Energy storage operation mode and energy storage cost sharing mechanism method in typical electricity market
The proposed energy storage operation mode and cost sharing mechanism address the operational challenges by leveraging foreign market practices to establish a sound market mechanism and subsidy policies, ensuring economic feasibility and promoting the development of China's energy storage industry.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202411027540.9
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-07-30
- Publication Date
- 2024-12-06
Smart Images

Figure CN119090528A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention belongs to the field of electric energy storage technology, and specifically relates to an energy storage operation mode and an energy storage cost sharing mechanism method in a typical electricity market. Background Art
[0002] Under the "dual carbon" goal, a high proportion of variable energy has become an inevitable trend in the development of the power system, which puts higher requirements on the flexibility of the system. Energy storage resources can improve the power balancing ability of the system and transform the original point balance into surface balance, which is of great significance for ensuring the low-carbon and safe operation of the new power system. In this context, new forms of energy storage such as centralized and distributed ones have gradually penetrated into all aspects of the power system. Diversified energy storage through low-load charging and high-load discharging can solve the problem of temporal and spatial mismatch between power supply and demand, thereby optimizing flexible resource allocation and improving system operation efficiency. It has greater potential in providing fast frequency response, flexible adjustment and virtual inertia support for auxiliary services. However, with the rapid growth of new energy storage, existing projects have gradually exposed operational problems. The weaknesses of single operation model, disconnected market mechanism and lack of economic feasibility are not conducive to the further development of energy storage market. With the acceleration of power market construction, compared with the existing mechanism, investment subjects, market access mechanism and cost recovery channels are expected to change. Therefore, looking forward to the future development of power market, it is necessary to explore energy storage operation mode suitable for my country's national conditions. However, due to the lack of mature power market environment and corresponding mechanism, energy storage is currently facing problems such as unclear operation model, insufficient cost recovery mechanism and single investment subject, which makes it difficult to support the rapid development of energy storage industry. Therefore, it is very necessary to provide a typical power market energy storage operation mode and energy storage cost sharing mechanism method to ensure economic feasibility, improve electricity price mechanism, adopt different energy storage subsidy policies and gradually improve market mechanism. Summary of the invention
[0003] The purpose of the present invention is to overcome the shortcomings of the prior art and to provide an energy storage operation mode and energy storage cost sharing mechanism method in a typical power market that ensures economic feasibility, improves the electricity price mechanism, adopts different energy storage subsidy policies, and gradually improves the market mechanism.
[0004] The object of the present invention is achieved by: an energy storage operation mode and an energy storage cost sharing mechanism method in a typical power market, the method comprising the following steps:
[0005] Step 1: An overview of the operation modes of ES in typical foreign power markets, comparing the characteristics of regional power market energy storage operation policies and their synergy with marketization, and summarizing the front-end market and back-end market;
[0006] Step 2: Based on the actual development of the electricity market, identify the key issues that affect the construction of energy storage cost sharing mechanisms under the marketization background;
[0007] Step 3: Based on the expected development of the future electricity market, provide analysis and suggestions from multiple aspects.
[0008] The step 1 is specifically as follows: by comparing the market access mechanisms, cost recovery channels, policy subsidies and economically feasible energy storage operation modes of energy storage projects in various countries before and after the market, it is concluded that the improvement of the electricity market mechanism and reasonable subsidy policies are crucial to the economic feasibility of energy storage projects.
[0009] The overview analysis of the operation modes of ES in typical foreign power markets in step 1 includes the operation modes of the United States, Europe, and the energy storage operation modes of the power market in Australia.
[0010] The operating model of the United States mentioned above includes the FTM market before the meter and the BTM market after the meter. The operating scope of the FTM energy storage market before the meter includes peak load regulation, frequency regulation and ancillary service markets, spot energy markets, energy time shifting and friendly access on the renewable energy generation side; the operating scope of the BTM energy storage market after the meter includes household energy storage and energy storage for industrial and commercial users.
[0011] The European operating model includes the FTM market before the meter and the BTM market after the meter. The operating scope of the FTM energy storage market before the meter includes peak load regulation, frequency regulation, backup power supply, renewable energy integration and flexible load; the operating scope of the BTM energy storage market after the meter includes household photovoltaic energy storage.
[0012] The key issues of the energy storage cost sharing mechanism in step 2 include the form of energy storage market participation, energy storage operation and investment model under the influence of the electricity price mechanism, and energy storage profit model, namely cost recovery mechanism.
[0013] The step 3 provides analysis and suggestions from multiple aspects, including market environment construction, electricity price formation mechanism, cost sharing path and target, and policy subsidy or compensation mechanism, so as to formulate appropriate cost sharing mechanism for different stages of market-oriented development.
[0014] The cost sharing path of ES in step 3 at different marketization stages is as follows: in the initial stage of power market construction, the cost sharing path of energy storage is transmitted to the user end through the transmission and distribution price determined by the government; in the mid-term development of the power market, the energy storage power station adopts a price formation mechanism of "fixed income + variable bidding", in which the fixed income part includes ancillary service compensation and peak-valley power generation compensation, which are shared by power generation enterprises, power grids and users; the variable bidding part is determined by market competition, and the remaining capacity participates in the bidding of the power energy market and the ancillary service market; in the mature stage of power market development, the energy storage power station adopts a fully market-based price formation mechanism under the complete market system, and each market participant should provide a certain amount of funds to the energy storage system according to market rules, and all participants in the power market participate in cost sharing.
[0015] The funds that market participants should provide to energy storage systems in accordance with market rules during the mature stage of electricity market development include contract electricity prices in the medium and long-term markets, electricity charges in the electricity market, and ancillary service fees in the standby and ancillary service markets in accordance with market rules; all participants in the electricity market include users, various power generation companies, power grid companies, and power sales companies.
[0016] The policy recommendations for my country's ES cost-sharing mechanism in step 3 include gradually improving the domestic spot market mechanism, forming electricity market clearing prices and ancillary service prices through market-based means; formulating a reasonable time-of-use electricity price mechanism to guide orderly investment in distributed energy storage; strengthening the energy storage cost-sharing path for both the supply and demand sides of the power system; and improving the adaptability of the energy storage capacity compensation mechanism.
