Analysis apparatus, analysis method, and analysis program

The risk analysis device optimizes the re-evaluation of system risks by determining the appropriate phase for reanalysis based on introduced security measures, addressing the inefficiencies and costs of traditional risk analysis methods.

JP2024163229AInactive Publication Date: 2024-11-21NEC CORP
View PDF 3 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
JP2024151498
Authority / Receiving Office
JP · JP
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2024-09-03
Publication Date
2024-11-21
Estimated Expiration
Not applicable · inactive patent

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Performing risk analysis to confirm how cyber attack countermeasures affect system risks is time-consuming and costly, and it is unclear what security tests are needed to assess these changes.

Method used

A risk analysis device that includes configuration information acquisition, threat analysis, attack route generation, risk value calculation, and result output, with a reanalysis mechanism to determine the optimal phase for re-evaluating risks based on introduced security measures.

Benefits of technology

Enables low-cost risk analysis by efficiently determining the necessary phases for re-evaluation, reducing time and manpower, and allowing for effective assessment of risk changes with minimal processing.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure 2024163229000001_ABST
    Figure 2024163229000001_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

To realize risk analysis at a low cost when a measure is introduced.SOLUTION: Configuration information acquisition means (11) acquires configuration information on a system to be analyzed. Threat analysis means (12) analyzes an attack technique that can be implemented in the system to be analyzed. Attack route generation means (13) generates an attack route from a start point to an end point of an attack. Risk value calculation means (14) calculates a risk value of the generated attack route. Result output means (15) outputs a risk analysis result including the calculated risk value. Risk reanalysis means (16) performs, according to a planned security measure, risk analysis when a security measure is introduced from any of the configuration information acquisition means (11), the threat analysis means (12), the attack route generation means (13), and the risk value calculation means (14).SELECTED DRAWING: Figure 1
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[Technical field]

[0001] The present disclosure relates to a risk analysis apparatus, a risk analysis method, and a computer-readable medium. [Background technology]

[0002] In recent years, the threat of cyber attacks has not only been limited to the field of ICT (Information and Communication Technology), but there have also been cases of damage occurring in the fields of control systems and IoT (Internet of Things). In particular, there have been cases of control systems threatening the operation of critical infrastructure, such as the shutdown of power systems and factories. To counter the threat of cyber attacks, it is important to clarify the security risks that systems pose, implement measures, and reduce those risks.

[0003] As a related technique, Patent Document 1 discloses a risk assessment and countermeasure planning system that plans countermeasures against attacks on a system and security tests. A processing device of the risk assessment and countermeasure planning system described in Patent Document 1 analyzes vulnerabilities based on design information, and analyzes threats to the system based on the vulnerability analysis results. The processing device plans countermeasures to reduce the impact of vulnerabilities based on the threat analysis results and vulnerability information stored in a vulnerability database. The processing device plans security tests based on the countermeasure plans, and performs evaluation based on the security tests.

[0004] In the evaluation based on the security test, the processing device generates an attack path from the starting point of the attack to the components based on multiple components of the system, the connection relationships between the multiple components, and vulnerability information related to the components.The processing device generates an asset value held by each component and an occurrence probability of causing a threat event based on the order of attack techniques present in the attack path, vulnerabilities related to the attack techniques, and the security test.The processing device plans additional measures to reduce the occurrence probability to an occurrence probability equal to or lower than the requirement for the asset value. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]

[0005] [Patent Document 1] JP 2020-166650 A Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]

[0006] Here, when measures against the threat of cyber attacks are proposed, risk analysis is required again to confirm how the risk changes when the measures are introduced into the system. Performing risk analysis again requires a lot of cost in terms of time and manpower. In addition, in the risk analysis performed again, it is difficult to determine whether it is sufficient to simply recalculate the risk value or whether a reconsideration of the threat is required. For example, it is difficult to determine whether the attack route will disappear or the risk will only decrease. In order to determine whether the attack route has disappeared, risk analysis needs to be performed again.

