System and method for testing high-precision uranium-lead ratio of apatite
By combining LA-ICP-MS technology and Isoplot analysis, the problem of poor accuracy of apatite samples in U-Pb dating was solved, and high-precision U-Pb ratio testing was achieved, which was suitable for dating of terrestrial fossil samples. , especially in the absence of obvious sedimentary sequences in the late Cenozoic strata, provide more accurate geological chronological information.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202410791421.4
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-06-19
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-29
- Estimated Expiration
- 2044-06-19
AI Technical Summary
In the prior art, when using U-Pb dating, it is difficult to achieve high accuracy and accuracy of apatite samples, especially in terrestrial fossil samples, which leads to poor dating accuracy and cannot effectively solve the high level of the new generation of fossil samples. Accuracy test analysis requirements.
The test system was used to combine Resolution LR-S155193nm ArF excimer laser erosion system and Thermo Scientific iCap TQ inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (LA-ICP-MS). The test system was cut, cleaned, dried, and target-making. It was carried out by Isoplot. Dimensional and three-dimensional linear regression analysis, optimize airflow and ICP parameters, reduce interference, and improve data accuracy.
Achieve high-precision U-Pb ratio test for apatite samples, significantly improving the accuracy and reliability of dating, and can obtain high-precision U/Pb age in different types of fossil materials, reducing dating errors, and is applicable In the absence of obvious sedimentary stratigraphic sequences in stratigraphic research.
Smart Images

Figure CN119044298A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The invention relates to the technical field of uranium-lead dating, and in particular to a high-precision apatite uranium-lead ratio testing system and method. Background Art
[0002] U-Pb dating based on tooth fossil enamel has higher accuracy and stronger anti-interference ability, and has broad application prospects in the field of stratigraphy. This relatively independent absolute dating method is helpful for stratigraphic research, especially in the absence of obvious sedimentary sequences in the late Cenozoic strata. It can establish a chronology based on fossil materials, or be applied to the determination of the age of meteorite impacts, geological landslides or collapse events (provided that there are biological fossils buried during the event, that is, the lithology of sedimentary strata and buried strata changes). The feasibility of U-Pb dating of fossils has been confirmed, but it is still in its infancy. The current small amount of results is mainly concentrated on marine fossil types, and research on terrestrial fossils is still blank.
[0003] Uranium-lead (U-Pb) dating is based on the accumulation of radioactive Pb and has no age time range restrictions. It has been used for decades to date the minerals of igneous and metamorphic rocks. For samples that are several million years old, the calculation of the Tera-Wasserburg age first assumes that there is no imbalance effect in the U decay chain ([234U / 238U]i=[231Pa / 235U]i=[230Th / 238U]i=1), and then the estimated imbalance value is corrected. U-Pb dating has also been gradually applied to the dating of carbonates and apatites in the past decade. It is theoretically feasible to apply it to bones and enamel, which are mainly composed of carbonates and apatites, and people have been trying it, but it has not been popularized because the method has poor accuracy (the mean standard weight deviation MSWD is usually greater than several dozen). The reason for the poor accuracy is that enamel, dentin and bone have significant chemical and structural differences and have different resistance to diagenetic changes.
[0004] In view of this, high-precision, high-accuracy and low-signal U-Pb ratio test and analysis of Cenozoic fossil samples has become one of the technical problems that need to be urgently solved in the field of geochemical analysis technology.
[0005] To this end, the present invention aims to provide a high-precision apatite uranium-lead ratio testing system and method to solve the above-mentioned problems. Summary of the invention
[0006] The purpose of the present invention is to solve the above problems and to provide a high-precision apatite uranium-lead ratio testing system and method.
[0007] In order to achieve the above object, the technical solution of the present invention is as follows:
[0008] The invention provides an apatite high-precision uranium-lead ratio testing system, the testing system comprising a Resolution LR-S155 193nm ArF excimer laser ablation system (LA) and a Thermo Scientific iCap TQ inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometer (ICP-MS); the testing system complies with a standard method commonly used in laboratories.