[0017] Beneficial effects of the present invention: The present invention is an energy storage operation mode and energy storage cost sharing mechanism method in a typical power market. During use, the present invention first summarizes the existing practices of energy storage operation modes in the North American, European and Australian power markets by dividing them into front-end markets and back-end markets, and finds that a sound market mechanism and a reasonable subsidy policy are one of the main driving forces for the rapid development of the energy storage market; then, in combination with the actual development of my country's power market, three key issues affecting the construction of the energy storage cost sharing mechanism under market conditions are discussed: market participation form, investment and operation model, and cost recovery mechanism; finally, in combination with the expected development of my country's future power market, suggestions are put forward from four aspects: market environment construction, electricity price formation mechanism, cost sharing path, and policy subsidy mechanism, to promote the healthy and rapid development of China's energy storage industry; the present invention has the advantages of ensuring economic feasibility, improving the electricity price mechanism, adopting different energy storage subsidy policies, and gradually improving the market mechanism. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0018] Figure 1 This is a schematic diagram of the growth trend and future forecast of various types of energy storage in the United States from 2021 to 2024 of the present invention.
[0019] Figure 2 This is a schematic diagram of the number and installed capacity of new residential energy storage devices in Australia from 2016 to 2022 of the present invention.
[0020] Figure 3 This is a schematic diagram of the energy storage benefits in the Australian electricity market according to the present invention.
[0021] Figure 4 A framework diagram for designing the energy storage cost transmission mechanism of the present invention.
[0022] Figure 5 Schematic diagram of the changes in policies and electricity price mechanisms related to China's energy storage market according to the present invention.
[0023] Figure 6 It is a schematic diagram of the cost reduction path of the energy storage power station under the two-part electricity price system of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0024] In academia, scholars from various countries have conducted extensive research on different operation strategies, revenue sources, value distribution, and economic evaluation of energy storage under different operation modes. For example, the paper "Evaluation of peer-to-peer energysharing mechanisms based on a multiagent simulation framework" established a performance evaluation index system for peer-to-peer energy sharing mechanisms and analyzed three common modes: supply-demand ratio (SDR), middle market rate (MMR), and bill sharing (BS), indicating that the MMR mechanism performs well under medium photovoltaic penetration levels; another example is the paper "Peer-to-peer transactive mechanism for residential shared energy storage", which studies the equilibrium state of supply and demand flows under the peer-to-peer market model of residential shared energy storage units, proposes service pricing and load scheduling methods, and proves through example simulation that the peer-to-peer business model is beneficial to both shared energy storage and users; another example is the paper "A tri-layer stochastic framework to manage electricity market within a smart community in the presence of energy storage systems” proposed a three-layer model for managing competitive electricity markets with microgrids and demand response (DR) aggregators. By simultaneously considering system stability and user comfort (CI), it effectively improves user comfort and reduces total operating costs. Other scholars have also studied the operation modes of energy storage at different grid connection points.
[0025] Although existing theoretical research has explored the possibility of diversified operation modes for energy storage, there are still some deficiencies in guiding energy storage to participate in China's power market. Therefore, academic research may not be completely consistent with the future development of energy storage markets in various countries. Therefore, the existing practices of other countries have greater reference value. In the United States, Europe, Australia and other regions, operators have gradually explored and established relevant energy storage operation mechanisms through incremental market practices. They have ensured the economic feasibility of energy storage projects by combining a sound market mechanism with subsidy policies, which provides valuable experience for the development of my country's energy storage market. However, my country is currently in a transitional period of the spot market, lacking a sound energy storage investment mechanism and diversified sources of income. It is very necessary to combine foreign experience with the actual development of China's power market. Therefore, analyzing foreign energy storage operation modes, drawing on their excellent practices, and combining them with the actual exploration of my country's energy storage market development are necessary steps to formulate a reasonable energy storage operation model. This is conducive to better promoting energy transformation and promoting the healthy development of the power system.
[0026] The present invention will be further described below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings.
[0027] Example 1
[0028] like Figure 1-6 As shown, the energy storage operation mode and energy storage cost sharing mechanism method in a typical power market, the method includes the following steps:
[0029] Step 1: An overview of the operation modes of ES in typical foreign power markets, comparing the characteristics of regional power market energy storage operation policies and their synergy with marketization, and summarizing the front-end market and back-end market;
[0030] In this embodiment, with the expansion of the energy storage market and the evolution of application scenarios, energy storage is no longer limited to a single operation mode. According to the location of integration, many countries have gradually developed two main energy storage market operation modes: before the meter (FTM) and after the meter (BTM). The pre-market energy storage operation mode is highly related to different dispatch plans. For the centralized market, it usually corresponds to grid-side energy storage and generation-side energy storage in my country. After-market energy storage mainly refers to batteries owned by residential users or enterprises, mainly for the distributed market, similar to China's user-side energy storage. The definitions and differences of different energy storage markets are shown in Table 1;
[0031] Table 1: Comparison of FTM and BTM
[0032]
[0033] Globally, the markets where energy storage is developing particularly rapidly are the United States, Europe and Australia: the United States mainly focuses on centralized energy storage, while the latter two emphasize distributed energy storage; various countries have conducted a lot of exploration in terms of energy storage investment entities, cost recovery, subsidy policies, etc. In contrast, my country does not yet have a mature energy storage operation mechanism. Both centralized and distributed energy storage are still in the early stages of development. Therefore, it is necessary to learn from the development path and policy guidance methods of the typical power market energy storage market and explore future energy storage development models suitable for my country's national conditions. This paper will take the United States, Europe and Australia as examples to explore the similarities and differences between FTM and BTM markets in different market trading mechanisms, investment entities and cost recovery.
[0034] The step 1 is specifically as follows: by comparing the market access mechanisms, cost recovery channels, policy subsidies and economically feasible energy storage operation modes of energy storage projects in various countries before and after the market, it is concluded that the improvement of the electricity market mechanism and reasonable subsidy policies are crucial to the economic feasibility of energy storage projects.
[0035] The overview analysis of the operation modes of ES in typical foreign power markets in step 1 includes the operation modes of the United States, Europe, and the energy storage operation modes of the power market in Australia.
