A hierarchical ecological risk assessment method for PPCPs in surface water
By introducing stratified assessment methods in pollutant ecological risk assessment, including risk quotient method, potential impact ratio method, safety degree assessment and joint probability curve method, the problems of single-point assessment and risk probability statistics in the existing technology are solved. A multi-level comprehensive evaluation of PPCPs in surface water and a more reliable pollutant risk assessment were achieved.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202210187867.7
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2022-02-28
- Publication Date
- 2024-12-06
- Estimated Expiration
- 2042-02-28
AI Technical Summary
In the prior art, the ecological risk assessment method for pollutants is evaluated in a single point, and the overall risk cannot be fully evaluated, and the differences in various species in the ecosystem and the chronic effects are not taken into account. The calculation result of the risk quotient method is a single point determined value, which cannot provide risk probability. statistics.
A stratified ecological risk assessment method for PPCPs in surface water is proposed, including four-level evaluation: first-level risk quotient method, second-level potential impact ratio method, third-level safety assessment and fourth-level joint probability curve method, through environmental exposure concentration and toxicity The data were evaluated in a comprehensive multi-level manner, reflecting the potential harm of pollutants to aquatic organisms.
A multi-level comprehensive evaluation from simple to complex has been achieved, which can truly reflect the environmental pollution status, and the evaluation results are consistent, which improves the reliability and comprehensiveness of the evaluation.
Smart Images

Figure CN114707798B_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The invention belongs to the field of ecological risk assessment methods, and in particular relates to a hierarchical ecological risk assessment method for PPCPs in surface water. Background Art
[0002] Pharmaceuticals and personal care products are a class of emerging organic pollutants, which involve a wide range of categories, including drugs used to treat and prevent various diseases in humans and animals, as well as organic compounds added to care products and industrial products. As the production, use and discharge of these compounds continue to expand, they show a "pseudo-persistent" status in the environment, gradually causing harm to the water environment and aquatic organisms. Ecological risk assessment is based on environmental exposure concentrations and species toxicity data to assess the possibility of adverse ecological effects caused by exposure to different stressors. Ecological assessment provides a key factor for environmental decision-making. The ecological and environmental risks of PPCPs in the water environment originated abroad, and China gradually began to pay attention to the environmental risk assessment of PPCPs in the 1990s. Sweden used the Stockholm model to conduct ecological risk assessment of residual drugs in water bodies. The assessment results showed that about 1 / 3 of the 160 drugs were bioaccumulative, about 2 / 3 of the drugs were highly toxic to organisms, and almost all drugs were not biodegradable in the water environment. In 1992, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) also began to study the occurrence, sources, environmental behavior, ecological risks and potential risks to human health of PPCPs in the water environment. They found that although PPCPs have low concentrations and short half-lives in the environment, these substances are cumulative in organisms and pose potential risks to aquatic organisms and human health if they exist in the environment for a long time.
[0003] In the prior art, when evaluating the ecological risk of pollutants, the method used is mostly the risk quotient method (Riskquotient, RQ), which is mainly based on single-point assessment, that is, the ratio of the measured environmental concentration (MEC) to the predicted no-effect concentration (PNEC) to quantitatively assess the environmental risk. The MEC value is the actual measurement data or the model calculation value; the PNEC value is usually obtained from the toxicity test results of a single species, and the model prediction value can also be used for substances that lack experimental data. The larger the RQ value, the higher the ecological risk.
[0004] Disadvantages:
[0005] (1) The risk quotient method is the most commonly used method due to its simplicity. However, this method is only a single-point assessment method and is a relatively conservative risk assessment method.
[0006] (2) The calculation result of the risk quotient method is a single-point fixed value, not a statistical value of risk probability, and cannot assess the overall risk size.
[0007] (3) The PNEC value is determined from the toxicity data of the most sensitive species, without considering the differences among species within the ecosystem and the chronic effects of species. Summary of the Invention
[0008] The present invention provides a hierarchical ecological risk assessment method for PPCPs in surface water, which solves the above problems.
