Fair appraisal system and method thereof
By introducing target recommendation, user access, effective judgment and result statistics components in the evaluation system, combined with expert review and data analysis, the problem of repeated review and vote swiping in the evaluation system is solved, the fair review results are achieved, and the public's evaluation results are restored Trust.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202410940470.X
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2021-09-23
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-08
AI Technical Summary
Due to the problems of arbitrary review, artificial participation in order swiping, canvassing, etc., the existing review system has led to unfair review results and lost public trust. How to eliminate the phenomenon of repeated reviews and canvassing, and achieve fair review results.
A fair review system was designed to restrict user repeated reviews through target recommendation components, review user access components, effective review judgment components and review result statistics components, and ensure that each user effectively evaluates multiple targets to be reviewed and passes experts Review and data analysis exclude vote swiping data to ensure the fairness of the review results.
It effectively prevents users from repeatedly reviewing and vote-brushing, ensures the fairness and trust of the review results, and improves the reliability and credibility of Internet reviews.
Smart Images

Figure CN118916402A_ABST
Abstract
Description
[0001] This application is filed on September 23, 2021, and the national application number is
[0002] A divisional application of the invention patent application No. 202111113369.X, entitled “Fair review system and method thereof”. Technical Field
[0003] The present disclosure relates to a fair review system and method thereof. Background Art
[0004] At present, Internet business is developing rapidly, and many industries are carrying out various review projects and launching voting and review invitations to the public through various application software.
[0005] However, the existing review system cannot actually reflect people's actual attitudes towards the various review targets in the reviewed projects due to the fact that reviewers make random reviews, artificially participate in fake orders, and canvass for votes. As a result, the final review results sometimes completely deviate from people's intuitive feelings, causing people to increasingly distrust the review results, forming a sense of distrust in social networks, and causing extremely negative social effects. How to eliminate the problem of repeated reviews by the same user and the problem of many users making consistent reviews for the same review target due to canvassing has become a practical need that needs to be solved now.
[0006] Therefore, as online social networking becomes more and more convenient, people hope to obtain a review system and review method that can achieve fair review results, which can limit people's arbitrary vote-rigging and vote-buying behaviors, and even if vote-buying exists, it can eliminate the injustice caused by vote-buying, thereby rebuilding trust in Internet reviews. Summary of the invention
[0007] To this end, in order to solve the above technical problems, the present disclosure proposes a fair review system, including: a target recommendation component, used to recommend multiple targets to be reviewed belonging to the same review project, and attach an initial presentation serial number publicly presented to users to each target to be reviewed; a review user access component, which obtains the unique identity information of each user, and assigns the user a review restriction on the target to be reviewed, wherein the review restriction indicates that the user reviews at least two or more predetermined numbers of targets to be reviewed in the same review, and restricts the user to review the same review project only once; a valid review judgment component, which obtains the review data input by each user, and judges the review containing the results of one review for a predetermined number of targets as valid review data, thereby eliminating invalid review results; and a review result statistics component, which regularly counts the user review scores of each target to be reviewed in the same review project that is publicly presented, and modifies the presentation serial number according to the order of the cumulative review scores.
[0008] The fair review system according to the present disclosure also includes: an expert review access component, which is used to transmit multiple targets to be reviewed in the same review project that have not been publicly presented to expert users, so that the expert users can conduct expert reviews based on their expert review authority, thereby enabling the target recommendation component to perform target recommendations based on the expert review results, and recommend a predetermined number of top-ranked targets to be reviewed for public presentation.
[0009] According to the fair review system disclosed in the present invention, when the scores of the expert review results of the multiple targets to be reviewed reach a predetermined score, they are recommended for public presentation.
[0010] The fair review system according to the present disclosure also includes: a review target collection component, which is used to publicly collect multiple targets to be reviewed belonging to the same review project from the public, and after a predetermined time period or after the multiple targets to be reviewed exceed a predetermined number, send a review invitation to the expert review access component, so that the experts who receive the invitation conduct expert reviews on the collected multiple targets to be reviewed through the expert review access component.
[0011] According to the fair review system disclosed in the present invention, the review user access component obtains each user's unique identity information including user information of multiple application software associated with each other and deployed on one or more terminal devices.
[0012] According to the fair review system disclosed herein, the unique identity information of the user includes but is not limited to: one of various combinations of Weibo, QQ, WeChat, Twitter, SMS and Facebook user information associated with the same user.
