Grid optimization method for preventing commutation failure of power grid with multiple direct current receiving ends

By setting weakness and key branch indicators in the receiving power grid, and optimizing the grid frame with the MMC-HVDC system, the risk of phase commutation failure of multi-DC system is solved, the identification and enhancement of weak buses is achieved, and the failure of phase commutation is reduced. The risk ensures the safe and stable operation of the power grid.

CN119070271APending Publication Date: 2024-12-03STATE GRID JIANGSU ECONOMIC RES INST +2
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202410984333.6
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Applications(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2024-07-22
Publication Date
2024-12-03

Smart Images

  • Figure CN119070271A_ABST
    Figure CN119070271A_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The invention relates to a grid optimization method for preventing commutation failure of a multi-direct-current receiving-end power grid, and the method comprises the steps: firstly, setting a weakness evaluation index of a bus, and recognizing a weak bus according to the weakness evaluation index; then, a weak bus needing to be reinforced is selected, and a PCC close to the weak bus is selected; setting an identification index of a key branch which affects the electrical distance between the weak bus and the PCC; selecting one branch as the key branch according to the identification index of the key branch; the MMC-HVDC system is adopted to replace the key branch circuit; finally, recalculating the weakness evaluation index of the weak bus, and if the weakness evaluation index meets the requirement, ending optimization; and if the weakness evaluation index does not meet the requirement, returning to the step 3 to add the key branch until the weakness evaluation index of the weak bus meets the requirement, and the method can provide reference for planning operation of the multi-infeed receiving end power grid and guarantee safe and stable operation of the system.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The invention relates to a grid optimization method for preventing phase commutation failure of a multi-DC receiving-end power grid, and belongs to the technical field of power systems. Background Art

[0002] There are many multi-feed receiving-end power grids in my country, and most of the inverters are composed of line commutated converters. At present, there are relatively few inverters composed of modular multilevel converters (MMC). When the AC voltage suddenly drops, the inverter composed of line commutated converters (LCC) will fail to commutate. The simultaneous commutation failure of multiple DC systems will cause large-scale power shortages, seriously threatening the safe and stable operation of the receiving-end power grid. With the continuous increase in the number and capacity of high-voltage direct current (HVDC) transmission systems, it is becoming increasingly important to study the evaluation methods of the receiving-end power grid and the preventive measures for commutation failure.

[0003] There are many methods for evaluating the strength of the receiving-end power grid and the risk of commutation failure, such as the short-circuit ratio of multiple infeeds, voltage interaction factors, etc. However, most of the existing evaluation methods are based on the interaction between AC and DC systems, and how to accurately identify the weak links of the receiving-end power grid in the planning stage needs further research.

[0004] In recent years, scholars have proposed various measures to deal with commutation failure, including preventive measures in the planning stage and emergency control measures in the operation stage. Although there are many measures to deal with commutation failure in multi-DC systems, most of them focus on emergency control and reactive power flow optimization. How to reduce the risk of simultaneous commutation failure through grid optimization needs further study. Summary of the invention

[0005] In order to solve the problems existing in the prior art, the present invention provides a grid optimization method for strengthening a weak busbar and preventing multiple DC commutation failures.

[0006] In order to achieve the above object, the technical solution proposed by the present invention is: a grid optimization method for preventing phase commutation failure of a multi-DC receiving-end power grid, comprising the following steps:

[0007] Step 1: setting a weakness evaluation index of the busbar, and identifying a weak busbar prone to commutation failure according to the weakness evaluation index;

[0008] Step 2: Select the weak busbar that needs to be strengthened and select the PCC close to the weak busbar; set the identification index of the key branch that affects the electrical distance between the weak busbar and the PCC;

[0009] Step 3: Select a branch as a key branch according to the identification index of the key branch;

[0010] Step 4: Use the MMC-HVDC system to replace the key branch;

[0011] Step 5: Recalculate the weakness evaluation index of the weak busbar. If it meets the requirements, the optimization ends; if it does not meet the requirements, return to step 3 to add key branches until the weakness evaluation index of the weak busbar meets the requirements.

