solution is used to evaluate the performance of each energy storage solution. and the weight w of each technical indicator total,j , calculate the group utility value Si and individual regret value Ri corresponding to each energy storage scheme, and then normalize the group utility value and individual regret value. Specifically, the formula and After normalization and preference weighting (the preference ratio is determined by the compromise fusion coefficient κ), the score of each energy storage solution is determined, and the decision result is determined based on the sorting result, that is, the optimal energy storage solution. In this way, the scores and rankings of various energy storage solutions on different technical indicators can be obtained, thus providing a basis for decision-making.
[0128] First, determine the positive ideal solution of each technical indicator j ' + and negative ideal solution z j ' - For the jth positive technical indicator, its positive ideal solution and negative ideal solution are defined as shown in formula (17). For the jth negative technical indicator, the relevant definition is shown in formula (18):
[0129]
[0130]
[0131] Secondly, the group utility value and individual regret value of all energy storage solutions are calculated. The VIKOR method evaluates the effectiveness of decision-making solutions based on the group utility value and individual regret value. The group utility value is the utility value generated by each energy storage solution for the whole, aiming to select solutions with less prominent single indicators but greater overall contribution. The individual regret value is the gap between each energy storage solution and the optimal solution, aiming to select the solution with the best performance in a certain aspect. Group utility value S i and individual regret value R i The calculation method is shown in formula (19):
[0132]
[0133] Finally, the comprehensive evaluation results of all energy storage solutions are calculated. Based on the group utility value and individual regret value, the energy storage solutions are ranked by performance using the compromised evaluation results, and the advantages and disadvantages of the solutions are determined based on the scores. The calculation method of the compromised comprehensive evaluation results is shown in formula (20):
[0134]
[0135] In the above formula, κ is the compromise fusion coefficient, which represents the decision maker's preference for group utility value and individual regret value; Ω i To compromise the comprehensive evaluation results, Ω i The smaller the value, that is, the lower the score, the more suitable the solution is for the current research scenario.
[0136] Case analysis:
[0137] In order to verify the effect of the present invention in expanding the difference of indicators when realizing the combination of subjective and objective weighting, a simple example comparative analysis is carried out on three application scenarios of grid-side energy storage: extending service life, long-term peak shaving and valley filling, and energy storage participating in primary frequency regulation.
[0138] Step 1: Determine the six types of energy storage technology indicators to be selected and the five main reference indicators. Construct the indicator set, as shown in Table 3.
[0139] Table 3:
[0140]
[0141] Step 2: In view of the relative importance of the five indicators in the three application scenarios, experts were asked to make multiple evaluations based on the language variable table in step 2, and the judgment matrix was used to calculate the subjective weights of the five indicators in the three application scenarios according to the interval type-2 fuzzy basic algorithm and the DEMATEL method. The subjective weights are shown in Table 4.
[0142] Table 4:
[0143]
[0144] Step 3: Perform interval fuzzification on the interval data and qualitative description data in Table 4. Then use the defuzzification method in step 2 to defuzzify the index interval data.
[0145] Step 4: Use the anti-entropy weight method to assign objective weights to the indicators, as shown in Table 5.
[0146] Table 5:
[0147] index Objective weight Cycle times 0.1514 Calendar life (a) 0.2232 Response time 0.2171 Energy conversion efficiency 0.2093 Security 0.1991
[0148] Step 5: Fuse the subjective and objective weights to obtain the comprehensive weight after subjective and objective fusion, as shown in Table 6.
[0149] Table 6:
[0150]
[0151]
[0152] Step 6: According to the calculated comprehensive weights of the indicators, calculate the group benefit value and individual regret value of each indicator. Set the compromise coefficient in the scoring ranking formula to 0.5, and you can get the comprehensive scores of each solution under different application scenarios, as shown in Table 7.