[0007] Patent Document 1 describes that a security test is created based on a countermeasure plan, and an evaluation is performed based on the security test. However, it is unclear in Patent Document 1 what kind of security test is generated based on the countermeasure plan. Also, in Patent Document 1, when a countermeasure is introduced into a system, risk analysis is required again to confirm how the risk changes, which requires a lot of cost in terms of time and manpower.

[0008] In view of the above circumstances, an object of the present disclosure is to provide a risk analysis device, method, and computer-readable medium that can perform risk analysis at low cost when countermeasures are introduced. [Means for solving the problem]

[0009] In order to achieve the above object, the present disclosure provides, as a first aspect, a risk analysis device, which includes: a configuration information acquisition means for acquiring configuration information of a system to be analyzed; a threat analysis means for analyzing an attack method that may be implemented in the system based on the configuration information and vulnerability information; an attack route generation means for generating an attack route from a start point to an end point of an attack based on the configuration information and the attack method; a risk value calculation means for calculating a risk value of the attack route; a result output means for outputting a risk analysis result including the calculated risk value; and a risk reanalysis means for causing any of the configuration information acquisition means, the threat analysis means, the attack route generation means, and the risk value calculation means to perform a risk reanalysis in the case where the security countermeasure is introduced, according to a security countermeasure proposed for the system.

[0010] The present disclosure provides, as a second aspect, a risk analysis method, which performs risk analysis on a system to be analyzed, including a configuration information acquisition phase for acquiring configuration information, a threat analysis phase for analyzing an attack method that may be implemented in the system based on the configuration information and vulnerability information, an attack route generation phase for generating an attack route from a start point to an end point of an attack based on the configuration information and the attack method, and a risk value calculation phase for calculating a risk value of the attack route, outputs a risk analysis result including the calculated risk value, and performs a risk reanalysis in the case where the security countermeasure is introduced from any of the configuration information acquisition phase, the threat analysis phase, the attack route generation phase, and the risk value calculation phase according to a security countermeasure proposed for the system.

[0011] The present disclosure provides a computer-readable medium as a third aspect. The computer-readable medium stores a program for causing a computer to execute a process of performing a risk analysis for a system to be analyzed, the risk analysis including a configuration information acquisition phase for acquiring configuration information, a threat analysis phase for analyzing an attack method that may be implemented in the system based on the configuration information and vulnerability information, an attack route generation phase for generating an attack route from a start point to an end point of an attack based on the configuration information and the attack method, and a risk value calculation phase for calculating a risk value of the attack route, outputting a risk analysis result including the calculated risk value, and performing a risk reanalysis in the case where the security countermeasure is introduced from any of the configuration information acquisition phase, the threat analysis phase, the attack route generation phase, and the risk value calculation phase according to a security countermeasure proposed for the system. Effect of the Invention

[0012] The risk analysis device, method, and computer-readable medium according to the present disclosure can perform risk analysis at low cost in the case where countermeasures are introduced. [Brief description of the drawings]

[0013] [Figure 1] FIG. 1 is a block diagram showing a schematic configuration of a risk analysis device according to the present disclosure. [Diagram 2] FIG. 1 is a block diagram showing a risk analysis device according to a first embodiment of the present disclosure. [Diagram 3] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing an example of a countermeasure information table. [Figure 4] 4 is a flowchart showing an operation procedure in the risk analysis device. [Diagram 5] FIG. 11 is a block diagram showing a risk analysis device according to a second embodiment of the present disclosure. [Figure 6] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing an example of vulnerability information. [Figure 7] FIG. 1 is a block diagram showing an example of the configuration of a computer device. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS

[0014] Prior to describing the embodiments of the present disclosure, an overview of the present disclosure will be described. Fig. 1 shows a schematic configuration of a risk analysis device according to the present disclosure. The risk analysis device 10 includes a configuration information acquisition means 11, a threat analysis means 12, an attack route generation means 13, a risk value calculation means 14, a result output means 15, and a risk reanalysis means 16. The configuration information acquisition means 11 acquires configuration information of a system to be analyzed. The threat analysis means 12 analyzes attack techniques that may be implemented in the system to be analyzed based on the acquired configuration information and vulnerability information.