[0009] To solve the above technical problems, the present invention is realized through the following technical solutions:
[0010] The hierarchical ecological risk assessment method for PPCPs in surface water of the present invention includes screening from low levels to risk assessment at high levels, and is divided into four levels of evaluation:
[0011] First-level risk assessment: Risk quotient method, which uses the ratio method of environmental exposure concentration MEC and PNEC. The assumption of this method is that when the pollutant exposure concentration is greater than NPEC, potential hazards may occur at any time; otherwise, the expected risk is minimal;
[0012]
[0013] RQ < 0.01 indicates that the environmental exposure concentration of this pollutant is risk-free;
[0014] 0.01 < RQ < 0.1 indicates that the environmental exposure concentration of this pollutant is at low risk;
[0015] 0.1 < RQ < 1 indicates that the environmental exposure concentration of this pollutant has medium risk;
[0016] RQ > 1 indicates that the environmental exposure concentration of this pollutant has high risk;
[0017] Second-level risk assessment: Potential impact proportion method, which is the cumulative probability directly obtained based on the position of the pollutant exposure concentration on the SSD curve as the proportion of species affected at this sampling point. This method uses parameter fitting, usually using log-logistic to obtain the SSD curve, and then substituting the environmental exposure concentration into the model formula to calculate the potential impact proportion;
[0018]
[0019] x - Environmental concentration of the pollutant;
[0020] a, b - Model parameters;
[0021] Three-level risk assessment: safety, which is a ratio calculated by toxicity data and environmental concentration distribution. SSD10 is the concentration when 10% of aquatic organisms are affected, and C90 is the concentration value of the 90th percentile of the environmental concentration distribution. Toxicity and concentration data are logarithmically transformed. Generally speaking, MOS10<1 means that the toxicity data and environmental concentration distribution are highly consistent, which may cause high risks to aquatic organisms; MOS10>1 means that the environmental risk to aquatic organisms is small.
[0022]
[0023] SSD10—the concentration at which 10% of aquatic organisms are affected;
[0024] C90—the concentration at the 90th percentile of the ambient concentration distribution;
[0025] Fourth layer and risk assessment: Joint probability curve method, which comprehensively considers the variability and uncertainty of pollutant exposure concentration and biological toxicity value in the environment, uses toxicity data and concentration data, and obtains the relationship between the proportion of organisms harmed by pollutants and the risk ratio of target water bodies through Matlab fitting, reflecting the probability of exposure concentration exceeding the critical concentration under different hazard levels; in the joint probability curve, the X-axis represents the probability of aquatic organisms being affected, and the Y-axis represents the frequency of environmental exposure concentration exceeding the standard; the area formed by JPC and the coordinate axes on both sides can represent the expected value of the overall risk; a point on the joint probability curve represents the probability of a concentration that harms a specific percentage of aquatic organisms appearing in the target water body.
[0026] Compared with the prior art, the present invention has the following beneficial effects:
[0027] The present invention proposes a method for evaluating the ecological risk of water environment by stratification, that is, it is divided into four levels of evaluation from low-level screening to high-level risk assessment, and can carry out multi-level comprehensive evaluation from simple to complex. By analyzing the actual water environment exposure concentration in the surface water of Jiangsu Province, it truly reflects the environmental pollution status, adopts a four-level hierarchical ecological risk assessment, and the evaluation results are consistent, reflecting the reliability of the invention.
[0028] Of course, any product implementing the present invention does not necessarily need to achieve all of the advantages described above at the same time. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0029] In order to more clearly illustrate the technical solutions of the embodiments of the present invention, the accompanying drawings required for describing the embodiments will be briefly introduced below. Obviously, the accompanying drawings described below are only some embodiments of the present invention. For ordinary technicians in this field, other accompanying drawings can be obtained based on these accompanying drawings without paying creative work.
[0030] Figure 1 Species sensitivity distribution curve based on chronic data with groundwater in Jiangsu Province as a specific example;
[0031] Figure 2 Species sensitivity distribution curve based on acute data;
[0032] Figure 3 Box plot of risk quotient values of PPCPs in surface water of Jiangsu Province based on one - level risk assessment;
[0033] Figure 4 Data table graph for evaluating the potential risk values of PPCPs based on two - level risk assessment;
[0034] Figure 5 Data table graph for evaluating SSD10, C90, and MOS10 values of PPCPs based on three - level risk assessment;
[0035] Figure 6 Joint probability curve graph of PPCPs in surface water of Jiangsu Province based on four - level risk assessment. Detailed implementation manners
[0036] Next, the technical solutions in the embodiments of the present invention will be clearly and completely described in conjunction with the accompanying drawings in the embodiments of the present invention. Obviously, the described embodiments are only a part of the embodiments of the present invention, rather than all of the embodiments. Based on the embodiments of the present invention, all other embodiments obtained by those of ordinary skill in the art without making creative efforts belong to the scope of protection of the present invention.