[0153] Table 7:
[0154]
[0155] In summary, under the condition of extending the service life of the system, the score of the pumped storage system is 0.2181, which is the optimal system under this condition, corresponding to the higher calendar life and number of cycles of the pumped storage system; under the condition of long-term peak shaving and valley filling, the score of the lithium iron phosphate battery is 0.0710, which is the optimal system under this condition, and the battery type energy storage schemes all have low scores, which is in line with the actual situation of high energy conversion efficiency of the battery energy storage scheme; under the condition of energy storage participating in primary frequency regulation, the battery energy storage schemes are evaluated as excellent, among which the all-vanadium liquid flow battery scores 0.2645 as the best, which is due to the higher safety and higher number of cycles of the all-vanadium liquid flow battery. Under the working conditions of different scenarios, the scores of different energy storage schemes vary according to the indicators applicable to the working conditions, but the ranking results are also different. This is because the case analysis only considers the technical indicators that are most coupled with the working conditions. If all indicators are considered comprehensively, the ranking results of the schemes will be closer, and the applicability under different working conditions will be reflected in the difference in scores.
[0156] The present invention establishes a set of energy storage applicability analysis indicators under multiple scenarios, uses the DEMATEL method and the anti-entropy weight method to obtain comprehensive weights, scores to determine the final solution, and constructs multiple types of control strategies including site operation data management and multi-mode control management functions, which are switched according to different energy storage needs; and analyzes the operating mechanisms of different energy storage devices, establishes an energy storage device simulation model, conducts step response tests, and determines the response speed indicators of different types of energy storage.
[0157] The present invention converts the linguistic variables of the importance of the indicators evaluated by experts into interval type II fuzzy sets, which are more accurate than other general evaluation methods. The DEMATEL method is used in the calculation of subjective weights, which can take into account the relative importance of each indicator. The influence of each indicator is obtained by calculating the comprehensive influence matrix, making the assignment of the subjective weight of the indicator more reasonable and scientific. The anti-entropy weight method is used in the objective weight. Based on the idea of information entropy, it can objectively reflect the differences and importance between different indicators, is not affected by subjective factors, does not exist the risk of expert scoring or excluding certain indicators, and the calculation results are more objective and reliable; in the scoring and sorting stage, the group benefit value and individual regret value of each indicator are calculated, and the compromise coefficient is set artificially to decide whether to maximize the group benefit value or minimize the individual regret value, and compromise the two results, so that the method is more reasonable to study the multi-attribute decision-making problem. The method based on the patent design solves the problem of analyzing the applicability of energy storage solutions in different application scenarios.
[0158] In the above embodiments, although the steps are numbered S1, S2, etc., these are only specific embodiments given by the present invention. Those skilled in the art may adjust the execution order of S1, S2, etc. according to actual conditions, which is also within the protection scope of the present invention. It can be understood that in some embodiments, some or all of the above embodiments may be included.
[0159] like Figure 4 As shown, an energy storage multi-scenario applicability analysis system 200 based on subjective and objective weights according to an embodiment of the present invention comprises a technical indicator set establishment module 201, an evaluation indicator data matrix construction module 202, a subjective weight determination module 203, an objective weight determination module 204, a subjective and objective weight fusion module 205 and an optimal energy storage solution determination module 206;
[0160] The technical indicator set establishment module 201 is used to: establish a technical indicator set for analyzing the applicability of energy storage solutions in multiple scenarios;
[0161] The evaluation index data matrix construction module 202 is used to: obtain and construct an evaluation index data matrix according to the data of each technical index in the technical index set;
[0162] The subjective weight determination module 203 is used to: process the direct impact matrix corresponding to the technical indicator set, and calculate the subjective weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios;
[0163] The objective weight determination module 204 is used to: calculate the objective weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios based on the evaluation indicator data matrix;
[0164] The subjective and objective weight fusion module 205 is used to: fuse the subjective weight and objective weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios to obtain the comprehensive weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios;
[0165] The optimal energy storage solution determination module 206 is used to determine the optimal energy storage solution in different scenarios according to the comprehensive weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios.