[0036] In this embodiment, ① the operation mode of the United States: With the gradual improvement of relevant policies, the United States has gradually formed two energy storage markets according to different application scenarios: the operation scope of the pre-meter energy storage market mainly includes peak load regulation, frequency regulation and auxiliary service market, spot energy market, energy time shifting and friendly access on the renewable energy generation side; while the operation scope of the post-meter energy storage market mainly includes household energy storage and industrial and commercial user energy storage;
[0037] Since the United States is divided into multiple electricity markets based on regional operators, the participation mechanisms and subsidy policies for energy storage are also different. Representative examples include the PJM market, CAISO market, and ERCOT market. Specifically, the PJM market is located in Pennsylvania-New Jersey-Maryland, the CAISO market is located in California, and the ERCOT market is located in Texas. The participation of energy storage markets in different regions is shown in Table 2.
[0038] Table 2: Comparison of energy storage market participation in different regions of the United States
[0039]
[0040]
[0041] As shown in Table 2, the revenue of pre-meter energy storage in the United States is mainly driven by market competition under the market mechanism. Large-scale energy storage actively participates in the fast frequency regulation market. Policy subsidies are not prominent, mainly because CAISO, PJM and ERCOT are all deregulated electricity markets under the jurisdiction of independent system operators (ISOs). However, the growth of post-meter energy storage in the United States relies heavily on government subsidies. Each state has relevant policies to provide tax exemptions or subsidies for demand-side energy storage investment projects.
[0042] 1) US pre-meter FTM market: The revenue growth of the US pre-meter energy storage market mainly comes from two aspects: first, participating in ancillary service markets such as frequency regulation and spot energy markets; second, joint operation with renewable energy generators;
[0043] At present, the most common application of pre-meter energy storage in the United States is the frequency regulation ancillary service market, which is the most important capacity market. The economic feasibility of energy storage in the frequency regulation ancillary service market has been fully verified. Among them, the PJM market is mainly based on the electricity market (capacity market); the CAISO market mainly focuses on the energy market; and the market design of the ERCOT market only pays energy fees, not capacity fees; unlike the CAISO and PJM markets, the ERCOT market in Texas is not designed for the real-time spot market, but only for planning the next day's electricity consumption; in addition, energy storage in the ERCOT market mainly relies on the ancillary service market to solve the energy imbalance and frequency fluctuation problems in the electricity market and generate revenue;
[0044] 2) The U.S. behind-the-meter BTM market: The operating model of the behind-the-meter energy storage market includes residential energy storage users and commercial and industrial energy storage users. According to statistics, in 2020, the newly installed capacity of household energy storage was 154MW, a year-on-year increase of 63%, accounting for 15% of the total newly installed capacity that year; the newly installed capacity of industrial and commercial energy storage was 55MW, a year-on-year decrease of 24%, accounting for 5% of the total newly installed capacity that year; What are the growth trends and future forecasts of various types of energy storage in the United States from 2021 to 2023? Figure 1 As shown in the figure, it can be observed that the growth of household user-side energy storage is second only to the energy storage participation in the auxiliary service market, and has become the second largest energy storage market in the United States; in contrast, the demand for industrial energy storage is gradually decreasing;
[0045] The demand for power reliability and related incentive policies has driven the growth of energy storage. The development of the U.S. after-meter market is mainly due to two reasons: First, the instability of the U.S. power grid has led to the growth of demand-side energy storage. The strong independence of the U.S. power grid in different regions makes cross-regional scheduling difficult, and high peak power consumption easily causes local power grid frequency fluctuations and transmission congestion. Second, the United States has adopted certain welfare policies for the installation of energy storage systems. Users who install energy storage can be exempted from some taxes and fees, which is equivalent to reducing the investment cost of energy storage.
[0046] The economic feasibility of household energy storage has promoted the rapid development of residential photovoltaic systems with energy storage functions. According to statistics, as of 2020, the global installed capacity of behind-the-meter energy storage is about 1,000MW, of which 550MW is paired with solar photovoltaics. Currently, 80% of household energy storage is installed in bundles with solar photovoltaics. In terms of policy, federal and state governments provide different degrees of tax deductions and tax rebates for the installation of solar photovoltaic systems, which reduces the construction cost of residential energy storage for self-use. From an economic point of view, residents can store electricity when the sunshine is good and the electricity price is low, reducing the amount of electricity purchased at high prices at night, which greatly saves their own electricity bills and also provides benefits for the entire power system.
[0047] In general, the overall growth demand for commercial and industrial energy storage in the United States is slightly lower than that for household energy storage. Contrary to the domestic electricity price mechanism, commercial and industrial electricity prices in the United States are lower than residential electricity prices, so residential users have a stronger tendency to install energy storage. With the exception of the CAISO market in California, in most other electricity markets, energy storage installations in residential areas are larger than those in commercial and industrial areas.
[0048] ② European operation mode: The European power market has always been a pioneer in the development of renewable energy and energy storage. In the UK, energy storage is mainly distributed in the pre-meter market, focusing on the construction of the market where energy storage provides auxiliary services; in Germany, energy storage mainly involves the post-meter market, and user-side distributed energy storage leads the world; at the same time, Australia's solar photovoltaic development is rapid, the scale of customer-side energy storage has increased significantly, and there is also a certain practice in the post-meter market; therefore, this invention will examine the energy storage operation mode of the European power market, taking the UK and Germany as representative, and considering the Australian post-meter market, therefore, this invention takes the UK and Germany as representatives to analyze and study the energy storage operation mode of the European power market;
[0049] 1) European front-end energy storage market: The UK is the largest front-end energy storage market in Europe. Large-capacity devices mainly participate in the ancillary services market. The main functions of energy storage in the front-end energy storage market include peak load regulation, frequency regulation, backup power supply, renewable energy integration and flexible load.
[0050] In the UK energy storage market, the main source of income for new energy storage systems on the power generation side is to provide frequency control reserve (FCR) services. Participating in the energy market to obtain clearance income is not the main source of income for UK energy storage. Energy storage mainly obtains income by providing auxiliary services to the power grid or helping renewable energy generators to connect to the grid. As shown in Table 3, about 48% of large energy storage systems in the UK are used for frequency control, 26% for capacity market, and 13% for renewable energy grid integration.