[0037] Please refer to Figure 1-6 As shown, the hierarchical ecological risk assessment method for PPCPs in surface water of the present invention uses the actual water environment exposure concentration in surface water of Jiangsu Province to truly reflect the environmental pollution situation, including screening from low - level to high - level risk assessment, which is divided into four - level evaluations:
[0038] One - level risk assessment: Risk quotient method, using the ratio method of environmental exposure concentration MEC and PNEC. The assumption of this method is that when the pollutant exposure concentration is greater than NPEC, potential hazards may occur at any time; otherwise, the expected risk is minimal;
[0039]
[0040] RQ < 0.01 indicates that the environmental exposure concentration of this pollutant has no risk;
[0041] 0.01 < RQ < 0.1 indicates that the environmental exposure concentration of this pollutant has low risk;
[0042] 0.1 < RQ < 1 indicates a medium risk for the environmental exposure concentration of this pollutant;
[0043] RQ > 1 indicates a high risk for the environmental exposure concentration of this pollutant;
[0044] Second-level risk assessment: Potential impact proportion method. The cumulative probability directly obtained based on the position of the pollutant exposure concentration on the SSD curve is the proportion of species affected at this sampling point. This method uses parameter fitting, usually using log-logistic to obtain the SSD curve, and then substituting the environmental exposure concentration into the model formula to calculate the potential impact proportion;
[0045]
[0046] x—the environmental concentration of the pollutant;
[0047] a, b—model parameters;
[0048] Third-level risk assessment: Safety factor. It is a ratio calculated from toxicity data and environmental concentration distribution. SSD10 is the concentration when 10% of aquatic organisms are affected, and C90 is the concentration value at the 90th percentile of the environmental concentration distribution. Both the toxicity and concentration data are logarithmically transformed; generally, MOS10 < 1 indicates a high degree of conformity between toxicity data and environmental concentration distribution, posing a high risk to aquatic organisms; MOS10 > 1 indicates a low environmental risk to aquatic organisms;
[0049]
[0050] SSD10—the concentration when 10% of aquatic organisms are affected;
[0051] C90—the concentration at the 90th percentile of the environmental concentration distribution;
[0052] Fourth-level risk assessment: Joint probability curve method. It comprehensively considers the variability and uncertainty of pollutant exposure concentration and biological toxicity values in the environment. Using toxicity data and concentration data, the relationship between the proportion of organisms harmed by the pollutant and the risk proportion of the target water body is obtained through Matlab fitting, reflecting the probability that the exposure concentration exceeds the critical concentration at different harm levels; in the joint probability curve, the X-axis represents the probability of aquatic organisms being affected, and the Y-axis represents the frequency of environmental exposure concentration exceeding the standard; the area of the region formed by the JPC and the two coordinate axes can characterize the expected value of the overall risk (Expected total risk, ETR); a certain point on the joint probability curve represents the probability that the concentration at which a specific percentage of aquatic organisms are harmed appears in the target water body.
[0053] This specific embodiment is based on the method of the present invention, and utilizes the actual water environment exposure concentration in the surface water of Jiangsu Province to truly reflect the environmental pollution status, and characterizes the risk by quantitatively comparing the distribution probability of the water environment exposure concentration and the effect concentration, fully evaluates the risk of pollutants to the water environment, and adopts a four-level hierarchical risk assessment method to perform a multi-level comprehensive evaluation from simple to complex; the water environment exposure concentration in this specific embodiment is the actual concentration measured by myself at 203 sampling points in the surface water of Jiangsu Province, and a four-level hierarchical ecological risk assessment is adopted, and the evaluation results are consistent, reflecting the reliability of the invention.