[0166] Optionally, in the above technical solution, the evaluation index data matrix construction module 202 is specifically used for:
[0167] According to the data of each technical indicator in the technical indicator set, the original indicator scheme data matrix is constructed, and the original indicator scheme data matrix is defuzzified to obtain the evaluation indicator data matrix.
[0168] Optionally, the above technical solution further includes a direct impact matrix acquisition module, which is used to obtain multiple rounds of fuzzy evaluations of each technical indicator by preset personnel and perform defuzzification processing to obtain a direct impact matrix.
[0169] Optionally, in the above technical solution, the direct impact matrix acquisition module is specifically used to: obtain the importance evaluation of each technical indicator in different scenarios by multiple preset personnel, use interval type-2 fuzzy sets to represent the evaluation language variables, construct an intermediate direct impact matrix, defuzzify the intermediate direct impact matrix, and obtain the direct impact matrix.
[0170] Optionally, in the above technical solution, the subjective weight determination module 203 is specifically used to:
[0171] The direct impact matrix is normalized to obtain a normalized direct impact matrix;
[0172] The sum of the direct impact matrix of the specification from 1 to the kth power is taken as the comprehensive impact matrix, where k is a positive integer;
[0173] According to the comprehensive impact matrix, the subjective weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios is calculated.
[0174] Optionally, in the above technical solution, the objective weight determination module 204 is specifically used to: use the anti-entropy weight method, and combine with the evaluation index data matrix to calculate the objective weight of each technical index in different scenarios.
[0175] Optionally, in the above technical solution, the subjective and objective weight fusion module 205 is specifically used to: fuse the subjective weight and objective weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios to obtain the comprehensive weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios, including:
[0176] The comprehensive weight calculation formula is used to calculate the comprehensive weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios. The comprehensive weight calculation formula is: w total,n 、w obj,n and w sub,n They respectively represent: the comprehensive weight, objective weight and subjective weight of the nth technical indicator in the same scenario; Q represents: the total number of technical indicators in the technical indicator set.
[0177] It should be noted that the beneficial effects of the energy storage multi-scenario applicability analysis system 200 based on subjective and objective weights provided in the above embodiment are the same as the beneficial effects of the energy storage multi-scenario applicability analysis method based on subjective and objective weights, which will not be repeated here. In addition, when the system provided in the above embodiment realizes its functions, it only uses the division of the above-mentioned functional modules as an example. In actual applications, the above-mentioned functions can be assigned to different functional modules as needed, that is, the system can be divided into different functional modules according to actual conditions to complete all or part of the functions described above. In addition, the system and method embodiments provided in the above embodiment belong to the same concept, and the specific implementation process is detailed in the method embodiment, which will not be repeated here.
[0178] like Figure 5 As shown, an electronic device 300 of an embodiment of the present invention includes a processor 320, the processor 320 is coupled to a memory 310, and the memory 310 stores at least one computer program 330, and the at least one computer program 330 is loaded and executed by the processor 320, so that the electronic device 300 implements any of the above-mentioned energy storage multi-scenario applicability analysis methods based on subjective and objective weights, specifically:
[0179] The electronic device 300 may have relatively large differences due to different configurations or performances, and may include one or more processors 320 (Central Processing Units, CPU) and one or more memories 310, wherein at least one computer program 330 is stored in the one or more memories 310, and the at least one computer program 330 is loaded and executed by the one or more processors 320, so that the electronic device 300 implements any of the energy storage multi-scenario applicability analysis methods based on subjective and objective weights provided in the above embodiments. Of course, the electronic device 300 may also have components such as a wired or wireless network interface, a keyboard, and an input and output interface for input and output. The electronic device 300 may also include other components for realizing device functions, which will not be repeated here. The electronic device may specifically be a computer, etc.
[0180] A computer-readable storage medium according to an embodiment of the present invention stores at least one computer program, and the at least one computer program is loaded and executed by a processor so that a computer implements any of the above-mentioned energy storage multi-scenario applicability analysis methods based on subjective and objective weights.