[0051] Table 3: Revenue sharing statistics for front-end energy storage applications in the UK
[0052]
[0053] Table 4: UK electricity market energy storage revenue sources
[0054]
[0055]
[0056] Table 4 shows the main sources of revenue for energy storage in the UK electricity market. Currently, the most mature development in the UK is energy storage participating in the frequency regulation and reserve market. Energy storage provides high and stable value for frequency control reserves (FCR). Although the frequency regulation business has high returns, the demand is limited. The market capacity is usually only a few hundred or a few thousand megawatts, which is dozens to hundreds of times lower than the energy storage demand for short-term operating reserves (generation capacity or load reduction) or energy arbitrage.
[0057] The value of energy storage in the UK energy market or in obtaining clearing gains through energy price arbitrage is unstable, and the participation of energy storage in the energy market system has not yet been fully established, which is different from the United States, where the front-of-meter energy storage market tends to develop the day-ahead energy market and the ancillary service market of the ISO plan in the trading center; however, it is worth noting that the UK is promoting the establishment of a spot market system, which can reflect the scarcity of inter-period flexibility. When the price difference increases, the arbitrage value of energy storage participating in the day-ahead energy market is expected to be more fully reflected;
[0058] 2) The post-meter BTM market in Europe and Australia: [1] Germany: Compared with the UK, Germany is in a leading position in the development of new energy storage in the post-meter market. The growth of energy storage in the post-meter market far exceeds that in the pre-meter market. The growth rate of new energy storage in the German post-meter market is the highest. Household photovoltaic energy storage is the main operating mode of post-meter energy storage. The development of user-side photovoltaic and higher retail electricity prices provide space for the post-meter market. In 2020, 92% of Germany's new installed capacity came from post-meter energy storage. Taking Germany as an example, the average household electricity purchase cost in 2020 was US$0.314 / kWh, and it is on an upward trend. At the same time, the levelized cost of electricity (LCOE) of household photovoltaic energy storage systems continues to decline. At present, Germany is promoting policies to subsidize household photovoltaic storage equipment, aiming to increase the utilization rate of household photovoltaic storage, promote the self-use post-meter energy storage operation model, and offset the high electricity costs.
[0059] In summary, household photovoltaic energy storage is the main operating mode of behind-the-meter energy storage in Germany, and has certain economic feasibility in increasing the self-use rate;
[0060] [2] Australia: Australia is the world's second largest PV energy storage market after Germany. Due to Australia's abundant natural light resources and high electricity prices, PV power generation, microgrid energy storage and user-side PV energy storage combination projects have developed rapidly, and a large number of users have installed PV systems. In the future, the Australian government will continue to provide subsidies and low-interest loans to users who install PV energy storage systems to reduce the installation and investment costs of energy storage. Australia's behind-the-meter energy storage installed capacity is expected to continue to grow. Figure 2 As shown;
[0061] The value and income of household photovoltaic energy storage in Australia mainly come from two aspects: first, the income from the self-use of electricity stored by household photovoltaic energy storage equipment, which saves electricity costs by storing energy during the day and releasing it during the peak period when electricity prices are high at night; second, the battery subsidy (South Australian government) and tax rebate (Victorian government) policies, to a certain extent, guarantee that the energy storage equipment will recover its costs within a limited number of years; in addition, in order to promote the diversified development of energy storage projects, energy storage transactions in the Australian National Electricity Market (NEM) have also begun to grow rapidly, and its main value comes from emergency frequency regulation in the frequency control ancillary service (FCAS) market; the income of energy storage in the ancillary service market has seen significant growth, such as Figure 3 As shown in the figure, it can be seen that although the revenue of energy storage in the energy market accounts for a small proportion, it has also increased. This is because with the large-scale entry of renewable energy into the electricity market, the price fluctuations in the energy market at different times have gradually increased, providing more opportunities for energy storage to arbitrage in the energy market;
[0062] ③ Comparison of operating models in different countries: Based on different national conditions, the energy storage development market types, revenue sources, transaction objects, policy subsidy priorities, etc. represented by the United States, the United Kingdom, Germany, and Australia are not completely consistent, as shown in Table 5;
[0063] The energy storage costs in the U.S. front-end market are mainly recovered from transactions in the ancillary service market and the spot energy market. The existing mechanism allows energy storage to declare the charging and discharging quantity and sales price in the market. The market can spontaneously guide energy storage to realize its own frequency regulation value. The U.S. has more laws aimed at promoting the improvement and reform of market mechanisms, rather than simple policy incentives. The centralized large-scale energy storage in the U.S. has generated good returns under the mature market mechanism. In recent years, some energy storage incentive policies have mainly targeted distributed energy storage on the user side.
[0064] Energy storage revenue in the UK pre-meter market mainly comes from independent energy storage or energy storage participating in the capacity market to obtain frequency regulation benefits. The energy market contributes relatively little to energy storage cost mitigation. The UK market generally does not recognize system operators' direct investment and use of energy storage, and often requires energy storage to play a frequency regulation role in the system as a market player.
[0065] The economic feasibility of energy storage in Germany's after-the-meter market is obviously insufficient. The methods of earning income through peak-valley arbitrage in the electricity market or participating in the frequency regulation auxiliary market are not yet mature. Germany's leading energy storage project is household photovoltaic energy storage. Relying on time-of-use electricity prices, government tax exemptions and tax exemptions, users can fully recover costs in about 5 years by increasing their self-use rate. It already has a certain degree of economic feasibility;
[0066] Table 5: Comparison of energy storage operation modes in various countries
[0067]
[0068]
[0069] The development of household energy storage in Australia has a long history. Its value mainly comes from two aspects: self-use and policy subsidies. It can ensure that the household self-use energy storage system can recover its cost in a relatively short time within a few years. In addition, with the integration of large-scale renewable energy into the Australian electricity market, the fluctuation of electricity prices in the energy market has gradually increased, and the energy storage energy transactions and frequency capacity transactions participating in the electricity market are also increasing rapidly. In contrast, the pioneering countries in the development of energy storage, such as the United States, mainly support the development of energy storage by formulating energy storage planning goals, supporting technological innovation of the local industrial chain, providing fiscal and tax incentives, providing financial support, and developing electricity market transaction products suitable for energy storage. By improving the market mechanism to form price signals, it effectively promotes the diversification of energy storage roles and guarantees some benefits. At the same time, Diversified subsidy policies ensure the recovery of fixed costs of energy storage, thereby effectively improving the economic feasibility of energy storage projects; in contrast, my country started late in the development of new energy storage, and the economic feasibility and utilization rate of most energy storage projects are analyzed through the existing experience of typical power systems. This paper preliminarily proposes several aspects of China's future energy storage construction: first, explore the reasonable positioning of the role of energy storage and the status of market entities, and clarify the direction of future energy storage development; second, appropriately relax energy storage investment and operation restrictions, and continuously explore and improve market rules in areas such as capacity markets to lay the foundation for future energy storage operation models; third, at this stage, we should learn from the subsidy models of the United Kingdom and other countries, consider expanding energy storage benefits through joint policies, and ensure the reasonable recovery of energy storage investment;
[0070] However, it should be noted that due to differences in national conditions, the operating experience of typical electricity markets must be adjusted to adapt to the future development of my country's electricity market. It is necessary to conduct an adaptive analysis of market participation forms, investment models, and revenue models under my country's market environment in order to develop energy storage operation models that are suitable for the low-carbon transformation of my country's power system.