[0009] The present invention also provides a method for testing an apatite high-precision uranium-lead ratio testing system, comprising the following steps:
[0010] S1. Pretreatment: cutting, cleaning, drying and target preparation (or slice preparation) of the apatite sample;
[0011] S2, instrument analysis: including instrument debugging, pre-stripping samples and data processing;
[0012] S3. Data processing: The U-Pb age calculation results of the apatite sample are obtained according to the data results obtained in the instrumental analysis in step S2 and the corresponding age calculation method. In order to evaluate the impact of initial value differences and diagenesis on the U-Pb age of fossils, Isoplot (Pieter V., 2018; Ludwig, KR, 1998) was used to compare and analyze the U-Pb age data using two-dimensional and three-dimensional linear regression to evaluate the impact of subsequent diagenetic modification and initial value heterogeneity on the accuracy of U-Pb age.
[0013] The reported result is: MSWD = u,p(χ 2 )=v.
[0014] Where: u: Mean square weighted deviation (MSWD) of the equidistant fitting.
[0015] v: Chi-square p-value for the equidistant fit.
[0016] Age = x ± y(|z).
[0017] Where: x: Maximum likelihood estimate of age or initial Pb ratio using the algorithm of Ludwig (1998). y: Analytical uncertainty of x (2σ). z: Analytical uncertainty of x with overdispersion. Calculated as: z = y√MSWD (reported only when p < α from chi-square test).
[0018] Furthermore, the cutting in step S1 is to cut the apatite sample into suitable sizes.
[0019] Furthermore, the cleaning in step S1 is performed by cleaning the apatite sample with MilliQ water in an ultrasonicator to remove impurities on its surface.
[0020] Furthermore, the drying in step S1 is to dry the cleaned apatite sample on a hot plate or in an oven at 45° C.-60° C. overnight.
[0021] Furthermore, the target preparation is to fix the apatite sample with epoxy resin and polish it to expose a flat surface of the apatite sample for testing.
[0022] Furthermore, the instrumental analysis is specifically as follows:
[0023] The laser time was set to: 5 seconds surface cleaning, 7 seconds rinse, 10 seconds background, 20 seconds ablation, 5 seconds rinse, repetition rate of 8 Hz, and flux of 3 J / cm 2 , the spot of apatite sample is 30um;
[0024] Gas flow settings: Helium was used as the carrier gas, and the flow rate was set to 280 mL / min. The nebulizer gas of iCap TQ was argon, and the flow rate was adjusted according to the oxide yield and sensitivity. A small amount of nitrogen was introduced into the mass spectrometer and introduced into the receiving cup at a flow rate of 5 mL / min to mix with the He carrier gas.
[0025] The instrument parameters were optimized. The iCap TQ was mainly used to adjust the mass spectrometry parameters such as gas flow according to NIST 612 to optimize the sensitivity and acceptable oxidation rate (232Th / 16O 232Th, less than 0.2% in this experiment).
[0026] The ICP parameters were optimized; the ICP conditions were: cooling gas, 14 L / min; RF power, 1550 W; auxiliary gas, 0.8 L / min; 204 Hg 204 Pb has a large interference, so we did not measure the masses 202 (Hg) and 204 (Pb + Hg), and only collected the masses 206 Pb, 207 Pb, 208 Pb, 232 Th, 238 Data of U.
[0027] Standard instrument tests were performed; the sensitivity of U was greater than 500k cps, equivalent to greater than 13kcps / ppm, and the Th / U ratio of NIST612 was between 0.9-1.0.