[0181] Optionally, the computer-readable storage medium may be a read-only memory (ROM), a random access memory (RAM), a compact disc (CD-ROM), a magnetic tape, a floppy disk, an optical data storage device, and the like.
[0182] In an exemplary embodiment, a computer program product or a computer program is also provided, the computer program product or the computer program comprising computer instructions, the computer instructions being stored in a computer-readable storage medium. A processor of an electronic device reads the computer instructions from the computer-readable storage medium, and the processor executes the computer instructions, so that the electronic device executes any of the above-mentioned energy storage multi-scenario applicability analysis methods based on subjective and objective weights.
[0183] It should be noted that the terms "first", "second", etc. in the specification and claims of the present application are used to distinguish similar objects and represent the definition of a specific order or sequence. The order of use of similar objects can be interchanged where appropriate, so that the embodiments of the present application described herein can be implemented in an order other than the order shown or described.
[0184] Those skilled in the art know that the present invention can be implemented as a system, method or computer program product. Therefore, the present invention can be specifically implemented in the following forms, namely: it can be complete hardware, it can be complete software (including firmware, resident software, microcode, etc.), or it can be a combination of hardware and software, which is generally referred to as "circuit", "module" or "system" herein. In addition, in some embodiments, the present invention can also be implemented in the form of a computer program product in one or more computer-readable media, and the computer-readable medium contains computer-readable program code.
[0185] Any combination of one or more computer-readable media can be used. The computer-readable medium can be a computer-readable signal medium or a computer-readable storage medium. The computer-readable storage medium can be, for example, but not limited to, an electrical, magnetic, optical, electromagnetic, infrared, or semiconductor system, device or device, or any combination of the above. More specific examples of computer-readable storage media (a non-exhaustive list) include: an electrical connection with one or more wires, a portable computer disk, a hard disk, a random access memory (RAM), a read-only memory (ROM), an erasable programmable read-only memory (EPROM or flash memory), an optical fiber, a portable compact disk read-only memory (CD-ROM), an optical storage device, a magnetic storage device, or any suitable combination of the above. In the present invention, a computer-readable storage medium can be any tangible medium containing or storing a program, which can be used by an instruction execution system, device or device or used in combination with it.
[0186] Although the embodiments of the present invention have been shown and described above, it is to be understood that the above embodiments are exemplary and are not to be construed as limitations of the present invention. A person skilled in the art may change, modify, replace and vary the above embodiments within the scope of the present invention.
Claims
1. A multi-scenario applicability analysis method for energy storage based on subjective and objective weights. It is characterized in that include: Establish a set of technical indicators for analyzing the applicability of energy storage solutions in multiple scenarios; Obtain and construct an evaluation indicator data matrix based on the data of each technical indicator in the technical indicator set; Processing the direct impact matrix corresponding to the technical indicator set, and calculating the subjective weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios; Based on the evaluation index data matrix, calculate the objective weight of each technical index in different scenarios; The subjective weight and objective weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios are integrated to obtain the comprehensive weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios; According to the comprehensive weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios, the optimal energy storage solution in different scenarios is determined.
2. According to claim 1, a method for analyzing the applicability of energy storage in multiple scenarios based on subjective and objective weights, It is characterized in that According to the data of each technical indicator in the technical indicator set, an evaluation indicator data matrix is constructed, including: According to the data of each technical indicator in the technical indicator set, an original indicator scheme data matrix is constructed, and the original indicator scheme data matrix is defuzzified to obtain the evaluation indicator data matrix.
3. According to claim 1, a method for analyzing the applicability of energy storage in multiple scenarios based on subjective and objective weights, It is characterized in that The process of obtaining the direct impact matrix includes: Multiple rounds of fuzzy evaluations of each technical indicator by preset personnel are obtained, and defuzzification processing is performed to obtain the direct impact matrix.