[0015] The attack route generation means 13 generates an attack route from the start point to the end point of the attack based on the acquired configuration information and the analyzed attack method. The risk value calculation means 14 calculates a risk value of the generated attack route. The result output means 15 outputs a risk analysis result including the calculated risk value. The risk reanalysis means 16 causes any of the configuration information acquisition means 11, the threat analysis means 12, the attack route generation means 13, and the risk value calculation means 14 to perform a risk analysis in the case where a security measure is introduced, depending on the security measure proposed for the system to be analyzed.

[0016] In the present disclosure, the risk reanalysis means 16 executes risk reanalysis from any of the configuration information acquisition means 11, the threat analysis means 12, the attack route generation means 13, and the risk value calculation means 14, depending on the security measures proposed for the system to be analyzed. In other words, the risk reanalysis means 16 determines to which stage the risk analysis should be returned to, depending on the security measures. In the present disclosure, by re-executing the risk analysis from the determined stage, risk reanalysis when security measures are introduced can be executed at low cost.

[0017] Hereinafter, an embodiment of the present disclosure will be described with reference to the drawings. Note that the following description and drawings are omitted and simplified as appropriate for clarity of explanation. In addition, in each of the following drawings, the same elements and similar elements are given the same reference numerals, and duplicate explanations are omitted as necessary.

[0018] 2 shows a risk analysis device according to the first embodiment of the present disclosure. The risk analysis device 100 includes a configuration information acquisition unit 101, a threat analysis unit 102, an attack route generation unit 103, a risk value calculation unit 104, an analysis result output unit 105, a countermeasure input unit 106, and a reanalysis unit 107. The functions of each unit in the risk analysis device 100 can be realized, for example, by a computer device executing processing according to a program. The risk analysis device 100 corresponds to the risk analysis device 10 shown in FIG. 1.

[0019] The configuration information acquisition unit 101 acquires configuration information of the system to be analyzed. The configuration information includes, for example, information on each asset constituting the system, network configuration, vulnerability, open ports, account information, and software. The threat analysis unit 102 analyzes threats anticipated in the system to be analyzed. The threat analysis unit 102 analyzes attack methods that an attacker can use in the system to be analyzed, for example. The configuration information acquisition unit 101 corresponds to the configuration information acquisition means 11 shown in FIG. 1, and the threat analysis unit 102 corresponds to the threat analysis unit 102 shown in FIG. 1.

[0020] The attack route generation unit 103 searches for an attack route in the system to be analyzed. For example, in the analysis of security risks, several attack scenarios are assumed. The attack scenario includes, for example, an entry point used in the attack, a final target of the attack, and a type of final attack. The attack route generation unit 103 refers to the configuration information of the system, etc., and deductively infers attack steps based on the attack conditions for the attack scenario, and searches for an attack route. The attack steps included in the attack route include an attack source, an attack destination, and an attack method. A graph that graphically represents the attack steps in the attack route and the conditions of each attack step is called an "attack graph" or an "attack tree." The attack route generation unit 103 corresponds to the attack route generation means 13 shown in FIG. 1.

[0021] The risk value calculation unit 104 calculates a risk value in the analysis target system. For example, the risk value calculation unit 104 may calculate a risk value for each attack route generated by the attack route generation unit 103. The risk value calculation unit 104 may calculate a risk value for an attack step included in the attack route. The risk value calculation unit 104 corresponds to the risk value calculation means 14 shown in FIG. 1.