[0071] Step 2: Based on the actual development of the electricity market, identify the key issues that affect the construction of energy storage cost sharing mechanisms under the marketization background;
[0072] Step 3: Based on the expected development of the future electricity market, provide analysis and suggestions from multiple aspects.
[0073] The present invention is an energy storage operation mode and energy storage cost sharing mechanism method in a typical power market. In use, the present invention first summarizes the existing practices of energy storage operation modes in the power markets of North America, Europe and Australia, and finds that a sound market mechanism and a reasonable subsidy policy are one of the main driving forces for the rapid development of the energy storage market; then, combined with the actual development of my country's power market, three key issues affecting the construction of energy storage cost sharing mechanism under market conditions are discussed: market participation form, investment and operation model, and cost recovery mechanism; finally, combined with the expected development of my country's future power market, suggestions are put forward from four aspects: market environment construction, electricity price formation mechanism, cost sharing path, and policy subsidy mechanism, to promote the healthy and rapid development of China's energy storage industry; the present invention has the advantages of ensuring economic feasibility, improving electricity price mechanism, adopting different energy storage subsidy policies, and gradually improving market mechanism.
[0074] Example 2
[0075] like Figure 1-6 As shown, the energy storage operation mode and energy storage cost sharing mechanism method in a typical power market, the method includes the following steps:
[0076] Step 1: An overview of the operation modes of ES in typical foreign power markets, comparing the characteristics of regional power market energy storage operation policies and their synergy with marketization, and summarizing the front-end market and back-end market;
[0077] Step 2: Based on the actual development of the electricity market, identify the key issues that affect the construction of energy storage cost sharing mechanisms under the marketization background;
[0078] The key issues of the energy storage cost sharing mechanism in step 2 include the form of energy storage market participation, energy storage operation and investment model under the influence of the electricity price mechanism, and energy storage profit model, namely cost recovery mechanism.
[0079] In this embodiment, with the continuous integration of new energy sources such as wind energy and solar energy, energy storage will assume various functions in the future power system, including smooth output and peak load regulation on the power supply side, congestion relief and delayed capacity expansion on the grid side, peak load regulation, valley filling, capacity management and reliability improvement on the user side. In this context, designing a reasonable energy storage market mechanism is crucial to promoting the orderly transformation of the power system and ensuring the safe and stable operation of the power system.
[0080] In the process of designing the power market mechanism, the energy storage cost sharing mechanism is one of the key issues. Under the market environment, the key issue of energy storage cost guidance is the key issue in the design of the power market mechanism. In the process of continuously promoting the construction of new power markets and the reform of power market mechanisms in my country, it is urgent to explore market mechanisms suitable for energy storage to participate in market operations. This paper combines the current market situation at home and abroad and existing research to summarize four key elements that need to be considered in the design of energy storage cost sharing mechanisms, such as Figure 4 As shown;
[0081] ① The form of market participation: In the process of energy storage investment and construction, the form of market participation is one of the important factors affecting its functional positioning and cost recovery ability. Large-scale energy storage facilities represented by pumped storage power stations are mostly independently invested and operated by power grid operators due to their high investment costs and the ability to exert large-scale regulation effects, and they participate in market transactions in a centralized manner. With the rise of distributed energy storage, on the one hand, a large number of small-scale energy storage systems are connected to the grid; on the other hand, distributed energy storage involves complex investment and operation relationships, and profits are obtained through market competition between different entities rather than centralized scheduling. Therefore, in the future marketization process, it is necessary to determine a reasonable cost-sharing mechanism based on the two different market participation forms of centralized and distributed energy storage.
[0082] At present, the market participation of energy storage systems in my country is mainly based on independent investment and centralized grid dispatching. Its advantages are that it can plan and manage the power supply and demand of the system in a unified manner, with richer usage scenarios, more frequent usage, and higher utilization rate of energy storage equipment. Its disadvantages are that the power grid company, as the only investment entity, is under great financial pressure and capital recovery pressure. In addition to the determination of transmission and distribution prices, it has not found an effective way to recover the investment cost of energy storage, which cannot support the long-term construction of energy storage, and its income does not fully reflect the multiple values of power stations in the system. With the increase in the number of energy storage entities and installed capacity, the trend of independent energy storage participating in market competition as a market entity is inevitable. In other countries, the British electricity market requires energy storage to participate as a market entity, and generally does not accept system operators' direct investment and dispatch of energy storage resources.
[0083] In addition, the scenarios in which distributed energy storage appears as a market participant are becoming more and more diverse. Due to objective constraints, the development progress of distributed energy storage as the main market participant in other countries is significantly higher than that in China. The entry threshold of foreign power markets is relatively low, which greatly increases the number of distributed energy storage operators participating in the entire market, allowing small-capacity distributed energy storage to enjoy an equal market position with other members, which helps various types of energy storage operations to reasonably allocate energy storage resources in a competitive manner. However, it also puts forward higher requirements for the design of market mechanisms, so that distributed energy storage can be effectively restored on the power generation side, demand side and grid side respectively;
[0084] ② Energy storage operation and investment model under the influence of electricity price mechanism: In the process of power market development, changes in electricity price mechanism reflect the evolution of market competition and related mechanisms, and directly affect the operation and investment model of energy storage. Generally, according to the differences in regulatory policies and electricity price mechanisms in different periods, the operation mode of energy storage power stations can be divided into three types: grid connection, leasing and independent operation. From the development history of foreign electricity prices, the electricity price formation mechanism is different at different stages of the electricity market. The early, mid-term and mature stages of the electricity market adopt two-tier electricity prices, the price formation mechanism of "fixed income + variable bidding" and the fully market-based electricity price formation mechanism respectively.