[0013] According to the fair review system disclosed in the present invention, the review result statistics component excludes review results submitted by different applications associated with the user's unique identity information based on the association relationship of the user information contained in the user's unique identity information.
[0014] According to the fair review system disclosed in the present invention, it also includes: a review reward component, which compares the similarity between the review results provided by any user through the review user access component and the review results at the review deadline, and sends a predetermined reward to the user when the similarity of the user's review results reaches a predetermined value.
[0015] According to the fair review system disclosed in the present invention, it also includes: a transaction request component, which, based on a user's request, issues a transaction request for the target to be reviewed to a specific public that provides the collected target to be reviewed, and based on the confirmation of the specific public, feeds back a confirmation result to the user who issued the request.
[0016] According to the fair review system disclosed in the present invention, it also includes: a review project initiation component, which is used to create a new review project, and based on the created new review project, send a review project collection request to the review target collection component, wherein the request includes a target category, review method, collection time period, review time period and review reward method.
[0017] According to another aspect of the present disclosure, a fair review method is provided, including: recommending multiple targets to be reviewed in the same review project through a target recommendation component, and attaching an initial presentation serial number publicly presented to users to each target to be reviewed; when a user accesses a review project through a review user access component, obtaining unique identity information of each user, and assigning review restrictions to the target to be reviewed to the user; obtaining a review result input by the user through the review user access component based on the review restrictions only for at least two or more targets to be reviewed in the same review project; obtaining review data input by each user through a valid review determination component, and determining the review containing the review results for a predetermined number of targets as valid review data; and timely counting the user review scores of each target to be reviewed in the same review project that are publicly presented through a review result statistics component, and modifying the presentation serial number according to the order of the cumulative review scores.
[0018] The fair review method according to the present disclosure also includes: transmitting multiple targets to be reviewed in the same review project that have not been publicly presented to expert users through the expert review access component, so that the expert users can conduct expert reviews based on their expert review authority, thereby enabling the target recommendation component to perform target recommendations based on the expert review results, and recommending a predetermined number of top-ranked targets to be reviewed for public presentation.
[0019] The fair review method according to the present disclosure also includes: when the expert review result scores of the multiple targets to be reviewed reach a predetermined score, recommending public presentation of the targets to be reviewed.
[0020] According to the fair review method disclosed in the present invention, it also includes: publicly soliciting multiple targets to be reviewed belonging to the same review project from the public through the review target solicitation component; after a predetermined time period or after the multiple targets to be reviewed exceed a predetermined number, sending a review invitation to the expert review access component; and the experts who receive the invitation conduct expert reviews on the collected multiple targets to be reviewed through the expert review access component.
[0021] According to the fair review method disclosed in the present invention, the review user access component obtains each user's unique identity information including user information of multiple application software associated with each other and deployed on one or more terminal devices.
[0022] According to the fair review method disclosed herein, the unique identity information of the user includes but is not limited to: one of various combinations of Weibo, QQ, WeChat, Twitter, SMS and Facebook user information associated with the same user.
[0023] According to the fair review method disclosed in the present invention, it also includes: excluding review results submitted by different applications associated with the user's unique identity information based on the association relationship of user information contained in the user's unique identity information through the review result statistics component.
[0024] According to the fair review method disclosed in the present invention, it also includes: comparing the similarity between the review results provided by any user through the review user access component and the review results at the review deadline, and sending a predetermined reward to the user when the similarity of the user's review results reaches a predetermined value.
[0025] According to the fair review method disclosed in the present invention, it also includes: issuing a transaction request for the target to be reviewed to the specific public that provides the collected target to be reviewed based on the user's request, and based on the confirmation of the specific public, feeding back the confirmation result to the user who issued the request.
[0026] According to the fair review method disclosed in the present invention, it also includes: creating a new review project through a review project initiation component, and based on the created new review project, issuing a review project solicitation request to a review target solicitation component, wherein the request includes a target category, review method, solicitation time period, review time period, and review reward method.