[0022] The analysis result output unit 105 outputs the risk analysis result of the analysis target system. For example, the analysis result output unit 105 displays the risk value calculated for each attack route by the risk value calculation unit 104 on a display device (not shown). For example, the analysis result output unit 105 may display attack routes with high risk values ​​more emphasizing them than attack routes with low risk values. The analysis result output unit 105 corresponds to the result output means 15 shown in FIG. 1.

[0023] The user refers to the risk analysis results output by the analysis result output unit 105 and plans countermeasures for at least mitigating threats present in the analysis target system. The countermeasure input unit 106 inputs countermeasures against threats present in the analysis target system. The countermeasure input unit 106 includes input devices such as a keyboard, a mouse, and a touch panel, and the user can input countermeasures to the risk analysis apparatus 100 by operating the input devices. The countermeasure input unit 106 can input multiple countermeasures.

[0024] When a countermeasure is input, the reanalysis unit 107 reanalyzes the security risk of the analysis target system when the countermeasure is introduced. The risk analysis includes a configuration information collection phase, a threat analysis phase, an attack route generation phase, and a risk value calculation phase. The configuration information collection phase, the threat analysis phase, the attack route generation phase, and the risk value calculation phase correspond to the configuration information acquisition unit 101, the threat analysis unit 102, the attack route generation unit 103, and the risk value calculation unit 104. In the reanalysis, the reanalysis unit 107 determines from which phase the risk analysis should be performed according to the countermeasure input from the countermeasure input unit 106. For example, the reanalysis unit 107 refers to a countermeasure information table that associates the type of countermeasure with the phase in which the reanalysis should be performed, and determines from which phase the risk analysis should be performed according to the input countermeasure. The reanalysis unit 107 corresponds to the risk reanalysis means 16 shown in FIG. 1.

[0025] FIG. 3 shows an example of a countermeasure information table. The countermeasure information table includes countermeasure names, countermeasure types, countermeasure contents, and return locations. The countermeasure types indicate the types of security countermeasures identified by the countermeasure names. The countermeasure types include, for example, mitigation measures and fundamental measures. The mitigation measures indicate, for example, security countermeasures that cannot eliminate threats in the analysis target system but can reduce the impact of the threats. The fundamental measures indicate security countermeasures that can at least partially eliminate threats in the analysis target system. The countermeasure contents indicate the contents of the security countermeasures identified by the countermeasure names.

[0026] In the countermeasure information table, the return location indicates the phase where risk analysis is performed in the reanalysis. The return location is defined corresponding to the countermeasure identified by the countermeasure name, for example. For example, for a countermeasure that significantly changes the system configuration when the countermeasure is introduced, configuration information collection is defined as the return location. For a countermeasure that significantly changes the number of threats when the countermeasure is introduced, threat analysis is defined as the return location. For a countermeasure that reduces a specific threat when the countermeasure is introduced, attack route generation is defined as the return location. For a countermeasure that changes the risk value when the countermeasure is introduced, risk value calculation is defined as the return location.

[0027] The reanalysis unit 107 refers to the countermeasure information table and acquires a return location corresponding to the countermeasure input from the countermeasure input unit 106. The reanalysis unit 107 determines the phase in which to perform reanalysis according to the acquired return location. For example, the reanalysis unit 107 determines to re-perform risk analysis starting from risk value calculation for a security countermeasure with a countermeasure name of "log monitoring". The reanalysis unit 107 determines to re-perform risk analysis starting from attack route generation for a security countermeasure with a countermeasure name of "patch application".

[0028] In the above, an example has been described in which a return location is defined for each security countermeasure (countermeasure name), but this embodiment is not limited to this. The return location may be defined corresponding to the countermeasure type. In this case, reanalysis unit 107 may acquire the countermeasure type by referring to a table (first table) that associates the countermeasure name with the countermeasure type, and may acquire the return location by referring to another table (second table) that associates the countermeasure type with the return location. Reanalysis unit 107 may determine the return location according to the countermeasure content in addition to the countermeasure type.