[0012] The weakness evaluation index of the busbar in step 1 is:

[0013]

[0014] Among them, D i is the evaluation index of busbar i, Z ik,equ is the equivalent impedance between bus i and the PCC point of the kth inverter.

[0015] The equivalent impedance Z ik,equ is the electrical distance between busbar i and the PCC point of the kth inverter.

[0016] The equivalent impedance Z ik,equ It is equal to the voltage difference U between bus i and the PCC point of the kth inverter after the unit current is injected from bus i. ik .

[0017] The key branch identification index in step 2 is:

[0018]

[0019] Among them, where: ik,l is the key branch identification index, x l is the reactance of branch l.

[0020] In step 3, the branch with the largest key branch identification index is selected as the key branch.

[0021] If the requirement is not met in step 3, return to step 3 and increase the key branches in descending order according to the key branch identification index.

[0022] The beneficial effects of the present invention are:

[0023] The present invention first proposes a weakness evaluation index and a key branch identification index for a multi-input DC receiving-end power grid. The proposed weakness evaluation index can effectively find out the weak busbar, and the key branch identification index can accurately identify the branch with the greatest impact on the electrical distance between the two buses. Then, based on the above-mentioned weak busbar and key branch, a comprehensive grid reinforcement method is proposed, and the MMC-HVDC system is used to strengthen the weak busbar to prevent multi-DC commutation failure, thereby optimizing the grid, which can provide a reference for the planning and operation of the multi-input receiving-end power grid and ensure the safe and stable operation of the system. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0024] Figure 1 The figure is a flow chart of the optimization method of the present invention.

[0025] Figure 2 This is the modified New England 39-node system structure diagram.

[0026] Figure 3 It is the relationship between the evaluation index D and the number of DC commutation failures K.

[0027] Figure 4 This is the weak busbar in the modified New England 39-node system.

[0028] Figure 5 It is the weak busbar after adding the MMC-HVDC system. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0029] The present invention is described in detail below with reference to the accompanying drawings and specific embodiments.

[0030] Example

[0031] The grid optimization method for preventing commutation failure of multiple DC receiving-end power grids in this embodiment has a process as follows: Figure 1 As shown:

[0032] Step 1: Set a weakness evaluation index for the busbar, and identify a weak busbar that is prone to multiple commutation failures based on the weakness evaluation index.

[0033] This embodiment proposes a weak link evaluation index based on electrical distance:

[0034] First, the concept of electrical distance is set. The electrical distance between busbar (node) i and busbar (node) j can be defined as the equivalent impedance Z ij,equ , where the equivalent impedance Z ij,equ Equal to the voltage difference U between busbars i and j after unit current is injected from busbar i ij . Equivalent impedance Z ij,equ The expression is shown in formula (1).

[0035]

[0036] In the formula, I i is the unit current and its value is 1.

[0037] According to the superposition principle, the equivalent impedance Z ij,equ It can be represented by the elements of the impedance matrix, as shown in (2).

[0038] Z i x ,equ =(Z ii -Z ij )-(Z ij -Z jj ) (2)

[0039] Among them, Z ij is the element in the i-th row and j-th column of the impedance matrix.

[0040] Assuming that there are m LCC inverters in the multi-infeed receiving-end power grid, the evaluation index of the weak bus is defined as (3).

[0041]

[0042] Among them, Di is the evaluation index of busbar i, Z ik,equ is the equivalent impedance between bus i and the PCC point of the kth inverter.

[0043] If the electrical distance between busbar (node) i and LCC inverter PCC point is closer, D i The smaller the value of , the more likely the short-circuit fault near busbar (node) i will cause the commutation failure of the multi-circuit DC system, and the more likely the busbar (node) i will be affected. According to the simulation results under various working conditions, D i The busbar below the threshold is judged as a weak busbar.