[0027] Through the fair review system and method disclosed in the present invention, each user, in addition to reviewing the target to be reviewed by himself, must also review one or more other targets to be reviewed in order to form an effective review result. Therefore, when people review a target to be reviewed that is related to themselves with subjectivity, they will review and choose more substantively when reviewing other non-relational targets to be reviewed. Even if users make random reviews when reviewing other non-relational targets to be reviewed, the randomness caused by their randomness will not cause extremely unfair review results to other targets to be reviewed. In addition, since the identity provided by this review system for users is unique identity information, it links various application platforms that can participate, and can obtain the user identity information of different social software platforms of users on different terminals, thus linking the user identity information of different platforms pointing to the same actual user to form unique identity information. Therefore, the review system disclosed in this disclosure can be associated with the unique identity information based on the user identity information of the software platform adopted by the actual user, thereby prohibiting the same actual user from making repeated reviews on the same review project, further eliminating the unfairness of Internet reviews. Moreover, through the final data analysis, the vote-rigging data is identified and eliminated, which further ensures the fairness and justice of the review.
[0028] Other advantages, objectives and features of the present invention will be embodied in part through the following description, and in part will be understood by those skilled in the art through study and practice of the present invention. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0029] Figure 1 Shown is a schematic diagram of a fair review system according to the present disclosure.
[0030] Figure 2 Shown is a flowchart of a fair review method according to the present disclosure. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0031] The present invention is further described in detail below in conjunction with embodiments and drawings so that those skilled in the art can implement the invention with reference to the description.
[0032] Exemplary embodiments will be described in detail herein, examples of which are shown in the accompanying drawings. When the following description refers to the drawings, the same numbers in different drawings represent the same or similar elements unless otherwise indicated. The embodiments described in the following exemplary embodiments do not represent all embodiments consistent with the present disclosure. Instead, they are merely examples of devices and methods consistent with some aspects of the present disclosure as detailed in the appended claims.
[0033] The terms used in this disclosure are for the purpose of describing specific embodiments only and are not intended to limit the disclosure. The singular forms of "a", "said" and "the" used in this disclosure and the appended claims are also intended to include plural forms unless the context clearly indicates otherwise. It should also be understood that the term "and / or" used herein refers to and includes any or all possible combinations of one or more associated listed items.
[0034] It should be understood that although the terms first, second, third, etc. may be used in the present disclosure to describe various information, such information should not be limited to these terms. These terms are only used to distinguish the same type of information from each other. For example, without departing from the scope of the present disclosure, hereinafter, one of two possible graphics cards may be referred to as the first review target or the second review target. Depending on the context, the word "if" as used herein may be interpreted as "at the time of" or "when" or "in response to determining".
[0035] In order to enable those skilled in the art to better understand the present disclosure, the present disclosure is further described in detail below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings and specific embodiments.
[0036] Figure 1 FIG. 1 is a schematic diagram of a fair review system according to the present disclosure. Figure 1 As shown, the fair review system 100 includes: a target recommendation component 105, a review user access component 110, an effective review determination component 115, and a review result statistics component 120. Optionally, the fair review system 100 also includes one or a combination of an expert user access component 130, a review target solicitation component 135, a review project initiation component 140, a review reward component 145, or a target transaction request component 150.
[0037] Specifically, the target recommendation component 105 is used to recommend multiple targets to be reviewed in the same review project, and to attach an initial presentation serial number for public presentation to the user to each target to be reviewed. The initial serial number can be arbitrarily marked for the target to be reviewed or can be marked in the order of collection and acquisition. During the collection period, the numbering continues as the number of collected targets increases until the collection task expires. Optionally, the target recommendation component 105 can also assign the initial presentation serial number based on the expert review results output by the expert review access component 130 (described later).
[0038] When the public participates in the target review, they will access the review system 100 through the review user access component 110. The review system 100 will obtain the unique identity information of each accessing user based on the access message, and give the user the review restrictions on the review target. The unique identity information of each user obtained by the review user access component includes the user information of multiple application software associated with each other deployed on one or more terminal devices. These application software include but are not limited to Weibo, QQ, WeChat, Twitter, SMS and Facebook, etc. These application software also contain the user information dedicated to the software of the accessing user. These user information or user identifications are different from each other, but all point to the same actual user. For this reason, when the review user access component 110 receives the user access message, it obtains the proprietary user identity information of multiple application software deployed by the user on the current terminal device through the user's authorization confirmation, and associates these proprietary user identity information with the unique identity information used for the fair review system 100. In this way, the possibility of an actual user using different application software for repeated review is eliminated. The specific application software that needs to obtain proprietary user identity information is based on the application software on which the project to be reviewed will be deployed.