[0029] Next, the operation procedure will be explained. Fig. 4 shows the operation procedure (risk analysis method) in the risk analysis device. The risk analysis device 100 analyzes the risk in the system to be analyzed (step S1). In step S1, the configuration information acquisition unit 101 acquires configuration information of the system to be analyzed. The attack route generation unit 103 searches for attack routes in the system to be analyzed. The risk value calculation unit 104 calculates the risk value of each attack route. The analysis result output unit 105 outputs the risk analysis result of the system to be analyzed.

[0030] The user uses the outputted risk analysis results to plan security measures. The countermeasure input unit 106 inputs the countermeasures planned by the user to the reanalysis unit 107 (step S2). The reanalysis unit 107 determines a return location in the reanalysis according to the inputted countermeasure (step S3). In step S3, the reanalysis unit 107 determines a return location corresponding to the countermeasure type of the inputted countermeasure, for example, by using a countermeasure information table (see FIG. 3). The reanalysis unit 107 reanalyzes the risk analysis in the case where the countermeasure is introduced, from the phase corresponding to the determined return location (step S4). The analysis result output unit 105 outputs the risk analysis result of the analysis target system in the reanalysis.

[0031] For example, when a mitigation measure is introduced, it is considered that there will be no change in the attack methods and attack routes that may be used in the system to be analyzed. In that case, it is considered that in the reanalysis, the risk analysis may be redone from the calculation of the risk value. The reanalysis unit 107 instructs the risk value calculation unit 104 to calculate the risk value, and causes the reanalysis to be performed from the risk value calculation. When a fundamental measure is introduced, it is considered that a specific attack step will become unusable, and the attack route will change. In that case, it is considered that in the reanalysis, the risk analysis may be redone from the generation of the attack route. The reanalysis unit 107 instructs the attack route generation unit 103 to generate an attack route, and causes the reanalysis to be performed from the attack route generation. In the reanalysis, the attack route generation unit 103 neutralizes a specific threat in the countermeasured host or terminal, and generates an attack route.

[0032] The reanalysis unit 107 can also determine the return location according to the location where the countermeasure is implemented in the system to be analyzed. For example, when multiple security countermeasures are implemented for an intrusion point or an attack target host, the risk value of the attack route decreases, so the reanalysis unit 107 may determine the risk value calculation as the return location. When security countermeasures are implemented for a transit terminal, the reanalysis unit 107 may determine the threat analysis as the return location, so that attacks on the transit terminal may not be possible. When a fundamental measure is introduced to a host serving as a springboard, the reanalysis unit 107 may determine the risk value calculation as the return location, so that a work terminal or the like is likely not to be taken over. For countermeasures involving an OS version upgrade, the vulnerability changes significantly, so the reanalysis unit 107 may determine the threat analysis as the return location.

[0033] In general, when examining an attack route, if all attack routes are listed, the number of attack routes becomes enormous. For this reason, the attack route generation unit 103 usually limits the number of hops from the starting point to the end point, and extracts an attack route with a predetermined number of hops (first number of hops) as the upper limit. For example, if a certain number of fundamental measures are introduced for a certain asset, it is considered that attacks via the asset will not be possible and the attack route will disappear. For this reason, in the reanalysis, the number of hops may be increased from the normal number of hops (first number of hops) in examining the attack route, and the examination range of the attack route may be expanded from the examination range in the previous risk analysis. For example, the attack route generation unit 103 may generate an attack route with a second number of hops, which is greater than the normal number of hops (first number of hops), as the upper limit. In this case, it becomes possible to perform risk analysis on attack routes that are detours that were not examined in the previous risk analysis.