[0028] The difficulty and significance of the technical problem solved by the present invention are:
[0029] From the perspective of the development of U-Pb dating technology for biogenic apatite: Uranium-lead (U-Pb) dating is based on the accumulation of stable radiogenic lead, without age range restrictions, and has been widely used in dating igneous rocks and metamorphic accessory minerals for decades. This technology has also been gradually applied to the dating of carbonates and apatites in the past decade. It is theoretically feasible to apply it to bones and enamel, which are mainly composed of biogenic apatite, and people are constantly trying. However, it has not been popularized because of its poor accuracy (the mean standard weight deviation MSWD is usually greater than dozens). The reasons are: enamel, dentin and bone have significant chemical and structural differences and have different resistance to diagenetic changes; the high proportion of common lead leads to low μ values; low μ value samples require high test accuracy; the initial values are multi-source and there are differences, etc. From the perspective of stratigraphic research needs: in the absence of obvious sedimentary sequences in the late Cenozoic strata, ordinary dating methods are difficult to accurately date. The absolute dating of sedimentary rocks and fossils in the late Miocene is still a rare problem. Based on the uncertainty of U-Pb dating produced by previous studies, the inventors of the present application selected sample characteristics and data processing methods to jointly solve the above-mentioned problems. The solution of the present invention is of great significance in geological stratigraphy: U-Pb dating based on tooth fossil enamel has broad application prospects in the field of stratigraphy, especially in the absence of obvious sedimentary sequences in the late Cenozoic strata, a chronology based on fossil materials can be established.
[0030] Compared with the prior art, this solution has the following beneficial effects:
[0031] 1. Through the application of the test system of the present invention, the requirements for low-content, high-precision apatite sample analysis and testing can be met, especially the LA-ICP-MS method can help obtain high-precision U / Pb ages with spatial resolution in different types of fossil materials;
[0032] 2. Since paleomagnetic age is determined based on the magnetic pole cycle, the essence of paleomagnetic absolute age is a time interval (or interpolar interval), while the attribute of U-Pb absolute age is a time point, which is theoretically more accurate and greatly reduces the error of the age obtained by the test. Therefore, in the test method of the present invention, U-Pb fossil dating can not only be carried out in an independent absolute dating system, but also can be combined with traditional methods and conclusions. The absolute dating of fossils is helpful for stratigraphic research and the determination of the geological age of sedimentary sequences;
[0033] 3. Through the application of the test system of the present invention, it is possible to meet the requirement that the dating method has no limitation on the age time range, and solve the problems of lack of suitable absolute dating technology for early Cenozoic strata and the rarity of absolute dating of late Miocene sedimentary rocks and fossils. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0034] Figure 1 The horse, deer and elephant fossil samples sampled in the present invention;
[0035] Figure 2 It is the experimental result of the horse fossil sample in the present invention;
[0036] Figure 3 It is the selection point of the horse fossil sample in the present invention;
[0037] Figure 4 This is the preliminary result of the horse fossil sample in this invention;
[0038] Figure 5 This is the result of sampling giraffe fossils of different species in the same layer of Fugu, which anchors the initial value in the present invention;
[0039] Figure 6 It is the result of one of the processing methods of the deer fossils in the present invention;
[0040] Figure 7 This is the result of another method of processing deer fossils in the present invention;
[0041] Figure 8 It is the result of one of the processing methods of the rhinoceros fossils in the present invention;
[0042] Fig. 9 It is the result of another processing method for rhinoceros fossils in the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0043] In order to enable those skilled in the art to better understand the solution of the present invention, the technical solution of the present invention will be further described in detail below in conjunction with the embodiments of the present invention and the accompanying drawings. Obviously, the described embodiments are only part of the embodiments of the present invention, not all of the embodiments. Based on the embodiments of the present invention, all other embodiments obtained by ordinary technicians in this field without creative work should fall within the scope of protection of the present invention.
[0044] It should be noted that, in the absence of conflict, the embodiments and features in the embodiments of the present invention can be combined with each other. The present invention will be described in detail below in conjunction with the embodiments.
[0045] The solution provided by the present invention is: a high-precision uranium-lead ratio test system and method for apatite, the test system includes a Resolution LR-S155 193nm ArF excimer laser ablation system (LA) and a Thermo Scientific iCapTQ inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometer (ICP-MS); the test system follows the standard method commonly used in laboratories. The test method includes three steps: pre-processing, instrument analysis and data processing.
[0046] in:
[0047] Pre-processing mainly includes cutting, cleaning, drying, and target making (or film making).