[0039] The review user access component 110 will assign a review restriction range to a specific review user based on the review restriction requirements set for a specific review project. For example, when each user reviews the same review project, he needs to review at least two or more targets to be reviewed, and no matter what application software is used, he can only review once. In this way, each user who actually participates in the review must review one or more other targets to be reviewed in addition to reviewing the target he wants to review in order to form an effective review result. Therefore, when the review user reviews a target to be reviewed that is related to him subjectively, when reviewing other non-relational targets to be reviewed, he will review and choose more from the essence. Even if the user reviews other non-relational targets to be reviewed at random, the randomness caused by its randomness will not cause extremely unfair review results to other targets to be reviewed.
[0040] The review user access component 110 includes a favorites folder, which is used to collect the review targets that the user is willing to review in the favorites. The number of collections is limited to a predetermined number. Users can directly submit the review results reviewed in the favorites in the favorites. Each user can obtain different review score ranges based on the number of times they participated in the review and the review history data. For users whose review results are highly similar to the final review results according to the review history, they will be given review permissions with higher scores, that is, the user's review of the target can be given a higher weight or a higher score range.
[0041] Optionally, the review user access component 110 includes a review target quantity selection unit and a review score selection unit, so that when conducting target review, the number of reviews and the review score to be given can be directly selected through a drop-down menu. In addition, the review user access component 110 can also include a warning unit, which warns the user when an erroneous operation occurs, such as when the number of reviews exceeds the specified number or the review score exceeds the weight or score assigned to the user.
[0042] After each user conducts a review, the effective review determination component 115 will obtain the review data input by each user, and will determine the review results for a predetermined plurality of targets as effective review data. Specifically, there may be a situation where the same user uses different application software to conduct multiple reviews. For this reason, the effective review determination component 115 will conduct a correlation query based on the proprietary identity information of the application software actually used for access by the user to determine whether it has been reviewed using other application software, thereby determining the validity of its review, and if valid, the review result will be transmitted to the effective review result library, otherwise, the review result will be discarded. Optionally, the review user access component 110 can delete its previous review results when using different application software to participate in the target review again, thereby achieving the purpose of correcting its own review results.
[0043] Finally, the review result statistics component 120 counts the user review scores of each target to be reviewed in the same review project and modifies the presentation sequence number according to the order of the cumulative review scores. Therefore, the review result presentation device 125 always presents the current actual results on time, and the numbering and display order of all the targets to be reviewed are also publicly presented to the public in a timely manner. The review result statistics component 120 excludes the review results submitted by different applications associated with the user's unique identity information based on the association relationship of the user information contained in the user's unique identity information. By analyzing the user evaluation results in this way, illegal (vote-brushing) data is found, analyzed and judged, and finally the illegal user evaluation data is eliminated to obtain a fair evaluation result.
[0044] Optionally, the expert review access component 130 of the fair review system disclosed herein transmits multiple targets to be reviewed in the same review project that are not publicly presented to the expert user, so that the expert user performs expert review based on his expert review authority, so that the target recommendation component 105 performs target recommendation based on the expert review result, and recommends a predetermined number of targets to be reviewed in the front row for public presentation. In addition, optionally, the expert review result scores of the multiple targets to be reviewed reach a predetermined score and are recommended for public presentation. Using experts to pre-review and recommend the targets to be reviewed can guide the general public to participate in the review, can see excellent targets faster, and improve the efficiency of public review. Optionally, even after all targets to be reviewed are publicly presented, experts can also perform expert review through the expert review access component 130, so that newly added excellent targets can be recommended to the front row for sorting.
[0045] The fair review system 100 according to the present disclosure is a review system for the public, and the public can create their own accounts on the review system and initiate project reviews through the review project initiation component 140. The review project initiation component 140 is used to create a new review project, and based on the created new review project, send a review project collection request to the review target collection component, the request includes target category, review method, collection time period, review time period and review reward method.
[0046] Regardless of whether it is the owner of the fair review system 100 or a public user with an account, after initiating a project review through the review project initiation component 140, a plurality of targets to be reviewed belonging to the same review project can be publicly solicited from the public through the review target solicitation component 135, and a review invitation can be sent to the expert review access component 130 after a predetermined time period or after the plurality of targets to be reviewed exceeds a predetermined number, so that the experts receiving the invitation can conduct expert reviews on the collected plurality of targets to be reviewed through the expert review access component.