[0044] Step 2: Select the weak busbar that needs to be strengthened and select the PCC close to the weak busbar; set the identification index of the key branch that affects the electrical distance between the weak busbar and the PCC;

[0045] After identifying the weak busbars using the evaluation index D, certain measures need to be taken to reinforce these weak busbars. From the perspective of network planning, increasing the electrical distance between the weak busbar and the PCC point of the LCC inverter can effectively strengthen the weak busbar, thereby eliminating the risk of commutation failure. In order to increase the electrical distance, the MMC-HVDC system is used to replace the AC branch. In this embodiment, the AC branch that needs to be replaced is called a critical branch.

[0046] In the transmission network, the electrical distance between two nodes is mainly affected by the reactance of each branch, while the resistance and capacitance have little effect on the electrical distance. Therefore, only the influence of reactance is considered when identifying key branches. The electrical distance Z between busbar (node) i and PCC k ik,equ The sensitivity to the reactance of branch l is shown in equation (4). Define the sensitivity factor λ ik,l Identify indicators for critical branches.

[0047]

[0048] Where: ik,l is the sensitivity factor, x l is the reactance of branch l, Z ik,equ is the equivalent impedance between bus i and the PCC point of the kth inverter, which is equal to the voltage difference U between bus i and the PCC point of the kth inverter after the unit current is injected from bus i ik .

[0049] In order to obtain λ ik,l , we need the impedance matrix Z for x l Sensitivity. dZ / dx l The expression of is shown in formula (5).

[0050]

[0051] Among them, Z is the impedance matrix of the system, Y is the admittance matrix of the system, and Λ is the sensitivity matrix.

[0052] When the branch resistance and capacitance are ignored, the sensitivity matrix Λ can be simplified as formula (6).

[0053]

[0054] Among them, Z' is the imaginary part of the impedance matrix, and Y' is the imaginary part of the admittance matrix.

[0055] Assume that the two end nodes of branch l are q1 and q2 respectively, then dY′ / dx l The expression of is shown in formula (7).

[0056]

[0057] In dY′ / dx l In , only 4 elements are non-zero, which are given in (7), and the rest are zero. Combining (2) and (4), we can get (8).

[0058]

[0059] Among them, dZ ik,equ / dx lis the element in the i-th row and j-th column of the sensitivity matrix Λ.

[0060] Step 3: Select a branch as a key branch according to the identification index of the key branch;

[0061] According to the identification index λ ik,l By using the value of , we can find the branch that has the greatest impact on the electrical distance between the two busbars (the weak busbar and the PCC), that is, the branch with the largest sensitivity factor, as the key branch.

[0062] Step 4: Use the MMC-HVDC system to replace the key branch;

[0063] Step 5, recalculate the weakness evaluation index of the weak busbar. If the requirements are met, that is, the short-circuit fault at the busbar (node) i no longer causes the DC k commutation failure, the optimization ends; if the requirements are not met, return to step 3 to add key branches until the weakness evaluation index of the weak busbar meets the requirements; add key branches in descending order according to the key branch identification index, that is, select the branch with the second largest key branch identification index as the newly added key branch. If the requirements are still not met, continue to select the branch with the second largest key branch identification index as the newly added key branch, and so on.

[0064] Test Examples

[0065] This section will verify the above indicators and methods through simulation analysis. Simulation is performed on PSS / E. First, the New England 39-node system is modified to a multi-feed receiving-end power grid, which will be described below. The generators connected to bus 32, bus 35 and bus 38 are replaced with three LCC-HVDC systems, and the outputs of the three LCC-HVDC systems are the same as the three generators. The sending ends of the three LCC-HVDC systems are all three independent stand-alone systems, and the receiving ends are connected to bus 32, bus 35 and bus 38 respectively. The structural diagram of the modified New England 39 bus is shown in the figure. Figure 2 shown.

[0066] Then, the weakness evaluation indexes of all buses are calculated, and short-circuit fault scanning is performed to verify the weakness evaluation indexes. The short-circuit fault is set as a three-phase grounding short-circuit fault. When the fault occurs, the bus voltage drops to 0.5pu instantly. After calculation, the weakness evaluation indexes of 39 buses and the number of commutation failures K caused by these 39 short-circuit faults can be obtained. The relationship between the index and the quantity is as follows: Figure 3 As shown. Figure 3 It can be seen that the smaller the weakness evaluation index is, the more commutation failures caused by short-circuit faults are. Therefore, this weakness evaluation index can correctly identify weak busbars.