[0054] like Figure 1 Shown is a species sensitivity distribution curve based on chronic data; Figure 2 It is a species sensitivity distribution curve based on acute data; Figure 3 This is a box plot of the risk quotient values of PPCPs in surface water of Jiangsu Province based on a hierarchical risk assessment; Figure 4 It is a data table showing the potential risk value assessment of PPCPs based on the second-level risk assessment; Figure 5 It is a data table diagram for evaluating the SSD10, C90, and MOS10 values of PPCPs based on the three-level risk assessment; Figure 6 This is a joint probability curve of PPCPs in surface water of Jiangsu Province based on four-level risk assessment; the results of the four-level risk assessment consistently show that diclofenac, ibuprofen, carbamazepine and octocrylene in surface water of Jiangsu Province pose potential risks to the water environment.
[0055] Beneficial effects:
[0056] The present invention proposes a method for evaluating the ecological risk of water environment by stratification, that is, it is divided into four levels of evaluation from low-level screening to high-level risk assessment, and can carry out multi-level comprehensive evaluation from simple to complex. By analyzing the actual water environment exposure concentration in the surface water of Jiangsu Province, it truly reflects the environmental pollution status, adopts a four-level hierarchical ecological risk assessment, and the evaluation results are consistent, reflecting the reliability of the invention.
[0057] The preferred embodiments of the present invention disclosed above are only used to help illustrate the present invention. The preferred embodiments do not describe all the details in detail, nor do they limit the invention to the specific implementation methods described. Obviously, many modifications and changes can be made according to the content of this specification. This specification selects and specifically describes these embodiments in order to better explain the principles and practical applications of the present invention, so that those skilled in the art can understand and use the present invention well. The present invention is limited only by the claims and their full scope and equivalents.
Claims
1. A hierarchical ecological risk assessment method for PPCPs in surface water, characterized in that: It includes screening at a low level and risk assessment at a high level, which are divided into four levels of assessment: First-level risk assessment: Risk quotient method. It uses the ratio method of environmental exposure concentration MEC and PNEC. The assumption of this method is that when the pollutant exposure concentration is greater than NPEC, potential hazards may occur at any time; otherwise, the expected risk is minimal. RQ < 0.01 indicates that there is no risk in the environmental exposure concentration of this pollutant. 0.01 < RQ < 0.1 indicates that there is a low risk in the environmental exposure concentration of this pollutant. 0.1 < RQ < 1 indicates that there is a medium risk in the environmental exposure concentration of this pollutant. RQ > 1 indicates that there is a high risk in the environmental exposure concentration of this pollutant. Second-level risk assessment: Potential impact proportion method. It is the cumulative probability directly obtained based on the position of the pollutant exposure concentration on the SSD curve, which is the proportion of species affected at this sampling point. This method uses parameter fitting, usually using log-logistic to obtain the SSD curve, and then substituting the environmental exposure concentration into the model formula to calculate the potential impact proportion. x—the environmental concentration of the pollutant a, b—model parameters Third-level risk assessment: Safety factor. It is a ratio calculated through toxicity data and environmental concentration distribution. SSD10 is the concentration when 10% of aquatic organisms are affected, and C90 is the concentration value at the 90th percentile of the environmental concentration distribution. Both toxicity and concentration data are logarithmically transformed. Generally speaking, MOS10 < 1 indicates a high degree of conformity between toxicity data and environmental concentration distribution, which may pose a high risk to aquatic organisms; MOS10 > 1 indicates a small environmental risk to aquatic organisms. SSD10—the concentration when 10% of aquatic organisms are affected C90—the concentration at the 90th percentile of the environmental concentration distribution Fourth-level risk assessment: Joint probability curve method. It comprehensively considers the variability and uncertainty of pollutant exposure concentration and biological toxicity values in the environment. Using toxicity data and concentration data, the relationship between the proportion of organisms harmed by pollutants and the risk proportion of the target water body is obtained through Matlab fitting, reflecting the probability that the exposure concentration exceeds the critical concentration at different harm levels; in the joint probability curve, the X-axis represents the probability that aquatic organisms are affected, and the Y-axis represents the frequency of environmental exposure concentration exceeding the standard; the area of the region formed by JPC and the two coordinate axes can characterize the expected value of the overall risk; a certain point on the joint probability curve represents the probability that the concentration at which a specific percentage of aquatic organisms are harmed appears in the target water body.