[0048] Cutting is mainly to cut the apatite samples required for the experiment into suitable sizes for machine testing.
[0049] Cleaning was mainly performed by washing the samples with MilliQ water in an ultrasonicator to remove surface impurities.
[0050] Drying mainly involves drying the cleaned samples on a hot plate or in an oven at 45°C-60°C overnight.
[0051] The target making mainly involves fixing the sample with epoxy resin and polishing it to expose a flat surface of the sample for testing.
[0052] The instrument analysis steps mainly include instrument debugging, pre-stripping samples and data receiving.
[0053] The laser time settings in the experiment were: 5 seconds surface cleaning, 7 seconds rinse, 10 seconds background, 20 seconds ablation, 5 seconds rinse, repetition rate of 8 Hz, and flux of 3 J / cm 2 , the sample spot is 30um.
[0054] First, the gas flow is set. Helium (He) is used as the carrier gas, and the flow rate is set to 280 mL / min. The nebulizer gas of iCapTQ is argon (Ar), and the flow rate is adjusted according to the oxide yield and sensitivity. In order to improve the sensitivity of the instrument, a small amount of nitrogen (N2) is introduced into the mass spectrometer and introduced into the receiving cup at a flow rate of 5 mL / min to mix with the He carrier gas.
[0055] Secondly, the instrument state parameters were optimized. Mainly, the iCap TQ was adjusted according to NIST 612 to adjust the mass spectrometry parameters such as gas flow to optimize sensitivity and acceptable oxidation rate (232Th / 16O 232Th, less than 0.2% in this experiment).
[0056] Next, the ICP parameters were optimized. The main ICP conditions were: cooling gas, 14 L / min; RF power, 1550 W; auxiliary gas, 0.8 L / min. 204 Hg 204 Pb has a large interference, so we did not measure the masses 202 (Hg) and 204 (Pb + Hg), and only collected the masses 206 Pb, 207 Pb, 208 Pb, 232 Th, 238 Data of U.
[0057] Finally, standard instrument tests are performed, mainly with a U sensitivity greater than 500 kcps, equivalent to greater than 13 kcps / ppm, and a NIST612 Th / U ratio between 0.9 and 1.0.
[0058] The data analysis step mainly calculates the U-Pb isotope ratio based on the raw data obtained from the instrumental analysis step to obtain the U-Pb age results of the samples. In order to evaluate the impact of initial value differences and diagenesis on the U-Pb age of fossils, Isoplot (Pieter V., 2018; Ludwig, KR, 1998) was used to compare and analyze the U-Pb age data using two-dimensional and three-dimensional linear regression to evaluate the impact of subsequent diagenetic modification and initial value heterogeneity on the accuracy of U-Pb age.
[0059] The reported result is: MSWD = u,p(χ 2 )=v.
[0060] Where: u: Mean square weighted deviation (MSWD) of the equidistant fitting.
[0061] v: Chi-square p-value for the equidistant fit.
[0062] Age = x ± y(|z).
[0063] Where: x: Maximum likelihood estimate of age or initial Pb ratio using the algorithm of Ludwig (1998). y: Analytical uncertainty of x (2σ). z: Analytical uncertainty of x with overdispersion. Calculated as: z = y√MSWD (reported only when p < α from chi-square test).
[0064] Example 1
[0065] The Wang Dafuliang section 2 (e.g., Figure 3 Six three-toed horse tooth fossils collected from Figure 1 As shown), in order to obtain higher accuracy and reproducibility. Figure 2(shown in Figure 2), the U-Pb ages obtained from the six teeth of Hipparion vary from 6.87±0.13Ma to 7.71±0.39Ma(2s), with an average of 7.26Ma, which is consistent with the results of paleomagnetic and stratigraphic cycles. In addition, the U-Pb age of a Hipparion tooth fossil was determined, and the youngest U-Pb age of the stratigraphic layer can reach 900,000 years, which is also consistent with the paleomagnetic results. The U-Pb age results of the horse fossils from the above two different ages provide new evidence for the age determination of the chiai-Dinocrocuta gigantean-Hezhengia-Shaanxispira standard fossil belt (indicator fossil assemblage) of the late Miocene Hipparion in northern China. The age of this belt may be 7.26Ma, instead of the previously estimated 10-9Ma. It also provides a connection between global environmental disturbances, carbon cycle destruction, mass extinctions, and recovery on the sub-millennial time scale.