[0034] In this embodiment, the reanalysis unit 107 determines the return location of the risk reanalysis according to the countermeasure input to the countermeasure input unit 106. For example, for a certain countermeasure, since it is considered that there is no change in the attack method, it is possible to redo the risk analysis from the risk value calculation. Also, for another countermeasure, since it is considered that the attack method is reduced, it is possible to redo the risk analysis from the threat analysis. By looking at the result of the risk reanalysis, the user can confirm, for example, that the vulnerability is eliminated by applying a security patch, and attacks exploiting the vulnerability will no longer be possible.

[0035] In this embodiment, the phase in which a risk analysis is performed when a countermeasure is implemented is determined according to the countermeasure, so that it is possible to reduce costs such as time and manpower required for re-analyzing risk for the proposed countermeasure. Therefore, this embodiment can confirm risk changes with minimal processing for the proposed countermeasure. Also, in this embodiment, risk analysis when a countermeasure is implemented can be performed at low cost, so that it is possible to propose multiple countermeasures and confirm how much risk is reduced for each of the multiple countermeasures. Therefore, the user can compare the risk reduction effects of multiple countermeasures and find a countermeasure with a high risk reduction effect.

[0036] Next, a second embodiment of the present disclosure will be described. Fig. 5 shows a risk analysis device according to the second embodiment of the present disclosure. A risk analysis device 100a according to this embodiment has a difference determination unit 108 in addition to the configuration of the risk analysis device 100 shown in Fig. 2. The difference determination unit (difference determination means) 108 determines whether or not at least one of the configuration information and the vulnerability information has changed. The difference determination unit 108 determines whether or not the configuration information and the vulnerability information have changed, for example, periodically.

[0037] In this embodiment, the reanalysis unit 107 periodically performs risk analysis, for example, at a predetermined time interval. The difference determination unit 108 determines, for example, whether the vulnerability information has changed from the vulnerability information in the previous risk analysis. When it is determined that the vulnerability information has changed, the reanalysis unit 107 determines from which phase the risk analysis should be performed depending on the content of the change.

[0038] FIG. 6 shows an example of vulnerability information. The vulnerability information includes a vulnerability identifier, the presence or absence of damage cases, the presence or absence of attack verification code, and CVSS (Common Vulnerability Scoring System). CVE (Common Vulnerabilities and Exposures) can be used as the vulnerability identifier. CVSS indicates the severity score of the vulnerability.

[0039] The difference determination unit 108 compares the vulnerability information from the previous risk analysis with the vulnerability information from the current risk analysis. The difference determination unit 108 determines, for example, that a new vulnerability has been added between the previous risk analysis and the current risk analysis. When a new vulnerability is discovered, a new attack exploiting that vulnerability may become possible. When it is determined that a new vulnerability has been added, the reanalysis unit 107 determines the threat analysis as the return location. In that case, the reanalysis unit 107 instructs the threat analysis unit 102 to perform a threat analysis.

[0040] The difference determination unit 108 determines that for a certain vulnerability, the damage example has changed from "none" to "present" or the attack verification code has changed from "none" to "present" between the previous risk analysis and the current risk analysis. If a damage example or an attack verification code is found, it is considered that the attack method itself does not change but the risk value has changed. If it is determined that a damage example or an attack verification code has been found, the reanalysis unit 107 determines risk value calculation as the return point. In that case, the reanalysis unit 107 instructs the risk value calculation unit 104 to calculate the risk value.

[0041] Furthermore, the difference determination unit 108 compares the configuration information at the time of the previous risk analysis with the configuration information at the time of the current risk analysis. For example, the difference determination unit 108 determines that the configuration information has changed when the firewall settings have been changed, a sub-network has been added, or the network configuration has been changed. When it is determined that the configuration information has changed, the reanalysis unit 107 determines that the configuration information collection is the return location. In that case, the reanalysis unit 107 instructs the configuration information acquisition unit 101 to acquire the configuration information.