[0085] my country's electricity market is still in its early stages, mainly based on grid-fixed electricity prices and two-tier electricity prices, and has not yet formed a fully market-oriented electricity price. my country has tried to implement time-of-use electricity prices and tiered electricity prices, but electricity prices have not yet completed the market-oriented transformation. Therefore, it is of great significance to formulate a suitable energy storage electricity price formation mechanism, obtain benefits in the power energy market, and guide energy storage investment. Figure 5 It shows the relevant policies and changes of China's electricity price mechanism; energy storage power stations are capital-intensive systems with high construction costs and long investment payback periods. Large-scale, long-term energy storage projects are not attractive to most social enterprises and investors. Initially, most domestic energy storage projects were funded and built by power grid companies, and the costs were recovered through transmission and distribution pricing. However, the fairness and rationality of this approach have been questioned, and it has been revised and improved twice;
[0086] Before 2021, most energy storage projects mainly relied on single capacity pricing to recover their investments, and rarely used two-part electricity prices. At present, my country has not yet formed a mature electricity market mechanism. The operation and pricing mechanism of new energy storage can refer to pumped storage power stations, which use two-part electricity prices as the main operating mode. Under this model, energy prices are determined through market competition and market clearing, while capacity prices are collected through transmission and distribution pricing. At the same time, it is necessary to promote the development of the underlying electricity market and promote the good connection between energy storage and the market.
[0087] As the demand for energy storage in the power system and the market continues to grow, it is imperative to attract more social capital investment outside of grid companies and promote the commercial development of energy storage. Therefore, considering the operating model and profit channels of energy storage, it is crucial to design and implement a reasonable pricing mechanism. Allowing energy storage to participate in market competition as an independent entity, formulate its own capacity allocation plan for energy and frequency support services, and maximize its own economic profits is crucial to recovering costs and attracting external investment.
[0088] ③ Energy storage profit model, i.e. cost recovery mechanism: At present, my country's energy storage is mainly divided into two categories: grid-side energy storage, which is directly invested and operated by the grid company; source load-side energy storage, which is invested and profited by third parties; under the current dual pricing system, energy storage profits mainly include capacity income, electricity income and ancillary service income, which are achieved by reducing the demand for thermal power capacity, peak-valley price arbitrage and providing ancillary services; from the perspective of market participants, when energy storage plays a role in ensuring the safe and stable operation of the power system, promoting the absorption of clean energy power generation, and reducing the system's power generation and transmission and distribution costs, it will radiate differentiated value to different entities, including power sources, grids, and users; these beneficiaries have the responsibility to cooperate with energy storage to achieve cost recovery;
[0089] However, under the current market mechanism, the profitability of my country's energy storage projects is still relatively low. In terms of grid-side energy storage, the current investment entities and cost recovery methods of energy storage are relatively single; in terms of source load-side energy storage, its income mainly comes from the electricity market and ancillary service market; at the electricity market level, the time-of-use electricity price difference in my country's current market mechanism is small, so the arbitrage value of energy storage charging and discharging is small, which is incompatible with the power balance value brought to the market; at the ancillary service market level, there is a large uncertainty in the quantity and price of energy storage participating in peak load regulation and frequency regulation, which depends on policy subsidies, and the scale of energy storage participating in the ancillary service market is limited, which is not commensurate with its actual regulatory value in the ancillary service market; generally speaking, the current cost recovery of energy storage projects is highly dependent on policy subsidies, and the specific ancillary service income depends on the energy storage frequency regulation mileage compensation, capacity compensation, and user power quality improvement compensation formulated by relevant standards;
[0090] In order to solve the current profitability problem of energy storage in my country, it is necessary to refer to the practical experience of various countries and formulate a reasonable cost guidance mechanism. From the perspective of different market types, in relatively mature foreign power markets, power investment, including pumped storage cost recovery, is generally composed of power market, ancillary service market and capacity market. Considering the connection with the power market, energy storage power stations represented by pumped storage can obtain income through three main channels: electricity price, ancillary service market and capacity fee, and incorporate it into the transmission and distribution price; for the most widely used dual pricing system in my country, the external value of energy storage in the market can be regarded as the value reflected and radiated through the power market and capacity market, among which the capacity market includes some functions of the ancillary service market. The cost guidance path of energy storage power stations under the dual pricing system is as follows: Figure 6 As shown;
[0091] At present, some companies in the United States and Germany adopt a "lease to own" model to serve users, promoting the interaction between distributed flexible energy storage resources and the operation of the entire power system. In my country, the main benefits of distributed energy storage come from four aspects: time-of-use electricity price management, capacity fee management, improving power supply reliability and improving power quality; because the installed capacity of commercial and industrial photovoltaics exceeds that of household photovoltaics, the efficiency of energy storage has been greatly improved, occupying a dominant position in the revenue flow. Industrial and commercial users can also obtain certain benefits through peak-valley price arbitrage, demand management, backup power supply, electricity spot trading, power auxiliary services, etc., further reducing corporate electricity costs.
[0092] Step 3: Based on the expected development of the future electricity market, provide analysis and suggestions from multiple aspects.