[0047] In order to enhance the enthusiasm of users to participate in the review and eliminate the situation that users only actively review the targets they are concerned about and passively review other additional targets, the review reward component 145 of the fair review system disclosed in the present invention provides rewards for users who review seriously. Specifically, since the non-utilitarian review of the additional target more reflects the true value of the target, the final result of the non-utilitarian evaluation of the additional target will be more similar to the review statistics. For this reason, the review reward component 145 will compare the review results provided by any user through the review user access component with the review results at the review deadline after the review is closed, and send a predetermined reward to the user when the similarity of the user's review results reaches a predetermined value. In order to make the initial ranking of the recommended targets more fair, the review reward component 145 also compares the target recommendation results provided by any expert through the expert review access component with the review results at the review deadline, and sends a predetermined reward to the expert when the similarity of the target recommendation results reaches a predetermined value. Optionally, the review weight of the rewarded expert can be increased so that a higher weight value is given to his review result in subsequent expert reviews, thereby increasing his weight in the initial target review.
[0048] In order to facilitate the public users to obtain their favorite targets for review, the fair review system according to the present disclosure also includes a transaction request component 150, through which the user can issue a transaction request. Such a transaction request can be a purchase, contact for production license, etc. The user can issue a transaction request for the target for review to the specific public who provided the collected target for review through the transaction request component 150. After obtaining the request, the specific public can send a confirmation message so as to feedback the confirmation result to the user who issued the request.
[0049] Figure 2 FIG. 1 is a flow chart of a fair review method according to the present disclosure. Figure 2As shown, first at step S205, multiple targets to be reviewed in the same review project are recommended through the target recommendation component, and an initial presentation sequence number for public presentation to the user is added to each target to be reviewed. At step S210, when a user accesses a review project through the review user access component, the unique identity information of each user is obtained, and the user is given a review restriction on the target to be reviewed. At step S215, a review result input by the user through the review user access component based on the review restriction only for at least two or more targets to be reviewed in the same review project is obtained. The review user access component 110 obtains the unique identity information of each user including user information of multiple application software associated with each other deployed on one or more terminal devices. These application software include but are not limited to Weibo, QQ, WeChat, Twitter, SMS, Facebook, etc. These application software also contain user information dedicated to the software of the accessing user, and these user information or user identifications are different from each other, but all point to the same actual user. To this end, when receiving the user access message, the review user access component 110 obtains the user's dedicated user identity information of multiple application software deployed on the current terminal device through the user's authorization confirmation, and associates these dedicated user identity information with the unique identity information used for the fair review system 100. In this way, the possibility of an actual user using different application software for repeated review is eliminated. The specific application software that needs to obtain dedicated user identity information is based on the application software on which the project to be reviewed will be deployed.
[0050] Thereafter, at step S220, the review data input by each user is obtained through the effective review determination component, and the review containing the review results for a predetermined plurality of targets is determined as the effective review data. Specifically, there may be a situation where the same user uses different application software to conduct multiple reviews. For this reason, the effective review determination component 115 will perform a correlation query based on the proprietary identity information of the application software actually used for access by the user to determine whether it has already conducted reviews using other application software, thereby determining the validity of its review, and if valid, the review result is transmitted to the effective review result library, otherwise, the review result is discarded. Optionally, when the review user access component 110 participates in the target review again using different application software, it can delete its previous review results, thereby achieving the purpose of trimming its own review results.
[0051] At step S225, the review result statistics component timely counts the user review scores of each target to be reviewed in the same review project, and modifies the presentation sequence number according to the order of the cumulative review scores. Therefore, the review result presentation device 125 always presents the current actual results on time, and the numbers and display order of all the targets to be reviewed are also publicly presented to the public in a timely manner. The review result statistics component 120 excludes the review results submitted by different applications associated with the user's unique identity information based on the association relationship of the user information contained in the user's unique identity information.
[0052] In addition, the fair review method according to the present disclosure also includes, at step S230, transmitting multiple targets to be reviewed in the same review project that are not publicly presented to the expert user through the expert review access component 130, so that the expert user can conduct expert review based on his expert review authority, so that the target recommendation component 105 performs target recommendation based on the expert review result, and recommends a predetermined number of top ranked targets to be reviewed for public presentation. Optionally, when the expert review result scores of the multiple targets to be reviewed reach a predetermined score, the targets to be reviewed are recommended for public presentation.