[0042] The reanalysis unit 107 may perform risk reanalysis from threat analysis in a specific segment when an OS update is performed on a certain terminal, when a new terminal is installed, or when the installation location of a terminal is changed. In this case, the threat analysis unit 102 may analyze whether an attack can be made on a terminal such as a new terminal, and whether an attack can be made from a terminal such as a new terminal. In this embodiment, the reanalysis of the countermeasures input from the countermeasure input unit 106 may be the same as the reanalysis in the first embodiment.

[0043] In this embodiment, the difference determination unit 108 determines changes in the configuration information and the vulnerability information. When the configuration information and the vulnerability information change, the reanalysis unit 107 determines a return location for the risk reanalysis according to the contents of the changes. For example, when an item of vulnerability information used in the risk value calculation changes, the reanalysis unit 107 determines the phase of the risk value calculation as the return location. Also, when a new vulnerability appears, the reanalysis unit 107 determines the phase of the threat analysis as the return location. In this way, it is possible to confirm, with a minimum of processing, how the risk changes when the information on which the analysis is premised changes. Other effects are the same as those described in the first embodiment.

[0044] In the above embodiments, an example has been described in which the phase in which the reanalysis is to start is determined according to the input countermeasures or changes in the configuration information and vulnerability information. However, the present disclosure is not limited to this. For example, if the user wishes to perform a risk analysis from the beginning, the reanalysis unit 107 may perform the reanalysis from the collection of configuration information.

[0045] In the above-described second embodiment, an example has been described in which the reanalysis unit 107 performs reanalysis when a countermeasure is input and reanalysis when configuration information or vulnerability information has changed. However, the present disclosure is not limited to this. In the second embodiment, the reanalysis when a countermeasure is input may be omitted, and only reanalysis when configuration information or vulnerability information has changed may be performed.

[0046] Next, a description will be given of the physical configuration of the risk analysis device 100. Fig. 7 shows an example of the configuration of a computer device that can be used as the risk analysis device 100. The computer device 500 has a control unit (CPU: Central Processing Unit) 510, a storage unit 520, a ROM (Read Only Memory) 530, a RAM (Random Access Memory) 540, a communication interface (IF: Interface) 550, and a user interface 560.

[0047] The communication interface 550 is an interface for connecting the computer device 500 to a communication network via a wired communication means or a wireless communication means, etc. The user interface 560 includes a display unit such as a display, and an input unit such as a keyboard, a mouse, and a touch panel.

[0048] The storage unit 520 is an auxiliary storage device that can hold various data. The storage unit 520 does not necessarily need to be a part of the computer device 500, and may be an external storage device or a cloud storage connected to the computer device 500 via a network.

[0049] The ROM 530 is a non-volatile storage device. For example, a semiconductor storage device having a relatively small capacity, such as a flash memory, is used for the ROM 530. The programs executed by the CPU 510 may be stored in the storage unit 520 or the ROM 530. The storage unit 520 or the ROM 530 stores various programs for implementing the functions of each unit in the risk analysis device 100, for example.

[0050] The program includes a set of instructions (or software code) that, when loaded into a computer, causes the computer to perform one or more functions described in the embodiments. The program may be stored in a non-transitory computer-readable medium or a tangible storage medium. By way of example and not limitation, the computer-readable medium or tangible storage medium includes random-access memory (RAM), read-only memory (ROM), flash memory, solid-state drive (SSD) or other memory technology, Compact Disc (CD), digital versatile disc (DVD), Blu-ray® disk or other optical disk storage, magnetic cassette, magnetic tape, magnetic disk storage or other magnetic storage device. The program may be transmitted on a transitory computer-readable medium or communication medium. By way of example and not limitation, the transitory computer-readable medium or communication medium includes electrical, optical, acoustic, or other forms of propagated signals.