[0093] In this embodiment, at present, my country's power market mainly formulates transmission and distribution prices through power grid companies, and transfers part of the energy storage costs to users. However, the cost recovery method guided by price signals and unified market mechanisms has not yet been established. Therefore, when designing the relevant mechanism for energy storage participation in my country's power market, we should not directly apply the foreign model, but should design the cost sharing method according to the price mechanism of different development stages of my country's power market and follow the market evolution path;
[0094] ① The cost-sharing path of ES at different stages of marketization: In the initial stage of power market construction, energy storage occupies a very small market share, and power stations adopt a two-part electricity price. The cost-sharing path of energy storage is transmitted to the user end through the transmission and distribution price determined by the government; users pay electricity fees to the power grid company according to the electricity price, which includes the electricity price and the capacity price; the power grid company recovers the investment cost of the energy storage power station through the electricity fees and capacity fees paid by users; at this stage, grid-side energy storage can achieve a certain cost diversion based on the transmission and distribution price, while the profitability of third-party investment in source load energy storage is limited by the difficulty of directly benefiting from the electricity price mechanism, and cost diversion is difficult;
[0095] In the mid-term development of the electricity market, energy storage power stations can adopt a price formation mechanism of "fixed income + variable bidding", which can guarantee the income of energy storage power stations to a certain extent and introduce market mechanisms to reflect the objective value of energy storage power stations; the fixed income part includes compensation for ancillary services and compensation for peak and valley power generation, which are shared by power generation companies, power grids, and users; the user transmission and distribution price and the power generation company transaction price are determined annually by the government and paid uniformly to the power grid company, which pays the energy storage power station annually; the variable bidding part is determined by market competition, and the remaining capacity participates in the bidding of the electricity energy market and the ancillary service market. This part of the additional income is directly transferred to the energy storage power station by users and power generation companies in a certain proportion. At this time, the costs of grid-side and source load energy storage can be well transferred to various stakeholders, but are still subject to certain constraints of relevant policies and systems;
[0096] In the mature stage of the power market development, energy storage power stations adopt a completely market-based price formation mechanism under the complete market system, and the government does not participate in the determination of electricity prices at any stage; the energy storage system has obtained many profit opportunities in the auxiliary service market and the electricity market in different time dimensions such as day-ahead and real-time, and has obtained reasonable returns. Through market competition, each market participant should provide a certain amount of funds to the energy storage system according to market rules, including the contract electricity price in the medium and long-term market, the electricity fee in the electricity market, and the auxiliary service fee in the standby and auxiliary service market. All participants in the power market participate in cost sharing, including users, various power generation companies, power grid companies, and power sales companies. At this time, whether it is grid-side energy storage invested by power grid companies or third-party source load energy storage invested by third parties, they can recover costs through multiple markets and use reasonable and effective market mechanisms to transfer energy storage investment and construction costs to beneficiaries.
[0097] ② Policy recommendations for my country's ES cost-sharing mechanism: 1) Gradually improve the domestic spot market mechanism, and form the electricity market clearing price and ancillary service price through market-based means: Improving the market mechanism will help establish reasonable price signals and encourage energy storage to profit from the market through various services. It is recommended to refer to the spot market mechanism of typical power systems in North America, Europe and other regions, and design an electricity energy market and supporting service market suitable for my country's national conditions; through market competition, gradually realize the rational allocation of various power generation resources, and form electricity settlement prices and ancillary service prices through market-based means; At present, strive to use the time-of-use electricity price mechanism to form peak-valley price difference income to fill capacity costs and increase the income of energy storage itself; Under the time-of-use electricity price policy, ensure that new energy storage participates in multiple markets, provides multiple services, and realizes the superposition of multiple market benefits; In the long run, with the goal of large-scale energy storage competition in the entire electricity energy market, use its market influence to form a larger electricity price difference, which is convenient for obtaining benefits during peak load regulation, and no longer compensate for the capacity of energy storage power stations, and fully recover costs through the market to obtain benefits;
[0098] 2) Formulate a reasonable time-of-use electricity price mechanism to guide orderly investment in distributed energy storage: Distributed energy storage systems have flexible access locations. Referring to the development paths of energy storage markets in Germany, Australia and other countries, the proportion of household energy storage projects and light energy storage joint construction projects will continue to increase in the future. The potential market for distributed energy storage is huge. The time-of-use electricity price in the domestic market is often determined by the power grid, and the difference between peak and valley time-of-use electricity prices is not large. In the power energy market, energy storage cannot fully recover its own value through arbitrage income. Therefore, it is recommended to learn from the existing electricity price mechanism experience of typical power systems and formulate a more reasonable time-of-use electricity price mechanism, which will help increase the willingness of social capital to invest in energy storage;
[0099] 3) Strengthen the energy storage cost sharing path between the supply and demand sides of the power system: At a stage where the marketization level is low, energy storage cannot pass on the cost to all market participants through the market. A relatively rough secondary distribution form can be used to recover part of the energy storage cost in advance: First, calculate the external value of energy storage to the power generation side and the demand side, and actively include the user side, the grid side, and the power supply side into the market mechanism; second, on the power generation side and the demand side, each unit or user shall bear part of the construction cost of the energy storage power station according to the degree of demand or benefit of energy storage, and the cost borne by the unit or user shall not exceed 85% of the added value;
[0100] 4) Adaptability of energy storage capacity compensation mechanism: In the initial stage of establishing the capacity market, it is recommended to consider compensation mechanisms in regions such as North America and the United Kingdom. Governments and authoritative agencies can provide differentiated capacity compensation based on the available capacity and related cost estimates of energy storage stations. This will help energy storage stations expand their profit channels and recover as much fixed costs as possible in the early stage. As the capacity market mechanism matures, it is advisable to gradually promote the marketization of energy storage transactions, form capacity compensation prices through market competition, and ultimately distribute these costs to all users through transmission and distribution prices.
[0101] In summary, the present invention first conducts a comparative analysis of the energy storage operation mechanisms in three typical markets: the United States, Europe, and Australia, and analyzes and explores the feasible market operation experiences of these countries from the perspectives of pre- and post-listing participation, operation models, profit channels, and other factors; on this basis, it focuses on sorting out the development history of my country's energy storage market participation forms, investment models, and profit channels, and summarizes the key issues of the energy storage cost-sharing mechanism under market conditions; finally, it looks forward to the cost-sharing paths at different stages of marketization, and puts forward policy recommendations for the cost-sharing mechanism that adapts to the development of my country's electricity market. It aims to clarify the multiple revenue channels of energy storage and the existing contradictions, and to solve the key issues of energy storage cost sharing under my country's current dual pricing system;
[0102] The present invention has the following advantages: 1) Analysis of typical foreign power systems shows that a sound market mechanism and reasonable policy subsidies are crucial to the economic feasibility of energy storage projects; the early market relies more on a sound market access mechanism and electricity price mechanism, while the development of energy storage in the later market mainly relies on the promotion of relevant subsidy policies; with the acceleration of the energy transformation process, it is necessary to continuously improve the market mechanism and explore reasonable subsidy policies, while promoting the development of energy storage before and after marketization, so as to ensure the economic feasibility of energy storage projects;
[0103] 2) my country's current energy storage cost guidance mechanism faces a series of problems in terms of market participation forms, operation and investment models, and profit channels. We need to further explore the market participation methods of centralized and distributed energy storage, improve the electricity price mechanism, and broaden the profit channels of energy storage to better adapt to the marketization process of my country's power industry in the future;
[0104] 3) Considering the different stages of my country's electricity marketization, it is necessary to adopt different market access mechanisms and energy storage subsidy policies according to the cost-guided path, gradually improve the market mechanism, establish a reasonable electricity price mechanism, clear the cost-guided path of both supply and demand sides, and implement a comprehensive compensation policy. These measures will better ensure the economic feasibility of energy storage projects and guide the role of energy storage in the future marketization of my country's electricity industry.