[0066] Example 2
[0067] The laboratory used the Resolution LR-S155193nm ArF excimer laser ablation system (LA) and the ThermoScientific iCap TQ inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) to obtain the initial values of 207Pb / 206Pb based on the calcium nodules, and determined the geological age of the Nema fossils at a certain point. This method has made contributions in sample selection, data processing and initial values. In general, the common lead in apatite is very high, while the proportion of radiogenic apatite in special samples is about 75%. The initial value is determined by the results of calcium nodules in the same layer, and the data processing adopts the method of anchoring the initial value. For samples with high common lead, the more points the better, at least 50 points, and for samples with high common lead and no 232Th, at least 70 points. The samples taken in this embodiment have high U content, low proportion of common lead, and do not contain 232Th. The initial value of 232Th entering the sample system is zero, which greatly reduces the uncertainty of sample errors. Preliminary results show (such as Figure 4 As shown in the figure, for samples with a low proportion of ordinary lead (30%), the MSWD value of the result can be controlled at around 2.
[0068] Example 3
[0069] The laboratory used the Resolution LR-S155 193nm ArF excimer laser ablation system (LA) and the ThermoScientific iCap TQ inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) to determine the geological age of other species (cattle, giraffes, deer, and rhinos) at the same stratum. The results of different treatment methods for deer are not the same. For samples with high common lead content, there may be a range of variation. For samples with a low proportion of common lead (such as the horse fossils in the above example), this is not the case. However, due to the influence of the proportion of common lead, the results of different species will have discrepancies in age, but they are credible within a certain range. In addition, sample modification will also affect the dating, which is related to the degree of sample modification. The greater the sample modification, the greater the difference in age between the two treatment methods, and the results of deer (such as Figure 6 and Figure 7 As shown) relative to Rhino (as Figure 8 and Fig. 9 The modification of rhinoceros is slightly weaker, but there are still changes, so for samples with large modification, it is more reliable to choose the one with large MSWD. For samples of different species at the same point that have not been modified, it is more reliable to choose the one with low MSWD first, followed by the one with low MSWD. In addition, although the age of different species in the same stratum varies greatly, the samples of giraffe, rhinoceros and horse fossils (such as Figure 1 The results of the two-dimensional and three-dimensional linear regressions are consistent with the corresponding geological ages, proving that the difference between the two-dimensional and three-dimensional linear regression results of this method can be used as an evaluation index for whether the initial Pb isotope composition and diagenesis affect the U-Pb age of fossils. When the age results are consistent with 2D and 3D within the error range, we usually choose the age with smaller MSWD. When there is a limited difference in the age results within the error range, if it is due to different initial values, the MSWD difference between 2D and 3D is usually large, then the age with smaller MSWD in 2D and 3D is selected as the final possible age of the fossil. When there is a large difference between the ages of 2D and 3D, if it is due to late diagenesis, there is a large MSWD difference between 2D and 3D, then when the initial Pb values of 2D and 3D are set to the measured carbonate nodule Pb isotope ratios in the same layer as the fossil, we select the age with lower MSWD as the possible age of the fossil. At the same time, this method can also be used to determine whether there is diagenetic modification and whether the original sample is homogeneous.
[0070] Comparative Example 1
[0071] The laboratory used the Resolution LR-S155 193nm ArF excimer laser ablation system (LA) and the ThermoScientific iCap TQ inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) to test 6 Hipparion tooth fossils, and compared the traditional sedimentary stratigraphy and paleomagnetic methods. The data of the scheme of the present invention is closer to the existing paleomagnetic absolute age of 7.8Ma. At the same time, the difference between the U-Pb age and the paleomagnetic age is also worthy of attention. The paleomagnetic age is determined based on the magnetic pole cycle, so the essence of the paleomagnetic absolute age is a time interval (or the two poles of the interval). The attribute of the U-Pb absolute age is the time point, which is more accurate in theory.