[0051] The RAM 540 is a volatile storage device. Various semiconductor memory devices such as a dynamic random access memory (DRAM) or a static random access memory (SRAM) are used for the RAM 540. The RAM 540 can be used as an internal buffer for temporarily storing data and the like. The CPU 510 loads a program stored in the storage unit 520 or the ROM 530 into the RAM 540 and executes it. The CPU 510 executes a program to realize the functions of each unit in the risk analysis device 100. The CPU 510 may have an internal buffer for temporarily storing data and the like.

[0052] Although the embodiments of the present disclosure have been described in detail above, the present disclosure is not limited to the above-described embodiments, and changes and modifications to the above-described embodiments that do not deviate from the spirit of the present disclosure are also included in the present disclosure. [Explanation of symbols]

[0053] 10: Risk analysis device 11: Configuration information acquisition means 12: Threat analysis methods 13: Attack route generation method 14: Risk value calculation method 15: Result output means 16: Risk reanalysis measures 100: Risk analysis device 101: Configuration information acquisition unit 102: Threat Analysis Department 103: Attack route generation unit 104: Risk value calculation unit 105:Analysis result output section 106: Countermeasures input section 107:Reanalysis Department 108: Difference judgment part 500: Computer equipment 510:CPU 520: Storage section 530:ROM 540:RAM 550: Communication IF 560: User IF

Claims

1. Analyze security risks posed by threats to the target system, Re-analyzing the security risk of the target system in which security measures against the threat have been introduced; The analysis device outputs first information indicating a result of the analysis and second information indicating a result of the reanalysis.

2. a threat analysis means for analyzing an attack method against the target system based on configuration information and vulnerability information of the target system; A calculation means for calculating a risk value related to the attack method; A reanalysis means for performing the reanalysis; an output means for outputting the first information and the second information; The analysis device according to claim 1 .

3. a route generating means for generating an attack route from a starting point to an end point of the attack based on the configuration information and the attack method; Further equipped with The calculation means calculates the risk value for the generated attack route. The analytical device according to claim 2 .

4. An information acquisition means for acquiring the configuration information of the target system. The analysis device of claim 3 further comprising:

5. The reanalysis means determines, according to the type of the security countermeasure, any one of the information acquisition means, the threat analysis means, the route generation means, and the calculation means as a return location in the reanalysis, and performs the reanalysis from the determined return location. The analytical device according to claim 4.

6. The reanalysis means acquires a return location corresponding to the security countermeasure proposed for the target system using a countermeasure information table that associates the type of the security countermeasure with the return location, and executes the reanalysis from the acquired return location. The analytical device according to claim 5 .

7. The route generation means generates the attack route with a first hop count as an upper limit, In the re-analysis, the attack route is generated with a second hop number, which is greater than the first hop number, as an upper limit. The analytical device according to claim 3 .

8. A difference determination means for determining whether or not at least one of the vulnerability information and the configuration information has changed. Furthermore, When it is determined that at least one of the vulnerability information and the configuration information has changed, the reanalysis means causes any one of the information acquisition means, the threat analysis means, the route generation means, and the calculation means to perform a reanalysis in accordance with the content of the change in at least one of the vulnerability information and the configuration information. The analytical device according to claim 4.

9. The difference determination means periodically determines whether or not at least one of the vulnerability information and the configuration information has changed. The analytical device according to claim 8.

10. The computer analyzes security risks posed by threats in the target system, The computer reanalyzes a security risk of the target system in which a security measure against the threat has been introduced, The computer outputs first information indicating a result of the analysis and second information indicating a result of the reanalysis. Analysis method.

11. A function to analyze security risks posed by threats in the target system; A function of reanalyzing security risks of the target system to which security measures against the threats have been introduced; a function of outputting first information indicating the result of the analysis and second information indicating the result of the reanalysis; An analysis program that enables a computer to achieve this.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Security measure planning support system and method

    JP2018077597A

  • Risk analysis device, method, and program

    JP7552899B2

  • Risk assessment measure planning system and risk assessment measure planning method

    JP2020166650A