[0105] The present invention is an energy storage operation mode and energy storage cost sharing mechanism method in a typical power market. In use, the present invention first summarizes the existing practices of energy storage operation modes in the power markets of North America, Europe and Australia, and finds that a sound market mechanism and a reasonable subsidy policy are one of the main driving forces for the rapid development of the energy storage market; then, combined with the actual development of my country's power market, three key issues affecting the construction of energy storage cost sharing mechanism under market conditions are discussed: market participation form, investment and operation model, and cost recovery mechanism; finally, combined with the expected development of my country's future power market, suggestions are put forward from four aspects: market environment construction, electricity price formation mechanism, cost sharing path, and policy subsidy mechanism, to promote the healthy and rapid development of China's energy storage industry; the present invention has the advantages of ensuring economic feasibility, improving electricity price mechanism, adopting different energy storage subsidy policies, and gradually improving market mechanism.
Claims
1. Energy storage operation mode and energy storage cost sharing mechanism method in a typical power market, characterized by: The method comprises the following steps: Step 1: An overview of the operation modes of ES in typical foreign power markets, comparing the characteristics of regional power market energy storage operation policies and their synergy with marketization, and summarizing the front-end market and back-end market; Step 2: Based on the actual development of the electricity market, identify the key issues that affect the construction of energy storage cost sharing mechanisms under the marketization background; Step 3: Based on the expected development of the future electricity market, provide analysis and suggestions from multiple aspects.
2. The energy storage operation mode and energy storage cost sharing mechanism method in a typical power market as claimed in claim 1, characterized in that: The step 1 is specifically as follows: by comparing the market access mechanisms, cost recovery channels, policy subsidies and economically feasible energy storage operation modes of energy storage projects in various countries before and after the market, it is concluded that the improvement of the electricity market mechanism and reasonable subsidy policies are crucial to the economic feasibility of energy storage projects.
3. The energy storage operation mode and energy storage cost sharing mechanism method in a typical power market as claimed in claim 2, characterized in that: The overview analysis of the operation modes of ES in typical foreign power markets in step 1 includes the operation modes of the United States, Europe, and the energy storage operation modes of the power market in Australia.
4. The energy storage operation mode and energy storage cost sharing mechanism method in a typical power market as claimed in claim 3, characterized in that: The operating model of the United States mentioned above includes the FTM market before the meter and the BTM market after the meter. The operating scope of the FTM energy storage market before the meter includes peak load regulation, frequency regulation and ancillary service markets, spot energy markets, energy time shifting and friendly access on the renewable energy generation side; the operating scope of the BTM energy storage market after the meter includes household energy storage and energy storage for industrial and commercial users.
5. The energy storage operation mode and energy storage cost sharing mechanism method in a typical power market as claimed in claim 3, characterized in that: The European operating model includes the FTM market before the meter and the BTM market after the meter. The operating scope of the FTM energy storage market before the meter includes peak load regulation, frequency regulation, backup power supply, renewable energy integration and flexible load; the operating scope of the BTM energy storage market after the meter includes household photovoltaic energy storage.
6. The energy storage operation mode and energy storage cost sharing mechanism method in a typical power market as claimed in claim 1, characterized in that: The key issues of the energy storage cost sharing mechanism in step 2 include the form of energy storage market participation, energy storage operation and investment model under the influence of the electricity price mechanism, and energy storage profit model, namely cost recovery mechanism.
7. The energy storage operation mode and energy storage cost sharing mechanism method in a typical power market as claimed in claim 1, characterized in that: The step 3 provides analysis and suggestions from multiple aspects, including market environment construction, electricity price formation mechanism, cost sharing path and target, and policy subsidy or compensation mechanism, so as to formulate appropriate cost sharing mechanism for different stages of market-oriented development.
8. The energy storage operation mode and energy storage cost sharing mechanism method in a typical power market as claimed in claim 7, characterized in that: The cost sharing path of ES in step 3 at different stages of marketization is as follows: in the initial stage of power market construction, the cost sharing path of energy storage is transmitted to the user end through the transmission and distribution price determined by the government; in the mid-term development of the power market, the energy storage power station adopts a price formation mechanism of "fixed income + variable bidding", in which the fixed income part includes ancillary service compensation and peak-valley power generation compensation, which are shared by power generation enterprises, power grids and users; the variable bidding part is determined by market competition, and the remaining capacity participates in the bidding of the power energy market and the ancillary service market; in the mature stage of power market development, the energy storage power station adopts a fully market-based price formation mechanism under the complete market system, and each market participant should provide a certain amount of funds to the energy storage system according to market rules, and all participants in the power market participate in cost sharing.
9. The energy storage operation mode and energy storage cost sharing mechanism method in a typical power market as claimed in claim 8, characterized in that: The funds that market participants should provide to energy storage systems in accordance with market rules during the mature stage of electricity market development include contract electricity prices in the medium and long-term markets, electricity charges in the electricity market, and ancillary service fees in the standby and ancillary service markets in accordance with market rules; all participants in the electricity market include users, various power generation companies, power grid companies, and power sales companies.
10. The energy storage operation mode and energy storage cost sharing mechanism method in a typical power market as claimed in claim 7, characterized in that: The policy recommendations for my country's ES cost-sharing mechanism in step 3 include gradually improving the domestic spot market mechanism, forming the electricity market clearing price and ancillary service price through market-based means; formulating a reasonable time-of-use electricity price mechanism to guide orderly investment in distributed energy storage; Strengthen the energy storage cost sharing path between the supply and demand sides of the power system; the adaptability of the energy storage capacity compensation mechanism.