[0067] The buses that will cause commutation failure in three HVDC systems due to short-circuit faults are shown in Table 1. They are the weak buses in the modified New England 39-bus system. The D values ​​of these buses are all less than 0.18.

[0068] Table 1 Weak busbar statistics

[0069]

[0070] The weak busbar range is shown in blue. Figure 4 Among the weak busbars, the busbars closest to LCC1 are busbars 4 and 13, the busbars closest to LCC2 are busbars 21 and 24, and the busbars closest to LCC3 are busbars 3 and 27. The three key branches 26-27, 21-22, and 10-13 were identified through the key branch identification index.

[0071] Taking the search process of the key branch 26-27 as an example, the sensitivity factor of the electrical distance between bus 3 and bus 38 to all branches is calculated, and Table 2 lists the three branches with the largest sensitivity factors. Similarly, the three sensitivity factors of the largest electrical distances of all branches between bus 27 and bus 38 are shown in Table 3. Combining the results of Tables 2 and 3, branch 26-27 is selected as the key branch.

[0072] Table 2 The three largest key branch identification indicators between bus 3 and bus 38

[0073]

[0074] Table 3 The three largest key branch identification indicators between bus 27 and bus 38

[0075]

[0076] Finally, the key branch is replaced with the MMC-HVDC system. After the replacement, the system power flow remains unchanged. Short-circuit fault scanning is performed again. Weak nodes such as Figure 5 The blue part shows the Figure 4 and Figure 5 It can be seen that the area of ​​the weak busbar is reduced, which effectively improves the reliability of the 39-bus system after the transformation.

[0077] The technical solutions of the present invention are not limited to the above-mentioned embodiments, and any technical solutions obtained by equivalent replacement methods fall within the scope of protection required by the present invention.

Claims

1. A grid optimization method for preventing commutation failure of a multi-DC receiving-end power grid, characterized in that: The steps include: Step 1: Set the weakness evaluation index of the busbar, and identify the weak busbar according to the weakness evaluation index; Step 2: Select the weak busbar that needs to be strengthened and select the PCC close to the weak busbar; set the identification index of the key branch that affects the electrical distance between the weak busbar and the PCC; Step 3: Select a branch as a key branch according to the identification index of the key branch; Step 4: Use the MMC-HVDC system to replace the key branch; Step 5: Recalculate the weakness evaluation index of the weak busbar. If it meets the requirements, the optimization ends; if it does not meet the requirements, return to step 3 to add key branches until the weakness evaluation index of the weak busbar meets the requirements.

2. The grid optimization method for preventing commutation failure of a multi-DC receiving-end power grid according to claim 1, characterized in that: The weakness evaluation index of the busbar in step 1 is: Among them, D i is the evaluation index of busbar i, Z ik,equ is the equivalent impedance between bus i and the PCC point of the kth inverter.

3. The grid optimization method for preventing commutation failure of a multi-DC receiving-end power grid according to claim 2 is characterized in that: The equivalent impedance Z ik,equ is the electrical distance between busbar i and the PCC point of the kth inverter.

4. The grid optimization method for preventing commutation failure of a multi-DC receiving-end power grid according to claim 3 is characterized in that: The equivalent impedance Z ik,equ It is equal to the voltage difference U between bus i and the PCC point of the kth inverter after the unit current is injected from bus i. ik .

5. The grid optimization method for preventing commutation failure of a multi-DC receiving-end power grid according to claim 4 is characterized in that: The key branch identification index in step 2 is: Among them, where: ik,l is the key branch identification index, x l is the reactance of branch l.

6. The grid optimization method for preventing commutation failure of a multi-DC receiving-end power grid according to claim 5 is characterized in that: In step 3, the branch with the largest key branch identification index is selected as the key branch.

7. The grid optimization method for preventing commutation failure of a multi-DC receiving-end power grid according to claim 6 is characterized in that: If the requirement is not met in step 3, return to step 3 and increase the key branches in descending order according to the key branch identification index.