Laches
Also called Prosecution laches, Patent laches
Laches in US patent law is an equitable defense based on unreasonable, prejudicial delay in bringing suit1. In SCA Hygiene (2017), the US Supreme Court held that laches cannot bar damages for infringement within the period prescribed by section 2861. The Federal Circuit in Hyatt v. Hirshfeld (2021) explained that prosecution laches may render a patent unenforceable when unreasonable and unexplained prosecution delay, including prejudice, amounts to egregious misuse of the patent system under the totality of the circumstances2.
Laches as a defense to damages
In SCA Hygiene v. First Quality (2017), the US Supreme Court held that laches cannot be raised as a defense to damages for infringement that occurred within the period prescribed by 35 U.S.C. 2861.
Except as otherwise provided by law, section 286 bars recovery for infringement committed more than six years before the filing of the infringement complaint or counterclaim in the action3.
For claims against the US government for use of a patented invention, section 286 excludes from that lookback the time before suit, up to six years, between the authorized department or agency's receipt of a written compensation claim and the government's mailing of a notice denying it3.
In SCA Hygiene (2017), the US Supreme Court left unaddressed the Federal Circuit's treatment of laches as applied to equitable relief and its reversal of the district court's equitable-estoppel ruling1.
Prosecution laches in infringement actions
In Hyatt v. Hirshfeld (2021), the US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit explained that prosecution laches may render a patent unenforceable when it issued only after unreasonable and unexplained prosecution delay amounting to egregious misuse of the statutory patent system under the totality of the circumstances, including a finding of prejudice2.
The Federal Circuit in Hyatt (2021) said that in an infringement action the accused infringer must prove prejudice attributable to the patentee's delay by showing that the accused infringer or others invested in, worked on, or used the claimed technology during the delay2.
Prosecution laches in actions to obtain a patent
In Hyatt (2021), the Federal Circuit held that the USPTO generally must prove intervening rights to establish prejudice in a section 145 action2. The Federal Circuit held in Hyatt (2021) that if the USPTO shows an unreasonable and unexplained prosecution delay of six years or more, that showing raises a presumption of prejudice, including intervening rights2.
The Federal Circuit in Hyatt (2021) concluded that the USPTO had made that showing and that the burden therefore shifted to the applicant to prove lack of prejudice2.
The Federal Circuit in Hyatt (2021) also held that an applicant's clear abuse of the USPTO's patent examination system and its effects can satisfy the prejudice requirement in a section 145 action2.
For examination within the USPTO, MPEP 2190 says the examiner should obtain approval from the Technology Center Director before rejecting claims on prosecution history laches grounds4.
Questions people ask
Check a product
FTO Search AI Agent
Turn product details into a reviewable search strategy, focused patent candidates, and evidence your IP team can take further.
Run FTO SearchCan laches bar damages for infringement within the section 286 period?
No, the US Supreme Court held in SCA Hygiene (2017) that laches cannot bar damages where the infringement occurred within the period prescribed by section 2861.
Does section 286 measure its general damages lookback from when the owner learns of infringement?
No, subject to exceptions provided by law, section 286 looks back six years from the filing of the infringement complaint or counterclaim in the action3.
Can prosecution laches affect whether an issued patent is enforceable?
Yes, the Federal Circuit explained in Hyatt (2021) that prosecution laches may render a patent unenforceable when the statutory patent system was egregiously misused through an unreasonable and unexplained delay in prosecution, assessed under the totality of the circumstances and including prejudice2.
How it connects
Go from the term to the task
Read how the method works, run it on your own product or idea, then try a free tool.
- 01 / How-toHow to run a freedom-to-operate analysisScope, search, claim review and the report counsel will ask for.Read
- 02 / AI agentFTO Search AI AgentTurn product details into a reviewable search strategy, focused patent candidates, and evidence your IP team can take further.Run it
- 03 / Free toolAI prior art searchDescribe an idea, get the closest patents.Try tool