4. According to claim 3, a method for analyzing the applicability of energy storage in multiple scenarios based on subjective and objective weights, It is characterized in that Obtain multiple rounds of fuzzy evaluations of each technical indicator by preset personnel, and perform defuzzification processing to obtain the direct impact matrix, including: Obtain the importance evaluation of each technical indicator in different scenarios by multiple preset personnel, use interval type-2 fuzzy sets to represent the evaluation language variables, construct an intermediate direct impact matrix, defuzzify the intermediate direct impact matrix, and obtain the direct impact matrix.
5. According to claim 1, a method for analyzing the applicability of energy storage in multiple scenarios based on subjective and objective weights, It is characterized in that The direct impact matrix corresponding to the technical indicator set is processed to calculate the subjective weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios, including: Normalizing the direct impact matrix to obtain a normalized direct impact matrix; The sum of the direct impact matrix of the specification from 1 to the kth power is taken as the comprehensive impact matrix, where k is a positive integer; According to the comprehensive impact matrix, the subjective weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios is calculated.
6. According to claim 1, a method for analyzing the applicability of energy storage in multiple scenarios based on subjective and objective weights, It is characterized in that Based on the evaluation index data matrix, the objective weight of each technical index in different scenarios is calculated, including: The anti-entropy weight method is used in combination with the evaluation index data matrix to calculate the objective weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios.
7. According to claim 1, a method for analyzing the applicability of energy storage in multiple scenarios based on subjective and objective weights, It is characterized in that The subjective weight and objective weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios are integrated to obtain the comprehensive weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios, including: The comprehensive weight calculation formula is used to calculate the comprehensive weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios. The comprehensive weight calculation formula is: w total,n 、w obj,n and w sub,n They respectively represent: the comprehensive weight, objective weight and subjective weight of the nth technical indicator in the same scenario; Q represents: the total number of technical indicators in the technical indicator set.
8. A multi-scenario applicability analysis system for energy storage based on subjective and objective weights. It is characterized in that It includes a technical indicator set establishment module, an evaluation indicator data matrix construction module, a subjective weight determination module, an objective weight determination module, a subjective and objective weight fusion module and an optimal energy storage solution determination module; The technical indicator set establishment module is used to: establish a technical indicator set for analyzing the applicability of energy storage solutions in multiple scenarios; The evaluation index data matrix construction module is used to: obtain and construct an evaluation index data matrix based on the data of each technical index in the technical index set; The subjective weight determination module is used to: process the direct impact matrix corresponding to the technical indicator set, and calculate the subjective weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios; The objective weight determination module is used to: calculate the objective weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios based on the evaluation indicator data matrix; The subjective and objective weight fusion module is used to: fuse the subjective weight and objective weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios to obtain the comprehensive weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios; The optimal energy storage solution determination module is used to determine the optimal energy storage solution in different scenarios according to the comprehensive weight of each technical indicator in different scenarios.
9. An electronic device, It is characterized in that The electronic device includes a processor, the processor is coupled to a memory, at least one computer program is stored in the memory, and the at least one computer program is loaded and executed by the processor so that the electronic device implements a multi-scenario energy storage applicability analysis method based on subjective and objective weights as described in any one of claims 1 to 7.
10. A computer-readable storage medium, It is characterized in that At least one computer program is stored in the computer-readable storage medium, and the at least one computer program is loaded and executed by the processor so that the computer implements the energy storage multi-scenario applicability analysis method based on subjective and objective weights as described in any one of claims 1 to 7.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Energy storage multi-scene model selection subjective and objective weight fusion method, medium and system
CN117709781A
Electric power system operation state evaluation method, system, equipment and medium
CN117852938A
Cited By
Wind turbine generator primary frequency modulation self-adaptive control method considering active power regulation capability
CN119231572A
Method for evaluating comprehensive performance of linear guide rail pair
CN119963040A
Storage and transportation system equipment maintenance support capability assessment method, system, equipment and medium
CN120765226A
Cascade battery energy storage system based on water-cooling heat dissipation and comprehensive environment monitoring
CN120767490A
Cascade battery energy storage system based on water-cooling heat dissipation and comprehensive environment monitoring
CN120767490B
