Reduction to practice
Also called actual reduction to practice, constructive reduction to practice
Reduction to practice can be actual or constructive in US priority disputes governed by pre-AIA section 102(g)1,2. Actual reduction to practice in an interference requires constructing an embodiment or performing a process that meets every element of the interference count and works for its intended purpose1. Constructive reduction to practice occurs when a patent application is filed with a written description and enabling disclosure of the relevant subject matter1.
Actual and constructive reduction to practice
| Form | What establishes it |
|---|---|
| Actual | In an interference, a party must construct an embodiment or perform a process meeting every element of the interference count, and the embodiment or process must work for its intended purpose1. |
| Constructive | Under MPEP 2138.05, filing a patent application serves as conception and constructive reduction to practice for subject matter that the application adequately describes and enables1. |
Under MPEP 2138.05, the testing needed to show that an invention works for its intended purpose depends on the facts and the nature of the invention1. Construction alone can show workability for some simple inventions, and commercial readiness is unnecessary1.
MPEP 2138.05 also explains that, for an experiment to count as actual reduction to practice, the inventor must recognize and appreciate the invention at the time1.
Under MPEP 2138.05, an earlier US application relied on for filing-date benefit in an interference must meet section 120 and the applicable requirements of section 112(a) or pre-AIA section 112, first paragraph, for the subject matter of the interference count1.
Priority under pre-AIA law
In an interference conducted under section 135 or 291, pre-AIA section 102(g)(1) bars a patent if another inventor in the proceeding establishes, to the extent permitted by section 104, that the other inventor made the invention before the person seeking or holding the patent did and had not abandoned, suppressed, or concealed it2. Under section 102(g)(2), a patent is unavailable if another inventor made the invention in the United States before the applicant's invention and had not abandoned, suppressed, or concealed it2. To establish prior art under pre-AIA section 102(g)(2), evidence must show that the other inventor actually reduced the subject matter to practice; filing a patent application alone does not establish actual reduction to practice1. In deciding priority, the decision maker considers when each party conceived and reduced the invention to practice and, if the first to conceive was last to reduce to practice, that party's reasonable diligence from just before the other party's conception through the first conceiver's own reduction to practice1,2.
Pre-AIA sections 102 and 103 govern applications filed before March 16, 2013, and may also govern later-filed applications under the transition rules explained in MPEP 21593,4.
Under AIA section 3(n)(2), an application or resulting patent also subject to the AIA amendments remains subject to pre-AIA section 102(g) for each claim if it contains or ever contained a claim with an effective filing date before March 16, 2013, or a specific reference under section 120, 121, or 365(c) to a patent or application that contains or ever contained such a claim3,4.
Ready for patenting under Pfaff
In Pfaff v. Wells Electronics (1998), the US Supreme Court held that the pre-AIA section 102(b) on-sale bar applies when a product is the subject of a commercial offer for sale and the invention is ready for patenting, with both conditions met before the critical date5. Under pre-AIA section 102(b), the invention must have been on sale in the United States, and the critical date is one year before the applicable US patent application date2,5. The Federal Circuit held in Crown Packaging (2024) that a commercial offer directed from abroad to a US entity at its US place of business can satisfy the US location requirement6.
The US Supreme Court in Pfaff (1998) said readiness could be shown in at least two ways: proof of reduction to practice before the critical date, or proof that before that date the inventor prepared drawings or other descriptions specific enough to enable a person skilled in the art to practice the invention5.
Questions people ask
Draft and prosecute
Patent Drafting AI Agent
Analyze source material, draft, review and format in one guided flow instead of repeating work across tools.
Start draftingCan filing an application count as reduction to practice?
Yes. Under MPEP 2138.05, filing serves as constructive reduction to practice for subject matter the application adequately describes and enables1.
Does actual reduction to practice require a commercially ready invention?
No. MPEP 2138.05 requires evidence that the invention works for its intended purpose1. The need for testing depends on the invention, and commercially satisfactory development is unnecessary1.
Is reduction to practice required to show readiness for patenting under Pfaff?
No, the US Supreme Court in Pfaff (1998) said that the inventor's drawings or other descriptions can also show readiness if prepared before the critical date and specific enough to enable a person skilled in the art to practice the invention5.
How it connects
Go from the term to the task
Read how the method works, run it on your own product or idea, then try a free tool.
- 01 / How-toPatentability search: a practical guideCheck whether an invention is new before you spend on a filing.Read
- 02 / AI agentNovelty Search AI AgentTurn an invention disclosure into ranked prior art and feature-level evidence, so IP teams can review novelty risk with clearer context.Run it
- 03 / Free toolPatent draft style studioRewrite a technical description in claim language.Try tool