[0053] In addition, according to the fair review method disclosed in the present invention, it also includes, at step S235, publicly soliciting multiple targets to be reviewed belonging to the same review project from the public through the review target solicitation component 135; after a predetermined time period or after the multiple targets to be reviewed exceed a predetermined number, sending a review invitation to the expert review access component 130; and the experts who receive the invitation conduct expert reviews on the collected multiple targets to be reviewed through the expert review access component.
[0054] In addition, the fair review method according to the present disclosure also includes, at step S220, excluding review results submitted by different applications associated with the user's unique identity information based on the association relationship of user information contained in the user's unique identity information through the review result statistics component.
[0055] In addition, according to the fair review method disclosed in the present invention, it also includes, at step S245, comparing the similarity of the review results provided by any user through the review user access component with the review results at the review deadline, and sending a predetermined reward to the user when the similarity of the user's review results reaches a predetermined value.
[0056] In addition, the fair review method according to the present disclosure also includes, at step S250, issuing a transaction request for the target to be reviewed to the specific public that provides the collected target to be reviewed based on the user's request, and based on the confirmation of the specific public, feeding back the confirmation result to the user who issued the request.
[0057] In addition, according to the fair review method disclosed in the present invention, it also includes, at step S240, creating a new review project through the review project initiation component, and based on the created new review project, issuing a review project collection request to the review target collection component, wherein the request includes a target category, review method, collection time period, review time period and review reward method.
[0058] In summary, through the fair review system and method disclosed in the present invention, each user, in addition to reviewing the relational target to be reviewed, must also review one or more other targets to be reviewed in order to form an effective review result. Therefore, when people review a target to be reviewed that is related to themselves with subjectivity, they will review and choose more substantively when reviewing other non-relational targets to be reviewed. Even if users make random reviews when reviewing other non-relational targets to be reviewed, the randomness caused by their randomness will not cause extremely unfair review results to other targets to be reviewed. In addition, since the identity provided by this review system for users is unique identity information, it links various application platforms that can participate, and can obtain the user identity information of different social software platforms of users on different terminals, thus linking the user identity information of different platforms pointing to the same actual user to form unique identity information. Therefore, the review system disclosed in this disclosure can be associated with the unique identity information based on the user identity information of the software platform adopted by the actual user, thereby prohibiting the same actual user from making repeated reviews on the same review project, further eliminating the unfairness of Internet reviews. Moreover, through the final data analysis, the vote-rigging data is identified and eliminated, which further ensures the fairness and justice of the review.
[0059] The basic principles of the present disclosure are described above in conjunction with specific embodiments. However, it should be pointed out that a person skilled in the art can understand that all or any steps or components of the method and apparatus of the present disclosure can be implemented in hardware, firmware, software or a combination thereof in any computing device (including a processor, storage medium, etc.) or a network of computing devices. This can be achieved by a person skilled in the art using their basic programming skills after reading the description of the present disclosure.
[0060] Therefore, the purpose of the present disclosure can also be achieved by running a program or a group of programs on any computing device. The computing device can be a well-known general-purpose device. Therefore, the purpose of the present disclosure can also be achieved by simply providing a program product containing a program code that implements the method or device. In other words, such a program product also constitutes the present disclosure, and a storage medium storing such a program product also constitutes the present disclosure. Obviously, the storage medium can be any well-known storage medium or any storage medium developed in the future.
[0061] It should also be noted that, in the apparatus and method of the present disclosure, it is obvious that each component or each step can be decomposed and / or recombined. These decompositions and / or recombinations should be regarded as equivalent schemes of the present disclosure. In addition, the steps of performing the above series of processes can naturally be performed in chronological order according to the order of description, but do not necessarily need to be performed in chronological order. Some steps can be performed in parallel or independently of each other.
[0062] The above specific implementations do not constitute a limitation on the protection scope of the present disclosure. It should be understood by those skilled in the art that various modifications, combinations, sub-combinations and substitutions may occur depending on design requirements and other factors. Any modification, equivalent substitution and improvement made within the spirit and principle of the present disclosure shall be included in the protection scope of the present disclosure.