[0072] Finally, it should be noted that the terms "comprises", "includes" or any other variations thereof in the present invention are intended to cover non-exclusive inclusion, so that a process, method, article or apparatus that includes a series of elements includes not only those elements, but also other elements that are not explicitly listed, or also includes elements that are inherent to such process, method, article or apparatus.
[0073] The above specific embodiments are merely explanations of the present invention and are not limitations of the present invention. After reading this specification, those skilled in the art may make modifications to the embodiments without any creative contribution as needed. However, such modifications are protected by the patent law as long as they are within the scope of the claims of the present invention.
Claims
1. A high-precision apatite uranium-lead ratio test system, characterized by: The test system includes a ResolutionLR-S155 193nm ArF excimer laser ablation system and a Thermo Scientific iCap TQ inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometer; the test system follows a standard method commonly used in laboratories.
2. The method for testing a high-precision uranium-lead ratio test system of apatite according to claim 1, characterized in that: The following steps are involved: S1. Pre-treatment: cutting, cleaning, drying and target preparation of apatite samples; S2, instrument analysis: including instrument debugging, pre-stripping samples and data processing; S3. Data processing: The U-Pb age calculation results of the apatite samples were obtained according to the data results obtained in the instrumental analysis in step S2 and the corresponding age calculation method. The U-Pb age data were compared and analyzed using two-dimensional and three-dimensional linear regression using IsoplotR and Isoplot to evaluate the impact of subsequent diagenetic modification and initial value heterogeneity on the accuracy of U-Pb age.
3. The method for testing a high-precision uranium-lead ratio test system of apatite according to claim 1, characterized in that: The cutting in step S1 is to cut the apatite sample into suitable sizes.
4. The method for testing a high-precision uranium-lead ratio test system of apatite according to claim 1, characterized in that: The cleaning in step S1 is to clean the apatite sample with MilliQ water in an ultrasonicator to remove impurities on its surface.
5. The method for testing a high-precision uranium-lead ratio test system of apatite according to claim 1, characterized in that: The drying in step S1 is to dry the cleaned apatite sample on a hot plate or in an oven at 45° C.-60° C. overnight.
6. The method for testing a high-precision uranium-lead ratio test system of apatite as claimed in claim 1, characterized in that: The target making method is to fix the apatite sample with epoxy resin and polish it to expose a flat surface of the apatite sample for testing.
7. The method for testing a high-precision uranium-lead ratio test system of apatite as claimed in claim 1, characterized in that: The instrumental analysis is specifically as follows: The laser time was set to: 5 seconds surface cleaning, 7 seconds rinse, 10 seconds background, 20 seconds ablation, 5 seconds rinse, repetition rate of 8 Hz, and flux of 3 J / cm 2 , the spot of apatite sample is 30um; Gas flow settings: Helium was used as the carrier gas, and the flow rate was set to 280 mL / min. The nebulizer gas of iCap TQ was argon, and the flow rate was adjusted according to the oxide yield and sensitivity. A small amount of nitrogen was introduced into the mass spectrometer and introduced into the receiving cup at a flow rate of 5 mL / min to mix with the He carrier gas. Optimize instrument status parameters; The ICP parameters were optimized; the ICP conditions were: cooling gas, 14 L / min; RF power, 1550 W; auxiliary gas, 0.8 L / min; Standard instrument tests were performed; the sensitivity of U was greater than 500k cps, equivalent to greater than 13kcps / ppm, and the Th / U ratio of NIST 612 was between 0.9-1.0.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Double dating method for single-particle monazite
CN105572217A
Method for determining U-Pb age of zircon sample
CN106908510A
Laser in-situ uranium lead isotope dating method for ancient marine carbonate rocks
CN110376273A
Fault activity time determination method and device and related equipment
CN115201451A
U-Pb dating method for common lead-containing secondary minerals based on LA-ICPMS surface scanning technology
CN116358953A
