Patent opposition
Also called EPO opposition, opposition proceedings
Patent opposition, under the European Patent Convention, is a procedure for challenging a granted European patent before the European Patent Office1,2. This page covers EPO opposition1,2.
Article 99 EPC permits notice within nine months of publication of the mention of grant in the European Patent Bulletin, and the notice is not deemed filed until the opposition fee is paid1. Article 100 limits opposition to its listed grounds3.
The closed list of grounds in Article 100
- The subject matter is not patentable under EPC Articles 52 to 573.
- The patent does not disclose the invention sufficiently clearly and completely for a person skilled in the art to carry it out3.
- The patent's subject matter extends beyond the application as filed, or, for a patent granted on a divisional or an Article 61 application, beyond the earlier application as filed3.
The notice, examination and decision
Rule 76 requires a written reasoned notice with the opponent's particulars under Rule 41(2)(c), the patent number, proprietor's name and invention title, the extent of opposition and its grounds with supporting facts and evidence, and, if a representative is appointed, the representative's particulars under Rule 41(2)(d)5. Part III of the Implementing Regulations applies to the notice with the necessary adjustments5.
Under Article 101(1), the Opposition Division examines an admissible opposition under the Implementing Regulations to determine whether an Article 100 ground prevents the patent from being maintained4. As often as necessary, the division invites the parties to respond to communications from another party or from the division4.
- Under Article 101(2), it revokes the patent if at least one opposition ground prejudices maintenance; otherwise, it rejects the opposition4.
- Under Article 101(3), the Opposition Division revokes the patent if the patent and invention as amended fail to meet the EPC requirements4. If they meet those requirements, the division maintains the patent as amended provided the conditions in the Implementing Regulations are met4. If the acts required by Rule 82(2) are late, they may still be completed within two months of the communication about the missed time limit7. Otherwise, the patent is revoked7.
Intervention after the opposition period
After the opposition period has expired, a third party may intervene under Article 105 EPC if it proves that infringement proceedings concerning the same patent were brought against it, or that it brought proceedings for a ruling that it does not infringe that patent after the proprietor requested that it cease the alleged infringement8. The opposition or an appeal must still be pending9. During the period for filing an appeal, intervention depends on a party to the proceedings filing an appeal under Article 107 EPC9.
Rule 89 requires intervention within three months of the institution of the Article 105 proceedings, by a written reasoned statement subject to Rules 76 and 77 as applicable, and the notice is not deemed filed until the opposition fee is paid10.
An admissible intervention is treated as an opposition under Article 105(2)8.
European opposition and US post-grant reviews
In the United States, 35 U.S.C. 321 provides for petitions for Post-grant review, and 35 U.S.C. 311 provides for petitions for Inter partes review11,12.
| Proceeding | Grounds identified by its statute |
|---|---|
| EPC opposition3 | Only the grounds in EPC Article 1003. |
| US post-grant review11 | Any ground that could be raised under 35 U.S.C. 282(b)(2) or (3), as specified in section 321(b)11. |
| US inter partes review12 | Only grounds under sections 102 or 103, and only prior art consisting of patents or printed publications, under section 311(b)12. |
Questions people ask
Search before filing
Novelty Search AI Agent
Turn an invention disclosure into ranked prior art and feature-level evidence, so IP teams can review novelty risk with clearer context.
Run Novelty SearchCan the proprietor oppose its own European patent?
No; EPO Guidelines D-I, 4 exclude the proprietor from the persons entitled to give notice of opposition6.
Is the EPO opposition deadline counted from filing?
No; Article 99(1) counts nine months from publication of the mention of grant in the European Patent Bulletin, and requires payment of the opposition fee for the notice to be deemed filed1.
Does an opposition apply in only one Contracting State?
No; Article 99(2) says the opposition applies in all Contracting States where the European patent has effect1.
Can an opposition leave the patent in force with amendments?
Yes, if the patent and invention as amended meet EPC requirements and the Implementing Regulations' conditions are fulfilled under Article 101(3)(a)4.
How it connects
Go from the term to the task
Read how the method works, run it on your own product or idea, then try a free tool.
- 01 / How-toHow to run a freedom-to-operate analysisScope, search, claim review and the report counsel will ask for.Read
- 02 / AI agentFTO Search AI AgentAn AI agent that finds in-force patents that could read on your product, with a claim chart for each one.Run it
- 03 / Free toolAI prior art searchDescribe an idea, get the closest patents.Try tool