Claims
1. A fair review system, comprising: The target recommendation component is used to recommend multiple targets to be reviewed in the same review project, and to attach an initial presentation sequence number for public presentation to users to each target to be reviewed; A review user access component, which obtains each user's unique identity information including user information of multiple application softwares associated with each other and deployed on one or more terminal devices, and assigns the user a review restriction on the review target, wherein the review restriction indicates that the user reviews at least two or more predetermined numbers of the review targets in the same review, and restricts the user to review the same review item only once, and upon receiving a user access message, obtains the user's proprietary user identity information of multiple application softwares deployed on the current terminal device through the user's authorization confirmation, and associates the proprietary user identity information with the unique identity information used for the fair review system, and each user is assigned a different review score range based on the number of times the user has participated in the review and the review history data; An effective review determination component obtains the review data input by each user, and determines the review containing a review result for a predetermined number of targets as effective review data, thereby eliminating ineffective review results; and The review result statistics component counts the user review scores of each review target in the same review project on time, and modifies the presentation sequence number according to the order of the cumulative review scores.
2. The fair review system as described in claim 1, wherein the review user access component grants review permissions with higher scores to users whose review results are highly similar to the final review results as shown in their review history, so that users can give higher weights or higher score ranges to their reviews of targets.
3. The fair review system according to claim 1, further comprising: The expert review access component is used to transmit multiple targets to be reviewed in the same review project that have not been publicly presented to expert users, so that the expert users can conduct expert reviews based on their expert review permissions, thereby enabling the target recommendation component to perform target recommendations based on the expert review results and recommend a predetermined number of top-ranked targets to be reviewed for public presentation.
4. The fair review system as claimed in claim 3, wherein the expert review results of the plurality of review targets are recommended for public presentation when their scores reach a predetermined value.
5. The fair review system according to claim 3 or 4, further comprising: The review reward component compares the similarity between the target recommendation result provided by any expert through the expert review access component and the review result at the review deadline, and sends a predetermined reward to the expert when the similarity of the target recommendation result reaches a predetermined value.
6. A fair review system as described in claim 5, wherein the review reward component increases the review weight of the rewarded expert, so that the expert gives a higher weight value to his review result in subsequent expert reviews, thereby increasing his weight in the initial target review.
7. A fair review method comprising: Recommend multiple targets to be reviewed in the same review project through the target recommendation component, and attach an initial presentation sequence number for public presentation to users to each target to be reviewed; When a user accesses a review project through the review user access component, the unique identity information of each user including user information of multiple application softwares associated with each other and deployed on one or more terminal devices is obtained, and the user is given review restrictions on the review target; Obtaining a review result input by the user through the review user access component based on the review restriction for at least two or more targets to be reviewed in the same review project, and upon receiving the user access message, obtaining the exclusive user identity information of multiple application software deployed by the user on the current terminal device through the user's authorization confirmation, and associating the exclusive user identity information with the unique identity information used for the fair review system, and assigning different review score ranges to each user based on the number of times the user participated in the review and the review history data; Obtaining the review data input by each user through the effective review determination component, and determining the review containing the review results for the predetermined multiple targets as the effective review data; and The review result statistics component timely counts the user review scores of each target to be reviewed in the same review project that is publicly presented, and modifies the presentation sequence number according to the order of the cumulative review scores.
8. The fair review method according to claim 7, further comprising: The review user access component grants review permissions with higher scores to users whose review results are highly similar to the final review results as shown in the review history, so that the user's review of the target can be given a higher weight or a higher score range.
9. The fair review method according to claim 7, further comprising: Multiple targets to be reviewed that belong to the same review project and are not publicly presented are transmitted to expert users through the expert review access component so that the expert users can conduct expert reviews based on their expert review authority, thereby enabling the target recommendation component to perform target recommendations based on the expert review results and recommend a predetermined number of top-ranked targets to be reviewed for public presentation.
10. The fair review method according to claim 9, further comprising: When the expert review result scores of the multiple targets to be reviewed reach a predetermined score, it is recommended to publicly present the targets to be reviewed.
11. The fair review method according to claim 9 or 10, further comprising: The review reward component compares the similarity between the target recommendation result provided by any expert through the expert review access component and the review result at the review deadline, and sends a predetermined reward to the expert when the similarity of the target recommendation result reaches a predetermined value.
12. The fair review method according to claim 11, further comprising: The review reward component increases the review weight of the rewarded expert, so that the expert can give a higher weight value to his review result in the subsequent expert review, thereby increasing his weight in the initial target review.
